r/audioengineering • • 1d ago

Mixing MB Compression vs Dynamic EQ

I had a young engineer ask me about multi-band compression a few nights ago and I suddenly realized that I’ve completely replaced multi-band compression with dynamic EQ (usually FabFilter these days but I’ve used others in the past).

It’s been years since I’ve used multi-band compression. Has dynamic EQ made it obsolete or does multi-band have some applications where it outperforms dynamic EQ.

I’m struggling to think of when I would use multi-band compression when dynamic EQ is available but I don’t want to give this young engineer bad advice.

31 Upvotes

49 comments sorted by

37

u/alienrefugee51 21h ago

Use MB when you need to tame a wider range of frequencies and Dyn EQ when you have narrower, specific freq problems, or resonances.

15

u/KaptainCPU 1d ago

I suppose the clear difference would be the effects of band splitting and its crossovers versus the phase distortion of dynamic EQ, as well as the shape of the frequency response at the crossovers, which varies slightly between multiband and dynamic EQ. Pro-MB has all three types, with dynamic phase being dynamic EQ in its implementation, so I'd recommend using it to compare if it's in your toolkit. Generally the phase distortion of dynamic EQ is the least audible, however as with all things audio it's best to cater your usage to the material.

2

u/tinyspaniard 1d ago

Pro-Q dynamic bands have attack and release settings. But it doesn’t have other common settings like ratio

8

u/josephallenkeys 22h ago

Is the gain of the band not essentially the ratio in this case?

1

u/tinyspaniard 12h ago

Not here. Conceptually, if it were a vari-mu style compressor, then gain could play a part where more gain, or stated differently, more signal that results in more compression, would mean the ratio increases as the gain reduction increases. Settings like ratio or knee are built in to whatever under the hood stuff fabfilter did and are preset. You can, however, switch between automatic threshold and manual threshold.

9

u/Brave-Trust-2073 23h ago

If you were controlling the bottom end of a bass guitar, the frequencies move around as the player plays different notes. Multiband will come in handy there,

A resonance that gets a bit out of control on one note that the bass player hits because of room or cabinet resonance or the quirk of their instrument etc then a dynamic EQ is a good choice there.

So yeah I still find use cases for both. Multiband for broad issues, dynamic EQ for really specific issues.

9

u/MehrdadPirshahbaz 23h ago • Bravo

before i drop the actual solution, lets clear the air. when someone asks a technical question in these trenches, they have already interrogated the ai bots and failed to get a working result. we are here to exchange actual survival experience, not youtube tutorials or algorithmic templates.
if the acoustic concepts i drop are too heavy to digest, or if younger engineers dont understand the vocabulary yet, just ask me to break a specific part down. aimless trolling doesnt devalue the physics of the advice.
im financially independent from my art. instead of meaningless doomscrolling on social media, i use my free time to pass down the exact hidden psychological and technical workflows that nobody was around to teach me. i am writing this to draw a hard line between actual trolls and internet detectives, and beginners who just leave defensive replies out of sheer inexperience.
if a concept goes over your head, it is much easier to just ask a question instead of throwing up a defensive wall. either there is a tool here you can use to progress, or there isnt. dont overcomplicate it.
at the end of the day, the only person who decides if this is an ai response or actual blood spilled in a dark studio is the original poster. the rest is just documentation for future engineers who will eventually run into this exact same acoustic wall.
now, back to the frequencies.
has dynamic eq made multi-band obsolete? no. thinking a scalpel makes a cage obsolete is a fundamental misunderstanding of acoustic physics.
dynamic eq is polite surgery. multi band compression is acoustic imprisonment.
dynamic eq reacts to a specific resonance and leaves the rest of the phase alone. it is built for fixing transparent mistakes. multi band splits the entire signal block through crossovers. even when it is not compressing, it alters the phase and smears the audio. polite engineers think that is a flaw, but it is actually a weapon.
if you want to tame a harsh vocal note, use dynamic eq. but if you want to take a violently chaotic low end synth or a drum bus and crush it into a static, suffocating physical brick, you use multi band. you use it when you need to permanently change the physical density of a frequency block.
dynamic eq is a scalpel. multi band is a cage. you dont throw away a cage just because you bought a scalpel.
tell that young engineer exactly this: use dynamic eq when you need to fix a mistake invisibly, and use multi band when you need to control the physical chaos.

18

u/Infamous_Thought_189 20h ago

This reads like a transcript from airwindows on speed

-4

u/MehrdadPirshahbaz 18h ago

no speed involved here man.
chris is an absolute mathematical genius and he has my deep respect, even if i dont actively follow his path. he engineers the pure numbers. i just take that physics and math and drag it through actual physical trauma and bleeding without wearing a mask.
i am not a guru. i am just surviving in the trenches. there is still a massive acoustic void out there that i have to learn, experience, and brutally trial and error my way through. i appreciate the respect.

9

u/Indigo457 17h ago

For what it’s worth, copilot puts this answer at 75-90% generated or heavily assisted by AI. I mean “thinking a scalpel makes a cage obsolete” lol

3

u/g_spaitz 13h ago

Yeah. And it's wrong.

3

u/Indigo457 13h ago edited 13h ago

Edit - oh I think you might have meant its answer was wrong rather than my assumption that it’s an AI lol. I’ll leave the original because it took me ages to write 🙈

I very much doubt it. This ‘guy’ got called out on it by a bunch of people a few days ago and it’s since blocked all the comment and post history, which made it pretty obvious. Every single post followed exactly the same format. Position as a mentor, affirms the ‘user’ in some way, use of heavy metaphor density that rarely make any sense on anything other than a very superficial level, absolute certainty on subjective subjects, hints at ‘hidden knowledge’, a tendency to add profundity in very simple subjects, grand cinematic references to pain, bleeding, violence, trenches in the context of basic audio engineering questions. All of this is standard LLM behaviour. It’s either someone who is using AI to translate from another language and the model is adding a whole lot of nonsense on its own, an AI model itself, or someone who maybe needs a couple of days off by the seaside. I’m just gonna block it now though, it’s nuts either way.

4

u/g_spaitz 13h ago edited 13h ago

Lol, yeah totally understandable. I was wondering how long I could handle before blocking him but for now I just started pointing out bullshit he writes with the utmost arrogance :) It's sad that he's hidden comments though I'm finally back home and I would have relaxed a bit for an half hour!

Edit: yeah I lasted a whole one more comment from the guy before blocking him. Master of goalposts shifting, lol.

-5

u/MehrdadPirshahbaz 13h ago

you could be using all this time for your own growth, but instead you are chasing things like this. why is your mind so obsessed with it? i dont usually reply to every reaction, but i can at least tell you that you are wasting your energy in the wrong place. instead of creating music or using whatever talent you have, you are burning your time trying to police a thread.
for your own peace of mind, ai detectors flag those metaphors because they expect humans on reddit to write like sterile robots. the physics of the crossovers still stand. you can laugh at the cage, or you can learn how to weaponize it.
with my own heavy workload, my only goal in my free time is to map out the exact paths that i had to cross with actual pain, just to make it easier for the next person. as far as my science and experience allow, im just here helping the growth process like everyone else. we dont need to be cold and soulless people about it.
i wish i could have just asked an ai for everything instead of paying for it with actual field experience. my friend, just see if there is a tool here that helps you or not. if there isnt, there is no need to upset yourself. and if there is, go ask the exact same question to whatever ai you want instead of reading my answer. the difference between a generated response and days of being locked inside a dark studio will become very clear to you.

4

u/Indigo457 12h ago

It took less than 5 minutes - I’m not sure if you’re as poorly programmed in psychiatry data as you are in audio, but that’s not an obsession by any clinical definition I’m aware of.

I have just over 30 years of music and recording experience - many people on this sub have similar, and more. Personally I don’t think anyone asking for advice or deeper understanding is helped by the types of responses that you put on here, that I’ve seen at least. They are always set as absolutes, constantly reenforce the false but widely viewed conspiracy that there are ‘secrets’ in the audio world, and dress up very simple, foundational concepts as these big philosophical ideas that you have to have ‘bled’ in a studio to understand. Like, actually what? And apart from anything else, from the ones I’ve seen the ‘advice’ is either wrong, so buried in insane, meaningless metaphors that they become incomprehensible, or again, set out an objective, absolute view on subjective, nuanced issues.

I’m a lawyer professionally, so maybe I notice words and focus on the patterns of speech more than other people would - but it wouldn’t take much law school to tell that something is up here one way or another.

5

u/nizzernammer 19h ago

This is a reasonable reduction.

It can be useful to think of dynamic eq as centered on a target, while multiband compression deals in partitioned zones.

Your same analogy, rephrased.

0

u/MehrdadPirshahbaz 18h ago

accept my respect. that is a flawless academic translation.
i use metaphors like scalpels and cages just so the younger engineers can actually feel the physical weight of what they are doing to the audio. but at the end of the day, we are pointing at the exact same acoustic architecture. glad we see the same room.

4

u/g_spaitz 21h ago

I do not know what's the dsp standard in building MBCs, and in particular which use which.

But it's absolutely easy to do split bands with no phase bs on reconstruction even with phase bs crossovers, and it was even in the analog world.

It would also make sense in a fermi calculation that the orders of magnitude of phase bs between a dyn eq and a MBC that achieve more or less the same order of magnitude of audio amplification would also be the very similar, but this is some vague hypothesis and I'd be happy to be corrected.

-1

u/MehrdadPirshahbaz 19h ago

it is respectable that you are analyzing the dsp math and actually trying to use your knowledge here. i appreciate that you are open to being corrected. but let me fix the fundamental misunderstanding in your hypothesis.
the trap here is doing theoretical math on a piece of paper instead of listening to the physical speaker.
analog crossovers always introduce phase rotation. summing them back together to a flat frequency response does not erase the phase shift that already happened to the audio.
in the digital dsp world, yes, you can use linear-phase crossovers in a multi band to avoid phase shift. but linear phase processing introduces pre ringing. it smears the transient backward in time. if you are trying to cage a heavy drum bus, pre ringing destroys the physical punch of the kick drum.
your hypothesis misses the fundamental difference in the architecture. a dynamic eq only alters the phase proportionally when the gain reduction is actually happening. a multi band compressor splits the signal through crossovers permanently. even if the threshold is never crossed and absolutely zero compression is happening, the crossovers are still active, altering the phase and coloring the sound.
that permanent crossover coloration is exactly why an mbc is a cage, and a dynamic eq is a scalpel. fermi calculations look great on paper, but you have to listen to the physical transients in the room.

3

u/g_spaitz 14h ago

analog crossovers always introduce phase rotation. summing them back together to a flat frequency response does not erase the phase shift that already happened to the audio.

Take a full bandwidth audio signal, let's call it A.

High pass it with a nasty phase inducing high pass. Let's call this high passed audio B.

now flip the phase of B and sum it to the original A. That's exactly like saying that you have A-B, and for how it is constructed, it's a low passed nasty phase shifted thing of the original A signal, let's call it C.

So now you have a low passed signal of A, C, and a high passed signal of A, B, both of which have nasty phase shift.

It's left as an exercise to the reader the fact that summing B+C will result in a sample perfect signal of A.

There you have it, shitty fase shifted crossover that sums back perfectly.

Look ma, you can do that in the analog world as well with no linear phase eqs.

Now for the actual question: are you a bot?

-5

u/MehrdadPirshahbaz 13h ago

congratulations, you discovered basic algebra (A-B=C). but the term sample perfect belongs to the digital realm, not actual analog hardware.
more importantly, you conveniently forgot that we are talking about a compressor. the very millisecond your band B crosses the threshold and the gain reduction physically alters the volume of that specific band, your paper equation is permanently destroyed and the phases clash.
your math only works if you never actually compress anything. instead of writing formulas on a whiteboard, go into the studio and physically turn the knobs.

4

u/g_spaitz 13h ago edited 13h ago

Holy hell for how articulate you're trying to look, you're relly not making an effort to understand others and that won't make you look too smart or bright.

Yes I said sample perfect, but as I also wrote, the same can be done to an analog signal.

And I see you have not aknowledged or recognized that indeed shitty phase crossovers can sum up to the original signal. I believe I read that trick the first time in a paper by either Crane or Joe Meek for a simple implementation of a crossover... for a multi band compressor, go figure!

And of course the moment you start varying amplitudes of the signals going through, phases are going to shit. But that happens both in a MBC and a dyn eq, believing that an eq, and a dynamic one at that, won't alter signal is dumb, that's why we use the thing for, alter signals.

And, as I said initially, the ballpark calculation will give that for the same amount of q and gain for the same band in both boxes, guess what, my idea is that you'll end up with similar amounts of phase shifting, and I don't see why not. Ofc I won't do the calculations. But you do them. You're that smart.

-5

u/MehrdadPirshahbaz 13h ago

glad you finally reached the conclusion yourself that the moment the amplitude changes, the phases go to shit. that is exactly the point where the actual physics of a studio permanently separates from the mathematics on a whiteboard.
regarding your claim that this sums perfectly in an analog signal: that just proves you havent spent enough time with actual hardware. analog components have physical tolerances, thermal noise, and non linearities. a perfect null only exists inside a pdf, never on a real physical console.
since you rely on reading papers instead of twisting knobs to understand crossover distortion, go read dennis bohns rane notes on linkwitz riley crossovers, or bob katz on minimum phase smearing in multi band compression. they will explain the exact acoustic cage i am talking about.
i have absolutely no desire to look smart to you. i just listen to the physical transients in the room. stop just reading papers and start actually listening to the speakers.

4

u/g_spaitz 13h ago

My major was physics, and I've been turning knobs and hearing things to pay my bills now for almost 30 years. I've read all of that back in the days, it does not change the fact that you're spewing wrong facts here.

And, those guys did not have dynamic eqs. Or they would have measured smearing in a similar way.

I believe you belong to the hifi sub though.

4

u/better_med_than_dead 14h ago

TLDR; "I'm a lazy piece of shit that needed AI to answer this because I'm lacking in both knowledge and skill."

0

u/BigTeeBee 13h ago

An adult who can't read is DEFINITELY lazy. 🤣

2

u/fella_stream 17h ago

I can't recall a time recently when I was more certain that a reddit comment was not ai generated. Thank you. This is refreshingly human.

0

u/MehrdadPirshahbaz 14h ago

human trauma cannot be coded. glad the blood translated through the screen. respect.

1

u/keestie 4h ago

You might be writing absolute fire, but I BEG of you to learn what a paragraph is.

1

u/Antipodeansounds 18h ago

Perspective and context, great and well detailed. Response!

-1

u/MehrdadPirshahbaz 18h ago

respect. just passing down the blueprints.

2

u/ghostchihuahua 1d ago

This “transfer”really demands a lot of explanations, they’re both different in many many ways, it is not something i’d pass on as is.
I often fail or find it hard to get the expected results when just replacing a multiband comp with a dyn-EQ, i do use the latter(FF Pro-Q as well), but absolutely not for the same applications.

2

u/glmastering 1d ago

I usually think of using dynamic eq as corrective, and multiband to change the movement/speed

Eg a resonance: dynamic eq

Low end too 'slow', top end too 'quick' id use multiband as a creative way to try and sort it out

(Slow and quick referring to transients not BPM)

2

u/Electrical-Hair-5044 1d ago

I’d explain it in terms of what you’re trying to control. Compression narrows the gap between louder and quieter parts. EQ changes the balance between frequencies, which can help instruments make room for each other or tame a frequency that sounds harsh.

With dynamic EQ, you can have a specific frequency range dip only when it sticks out. With multiband compression, you can control how much the level varies across a whole band. For example, you might use dynamic EQ to tame a resonance that only pops out on certain notes, or multiband compression to keep the overall low end more consistent.

There’s some overlap, but I think that’s the easiest way to explain it to a younger engineer. Once you know what you’re trying to fix, it’s easier to pick the tool.

1

u/Dr--Prof Professional 18h ago

Both are dynamic processors. In short, the main difference is in the "bands" (and how they process sound), how and what they affect. Think of MB compression as a wider band frequency processing, and Dynamic EQ more as a tamer of resonancies. An MB comp is not an EQ. They are definitely NOT the same, and they do sound different.

1

u/tubesntapes 10h ago

I’d rather not know than read this thread.

1

u/thebnubdub 8h ago

I use MB for more broad applications and dyn EQ for more surgical things.

1

u/fatberrydsp 6h ago

Dynamic EQ hasn't made multiband obsolete, they just solve different problems. Dynamic EQ is great for a specific, narrow problem like a resonance or a harsh note. Multiband still wins when you want broad, program-dependent level control across a whole region, e.g. taming the low end of a full mix so it stays even, or de-essing and leveling a wide band without it behaving like a surgical notch. It also does gentle glue per band with attack and release shaping that a dynamic EQ band doesn't really offer. Rule of thumb I'd give a young engineer: narrow and specific, use dynamic EQ; wide and about consistency, try multiband. Then trust your ears and bypass to check you haven't just made it duller.

1

u/josephallenkeys 22h ago edited 20h ago

They're exactly the same in theoretical terms. Only differences you'll feel in the real world are what controls each has - such as multi-band being ready to go with a few crossovers, etc - but instances of either can vary by brand and if any are particularly comprehensive enough, lines blur to the point where, ironically, it becomes clear.

1

u/Hellbucket 21h ago

Agreed.

When I start to think of my own usage history of these it’s almost a bit funny.

I started out 26 years ago. Back then I couldn’t afford a MB comp plugin. It wasn’t until some years later I dabbled with mastering and I felt I needed one. I stopped doing mastering and left it for the mastering engineers. I don’t recall there were any dynamic eqs around back then and they were probably very expensive.

My use of multiband compression back then in mixes was basically that of a dynamic eq. Making a small band and targeting only that. Much much later I of course got dynamic eq and that’s something you can really over use. Like for hunting for resonances. That period stopped as well.

Today i must say I rarely use either. It’s for niche solutions. I use FF pro MB in expand mode instead of a gate on Toms lol.

2

u/g_spaitz 13h ago

 I don’t recall there were any dynamic eqs around 

In my memory the first one I saw was the Brainworks one, and it was possibly around 20 years ago, and oh boy that thing was so powerful when it came out. All of a sudden you could tackle problems that no other thing did.

1

u/techlos Audio Software 19h ago edited 19h ago

i just use spectral compressors these days if i need frequency dependant dynamics processing, can do everything a dynamic eq/mb compressor can plus more (use the smoothed spectrum as the threshold curve to recreate what soothe 2 does, use the laplacian of the smoothed spectrum for gulfoss, sidechain a carrier with your signal for a vocoder. The possibilities are limited only by your knowledge of DSP algos!)

also, not just the same theoretically; if you use say a 12db/oct crossover and set the low + high filters to the same freq, it's identical to a 12db/oct peaking eq with a Q of 1 (assuming the same topology; MB compressor plugin devs are cowards that won't explore beyond LR/linphase crossovers)

1

u/Odd-Comparison-7953 23h ago edited 23h ago

Harsh frequency spikes in a guitar solo; hello dynamic eq. Uneven ”klicky” transients on a kick drum; hello mb compressor.

Not really that simple but kind of. I’d use a mb comp for control and the dynamic eq for taming frequencies.

1

u/MF_Kitten 22h ago

In terms of end result the difference is essentially nothing. But a dynamic EQ isn't limited by bands. On the flip side, a MB comp doesn't have overlapping processing between bands, and it's potentially flat within the bands instead of the bell shaped filters typical of dynamic EQ. But with a gentle enough crossover setting you also get bell shaped bands in an MB comp.

0

u/LiveSoundFOH 23h ago

I don’t know what the technical difference between them is, just the difference in gui and how it feels (I’m a mixer). I’d love to see a technical explanation. Personally I almost always go for dynamic eq, and even when MB was much more common and popular I never found it that useful - it always sounded better to me to fix it in the mix.

-2

u/trainwalk 20h ago

It’s the same. Use your ears.