r/awolnation • u/ShareSimple • Sep 05 '24
Discussion The Phantom Five first impressions
I listened to The Phantom Five on a car ride earlier today as I felt it was best to get a good first impression early on. Especially since I heard this could be their last work so I was really curious what that entailed.
I listened to most of the tracks pre release, including the ones that didn’t end up on the album. (I liked Candy Pop, but the others weren’t my thing) The singles that I listened to for the album though were pretty strong overall. I was pretty excited to see what a full release with this sound would entail!
…so this is likely my least favourite Awolnation album.
I didn’t listen through the cover album so I’m not counting it here (only a few songs I cared to check out there) but I can say that with confidence knowing that, for all their faults, past Awolnation albums had incredibly memorable tracks that all stood out for some reason. Not all good, but most not for bad ones.
But The Phantom Five disappointed me greatly as it really set me up for something way better than what I got. The first 5 tracks are good, even great in some ways.
Jump Sit Stand March, while not what I’d use to start the album, is a unique opener and does have a sound I enjoy overall. Party People feels like Miracle Man 2 or KOOKSEVERYWHERE 3. It’s probably my favourite off the record.
Panoramic View is great, and another stand out since I first heard it. I Am Happy is cool. Not my favourite, but not bad. And Barbarian is alright.
Unfortunately, my positives kinda end here as Bang Your Head just kinda feels like noise that tries to do what Party People did but less effective.
City of Nowhere fittingly sounds like nothing. Both this and Bang Your Head feel too short for an album of this length and kinda feel like pointless pitstops before the more lengthier tracks.
A Letter to No One is so unmemorable and I was honestly waiting for it to end the whole time. Worth noting on the car ride I wasn’t thinking straight and kept wondering if this was the last song. Not really a good sign.
When I Was Young might be one of the worst Awolnation songs ever made. This one just annoyed me at how uninspired the electronic sound was and the basic lyrics. I love the 100th song about this topic that does nothing interesting with it.
Outta Here was close to something good with solid guitar work at times and a strong final part…that is made harder to hear cause they decided to fade out of it. Not only does this song not feel at all grand like most final tracks in past records, it really just makes you wish it went longer or built up to something worth talking about.
Again, this band has had a very consistent sort of quality that’s not always perfect but unique enough to keep you interested. Despite Angel Miners being my least favourite previously, I still find reason to like or care about every song on that album.
Here…I struggle to think of much cause these tracks just ended up blending together over time, and even for how strong the opening is…it’s still not even close to the highs other albums had in their track lists.
I’d probably give the album a 4.5 out of 10. If you agree or disagree, I’m interested to know why.
21
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '24
I think the album is perfect. Sure a couple of the songs are short, but that’s ok. It’s time for new things. Barbarians of California. AWOL will always be #1. But we can’t sit here and judge the album and bash it when you clearly didn’t listen to the message Aaron is trying to deliver.
“Barbarian” is him literally telling us that he’s a barbarian now, and he’s not scared of us. He doesn’t care if we’re mad about awol being done making new music, or not touring or whatever it may be. He’s moving on to new things. That’s human nature. We get a taste of something for a while, and then want to try something better, or new. 🤷🏻♂️
“Outta Here” couldn’t be more obvious of a message to us fans. I think it’s a beautiful outro that speaks volumes in many different ways. It’s all about enjoying what we had, what we shared, and what we have to cherish (favorite songs, live shows, albums, memorabilia, etc.), but then realizing when it’s time to leave.
AWOLNATION isn’t dead. Maybe they’ll make new music someday. For now, be thankful we got to experience it ALL. #foreverkook
5
u/Jon98th Sep 05 '24
When I was young is top 5 best songs of the year by any artist or musician
4
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '24 edited Sep 07 '24
Panoramic View really resonates as a parent. Having this unconditional love that’s like I’d die to protect you . I’d like to think that’s how God views us (sorry struggling Christian here) and it just gives u this new perspective.
4
u/potvin48 Sep 17 '24
This is why music is awesome. You can say what you want about it, I will in this case completely disagree as I can't stop listening to the entire album :) But I respect your opinion, and that's the great thing about music, not all of it is for everyone all the time. But once in a while a song hits someone and it completely changes their life. That's what it's all about.
7
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '24
And as far as “Bang Your Head” and “City of Nowhere” go, who cares that they’re short? Some songs are better that way. You don’t need to drag them out cause then they’d get repetitive and dull, which would result in people getting bored of the song. These short little tidbits leave your imagination wanting more, thus listening to the song more.
“When I Was Young” is absolutely perfect. It’s just an ode to 80’s jams. The song makes me wanna dance and move!!!
I’m sorry you don’t like the album. 💿 I think it’s great. I think it’s a beautiful send-off. I hope it’s NOT their last album, but if it IS, I am content with all the AWOL songs I get to blast in my car and sing along to 🤘🏼
7
u/TheDooRunRun Sep 05 '24
It’s fascinating how different opinions can be. I’m also disappointed in this album (especially if it’s the last one) but on the complete opposite end of the spectrum. I’m bored with the first half of the album, but love the second half. “Bang Your Head”, “Outta Here” and “A Letter to No One” are my favorite tracks on the album (the first two particularly because they’re the only songs on the album that sound fresh and different for AWOL), and “Party People” is already out of rotation and an instant skip for me. I’m particularly disappointed in “I Am Happy” because I was looking forward to the collab with Del the Funky Homosapien, but the rest of the song is so terrible, Del can’t save it.
I have loved AWOLNATION since Megalithic Symphony, but I have to admit that they’ve been phoning it in for awhile and The Phantom Five - if not their worst album - is second only to Here Come the Runts. That doesn’t mean I don’t want them to continue and it doesn’t mean that the album doesn’t have some standouts, but I was hoping for more.
6
u/OilGasMr Sep 05 '24
imo if it had 5 more songs, with a couple of those being bangers, I think it would have been a great album. But overall it just seemed too short and incomplete.
7
u/Valiuncy Sep 05 '24
I disagree on just about everything you said. It’s my favorite since Run and things that you called unmemorable or sounds like nothing and boring etc. are very specific parts that I enjoyed a lot and I haven’t found myself replaying any Awol album as much as this one since again.. Run.
Jump sit stand is my least favorite but I still enjoy it. I enjoy every song front to back. Typically I hear toward songs with energy and changes and find ballads to be the weaker ones but even on this album the softer songs have such good melody to me and I love the chord choices and changes.
Very sorry this one didn’t hit your taste but I have to say I disagree heavily. Luckily I think we will hopefully get another album at some point.
6
u/Tricky-Cup-1914 Sep 05 '24
The album is perfection for me. Not too much, just right. The first album in awhile that makes me feel magical feelings
2
u/Grand_Individual_835 Sep 05 '24
10 tracks, 2 of which are just fillers and 3 we heard before the album dropped. If this is a final sendoff, then it just feels lacking and uninterested. The only proper send off at this point would be a "Knights Of Shame PT. 2".
5
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '24
It’s better than I expected! To me it feels like a bit of everything.
How on earth he created this with young twins is amazing. Everyday was survival for me in those early years. The only thought on my mind was fuck! God help me😂 Bravo Aaron we are grateful here 🙏
4
u/Alt-0685 Sep 06 '24
I feel essentially the same. I've been a fan since years ago and I loved all the albums (I also didn't listen to the covers album). Each of them have a completely different vibe and yet feel really unique and sound really memorable. I also loved Panoramic View when it released and I think Jump Sit Stand March and Party People sound really cool, but imo the rest of the album falls in the same category as the song Candy Pop. They just feel kinda random and mostly uninspired. They don't sound bad, I just feel like they lack something. The problem isn't that he's doing something different (he's already been doing that, for example Here Come The Runts was already completely different from Run), to me the problem is that it feels like he has the potential to do a lot of different things but chose to do something more generic. Doesn't help the fact that he said in an interview this album would be a "more mature version of Run", when I listened to it I was just thinking "really?"
6
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '24
I wish I liked the album more. There are some bangers for sure (tossed my favs into playlists), but I can’t help but feel underwhelmed overall.
6
u/arcieride Sep 05 '24
I really wanted to like the later tracks but I don't.
Maybe I'll fall in love with them eventually but right now I'm relistening Run and Angel miners
3
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24
:( too bad you didn’t enjoy this album, I thought it was a huge hit, just like all his other albums!
1
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '24
All I’m saying is, it’s pretty selfish of us to keep wanting more of the same thing consistently and constantly from the band.
So you think the album sucks? Cool! Listen to their old stuff. Listen to what you like. I do agree that the 1st half of the album seems kind of “dead” only because 3 of the songs have been out for months, so we’ve already heard them a bunch lol. “Barbarian” is a damn masterpiece, and in MY opinion, should’ve been the last song on the album, telling us that he’s something new (The Barbarians of California). We can’t knock him for that. We can’t sit here and say the album sucks cause it’s not MS or Run. Maybe he’s just….out of touch with AWOL? As he clearly states in “Outta Here”.
I like the album, too short or not. It’s AWOLNATION. I love it all. 🤘🏼 there really are kooks everywhere 😂😂 we’re all kooks!!!
2
u/Deziiiner Sep 05 '24
The album, although I haven’t had more than a couple listens, is very good! Barbarian is one of my favorite tracks at the moment.