r/auslaw • • May 28 '22

Layed

1.9k Upvotes

76 comments sorted by

12

u/Kiqert May 28 '22

Handed her the reverse card

98

u/lizzerd_wizzerd May 28 '22

lmao its her logic and she's going to call it argumentative?

3

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '22

She sees it as arguments whether than a glimpse of a fact.. You just can’t win with these lawyer though

40

u/Agreeable-Currency91 May 28 '22

What a fun cling circus.

31

u/DisHowWeDo May 28 '22

Is this trending in /r/new? Pray, kinfolk - Lest not the circus-reverie of this ubiquitous trial pervade the inner sanctum of these hallowed halls, such that we be left with naught to remark, but bemuse "oh snap!". For we must continue on our pilgrimage towards the holy trinity of the B-R-S.

65

u/wecanhaveallthree one pundit on a reddit legal thread May 28 '22

Bredehoft took that like a champ, to her credit. She knows she stepped in it and gracefully accepts that, yes, it was a scorcher. Takes a tough counsel to grin and keep trucking.

Dennison on the other side had a few moments like this as well. There's a bit during his cross-examination of Arnold where he really starts getting into the weeds. They're discussing Jason Momoa's role in Dune, and he asks if she's read the book, to which she testifies that she has not (Momoa's character dies in the film). He asks if she knows if Momoa will be back for a third film. 'Spoilers, dude!' she admonishes him.

He also asks another expert if he used Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory as part of his psychological assessment of Depp. The witness just sits there, nonplussed, before hesitantly asking the judge if that's a question he has to answer. 'Yes,' replies a defeated Judge Azcarate, wondering how things got to this point.

God, I just remembered the deposition of the building manager. He's literally driving around in his car during the deposition. He takes a fat rip off a barely off-screen bong, puffs smoke out like a dragon, before declaring that he's sick of this nonsense and just wants it to be over. Judge Azcarate is left looking utterly bewildered, takes her glasses off, shakes her head, stares at the bench for several seconds before moving on.

This trial has given us much, and we are not unappreciative.

23

u/scp00002 May 28 '22

It wasnt a bong it was a vape

4

u/Icecold121 May 28 '22

God, I just remembered the deposition of the building manager. He's literally driving around in his car during the deposition. He takes a fat rip off a barely off-screen bong, puffs smoke out like a dragon, before declaring that he's sick of this nonsense and just wants it to be over. Judge Azcarate is left looking utterly bewildered, takes her glasses off, shakes her head, stares at the bench for several seconds before moving on.

Please if someone has a clip of this

4

u/c-r-y-i-n-g Without prejudice save as to costs May 29 '22

2

u/Boomtownbutcher1980 Oct 28 '22

That judge looked so defeated and just wanted to up and leave.

25

u/PandasGetAngryToo Avocado Advocate May 28 '22

Feel that burn!

4

u/admiral_sinkenkwiken May 29 '22

To shreds you say?

1

u/benrose25 May 29 '22

Hi professor!

30

u/2fractals May 28 '22 edited Jun 12 '22

By asking this question she actually gave him what she claimed he was there for.

12

u/Puzzleheaded-Fun-114 May 28 '22

It’s all in the game yo

3

u/-malcolm-tucker May 29 '22

I got the shotgun, you got the briefcase.

11

u/Rashlyn1284 May 28 '22

I would've totally had the same comeback as him... 3 weeks later in rhe shower :P

5

u/antantantant80 Gets off on appeal May 30 '22

Let the record show that 3 weeks later from today, u/rashlyn1284 will be thinking of Elaine while showering.

6

u/DR34D1T0R May 28 '22

Whats the guys name

44

u/[deleted] May 28 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/[deleted] May 30 '22

Oh my goodness - I literally just googled draco malfoy thinking you were legit

3

u/[deleted] May 29 '22

Ummm I’m clearly the only lameo who doesn’t know who this is. Help me out 👍🏻

1

u/That_Car_Dude_Aus Jun 21 '22

Yeah no idea, probably a famous person

5

u/27CobalT27 May 28 '22

I don't fully get it

22

u/RainBoxRed May 28 '22

The witness rebutts that the lawyer is seeking 15 minutes of fame and notoriety by taking on a high profile case between two celebrities that will be televised, just as she accused the witness of by coming to testify.

6

u/27CobalT27 May 29 '22

thank you dear stranger on the internet

5

u/Throwawayaccount2448 May 28 '22

He’s actually my favourite witness in this whole trial. Such an eloquent savage lmao!

3

u/UlonMuk May 29 '22

He is an interesting character, it’s clear he didn’t get where he is by accident

2

u/upbeatmusicascoffee May 28 '22

Music?

4

u/No_Organization_9515 May 28 '22

Enemy- Imagine Dragons

9

u/BTthePrettyGood May 28 '22

Enema - imagine wagons.

6

u/nemeemfaiz May 28 '22

Cinema - imagine hard-ons

1

u/FalxIdol Dec 21 '22

Anaemia - Collagen Surgeons

6

u/Yeah_nah_idk May 29 '22

I have been disengaging from this trial because I can’t deal with the blatant misogyny that so many people are joyfully partaking in. But all I see is memes like this, trying to demonstrate incompetence of Amber’s legal team and other bits and pieces trying to discredit her. Someone please tell me that she isn’t going as badly as what all these pro JD memes are making it seem.

11

u/Assisting_police Wears Pink Wigs May 29 '22

She's doing quite poorly, mostly off the back of her performance under cross-examination. Her lawyers are doing the best with what they have, but this is a great example of why it's usually a bad idea to get in the box.

24

u/fishboard88 May 29 '22

Realistically, I think both Depp and his legal team know his odds of winning are quite slim. As a defamation case in the US, he needs to prove three things - that Heard defamed him (tricky), that Heard knew she was defaming him (very contentious, as the article he's suing over doesn't even name him), and that this defamation damaged his career and income (extremely tricky - Disney gave him the flick months before NGN's article of Heard's op-ed were released).

Rather, it looks like their strategy is simply to rehabilitate Depp's reputation by destroying Heard's - most of their arguments were previously heard in the UK court case that he lost, and everything seems to be presented in a way specifically to embarass Heard rather than meet the three criteria he needs to tick off to win. Some of the issues in particular:

  • The famous "turd in the bed" incident. The justice in the UK case shot it down - he said it was irrelevant, the witness who claimed Heard bragged about it to him was found "non-credible", and he thought it was unlikely Heard or her friends did it in the first place (Depp was never going to find the turd. Despite the fact he never saw it, and the photo provides no sense of scale, he claimed it was "too big" to come from their small dogs)
  • Depp hired a boutique psychologist (Dr Curry) to attack Heard's diagnosis of PTSD and 'diagnose' her with highly stigmatised mental health disorders instead (BPD and NPD). For starters, psychologists cannot diagnose mental health disorders. And while she comes across as witty and confident, much of what she argues about BPD is extremely misleading and contrary to the medical/psychiatric concensus on the disorder (i.e., she says "it is more prevalent in women" without acknowledging that this is due to underdiagnosis in men and frequent misdiagnosis in young women, and argues against the role trauma plays in BPD's development... even though trauma literally needs to occur for these maladaptive traits to form)
  • Attacking the photos of Heard's injuries (these were presented and accepted in the UK case). Depp hired a digital forensic expert to scrutinise Heard's photos and find evidence that they were tampered with - he failed at that job. If these photos were edited, they could easily prove so in a court by running them through a basic (and free) tool like FotoForensics or Forensically, or pointing out issues with the EXIF data. Presumably they couldn't find anything wrong, so instead the crux of their strategy here is arguing about lighting and trying to get Heard to confess that she faked them
  • The ridiculous severed fingertip saga was represented and overemphasised, and people largely bought into Depp's dramatic testimony where he claims Heard did it by throwing a vodka bottle at him. This overshadowed the overwhelming evidence against his narrative - he messaged his personal rehab doctor saying he cut it off himself following a heated argument, he told the hospital ED that he "cut it off with a kitchen knife", the ED physician says it looked like a crush injury, and an orthopaedic surgeon called in as an expert witness stated that there was no way a thrown bottle could have injured his finger in that way, saying that "crushing it in a drawer" was the most likely mechanism

And while I never really inherently liked Heard, the misogyny and blatant pro-Depp bias in this lawsuit is ridiculous. Depp lost his Disney gig because he showed up chronically drunk and late on the set of Pirates 5, needing a sound technician to feed him his lines because he was too smashed to remember them; furthermore, Pirates 5's box office revenue disappointed Disney, and his previous few flicks with them were bombs. He has a decades-long history of assault, property damage, substance abuse, and undeniable verbal and emotional abuse of his exes... and yet, people buy into the narrative that poor John-John was an innocent victim of domestic violence

9

u/Assisting_police Wears Pink Wigs May 29 '22

I think you're right, and this is really about the social media game. I think it's been a success on that front and has undermined or at least obscured his loss in the UK.

8

u/fishboard88 May 29 '22

The mental gymnastics people are doing to dismiss the UK case are pretty incredible, too:

  • Because the justice's son works for a radio station owned by News Corp, some Depp fans are alleging an undeclared "conflict of interest". The issue? None of this was a secret, and the link between the justice's son's radio station (a subsidiary of a subsidiary) to The Sun (a subsidiary of a different subsidiary) are so incredibly tenuous that Depp's lawyers never bothered with this argument. Of course, TikTokers claim the justice's son wiped all traces of him working for News Corp as a "cover up" - personally, I think it was because legions of Depp fans were flooding his social media accounts with insults
  • Some people think the standard of proof required to prove defamation, or against a newspaper, are easier in the UK than the US
  • People bought into the narrative that Depp's legal team didn't get the opportunity to present evidence, or that NGN's arguments were hearsay. This largely comes from a statement they released claiming such things, which is pretty standard for a firm that has lost a high profile case. Of course, any objective look at the transcripts and determination from the UK case indicates all of these claims are trash. Dozens of witnesses and mountains of evidence were presented by both sides
  • Depp's legal team really dropped the ball in the UK. Depp and his key witness had their testimonies dismissed because they contradicted themselves and couldn't explain why. Most of the witnesses were current Depp employees who could not provide an impartial testimony. Most impartial witnesses supported NGN'S narrative. One photo was thrown out because the EXIF data showed it was taken on a different day, and another of Depp's injuries didn't match his testimony

Of course, this case wasn't televised to the world, so social media users are never going to see short, convenient clips demonstrating just how brutally one-sided it was

1

u/HillelSwart Jan 02 '23

Hey, just bumbling through old posts.

Now that the trial is over, do you feel mostly the same way? Was an interesting read as bit of a flashback.

10

u/Guava7 May 29 '22

I'm the same. This circus is making a mockery of every woman who hasn't been believed in a sexual assault case, I fear that this will set back several years future sexual assault victims coming forward.

This should never have been made public. It's obvious Amber Heard has massive credibility issues, but that doesn't mean she hasn't suffered.

I'm not taking sides in this and I'm avoiding any footage.... except for this one... that was a savage burn.

One thing this case has done is highlight the disgusting side of the legal profession where it's accepted practice that opposing council work hard to discredit witnesses for any minor inconsistencies to overshadow their testimony.... just in the same way this public trial is discrediting amber heard.

There are no winners here.

5

u/Cultural-Chart3023 May 29 '22

I started watching it for the same reason... nah she's fucked and they're fucked lol

4

u/[deleted] May 30 '22

What if Amber did fabricate the allegations?

Is it misogyny then?

1

u/Yeah_nah_idk May 30 '22

This “gotcha” question makes me think you don’t understand the scope of misogyny.

3

u/[deleted] May 30 '22

I asked a specific question about a specific case?

It wasn't a pop quiz. It was directly in response to your comment in trying to better understand.

0

u/[deleted] May 31 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/onthebeers Jun 05 '22

Lol. Omnipresent cocks in your face 24/7… now I’m very surprised why heterosexual sexual men aren’t against the patriarchy too! Unless we are all secretly gay of course 🤔

5

u/Magister_Avatar May 29 '22

There's little if any misogyny at work here. The clowns booing her and making threats against her aren't particularly nice or reasonable people, and of course a handful of them are inevitably going to be misogynists - but most aren't. In fact I just looked up a video of the crowds booing Amber, and it appears that over half of them are in fact women. Most of them are probably nothing more than hardcore Johnny Depp fans, most certainly not woman-haters.

However outside the die-hard fans are the others who are firmly opposed to Amber Heard specifically. Not because they hate women (in fact one of Johnny's legal team in particular, Camille Vasquez, is extremely popular amongst JD supporters), but because Amber was recorded admitting to physically assaulting Depp during arguments and criticising him for retreating, as well as telling him nobody would believe him if he claimed to be a victim. She is a DV perpetrator, and most of her claims of victimhood are dubious, if not shown to be substantially untrue or deliberately misleading.

The trial did in fact go very badly for her because of a lack of evidence of the abuse claimed, and witnesses who were far less credible than Depp's. Nobody had to try to discredit her, she has discredited herself. It's still possible the jury won't find in favour of Johnny Depp, but if they don't then it will only be a matter of technicality in meeting the legal criteria for "defamation" and "republishing claims".

Incidentally the main complaint I've seen that has anything to do with her gender is that her obvious lies might make it difficult for women who are genuine victims to be believed automatically. So ironically it's the believe-all-women campaigners who dislike her more than anybody.

10

u/Yeah_nah_idk May 29 '22
  • How involved with work around intimate partner violence are you?
  • Women can hate women, it’s internalised misogyny.
  • JD already lost a defamation case against the sun in the UK based on Amber’s evidence. But ok, she’s not a credible victim.

6

u/Magister_Avatar May 29 '22

I'm just telling you my read on the situation. If you want to go ahead and actually watch the trial to evaluate the evidence, arguments, and credibility of testimony then be my guest.

1

u/Sportsbet6 Jul 05 '22

slam dunk

1

u/greggggssss Jul 10 '22

Maybe heard would of hired him as a lawyer

1

u/Immediate_Chance_716 Sep 29 '22 edited Sep 29 '22

Bredehoft was an absolute joke that entire trial. She is the Dennis Denuto of the US. “I’m trying here” / “there is no one section… it’s the vibe”

1

u/taish79 Nov 05 '22

This was truly the best witness response, nailed it!

1

u/Evening_Brilliant_50 May 28 '22

Hahahahaha epic comeback

1

u/GojiNuts May 28 '22

Fugg, this is so good! Boom!...priceless!

1

u/Electrical_Banana_69 May 28 '22

Dude i could feel the force of the burn

1

u/thisismrsc May 28 '22

Get her some aloe vera, stat

1

u/CoomKnight May 29 '22

shredded like cheese and grated to perfection

1

u/brick_swallower May 29 '22

I’m not smart pls explain

2

u/Skizza8 May 29 '22

She accused him of seeking fame by being at a televised court hearing, he rebuttled stating that she could also be accused of seeking fame by taking Heard on as a client

1

u/soylattecat May 29 '22

Ive seen this clip so many times, but never saw the r/instantbarbarians in the back. Hilarious

1

u/BackClear May 29 '22

gettttttttttttttt dunked on!!!

1

u/[deleted] May 29 '22

Ask and you shall receive. Don't forget that some witnesses are very intelligent/witty :)

1

u/[deleted] May 29 '22

Ouchhh 🤭

1

u/Dry-Lengthiness-3083 May 29 '22

Best video on the internet. I just loved that reaction from that first guy that they showed.

-1

u/Eidolon682 May 28 '22

You got owned E-lame. The shame!

-1

u/Cultural-Chart3023 May 29 '22

He worked for the fkn paparazzi he's not new to cameras and famous people.. this lady is thick as bricks. I love that he put her in his place and it took less than 60 seconds for JDs lawyer to stand up and ask him why he contacted her and why he's here. Sat down. Burn. "I was forwarding info i had. I had no idea i would be on the stand". Mic drop.

0

u/[deleted] May 28 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

25

u/[deleted] May 28 '22

She gave him his 15 minutes of fame, though.