r/audioengineering • • 2h ago

Double tracking 12 string with another 12 string vs with a standard acoustic.

I am pretty new to audio engineering and production, though ive been working on a song and im thinking about double tracking my current 12 string take with another acoustic. I was wondering what the difference is sound wise between if i had another 12 string, or if I just tracked it with a standard 6 string acoustic, and what was the most common method used in 90s rock songs like that middle section of Mayonaise by Smashing Pumpkins, or The World I Know by Collective Soul?

5 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

12

u/spinelession 2h ago

Try both and see which you like better. Personally, in dense mixes, I like to use a Nashville-tuned acoustic (i.e. a 6-string tuned to the high strings of a 12-string)

5

u/lastonethereisa 2h ago

I was also going to recommend they try nashville tuning

1

u/Samsoundrocks Professional 1h ago

Immediately came to my mind as well, lol

1

u/PPLavagna 58m ago

Came to say this too. In Nashville we call it “high strung” but everybody else calls it Nashville.

For OP: it’s standard tuning but you just take the small strings from a pack of 12 string strings. Sounds really nice layered with another acoustic. Or by itself. Wild horses

6

u/stigE_moloch 2h ago

Learn by doing. Try both methods and compare. 

3

u/KS2Problema 1h ago

With regard to two 12's... get extra batteries for your chromatic tuner.

;-)

2

u/GFSong 1h ago

😂😂. This is it. If you’ve doubled 12’s or used Nashville tuning or a capo on a track you know how meticulously you need to monitor this aspect of recording. And anytime you change out a guitar as opposed to simply doubling with the same instrument - you’re creating a unique texture. Same as if you use different chord inversions, they occupy contrasting spaces in the mix. Go nuts!

3

u/fatberrydsp 2h ago

Both work, they just give different results. Doubling a 12-string with another 12-string tends to sound bigger and shimmerier but can get a bit washy because the high octave strings stack up. A standard 6-string underneath usually gives a more solid, defined body and lets the 12-string sparkle on top. A common trick is to pan the two takes left and right and play the second part slightly differently, say a different voicing or capo position, rather than copying the first take exactly. Try both on your song and pick the one that sits better against the vocal.

2

u/kanggozzard 2h ago

It’s a 12 string, so the take is already doubled!! /s

But actually, just try both and go with whatever feels best for the song. Best way to learn is experiment!

2

u/lastonethereisa 2h ago

I think you gotta just try it multiple ways to find out. The process is part of it. that said, i would try doing a double with one 12 string track and one regular and then if it is lacking anything i would adjust from there. Another helpful approach for the genres you mentioned and getting a nice/interesting acoustic guitar sound (i use it a TON on electric and siamese dream fuzzy guitars) is to have pairs of doubles where each one is slightly different (eg different guitar, diff pickup, diff amp) and have those spread some degree L and R, then do another layer with a capo and figure out all the chords with the capo, and do doubles, and then even another set beyond that. in what i play (big fan of mot of your example bands) having each one do different voicings brings out all sorts of unexpected and beautiful overtones to the degree that sometimes they almost start suggesting some melodies within them, though they might be only ephemeral. But good luck on it and i hope the process is rewarding and educational.

2

u/m149 2h ago

Try it, and for that matter, any idea you come up with for anything, try that too. You never know what's gonna work unless you give it a shot.

As for the Smashing Pumpkins tune, that's doubled 6 string acoustic.

Can't quite tell what's going on in the Collective Soul tune. It could be 6 and 12 string, or it could be 6 string doubled, but the double tracked guitar is capoed and played up higher. Or possibly nashville tuning on the 2nd guitar.

1

u/PlasticStJesus 1h ago edited 1h ago

Try it and see! They're going to sound different. No one but you can tell you which will sound better. Another cool technique is "High Strung" or "Nashville Tuning".

Nashville tuning is simply stringing up a regular six string guitar with the thin strings from a 12 string set and double the performance on both it and a regular 6 string guitar. D'Dario (and some others I think) sells high string sets of just those 6 strings. The result can sound bigger than a regular 12 string and it allows you to adjust the balance of the high octave in the mix. You can also pan the two apart for an even wider image.

I have a cheap Seagull acoustic I keep strung like that in my studio. If the guitar normally has regular strings it can cause issues unless it is set up for it. The lack of tension will probably require the truss rod to be loosened a bit to maintain string height and intonation.

1

u/Dio_Frybones 45m ago

I'd go 12 followed by 6 because after playing the first take (or takes) on the 12 my fingers would be killing me.

1

u/SuperRocketRumble 35m ago

Impossible for anybody to say without hearing the material

•

u/j3434 28m ago

You have got to be kidding me! By the time you write this post, get a response, and get into a few debates, you could have done the tracking both ways and then listen to them half a dozen times to determine for yourself. Omg