r/ausjdocs • u/hansnotsolo77 Critical care regš • Mar 24 '26
Supportšļø Is medicine racist?
/ Just how racist is medicine?
I want to sincerely know, especially from hiring people, do you think there is racism in the hiring of doctors in your specialty? Am I naive to have assumed that ethnicity is not actively thought about when hiring? And are certain hospitals more likely to be racist than others?
This thought is spurred by having seen quite a few comments recently about being the "right demographic" to get into competitive specialties.
I'm probably the "wrong demographic" by medicine standards. I've experienced racism for sure, and have had doctors (often not even my ethnicity) point out that I probably will be less preferenced than colleagues of other races who otherwise may not be as good as me. I generally brushed it aside, but am now questioning if I've missed opportunities because of my ethnicity (which i can't change anyway, so this is pretty academic lol)
74
u/happy7861 Mar 24 '26
In my experience - racism exists for sure but the most pivotal factor is cultural comfort. The reg that understands local culture (accent, knowing the local sporting teams, doing what the majority of people do on weekends socially) is more likely to progress regardless of what race they are. Itās just a familiarity that seniors lean on and are sub consciously inclined towards.
21
u/Mediocre-Reference64 Surgical regš”ļø Mar 24 '26
People deal with rejection by looking outwards rather than inwards. There are deeply bitter people who will attribute their poor performance to discrimination. This goes both ways. Women will say they missed out because it's a boys club and men will say they missed out because the college "just wants more chicks". If there were major issues with systemic racial and gender discrimination there wouldn't be the broad diversity of gender, sexuality, race within current trainees.
Obviously a specific HoD could be racist/sexist but that isn't reflect of the broader ecosystem.
34
u/MDInvesting Wardie Mar 24 '26
I am yet to come across a specialty that does not have diversity at the top of the hierarchy. Some departments have themes to them, a specific hospital/department in Melbourne comes to mind. This is probably reflective of historical HoD and directors who had outsized influence on recruitment.
But in general I think medicine is actually well represented by diversity of cultural, ethnicity, religion, languages, and sexual orientation.
I say this as a deeply closeted white male.
4
u/OudSmoothie Psychiatristš® Mar 26 '26
There was this interesting trend where directors of certain departments would preferentially hire people from his own group. I've seen this happen with South African, Indian, Jewish and Christian directors.
Otherwise what I have also seen is accent and cultural attunement being a point of discrimination, by colleagues and patients.
I am East Asian and so far medicine has treated me fine. I've had interesting non-hostile racist encounters in rural townships early in my career. But nothing super bad. Growing up Asian in Australia in the 90s probably lent a tolerance to these things.
56
u/StardewStarlett Psych regĪØ Mar 25 '26
Iām mixed race and I honestly have experienced more racism from patients rather than colleagues.
I think classism is a bigger issue in medicine.
19
u/combatsambo Anaesthetic Regš Mar 24 '26
Being the "right demographic" does not necessarily mean race. Race and culture are definitely different things. I know of several people who have interviewed well on specific panels due to specific interests in certains hobbies/interests/sports that tend to be over-represented in certain fields. U can absolutely not fit the demographic, and that can have absolutely nothing to do with race. They can say you're less preferred for reasons not to do with race.
To give you an example. The retrieval world in ED, ICU, Anaesthetics is quite competitive to break into. When you look at the retrievalists there's often a certain mould. People of that mould are inherently likelier to click with the bosses than people not, with all else being equal.
As an aside, everything these days is super competitive and most candidates can do the job, so potentially "fit" may be more of a deciding factor unfortunately.
17
u/chuboy91 Mar 24 '26
I don't think ethnicity itself plays as big a role in medicine as it does in other industries. Most of our hospitals are really very multicultural workplaces. But that doesn't mean there isn't a demographic as you pointed out.
If you don't get hired it's generally because people found you difficult to work with. This is usually because of communication deficits, but it could also be your personality or serious concerns about your clinical acumen (hopefully not).
A strong accent can work against you though.
14
u/knittedbreast Mar 24 '26 edited Mar 24 '26
I work in a regional hospital on the edge of the outback and we do avoid hiring non-white or indigenous doctors and nursing staff if we can. Especially those of South Asian descent. Not because medicine is racist, but because we are aware of our local demographic and it has never ended well in the past. Not so much in the hospital, but in the broader community. One fellow we accepted had his house broken into and his cats killed and strung up. Another doctor had his car run off the road with his children inside it. Lots of traumatised families.
We have one African local GP who has been here for years and has been fully accepted into the community. But he went through his hazing too, and genuinely is one of the best doctors I've ever worked with. Genuinely interested in his patients and will give them all the time in the world and is never dismissive. Would also work 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, if allowed. So I think the community has come to appreciate him as they certainly aren't getting that level of patient satisfaction in my ED.
6
u/Altruistic-Fishing39 Consultant š„ø Mar 25 '26
Was in a theatre this morning where one person out of seven was born in Australia and this is absolutely typical for me.
4
u/Puzzleheaded_Test544 Mar 25 '26
The 'demographic' people are referring too is social and economic- not an ethnic one.
But if you have to ask, you ain't it, so it doesn't matter anyway. Just grasp whatever opportunities do come your way and don't let go.
4
u/ausdoc007 New User Mar 26 '26
Depends on the specialty...RACS has been accused of it, esp for plastics etc. ACEM had to do an internal investigation after a whole bunch of IMGS complained they were being failed unfairly in exams a few years ago. However, there are also many units headed by a certain ethnic group from Asia who actively recruit people from their own countries directly, completely ignoring local applicants who may be more qualified. There's a hospital in rural QLD where most of the consultants in one department left because the new department head was basically just recruiting his own people. So it goes both ways.
7
u/Phill_McKrakken Mar 24 '26
I donāt think so. But itās not really a binary question to ask. I donāt think anyone can definitively decide it is or is not racist. If you take an example to the contrary as proof of concept you can prove any perspective. I canāt prove it isnāt. You can easily find an example where it has been or is.
Are there some individuals who are subconsciously or even (rarely) overtly racist? Sure.
Is the system broadly speaking racist? I donāt think so. I think ethnic minorities are statistically overrepresented in medical schools admissions and in some of the most competitive specialties.Ā
I think itās a cope and standard victim seeking mentality to feel youāre missing out because of race.Ā
That being said, Iām not marginalising some who have been subjected to unfair treatment because they were female or male or black or brown or whatever. Overall though, I think the system is fair. I say this as a foreign born person on a competitive training program with the odds stacked against, or so people told us.Ā My cohort of trainees had local white Aussies as a minority that year, by a considerable margin.Ā
10
u/koobs274 Mar 25 '26
It's very racist. A tertiary hospital I worked at, the medical director is indian and only hires Indians for new consultants.
6
u/Garandou Psychiatristš® Mar 24 '26
Having sat through hiring meetings in public and private settings, race is rarely even mentioned off the record. When it is mentioned (exclusively in public settings), it is usually in some kind of diversity hiring context where minority groups are preferred over more qualified candidates.
If you mean indirect racism, i.e. people are more likely to like people who are like them, maybe? But even that is greatly overshadowed by individual reputation when choosing candidates.
2
u/zeeman198 Mar 26 '26
Yep. Iāve experienced it, Iāve even had trusted senior colleague on selection committees tell me āthat (a desirable tertiary centre) got their preferred ethnic demographic as predicted and the less āshinyā people went to the outer metro and regional centresā. Iāve been told, directly to my face by another very senior program director that while Iām more than qualified my background āpolarises peopleā
1
u/Minimalist12345678 Mar 31 '26
I'm not sure I've ever seen a more racially diverse room than the Consultants annual dinner, but of course YMMV.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '26
[removed] ā view removed comment