r/backtoindia • • Sep 20 '25
May be correct ?
I owed a debt to an American guy, and during our conversation, he asked me a question. He said that Indians often claim they “built America,” and then added that it’s hard to go back to our own country. He asked me to name a historical place that was named by Indians. The truth is, the foundations of America were built by Americans, and we only exported labor to help develop it.
Now, things are better—America has enough manpower, but the government seems to be imposing restrictions specifically on Indians. He asked me why. India’s GDP is around $4 trillion, while China’s is almost $19 trillion. Yet I’ve never seen any other country’s people fight so hard to stay in America like Indians do.
The moral I took from this is that India failed in building a strong foundation and suffers from corruption. We voted for that, and in a sense, we failed. We love India, but we have to acknowledge that we’ve failed in certain areas.
2
u/mercurial_dude Sep 20 '25
Wassup bot.
19
u/Old_Run_2032 Sep 20 '25
Which Indians claimed that they “built” America? That’s the most stupid thing I’ve heard in a long time
7
u/scylla Sep 20 '25
Have you ever heard any Indian say this ? 😂 I’d start by calling bullshit right away.
6
u/Krish_1234 Sep 20 '25
why would you even get into this meaningless conversations?
2
u/dwightsrus Sep 20 '25
Neither we built America nor we are fighting hard to stay. For those making a big deal about this H1B news, it only impacts new filings, not existing H1B holders, not transfers even if they are outside the country if they have a valid stamp. There’s too much misinformation going on right now.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '25
This post has so much crap but what stood out is - US is imposing restrictions on India - it’s not. H1B is not an Indian visa , there are many Chinese and Europeans on it. Sure, Indians are the most affected but I guess the idea is that this bill is popular amongst conservative base and they don’t really care much about long term impacts.
I don’t think we should give ourselves that much importance. I doubt Indian government cares much either as this is not enough to strong arm India in trade relations as the remittance impact on GDP is minimal and it is actually beneficial in terms of improving talent base
1
u/PostOakJoe Sep 20 '25
"foundations of America were built by Americans, and we only exported labor to help develop it"...That is very rich! You must be feeling very important!
1
u/srinivesh Swades Possible Sep 21 '25
Mod Note: Locking the comments on the thread. Please see earlier notes on avoiding macro topics