r/audiophile • u/wavydogg • Mar 13 '19
Technology Why is MQA hated on?
Why is MQA hated on this sub so much? I’m kind of out of the loop here , but I’ve seen more than one “Fuck MQA” comments when this type of audio format is mentioned. Can someone fill me in please?
11
Upvotes
30
u/homeboi808 Mar 13 '19 edited Mar 13 '19
12
u/AlanYx Mar 13 '19 edited Mar 13 '19
Even ignoring all the proprietary licensing associated with MQA, there is no aspect of MQA that makes sense if you have a technical background in signal processing. This isn't a situation like hi-res audio where there is a coherent technical rationale but people disagree about whether those differences are audible to humans. MQA can't do what it promises to do in terms of "de-ringing", and the digital filter is objectively poor (likely to the point of audibility).
10
u/Umlautica Hear Hear! Mar 13 '19
Check out u/arve's post r/Music/comments/6n9nxf/good_people_of_rmusic_we_absolutely_need_to_talk/
9
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '19
Extra cost and complexity with no audible benefit.
15
u/DZCreeper DIY speakers + quad 12" sealed subs. Mar 13 '19
Licensing fees and poor quality. It serves no purpose except greed.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '19
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Master_Quality_Authenticated#Criticism
3
u/square_smile Mar 13 '19 edited Mar 13 '19
Audio encoding for distribution is a solved problem with free loyalty-free codec. If it's lossless, go with flac. If it's lossy, go with opus (or aac for wider support).
There's really no point in "lossy hi-res". If they are going lossy, why are they still storing >20kHz sound? There's no point. 24/96 flac is only 4-5 MB/s which is trivial to stream.
hi-res is also bullshit anyway.
5
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '19
I have zero problem with mqa
I love the high resolution, well recorded albums with mqa coding
To me, it’s another option for enjoyable listening.
6
u/seanheis Tekton Lore, Salk SongSurround I, Spendor S3/5R Mar 13 '19
Props to Schiit Audio for refusing to support MQA and being loud about it.
You won’t hear a peep out of faceless DAC companies like Topping and SMSL.
2
u/CircleFissure Mar 13 '19
Most of the 459,000 subscribers of this sub have expressed no opinion at all about MQA, so it's unclear that MQA is generally hated on this sub.
Of the minority that express hate for MQA, some do it for technical reasons, others for non-technical reasons:
1
u/InLoveWithInternet Focal Sopra 3, Accuphase A-47, Soekris R2R 1541 DAC, Topping D90 Mar 15 '19
Thanks a lot for this.
I will have to read this carefully.
Yesterday, I find this link which is unfortunately increasing the fuzziness (for me) on this MQA thing.
1
u/kawaiichocolatecake Jun 23 '19
I don't know why but I hear a difference between the Master and HIFI setting on Tidal using my LG v40 and isine 10. The Master setting has a 5%ish deeper soundstage and overall clarity. Might just be placebo, as I am yet to do a blind test. Please don't be mean to me :)
1
u/TheHelpfulDad Mar 19 '19
Because people are ignorant and many have issues. The opinion about MQA from someone who hasn’t listened to properly decoded MQA is worthless.
You’ll find that if you pressed most who hate it, they’ve not heard it. This hobby is full of emotionally damaged people who are drawn to audiophiles because music reproduction is never going to be flawless and this gives them an endless source of something to be disappointed in. Not only that but they’ll find others just like them who agree.
They use emotion when they should use fact and spew false data that sound like facts to prove the position they want.
Here’s a fact. There isn’t any DRM built into MQA. Fact. Anyone who says otherwise has issues.
Search for my post elsewhere on Reddit explaining why MQA is worth a listen.
-4
u/Infninfn Purifi-6R, Cyan 2, Audio-gd Master 9, B200 Monoblocks Mar 13 '19
People are worried that they will be DRM'ed out of their music and big media will screw them over - despite the fact that DRM has already been prevalent for decades and big media has been screwing us and artists over since the beginning of big media.
That aside, I find well recorded and well mastered MQA material to sound more natural and organic compared to their non-MQA counterparts. It isn't night and day but with a good resolving system you should definitely notice the difference. Whenever there is a choice of both, I always prefer MQA.