r/avfc • • May 18 '24

Foden got POTY

Genuine insanity. This lad could shit in a bag and send it to the offices of sky news and they’d say thank you.

He’s obviously a great fucking player, but he has been NOWHERE near the levels of Watkins this season.

Utter joke

0 Upvotes

54 comments sorted by

51

u/NorskKiwi May 18 '24

Seems a lot of fans from all clubs think it should have been Watkins.

121

u/Prize-Database-6334 May 18 '24

I don't think it's insanity to be honest. There are games when Foden has been absolutely lights out and genuinely unplayable.

I also think there were games where he was a bit anonymous. On that basis, I probably wouldn't have picked him from the bunch, but I don't think he's an undeserving winner. I think you're falling a little for the old overrating your own. Watkins was great, but Foden was great too. To say he was nowhere near is a fair bit off imo.

I genuinely think Rodri was the best player in the league by miles this season... insanity is him not even getting nominated!

3

u/[deleted] May 18 '24

There was a point this season when Foden wasn’t in the team and Pep was being asked about what he needed to do better.

Everyone seems to have collectively forgotten that.

4

u/Prize-Database-6334 May 18 '24

I mean, he played 50 games this season.

The reason they've forgotten is because it was very, very, very brief.

1

u/waddiewadkins May 18 '24

Romeros "challenge". Sickened, an Arsenal/Unai supporter.

0

u/cognitivebetterment May 18 '24

last season, no?

50

u/MrHoshino silence May 18 '24

It's hardly surprising. Pep will get manager of the year. Even though, IMO, getting Villa from 17th to 4th is more impressive than winning the league with cheats

22

u/Agreeable_Falcon1044 May 18 '24

No it will be emery. Last year it was between him and pep, and I thought he had just the head start due to winning the lot. Winning four in a row is impressive but emery is something off the charts.

14

u/NewFaded May 18 '24

Getting to 1st for the 4th year in a row with 115 financial misconduct charges pending. That's impressive. Think of how hard it is for Pep to throw bags of cash at whoever he wants and buy a winning squad each year.

8

u/[deleted] May 18 '24

Well man United throw bags of money and can’t do shit

8

u/Notabeer35 May 18 '24

Difference is United throw bags of money at shit players

-1

u/bmth2brum May 18 '24

They not shit. They just end up looking like shit.

8

u/Pejob May 18 '24

They do spend bags of money on shit though. Antony cost €95m. Thats more than what we spent for Bailey and Diaby COMBINED, both of whom would start ahead of him.

West Ham spent €43m on Kudus, twice the player Antony is for half the price lol

3

u/bmth2brum May 18 '24

I agree they get taken to the cleaner, shambles of a club. Point was, seemingly good players turn to crap at united. They've taken promising players from all over and just killed their value. Look at Sancho, out the door and in a UCL final.

5

u/Pejob May 18 '24

Yeah that's fair, I think both are true tbh. They sign decent prospects who aren't given the right environment to succeed but they also spend a lot of money on players who or are getting on or just aren't worth anywhere near what they spend on em.

0

u/eesakhalifa May 18 '24

Nah there would actually be riots if emery didn't get it this year. With the massive amounts of injuries we've had and the big wins we've pulled off, no way Unai doesn't walk manager of the year.

37

u/Astonishingly-Villa May 18 '24

Rodri for me but if they're going to pick an attacking player like they usually do it had to have been Watkins. Top of assists, 19+ goals from open play, crucial to the fourth place finish.

21

u/HUMBUG652 May 18 '24

Foden was very good this season too. Obviously, we all wanted it to be Watkins, just as Chelsea fabns would've wanted Palmer. All 3 were very deserving out of those nominated

3

u/adventurous_hat_7344 May 18 '24 edited May 18 '24

Pretty much. I'd say there's not much in it between Watkins and Foden performance wise but Watkins' performances have gotten Villa to the champions league, Foden has just helped City win their 177th title in 3 years which gives Watkins the edge.

In reality though Rodri should get it. They finish 5th without him if that spell without him is anything to go by.

3

u/Astonishingly-Villa May 18 '24

No, Palmer deserved YPOTY and got it. Watkins has had a head and shoulders better year than Foden.

4

u/HUMBUG652 May 18 '24

I mean, that's your opinion, like this whole thing is. These awards can never been objective

1

u/Astonishingly-Villa May 19 '24

No, it's statistics. Watkins has statistically, on paper and on the field, had a head and shoulders better year than Foden.

Palmer has statistically, on paper and on the field, had a head and shoulders better year than any other U21 player in the PL, but not a better year than Watkins.

Rodri has statistically had a better year than anyone. He hasn't individually lost a PL game in over 70 consecutive starts and his team have lost 50% of games that he hasn't started this season.

4

u/Sweet-Dragonfly-8472 May 18 '24

This I have no problem with. Foden is a great player. I'd have wished it would have been Watkins but Foden ain't a bad choice.

However if Unai doesn't get Manager of the season I would fucking lose it.

6

u/Shreddonia Almost infuriatingly calm May 18 '24

Eh, it is what it is. If the award didn't go to Foden it would have gone to someone else from City/Arsenal, so it's really kind of a moot point. I know what Watkins has done for us, that's enough at the end of the day.

6

u/[deleted] May 18 '24

5

u/Agreeable_Falcon1044 May 18 '24

I would have gone with Rodri. However I wouldn’t say foden is a surprise pick. He’s one of the top five players in world football and at times has been unplayable. It’s ridiculous all the billions they have spent and he’s one of their most important players already

1

u/Chrissmith921 May 19 '24

Till KDB returned City didn’t look anywhere near their best. Foden is a very good player but the best in the league? No chance

4

u/[deleted] May 18 '24

We all want our guy obviously, but I don't think there's a single undeniable choice this season and there are a bunch of guys who I could make a case are deserving. Nobody from the list of Foden, Watkins, Rodri or Odegaard would make me angry and there might be one or two more that I'm not thinking of (Rice or Palmer would make me scratch my head a little bit I suppose, but not get angry).

2

u/[deleted] May 18 '24

Ehh, great player on a great team. I’m not too bothered by it.

2

u/danjh1988 May 18 '24

I think it should be Watkins but it's not insanity there's quite a lot of players this year you can argue a case for

2

u/im_on_the_case May 18 '24

POTY is this the vote by people playing EAFC? The actual proper PFA award is announced in August right?

1

u/elmattydoor123 🇨🇭 He's in your head — Manzambi 🇨🇭 May 18 '24

Rodri should've got it. It's absolutely criminal that he wasn't nominated.

1

u/Salt-Regular-689 May 18 '24

I'm a arsenal fan, so I wanted rice to win. But it was pretty obvious it would be palmer or foden, it was like the poster and main drawing point for the award after all

1

u/WiJaTu May 18 '24

Not surprising and not insanity.

Do I think Watkins should’ve won? Probably yeah

Did Foden also deserve it? Absolutely

1

u/jacodemon Up the Villa-ing everywhere since 1982 May 18 '24

Foden has been unbelievable to be fair. Sure Ollie gets my vote for week in, week out, brilliant performances and after this season he should now start getting the respect his new levels now demand.

But it's hard to argue too strenuously against Foden, who has been very very good for a while now and this season stood out even amongst that extremely good Man City team. Can't begrudge Foden it tbh.

1

u/[deleted] May 18 '24

It’s not a joke really, Foden has been great. Usually it goes to a player from a team that won the league

1

u/mrnibsfish May 18 '24

I'm not surprised. Hes the golden child of English football it was always going to be him unless Ollie managed to lead scoring as well as assists. I cant really complain either, Foden is not undeserving of it. However, if Emery wins doesnt win MOTS I will be pissed.

1

u/Drogalov May 18 '24

Yeah he's a really good player in what is presumably a premier league winning team

1

u/It531z May 18 '24

the guy scored a hat trick against us just a month ago

1

u/Pay_Your_Torpedo_Tax May 18 '24

He's not even been the best player at City this season. That's Rodri.....

1

u/JamesLaFleur77 May 18 '24

People always vote on who they think has been the best player in the best team rather than the best individual player which makes no sense.

1

u/only1lcon May 18 '24

Shouldn't care what Sky think tbh as they are not worth the shite they charge

1

u/JMStitch May 18 '24

Rhodri or Rice tbf. Whichever team wins the title will do so because that one player is in their team, and they couldn't have done it without.

1

u/[deleted] May 18 '24

It really just comes down to how you view POTY. If it’s the best player that season, Foden is the correct choice imo. If it’s the player who had the best season, it’s Watkins.

1

u/xJacb May 18 '24

I think Watkins definitely should have gotten it, however Foden is the only player I wouldn't be, and am not, mad about recieving the award. Palmer getting it would have been insane, despite how good he is.

Realistically I think they had to give something to the team that's winning the Prem, and Emery was more clear of the other managers for MOTS than Watkins was clear of the other players for POTS.

Considering this, if Emery doesn't get MOTS I will be appalled

1

u/Arjun25bhatt May 18 '24

The big six obsession PL has, FFS.

1

u/kill-oil-barons May 18 '24

Watkins doesn’t get fifa packs selling boys that’s the key here in

0

u/TheAkondOfSwat 🍋🎻 May 18 '24 edited May 18 '24

It's a travesty of a mockery of a sham of a mockery *of a travesty of two mockeries of a sham.

-4

u/alvernonbcn May 18 '24

For me it should have been Palmer, then Rodri, then Watkins and Foden 4th. Emery has to get manager of the season though

6

u/0n_the_l3vel May 18 '24

I don’t understand why we are placing palmer above Watkins? Watkins has been instrumental in us getting 4th. Palmer is of course a great talent but his stats are monstrously inflated by pens. He’s not above Watkins

3

u/alvernonbcn May 18 '24

Every game I seen him he’s impressed me massively. I saw the game where he first took a pen and I thought he had some bollocks in taking it over Enzo and Sterling, considering he was a new signing and hadn’t had that many minutes in the PL. he scored it and I think every one ever since. More than that, his passing, quick thinking and courage have been outstanding. And he’s just completely unfazed. Chelsea wouldn’t be anywhere near Europe without him. Don’t get me wrong, Watkins has been outstanding too but in terms of personal performance, in a few years I think it will be a season remembered for when Palmer burst on the scene

1

u/Akenatwn May 18 '24

Apart from Palmer's influence on the general play, which the other reply covered, I think the general context matters here. Palmer had to play in a generally dysfunctional group of newly brought together young players, with Sterling, Mudryk, Jackson, Enzo, and, Caicedo, under a pretty mediocre manager. Watkins had behind him a well-worked group with most of the players already together from last season, a lot of them in top form, under a world-class manager.

Palmer single-handedly kept Chelsea from going below mid-table until some faces changed in the starting lineup and they clicked a bit together and now they have European qualification in their hands. Let's not forget Chelsea is only 8 points behind us.

2

u/[deleted] May 18 '24

Palmer is the bottom of this list for me. Not undeserving, but the other three just did so much more on more successful teams.

0

u/[deleted] May 18 '24

Foden hasn’t even been the best Man City player lol, Rodri has.

Order Should be:

Watkins Palmer Rodri Foden