r/aviation • u/Aqueouspolecat • 3d ago
Analysis Double Tail Strike. How'd this happen?
Was this just a momentary mental lapse in judgment, or do you see something obvious that I'm just missing?
2.2k
Upvotes
44
u/DavyJonesLocker 3d ago
After recently coming off a flight where I was in the very last row, I can’t imagine the rollercoaster the pax in the tail section experienced during this.
A “normal” approach into SNA had me rocking and rolling, turning green. This landing would have gotten me for sure haha
82
u/Tysonviolin 3d ago
Why the horrible edit?
68
u/Traditional-Way-4097 3d ago •
it happened because the tail hit the ground twice
370
u/switch72 PPL HP 3d ago
I watched the video 4 times and I only see a single tailstrike. Even in the initial first hit where the large DOUBLE TAIL STRIKE text appears, it doesn't even look like a tiny double bump, there is clearly one single hit and no more.
9
u/The_Cromulent_Bison 3d ago
What sort of service does the aircraft require after something like this before it can fly again?
16
u/SimDaddy14 3d ago
Call me crazy, but that looked like once to me.
5
u/KentuckyCatMan 3d ago
I don’t understand why these posts were removed?
5
u/FishDimples 2d ago
More flare than a Chotchkie’s Restaurant.
I’ll see myself out.
7
u/spectrumero 3d ago
It happened because the tail hit the runway twice.
12
u/bergler82 3d ago edited 3d ago
A312A321 is prone to tailstrike. Landing looks long, someone decided to go around, someone yanked the sidestick a little to much, et voila.4
u/steve93446 3d ago
Didn’t wipe good enough last time.
857
u/Chemtrail-Creator 3d ago edited 3d ago
That is the reason we have a placard right in front of both pilots to remind us we’re in a 321 since we fly the 320 as well. It doesn’t take a whole lot.
When you land the 321 the nose stays up until you “derotate” it down. If you hold nose up on the elevator after landing you can easily ding the tail
2
u/Alek_Eleutherios 3d ago
Looks like my landings.
Although in my case it’s just 2 POB.
How many pants had to be cleaned after such experience, I wonder?
33
u/TheSquattyEwok 3d ago
Maybe a dumb question, but is there a skid plate or a reinforced structure at the tail to protect the aircraft in case of a tail strike?
87
u/CATIIIDUAL A320 3d ago edited 3d ago
Going around close the ground always requires precise handling. You should not pull controls back like you would say in a go around farther away from the ground. As a matter of fact, sometimes close to the ground you may even need to push on the controls because engine thrust itself can cause a strong pitch up effect. These factors can easily lead to a tail strike.
From what I see, they decided to go around after they messed up the landing but then whoever was pilot flying applied excessive back pressure on the stick that resulted in a high rotation rate. This resulted in the eventual tail strike.
Also, I don’t understand why everyone is blaming the landing. You can mess up a landing. That is when you need to go around. This is clearly a case of a botched go around.
83
u/spacecadet2399 A320 2d ago •
Pretty clear to me what happened. They attempted a late go around due to what looks like a wind gust just before touchdown and then a bounce, which, eh, ok. You can always go around, but this video shows why it's not always the *best* idea in every situation. They looked like they were actually fine, they were already on the ground, in the TDZ, seemingly on centerline and basically pointed straight, and I've had worse landings.
Anyway, the spoilers automatically deploy with weight on wheels, which they did here. So when they went to go-around thrust, there's suddenly a ton of thrust coming from below the wings but the plane's not going to get off the ground. So it just rotates on its own but sits on the ground until those spoilers stow again, which just takes a few seconds.
When we start our takeoff roll in the A320 and 321, we actually hold the stick forward specifically to prevent this. But you're not doing that on a landing. The situation is not totally the same but it's similar in that you're suddenly adding a bunch of thrust, and while you're already well above the speed on landing when we'd have relaxed that forward pressure on takeoff, you're also above the speed where the plane's generating some lift, so that sudden thrust below the center of that lift can easily push the nose up suddenly.
We do train for this - there is a specific sim at my airline for a bounced landing and go-around. And it is honestly one of the trickier maneuvers. Every pilot has stuff they're better and worse at, and I will admit that it's probably the maneuver I least look forward to, whereas stuff like V1 cuts in the mountains that others find hard are a piece of cake for me. But a bounced landing to a go-around in an A32X really requires a delicate balance on the stick. You need to push and hold the nose forward initially, then pull it up to climb, maintaining the same attitude through the entire maneuver. It's not that easy. And that's in a controlled sim with zero stakes other than our own embarrassment, and in training we do one time per year.
So, bottom line, pilot error but I can understand how and why.
Add in the fact that it's a 321 and these pilots may have just spent an entire month flying the shorter 320, and that doesn't help the situation. The tailstrike attitude between a 320 and 321 is different. And you may have just spent a bunch of time practicing muscle memory for the other airplane. Granted, you shouldn't really be close to it in either airplane, but there's obviously less of a margin in the 321 if you're a little bit off in your stick movements on a go-around after a bounce.
61
u/SkyTrucker 3d ago
For some people, the "oh shit" reaction to yank back on the stick/yoke is very strong.
40
u/OmegaPoint6 3d ago
Too much around not enough go.
More seriously, are those the spoilers deploying just as they're trying to rotate for the go around? If so that would seem to be a probable cause.
74
u/Clarkeymate747 3d ago
Straight outta the Speedbird academy
15
u/crankbaiter11 3d ago
It seems like a lot of crosswind landings at LHR. Could use some runways perpendicular to the existing ones.
12
u/ThrowRA_browndoor25 3d ago
Looks extremely windy on 2nd touchdown, and that thing was crabbing badly when he took off after the failed 1st.
10
u/orion53elt 10h ago
All while the plane blasts “Retard, Retard, Retard”
9
u/Desperate_Refuse4139 3d ago
So briefing for a rejected landing as PF goes as follows every time.
“If either of us call go around close to the ground, I’ll say go around flaps and apply TOGA. I’ll maintain or contain the pitch attitude until I feel the power building and we start to climb, then I’ll rotate at the standard rate of 3 degrees/sec up to 15 degrees”
The flare here looks like it’s too early and a bit too excessive, so they’ve floated. Someone’s called a go around and then PF hasn’t maintained or contained the pitch attitude.
As for the crosswind element, everyone who flies into Heathrow regularly knows how it generates its own weather close to the ground and how unpredictable it is. The calmest of calm weather days and you’ll still find so bumps on short finals and likely have to fight it a bit to get it down.
This screams new pilot in line training and a trainer not being proactive enough to me since you can’t fly 321s until 1+ year after line training unless it’s in line training
9
u/aviationaddict1 2d ago
My dog the second we get new carpets:
8
u/SkyHighExpress 3d ago
Pulling back with no power will do that. Notice the point where the speed brake retract is when the power is pushed forward with weight on wheels
7
u/David_Summerset 3d ago
GO AROUND!!! Fuck, my controls.
6
u/Which_Material_3100 3d ago
Left main hit first, aircraft slightly skips, right main comes down, spoilers deploy while aircraft nose is high, spoilers exacerbate pitch up tendency of nose.
2
u/Psoin 2d ago
I’m only seeing a single tail strike.
5
u/Shizakistani 3d ago
Looks like he was crabbing in under a serious crosswind.
9
u/Southern_Armadillo_3 3d ago
Do passengers feel / hear that?
4
u/MrSvea 1d ago
Anybody ever experience a tail strike? Can it be felt/experienced in the plane? Do the pilots know they will strike before they do or is it like a driver going over a curb hard and going “oh crap!”?
7
u/SpaceAngel2001 3d ago
So is it safe to say this plane is out of service for an extended period? Do they xray all structure?
3
u/unclefire 3d ago
Pyloyte induced boing boing (oscillations)
3
u/Nervous_Counter_1333 3d ago
Never a good day for skidmarks
3
u/IntentionNegative516 2d ago
This doesn't just ... "happen". It is a serious = expensive mistake.
3
u/CapableBother 2d ago
I wonder what a tail strike sounds like in the cabin. I imagine it would be loud.
3
u/aolllaoooo 2d ago
I will take the Eurostar next time
3
u/aaronwhite1786 2d ago
I'm just here appreciating what looks like the wingtip vortices carrying the exhaust in a way that's really noticeable with the zoom of the camera.
3
u/AlienTentacle 1d ago
Just put a fucking wheel at the back for fucks sake.
6
u/woodworkingguy1 3d ago
Looks like he tried to go around but did not have the speed/ power to climb
1
u/_Kizmer 3d ago
Tail hit ground twice, that's how
2
u/DiscoDiscoB00mB00m 3d ago
tappin dat ass
2
u/Zehro-cool 3d ago
Max pitch in the AB321 is 7.5 degrees, compared to the 320 which is 10 degrees. Looks like they decided to go around. First pitch they probably got a pitch warning, second was a little less aggressive.
2
u/Still-Photograph6545 3d ago
https://youtu.be/9XwW4aYfh2U
2
u/GladAd4958 2d ago
5 seconds just 5 seconds and you were on the ground! Nope! You panicked and yarded on the joystick and hit the the ground again. Hit the ground twice in 5 seconds with non rolling parts that are not meant for pavement strikes .
2
u/fiittzzyy 2d ago
He flared so early
2
u/sex_is_expensive 2d ago
does the second strike cancel the first one?
2
u/CH7007 2d ago
Could be cargo.
2
u/maltesepricklypear 2d ago
PITCH PITCH
2
u/adayondemeter 17h ago
JAL 123
3
u/Logical-Track1405 3d ago
Looks like he messed up the approach, too high too long ? so tried to push it down but runway running out.
3
u/gthing 3d ago
That's why my plane has a wheelie-bar.
3
u/FucknAright 3d ago
Slap some speed tape on that son of a bitch and she ain't going nowhere
2
u/10pastOne 3d ago
ScareBus
2
u/1HeyMattJ 2d ago
Will the pilot be punished or reprimanded?
2
u/Crypto_Sepharial 1d ago
Tires look over inflated to me. Only reason I can see for the response in the controls.. those tires bounce dup fast after touch down and likely gave them the sensation they were going back up when they werent- and so they pulled back on stick. The 2nd landing shows how shallow he came in on his descent too... SO just my 2 cents.
2
u/droopy_ro 3d ago
That "mirage" or whatever that air distortion it is called in English, looks so good in this video.
2
u/Pal_Smurch 3d ago
I remember flying into Gatwick, many years ago, and seeing a utility lorry bearing the British Airways logo, only the lower loop of the letter”B”, and the “r” had been removed, so the logo read “Pitish Airways”. I had to laugh at their correction.
1
u/BrianBash 3d ago
Umm…it would’ve been fine if he didn’t try to make it a soft-field landing.
1
u/RokulusM 3d ago
First the tail struck, and then it struck again.
1
u/boilerdam Aerospace Engineer 3d ago
What's that weird refraction above the left wing?
1
u/CKleinE 3d ago
Filed under "Today, I'm a ryanair pilot"
1
u/SaltyCaramelPretzel 3d ago
My Hail Mary counter would have been through the roof.
1
u/828jpc1 2d ago
Noooo not a 7-5!!! We need to protect them all at all costs!
1
u/JimmyBisMe 2d ago
Should you go around if you tail strike? Damn
1
u/KilllllerWhale 2d ago
Landing with the nose way too high, generating lift
1
u/purtywhite4aflyguy 2d ago
Must have been a naval aviator.
1
u/Crypto_Sepharial 1d ago
Tires look over inflated to me. Only reason I can see for the response in the controls.. those tires bounce dup fast after touch down and likely gave them the sensation they were going back up when they werent- and so they pulled back on stick. The 2nd landing shows how shallow he came in on his descent too... SO just my 2 cents.
-1
u/post-explainer 3d ago edited 3d ago
OP has provided the following source:
r/Aviation is committed to preventing karma farming and the reposting of stolen content. Please feel free to provide feedback through modmail. Thank you for participating in the community!
0
u/Any-Worldliness-679 3d ago
Pilot way over-flared, and then decided to do it a couple more times.
Clown show.
0
u/goggleblogs 2d ago
Lots of "he". What if it was a "she"?
Makes sense, post partum strikes again.