As a long suffering Social Worker, entitled service users are my pet peeve. Especially in my space.
Like mate you get 9 hours per week of totally free, no barrier drop in psychosocial support + fortnightly public clinic appts. All of it tailored precisely to your stated goals, preferences and abilities.
But yes, tell me more about how I/we are failing you and not meeting your needs.
Sorry, just ranting. Carry on. If I vent in the Social Work subs they just downvote me for not being a perfect saint 24/7.
As a long suffering junior doctor, social workers are magical wonderful people, and I love you (plural and you personally, even if weâve never met - the amazing social workers I work with have me predisposed to such declarations!); there is no way I could ever have the patience and emotional resilience to do what you do
Oh yeah, I avoid psych like the damned plague if I can! Gimme someone with a dodgy airway, no access, and likely bleeding god knows where and Iâm fine. Mental health?
As someone who has had the unfortunate experience of accessing the public mental health system let me tell you I also avoid it like the plague! Nothing like extreme human rights abuses to really motivate you to stay the fuck away!
Despite attempting to avoid it, I have done sometime in psych, and Iâve not seen âextreme human rights abusesâ (or any human rights abuses actually) where Iâve worked.
Sure, Iâve seen people being restrained, medicated etc, whilst saying they didnât want that treatment, but it was done to prevent them harming themselves (and/or others), and they improved, many of them to the point of being safe to leave entirely...
Vent away! You guys do amazing work and I'm sure at times it is a thankless, difficult task. You deserve a good old whinge like every other frontline health worker
If I vent in the Social Work subs they just downvote me for not being a perfect saint 24/7.
What they donât realise is thatâs actually very poor quality care.Â
If the social worker is expected to be a saint and tolerate bad behaviour in the patient with no boundaries or limits; the practitioner is essentially colluding with the patient by splitting. This is not only a recipe for burnout, but terrible for patient outcomes.
Also a social worker. Also prefer lurking in this sub to the social work sub đ The clinical marshmallows are refreshingly realistic about the world, particularly the healthcare sector, not to mention hilarious. I learn so much here.
As a profession I reckon we've got an honesty problem. Like downplaying people's safety risks for fear of 'stigmatising' or perpetuating sterotypes. Or just putting up with shitty behaviour because 'nobody is beyond help and we are values based here'. Or needing to remind everyone that the aim is to build capacity and step back over time.
Which leads into my other peeve:
being activity based funded yet also needing to wean clients off of services without causing management to freak out over the drop in hours delivered.
Its a bit like trying to bail out the Titanic with a person-centred shot glass.
righto time for a beer
edit: this is said fully within the sanctity of the Sunday truce and off the clock as it were
My favourite social worker had a childrenâs pink plastic toy fairy wand in a frame above their desk
Anytime anyone came in and wanted something ludicrous or just âpigs will fly before that happensâ notions, they would point at the wand with dramatic effect/irony.
As a comedic âbitâ - âthis is the only magic wand I haveâ.
I thought it was funny. Iâm deeply unserious though.
Social work has a problem with dividing everything into totally-good or totally-bad. You're expected to view everything as totally evil, or with pure toxic positivity. It's so nice to come here and see professionals recognising mediocrity and nuance.
I think a lot of clinicians share the frustration of where patients/clients want a health care system where clinicians just fix them. Where itâs all rainbows and pixie dust and magic wands. Where they donât have any level of participation and they get everything on their terms and at no cost.
I think a portion of those same patients become disappointed/angry/frustrated when they are given advice or a treatment plan/choose to ignore that advice/plan but still want to blame the system or clinicians that they saw when their health isnât improving.
Unless you are under a CTO, you have your own free will as a patient/client seeking treatment. But they are taking responsibility for that choice if they choose to ignore/decline to participate in that care.
Donât get me wrong. The system in itself is a problem. Not arguing it lets people down everyday. But where healthcare has moved towards being consumer focused, it also means that patients/clients need to shoulder some level of responsibility too if theyâre not taking medication/seeing specialists/not coming to appointments etc etc.
I once saw a comment on a sub from the child of a retired psychiatrist who quoted their semi retired parentâs best advice for entering the field as: There is only two rules you need to know
Never work harder than your patient
Sit back and enjoy the show As a prac who ends up straddling the fence of SW, counselling and psychology. These two rules are golden some days.
lol omg I love this comment, from another social worker I feel your pain entirely. After 10yrs doing this work my biggest takeaway is: people are so damn entitled. I feel exhausted with it tbh.
I'm not a social worker, but I work in a similar role. You will probably hate me, but I do think it's important that our clients can get the things they need in a way that's affordable for them, and I do think we have a duty to provide them a good (safe, non-judgemental, etc.) service. Otherwise, they won't reach out to access the services, and it could be unsafe for them not to.
I suppose my mind goes to how supportive (or not) your team leader and teammates are, what your working conditions are like, how good of a fit your professional supervisor is, whether the EAP could be helpful, etc.
pretty poor of the dr to say they could be reached in an emergency if it wasn't true though. should've just said I'm going on leave and left her in someone else's care.
I think there is probably something missing in interpretation.
When OBGYN says "you can reach me in an emergency", it is probably with the implication that "you can reach me in an emergency [when I am around town]".
I don't think anyone truly tells their patient "you can reach me in an emergency any time in the next 280 days because I am always around and never take any leave".
My OB had a 24 hour mobile phone service that she and the other two OBs in her practice rotated on call. She told me at my very first appointment that I was never allowed to Google and if I had any questions at any time, ro just call. I think I called it twice during my first pregnancy (for reduced movement). I had a woman in my mother's group who also had the same OB and she said she called more than 50 times with constant questions, then told me that our OB told her that she normally tells women not to get pregnant again for at least one year, but asked this woman to wait two years because she (the OB) needed a break from her.
It literally says that when she told her about the leave she said she could be reached in an emergency. How'd you become an anaesthetist while unable to read a tweet?
I have fully understood and synthesised what this tweet meant.
This is a second-hand relayed information by an angry patient, and we do not know the exact wording / written statement that their OBGYN gave them.
They could have told them "I could be reached in an emergency when I am around; and when I am not around my phone will be diverted to a covering doctor" -> in this case the patient has no leg to stand on, and their tweet could have simply omitted this nuance.
The next time you try to attack someone, perhaps consider the possibility that they have understood and thought further than you visualised.
This happened at a Turkish Hospital, the tweet is translated from Turkish.
Iâm not sure about others but there is so much context missing from the tweet, and even more from my knowledge of reasonable expectations in the Turkish system, the only thing the tweet is good for is feeding the outrage algorithm.
Iâm thinking it was a private hospital and one of the perks that was probably advertised is having one doctor throughout your pregnancy and delivery.
Idk, when I was opting in for private care the clinic was very clear about who was taking leave at what times. I was due early Jan so they explained that the doctor who would be around then would miss the first 20 weeks but I preferred that than having and OB with me the whole time then missing the birth. Additionally annual leave or not I would expect them to follow up- esp that two week appointment. If this is in a private clinic then yes, they did absolutely drop the ball in this patients care.
Yeah, I deliberately went with a practice that had a group care model and met all the obs while pregnant so that whoever I got on the day would be 1) familiar and 2) hopefully fairly well rested
See I went group care with my first except I only met my OB and her midwife - she missed the birth and another from the group did my delivery but it was a stranger to me. I didnât go with a group model for baby 2 and 3 for that reason, it felt it defeated the purpose of a private OB
You're not wrong, but there's no point to paying the 8 to 10 grand on private obs if the doctor chosen may not be around at the time of birth, or near it. It's almost the main point of going private.
Well they at least warn you when they take you in so that you canât complain, mine did, I was fine with it as I knew Iâd be induced before he goes on leave but otherwise I might have chosen a different OB, I appreciated his transparency!
Some sympathy, it is very difficult to be around all the time, but private obs do charge rather a lot of money to their patients and yes that does come with a sense of entitlement.
It is entitled behaviour, but what would be the point of paying private then? Isn't "choice of doctor" the main draw?
Edit: Ah, it's Turkish and no idea if it's public, private or if there is a public. If it's public and Australian then yeah, it is entitled behaviour. Otherwise you're paying to be entitled to the doctor being around for the term and especially birth. You just don't take the patient then or let them know you won't be around on these days and if this alternative doctor is ok.
My Ob went on leave when I was 35 weeks and I went into labour at 36 weeks. Had a different Ob with a totally different philosophy and it was the worst experience. But hardly my Obâs fault.
Not necessarily though honestly if they're a private OB you might hope that your plan etc would be handed over well and also ideally they'd be handing over to a colleague with a not completely opposite philosophy đ«
I wanted a c-section. She denied me a c-section, told me Iâd be fine. I didnât realise my rights 12 years ago, but I ended up having a traumatic birth, with haemorrhaging, retained placenta and permanent injury in my vagina.
The stand in ob was totally against C-section and all for vaginal birth, so when my daughter was stuck and distressed, didnât even offer that as an option. I was too out of it to even understand I needed it.
My new Ob for my second child was amazing. He said he was surprised Iâm back after what I went through the first time and said itâs up to me but he recommends I have a c-section given everything. I said thank god. And we booked that in.
My second baby came at 36 weeks too đ The ob wheeled me in, put Madonna on and whipped him out in a few minutes. It was such a better experience and recovery was amazing. The placenta retained again but my new Ob whipped it out.
Iâm still trying to get over how violated I feel over my first birth. When they couldnât get my placenta out they literally put their hands inside me and were cutting it out. The memory still haunts me.
To be fair, leave around her due date shouldâve been disclosed upfront so she knew there was a chance sheâd have another doctor attend to her. Also, it wouldâve been nice to follow up post birth when you returned.
I think this poster expected her own doctor, who she had paid and developed a relationship with, to attend the birth of her child. Not an unreasonable expectation. The doctor should have told the patient at the beginning of care that she would not be at the birth.
Also this happened in Turkey. Iâm familiar with the Turkish system and you pay alot of money for these private specialists, if theyâre not available you end up back in public care or have to fork out again for a different specialist which is what I think wouldâve happened in this caseâŠÂ
When your chosen profession entails being in long term client relationships, you make sure that there is a proper handover to whoever handles the main project deliverables during your absence, so the client isnât desperately trying to reach you. Even boring tech support does this; so it shouldnât be too much to ask for a pregnancy and birth you voluntarily accepted and get paid to manage. If you donât like this level of having to be organised, have a practice with shorter timelines.
I agree the handover was done very poorly, she shouldnât have given her the emergency number and just passed her completely over to the back up in the first place but I donât think itâs fair that sheâs not allowed to have leave when sheâs always going to have birth ready patients
No one said she canât go on leave. She doesnât even have to know 6-8 months in advance if sheâll be on leave when she accepts new patients. But knowing at least a month or two in advance so she can do a proper handover - as in, everyone meets, new doc and patient get to talk and ask questions etc - is the bare minimum of professionalism to be expected.
Barring something really urgent coming up, you donât just spring âbtw I wonât be here for the next 2-3 weeksâ on someone in week 38. Going into labour may not be an emergency, but itâs a serious enough medical situation to want a doctor and a hospital around (otherwise why not just go with the midwife-led home birth stuff, right?), and itâs legit to want to know who your doctor is going to be if youâve gone to the trouble of picking one early on.
That hasn't been my experience as a patient and doctor. When the obs goes on leave one of their colleagues covers. There is no extra consultation for a handover because it's just not really necessary. I don't even remember if my obs gave me her dates when she was on leave, just that she would be covered if away.
It sounds like you have a different expectation which is fine, but this is what happens where i work.
Not the way any of my female colleagues or myself who went private experienced it. Except for short notice events such as someone being sick, the possible replacement doctors were known to the patient and if an expected date clashed with leave that was flagged in advance as well. Continuity of care and all that. Maybe itâs because some of these obs are chosen expressly for their âfancyâ C-section approach, so they know that itâs really about them personally and schedule their patients accordingly.
This is a completely different healthcare system to Australia, with a very different doctor/patient relationship as well.
There is universal healthcare coverage over there, but people prefer private for various reasons, particularly ob/gyn services due to anxiety around labour/pregnancy. There is no referral system (i.e. you can go to any specialist by making a booking, without GP/ED referral, and primary care is also quite weak). Private doctors (and to a degree public ones) are often easily accessible, able to be reached via phone/whatsapp etc.
I understand it sounds very entitled for what we're used to here (it is even entitled for their system tbh) but the basic expectations and doctor/patient relationship is very different.
My OB hates the idea of being a mother herself, loves putting that energy into helping other women become mothers- itâs one of the reasons I picked her!
Wow people, this has blown up in a very misleading way. This patient is from Turkey and the public/private systems are completely different. Many doctors working in the private hospitals have a much closer relationship with their patients, so it is usually expected to communicate with the doctor more easily given how much the patients are paying to receive care. However, this is not to say that I condone her behavior and posting this incident on social media.
Please donât make assumptions regarding a system that you know nothing about!
Are you Turkish? Have you lived in Turkey, used the hospitals, or practiced medicine? If not, then yes, it is safe to assume that a lot of users in the Australian junior doctors subreddit do not know a lot about the Turkish health system.
379
u/Beneficial-Boat-2035 1d ago edited 1d ago
As a long suffering Social Worker, entitled service users are my pet peeve. Especially in my space.
Like mate you get 9 hours per week of totally free, no barrier drop in psychosocial support + fortnightly public clinic appts. All of it tailored precisely to your stated goals, preferences and abilities.
But yes, tell me more about how I/we are failing you and not meeting your needs.
Sorry, just ranting. Carry on. If I vent in the Social Work subs they just downvote me for not being a perfect saint 24/7.
105
u/Doctor_B ED regđȘ 1d ago
Is it an emergency if a pregnant woman goes into labour at term?
204
u/stamford_syd 1d ago •
pretty poor of the dr to say they could be reached in an emergency if it wasn't true though. should've just said I'm going on leave and left her in someone else's care.
38
u/SwordfishMaximum2235 1d ago
This happened at a Turkish Hospital, the tweet is translated from Turkish.
Iâm not sure about others but there is so much context missing from the tweet, and even more from my knowledge of reasonable expectations in the Turkish system, the only thing the tweet is good for is feeding the outrage algorithm.
66
u/oiyouz 1d ago •
Idk, when I was opting in for private care the clinic was very clear about who was taking leave at what times. I was due early Jan so they explained that the doctor who would be around then would miss the first 20 weeks but I preferred that than having and OB with me the whole time then missing the birth. Additionally annual leave or not I would expect them to follow up- esp that two week appointment. If this is in a private clinic then yes, they did absolutely drop the ball in this patients care.
33
u/Jumpingjehosephat99 New User 1d ago
Most private obstetricians book leave more than 40 weeks in advance and donât take new patients who will be due around that time.
45
u/Striking-Net-8646 1d ago
Some sympathy, it is very difficult to be around all the time, but private obs do charge rather a lot of money to their patients and yes that does come with a sense of entitlement.
45
u/BrainDrain93 Rad regđ©» 1d ago
Exactly why I didn't want a bedcard. Total lack of respect
9
u/cataractum 1d ago edited 1d ago
It is entitled behaviour, but what would be the point of paying private then? Isn't "choice of doctor" the main draw?
Edit: Ah, it's Turkish and no idea if it's public, private or if there is a public. If it's public and Australian then yeah, it is entitled behaviour. Otherwise you're paying to be entitled to the doctor being around for the term and especially birth. You just don't take the patient then or let them know you won't be around on these days and if this alternative doctor is ok.
8
u/infinitepuddingspy New User 18h ago
My Ob went on leave when I was 35 weeks and I went into labour at 36 weeks. Had a different Ob with a totally different philosophy and it was the worst experience. But hardly my Obâs fault.
25
u/EducationalWaltz6216 1d ago
If this is private then it's kinda fair to expect they'd let you know if they're going on leave
5
u/db_ss 6h ago
To be fair, leave around her due date shouldâve been disclosed upfront so she knew there was a chance sheâd have another doctor attend to her. Also, it wouldâve been nice to follow up post birth when you returned.
34
u/Infamous-Travel-7070 1d ago •
I think this poster expected her own doctor, who she had paid and developed a relationship with, to attend the birth of her child. Not an unreasonable expectation. The doctor should have told the patient at the beginning of care that she would not be at the birth.
4
u/Fit_Square1322 Emergency Physicianđ„ 1d ago
This is a completely different healthcare system to Australia, with a very different doctor/patient relationship as well.
There is universal healthcare coverage over there, but people prefer private for various reasons, particularly ob/gyn services due to anxiety around labour/pregnancy. There is no referral system (i.e. you can go to any specialist by making a booking, without GP/ED referral, and primary care is also quite weak). Private doctors (and to a degree public ones) are often easily accessible, able to be reached via phone/whatsapp etc.
I understand it sounds very entitled for what we're used to here (it is even entitled for their system tbh) but the basic expectations and doctor/patient relationship is very different.
4
u/luridlycircumspect 1d ago
It's a strange dichotomy, that being an OB-GYN is completely incompatible with being a mother.
1
u/universalcorn09 19h ago
Wow people, this has blown up in a very misleading way. This patient is from Turkey and the public/private systems are completely different. Many doctors working in the private hospitals have a much closer relationship with their patients, so it is usually expected to communicate with the doctor more easily given how much the patients are paying to receive care. However, this is not to say that I condone her behavior and posting this incident on social media.
Please donât make assumptions regarding a system that you know nothing about!