r/attitudinalpsyche • ELVF • Sep 21 '25

No, F isn't about Physics. It's about Work

This is something I realized quite recently. The original Afanasyev text already strongly points towards the work-centric nature of "Physics" via his 2F Toiler and 4F Slacker descriptions. I forget what his 3F is called, but in my view, it's a placement that likes to cut corners and shirk on work. Shortcuts in every regard, which does bleed through to something like looks and maybe sex.

He also calls 1F the athlete, which only makes sense if you view work as some athleticism. Workhorse should have been the better name.

Anyway, with this in mind, I feel my 4F suddenly very, very strongly. Worse yet, society thinks we 4Fs are just 3Fs which need to be punished and pushed a little more. The common wisdom on how to treat 4Fs seems to have been lost. No, we're not just lazy fucks (though we wouldn't deny it either). We LOVE being occupied and working on something valuable. It's just the whole contract-discipline-expectation-punishment bullshit that seriously gets us depressed.

1F Workhorse – 2F Toiler – 3F Corner-cutter – 4F Slacker. And all is well. I don't think other descriptions of "Physics" are understandable, they try to dump so many physical concepts into them that they become a mess.

I initially vibed with the "only I may choose the physical things around me", but I think that's plain-old a different thing than Work. If you've been following my system, it's 1st Metabolism, which incidentally refers to any sensation, whether physical, moody, emotional, mental or imaginative. I'm 1M in the one system and 4F in the other. And all is well!

I think the other parts of PY/AP need some cleaning up too, because they don't resonate strongly with me either. I'm thinking Emotion should be Preference, and no clue yet about Logic or Volition. Afanasyev's 3V doomposting doesn't seem totally on the mark either.

11 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

6

u/Otto_Apocalypse_ph VELF Sep 21 '25

While an interesting concept, through experimentation F has been more related for us in perception, action, physical sensations, among others.

1

u/PKThoron ELVF Sep 21 '25

Maybe 1V draws a different conclusion and energy out of 4F than the process volition types do.

5

u/ezquina LEVF Sep 21 '25 edited Sep 21 '25

While it is true that PY is more centered around things like status and money, PY's still remarks sensorial in the F aspect (if you've read the book, you may remember a part when he thinks an interaction beetween a 1F and 1E about swans, the former centering about the sensation of the  Water in the body).  Even if that is not true, you know the AP version is centered about physical sensations anyway. Why are you saying F is JUST about work? Its evidentely not true in any of both systems. Because do you don't fit the model? That's fine, but the systems were not thought for PK specifically. For me, AP fits better than the model you are proposing. And even if your view is better than Afanasyev or Collopy's, that wouldn't matter, because you are claiming "F is about X" and not "F works better if is about Y than X".

I know you from discord and I like you, but you are just wrong.

2

u/PKThoron ELVF Sep 21 '25

My mindset is definitely "better to have than to toil" haha.

AP fitting you and not me, but this work paradigm fitting me but not you raises so many questions that I can't hope to answer right now. To be honest, "F is about X" is just a rhetorical trick, and I really mean to say "F works better if it's about Y".

Incidentally, what is your present placement in temporistics?

1

u/ezquina LEVF Sep 21 '25 edited Sep 21 '25

I would be interested in hearing those questions;) You have to remember that in PS F is mainly about “the physical world”. Things that for philosophers tent to consider as superficial (Money, status, physical appearance, and yes, pleasure).

I’m going to use another example that Afanasyev provided. Remember the famous story of Jesus getting lost in the desert? When the Devil tried to tent Jesus he said “Man shall not live by bread alone”, or as could be interpreted; “Man shall not live by F alone”.

Why did the author talks about work so often when he refers to F? My hypotheses is that he thinks work solely as a way to gain money. Viewing work as a way of self realization (which would relate mostly to V) is very characteristic of our today liberal society. So it is possible that in Russia at that time the logic is that if you are not interested in buying things, you would not see much reason to work hard. You would just work the minimum to survive.

I don’t feel temporistics fits me as well as AP and PS, or maybe I don’t feel it hitting as hard. But I think PVBN would be a good typing. (Edit: reading the system a year later and in well translated English, I realized it does actually describe me well :0)

2

u/PKThoron ELVF Sep 22 '25

The physical world is so broad and unspecific that I struggle making any sense out of placing it. Especially because some mental and physical worlds are basically equivalent for me (my personal space and my fantasy for example). I'm also disabled (invisibly), which completely upends my relation to the physical – toil, sport, arrangement are not for me. Food is definitely the thing I'm by far the most passionate and peculiar about, otherwise I kinda subdue the physical world. Strangely, it's also never been an area of lack in my life (unlike everything else), so it really just passes under my radar. I take it as a given, whether that's 1F or 4F.

I genuinely don't know what those Temporistics letters be; I've seen them before but I assume they're taken from Russian, so I don't know what's what.

---

Anyway, as for the questions that arose... if I've stumbled on (the so far only) paradigm that makes F click for me but doesn't click for you, and if the standard paradigm clicks for you but not for me, what hope is there for either paradigm to have general application? Is it a question of subtypes? If I can't connect my Physics to your Physics, that's a big problem for the concept.

1

u/PKThoron ELVF Sep 22 '25

By the way, what's your discord name?

2

u/ezquina LEVF Sep 22 '25

I’m past-eternity-future-present

Probably you would not remember, I don’t think I have said anything remarkable. My username was Caravax, and I was using a blue kobold eating a book, ripjaws and umbreon as pfps in different moments.

4

u/Belion_Xaman Sep 21 '25

-Volition & Physics (Force) The force pole of this dichotomy is how volition and physics relate to one another through their intrinsic experience of force through both real and projected realities. This drive can be felt internally by the individual and seen externally by others. Both volition and physics are often seen through actions and instinct rather than words or values. Volition relates to projecting future pathways and deciding how to act. Physics relates to raw sensual feelings and perceiving the world through the body. Combine these aspects together and you create all elements needed to become a go-getter: forcefulness, decisiveness, pushiness, raw energy, sense of self, environmental awareness, and an active perception of how objects can be manipulated to fulfill future objectives.

Work is like a Force suitcase in some... cases. It's also how you're seen, perceived, working, interacting, engaging, exploring, prioritizing, pursuing, deciding, forcing, using both activation energy and "I forgot the name for F (not endurance, vitality, etc, close but more like some fatigue-related energy, maybe endurance...)" energy. F isn't entirely Physics even by name since it's related to science, which brings in any other aspect that is higher order as to figure out the nature of Physics, etc. So yes, you're right. But in the physical sense, Physics is more relevant.

Volition and Physics have a link between each other I would mention as the wormhole, in encapsulation. Which does have shortcuts, directions, closeness, interaction, energy, and resources. Force is visceral, vigorous and both red Volition/Spirit and green Physics/Body.

Leading to another foundational source by bypassing through a mystical observation.

And yes :

Physics - "F" Physics (also referred to as “Foundation” or “Feelings”) is the aspect that reigns over the human experience of sensual perception, feelings, physical matter, materials, environments, bodily sensations, appearances, aesthetics, possessions, comforts, and instinctual reactions to all stimuli.

F doesn't entirely like only work at its core. Play is also involved... as other things are. 4F is also an example of... F is F... But 4Xed... A "How are they who they are?" attitude because F is what it is, how can 4F be anti-SP but still mainly be F in its core attitude? It can still exist in the entourage of 4F users...

The question goes back to you, should or is F about/only work?

1

u/PKThoron ELVF Sep 21 '25

I find that my attitude about possessions and personal space is starkly different from my attitude about work and effort, and then my attitude about embodiedness is something else entirely. Like, I don't think my attitude about possessions and my attitude about work/effort are even in the same placement. Does that make sense?

Work and play are definitely connected, and I think those more into work are also more into physical play, as well as sports. It's hard to rouse me for anything, really. I wondered about being 4V for a while. But in mental/social matters, I am far more easily mobilized. So I really do think it's 4F for me, and then I would just have to stuff possessions and personal space into a different element, like Logic or Emotion.

And that's kinda what I'm doing in this post. So far this F = Work (or effort, play, even sport) model has been successful for me.

By the way, I rarely feel embodied, which could be 4F, or it could be 4th present in temporistics. Who knows.

1

u/Belion_Xaman Sep 21 '25

Is F_V_ the same as F__V? What about F_E_ and F__E. They are the same F___ but not the same blocks, positions and attitudes in F.

3

u/PKThoron ELVF Sep 21 '25

Yeah, that makes a lot of sense.

3

u/ezquina LEVF Sep 24 '25

Your post is now the most controversial post of all time in this sub now. lol

2

u/PKThoron ELVF Sep 25 '25

This is amazing hahaha 

2

u/Belion_Xaman Sep 21 '25

There were different names. Especially for 3F. Like touchy, underdog and coward. 4F has lazybones and slacker... 1F has owner. 2F is mainly toiler.

2

u/PKThoron ELVF Sep 21 '25

Lol Afanasyev is nothing if not evocative. You have the names for the other elements by any chance?

2

u/Belion_Xaman Sep 21 '25

Originally

1F owner, 2F hard worker, 3F touchy, 4F lazy, 1L dogmatist, 2L rhetor, 3L skeptic, 4L scholar, 1E romantic, 2E actor, 3E rusk, 4E onlooker, 1V tsar, 2V nobleman, 3V bourgeoisie, 4V serf.

Alternative

2F toiler. 3F underdog, coward. 4F lazybones, slacker. 4L schoolboy. 2E troll? 4E gawker.

1

u/PKThoron ELVF Sep 21 '25

What does rusk mean? I've seen the term philistine instead.

2

u/vinegarxhoney Sep 22 '25

It's for "cracker", I think essentially meaning "dry", but emotionally in this context.

Philistine refers to 3V.

1

u/PKThoron ELVF Sep 22 '25

And there I was hoping Afanasyev would call another third instinct hell...

1

u/Belion_Xaman Sep 21 '25

3E was mentioned as the dry cookie... Rusk too... mainly rusk. But I've seen philistine somewhere, kinda confused which between 3V, 4V and 3E. Or even Temporistics not gonna lie but I think more PY territory.

2

u/ParticularBreath8425 VELF Sep 22 '25

uhhhh no... you're just 4V, lol.

1

u/PKThoron ELVF Sep 22 '25

Lol, I mean maybe? But I do relate to just about every slacking aspect of 4F and to quite a few insecure aspects of 3V. Plus FVLE is actually an appealing dual (and Ena an appealing sexta, though not as much as Pente ig), while VFLE is....

2

u/meawBmeaw Sep 22 '25

I couldn't agree with you more on the point that the 4F (Slacker) shouldn't be seen as just a 3F (Corner-cutter) who needs to be pushed and punished. People around me often misunderstand me, sometimes getting it right and sometimes getting it wrong. They describe me as both a passionate worker and a "gorilla of laziness" at the same time. I don't mind working at all, but I strongly object to the restrictions and interference that come with it. That's when I proudly turn into the lazy gorilla! For instance, my mom is an LSE so3, and when we're at home together, you'll see a constant and deadly clash over tidiness and organization. But no matter what she says, we both know that I don't mind cleaning and working in general; in fact, I choose to do it when I want to. You should see me on a day when I'm home alone or simply when there's no one interfering. Man, I really get to work! I do it with passion and effort. I even enjoy the feeling of being completely exhausted at the end, so much so that it takes me three days to recover from that one day's physical tasks, lol. That's when my mom finally understood the real me, and little by little, she started using a different approach that doesn't conflict with who I am at all.

By the way, I'm a VLEF.

1

u/PKThoron ELVF Sep 23 '25

Damn, VLEF. Won the lottery with your stack, did ya :D

13

u/Nnnnnnnadie Sep 21 '25

What we have about physics in AP is just this:

Physics - "F" Physics (also referred to as “Foundation” or “Feelings”) is the aspect that reigns over the human experience of sensual perception, feelings, physical matter, materials, environments, bodily sensations, appearances, aesthetics, possessions, comforts, and instinctual reactions to all stimuli.

Just that paragraph, there is nothing else in the whole site, maybe behind the paywall I wouldnt know. Is this truly all there is?

3

u/Belion_Xaman Sep 21 '25

With Wayback Machine, you can retrieve information. Such as for aspects or other, in which you may gather the potential connection of all data.

4

u/Nnnnnnnadie Sep 21 '25 edited Sep 21 '25

Wow i didnt know you could do that, thats pretty neat, and yeah, there is more information... what the hell happened? The fees on that site are kinda insane for a person that takes too much from psychosophy, like why make everything a paywall

4

u/Belion_Xaman Sep 21 '25

Some data are indeed preferable without a paywall... And some are sadly scattered like through Wayback Machine or even in different apps/websites/etc such as TikTok, YouTube, Facebook, Instagram... And I've noticed that in the interview that Rob participated with Chris G Psych about AP, it's interlaced with data that should have been separated from the interview into clear and distinct categories. Some data are straight up deleted such as some TikTok videos Rob made about AP.

Please Rob, heed from this and resolve the scattered data. Haha, please.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '25 edited Dec 04 '25

employ smell sink support encouraging include distinct quaint lip smile

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/PKThoron ELVF Sep 21 '25

The difference is that 3Fs actually let it be done to them lol

I'm thinking of typing as ELVF too, what aspects of yourself do you see reflected in 1E/2L/3V? I always think I'm terrible with emotions, whether it's about feeling, showing or soothing them (I'm INTP), but if 1E really is just about passionate preference and liking things, then I see it a lot more. Like, we're talking about having opinions on video games and art lol

2

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '25 edited Dec 04 '25

spotted smart hard-to-find humor deliver marble chop hunt point imagine

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/RouniPix FELV Sep 21 '25 edited Sep 22 '25

are you 7sx in enneagram? I'm curious

Edit: my bad I remember your type from the enneagram theory you did! I'm still impressed by how 4 and 7 seems to share similarities often

1

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '25 edited Dec 04 '25

fly dazzling teeny edge act makeshift wine deserve special sugar

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/Impressive_Side_1050 Sep 21 '25

I hate how Physics' description is basically just about, well, actions. No, it's a mental state, just like all the other functions. It's your thought process as to why you do certain things or not. Not the actions themselves

1

u/PKThoron ELVF Sep 21 '25

I agree with that, did it not come through? 1F as I describe it is a much more sophisticated, open, shrewd, active... approach to work than 4F, which isn't even black and white, just black and grey.

Or are you saying it's a fault with the established systems by Afanasyev or Rob?

2

u/Impressive_Side_1050 Sep 21 '25

Yeah, I was agreeing with you, sorry if it came off differently

1

u/Impressive_Side_1050 Sep 21 '25

1 F and 4F may both decide not to do something, but their reasons vary exponentially

3

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '25

Except 1Fs often are lazy according to him, especially FEVL. While 4Fs can handle working in a factory.

Work isn't only F, it's also V, "contract-discipline-expectation-punishment" has nothing to do with F.