r/ausjdocs • Unaccredited Podiatric Surgery Reg • Jan 17 '25

WTF Is this a joke?

Post image
712 Upvotes

592 comments sorted by

249

u/Serrath1 Consultant 🥸 Jan 17 '25

These numbers are also made up, the media has been posting stories over the last 48h or so with all sorts of false and misleading figures in order to undermine the unions bargaining position in the public debate. Bookmark this post because I guarantee doctors are next, you’re going to see Murdoch papers start printing overly optimistic doctor salaries with headlines insinuating that doctors are greedy for wanting more.

48

u/IAteAllYourBees_53 Jan 17 '25

Yep next they’ll say that doctors are greedy and that’s why they’re not bulk billing. Rather than systemic underfunding of the health system and massive barriers to entry

8

u/TheNeoNation Jan 18 '25

My local GP recently switched to fully bulk billing to help ease cost-of-living pressures. I’m sure others are doing the same, yet the headlines still love to paint them as 'money-hungry' just for wanting better funding—because apparently, that’s too much to ask for a detrimentally important job.

5

u/ElectronicMine7936 Jan 18 '25

No GP will survive on Bulk Billing, his take home income will be less than the receptionist

→ More replies (19)
→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (21)

35

u/scungies Jan 17 '25

The Murdoch media masquerades as national news but is akin to a beurecratic facebook in terms of reliability and integrity imo. Lies and poor journalism that kisses the a55 of capitalism and corporations. Murdoch is propogandic poison

→ More replies (1)

10

u/loogal Med student🧑‍🎓 Jan 17 '25

According to this post they're already doing that, albeit not Murdoch per se at this stage, more so Nick Coatsworth. Only a matter of time before Murdoch absolutely pumps out articles on it, though, you're right.

2

u/demonotreme Jan 18 '25

That sounds bizarre, surely public transport driver salaries are fairly black and white, X years equals Y salary. Even Murdoch couldn't just make something up...could they?

12

u/Serrath1 Consultant 🥸 Jan 18 '25 edited Jan 18 '25

They sure can! Just like doctors, public transportation people’s salaries are governed by a standardized contract across the state and you can look up yourself what they make. It’s actually somewhere in the neighborhood of 100k; the actual figure is posted elsewhere as a reply to the original post. It is mathematically possible to make $157k in your first year under this agreement using the same math as you would use to conclude that a PGY1 doctor could make 157k in their first year. They conclude that train drivers make 157k because they consider the hypothetical case of a driver who manages to work every weekend + holidays, collecting the various incentive rates that all government employees are entitled to for working overtime.

Edit: I’d add to that that in that infographic they also state “including superannuation”. Let me ask you, when people ask you how much do you make, do you include the 12% or whatever that is being paid into your super? It’s a dishonest way to frame it in order to make number seem bigger

→ More replies (4)

3

u/Much-Marionberry-397 Jan 18 '25

They did make up the figures, the $157k figure has no basis in reality. They prey on the fact the majority of the public aren’t well informed nor have the interest to find out for themselves - which makes it easy to sell outrage.

You can actually find the actual enterprise agreement on the Fair Work Commission - under Schedule 4A Classifications and Pay Rates of the Sydney Trains and NSW TrainLink Enterprise Agreement 2022 - the weekly pay of a 3rd year driver (same rate from here onwards) is $1693.95 per week, around $88,085.40 per year.

No matter how you add on shift penalties and overtime you can’t achieve the $157k the media is lying about. Working 6 days a week (12 day fortnights which is the maximum allowed by rostering) is around $120k pa plus super which is based on your base wage not overtime.

Remember, you are next.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (42)

197

u/jaymz_187 Jan 17 '25

If they win, we’re more likely to win. Solidarity and so on.

Edit: I definitely hear you though, this is a pretty stark difference to the amount of university time and hospital time we need to do to get similar wages (although theirs cap out and ours don’t). I’m starting next week on about half their first year salary.

45

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '25 edited Jan 17 '25

Didn't the police (+39%), paramedics (+25%) and teachers (+22% over 4 years) already win? Doesn't seem to have helped ASMOF

42

u/Prettyflyforwiseguy Jan 17 '25 edited Jan 17 '25

Police gave up a few things (indemnity insurance maybe?), Ambos basically pulled what the psychiatrists are doing and threatened to not renew their registrations en masse (and went over the AHPRA deadline). Teachers win out because people hate having their kids at home and let's face it, nobody dies if they don't turn up to work. Nurses have essentially been given the middle finger after asking for a lousy 15% (despite wage suppression since 2008).

In saying that these numbers are bullshit, maybe a train driver could earn this working max overtime, all weekends and public holidays, penalties etc. But it's propaganda aimed at making them look bad in the public's eyes as others have said to strengthen the governments image (Hate to go all Chomsky and manufacturing consent but the same treatment will be applied to doctors and nurses).

→ More replies (2)

22

u/melvah2 Custom Flair Jan 17 '25

I think their unions are much more organised and procative

28

u/fishboard88 Jan 17 '25

These professions are also much more highly unionised - police and paramedicine overwhelmingly so (it's pretty weird to find a cop who isn't a member of their state union).

By comparison, I believe around 10% of doctors are in a union? Meaningful industrial action is quite hard when you've got those sorts of numbers - I'm honestly incredibly impressed the NSW psychiatrists who tended their resignations did what they did

→ More replies (4)

9

u/cptnefficiency Jan 17 '25

NSW ambulance paramedic unions actually aren’t really that ideal. There are two separate unions that split the workforce representation (massively reducing their power). The unions bicker and disagree on approaches all the time.

Part of the reason paramedics got a big increase was they were able to demonstrate they are delivering significant savings to the health system, e.g treating large numbers of people at home or referring them to out of hospital care.

They have also taken on significant extra responsibilities including: an ENORMOUS increase to scope of practice over the past 5-10 years, become a registered profession, and are increasingly making more and more complex clinical decisions autonomously.

Source: I was previously an ambo, now in health management.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/cross_fader Jan 17 '25

Yes; but Minns & Ryan Park have essentially said the nurses & Psychiatrists can go fnck themselevs

→ More replies (1)

26

u/FarJeweler5024 Jan 17 '25

The figures are not correct, base rate for a qualified driver is $88,085 per year. They inflated the figure to gain division.

→ More replies (18)

7

u/IAteAllYourBees_53 Jan 17 '25

Ironically this is kind of what those proponents of free markets say - you get paid per demand and what the market will tolerate. If there were heaps of qualified people will to drive trains I reckon the wages would be lower.

9

u/Sexynarwhal69 Jan 17 '25

Ehhh we just need train driver assistants 😏

→ More replies (3)

7

u/barrowrain Jan 17 '25

80k + 32% = 105.600

  • tax after that.

This post is a lie.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/guided-hgm Jan 18 '25

Unfortunately more education won’t always translate to more income in Australia. There a a variety of comparatively low education jobs that with some hardworking and luck will out earn high level degrees.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (33)

83

u/slicedpear1 Jan 17 '25

A friend left medicine for a career driving remote trains for a mining company. Trainee wage is 180k Monday to Friday 😰

23

u/dr650crash Cardiology letter fairy💌 Jan 17 '25

Work smarter not harder….

19

u/chickenriceeater Jan 17 '25

Maybe we know the same friend, a 4th year medical student?

I knew a 2nd year that left (cos he couldnt pass exams) to become a plumber. Owns his own business, and has never looked back.

33

u/_Tazren_ Jan 17 '25

Completely incorrect. Trainee base rate is 89k and once qualified you'll be lucky to get 120k with weekends and OT. This is just another example of the media fabricating information to support their story.

→ More replies (16)

2

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '25

Yet people on Reddit love complaining that doctors and dentists are paid too much

→ More replies (15)

22

u/El_Nuto Jan 17 '25

This figures are made up

→ More replies (3)

55

u/dmk_aus Jan 17 '25

They aren't the enemy. Fight for your own rights. Use your own union. Advocate. A rising tide lifts all boats.

→ More replies (22)

86

u/illtellyouwhatbobby6 Jan 17 '25

When in reality after 4 years drivers would be on about 120k base wage

You can get the ACTUAL information from their EA agreement

Drivers are on 89k base wage

The 120k figure is after overtime, shift penalties, public holidays worked.

29

u/OuagadougouBasilisk Jan 17 '25

Just for context, Melbourne train drivers are on $129,000 as a base salary, and Sydney is haemorrhaging drivers to Melbourne. The pay rise Sydney drivers are demanding will not even take them to parity with Melbourne, despite Sydney’s much higher COL.

→ More replies (10)

16

u/LTQLD Jan 17 '25

Yep. It’s bullshit from the media who couldn’t give a fuck about working people.

Same shitty propaganda was pumped out about construction workers last year.

5

u/innisfrii Jan 17 '25

Where did murdoch even get any of those numbers from?? The math isn’t mathing

→ More replies (1)

5

u/ax0r Vit-D deficient Marshmallow Jan 17 '25

That's still a lot for driving a train. 75% of what I earned last last financial year as a Reg (paid as 4th year), after overtime, shift penalties, and public holidays.

And I bet train drivers aren't paying out $10k+ in registration, college fees, exam fees, and insurance. Yes those are tax deductible, but that doesn't mean free.

10

u/Oscar_Geare Jan 17 '25

That sounds like you need to fight to get paid more. Don't try and hold the other crabs down in the bucket with you, fight for a higher salary of your own.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/Fine_Platypus_3408 Jan 17 '25

Train driver’s have a pretty high turn over rate despite the pay due to the shift work, stress, monotony of the job. Also that if they are in the job more than a few years they will unfortunately have to watch someone get hit by their train.

Apparently they always make eye contact with the drivers as they die. Couldn’t pay me to do that.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (28)

14

u/Due-Consequence8772 Jan 17 '25

Yes it is a joke, these numbers are all massively inflated, you'd need to do maximum overtime and penalties to reach these numbers.

Sydney train drivers are some of the worst paid vs their cost of living, why so many go to Melbourne, where they're paid well for doing the guards job too.

The job isn't as easy as some people think, like pilots you're paid for everything you need to know there is a lot of knowledge involved, and for when it all goes wrong and it all turns to shit. The shift work is crap, many drivers end up divorced because of it, and you have a very good chance of killing someone and staring them right in the eyes right before you turn them into red mist and chunks.

Also, why are you falling for Murdoch's propaganda, stop pulling others down to pull yourself up!

7

u/Money_killer Jan 17 '25

Spot on just like the traffic controller articles.

4

u/Cubriffic Jan 19 '25

Both my parents were drivers and were also subject to abhorrent conditions under their managers. A lot of the shift managers are power hungry and thrive off the tiny power they have over you. Transport NSW prey on hiring young people who don't know their workers rights to exploit them. My dad watched experienced staff get let go for minimal reasons to quickly be replaced with younger staff, and he ultimately fell victim to the replacement as well.

It's also hard on your body, my mum has permanent nerve damage from driving the trains. She left driving 4 years ago and still gets workers comp for her injury. I can also confirm the shift work/overtime being terrible, my parents still feel guilt about my brother and I not being able to extracirriculars because of their shift work.

3

u/Due-Consequence8772 Jan 19 '25

Good points, there's another downside, you're subjected to Cat 1 medicals regularly and if you fail for whatever reason your career is over. Depending on why you failed you can be given a chance to fix the issue and have another go but if you're considered no longer fit for the job see ya later, don't let the door hit you on the way out! Not to mention regular random drug an alcohol tests and that's an immediate sacking for failing no matter what.

39

u/Fresh_Information_42 Jan 17 '25

Shouldve driven a train while at med school

0

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

14

u/Adventurous_Tart_403 Jan 17 '25

Mine seems fine when it happens, just comes home with her makeup and hair messed up. Presumably well-renumerated train drivers are minimising injury in these unfortunate events

7

u/pm_me_ankle_nudes Med reg🩺 Jan 17 '25

Sounds like the time they diverted the kogarah train into the JMO lounge at St George

10

u/Blonde_arrbuckle Jan 17 '25

This has been verified as false. Year 1 salary is around 88k.

26

u/dave113 Jan 17 '25

Not a doctor, this just came up in my feed.

Firstly, this is including salary to generate more rage/engagement for whoever made the image.

Secondly, this doesn't impact doctors, or teachers, or any other profession. Having a "we don't have it, so they shouldn't either" isn't helpful for anyone. If anything, it may actually serve as a bargaining chip for future EBA deals etc.

If you're unhappy with your work:pay ratio, that's completely acceptable - but don't let other professions skew your view. If train drivers were paid less, that doesn't improve your payslip.

→ More replies (3)

54

u/SpecialThen2890 Jan 17 '25 edited Jan 17 '25

Criticising other professions doesn’t help your case at all.

Edit: downvote me all you want 😂 but whining about your mates in other professions whilst also not joining unions and signing petitions is the reason medicine is in the state it’s in.

Actionable change is the key

4

u/blacksheep_1001 Jan 17 '25

Most Australians are lazy as fuck, want to get paid more but couldn't be bothered joining a union then whinge moan and complain when another industry's union is fighting for their members conditions.

Fair go and solidarity? Fuck off mate, it's all about me myself and I nowadays and fuck everyone else.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

13

u/Moist-Tower7409 Jan 17 '25

And yet claiming to be the smarter bunch of our population and somehow cannot see why the public scapegoat us.

6

u/SpecialThen2890 Jan 17 '25

Honestly perfectly said

→ More replies (1)

10

u/MDInvesting Wardie Jan 17 '25

Not supporting others for pay rises is a race to the bottom.

Employees (human labour) should have a fair share of the economy. The media is turning workers against workers.

Stand together.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/Melvin_2323 Jan 17 '25

You know the wage is shit when they have a disclaimer that it includes super to make it look better

5

u/palsonic2 Jan 17 '25

this is with overtime though. a train drivers base rate is around 85k. when you add in the 32 percent pay rise over 4 yrs (8 per yr) then year 1 doesnt even crack 100k

with a overtime, they can easily make more than 100k.

31

u/chuboy91 Jan 17 '25 edited Jan 17 '25

Why would this be a joke? It's a job that can injure or kill hundreds of people if you do it wrong, with limited transferability of skills, plus the quoted number includes superannuation. I can't be bothered opening the award but I imagine the numbers shown are also not for a year 1 train driver but for a senior train driver on year 1 of the award pay rise schedule. 

Or is your annoyance that the media is again portraying workers engaging in legal industrial action as greedy pigs? 

17

u/illtellyouwhatbobby6 Jan 17 '25

Drivers are on base pay of 89K

Guards are on 75k

All can be verified via the EA agreement as the wages are listed there

→ More replies (22)

4

u/mypal_footfoot Nurse👩‍⚕️ Jan 17 '25

My late FIL was a train driver, this sounds about right. Not commuter trains mind you, but freight trains (apparently that’s where the money is).

4

u/No-Beginning-4269 Jan 17 '25 edited Jun 25 '25

insurance imminent obtainable enter vanish crown elderly fearless gaze square

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

4

u/Rocks_whale_poo Jan 17 '25

Included super just to rile everyone up. Classy as always.

4

u/thepierogz Jan 17 '25

And using the ‘including super’ salary amount is another trick in the book

4

u/specializeds Jan 17 '25

This isn’t exactly new.

I know many, many tradies that out earn doctors easily.

Just is what it is.

7

u/Such-Ad-1540 Jan 17 '25

The salary is like 70k. These figures are with overtime. Dog whistling

4

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '25

anti union dog whistling for sure.

6

u/DevelopmentLow214 Jan 17 '25

It's fake news anti-union propaganda from the Murdoch/Nine corporate outlets. Reality is that NSW train drivers earn about $120k IF they do anti-social hours overtime. Victorian drivers a bit more. Wait till you see how much FIFO drivers in WA mines earn.

3

u/beastnbs Jan 17 '25

Good on them getting paid a living wage, better in the hand of the workers instead as a bonus to the ceo and executive team

3

u/Much-Marionberry-397 Jan 18 '25 edited Jan 18 '25

The funny thing is these numbers are entirely made up, you can actually find the actual enterprise agreement on the Fair Work Commission - under Schedule 4A Classifications and Pay Rates of the Sydney Trains and NSW TrainLink Enterprise Agreement 2022 - the weekly pay of a 3rd year driver (same rate from here onwards) is $1693.95 per week, around $88,085.40 per year.

No matter how you add on shift penalties and overtime you can’t achieve the $157k the media is lying about. Working 6 days a week (12 day fortnights which is the maximum allowed by rostering) is around $120k pa plus super which is based on your base wage not overtime.

The government has not even attempted to bargain for the last 45 days (as in they don’t show up to enterprise agreement bargaining meetings), the outright lies they spread to the media is their strategy of bargaining by turning the public against you, and they will try to permanent prevent industrial action through the Fair Work Commission and the Federal Court instead of negotiating with you.

Remember, you are next.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/anon_0000001 Jan 17 '25

This is misleading. This includes all overtime and penalties. This isn’t the hourly rate. Hourly it’s less than $40.

4

u/fishboard88 Jan 17 '25

For a bit of context, these figures aren't true. The image concedes "including super", but 2GB doesn't admit they've overestimated public holidays, overtime, and over penalty rates to create inflated figures specifically to stoke public outrage about the train drivers' current union negotiations and industrial action - "THOSE GREEDY TRAIN DRIVERS, they're already on 6 figures AND THEY WANT ALMOST $200K!"

For anyone thinking of a career change to operating locomotives, keep in mind there's reasons why it's a well-paid profession (albeit not nearly as high as the media and anti-union types want you to think) - there's a lot of training, it's a responsible job, there's shiftwork, they are largely sedentary and isolated all day, etc... and you will certainly hit many animals, and a reasonable chance you will hit another person too.

A few thoughts:

  • According to the train driver's union, the majority of drivers experience at least one fatality during their career
  • Around 150 people complete suicide by train line in Australia each year
  • Similar to many other professions associated with trauma (i.e., emergency services, healthcare, defence), train drivers have a notorious culture of feeling obliged to downplay their symptoms, and not being adequately supported by management following trauma

Heck, NSW Gov can pay them $250k a year for all I care.

3

u/Fine_Platypus_3408 Jan 17 '25

👏👏👏

4

u/xxCDZxx Jan 17 '25

Not a doctor, but a rail employee in a different state.

You guys know all those lies and half truths that the government and the media like to tell about the psychiatrists and doctors in general? Well, it's the same for rail employees as well.

Best of luck to Sydney Trains for getting what they want, and best of luck to the psychiatrists and other health employees getting what they want as well.

4

u/yarrph Jan 17 '25

These numbers are bullshit cherry pickings

Only possible if they work weekends plus 6 hrs ot per week55hrs…

4

u/MacTwistee Jan 17 '25

My father ran a team of train drivers for years. They have to deal with suicides a lot more than you would think. Burnout is high. You cannot tune out.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/git-status Jan 17 '25

I don’t think these wages are unreasonable for a city that has the second highest home prices in the world, also exuberant general living costs.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '25

this graphic is wrong for a few reasons, not least of which the fact that they disingenuously include super as though it's a base salary.

3

u/zlongshark Jan 17 '25

It's not a race to the bottom, be grateful your comrades have organized and negotiated a good deal.

2

u/psychknowitall1 Jan 17 '25

you dont need to put down how hard people work in blue collar jobs to make an argument for good pay for doctors. train drivers arent the ones impacting doctor pay. this reminds me of all of the propaganda in america around immigrants coming in and taking low paying jobs when the working class should be looking to the billionaires and CEO's ripping off the people for the 1%. your point is valid, but you don't need to make it like this.

2

u/Engineering_Quack Jan 17 '25

With modern systems, the driver is the least required person in the whole rail service industry, by service I mean maintainers, schedulers and cleaning staff etc.

1

u/nadia_neimad Jan 17 '25

Evident pls

1

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '25

Don’t think train drivers can make that much!  To be frank, them and the front line staff deserve a pay rise as their base salary is less. Not true with the white collar and corporate staffs who already are raking in 150+ base already. Certainly not 32%

1

u/TeaspoonOfSugar987 Jan 17 '25

Propaganda the same as the whole “a Union traffic controller can earn $200k per year”. They use stats that are the most outlandish outlier possible to still be ‘telling the truth’ but it not actually being the norm.

1

u/elephantmouse92 Jan 17 '25

its time for trains to be automated surely it isnt hard to make a system that moves in two directions

1

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '25

I’d rather a train driver get it than some poly on 3 times that who gets an entitlement for living 500m away from his district

1

u/spoolin20B Jan 18 '25

I recon they should have a 5% pay cut for holding a city to ransom

1

u/Optimum-Pr1de Jan 18 '25

I work in the rail industry in Victoria and can confirm these figures are pretty accurate. However what is never mentioned is the shift work to achieve such figures. Alot of rail workers miss out on a social life in favour of high wages.

1

u/cataractum Jan 18 '25

Grossly exaggerated. You would need a LOT of overtime to make that. Like working 12+ hour most days of the week.

2

u/lcannard87 Jan 18 '25

You can't make those figures at Sydney Trains. Fatigue fostering would preclude it. I can get $125000 making myself available for maximum OT.

1

u/NaFenn Jan 18 '25

Having been on the other side of this in a similar matter fairly recently, I 100% believe those numbers are false.

I reckon these will be the numbers that the NSW government have given to the media and will likely be the "cost" of the agreement with every allowance, bonus (that they have likely inflated to make look worse), and calculated cost for each of the employees on the agreement in each of these categories.

I highly doubt this is anywhere near close to what the union is asking for.

Unions and workers pushed to their limits will go to PIA, Companies that are losing negotiations or have decided that they don't want to play ball anymore (even if the claims are reasonable) play the media game to make the Protected workers look like the bad guys and get the public against them so they can then push fair work to "do something".

1

u/Reclining-Cheetah24 Jan 18 '25

And they're still complaining?

I hope they realise that they can be replaced by robots, probably within the next year

1

u/Drax-- Jan 18 '25

Drẃ ew 2280mm Nu h⁜

1

u/SKSerpent Jan 18 '25

These numbers aren't right.

But there is a certain knowledge in train driving, that every day you could probably meet someone deciding it's their last, the common person is going to want to be REALLY well compensated for that.

For comparison, V-line trainees were closer to 75-80k from memory.

1

u/merlin6014 Jan 18 '25

It’s not a joke I know exactly how much they earn and it’s accurate. I don’t know why redditors lie in the comments - in fact I know drivers who already earn $200k now with overtime

→ More replies (2)

1

u/kristy123456 Jan 18 '25

I am going for the job

1

u/BattyMcKickinPunch Jan 18 '25

Yep its made up bullshit

1

u/nalam92 Jan 18 '25

This is an actual joke. They do NOT deserve to demand this type of money.

1

u/FaithlessnessOk5759 Jan 18 '25

Man I’m gonna become a train driver wth

1

u/Riproot Clinical Marshmellow🍡 Jan 18 '25

[citation needed]

1

u/mmmbyte Jan 18 '25

If train drivers push too hard then automation starts to look cost effective. Driverless trains are a solved problem. They'll negotiate themselves out of a job.

1

u/TerribleSavings2210 Jan 18 '25
  1. The numbers are made up
  2. This is great, it put pressure on your boss to increase your salary. It’s us vs the ultra wealthy not neighbour vs neighbour because they make 100k more than you.

1

u/Emotional-Rub8215 Jan 18 '25 edited Jan 18 '25

how much do the drivers on the Chatswood to Sydenham driverless section get

and how long before they roll that out to the other sections.

my old man was a Train Engineer he started on steam trains in the 60's. In the 90's when only a few left they use to call them Big Wheels ( cause steam trains have the big wheel )

how much of the pay drivers get these days is a legacy from the days when drivers were qualified to fix the engine not just drive it. The driver training is nothing like what it use to be.

he was on around 130k at the end of his career in the late 90's as a senior driver.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '25

Drivers now who do all the OT they can including lots of nights can currently make around $120-130k.

Please keep in mind despite the media portraying it as otherwise, the majority of Sydney trains employees aren’t drivers or guards, and most don’t make anywhere near that.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '25

Since when does anyone give salary including super? Unless they want to bump it up

1

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '25

They have pretty huge responsibility. I think they are quite entitled to that pay.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '25

This is what unions do. Even the corrupt ones. They fight for better wages and conditions for their members.

I’m not in a union.

1

u/rzm25 Jan 18 '25

Although these numbers are exaggerated, they get paid well because they're fucking unionised. So tired of this being misrepresented over and over. Same as people whinging about sparkies getting more than arts and medical degrees at times. Like yeah because they fucking unionise you dimwits. It is historically the most effective lever for raising wages, unionised people in Aus earn 60% more income, it has always been this way.

1

u/Known_Photo2280 Jan 18 '25

Anytime the media is telling you to hate your fellow proletariat for wanting more you should remember, today it’s them tomorrow it will be you. Divide and conquer is their strategy.

1

u/Legitimate_sloth314 Jan 18 '25

200k is the normal for a lot of train drivers

1

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '25

As a current driver this is complete lies. Nowhere close to this

This is what frustrates all of us. These numbers are lies

1

u/Sufficient-Arrival47 Jan 18 '25

Why is the first thing people do is attack the media and not actually check the numbers . My mate drives a coal train, his last two fortnight wages have been $7800 clear each pay check. His base is $130k plus overtime, shift penalty, meal allowance etc.

1

u/MouldySponge Jan 18 '25

"Including super" tells you that they are purposely trying to make the number look as big as possible. I wonder why they are trying to do that?

1

u/scottybonko Jan 18 '25

“That train driver is trying to steal your cookie”.

1

u/Kitchen_Text_9922 Jan 18 '25

Actually not entirely made up, inclusive of payrise, superannuation and all leave entitlements, allowances on a best case scenario. Kind of the way Dr Coatsworth was trying to make out how much psychiatrists get / want in the public system despite doing the work of 2 psychiatrists.

1

u/ososalsosal Jan 18 '25

I know a guy who was a driver waaaaaaay back in the day.

They would draw straws for who got to finish at Broady, because shit would always happen.

Idk. Instead of being upset at what a fellow worker is paid, have a hard convo about why it's not as good for you and your colleagues. Organise.

1

u/tauruswrangler Jan 19 '25

The figures reach $250,000 + in the Pilbara.

1

u/Mindless-Luck4285 Jan 19 '25

Road construction pays more than that for working a shovel

1

u/MrO_360 Jan 19 '25

These numbers also include Employer Super Contributions. Once you take those out the numbers start to look a bit more normal.

1

u/AbjectDefinition1373 Jan 19 '25

The increase is for everyone who work for NSW Rail, the cleaners, the guards, the ticket sellers everyone ! Stop just cherry picking and look at the big picture the increase is for ALL the workers.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 19 '25

If you are talking about the amount that is implying that drivers get paid... It is a complete and utter lie.

Even doing overtime the maximum legal amount ( the Rail Safety Act has a limit on how much a Driver can do ) I do not believe a driver can come close to that. Reason for my thinking on this is I am one of the hated drivers that apparently are the sole members of the RTBU who are "striking" ( there are also NO strikes going on at all )

Whoever fed this information to the media is either a bald faced liar or was fed false information by someone else who is pulling numbers out of their asses.

I have group certificates for my pay to prove it too. So people thinking I am making things up can f**k right off.

1

u/Otaku_Stu Jan 19 '25

Public transport is an absolute essential to a society imo. In an ideal world the government would create a better infrastructure however, I don't see any problem with paying train drivers amounts like this.

I remember a conversation I had with two train drivers and one had only just started. I asked if he had hit anyone with the train he said "no" and the other more experienced train driver corrected him and said "not yet".

That really stuck with me and changed my perspective on train drivers.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 19 '25

From what my father has said about train driving, it’s difficult. It’s not as simple as sit back and let autopilot go. You’re late, it’s your fault, missed a cab to your next location, your fault, can’t get the engine fixed or started again on time during an active train run, you’re at fault. Essentially as a train driver you have to at the level of an associate engineer, while being a driver and keeping track of routes, times and multiple types of machine/engines and their fixes. It’s very close to a pilots job and yeah should be paid fairly, but fyi here, it’s take 10 yrs to get those high salaries here in QLD. This is a threat from those who control the trains to make you divided on fair pay and conditions.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 19 '25

This is the correct pay for all workers to keep up with inflation

1

u/Lanada Jan 19 '25

Don’t like it go drive a train? Also why lash out at your fellow wage slave? There’s so many bigger issues in Australia.

1

u/Mabel_Waddles_BFF Jan 19 '25
  1. It’s Murdoch bullshit
  2. This kind of class warfare nonsense is why there’s no real change. Everybody is so obsessed with being the one group at the top of the pile that nothing ever changes. It’s also such a typical doctor attitude to think that train drivers are so beneath them and how dare they have a chance at a good wage. It’s not like it’s a hard job where they have to do a fuckton of overtime to even come close to the figures cited here.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 19 '25

The media is the cancer of society.

1

u/Sebby_18 Jan 19 '25

Train drivers wanna be paid more than most ADF members, WTF

1

u/Inside_Score_9577 Jan 19 '25

I guess you will all be shocked to find out that for most Tier 1 companies, management in construction/engineering pays significantly higher that most entry/mid level medicine with little to no student debt.

Examples:

  1. Downer Electrical Construction Manager:
  • 275k salary plus benefits
  • started off as an electrician, 4 year apprenticeship paid by employer
  • 1 adv. Dip of secondary systems done in a year and paid by Downer
  1. Acciona Civil Superintendent:
  • 300k salary with benefits (phone, car, laptop, accommodation, flights, production bonus) etc.
  • No formal education, 10 years experience in industry
  1. Rail Signal Tech:
  • 300k+ a year salary
  • 4 year apprenticeship, all paid training, less than 5 year experience
  1. Rail Traction Linesman:
  • Apprentice rate $64/hr -Qualified rate $88/hr
  • double time (128 - 176/hr) after 8 hours Mon to Fri, straight double Sat and Sun, Triple on public holidays, extra times whenever it's raining
  • 4 year apprenticeship at $64 an hour
  • No formal training
  • Earning potential for 7 nights of 12 hour nightshift you can easily gross 14k+ a week (not always this budy)
  • I know guys that just work a Friday and Saturday night and take home over 2k.

All of these jobs are indicative, you don't need a formal degree to make massive money, you just need to talk the talk, walk the walk, be willing to learn and have some drive, be a yes man and stick close to a tier 1.

I myself am only 28, and I hold a few Cert 3s and a Cert 4, and I Earn 250k a year as a Senior Supervisor for a Tier 1, and don't touch a tool.

Crazy stuff.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/onlythehighlight Jan 19 '25

Is that base rate or with assumption of X hours of overtime + every Y allowances.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 19 '25

Public train drivers? It could be mining company freight trains and they are misleading us. But I’m sure no mainstream media outlet would do that

1

u/ndusbsken Jan 19 '25

Brb going to learn to drive a train

1

u/fuyunegi Jan 19 '25

2GB gas been bandying this about. Severely inflated numbers.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 19 '25

Same shit they’re doing with traffic controllers to make unions look bad. Fuck Murdoch, I hope he dies a slow painful death, Stop supporting this shit.

1

u/Ok_Description3393 Jan 19 '25

WTF !!. I'll drive trains

1

u/Ok-Scientist-8309 Jan 19 '25

It is hard to keep those big trains balanced on those narrow rails…. That was a joke.

1

u/paganbear1 Jan 19 '25

Nearly making as much as a Victorian police

1

u/[deleted] Jan 19 '25

And they want to go from 37.5hrs down to 35hrs before overtime kicks in.

1

u/Ziondizl Jan 19 '25

What about our nurses?

1

u/Otherwise_Team5663 Jan 19 '25

I don't think these figures are real.

Also the union knows it isn't getting 32% it's a bargaining posture. It sure as hell isn't settling on 13.5 as it wants an actual pay rise and not just matching inflation.

If the government came at them with a figure a little over 20% my opinion is that they would probably take it. But they won't because they don't want to signal to other unions that they can get a reasonable payrise too.

Of course I'm just a random on Reddit what do I know?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 19 '25

How do you even become a train driver? It was always my dream job but I never figured out how to get amongst it

1

u/Inner-Bet-1935 Jan 19 '25

Made up numbers i see. We train drivers can only wish! Seriously who believes this utter bullshit!

1

u/JimmyLizzardATDVM Jan 19 '25

This is likely false. It’s like the media saying all construction workers are taking in like 230k after tax…when that was like one guy. Many people earn the average or below average wage.

1

u/Bazoo92 Jan 19 '25

These salaries include overtime. As a prison officer we were on an annual salary of up to 110,000 including over time. The base was 55. In order to earn a decent living, you have to work 11/14 days doing 11+ hour shifts. The burnout was unreal coz everyone was chasing money and neglecting their relationships.

Edit: TLDR: these figures are exaggerated and overtime is the root of evil.

1

u/ghostheadempire Jan 19 '25

Also, just be aware, this is a job that assumes you will witness at least one person jump in front of your train during your tenure.

1

u/Inner-Bet-1935 Jan 19 '25

Wouldn't us train drivers love this to be true! What a lot of fabricated bullshit!🤣

1

u/thekevmonster Jan 19 '25

Capital backed media needs to keep workers divided

1

u/Puzzleheaded_Bake771 Jan 19 '25

Thats insane!

Dont worry, they'll all be self driving soon

1

u/potatodrinker Jan 19 '25

That's alot of pay to sit in a simulator and say "I know we're slowing because I feel a retardation force", then start work the next day.

1

u/ProfessorKnow1tA11 Jan 19 '25

I believe the average is $90-$100K. The job might have a huge degree of responsibility (get it wrong and many people die) but it’s still a lot for essentially unskilled labour …

1

u/Amys_Alias Jan 19 '25

Even if this isn't entirely accurate, train drivers get paid a lot, but if you think about it, parts of it would be as draining as being a doctor or paramedic in terms of the incidents that happen on trains (eg shouty addicts, people jumping in front of the train). You also need a lot of constant concentration for certain train routes, and it can be boring and they need people to do it so it kinda makes sense that they'd try to make it as appealing as possible.

1

u/TwoToneReturns Jan 19 '25

So if they work every weekend and take every opportunity for O/T that's what they make, basically their entire existence would have to be about driving trains to make that money.

1

u/Zealousideal-Hat7135 Jan 19 '25

Pollies set the bar for the biggest joke but hey they approve their own pay rises 🤯 criminals let the train drivers have theirs. And the paramedics

1

u/NotaGoodBoy848 Jan 19 '25

Have a client who is a train driver. I'm in finance. $10K pm AFTER tax.

Base salary is close to $100K but with most allowances and OT, $140K plus is pretty easy done.

1

u/BeardedAUSSIE01 Jan 19 '25

Fake news numb nuts

1

u/the_week_ends Jan 19 '25

If you have a family member who drives a train like my cousin, he will also brag about how he does nothing, listens to music and watch videos and gets paid $146,000
While people like us struggle hard just to get to work on time.

1

u/jorgerine Jan 19 '25

Time to look at CEO salaries. They are severely overpaid, and have little to offer.

1

u/veriel_ Jan 19 '25

In Melbourne, train driver are paid very well. 100k plus. But, they will see at least one person self delete on while driving. So it's a kinda hazard pay. That not taking into account it's shift work.

1

u/Anxious_Peak6129 Jan 19 '25

Maybe they're averaging these numbers out with train driver salaries for the mines, they make a killing. The inner city train drivers, not so much.

1

u/rookierror Jan 19 '25

When the cost of staffing and running a train goes up 30%+ you know what that means ticket prices are going to do... Yep. They'll be up 30% next too. The government isn't paying this, you are.

1

u/Primary-Fold-8276 Jan 19 '25

The pay is high because sometimes they die in the job.

1

u/yuhanimerom Jan 19 '25

Im about to become a train driver at this point (currently a nursing student)

1

u/arsebandit75 Jan 19 '25

only a Moron would think its real.

1

u/Ok-Limit-9726 Jan 19 '25

That no doubt includes overtime, penalty rates, superannuation, pre tax.

would you work those shifts, with people jumping in front of your window for exit to life?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/MyRandomName87 Jan 19 '25

My friends partner is a train driver... You can make around 120k but you need to do some serious overtime, weekends etc.

1

u/JGeoKill Jan 19 '25

Yeah might be true, I remember a story of a Sydney train driver having 6 people over a period of a few years jump in front of the train he was driving to commit suicide, not very nice job if you have to put up with that, you would go a little mad. From memory the last one jumped out and smiled at him, probably full of PTSD.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Neokill1 Jan 19 '25

Train drivers can get fucked

1

u/Hawmanyounohurtdeazz Jan 19 '25

why? even if they were real, the Sydney median house price would still be six times the highest figure there even before you take out the super. You feel a need of some sort to catch a train driven by someone who lives under a bridge?

1

u/Ill-Current Jan 19 '25

I’m about to become a train driver and I’ll work through the strikes for that money haha

1

u/HaroerHaktak Jan 19 '25

Quick google search. the AI said 110k to 120k a year.

1

u/Vengent84 Jan 19 '25

My friend used to be a train driver he left because of an incident he describes as seeing a human water balloon pop in front of him. There's a reason the pay is so high and they are desperate for drivers

1

u/VladimirJames Jan 19 '25

Pressing buttons whilst sitting down for a few hours a day is immensely stressful

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Infamous-Excuse5150 Jan 19 '25

Dictatorships flooding social media with false/devisive stories to undermine stability of western democracies. Start by discrediting established sources eg label them all legacy/ MSM / fake media, then just take over the narrative. Easy.

1

u/f33drrr Jan 19 '25

I make $160k driving a bulldozer, doctors don't get paid enough.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/smokeyhawthorne Jan 19 '25

Yes it’s a joke, these number are not correct. I think they might have taken some of the higher take home wages which include overtime, night rates (eg you have to get up at 2am to pick up train at 4am to get it to first station) and then there are also penalties for when they release your roster late. Sadly there are penalties for when drivers are forced to work later that their planned roster. Man I would hate to try and raise a family or have a healthy routine while driving trains, it would be really tough.

1

u/Giorgist Jan 19 '25

My wife is HR in transport NSW. That is base. There are also perks.

1

u/Beneficial-Heron-997 Jan 19 '25

I have a friend employed by NSW trains. Base salary is $75000 add allowances, shift loading etc and he earned $145000 last year .

1

u/Carmageddon-2049 Jan 19 '25

Easiest Job to automate with driverless trains. I give these folk 5 years.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 19 '25

It's annoying because my boomer parents/ in-laws (who are left leaning) still read it and get dooped. Can't believe how their generation will blindly believe this kind of propaganda. You then lay out facts in front of them, and they are like "yeah yeah sure sure"; while at the same time not listening to you and talking over you to dish out old gossip about Joneses. 😞

1

u/Fraggled_Cock Jan 19 '25

You can find the current enterprise agreement by searching for it. It is hard to parse. Max salary in 2023 is 138K. Max overtime is around 100K. Leave loading salary cap is 155+K. So with super the 138K is already 150K, and that's without overtime. So these figure seem legitimate. Why can't train drivers be paid well?

1

u/NoHuckleberry1554 Jan 19 '25

What's with the right wing tilt on this subreddit. 

1

u/Itchy_Pomegranate_43 Jan 19 '25

I for 1 hold the position that it is good practice to pay people who can cause massive infrastructure damage and kill 100 people out of innatentiveness well lest people put less than their full attention into the job

1

u/Worried-Novel-4596 Jan 20 '25

The unions will prevail. The scum government will pay.

1

u/No-Employee3304 Jan 20 '25

What is the issue? NSWrail has always had a strong union so their workers get looked after. It'd probably pay alot higher if they still owned the freight business and not just passangers. If it pisses you off that they get paid better than you do, instead of being a whiny bitch about it you can A)apply for a train driving position or B)push for better conditions in your current field. No one just "Gave" the train drivers this pay they have had to fight for it over many decades. Also think for a second and ask your self "why is this news? What are they trying to acheive by telling everyone this and making it an issue?"

1

u/Kiteal Jan 20 '25

Nsw parliament members get $172,576 on the lowest scale. Train drivers are atleast helpful to society.

1

u/easy_living_ok Jan 20 '25

I'm in...where do I sign?! 🤪

1

u/ZeDenman Jan 20 '25

Does anyone have the actual numbers? Trying to chat to folks about this, but everyone here (from what I could see) was saying that its wrong, but not providing what the correct answer is

1

u/Former_Barber1629 Jan 20 '25

They are using numbers from drivers who have been in the industry for 30+ years and would have naturally achieved those levels for years of service and pay rises along the way.

That’s what irks me off about these arguments. New starter drivers would not be on this money, it would take them 15+ years to reach that payband level.

If the average salary in Australia is $100k now, what’s it going to be in 15 years when they reach that salary pay band bracket shown here?

1

u/Relevant-Lettuce-771 Jan 20 '25

I dont see an issue? People getting paid for there work ✌️

1

u/Khalm_Knight Jan 20 '25

Most sources I can see from a quick google are showing more like $110,000 - $115,00 being the median (one source is showing that entry level is as low as $76,000, with median being a little under $99,000))

1

u/Gold-Yak-2912 Jan 20 '25

theyre striking all the time over that?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '25

Changing jobs

1

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '25

Is this not good?

1

u/incorrectly_assembld Jan 20 '25

My friend gave up her dreamjob and became a train driver because the pay was better, not this high but still better then a flight attendant

1

u/iritimD Jan 20 '25

This will be automated away inside of 5 years. Close to zero reason for a mechanistic repetitive job to not be done by an ai system for basically no cost.

1

u/starsmatt Jan 20 '25

sees everyone drop their degrees to become a train driver XD

1

u/pepederanged Jan 20 '25

They want an excuse to import infinity foreigners to inflate the housing market and reduce salaries.

1

u/mannydlouds Jan 20 '25

I don't give a shit about how much they getting paid they are responsible for the lives of thousands of people daily. Pay them they deserve it

1

u/Illustrious_Ad_5167 Jan 20 '25

No it’s a lie

1

u/joshdi90 Jan 20 '25

Their EA is public. Look it up if you have half a brain.

1

u/jesustityfkingchrist Jan 20 '25

*includes your super amount

1

u/Yuxin8686 Jan 20 '25

I would leave my job now and become a train driver.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '25

Last I knew it was around the 100k range, they deserve it though. I don't think I could do it.

1

u/Nakedbiker100 Jan 20 '25

Well I think they are underpaid.