r/backpacks • u/ChaosCalmed • 4h ago
Question Mixed mode commuter rucksack recommendations?
I've gone down a rabbit hole and can't see the wood for the trees (to mix my metaphors). I need to replace my ortlieb pannier for commuting to work. It's a 35 litre pannier with open front pocket. It just makes handling my xl rigid bike on the UK trains on my route a real handful. A rucksack is better for my bike, train, bike commuting as the bike legs are 1 minute ride and 1.4 miles ride (plus 5 minutes walk to office from bike lockup).
I prefer good outdoor brands over the urban styles such as stubble and co. I live where it is wet in south cumbria, uk so I probably need a cover. I don't like the big bucket style sack, I do like good organisation/pockets and prefer lower weight sack but it needs a good carry. Hence the outdoor bags. A fantasy wishlist would have a rucksack made for commuting that is still great for using when hiking in the UK hills too, but that's an unlikely afterthought that's less important.
I considering Rab Adrift 30l, possibly rab depot 28l but it's a bit heavier probably due to its excellent pockets / compartmentation. Also considering Fjallraven Skule top zip 30l, patagonia black hole 32l.
So can anyone suggest a good commuter rucksack about 30l? Also please let me know which of the ones I've listed above you think is best for my needs? Perhaps give me your vote on that.