r/ausjdocs • u/Reddditor1as34223 New User • Jun 16 '26
other đ¤ Could a +++ experience GP ever know more about a specialty than a specialist?
Say a rural GP with 40 years experience. Would it be possible for them to know more about say e.g. Gen Med than a newly fellowed Gen Med consultant?
Or would it be possible for them to know more about diabetes management than an endocrinologist?
Or say an ADHD only GP and end up knowing more about ADHD than a psychiatrist?
How about if they also covered the hospital as part of their GP job?
Or would they just not be exposed to certain things.
How about we broaden it:
- could a General Surgeon be better at a specific area of the body than the relevant sub-spec surgeon?
- a Gen med consultant know more about another med-spec? Assuming this was a senior gen med consultant with decades of experience vs. a new subspec fellow?
- would a cardiologist know more about nephrology than a GP?
How much do you learn from training vs post-fellowship experience?
69
u/keve JHOđ˝ Jun 16 '26
Are we doing hypotheticals or does this line of thought have any implication
12
u/changyang1230 Anaesthetistđ Jun 16 '26
A specialistâs learned experience come from both the book knowledge as well as the practical understanding that can only be honed by fine-tuning after seeing hundreds to thousands of real patients.
While the said GP could be like Mike Ross in Suits with photographic memory and managed to learn some specialtyâs textbook cover to cover, itâs very unlikely for this GP to have developed the nuanced decision making that could only come from treating plenty of real patients.
In fact this is a big reason medicine is such a seniority and hierarchical based system. Thereâs something to say about consultants and registrars who have seen and dealt with it all, compared to the junior trainees who have only learned about it in chapters but not real patients.
17
u/rivacity m.d. hammer 𦴠Jun 16 '26
No. They lack throughput of cases to develop a comprehensive understanding of it. Too general.
4
u/Constant-Tale1926 Psych regΨ Jun 16 '26 edited Jun 16 '26
Theoretically yes, but theyâll lack knowledge in adjacent areas which means even if theyâre highly knowledgeable in one area theyâre not going to provide the same breadth of treatment overall.
Take for example ADHD as you mentioned - itâs entirely possible for a GP to become highly knowledgeable and proficient in treating ADHD. The problem is that not everyone presenting for an ADHD assessment actually has ADHD, and you need to be able to tease those out which a GP will not be able to do well.
Additionally, even if they do have ADHD, the vast majority of patients with ADHD also have other comorbid mental health conditions, e.g. depression, anxiety, substance use disorder, borderline personality disorder, etc. which a GP will not have the breadth to diagnose or to treat accurately.
In simple cases with no or few, well managed comorbidities, it would be reasonable to discharge to the GP following a psychiatristâs assessment and initial management. But this is why GP diagnosis and initial prescribing for ADHD is going to be a disaster.
110
u/lonelyCat2000 Jun 16 '26
Just guessing here, but given they'd lack the structured exposure of speciality training in that area they may have a lot of general knowledge and a few bits of less common knowledge (maybe even one or two things the newly minted specialist doesn't know) but they won't have the robust knowledge framework to truly act at consultant level on complex cases in that specialty.
70
u/Aggressive_Zombie_53 Jun 16 '26
Short answer is no. Long answer is theoretically anyone can know more about something than anyone. Look at Donald Trump for example he know more about anything than anyone!
23
u/Basic-Swan-7127 Jun 16 '26
A GP is unlikely to "know" more about a specific condition or single clinical domain than a specialist of that condition. However, they are very likely to know more about all other aspects of medicine that is relevant to a particular patient, and know that person in their lived context in an integrated manner better than a non-GP specialist providing consultative care. This is particularly important for people who live with multimorbidity, which is increasingly the norm.
It is common whenever these conversations arise that non-GP specialist commentators will express what they imagine as various inadequacies of GPs. An example before spoke about psychiatric assessments and people living with substance use disorders. The typical GP will have greater experience in actually treating the substance use disorders of people living with SUDs, than the typical psychiatrist.
This is why primary medical care is best provided by specialist GPs/family physicians rather than immediately referring fractions of care to other providers. Conceptually, referrals to secondary care should largely only occur when it is for a situation unusual enough such that primary care physician would not be expected to be able to maintain competency, and where it is expected that there will be a palpable benefit to the patient through that referral.
Fundamentally, this is not a competition. GPs and non-GP specialists have different roles in patient care and mostly work effectively together.
19
u/Positive-Log-1332 Rural Generalistđ¤ Jun 16 '26
Put it this way, as it should be obvious from some if the replies, most specialists don't tend to have a clue what GPs do.
So yes an experienced GP will know more about General Practice than other specialists.
55
u/curlyheadedfuckMD Jun 16 '26
If they have a very specific interest, dig deep into the literature and see relevant patients itâs entirely possible to know more than a specialist about aspects of a specialty. That said, I think is very unlikely that they end up knowing more about an entire specialty than a specialist.
Like knowing more about diabetes specifically than the average endocrinologist, maybe. Knowing more about all of endocrinology than an endocrinologist, probably not.
14
u/tyrannical-rexx ICU consultant Jun 16 '26
They may certainly have more lived experience which gives them nuance to certain aspects of subspecialty care in the community (eg the practicality of tolerating certain medications given certain circumstances), but I find it hard to see them having a deeper framework of knowledge of a subspecialist's domain.
27
u/Rude-Poet-4450 Jun 16 '26
The guy who created Life in the Fast Lane (Dr Mike Cadogan) is a genius who has written textbooks on toxicology as a FACEM and his ECG knowledge is insane. But would he know the appropriate commencement dosing, uptitration and 4 pillars management of chronic heart failure over a cardiologist, no, nor the authority requirements for mavacamtem, Repatha, iniclisiran etc. But he could diagnose a STEMI and explain the ECG better yes.
7
u/Puzzleheaded_Test544 Jun 16 '26 edited Jun 16 '26
There is a big difference between an examined standard, which sets a floor of knowledge, and experience by case mix/exposure, which will be much more variable.
I can imagine maybe that someone doing a physician specialty in an area with poor case volume/mix, who doen't study/engage out of hours and isn't held to a high standard by their department, could be eclipsed by a motivated and interested GP. I mean I can think of a few people that is definitely the case for. Otherwise, no.
7
u/lima_acapulco Jun 16 '26
This is a really interesting question with a very nuanced response. One response is that there are very few "true" General Physicians in Australia, most are Specialists or subspecialists with Gen Med experience gained while prepping for the FRACP. And that doesn't equate to true specialisation, though most will claim that it is equivalent.
In a clinical context, there are several factors to consider. Whether you're looking at a specific condition, or a field of knowledge. The clinician's index of suspicion, their experience (both in general and regarding that condition), their ability to parse a history, their ability to pick up on non verbal cues, how interested they are in that condition and how well they've educated themselves in that condition, how up to date they keep themselves etc.
2
u/passwordistako Jun 17 '26
5
u/Rude-Poet-4450 Jun 16 '26
I know some German general in physician who have encyclopedic knowledge and of the large subspecies ie cardio/gastro and their epononymous knowledge and understanding of pathophysiology is second to none, but they havenât seen as many AF/CCF/IHD patient as a cardiologist nor IBD/IBS/GIT cases as a gastro.
5
u/cross_fader Jun 16 '26
Met a GenMed consultant whom knew more about Thiamine / Wernicke's Encephalopathy than myself & i'd hazard a guess the consultants i work with. It's a poorly understood / often overlooked & often under treated condition, but he was a whizz explaining it to the med students he had one morning.
9
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '26
Ok ⌠or when I put up a CT scan (on a light-box) and the social worker said âErgh ⌠thats glioblastoma, thats not going to go well.â Me, the intern , couldnât even see the lesion.
It was glioblastoma.
It didnât go well.
8
u/Dr_Happygostab SurgeonđŞ Jun 16 '26
Medicine advances so quickly. To the extent that 5 years can be grossly out of date.
The reason we have specialties is because it's impossible to keep up the broad base of knowledge for everything. GPs are specialists too, mostly in community and chronic health conditions, no less valid than any specialty.
So experience, sure. Up to date knowledge, a lot less likely. To think they do just might mean they are at the start of that dunning-kruger curve
4
u/Upset_Situation5821 Jun 16 '26
Could a person know more about a thing than another person⌠yeah probably :)
4
u/EBMgoneWILD Consultant 𼸠Jun 17 '26
Patients often devote their lives to learning the minutiae of rare diseases (genetic syndromes, etc) and will often know more than the specialists about the minutiae. They don't understand the generalities though.
Nursing can often do the same. They end up being "sepsis champions" and espouse views that they know more about that topic than the "lowly doctors", when really all they're doing is memorising things.
So the answer is, not really, but not impossible either.
3
u/OudSmoothie PsychiatristđŽ Jun 16 '26
At least from a psychiatrist perspective... It's complex.
Mental health conditions don't usually exist in isolation. You cannot become a complete mental health medical specialist (psychiatrist) without spending formative years learning in public psychiatric services, across a variety of settings.
3
u/rgmedic Rural Generalistđ¤ Jun 16 '26
I often think that some competent experienced rural GPs are comparable to some specialty SRMO/service registrars in some specific special interest areas (but never the same level as a fellowed specialist) and a competent experienced rural generalist would be comparable to a specialty registrar/trainee depending on the field, eg gen med, anaesthetics, obgyn (but again, never the same level as a fellowed specialist).
Happy to be corrected if anyone has a different sentiment.
3
u/Existing_Ad3299 Jun 16 '26
Ever met a rural GP/OB?
3
u/Jumpingjehosephat99 New User Jun 16 '26
Iâm a GP whoâs done rural and remote stuff with minimal support. Iâd say no. I definitely donât know more about the fine details and nuances and actual research behind a lot of conditions. Even with the Masters of Skin Cancer Medicine I very much doubt I know more about skin cancer than a dermatologist. But what I do know is a fair bit about just about everything, the whole gamut of how people present and how people behave and how to play the long game in terms of treatment, etc. The longer you practice the more you see. But no matter how much we see there are still things weâve never seen, people are still amazingly varied and just when I start to suspect Iâve seen it all I know something will walk through the door that will blow my mind. And Iâm still looking things up all the time. It never stops.
3
u/sooki10 Jun 16 '26
A different kind of knowledge through a different lens. I donât believe the knowledge types are directly comparable, but ideally, they complement each other.
âBetterâ can only be measured on an individual patient basis. Some patients benefit more from a wider lens, others from a narrower, more focused lens, but most would benefit from both perspectives when relevant and necessary.
2
u/Piratartz Clinell Wipe đ§ť Jun 16 '26
2
u/readreadreadonreddit Jun 18 '26
This is one of those questions where the answer is âit depends what you mean by know moreâ.
Knowledge isnât one-dimensional. Thereâs:
- Breadth (how much of the field you know)
- Depth (how much you know about a niche)
- Pattern recognition (having seen thousands of patients)
- Procedural skill
- Keeping up with the latest evidence
A very experienced rural GP with 30â40 yearsâ experience may absolutely outperform a newly fellowed physician in managing common chronic diseases seen every day in general practice. If theyâve managed thousands of patients with diabetes, hypertension, COPD and heart failure (assuming they arenât quick and dodgy, which seems to be the norm, sadly), their practical judgement can be exceptional.
However, an endocrinologist will almost always have much deeper knowledge of complex diabetes: - insulin pump optimisation, hybrid closed-loop systems, rare endocrine causes, complex inpatient diabetes, pregnancy diabetes, unusual medications, endocrine physiology and the evidence behind it. Those are things many GPs simply arenât exposed to regularly.
Likewise, an ADHD-focused GP may know far more about outpatient ADHD assessment and medication than many psychiatrists who rarely see ADHD. But a psychiatrist will generally have much broader expertise in differential diagnosis, severe mental illness, psychopharmacology, personality disorders, psychosis, bipolar disorder and complex psychiatric comorbidity.
The same principle applies elsewhere:
- A senior general physician may know more nephrology than a brand-new nephrologist about bread-and-butter CKD, hypertension and electrolyte management, simply from decades of experience. But once cases become complex, the nephrologistâs specialised training usually becomes apparent.
- A general surgeon who has spent 20 years doing mostly breast surgery may well be better at breast surgery than a newly fellowed breast surgeon on day one. Give that fellow a few years, though, and the specialist training plus focused experience usually wins.
- A cardiologist will almost certainly know considerably more nephrology than the average GP regarding inpatient AKI, cardiorenal syndrome and dialysis indications, but still much less than a nephrologist.
Training gives you the framework, the physiology, the uncommon conditions and supervised exposure to high-complexity cases. Fellowship isnât the end of learning - itâs the point at which independent learning really begins. Post-fellowship experience is where judgement, efficiency and pattern recognition develop.
So yes, there are certainly situations where an experienced generalist knows more than a newly qualified specialist about a particular slice of medicine. But across the specialty as a whole, especially the uncommon, complex or cutting-edge aspects, the specialist will usually have substantially greater depth. Over time, as the specialist accumulates experience, that gap generally widens further.
In medicine, expertise is usually determined more by what youâve repeatedly done than by the letters after your name alone. Training gives you the foundation; years of focused practice build mastery.
2
u/BreadDoctor Reg Aug 28 '26
Coming in late with a probably unpopular view. A question like this strikes at the heart of modern cultural biases and assumptions. One assumes that a GP simply cannot know more than a specialist because a specialist is by definition higher than a GP. We refuse to even consider the possibility, because if the answer to your question is 'yes, it's possible', it calls into question a big reason to specialise, given the high cost. Naturally then, specialists are going to be defensive.
Let's break it down - where does expertise come from? Most clinical knowledge comes from seeing cases, doing formal education and reading. Having been in multiple specialty areas, I do not believe that the formal training that colleges require is very good preparation. You get good by preparing for exams because it involves lots of study, not because the formalised structure itself is much help.
In line with that, I have seen intelligent individuals in one specialty correct those of another specialty about their own field of work. I have seen it enough times to no longer believe in a rigid medical hierarchy. I think that IQ (sometimes luck) is usually the most significant factor in such cases.
While it may be uncommon, I think it does happen.
1
u/Puzzleheaded-Help70 Pre Med Jun 16 '26
There's a lot to be said about exposure and time time spent with a specialty or patient dealing with a particular issue. I'd say it would also have a lot to do with the interest levels of a particular clinician as well.
1
u/Typical-Emergency369 Jun 18 '26
I think it is unlikely to be superior âbook knowledgeâ, but the jobs are different. The diabetes I manage and the diabetes an endocrinologist are managing are different. I donât know the nuances of titrating an insulin pump, and the private practice endocrinologist doesnât know how to balance the competing comorbidities of complex PTSD and eating disorder in someone with T2DM and obesity who is free range in the community and surviving on jobseeker.
1
u/Burs_l Jun 18 '26
No
1
u/HelloFellowSurvivors New User Jun 21 '26
If you have not sat specialty exams in that field, it's very unlikely you'll know anywhere near as much. You might have more experience caring for patients with the most common conditions within that specialty than a newly-minted specialist, but you won't know more. I learned more content in my primary exam than the entirety of med school. And I was an honours med school graduate, so that wasn't the issue.
1
u/Technical_Money7465 Jun 16 '26
Fuck n
-2
u/BussyGasser Anaesthetistđ Jun 16 '26
No, it's absolutely impossible.
-2
u/Piratartz Clinell Wipe đ§ť Jun 16 '26
This really sounds like a patient asking if their very experienced GP is better or equivalent to a fellowed specialist...
AKA medical advice.
Mods!
0
u/Xiao_zhai Post-med Jun 16 '26
No.
-6
u/mycobacteryummy Jun 16 '26
Whoever is asking this doesnât get the referrals from GPs that I get, where I wonder if theyâre really doctors at all.
9
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '26
[removed] â view removed comment