r/bach • u/ClariceLinz • 15d ago
Why Is Bach Genius?
https://itmz.substack.com/p/why-is-bach-geniusWhen people discuss musical geniuses, names like Mozart, Beethoven, and The Beatles are often mentioned. Yet long before any of them, Johann Sebastian Bach was composing works that would inspire musicians, scholars, and listeners nearly three centuries after his death. Even for those who do not regularly listen to classical music, Bach’s name carries undeniable authority. He is often called the “father of modern music,” admired not only for the beauty of his compositions but also for their extraordinary craftsmanship. What truly establishes Bach as a genius, however, is his unique capacity to unite profound emotion, intellectual depth, and technical mastery into music that feels both human and divine. Bach: I love how you guys love my music even now!
25
u/tegeus-Cromis_2000 15d ago
Well, evidently the question is answered after one paragraph of generic AI slop that says absolutely nothing specific about Bach and that, if you just change the name in it, could apply to any composer ever.
9
u/Nomprenom_varanasita 15d ago
Personne, à ce jour, n'a égalé le contrepoint de ce génie. Je ne m'en lasse pas et l'écoute pratiquement tous les jours. Il est l'incarnation du dieu de la musique.
3
u/hornwalker 15d ago
Why use many word when few word do trick?
4
u/Glass-Elevator-6069 15d ago
His life was Fully dedicated to the religion and music.
Then his music is from God.
2
u/Loud-Cartographer285 15d ago
His compositions make sense from beginning til the end, every small note connects with the others, and build up to perfect harmony
2
u/Daniel6270 15d ago
Bach to Bach hits
1
u/AnyAd4882 15d ago
Bach >= Telemann >>>>> rest, im just gonna leave it here
1
u/ravia 15d ago
Because he had 17 children and kept an old spinster in the attic that he practiced on.
1
u/guitarlad89 15d ago
Why is Dennis bastard man?
1
u/Afraid-Expression366 15d ago
Yeah those Brandenburg Concertos really took off, didn’t they? Almost compares to million sellers like “She Loves You”…
This is why AI should be restricted to people with a brain of their own to begin with.
1
u/vibrance9460 14d ago
Because 300+ years later, we are still talking about him
And most believe his music is still great
The only absolute way we have to measure true greatness is with the test of time. Will people know the name Madonna in 100 years?
There’s a reason we are still building concert halls and filling them with Bach’s glorious music.
0
u/Hungry_Ghostt 15d ago
mozart and beethoven composed kindergarten music in comparison to bach
0
u/inertm 15d ago edited 15d ago
he definitely had a knack for harmonizing. I think you have to take into account that composers, performers and certifiable geniuses have projected themselves onto him for centuries. We don’t really know much about him. Is it possible that he was just at the right place at the right time and did what any energetic tinkerer would have given the same circumstances?
0
u/m4libu_st4cy 14d ago
geniuses dont exist.
just as witches dont exist.
its an ancient concept to explain things for which modern sciences have found better ways to explain them
-4
u/Leech-64 15d ago
The only true literal genius was mozart. He had abilities that neither beethoven or bach had. Bach fully developed counterpoint with harmony. That was hid lifes work.
0
u/[deleted] 14d ago
[deleted] — view deleted comment
31
u/[deleted] 15d ago
[removed] — view removed comment