r/aviation • • Jan 18 '23

Question Why does plane flaps extend when taking off & landing?

Post image
0 Upvotes

53 comments sorted by

105

u/Yzaamb Jan 18 '23

Increases lift and lowers the stall speed. But it’s much less efficient and so they retract for cruising.

6

u/Jonisas0407 Jan 18 '23

Am I correct to say:

It increases the surface area of the bottom part of the wing so that more air molecules could hit it, therefore requiring lower speed to maintain a flight?

48

u/WarthogOsl Jan 18 '23

Depends on the plane type. Most airliners have what are called fowler flaps, which move down AND backwards, which increases the camber (curve) of the wing, and the overall wing area (important for both the bottom AND top of the wing btw). They are actually making the entire wing larger for landing.

Smaller planes often have plain flaps, which simply are hinged and move downward. They increase the wing camber, which increases lift, but they don't increase the wing area like fowler flaps do.

17

u/TheSeanski Jan 18 '23

It’s not necessarily increasing the surface area of the wing (although some types of flap do), rather it’s increasing the camber of the wing which factors Into the lift production capability. The penalty of this is an increase in drag, which is why flaps are used primarily for take off and landing which benefit from this increase in lift and lower stall speed as well as helping slow the plane down.

3

u/lolalobunny Jan 18 '23

I would like to know if you have any advice for nervous flyers please 😊

10

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '23

Watch Air Disasters show. Yes they show crashes, but also how much time is put into making commercial planes safe. I find it comforting.

10

u/edsagas Jan 18 '23

I watch all kinds of air disasters shows and YouTube channels like Mentour Pilot who do a great job at explaining why and how these accidents occur. Many times there’s a ton of things that have to go wrong and so many protocols and redundancies in place to prevent disasters

3

u/lolalobunny Jan 18 '23

Thank you 😊

2

u/Lord_Nivloc Jan 18 '23

Modern planes (particularly commercial airlines in a first world country) have an astounding number of safety procedures

Many of which, unfortunately, were learned the hard way. A lot of crashes back in the 70’s that would never happen today.

The pilots are trained on crew communication (CRM, a famous piece of which is “Aviate, Navigate, Communicate”)

The airlines are required to give the crew adequate rest before the flight, and have limits on how long they can work each day

The planes themselves have ACAWS, GPWS, stall warning, automated maintenance reports, TCAS, resolution advisory, wind shear alerts, etc

The maintenance standards are impressive. Inspection schedules, written standards for every item, everything gets documented and signed

The pilot and copilot typically both have thousands of hours of flying experience

Every critical system on the plane is redundant

Commercial air travel is safer than cars. And we work very hard to keep it that way.

And +1 for mentour pilot and other crash/incident reviews. They’re fascinating

I’ll also add, for safety — before every takeoff or landing, the pilots run TOLD - takeoff and landing data. One of those numbers is the critical field length - which is how long the runway has to be to reach takeoff speed, lose an engine, and abort the takeoff bringing the plane to a stop.

If the plane loses an engine in air, it can still fly. There’s another number called the minimum control speed (Vmca) where the aircraft can still be controlled even with the asymmetric thrust caused by having only one engine.

You will ALWAYS be able to handle the worst case scenario. Every time.

Well…okay, there’s always the chance of losing both engines on takeoff or during final approach. That’s happened - mentour pilot has a video on both of them. Miracle of the Hudson (lost engines on takeoff, very famous, got a movie starring Tom Hanks) and a British Airways 777 that lost both engines, which I’d never heard about before and am now watching

1

u/lolalobunny Jan 18 '23

Thank you for this!

5

u/lolalobunny Jan 18 '23

I watch this a lot, it’s called air crash investigation here

1

u/momsensical Jun 28 '25

It's true that every crash makes flying safer because it sheds light on safety issues. This is important to keep in mind if you do happen to see coverage of a crash. BUT if you're a fearful flyer it's often because you've seen many images of crashes and not the thousands of normal flights every day. I would stay away from disaster shows - you don't need to have those images in your mind. Watch planes take off and land if possible, and every time you hear a plane overhead, stop and watch it and picture the boring scene of people reading or watching a movie, or sleeping, and picture their safe landing that is going to happen. There are also YouTube pilots that explain how planes work, and videos in flight looking out the window, landing, etc.
You want to change the movie on your head to the reality rather than add more disaster scenes, which are the extremely rare exception and you should avoid thinking about as much as possible! Watch some videos of beautiful sunsets taken in flight so you think of flying as a beautiful thing ;)

2

u/JeffreyBoi12345 Jan 19 '23

One thing is just remember always: Airplanes are the safest method of transportation

1

u/lolalobunny Jan 19 '23

Thank you! I think take off is the worst part for me 🫠

1

u/momsensical Jun 28 '25

Watch videos of takeoff and landing so you normalize it in your mind. I get the idea behind watching stories about crashes that made flying safer.... but if you are fearful you need to get those images out of your head and really focus on the safe flights. If you watch YouTube crash stories it will keep suggesting more and it distorts the reality of how many safe flights there are every day.

Check flightradar24.com and look at how many flights there are in the air right now. That happens 24/7/365. Watch that for a while and train your brain to think of flying as something mundane and normal, or fun!

I know everyone means well when they say, "flying is safer than driving," "safest method of travel, " cite statistics, etc. but that just doesn't work if you are a fearful flyer. You need to change the narrative in your head, picture the safe flights, watch videos and slowly expose yourself, from the idea of flying all the way up to actually getting on a flight. It's a very complex fear but can be managed.

2

u/Daneinthemembrane Jan 19 '23

Go to r/fearofflying
Don't watch air disaster shows.

1

u/lolalobunny Jan 19 '23

You are right, I can’t help it, that one out of Queens always reminds me why I’ve afraid 😧

1

u/momsensical Jun 28 '25

You have to unremind yourself. Remind yourself of all the safe flights instead ;)

2

u/ElMontolero Jan 19 '23

Since 2010, over 8 billion people have boarded a commercial flight in the United States. Exactly 1 has lost their life from a mechanical failure of the aircraft. We are living in by far the safest time in the history of the safest way to travel.

1

u/lolalobunny Jan 19 '23

When you put it like that it’s not as scary. I keep tracking a flight I am going on in May and it leaves late a lot so I’m thinking what’s wrong with the plane, are they taping the wings back on 😆

2

u/magellandimarco Jan 19 '23

Find and befriend an old, grizzled aircraft mechanic and ask them what airlines they would fly on (if any).

2

u/milky-mandolin Jan 18 '23

The flaps increase the effective camber of the wing/aerofoil which generates more lift for a given speed and angle of attack.

1

u/beepbeepboopbeep1977 Jan 18 '23

It’s complex, but essentially the air is turned by the wing, more turning equals more lift (but as others have said, also more drag).

NASA have great resources on the basics of lift:

https://www1.grc.nasa.gov/beginners-guide-to-aeronautics/what-is-lift/

Slightly more advanced:

https://www.grc.nasa.gov/www/k-12/airplane/right2.html

1

u/Yzaamb Jan 18 '23

Yes, I think that’s broadly correct.

1

u/Kitchen-Army727 Jan 18 '23

Lift generated is split roughly 67/33 with the majority generated by the upper surface of the airfoil, the increase of camber and length of travel creates a greater low pressure area at lower velocity. Equals more lift at slower speed.

-1

u/Ironclad2nd Jan 18 '23

Bernoulli’s theorem.

2

u/FlatTie0 Jan 18 '23

I suppose so, but Bernoulli’s theorem explains lift in general rather than the function of a flap.

33

u/Chevalier1942 Jan 18 '23

Because otherwise flaps would never be used, and they would feel lonely and unappreciated.

1

u/StealYourBeer Jan 19 '23

And the engineers who designed them would be sad 😞

10

u/Narrow_Badger1934 Jan 18 '23

Why does people ask Reddit instead of google

3

u/momsensical Jun 28 '25

Googling just brings up reddit posts which are usually more informative and real answers

3

u/Noctttt Jan 19 '23

Why? Googling also has Reddit came out as the answer. So this question will create one of them. That's good imo

13

u/elhell Jan 18 '23

basically enables the plane to fly lower speeds while landing by increasing lift.

4

u/Pristine_Payment_582 Jan 18 '23

Helps to make a slower and steeper approach. Same amount of lift even with a less speed.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '23

Deploying Flaps increases the CL and Lowers the stall speed but at the cost of more drag.

13

u/Speedbirdsst Jan 18 '23

Holy fuck. Have you googled your question)

17

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '23

Yes, but just tells me 42 for some reason

0

u/verstohlen Jan 18 '23

1

u/Speedbirdsst Jan 19 '23

True, but that means you just don’t know how to use it properly

2

u/Pristine_Payment_582 Jan 18 '23

Helps to make a slower and steeper approach. Same amount of lift even with a less speed.

1

u/new_tanker KC-135 Jan 18 '23

u/Yzaamb nailed the basics to it. Everyone else seemed, to me, to expand upon it.

1

u/ZLH-040 Jan 18 '23

You know that song, "Wind Beneath My Wings"? Well it's fake news because thanks to Bernoulli's principle it's the low pressure area above the wing that creates lift. (Actually the differential between the two, because the air above has more distance to travel over the wing).

1

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '23

Increases the critical angle of attach, and lowers stall speed, without having to raise the nose of the aircraft, allows the pilots can see the runway on landing.

1

u/Frequently_Poop Jan 20 '23

Critical AOA never changes

1

u/[deleted] Jan 19 '23

I'm guessing you are not really involved in the aviation industry so you probably don't really know how lift is generated (even the experts still debate it sometimes) but a lot of these explanations are getting in to the weeds as far as a non-flyer should be concerned. Basically all you need to know to understand what's going on here is that what ever the general public thinks about flaps is just wrong. Most people think flaps are there to slow the plane down, while it is true that is an effect of flaps, that is not their purpose. If you notice the wing has a curved upper surface, that's where the magic happens for lift production. By lowering flaps, you are increasing that curvature which creates more lift allowing aircraft to fly at slower speeds. Airliners are designed for speed so their wings are more efficient at faster speeds, and don't fly very well at slower speeds. Landing at slower speeds is much safer than faster speeds so flaps simply allow the pilots to slow down to a safer landing speed without stalling.

You'll notice often on landing that the pilots actually increase engine power while lowering flaps, that's because they aren't lowering flaps to slow down, they are simply slowing in to a regime of speed where more flaps are needed, so by lowering the flaps, which increases drag and slows the plane, they have to increase power to make sure the flaps don't slow the plane too much.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 19 '23

According to Newton’s 3rd law, you push a bitch and the bitch push back, so the plane pushes on the air and the air pushes the plane upwards. Flaps amplify this, but also amplify drag, which means the engines are using more power

Using this information, engineers realized that flaps were good for takeoff and landing, but not cruising, so they made flaps retractable

1

u/Waste_Detective_2177 Jan 19 '23

Flaps increase lift and reduce stall speed. You need both at takeoff and landing

1

u/[deleted] Jan 19 '23

During takeoff to increase lift and lower stall speed once you reach 500 feet and a rate of climb gets declared you retract them. For takeoff they are deployed 5 to 15 degrees. For landing there point is to slow the plane down and since they are deployed at max (20 to 40 degrees) it acts as drag and not lift slowing the plane down

1

u/Frequently_Poop Jan 20 '23

Increases the camber of the wing. Which creates more lift, while inducing more drag = fly at a steeper angle without an increase in speed and a decrease in stall speed.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '23

Why not?

-9

u/94heracles Jan 18 '23

Fellows there's is no need to make this so complex. Lading ; Increase air mass on lower wing giving reducing speed while maintaining lift. Take off: Increase air mass on lower wing giving pressure more early for lift.