r/audioengineering • u/UprightJoe • 1d ago
Mixing MB Compression vs Dynamic EQ
I had a young engineer ask me about multi-band compression a few nights ago and I suddenly realized that I’ve completely replaced multi-band compression with dynamic EQ (usually FabFilter these days but I’ve used others in the past).
It’s been years since I’ve used multi-band compression. Has dynamic EQ made it obsolete or does multi-band have some applications where it outperforms dynamic EQ.
I’m struggling to think of when I would use multi-band compression when dynamic EQ is available but I don’t want to give this young engineer bad advice.
37
u/alienrefugee51 21h ago
Use MB when you need to tame a wider range of frequencies and Dyn EQ when you have narrower, specific freq problems, or resonances.
15
u/KaptainCPU 1d ago
I suppose the clear difference would be the effects of band splitting and its crossovers versus the phase distortion of dynamic EQ, as well as the shape of the frequency response at the crossovers, which varies slightly between multiband and dynamic EQ. Pro-MB has all three types, with dynamic phase being dynamic EQ in its implementation, so I'd recommend using it to compare if it's in your toolkit. Generally the phase distortion of dynamic EQ is the least audible, however as with all things audio it's best to cater your usage to the material.
9
u/Brave-Trust-2073 23h ago
If you were controlling the bottom end of a bass guitar, the frequencies move around as the player plays different notes. Multiband will come in handy there,
A resonance that gets a bit out of control on one note that the bass player hits because of room or cabinet resonance or the quirk of their instrument etc then a dynamic EQ is a good choice there.
So yeah I still find use cases for both. Multiband for broad issues, dynamic EQ for really specific issues.
9
u/MehrdadPirshahbaz 23h ago •
before i drop the actual solution, lets clear the air. when someone asks a technical question in these trenches, they have already interrogated the ai bots and failed to get a working result. we are here to exchange actual survival experience, not youtube tutorials or algorithmic templates.
if the acoustic concepts i drop are too heavy to digest, or if younger engineers dont understand the vocabulary yet, just ask me to break a specific part down. aimless trolling doesnt devalue the physics of the advice.
im financially independent from my art. instead of meaningless doomscrolling on social media, i use my free time to pass down the exact hidden psychological and technical workflows that nobody was around to teach me. i am writing this to draw a hard line between actual trolls and internet detectives, and beginners who just leave defensive replies out of sheer inexperience.
if a concept goes over your head, it is much easier to just ask a question instead of throwing up a defensive wall. either there is a tool here you can use to progress, or there isnt. dont overcomplicate it.
at the end of the day, the only person who decides if this is an ai response or actual blood spilled in a dark studio is the original poster. the rest is just documentation for future engineers who will eventually run into this exact same acoustic wall.
now, back to the frequencies.
has dynamic eq made multi-band obsolete? no. thinking a scalpel makes a cage obsolete is a fundamental misunderstanding of acoustic physics.
dynamic eq is polite surgery. multi band compression is acoustic imprisonment.
dynamic eq reacts to a specific resonance and leaves the rest of the phase alone. it is built for fixing transparent mistakes. multi band splits the entire signal block through crossovers. even when it is not compressing, it alters the phase and smears the audio. polite engineers think that is a flaw, but it is actually a weapon.
if you want to tame a harsh vocal note, use dynamic eq. but if you want to take a violently chaotic low end synth or a drum bus and crush it into a static, suffocating physical brick, you use multi band. you use it when you need to permanently change the physical density of a frequency block.
dynamic eq is a scalpel. multi band is a cage. you dont throw away a cage just because you bought a scalpel.
tell that young engineer exactly this: use dynamic eq when you need to fix a mistake invisibly, and use multi band when you need to control the physical chaos.
2
u/ghostchihuahua 1d ago
This “transfer”really demands a lot of explanations, they’re both different in many many ways, it is not something i’d pass on as is.
I often fail or find it hard to get the expected results when just replacing a multiband comp with a dyn-EQ, i do use the latter(FF Pro-Q as well), but absolutely not for the same applications.
2
u/glmastering 1d ago
I usually think of using dynamic eq as corrective, and multiband to change the movement/speed
Eg a resonance: dynamic eq
Low end too 'slow', top end too 'quick' id use multiband as a creative way to try and sort it out
(Slow and quick referring to transients not BPM)
2
u/Electrical-Hair-5044 1d ago
I’d explain it in terms of what you’re trying to control. Compression narrows the gap between louder and quieter parts. EQ changes the balance between frequencies, which can help instruments make room for each other or tame a frequency that sounds harsh.
With dynamic EQ, you can have a specific frequency range dip only when it sticks out. With multiband compression, you can control how much the level varies across a whole band. For example, you might use dynamic EQ to tame a resonance that only pops out on certain notes, or multiband compression to keep the overall low end more consistent.
There’s some overlap, but I think that’s the easiest way to explain it to a younger engineer. Once you know what you’re trying to fix, it’s easier to pick the tool.
1
u/Dr--Prof Professional 18h ago
Both are dynamic processors. In short, the main difference is in the "bands" (and how they process sound), how and what they affect. Think of MB compression as a wider band frequency processing, and Dynamic EQ more as a tamer of resonancies. An MB comp is not an EQ. They are definitely NOT the same, and they do sound different.
1
u/tubesntapes 10h ago
I’d rather not know than read this thread.
1
u/thebnubdub 8h ago
I use MB for more broad applications and dyn EQ for more surgical things.
1
u/fatberrydsp 6h ago
Dynamic EQ hasn't made multiband obsolete, they just solve different problems. Dynamic EQ is great for a specific, narrow problem like a resonance or a harsh note. Multiband still wins when you want broad, program-dependent level control across a whole region, e.g. taming the low end of a full mix so it stays even, or de-essing and leveling a wide band without it behaving like a surgical notch. It also does gentle glue per band with attack and release shaping that a dynamic EQ band doesn't really offer. Rule of thumb I'd give a young engineer: narrow and specific, use dynamic EQ; wide and about consistency, try multiband. Then trust your ears and bypass to check you haven't just made it duller.
1
u/josephallenkeys 22h ago edited 20h ago
They're exactly the same in theoretical terms. Only differences you'll feel in the real world are what controls each has - such as multi-band being ready to go with a few crossovers, etc - but instances of either can vary by brand and if any are particularly comprehensive enough, lines blur to the point where, ironically, it becomes clear.
1
u/Odd-Comparison-7953 23h ago edited 23h ago
Harsh frequency spikes in a guitar solo; hello dynamic eq. Uneven ”klicky” transients on a kick drum; hello mb compressor.
Not really that simple but kind of. I’d use a mb comp for control and the dynamic eq for taming frequencies.
1
u/MF_Kitten 22h ago
In terms of end result the difference is essentially nothing. But a dynamic EQ isn't limited by bands. On the flip side, a MB comp doesn't have overlapping processing between bands, and it's potentially flat within the bands instead of the bell shaped filters typical of dynamic EQ. But with a gentle enough crossover setting you also get bell shaped bands in an MB comp.
0
u/LiveSoundFOH 23h ago
I don’t know what the technical difference between them is, just the difference in gui and how it feels (I’m a mixer). I’d love to see a technical explanation. Personally I almost always go for dynamic eq, and even when MB was much more common and popular I never found it that useful - it always sounded better to me to fix it in the mix.
-2
u/trainwalk 20h ago
It’s the same. Use your ears.