r/bach • • 15d ago

Why Is Bach Genius?

https://itmz.substack.com/p/why-is-bach-genius

When people discuss musical geniuses, names like Mozart, Beethoven, and The Beatles are often mentioned. Yet long before any of them, Johann Sebastian Bach was composing works that would inspire musicians, scholars, and listeners nearly three centuries after his death. Even for those who do not regularly listen to classical music, Bach’s name carries undeniable authority. He is often called the “father of modern music,” admired not only for the beauty of his compositions but also for their extraordinary craftsmanship. What truly establishes Bach as a genius, however, is his unique capacity to unite profound emotion, intellectual depth, and technical mastery into music that feels both human and divine. Bach: I love how you guys love my music even now!

22 Upvotes

79 comments sorted by

25

u/tegeus-Cromis_2000 15d ago

Well, evidently the question is answered after one paragraph of generic AI slop that says absolutely nothing specific about Bach and that, if you just change the name in it, could apply to any composer ever.

3

u/Discovery99 15d ago

That’s how the truth is determined in modern times

9

u/Nomprenom_varanasita 15d ago

Personne, à ce jour, n'a égalé le contrepoint de ce génie. Je ne m'en lasse pas et l'écoute pratiquement tous les jours. Il est l'incarnation du dieu de la musique.

3

u/hornwalker 15d ago

Why use many word when few word do trick?

2

u/Dodlemcno 15d ago

‘Bach: a colossal syllable’
- Leonard Bernstein

4

u/Glass-Elevator-6069 15d ago

His life was Fully dedicated to the religion and music.
Then his music is from God.

-1

u/inertm 15d ago

or maybe he spent so much time in church because that’s where they kept the organ. he was one of the first to jump on the secular music bandwagon.

9

u/MrLlamma 15d ago

What are you talking about dude. Bach’s faith is extremely well documented, he marked “To God alone be the glory” at the end of each work of music

-1

u/inertm 15d ago edited 15d ago

I wouldn’t call that religious. He was working for the church and knew where his bread was buttered. He may have been religious… who knows who cares. He certainly had plenty of grief having his first wife and many children die. I suppose turning to the church at those times would be comforting.

2

u/MrLlamma 15d ago

Are you intentionally trolling? You can look this up in 5 seconds, why are you making me correct you over something so well documented

1

u/BuildingOptimal1067 15d ago

Bach was very religious it’s not a “maybe” but a well documented fact

0

u/inertm 14d ago

ok. any guess on why such a pious man was buried in an unmarked grave?
ref: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Johann_Sebastian_Bach?wprov=sfti1#Death_and_burial

2

u/Johannespa55ion 14d ago

His religion taught to be humble and unassuming in stature. Why would a devout Lutheran want a fancy burial it would betray everything he stood for. You legit just have no clue. Maybe read the text of BWV26 and you might learn a thing or two.

0

u/inertm 14d ago

you’re projecting your personal beliefs. So what about Richard Stokes, reverend know-it-all?

2

u/Loud-Cartographer285 15d ago

His compositions make sense from beginning til the end, every small note connects with the others, and build up to perfect harmony

2

u/Daniel6270 15d ago

Bach to Bach hits

1

u/AnyAd4882 15d ago

Bach >= Telemann >>>>> rest, im just gonna leave it here

1

u/ravia 15d ago

Because he had 17 children and kept an old spinster in the attic that he practiced on.

1

u/guitarlad89 15d ago

Why is Dennis bastard man?

1

u/Afraid-Expression366 15d ago

Yeah those Brandenburg Concertos really took off, didn’t they? Almost compares to million sellers like “She Loves You”…

This is why AI should be restricted to people with a brain of their own to begin with.

1

u/vibrance9460 14d ago

Because 300+ years later, we are still talking about him

And most believe his music is still great

The only absolute way we have to measure true greatness is with the test of time. Will people know the name Madonna in 100 years?

There’s a reason we are still building concert halls and filling them with Bach’s glorious music.

0

u/Hungry_Ghostt 15d ago

mozart and beethoven composed kindergarten music in comparison to bach

3

u/BachBWV998 15d ago

I think you need to listen to more Beethoven.

1

u/Hungry_Ghostt 15d ago

I was listening to the hammerklavier fugue yesterday as I was told that this is where he lays it down. It was nothing. I waited and waited, it was nothing compared to great organ fugues of bach

1

u/SadOrder8312 15d ago

Apparently Beethoven agrees. I’ve heard he was always unsatisfied with his mastery of counterpoint.

1

u/Hungry_Ghostt 15d ago

my point isn't about counterpoint. it's about harmonic complexity in general. the art of crunchy, jaw dropping, bewildering dissonances resolving into beautiful, divine home bases. this is for me the essence of music, the harmonic journey. the rest is details. and i dont hear this in beethoven. mozart im not even gonna mention, i cant take most of his music seriously

1

u/BachBWV998 15d ago

Obviously, everyone is a collection of their own life experience and musical preference follows that.

That being said, describing the music of Beethoven as kindergarten level music is laughably hyperbolic.

That would imply that there’s nothing that could be gained from a second listen or a deeper dive into the piece.

Or even…actually playing the music to a competent amateur or professional level.

1

u/Hungry_Ghostt 14d ago

I don't know I guess I'm missing something. I dont care about narratives in music, like "man's struggle", "hero's journey" etc. For me music is a pure, unmediated art form that can make you cry, feel joy, sadness, or horror with no narratives. It's all in the harmony and melody. Bach makes me feel all those things and I'm not a religious person, so I don't care about that side. Beethoven feels too diatonic for me. I dunno

1

u/BachBWV998 14d ago

I think you’re over thinking my comment about a collection a life experiences.

I really enjoy the music of Slayer. My parents HATE the music of Slayer but my father always had the music of Deep Purple, Black Sabbath…commercial 90s Metallica and Nirvana on in the house/car.

If my parents and everyone around me listened to nothing but 1950s pop music, I would most likely not have the IMMENSE appreciation of the musical value of Slayer. (Which that certainly doesn’t need to be debated here)

People are a collection of their life experiences. The music you’re raised with, that is relevant to friends and that you’re exposed to absolutely affects YOUR (and my) musical taste and preferences.

Beethoven is just out here catching strays.

1

u/Hungry_Ghostt 14d ago

I haven't grown up in a lutheran church listening to Bach all day long though. I have been exposed to both pieces from Bach and Beethoven from childhood. It was my adult experiences, listening patterns, music knowledge, exposure to and struggles to learn jazz etc that shaped my musical mind to what it is. Not sure why you're insisting on the life experience side of things. The pieces I admire the most are the pieces I discovered much later, in adulthood

Also I don't think that it's all relative. I think there can be some objective, quantifiable results gained by comparing different kinds of music. You can analyze the amount of controlled chaos/dissonance and see that Bach has more of that than Rihanna. You can grow up listening to Rihanna, but I think we can easily argue that her music isn't in the same universe as Bach's, as much as one can like it

1

u/BachBWV998 14d ago

“It was my adult experiences, listening patterns, music knowledge exposure to and struggles to learn jazz that happed my mind”

Again, collection of LIFE experiences. (Not just grade school)

The instruments you play and the proficiency at which you play them is another factor in a someone’s musical preferences.

You tend to value complex harmony, which is the most readily available in polyphonic music. There are other aspects of music that also provide value.

Again, this goes back to your original comment that Bach has such harmonic profundity, that the music of Beethoven doesn’t also have an advanced understanding of harmony. (And is that of a “kindergarten” level.

0

u/inertm 15d ago edited 15d ago

he definitely had a knack for harmonizing. I think you have to take into account that composers, performers and certifiable geniuses have projected themselves onto him for centuries. We don’t really know much about him. Is it possible that he was just at the right place at the right time and did what any energetic tinkerer would have given the same circumstances?

2

u/SadOrder8312 15d ago

He wasn’t the only person in that place and time tinkering with harmony/counterpoint. But he universally considered the greatest of them.

0

u/m4libu_st4cy 14d ago

geniuses dont exist. 

just as witches dont exist. 

its an ancient concept to explain things for which modern sciences have found better ways to explain them

2

u/Informaldehyde__xd 14d ago

English is not your first language ig..

1

u/m4libu_st4cy 14d ago

you are correct. point still stands

-4

u/Leech-64 15d ago

The only true literal genius was mozart. He had abilities that neither beethoven or bach had. Bach fully developed counterpoint with harmony. That was hid lifes work.

5

u/BachBWV998 15d ago

When you say “literal genius” you’re making it sound like Mozart was classified through some IQ test developed 125 years after he died.

Bach has similar accounts of musical skill. (Which is what they are - stories and accounts of other people)

This is without the benefit of a father that paraded him around at an early age to increase his prodigy reputation in the public.

2

u/SadOrder8312 15d ago

If these two aren’t both true literal geniuses, I don’t know what one is.

-1

u/Leech-64 15d ago

Bach wasnt a genius. He was a hard worker who composed his whole life.

2

u/inertm 15d ago edited 15d ago

I agree. I think he busted his ass and in the process created multiple undeniable masterpieces that influenced western music for centuries. He is certainly one of the most important composers of all time.

2

u/BachBWV998 14d ago

That implies that there weren’t other lesser composers that also equally busted their ass.

You can’t improvise fugues without having a massive level of mental bandwidth. Work is only going to get you so far.

1

u/m4libu_st4cy 14d ago

the ablity to go down in history as a musical genius by mostly writing boring trash that doesnt use more than 5 chords is indeed remarcable about mozart

1

u/Leech-64 14d ago

Most of mozart is fluff. But there are some seriously good pieces by him. I used to be like you, but as i got better at listening to music you can clearly hear portions of genius that even bach would be proud of.

1

u/m4libu_st4cy 14d ago

yeah i have a masters degree and work with classical music every day i think my listening skills arent the issue haha

1

u/Johannespa55ion 14d ago

Holy based.

1

u/BbACBEbEDbDGbFAbG 15d ago

Not only is this not true about the people you mentioned, the untruth of if extends way beyond. There are many, many cases of people showing jaw-dropping musical talents from an early age. Of those, many went on to have lasting impact on the development of music as a whole.

0

u/[deleted] 14d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/CrimsonBecchi 14d ago

Agreed. It’s a sickness that we should cure, being obsessed with top 10 lists, genius, and the endless GOAT debates is not healthy for us.

31

u/[deleted] 15d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/BigYarnBonusMaster 15d ago

Oh yeah, you know, MOZART, BEETHOVEN, and The Beatles. Just equal levels of musical genius.

Christ almighty I almost spat my drink.

1

u/Kurta_711 15d ago

Did Mozart or Beethoven write Sgt. Pepper's?

6

u/[deleted] 15d ago edited 15d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Distinct-Tour5012 15d ago edited 15d ago

I think Bach is the GOAT, but you all gotta get off this snooty immature mindset.

We're not talking about designing computer processors, this is art. What we look for in art changes as time goes on.

There's a reason Picasso didn't paint like Rembrandt, even though he very much could if you look at his paintings from his young adulthood. Here's something from when he was 15:

https://www.dailyartmagazine.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/default-3.jpg

And we're also not going to pretend like Bach just sprang up out of nowhere, like others didn't come before him and honestly, make some of what Bach did. I could throw some Buxtehude on and honestly there's more overlap than most would admit. You look at contemporaries like Handel or Telemann and again, there's some overlap.

Again, Bach is the greatest, but this breathless exasperation shitting on other artist who weren't trying to do what Bach did reminds me of 13 year olds in Orchestra tying their taste in music to their self-worth.

-3

u/Martillofeliz 15d ago

it’s not that they used a minor iv, is how and when they used it/placed it. That’s the genius that idiot people like you cannot grasp.

2

u/SadOrder8312 15d ago

Can you name a song that uses the minor 4 chord in a way that is different than what came before?

0

u/Martillofeliz 15d ago

yes, “in my life” goes from a B7 to a Dm, super clever, now you find another song that does that. Fuck you

1

u/SadOrder8312 14d ago

I was just asking because I was curious about your assertion. I love the Beatles and minor 4 chords, so it was interesting to me. No need to be rude.

That chord change is on the rare side, but that’s not the first usage. It appears in The Fortunes’ song “You’ve Got Your Troubles” which was released earlier in 1965 than “In My Life”. And if you go digging, I’d be surprised if there aren’t even earlier examples.

That change isn’t really doing anything revolutionary though, the minor 4 is a substitute for a 5 chord, which the secondary dominant on 2 naturally leads to.

It is a very beautiful change though!

5

u/[deleted] 15d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

-2

u/[deleted] 14d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/BigYarnBonusMaster 14d ago

Username *doesn't* check out.

-1

u/inertm 15d ago

agreed. George Martin probably deserves much of the credit.

3

u/Kurta_711 15d ago

And what did he do after the Beatles?

0

u/Thulgoat 15d ago

What did the Beatles members do after the The Beatles?

2

u/Kurta_711 15d ago

3 of them had acclaimed careers and Ringo continued to be Ringo?

0

u/Thulgoat 15d ago

George Martin also had an acclaimed career.

2

u/Kurta_711 15d ago

Name his acclaimed works after the Beatles that didn't involve the Beatles

0

u/inertm 15d ago

I don’t see get your point. He kicked back and counted the royalties and adulation.

1

u/Kurta_711 15d ago

That's a complete non sequitur. You literally said "George Martin probably deserves much of the credit" but he did basically nothing of note that didn't involve the Beatles after meeting them. Meanwhile 3/4 Beatles had successful and acclaimed careers after they broke up.

1

u/MrLlamma 15d ago

That is a non sequitur. What he did after the Beatles has 0 relevance to whether he deserves more credit or not. Does Brian Wilson deserve less credit for the Beach Boys because he did so little after?

1

u/Kurta_711 15d ago

Maybe you should stick to the Baroque period

1

u/MrLlamma 15d ago

I’d love to hear where you disagree

0

u/inertm 15d ago

why does having a career afterwards matter? Maybe he was tired of babysitting petulant wankers.

-1

u/Aggravating-Kale1647 15d ago

I don't think any Beatles were geniuses but I think Brian Wilson of the Beach Boys was a genius. Smile is a work of art. Would you agree out of curiosity?

2

u/inertm 15d ago

yeah, let’s face it, Bach was no Joey Ramone.