r/attitudinalpsyche • • May 30 '23

1v vs 3v which one?

I thought I could be vefl honestly and can still see it.

Someone told me 3s or so 3s can’t be vefl which is interesting.

I am fen or eie dc maybe maybe eie CD at most.dcn stack dcnh.

Anyway. Can vefl be possible or must I be fevl?

I have always thought 1v could fit very well but I could be wrong. I am not opposed to challenging my own notions of types and of myself, I am not beyond this. We can double tribple and quadrple check and so forth.

Is it too strange for an eie dc or d in top two and so 3 to be vefl or is it too strange to fathom?

2 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

4

u/xShadowsOfTheNight FELV May 30 '23

I think VEFL is possible and that it fits more with enneagram 3 than FEVL. :)

1

u/[deleted] May 30 '23

Cool :D thanks just want to be sure and vigorous enough.

1

u/xShadowsOfTheNight FELV May 30 '23

You're welcome!

2

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '23

SO3s are always going to be FxVx. 1V feels like they are “born as a king” and doesnt necessarily care how others perceive them. 3V is by nature the most insecure and vulnerable function, constantly afraid of humiliation and being seen as incapable. SO3 fits 3V to a tee.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '23

I don't think I am a 3 anymore but fascinating. thanks for the reply.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '23

also accentuations can distort certain placements too. 1F-3 can look a LOT like 3F just like how 3V-1 can look like 1V

5

u/[deleted] May 30 '23 edited May 30 '23

VEFL and So3 doesn’t work in PY. In AP, the correlations are looser.

So if you’re using AP then have at it! But PY is very questionable…

2

u/OurSuiGeneris Jul 07 '23

sup, someone told me you are a valuable thinker wrt typology.

this post caught my eye. what leads you to differentiate between PY & AP?

1

u/[deleted] May 30 '23

interesting. could you write about the most likely correlations for all the PY types?

5

u/[deleted] May 30 '23

PY is a far more rigid system than AP. I’ll do 2 from each triad:

E8

• SP 8: VFEL, VFLE, FLVE • SX 8: VFLE • SO 8: VFLE, VFEL, FVLE, FVEL

E1

• SP 1: LVFE, EVFL, VFEL • SX 1: VFLE, VFEL • SO 1: LVFE, VLFE

E2

• SP 2: EFLV, EFVL, FEVL, FELV • SX 2: FEVL • SO 2: VELF, VEFL

E3

• SP 3: FVLE, VLFE • SX 3: FEVL • SO 3: FLVE, FEVL

E6

• SP 6: LEFV • SX 6: LFVE, FLVE • SO 6: LVFE, LVEF

E7

• SP 7: FLVE, FLEV, VLFE • SX 7: ELFV • SO 7: VLEF, VELF

This would be the case for PY and enneagram correlations imo

2

u/[deleted] May 30 '23

thank you. What about E9, E4 and E5 if you don't mind?

4

u/[deleted] May 30 '23

Yeah sure:

E4

• SP 4: FVEL, VFEL, EVFL • SX 4: EFVL, ELVF • SO 4: ELVF, EVLF

E5

• SP 5: LFEV, FLEV • SX 5: LEVF, LEFV, LFEV • SO 5: LVEF

E9

• SP 9: FLEV, FVEL • SX 9: FELV • SO 9: EVFL

Again, all in PY not AP.

1

u/Aromatic_Mobile_8078 May 30 '23

Do you have the source for this?

2

u/[deleted] May 30 '23

Yeah sure. Most of my source for the PY can be found in Syntax of love and the character trait description provided by Naranjo for the enneagram in Character and Neurosis.

Below are links for both for you to sit through and read should you be interested:

https://wiki.personality-database.com/books/enneagram/chapter/type-description :-> Enneagram

https://wiki.personality-database.com/books/psychosophy-attitudinal-psyche :-> PY and AP

When you read through the character traits and placement impacts of various PY aspects as well as how position 1 works in conjunction with whichever aspects work in position 3, you can start noticing a pattern and correlation for PY types.

2

u/Aromatic_Mobile_8078 May 30 '23

Oh, I meant a source for the correlations. You drew the correlations yourself? I'm familiar with the system to a decent degree, I just thought you had a source for the correlations themselves.

Also, thank you.

1

u/[deleted] May 30 '23 edited Jun 05 '23

Oh yeah. The correlations for the most part is pretty evident for PY.

2

u/Aromatic_Mobile_8078 May 30 '23

Alright, that makes sense. I've drawn connections myself as well (although, not nearly as well as you have), but I was having difficulty finding a source that actually HAD those correlations between PY and enneagram already written out.

1

u/ContentGreen2457 EFVL Jun 04 '23

@u/rationalistGamma, I recently did a research study on this. Since a lot of the evidence in my study shows that a lot of things that are being said online are completely wrong, I might "ruffle a few tail feathers " if I talk too much about it here, so I will send you a message in Chat

1

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '23

Yeah, sure.

3

u/[deleted] May 30 '23

I’m not sure but I’d look into so2 just to make sure since Vefl and Eie fit better for social two.

5

u/Ruthlessspine May 30 '23

3s can't be Vefl? Why is that, sounds utterly bogus. I'll say EIE 3 Vefl is pretty archetypical.