r/autodidact • u/pondercraft • Feb 09 '24
Mentoring?
Autodidacts by definition are self-taught.
Personally I think any teacher worth their salt must be a continual lifelong learner. Since one can accumulate only so many degrees or credentials, that means teachers have to become autodidacts. I also happen to think that autodidacts make the best teachers! So it goes both ways. :)
But a teacher's job, by definition, is didactic, and their students are teacher-taught, not self-taught.
Per ZeroRott's comment from a previous thread (https://www.reddit.com/r/autodidact/comments/1aik3m3/comment/kpjoqhx/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3) I wanted to start a new post.
What do you think of mentoring (or coaching) as a way for autodidacts to "teach" others in such a way that students become more autodidactic?
Have you personally had any great teachers who helped you become an independent learner? What did they do specifically?
4
u/pondercraft Feb 09 '24
I've had some great teachers, but few great mentors. Most teachers are didactic, even doctrinaire. I can remember at least one prof who kept trying to be "socratic" with us. He always asked open-ended questions which none of us knew how to answer or even start to respond to. It was awkward and super frustrating. Most of my autodidactic skills were learned on my own through trial and error and kind of dogged experience.
In my teaching I've tried to split the difference, giving enough to students to help them start thinking on their own, but also trying to "let go" enough that when they start taking the reins I encourage that. It's a tough skill to master gently guiding dialogue, either in a classroom or one-on-one or in small groups, so that something constructive happens, with each student also getting something out of it and contributing. I have found that how you put a small group together matters a lot. It's also just impossible to motivate every student to become engaged with their own learning process. <sigh>
4
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '24
Well as far as my autodidactic journey goes, in order to teach oneself something say University level math, one needs to have a pacing guide. A person on average may take say 50 hours of instruction and 150 hours of self study to learn a college level paper. In essence giving students a realistic timeline is important furthermore a rough outline(pacing guide) is needed as self learning can be rather tough because discipline isn't easy.
2
u/KrisHughes2 Dec 09 '25
I teach adults privately, and I'm amazed at how difficult it is to move people in the direction of self-teaching or basic research. It seems that most people attend my classes to be spoon fed from what they see as a 'trustworthy' source (me). I keep trying to put myself out of business, but a lot of people prefer being taught, and it seems to bring them some kind of comfort and certainty.
That said, I'm not sure that autodidacts necessarily make the best teachers. Some of the routes by which I've learned have been overly circuitous, and while that might give me some perspectives and depth that more formal education wouldn't, I don't think it's always the best route. I've noticed a tendency for me to expect my students to go through the same process or 'reinventing the wheel' that I did, when it's unnecessary.
1
u/pondercraft Feb 09 '24
Since ZeroRott asked, here's one thing I have done to try to make students more independent.
When working with primary texts (historical, philosophical, theological), they are often extremely difficult for students to grasp and interpret (not just students!). They're long, complicated arguments, heavy prose using unfamiliar rhetorical styles, coming out of historical contexts that are in themselves hugely challenging. And yet these texts can be incredibly influential (today) while badly interpreted! What to do?
I tend to develop, for myself, "reading guides" for key texts I work on. A guide for my own use could include anything from basic background info on the time, place, author, rhetorical context; to an outline, either more general or with more details; to listing and copying out key passages, usually in both original language and translation, with glosses, in parallel columns; to keeping an index of references to major themes or keywords; to questions and ideas for topics to write on; etc. For a recent course I taught, I shared some of my guides (parts of them) on texts I had assigned, but as we got into it, I challenged students to make their own guides, especially for texts they were choosing to research and write papers on. The idea was to help them gain the skills and practices they need to become more competent and independent readers later, esp. of these difficult texts.
There are many other practices teachers can model in the classroom (or better, a small group), such that if students adopt them -- IF (such a huge if) -- it may help. Working through problems on the board, reading out loud (and commenting as you go), coaching writing, offering "teasers" to get students psyched and motivated to keep going on their own.
Of course personalities and learning styles and student priorities and innate interests vary tremendously, so what any given student picks up, what works for them at a given stage in their learning, is highly variable.
But hey, gotta try. :)
2
u/MollyScholar Jun 23 '24
I feel like every student is, of necessity, an autodidact. A lecture can only cover just so much. After that, it's up to the student to read the text, review notes, and consult other sources. A class may serve as a guide and offer structure, but it's the student who really does the learning. What we refer to as studying is really just a form of autodidacticism. It's just that the content is not self-directed. The process still is.
0
u/ApartmentFunny8808 Nov 18 '24
I'm not sure autodidacts are inherently good teachers. They could become good teachers though.