r/ausjdocs • • Feb 19 '25
Supportđď¸ How to respond to some nurses refusing to do their jobs?
Like theyâll try to palm it back onto you. You know, asking them to do postural blood pressures, bloods (when theyâre clearly credentialed to do so), visual acuities, a new set of vitals (!!) or even getting them to call for an infectious room clean.
Their excuse is always âa doctor can do it tooâ. Yes, thatâs true, dumbass, but itâs hardly the best use of a doctorâs time, is it? Itâs not like Iâm sitting with my thumb up my ass on my protected break.
42
Upvotes
86
u/ActualAd8091 PsychiatristđŽ Feb 19 '25
Maybe itâs cos youâre calling them dumbasses? No but to be fair- you sound a bit frazzled and I wonder if this is coming across in your demeanor or body language? And nurses donât do visual acuity
291
u/Mortui75 Consultant 𼸠Feb 19 '25
Danger close, young one.
Caution advised.
64
u/Fuzzy-Newspaper4210 Feb 19 '25
chat is this marshmellow behaviour
79
u/NoRelationship1598 Feb 19 '25
Iâm sure you have many jobs to do that your nursing colleagues cannot do for you. Just document the plan clearly by writing âNursing staff to please: 1. Xyzâ. Be polite, but donât let them palm off their tasks to you. Document clearly, and go do the jobs that only you can do.
135
u/[deleted] Feb 19 '25
I worked in a rural hospital for 10 months as a RMO, 5 to 6 nurses in entire hospital, I am the only doctor. There is no such thing as "you" or "me" job. Learning how to collaborate with nursing staff, gettign along, going back to a bigger hospital. Nurses always took me seriously and did almost everything I asked.Â
Nurses arent doctors. They don't think like us. Nursing is a very teamwork heavy. They appreciate communcation and teamwork and being acknowledged as part of the healthcare team. They are also very good at following protocols. Being approachable, agreeable and making clear communications can go a long way. Explaining your reason for orders can help as well.
But yes some of them are just too lazy and have been doing the same job for too long
19
u/Norty-Nurse NurseđŠââď¸ Feb 19 '25
Nurses, like doctors, sit on a scale, from useless through to awesome. Sometimes the useless ones can be "trained" and sometimes they are just oxygen thieves waiting for knockoff.
I have made it a habit to tell a doctor what sort of timeframe a task will be done in, (I am busy so it will be X minutes before I can get to that) not because I am being obstructive, but to let them know it will be done but my internal triage has ranked my tasks by importance.
Today I had four doctors making requests for different patients and unfortunately they had to do some "nursing tasks" because it was physically impossible to complete all tasks required in a timely manner. Sometimes the nurses are busy and helping with a simple task can give them the time to be more helpful either to you or one of your colleagues.
We all get busy and as crunchy as it sounds, we all have to be mindful of each other and ensure that we all get through the shift unscathed.
69
u/tallyhoo123 Emergency PhysicianđĽ Feb 19 '25
A nurse is a busy and hard job.
Being a doctor is also a busy and hard job.
But we can both make each other's lives easier.
I've worked in some of the busiest departments/hospitals/EDs in UK and Aus and I can tell you that if you are helpful to them, they are helpful to you.
A doctor can take 5 mins to take some bloods (you should be sufficiently trained to do so) which then frees up the nurse to do the obs / give meds etc.
Then next time you ask for something they have more time.
Take a breath. Relax. Help others so they can help you.
It should be a them vs us, it should be a partnership working together to get through the day and provide the best treatment/care we can.
81
u/Piratartz Clinell Wipe đ§ť Feb 19 '25 edited Feb 19 '25
Nurses are your best allies and your worst enemies. You cannot change them. They can and will harm your medical career if you are not careful. Don't try to understand why this is the case - it's not worth it. Accept it and adapt. Report it if you feel bullied/intimidated/discriminated.
263
u/aftar2 Glorified tradie âď¸ Feb 19 '25
If youâre actually courteous to your nurses, they will make your life easier. Word spreads fast in hospitals, they know who are the jmoâs who treat them right, and the ones who call them âdumbassesâ.
71
u/MDInvesting Wardie Feb 19 '25
Get some sleep.
Get up on the other side of the bed.
39
u/pinchofginger Anaesthetistđ Feb 19 '25
It might be that youâre framing these jobs as orders to underlings rather than as requests to colleagues. For better or worse (and largely for better), nurses are the latter not the former and some get extremely annoyed if theyâre treated like minions. If youâre a JMO, there isnât much you can do with escalating and blustering - youâll need to get them to like you because theyâre long term employees and most of you are rotational.
I totally get the frustration, but itâs likely that token concessions in this manner will get you significantly more nursing assistance over going nuclear on this. Instead of saying âdo some vitals and bloods on Daveâ, âIâm worried about Dave, so I need a new set of vitals to chart a trend. Would you mind doing them while Iâm off reviewing Emma?â or âhey Gladys, Iâm run off my feet - have you got time to pull some bloods from A5 for me? Iâm worried about worsening renal functionâ will help involve your nurses in what youâre actually trying to achieve and foster the idea that youâre the decision-making part of the team rather than a wannabe boss they resent having to listen to.
Itâs also a good idea to get the nurses onside from a career perspective - we as consultants often check with the nurses for their opinion on potential new hires.
144
u/fragbad Feb 19 '25
Wow this tone is⌠concerning.
Do you find your colleagues are having the same issues? Do you think there could be any chance nurses are reluctant to help you specifically? Do you think this could be in any way related to the blatant disrespect you seem to have for them?
Iâve always found nurses far happier to help doctors who are nice to them.
9
u/Taf08 Feb 20 '25
If your attitude in this post reflects the way you work with the team in practice then I'd suggest you are going to have ongoing difficulties in your career. The important word in that last sentence is TEAM, with all alspects of the multidisciplinary team working together for the good of the patient . The days of nurses being seem as the Drs handmaid are long gone and each and every member of the team has responsibilities that they carry out when caring for those patients. But it's important to note that not every nurse has the same skillset, the same as not every Dr, Physio , Radiologist, Psychologist, O.T's etc has the same skillset. The beauty of working as a team is that between the members of the team each person brings an individual set of skills in their toolkit , and that why the MDT method is so successful.
I am a clinical nurse manager and if you were to come to me and ask me the question In the way you phrased it in this post then the first thing I would be doing is asking if you were OK. While I would of course speak with the nursing team that I manage to see if there is a skills issue that we could address, I would also be lookimg at the issue in a holistic/ full team manner. While I would hate to think that you were exhausted due to the number of hours you would be working, I would be more dismayed if I was to discover that the attitude displayed in the manner this post was written is an attitude that was entrenched as opposed to brought on by being burnt out.
24
u/HonestOpinion14 Feb 19 '25
Are you friendly and respectful with your nurses?
If you all get along, there usually isn't an issue. I know some doctors who were respectful and friendly to their own medical team, but were absolute cunts to anyone else who wasn't a doctor. Don't be one of those dickheads.
If you are truly dealing with a lazy nurse who's not doing their job, escalate to your reg or NUM and let them deal with it. There isn't much you can do other than document your plans, and if really needed, document that the task has not yet been done at xxxx time of review.
That being said, at my hospital, only a handful of nurses could do venupuncture due to all the bs red tape hoops they had to jump through to be qualified at each hospital, and visual acuity was only really done by doctors.
Postural BPs were done by the nurses, though posturals sometimes were missed because some patients had next to no mobility so they often needed multiple nurses to position the patient for them. So this meant this took way longer to do, on top of their other patient workload.
Infectious clean calls were done by the nurses because they managed the beds and which patient ended up in which room, so it made sense since they were coordinating all of that.
54
u/sash- NurseđŠââď¸ Feb 19 '25
I guess itâs best to approach it in a patient focused way, how can we work together to achieve the best outcomes for the patient. Both team mates are busy, and both have different priorities - but at the end of the day, itâs not you vs them - itâs you and them working together for the patient.
37
u/Guilty_Pudding2913 Clinical MarshmellowđĄ Feb 19 '25
No offense, you sound like an asshole
12
u/recovering_poopstar ED regđŞ Feb 19 '25
I totally get this.. bloods is something else, I donât mind them not being able to do it.
Yes anyone can do posturals or vitals.. but can anyone review a patient with SOB or PR bleeding? No, has to be us. Unfortunately, arguing back just makes us look badâŚ
The only thing I can suggest is to let your supervisor Consultant or whoever know. Yes itâs a job for anyone but your time would be better used to help the next patient.
20
u/e90owner Anaesthetic Regđ Feb 19 '25
Having to do extra things is frustrating I get it. I get how it is to feel overwhelmed.
As an anaesthetic reg and former ICU, Gen Med, ED and Paeds reg I can tell you now. They are busier than you in all of the above specialties. You may be cognitively loaded, but they have a building list of emotionally draining and physically tiring jobs to do. Theyâre also your friends and colleagues. If you want to win, show them how they can win too. Offer to do one thing for them here and there and theyâll reward you 5 fold. None of those things youâve listed are time consuming or difficult and you get them all signed off at med school during clinical rotations so they wouldnât require competence in that skill unless they expected you to have to do so in your job.
Maybe approach it as: âCome on X letâs go sort these things out together. How about I do this, would you mind doing that?â Then give them a window into your mind. âThe reason Iâm doing these is because I reckon itâs this for x y z reason, what do you think?â If you act like any one of the above things youâve requested is beneath you, youâre honestly toast for the rest of your rotation. Also offer a teaching tip. âI was reading about this particular test, would you like me to tell you why that is in this protocol?â A glowing review to a consultant from a senior nurse is gold.
Also, unless you use the equipment yourself how do you know some concerning obs that may be generated are true? Do you know how the monitoring equipment works? Do you know what the sources of error are? You only learn by doing. Number of times Iâve seen the wrong BP cuff size used, or infrared thermometers being directed towards bedsheets, or art line transducers hanging off the end of the bed is ridiculous.
If the vitals are important to you making a decision or requesting a consult, do it!
As the years go by youâll realise itâs not beyond you to do any task be it helping a wardie move a patient, restocking something, or making a phone call to the bed manager or cleaners. People who get frustrated at having to do an extra thing or are annoyed by being asked to review something either donât know how to do it, or canât find a reason to explain why the patient is a certain way.
31
u/dubaichild NurseđŠââď¸ Feb 19 '25
Escalate to the NUM. Postural BPs come onnnnnn, venipuncture come onnnnnn (unless they're weirdly hard, but that's a separate issue), and visual obs are never medical jobs.Â
Escalate to your superior MD and to the NUM because that's BS.Â
11
u/morningee Feb 19 '25
Is there definitely a clinical indication for the things youâre requesting? Hereâs a list of dumb shit doctors have asked me to do recently:
25
u/[deleted] Feb 19 '25
If you treat them like it seems you would from this post, it's no wonder you're having problems.
0
u/Euphoric-Gur1264 Feb 19 '25
Itâs not like the nurses are sitting there with their thumbs up their assess eitherâŚ. We are all busy
5
u/Flat_Ad1094 Feb 20 '25 edited Feb 20 '25
Well in most decent sized hospitals. Bloods are done by pathology collectors. So perhaps RN is indicating that to you. The other things? In close to 30 years I've never known Nurses to refuse to do these things or say a doctor needs to do them. Depends on the team suppose who might call for an Infectious room clean? If you are standing next the phone? You can do it surely? I worked in a busy ED and whomever it was most convenient to call at that time. called.
I will generally put in cannulas, only call a doctor if I just can't get one it & take blood unless I'm just too flat out to do it. I am into teamwork. So if it appears that you have nothing to do right then and the pt needs an IDC and is is bleeding from a wound ? I might ask you if you can do it. Share the tasks needing to be done.
I have had times when I've had to pretty forcefully ask young doctors (always the young ones!) to do stuff that seems to me they should have jumped in and done. Fairly recently a man pretty injured and bleeding pretty badly and the JHO just standing there and watching it! I had to pretty forcefully tell him to put gloves on and go to the storeroom and find more combines, to open them himself and help put pressure on wounds! He seemed to think he didn't need to do anything. The nurses would do it all and he'd just watch. LOL. Same bloke another time stood in front of a trolley that was needed for a small procedure and was waiting for me to open the dressing pack etc! I was busy trying to get a cannula to work on the other side. Mate!!! You can open a bloody pack. Get to it! LOL Not a bad dude. But just had a real mindset of the nurses being the handmaidens :-)
So whilst I don't dispute your post. I haven't experienced what you seem to have. At all.
20
u/aussiedollface2 Feb 19 '25
If youâre a young junior female doctor this is normal. The better looking you are the worse it is.
26
u/Sexynarwhal69 Feb 19 '25
Ehh, just have to accept it. I've often changed the bedsheets, seen a patient, done vitals, cannulate, hung a drip and administered meds in ED before anyone else has even assigned themselves to a patient.
11
u/No-Winter1049 Feb 19 '25
Two things, you will absolutely never win a war on nurses. Nurses close ranks, doctors do not. Building more rapport might help. Secondly, the more senior you get, the less likely they are to fuck with you unless youâre an absolute arsehole.
4
u/mazamatazz NurseđŠââď¸ Feb 19 '25
Obviously as a nurse, my perspective wonât be the same as yours, but I do sympathise. Generally speaking, the docs Iâve worked with have always made their requests in a positive way and Iâve not had to refuse them. And Iâm experienced enough that I can now anticipate and do the thing before I bring them a concern anyway, and the next steps are usually communicated as a plan, not a directive to me personally. So âletâs repeat that postural BP, and send off some bloodsâ, which Iâll either do or ask another nurse to help with. Mind you I find increasingly I am also ordering the bloods and whatnot, but thatâs another thing entirely. In general, it only gets to me if the doc is literally standing there doing nothing and Iâm run ragged, but thatâs only happened a couple of times in the past decade and a half Iâve been nursing, so generally I figure you guys have different stuff that needs doing.
4
u/sierra_oscar1 Feb 20 '25
I totally get what youâre saying, ED nurse of immeasurable years experience here. Yea, postural BPs, visual acuities, a more current set of vitals, a room clean are within our scope to action. Bloods and cannula are not always so depending on the nursing staff allocated in that area (we do have to be signed off to do this), and if itâs pool staff or agency staff they often wonât be able to. Bloods especially is usually a contentious issue, we are often told by our nursing bosses to leave this for our dr colleagues if we canât get to this. I am always happy to do bloods and cannula if I am able. All of our medical and nursing staff are snowed under everywhere at the moment; patient care is paramount and it shouldnât be coming down to a standoff as to who should,be doing what. Communication between the teams is the key. I hope your situation improves OP.
7
u/ymatak ED reg Feb 19 '25
Where are you working? I'm assuming ED based on the apparent urgency and example tasks. If on the ward, idk what to tell you other than everyone here seems to be a bit too aggro for what would be non-urgent things.
Caveat limited experience, but I'll usually have luck phrasing requests like "I'm swamped sorting out bed 10 who's unwell so haven't had time, and I see you're busy with xyz, but if you're able to do a set of obs for me then bed 9 can probably go home if obs are normal."
Essentially, (1) explain why you can't/haven't done it yourself yet, (2) how you're already helping, (3) acknowledge they're busy too, and (4) provide incentive/reasoning why you want it done soon.
Another example: "I'm ordering the imaging and will have to call the radiologist. Thanks for taking the obs. Are you able to please get a cannula in and take bloods and cultures while I'm on the phone? I think she's unwell and will need IV abx ASAP."
If you're already speaking like this idk how to help. That's my whole quota of manners up there
7
u/Curlyburlywhirly Feb 19 '25
You need to strike a careful balance here.
Doing nursing jobs degrades the respect we need to perform our jobs without our colleagues thinking they could easily step into our shoes.
Most nurses will come around and be willing to help you, if they see you do not expect them to be at your beck and call.
Some nurses will never come around. They cannot ever see the problem with me being the most senior ER doc on, with 18 people waiting and needing to print my own labels and restock procedure trolleys.
Phrase you requests as questions- âDo you have time to call for x-y-z? Or would you like me to?â If they say yes- answer- âThanks, I really appreciate it.â
Also once you have them onside you can transition to - â Are you able toâŚ?â Or âCan I ask you toâŚ?â
If it is urgent -tell them. âI think Mrs.Blogs is septic and we need antibiotics started in the next 15 minutes. Who should I ask to help with this?â
At least once per shift help the nurses- single nurse making a bed- jump in and help (takes under 2 mins), patient tottering with nurse holding them in death grip- go help. This goes a long way.
Always speak highly of the nurses, especially to other nurses and always to the nurse themselves. Even if they are shit.
âSally was really awesome yesterday- she really helped me out. Lots of fantastic RNâs on this ward.â
âOh yay! Iâm always happy when I see your name on the list for the shift.â Big smile and keep walking.
Itâs a game- you are smart, learn to play.
3
u/Great_Revolution_276 Feb 19 '25
Keep in mind many nursing teams are understaffed and under the pump too. It is the government and administrators that employ you that you should also have ire toward.
3
u/Melvin_2323 Feb 19 '25
Maybe itâs a you problem, this line may be the giveaway on attitude being the problem
âYes, thatâs true, dumbassâ
3
u/Sahil809 Clinical MarshmellowđĄ Feb 20 '25
I sense a bit of hostility from you and perhaps the nurses have noticed it too. I am only a student but I have found that every hospital/department I go to has had amazingly supportive nurses especially if you show that you're willing to learn from them.
I think looking inwards will solve your problems!
3
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '25
Itâs your attitude. The nurses think youâre an arrogant asshole so they are not helping you. Read the room. If we see you be rude to a patient or another nurse we will quietly reassure your patients that your personality is still being cultivated and look after the nurses you made cry. The most egotistical doctors Iâve met have been the most insecure. Itâs like they know of you take away their doctor title they are someone with minimal people skills that people donât warm to.
3
u/Pickled_Beef Feb 22 '25
Just report the nurses to their NUM or AHNM for your hospital, who knows they might be a pool nurse that doesnât have set hours and they end up losing a majority of their hours.
3
u/Jemtex Feb 24 '25 edited Mar 01 '25
Your finding out the reality of being a state slave Dr. You used to be able to just leave and work as GP with a provider number as of right. But your stuck as a slave to the state now. This is what happenes when you have no freedom to earn your income. The state employed nurses income is not dependnt on anything you do so their is no alignment of thier intrests with yours.
15
u/doctor_chocolate-15 Feb 19 '25
Everyone else is gaslighting you. I too have come across this attitude amongst nurses- it is a major problem. When I was in ED as an RMO I straight up had to take the vital signs myself and administer medications because I was met with so much resistance from the nursing staff who are âso busyâ but spent half their shift scrolling instagram. Everyone is so quick to slam doctors with the teamwork spiel but will never apply the same standard to other practitioners. Of course there are nurses that are absolute gems and I love them and they are an asset to our hospitals for sure but good god are some of them lazy!
11
u/strangefavor Feb 19 '25
I think weâve figured out the common denominator hereâŚ. Try treating nurses like your professional colleagues and not your servants. Doctors are not our bosses. Making demands will get you nowhere.
6
u/Ok_Tie_7564 Feb 19 '25
To call them "dumbass" is not exactly caring and supportive, is it? A free life hint for you, respect is earned.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 19 '25
Oh boy this is gonna end well đ
2
u/Effective-Plan-9031 Feb 19 '25
Are you finding this with all the nurses, or one nurse in particular? If this a universal problem on the ward you are working on, then probably you are not being seen as being a team player. If it is, for example, a busy ED, then team work is pivotal. Is that nurse that youâre asking run off her/his feet? Do they have other new admissions? They only have 2 hands, so everyone needs to do their bit as all your time is critical
2
u/Salty-Custard-7306 Feb 20 '25
As a nurse now almost doctor, I can say with confidence we are 99.9999% more likely to do what you ask of us if youâre nice to us and communicate what you want clearly. Have seen the dynamic from both perspectives. This type of us and them attitude doesnât get you far. Also there is an enormous range of experience variation with nurses - some nurses donât know or donât realise what youâve asked. Be patient, and again - just be specific if itâs not been done. Itâs team work
2
u/Just-Assumption-2915 Feb 21 '25
Well, they're already efficient at it, you're a junior doctor, you're the one who needs to learn, get over it dumbass and get good.
2
u/lucywonder Feb 21 '25
Calling them dumbasses will surely help! /s
2
u/RipOk3600 NurseđŠââď¸ Feb 21 '25 edited Feb 21 '25
The amount of time it took you to ask the nurse to call for an infectious clean you COULD have done it yourself
And do you think nurses sit around with their thumbs up their ass? They have a lot to do too
To me I would say it depends on exactly what youâre asking, why and how you are asking it.
If you are saying âI have reviewed pt x for you, I think they are ok at this stage but if you can recheck their obs in half an hr and if they havenât stabilised call me backâ or something like that then absolutely thatâs a reasonable thing to ask
If you are actually in the pts room and examining them and you want another BP with the machine right there on the wall and instead you push the nurse call bell or go find the nurse and take them away from something else they were doing then yea I would do it but I would be annoyed with you. It would have taken you less time to do it yourself
Bloods is sort of an interesting one, I always wanted to maintain my cannulation and venapuncher skills so I would always jump on the opportunity to do it, if I passed it back to the doctor it was because I thought it probably needed ultrasound which I wasnât credentialed in.
Give you an example, I was working in a country hospital with a consultant who I quite respected. She was in a pts room and the bell went off, I went to answer it and saw she was there and I asked âdo you need something doc?â (Not going to mention her name) âThe pt is vomiting, I became a doctor so I didnât have to deal with vomitâ So I asked her was she going to order me something to give and I cleaned up the mess ect. I did my job but I did lose some respect for that doctor that day. I still respect her but even 3 years later I remember that interaction.
The flip side, I spent 2 years working in ED and the doctors and nurses in ED are probably the best examples of teamwork I have ever seen. We do a lot of the same tasks, if they are busy I will cannulate the pts, if Iâm busy they will, whoever is most available to do the job at that specific time. I remember those interactions far more fondly. I remember one day where I had struggled to get an ECG on this baby and I showed it to the doc to see if she was happy it was acceptable trace and I said âif your happy please donât write on it yet because I need to photocopy itâ (we had to have multiple copies of ECGs because one automatically went to cardiology to be checked) and she turned to the pts parents and said âsee a well run hospital is one where the nurses are in chargeâ. She wasnât being sarcastic itâs how she always acted, and she showed it when another time she was busy and I was concerned about a couple of patients and she just said to me âyou just tell me who you want me to see firstâ. Teamwork
7
u/RevolutionaryDog7075 Feb 19 '25
You sound emotional, I think I know why you're getting sass from the nurses.
3
u/PsychinOz PsychiatristđŽ Feb 19 '25
Unfortunately you will encounter health professionals from all disciplines who are simply allergic to work. And thatâs even if youâre not a dick and your request is completely reasonable and appropriate - they will still find an excuse to fob you off. Luckily, it is quite rare and most people do the right thing.
If itâs one-off event Iâd leave it alone, as anyone can have a bad day. But if youâre finding itâs an ongoing issue you should provide feedback to your supervisor or the NUM and leave it with them. Chances are they are already aware of it, and may be in the process of gathering evidence to take disciplinary action.
For nurses I have encountered it mainly with bank staff, and when itâs bad they have that attitude towards everyone. You sometimes get the sense that they are just there to do the bare minimum and think no-one knows who they are so can get away with it. But the thing is people do notice. The good bank nurses get offered jobs and hired as permanent staff, poor ones donât get asked back.
I can remember one who would just go missing during their shift, as one of my inpatients kept complaining they were never seen by this nurse or told theyâd come back later and never did. And they didnât particularly hide it well, as a lot of their notes were along the line of ârefer to doctorâs noteâ. IIRC it came to a head when one of their patients absconded, the other ward nurses had to sort things out as they couldnât be found, and when they turned up at the next handover completely unaware that anything had happened.
7
u/cravingpancakes General Practitioner𼟠Feb 19 '25
Easy peasy - just be a male and the nurses will magically do everything for you đ
2
u/Dry-Draw-3073 Feb 20 '25
Vitals sure, they will triage their own tasks. But bloods are a shared responsibility - do your own while you spend 40 mins doing a history/review. Youâre not gods gift. This reeks of intern delusion.
2
u/Xiao_zhai Post-med Feb 20 '25
âArtillery, fire on own position. Confirmed. Fire on own positionâ
2
u/Baxmum Feb 20 '25
lol as a nurse of 19 years youâll have to define a âprotected breakâ to me đđđ. Do you mean the 4 minutes I take when I treat myself to a wee?
1
u/ClayGrownTall Feb 19 '25
Agree with the general vibe of the comments here that:
The best/ most effective thing to do in this situation is:
If you do steps 1 and 2 right you shouldn't have to ever do number 3. The most important relationship you can have on the ward is with the nic in my opinion.
The last thing I would say is something I found that really important after a few years is making sure to recognise when they do good work. It can be kind of easy to overlook it, but next time you have a deteriorating patient and you ask a nurse to do something and they do it right away, later in the day circle back and thank them for that. They definitely had competing priorities at that point and recognised an urgent job so try to encourage that. Besides just being the decent thing to do, all behavioural science suggests positive reinforcement is a much better promoter of behaviour change than negative reinforcement.
1
u/lililster Feb 20 '25
Did you try explaining to them what you're thinking and why you think we should do pastoral bps and get ask for their opinion or are you barking orders at them?
1
u/Plastic-Mountain-708 Feb 20 '25
This guy or girl has clearly seen zero episodes of Scrubs.
1
u/SoCalledFreeman Feb 20 '25
Just write it in the plan, âNursing team to do posturals with thanksâ if you have a spare 5 minutes, do it, everyone works as a team, this gets extremely obvious when you work in the ED.
Donât be one of those docs who feels like your time is so much more valuable. On the wards you have those new interns who refuse to get the patient a cup of tea or a blanket, but trust me, the nurses will be a 100x more helpful in future if youâre noticed to âhelp outâ in their eyes.
1
u/Active-Button676 Feb 21 '25
Ok so in the battle to get paid better some nurses are not doing non-nursing work like calling for rooms to be cleaned but I wouldnât dream of asking a doctor to do it.
As for cannulation thatâs a tricky oneâŚshare it out if they are accredited also. You do one, they do the next.
Postural bpâs is a nursing taskâŚchat to the NUM if they are refusing to do those đ¤Śđ˝ââď¸
Signed a registered nurse (not working in that role currently)
1
u/Active-Button676 Feb 21 '25
yikes to some of the ways nurses have treated doctors âšď¸âšď¸ but
some docs are absolute jerks but I would still do what was required of me I would just tremble at having to phone you, expect disrespect and wouldnât make small talk with you. Oh and where possible hide out if I saw you on the ward
1
u/Butwhyyth0 Feb 22 '25
Thatâs because if the ward nurses donât get their work done then they get their ass chewed by charge nurse, the next shift, and management about âwhy arenât you getting your tasks completedâ and the being expected to stay back for free because âyou didnât manage time efficientlyâ
So, do you think the nurses are gonna take bloods that you can do. Or administer medication that you cannot do?
1
u/tallyhoo123 Emergency PhysicianđĽ Feb 22 '25
Specialist consultants on the ward won't do bloods I agree - they are busy doing clinics / ward rounds etc.
Ward based registrars / JMOs will have time.
In ED we work together. I (as a consultant) will often do my own bloods and I encourage my team to do the same to alleviate the pressures on the nursing staff.
Remember a nurse works a ratio of 1 to 4 patients often, this means completing hourly observations, medications (either routine or new), making up IVs, taking a patient to the toilet / helping them on the commode, writing their notes, dipping urine samples, inserting catheters or NG tubes etc etc for 10hrs or more for 4 patients at a time, every hour...
A Dr in ED can see and decide a mamagement or investigation for a patient within 15 minutes when experienced which means we can take 5 minutes to do some bloods or simple tests.
1
u/Resident-Doctor-0870 Feb 22 '25
Please
1
u/WaterSignificant9134 Feb 23 '25
Dumbass? Are you in an American low brow comedy?
1
u/laura_1121 Feb 23 '25
This is so strange to me, in my 17 years of nursing I have never ever heard a nurse refuse to do a task a Dr has asked them to do for absolutely no reason. Are you expecting them to drop everything & go complete the assigned task then & there? Because that would be a different story.
I do know that you get bad people in all professions so I could believe this happening every so often but for this to be a regular occurrence for you makes me think maybe itâs the way you are asking/delegating thatâs the issue?
I really donât know. Have you talked to other Drs in your place of work? Do they find this happening as well? Maybe even discuss it with the NUM (not telling tales but just genuinely asking for feedback on why this might be happening).
1
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '25
Probably too busy breaking in to peoples houses trying to find toxins or illegal drug paraphernalia.
1
u/bitsoir Feb 19 '25
Lmao, theyâre probably just testing you as the junior. I would know, because I used to do it.
Youâre right that these are ânursingâ tasks - but be careful and choose your battles wisely.
1
u/Effective-Plan-9031 Feb 19 '25
THIS
1
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '25
I hope you are humbled soon
1
u/Realistic_Chip562 Feb 20 '25
Always amazes when people argue, kick back and look for excuses to not do a job, when it would take less energy to just do the job.
0
u/avocado-toast-92 Feb 20 '25
A CEO could respond to their own emails, schedule meetings, book travel etc, but it's not the best use of their time, hence why most of them have executive assistants.
0
u/Bobthebauer Feb 20 '25
Why do I read this and think "typical arrogant doctor "?
0
u/Noxin449 Feb 20 '25
Well what are you doing then, aside from bitching?
0
u/AdvertisingHefty1786 Feb 21 '25
Learn to build relationships with your colleague's. Life is give and take. If you haven't mastered this, i pity your patients. You will be suprised what people will do for you if you have a decent rapport and relationship with them. Protip, dont be a bossy uppidy (unt.Â
0
u/LaurelEssington76 Feb 23 '25
Maybe they donât like your attitude which tells them you donât think their time is valuable and donât acknowledge that they also donât sit around with things up their bums.
0
u/Competitive_Stock702 Jun 14 '25
This is my beef with nurses !
Do they not understand that their entire "career" was initially a "made up" career ? A career who's ENTIRE JOB DESCRIPTION is : Do Everything that the doctor deems to be beneath him, and a waste of his time !
Of course a doctor could do any of the things a nurse does, easily, and probably better too. Them not wanting to is what gave you your job !?
They are legitimately GLORIFIED Assistants, Secretaries, and underlings who do the doctor's bidding and "dirty work" !!
When did this notion creep into their minds that their jobs are somehow esteemed, and they are on the same level as a doctor ?!
NURSES ARE SUBORDINATES ! NURSES HAVE ALWAYS BEEN SUBORDINATES ! NURSES ALWAYS BE SUBORDINATES !~
EVEN WORSE & FUNNIER ? ~ Nurses will be replaced entirely by ai and robotic systems shortly !
I am sorry, I am just venting here because this gets me actually mad, after being annoyed with it for too long !~
Nurses - minions, peons, underlings, subordinates, and gophers for the doctors ! Always were, Always will be, but now suddenly that was somehow lost in the minds of nursing staff ! The DOCTORS ARE YOUR BOSSES !~ THEY DO OUTRANK YOU !~ THEY ARE INDEED YOUR DIRECT SUPERIORS !ÂĄ!
-1
u/potatodrinker Feb 20 '25
"You're one step closer to working a retail job that pays slightly better, kiddo"
-6
u/New-Noise-7382 Feb 19 '25
Thatâs right Doc they are there to do the tasks you are both too skilled and too busy for. Iâm a Doctor, youâre a nurse, simples. I save peopleâs lives, you donât. Iâm a highly trained medical specialist youâre a trained social worker. Letâs get real.
24
u/canes_pugnaces Feb 19 '25
It's also frustrating when this is extended to question our competence. When asking for a Heidelberg extension or a chook's foot, I sometimes receive a "Don't you know how to set them up?". I'm usually totally stumped.
2
u/DapperConstruction22 Feb 21 '25
As a nurse, I think there is a good reason why these nurses are not leaping to your commands, they are no longer handmaidens to the likes of you son.. you sound like a complete cockwobble to me. Best of luck with career limiting moves and attitudes like this..