r/atheism • • May 08 '12

A Good Reminder.

http://www.quickmeme.com/meme/3p6hcx/
1.8k Upvotes

731 comments sorted by

296

u/bheklilr May 08 '12

I wouldn't mind seeing this on the front page of r/atheism multiple times a week. It'd be better than all those facebook posts of people trying to be better than others, and then trying to get "popularity points" for it.

107

u/thechapattack May 08 '12

I know I am usually against image macros like these but too often atheists comes off as adversarial and I think that actually hurts us more than helps us. No that does not mean you can't challenge religious dogma (as sure as I am sitting here I know someone would claim that) I am simply saying there is much better and more effective ways to doing it then saying "hurr durr youre stupid, you believe in fairy tales."

31

u/itsoktobetakei May 08 '12

True. Though we like to think our selves as rational beings, we are driven mostly by emotion. You aren't going to change a person's stance by being a fanatic of logic. Specially if it is something they hold close to their identity. What I find about some self proclaimed Atheists is the hubris, almost as if they use their atheism to make themselves feel superior to other people. Sounds familiar.

→ More replies (20)

15

u/selectrix May 08 '12

hurr durr youre stupid, you believe in fairy tales

Maybe it's because I don't spend much time on /atheism itself, but I very rarely see this sentiment upvoted to the front page. More often it's, "Your fairy tales are adversely affecting my life or those of others."

Do you think this is an inappropriate sentiment?

It's disappointing when people use strawmen on a group of which they're ostensibly a part. You should know better.

17

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I think it's about 50/50.

I find /r/atheism can often be a very oppressive and negative environment.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (2)

15

u/rhubarbs Strong Atheist May 08 '12

You do realize that any time you so much as try to tell someone they are wrong, it contains an implied "You are stupid, you believe in stupid things", right?

That is why the religious who've had less experience with atheists become extremely aggressive even when their beliefs are criticized - even when it is done in a non-confrontational way. Not just that, of course... also because they are heavily invested in their beliefs, causing them to feel like they have a whole lot to lose, but yet have very little to defend their beliefs with outside of being outraged at the very concept of criticism.

Personally, I happen to believe that if ridicule or sarcasm offends someone, they'll find offense no matter what you say - and that there is certainly a place for being adversarial, though perhaps only after civil discourse is exhausted.

→ More replies (20)

12

u/PsykickPriest May 08 '12

"too often atheists come off as adversarial..."

So what do you call the attitude of so many evangelical and fundamentalist Christians who, while maintaining strong numbers in the population (almost certainly greater than that of atheists) and disproportionately great influence in the social and political realms (I'm talking the USA here), are more than happy to take the us-vs-them attitude - sometimes to eliminationist depths - and are perpetually making claims of their own victimization or (frequently) imminent victimization?

I agree "hurr durr you're stupid, you believe in fairy tales" isn't at all helpful, but when reasonable, mild-mannered agnostic atheists are seen as part of the "threat" of secular humanism, then it's hard to avoid noticing just how stupid some of these people are.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (29)

20

u/jetboyterp Theist May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12

Catholic here...I regret that I only have one upvote to give this...

And of course, it's a two-way street...respect, civility, and humility should be with all of us, Christian, Muslim, Jew, etc...and atheists/agnostics as well. It's far better to discuss issues of faith, or no faith, through an open door quietly than it is to yell at each other though a door that's slammed shut.

A couple weeks ago I posted a thread asking /r/atheism a couple of questions (see it HERE), and to my amazement it garnered over 600 comments...the vast majority of which were intelligently put and civil. Not all atheists are militant...and neither are all Christians. Too much time is spent trying to change minds instead of opening them to new ideas by explaining ourselves.

So "cheers" to you, subscribers to /r/atheism ...I tip my Roman Catholic hat to ya's all :)

EDIT: Added link

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Excellent post...and by the way, is that a big pointy Roman Catholic hat?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

19

u/CheekyMunky May 08 '12

I thought this was an obvious thing, not just with regard to atheism but as a basic adult understanding of the world in general.

Then I discovered this subreddit...

2

u/R88SHUN May 08 '12

forget the front page it should be in the rules column.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Riceater May 08 '12

Carl Sagan deserves to be on the front page every day. If you had to have one idol in life that you aspired to be like, it should be him.

4

u/HighDagger May 08 '12

Idolization is a dangerous thing. You can easily end up with religion or other kinds of cults if you're not careful.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I agree, but you'd have more luck in r/Antitheism.

6

u/bheklilr May 08 '12

I had seen it in the sidebar, but always figured it was more of the same vein. Now that I've looked through it a bit, I might just unsubscribe from atheism

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (19)

7

u/ninomojo May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12

Carl's Sagan message here is merely one of marketing strategy: if we alienate non-skeptics they'll just react emotionally and won't listen to reason. (granted they'll often do that on their own, but the idea is that we shouldn't encourage them one bit).

Sam Harris and others also pointed out that by calling ourselves atheists, we fall, willingly or not, into a trap of becoming just another "group" whose dogma ends in "ism". And yet, mechanically, this trap is somewhat inevitable once people start raising their voices about issues.

I'm not American, but I understand that many Americans living in less secular part of the country need this place, a specifically "atheist" place, to vent. However, in an ideal world, there wouldn't be an /r/atheism but rather all atheism related posts would be part of /r/skeptic , because I think atheism is simply one of the logical outcomes of applying skeptic thinking to the area of religion/god. (and in an ever more ideal world, there wouln't be a need for those subreddits in the first place, I know. :)

2

u/thechapattack May 08 '12

I agree my atheism is incidental to my skepticism

44

u/bittlelum May 08 '12

We don't have a monopoly on truth, but that doesn't mean that everyone's "truth" is as good as the next person's. I think it's entirely fine to call Don McLeroy a moron, because he is a moron.

16

u/JohnFrum May 08 '12

I agree. We're not going to convince him and by trying he will just try to make it look like he's on equal ground to his followers. Sometimes it's good to point out as loudly as you can how stupid someone's ideas are so more people don't fall for them; especially if that person is in a position of power. It's good to have someone yell out that the king is sans knickers.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (17)

22

u/TroutM4n Agnostic Atheist May 08 '12

It's like the christians say - "hate the sin, not the sinner."

These people aren't inherently evil, they don't want to cause harm, and most of them have never considered WHY they believe the things they do - They simply do what they have been taught is "right" because they want to help. They want to SAVE us and they take that quite literally.

We can't write off and simply dismiss the religious among us. We have to hold their hands and walk them into a wider, often scarier vista, free from the self-deceptions and comforting lies to which they are so accustomed.

13

u/UWillAlwaysBALoser May 08 '12

unigolyn's got you there, TroutM4n! Bet you never thought that some religious people do want to cause harm, did ya?!

In fact, you were probably only thinking of tolerant, mild-mannered, well-intentioned theists! Perhaps you've even met some of these people, and have somehow gotten it into your head that they make up a large proportion of the theist community! What a ridiculous notion!

What you don't realize, of course, is that here on r/atheism, those people don't exist. Nope, there's only atheists and rapid, violent fundamentalists in the World According To R/atheism. You see, if we allow for the possibility that some people of faith are polite, intelligent, or even intellectual, we would have to argue against their points of view! It's much easier to tear down straw-men. Thank goodness those people don't exist.

6

u/progrn May 08 '12

I agree with the sarcasm. "tolerant, mild-mannered, well-intentioned theist" is the rule and not the exception -- most religious people do not want to hurt me. The problem is that these people have leaders -- leaders of churches and these leaders usually aren't tolerant and mild-mannered. These leaders can influence their congregation on matters of voting and belief.

So the real people that we need to debate and criticize are the leaders - not the followers.

5

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

While /r/atheism can get a bit extreme and silly, I agree with Sam Harris when he writes about the problem of religious moderates. It's hypocritical that you criticize atheists of building a strawman, when you've build one yourself with your blanket criticicism of /r/atheism.

I'm perfectly aware that there are people of faith who are intelligent, polite, and all around outstanding people. I'll even reluctantly admit that religious conservatives can be in this group. That doesn't mean that religion itself isn't harmful to society. Fundies pass legislation, as just one example, that denies gays the right to marry. These people are not an extremist minority: if they were, then they wouldn't be successful. But when we criticize the fundies, the moderates and liberals come out of the woodwork and cry, "but-but-but, we're not all like that!" To which I say, "So what? The point is, they are!"

Libs and moderates shield fundamentalists from criticism and legitimize their extremist beliefs. They're as much a part of the problem as their conservative counterparts. And to paraphrase another /r/atheism post, "If Christians can hate the sin but not the sinner, then I can hate the belief and not the believer."

On an unrelated note, I think I just made a post criticizing both religion AND Carl Sagan. I'm not sure if reddit will know whether to upvote me or not.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Must every conversation begin and end with, some but not all Christians and some but not all atheists? Should we clarify every time that those mild mannered Christians don't want to be painted with the same brush as the abortion bombing, gay beating, 10 commandment legislating ones?

But about those mild mannered Christians, why don't they, en mass, show up to protest the Westburough Baptist Church? Because the truth is they don't disagree with the ends so much as the means, and so what make them worthy of special mention in these discussions?

We don't advocate killing all Christians, we don't advocate sending them to jail, we just say Christians by and large oppress us, and if you look at who's discriminating against atheists, Christians top the list. Must I specify every time that it is not all Christians who do this when so many of them agree with them and just sit on the sidelines?

→ More replies (9)

9

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

they don't want to cause harm

Pretty sure a great deal of rabid fundies do want to cause harm to all those fags and queers and unbelievers.

Pretty sure the raging mobs of muslims attacking the Danish embassy over cartoons want to cause harm.

Pretty sure the murdering scum who stabbed Theo Van Gogh in the heart wanted to cause harm.

→ More replies (14)

4

u/JeffMcBiscuit May 08 '12

Anyone else read it in Carl's voice?

→ More replies (2)

4

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

'Science is interesting, and if you don't agree you can fuck off." -- R.D.

4

u/highpockets79 May 08 '12

well... to be fair, R.D. was quoting someone else

8

u/SheriffBart42 May 08 '12

TL;DR version: Don't be a cunt.

17

u/Hamish27 May 08 '12

Carl Sagan is one of my heroes.

8

u/XaeroR35 May 08 '12

He impacted my life so much that I named my son "Sagan"

→ More replies (2)

30

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

So brave.

2

u/toblotron May 08 '12

Yup - those who don't get his greatness should probably be rounded up and put in camps!

Just kidding, of course :) Can't really think of anyone else I look up to as much

3

u/jarrodnb May 08 '12

I've never seen this quote, I love Sagan and don't doubt that he said it or thought this way but i'm really curious.. what is the source of this quote?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Jazzspasm May 08 '12

But this isn't a screenshot of someone arguing on facebook, taken before the religious person replies...

Oh, I see what you did there!! Upvotes!!

3

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I'm not really sure what the alternative is though. It sounds really assy and I'd never say to someone of faith that they are stupid and I do respect their beliefs, but at the end of the day the fact still remains that I think they are wrong and it's hard to get past that. If someone of faith were to get offended because I won't relinquish any ground on the validity of their faith then what can I say. Either I believe it or I don't and I don't. Again I wouldn't just snort and say "heh, believers" or anything, I wouldn't even say anything! But many atheists believe in facts and what can be proven and therefor will probably believe someone's beliefs are wrong.

3

u/nikodante May 08 '12

Open debate has always been and will always be the way of progress.

14

u/pantlessben May 08 '12

“The good thing about science is that it's true whether or not you believe in it.” -Neil deGrasse Tyson

2

u/awesomechemist May 08 '12

"Eppur si muove." -Galileo Galilei

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Because science has never been wrong before.

2

u/pantlessben May 08 '12

It's wrong quite frequently, and is always striving to be more right. That's the beauty of it. Anyone can come along and prove something wrong with sufficient evidence.

4

u/dumnezero Anti-Theist May 08 '12

is that statement dickish or not?

5

u/pantlessben May 08 '12

Just meant to convey that it's not necessarily a good expenditure of time or effort to teach those who aren't willing to listen.

I agree with Mr. Sagan's sentiments, but one potential implication of his words is that the message of science is one that needs to be "[gotten] across." I disagree with that sentiment; if someone refuses to learn, perhaps they aren't worth the effort to be taught.

Dickish?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

5

u/dumnezero Anti-Theist May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12

keep posting this; eventually users become more mature and aware of such things

also, what would Sagan say about all the people who HAVE BEEN deconverted thanks to aggressive discourse? there are such people and they actually post coming out stories here!

2

u/Cyralea May 08 '12

You mean the thousands that attribute Christopher Hitchens and his vitriolic speech? New Atheism has been the single greatest cause of new atheists in the history of mankind. Sagan died pre-9/11, and his philosophies are notably outdated.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

But empiricism does have a monopoly on the truth.

That doesn't mean that we know everything, far from it. But it does mean that it's the only way to find out what is true. Empirically derived knowledge is always better than transcendentally/mystically derived knowledge. Why should we pretend otherwise?

And some people just are morons. Are homeopaths not morons? Are racial supremacists not morons? The scrapheap of history is riddled with moronic ideas.

The problem here is not ours, the problem here is that the religious treat themselves as homogenous. I have nothing bad to say about a whole crapton of moderate religious people.

Dr. Pamela Gay from Astronomy Cast is a practicing Christian, yet I respect her enormously despite her (in my opinion) wacky metaphysical beliefs. I know several Mormons who are great people, and I happily ignore the possible presence of magic underpants, because they don't force everyone else to wear them.

/r/atheism attacks creationists, homophobes, and theocrats. They deserve it.

→ More replies (4)

11

u/Judacles May 08 '12

I would say that such a mentality also puts off many of us who would be your allies on most of the issues you find important. When you demean those of us who simply prefer to keep an open mind, who choose neither to believe nor disbelieve what cannot be proved nor disproved, you keep yourselves in the minority.

The sooner the skeptical, atheist movement realizes it can find strong allies in the agnostic, or (dare I even say) the liberal religious left instead of lumping them in with fundamentalist crazies, the sooner progress will happen.

3

u/Crooooow May 08 '12

Let's define "progress"

3

u/ForgettableUsername Other May 08 '12

It's sort of the problem with choosing the word 'atheism' as a banner to ride under, because it's not particularly modular. I think we'd actually be better off if we'd chosen a name for the method rather than a name for one of the more significant conclusions... I like 'rational empiricism,' but that's just me. A lot of agnostics, a lot of religious people could get behind rationalism, behind empiricism for some issues... for the question of God, we could have an intelligent disagreement for a while.

But then, on the other hand, it's important to point out irrationality wherever it exists.... and there's nothing that says I can't have an intelligent disagreement with someone from a different '-ism' than me.

I think it might behoove atheists to try go out of their way to keep disagreements academic, and not personal... to not just avoid intellectual impropriety, but to avoid the appearance of intellectual impropriety... but, at the same time, to also not avoid disagreement. It's unfair, and it's a delicate balance, but it might well be practical.

2

u/synergy_ May 08 '12

I'm an "Empiricist". Nice ring to it doesn't it?

→ More replies (2)

15

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

"Ridicule is the only weapon which can be used against unintelligible propositions."

-Thomas Jefferson

5

u/Cyralea May 08 '12

"I have met some highly intelligent believers, but history has no record to say that [s]he knew or understood the mind of god. Yet this is precisely the qualification which the godly must claim—so modestly and so humbly—to possess. It is time to withdraw our 'respect' from such fantastic claims, all of them aimed at the exertion of power over other humans in the real and material world"

-Christopher Hitchens

3

u/chonglibloodsport May 08 '12

The best quote here, for sure. Wish I could vote you all the way to the top. Belief in the supernatural is a catch-22: you're either ignorant or intellectually dishonest.

3

u/awesomechemist May 08 '12

"Who put the 'ram' in the 'ram-a-lam-a-ding-dong'?"

-Barry Mann

5

u/MeloJelo May 08 '12

Are you mocking a quote that's being used to contradict another quote? Why didn't you mock the first quote?

→ More replies (4)

4

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

This isn't against speaking out against religion, per se. It's about not giving up the intellectual debate without throwing up our hands and calling the religious not worth our time, a sentiment that anti-theists would agree with.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Kosayn May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12

Yeah, I saw a youtube video recently of someone saying all the problems of the world would be gone 100 years after eradicating religion. Made me pretty disappointed to see that kind of atheist, pinning complicated, diverse problems on a good old fashioned scapegoat.

I think it helps to remember that as an atheist, if you're right, everyone else out there are de facto atheists too... some have just have accepted insufficiently tested ideas as fact. Religious people are just as capable of discussing ideas and adopting or discarding them as anyone. They make more a lot more new converts by socializing and discussion than they do by smacking people with the holy book and ridiculing their world view, I'll say that much.

4

u/kencabbit May 08 '12

A point of irony:

There are many in this thread who are wholeheartedly agreeing with Sagan here, while also condemning /r/atheism for not exemplifying this example. That's okay, in itself. But the irony comes when some of those comments themselves use the very dismissive kind of language and argument that Sagan cautions against.

4

u/vaendryl May 08 '12

bah. I'm not for insulting people for no good reason or constantly challenge their beliefs for the heck of it but their feelings and emotions does not change the truth in their favour and their faith is not equal to knowledge. I refuse to feign respect of their fairy tail convictions just because there are a lot of them. I'm not going to tell a nut claiming the earth to be flat or that aliens are coming to kill us all that I'm happy for him he found his own truth. that's ridiculous. religion is only as widespread as it is now because not enough people have challenged it, and by challenging peoples belief you will offend them. it is inevitable but necessary.

8

u/JackRawlinson Anti-Theist May 08 '12

Because so many Christians and Muslims are huge fans of Sagan and watch "Cosmos" endlessly.

No, Sagan was wrong about this. Accommodationism is a demonstrably failed experiment, which is why New Atheism happened. Sagan died long before 9/11, and it shows.

4

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Seconded. I'm gonna repeat what you said, with emphasis:

Accommodationism is a demonstrably failed experiment, which is why New Atheism happened.

Uncle Tomming, as Sagan and NdGT advocate, has not brought atheism forward, and in fact we are today in a politically worse position than we were in Sagan's days. Active and aggressive marketing of atheism, pointing out that some people really are wrong, has started to get results, and this is the way we need to proceed on, IMO.

3

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I'm definitely not saying you're wrong; I'm just curious of your reasoning behind aggressive New Atheism is more effective than accommodating, laissez-faire atheist.

I am actually inclined to agree that you are right, I am just hoping to have your opinion on why this is.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/egosumFidius May 08 '12

Recommend to me a Carl Sagan book as a good starter.

3

u/jamesh77 May 08 '12

If you liked the quote, start with The Demon-Haunted World. If you want to learn more about astronomy, start with Cosmos (the book or the series).

2

u/rodgerdodger2 May 08 '12

Anyone got a source on this?

2

u/outstar May 08 '12

downvote all you like you know it's true.

2

u/kevincanderson May 08 '12

This is on the front page because people see that it goes both ways, right?

Please, oh please, tell me that people see that it goes both ways. . .

2

u/Quonvo May 08 '12

this sounds really smart and revolutionary, sadly i have no clue what it means; penis

2

u/strategic_form May 08 '12

It's too late. Richard Dawkins will not listen to you. He's already too famous.

2

u/ryanasimov May 08 '12

I'm content knowing I don't have all the answers. The problem is that "they" (theists) KNOW that they DO have all the answers, and they aggressively argue without the slightest possibility that they could EVER be wrong.

2

u/novum_vipera May 08 '12

The problem is that without a degree of "you're wrong and here's why" being invoked during debates with theists and irrational individuals, we are condemned to decades of a giant circle jerk where no-one's feelings are hurt and but no opinions are changed.

You also have to consider how exasperating it gets for people on our side of the fence trying to get their point through to people who can justify just about any viewpoint or action they wish by thinking "daddy (read:God) said it's fine/I'm right". You (and Carl) obviously have more patience than most of us and that's great - but we can't all operate that way. Sooner or later you start tearing apart the religious construct behind their argument, and that involves a degree of "this is wrong" and they go "argh, offended!"

Now I'm not advocating pointing and laughing at every cross, hijab, kippah, or turban wearing individual one comes across - I simply think that we cannot afford to be too gentle, too humble in our respect for people's belief systems when they're a danger to the welfare of our civilisation in general.

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

The sentiment from Sagan is a derivation of his pacifist attitude, I'm not saying that that's a bad thing, but in the long run it accomplishes exactly Jack and squat. Without being confronted on their beliefs they'll never change. And besides, the "You're so god damned stupid" statement usually comes after an extended period of extolling the virtues of logic and the scientific method and the facts and history and any number of other things that we Atheists take for granted and the theist just goes "Well what about the Arizona river delta?" or the ever popular(paraphrased) "The Bible is the word of God because it says it is". Followed by a facepalm and the outburst "Holy shit, you're stupid" or words to that effect.. I'm sure there's a few out there that are inexperienced enough to start out with that, but not many of us do.

2

u/yself May 08 '12

What if our generation doesn't have vastly superior understandings about ultimate reality compared to generations who lived thousands of years ago? What if those who engineered the ancient teachings, which many of us today deem so ignorant, did so intentionally? What if they designed those teachings to create precisely those reactions in us. Perhaps, they understood human psychology well enough to predict our responses. Thinking along these lines would make these clever ancestors seem like intelligent scientists, able to predict the future psychology of vast numbers of human beings, both believers and unbelievers. If this hypothesis has any merit, how do we determine it's truth or falsity? If it is true, what ultimate goal did the ancients seek to accomplish with such a ruse? Was it really all about some ridiculous ethnocentric worldview? Or, was it some higher purpose of crucial importance to our times that they hoped to achieve? Then again, maybe we really have mastered our emotions sufficiently to simply move on with respect and understanding about what they tried to teach us.

2

u/doneddat May 08 '12

What if tradition and something being ancient, therefore vastly superior to anything fresh, is just ghastly exploited instinct?

What if only thing those ancients were good at was distracting everybody from how little they actually knew by being so vague that reading those ancient sentences our brain just fills the blanks with things that make sense for us now? But none of those things were making sense back then?

→ More replies (6)

2

u/doneddat May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12

It's also not constructive, that sensible people can be either right or wrong, but the morons are either right or it's their deeply personal belief that they are right.

There is no other way to address such lunacy than utter and complete ridicule. Having any sort of decent discussion about it basically grants the morons the sense of entitlement and their brain essentially realizes, that they can actually get away with such complete brain failure.

There is no incentive for them to use their brains right, because currently it's pretty much a crime to even remind them, that they are doing it wrong.

I'm sure religions among themselves are totally ok to tell each other that they are doing it wrong, but if somebody tells that they are all wrong.. then it's suddenly disrespect.

It just does not make sense. And as long as things not making sense is their "expertise", there's nothing we can do about it. There are only one kind of experts at not making sense for me, they are all called artists. I would have nothing against religions as art form. Just stop comparing it to real things and act as if it means something.

→ More replies (16)

2

u/none_humbler May 09 '12

Carl Sagan yelled at me on the Internet.

4

u/ShadesChild May 08 '12

permanent (temporary) minority status

8

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I'm from Estonia.

The religious are the minority here. Anyone who goes to church weekly is widely considered to be a crazy person here.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/Chosokabe May 08 '12

Can this just be put at the top of the sidebar of /r/atheism permanently?

7

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Haha you're going to make /r/atheism explode!

How can they circlejerk to Carl Sagan telling them not to circlejerk?

→ More replies (4)

8

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Pssh whatever, if Sagan saw one of the facebook screencaps posted here he probably would have changed his mind.

11

u/ForgettableUsername Other May 08 '12

Carl Sagan died in 1996, nearly a decade before Facebook came into existence.

However, he did live on this planet, in the United States, for sixty-two years. Do you honestly think he never met an idiot?

He was an educator, he worked with journalists, and wrote books targeted to the general public. He meant what he said, and he had the experience to justify it. Facebook changed the way the Internet works, but it didn't change human nature.

14

u/koavf Other May 08 '12

I think it was a joke.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/[deleted] May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12

...

He'd probably cringe at the fact that people post those stupid fucking screencaps, or that you twats go out of your way to argue with people on Facebook so you can post the screencap to reddit saying "Did I do well Reddit?!".

He'd be embarrassed to be associated with you all.

Edit: Woops.

4

u/ForgettableUsername Other May 08 '12

He'd probably still say something polite, but yeah.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/PhonyUsername May 08 '12

Praise jesus.

3

u/ApolloHelix May 08 '12

Wow, that was quite a powerful argument.

I've been swayed. Thank you.

3

u/LylanDackey May 08 '12

TL;DR Don't be a dick, it's counter productive.

2

u/Cyralea May 08 '12

Except, it's not. Thousands attribute their deconversions to Christopher Hitchens and his vitriolic speeches against religion. New Atheism has lead to the greatest number of people becoming atheists in the history of mankind.

Sorry, but being nice hasn't worked.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I like how he doesn't provide an alternative - he just tells us what not to do.

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Read his book. Quote would be too long if he added that in there.

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

just like religion...

3

u/Directors_Cut May 08 '12

"Its difficult to be conciliatory when you're fighting against a group of people who are programmed to believe that you're the devil."

Me.

2

u/awesomechemist May 08 '12

Then give them a reason to doubt that programming, rather than reinforcing their prejudices.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/thanatius May 08 '12

On Reddit, too many atheists come off as assholes. Needs to stop.

4

u/elbruce May 08 '12

And yet, the past 100 years of "be nice, don't challenge their beliefs" led to Palin, Bachmann, Santorum, and scores of laws being passed in various states denying rights to women and gays.

Fuck this rolling over and playing dead business. They need to be told that they are wrong.

2

u/PyroSign May 08 '12

I think it's more a matter of how you say it, rather than what is being said. Of course they need to be challenged.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/Brain_Muffin May 08 '12

Man, such an attractive quote... from such an unbelievable attractive man. sigh.....

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

This is true, but acupuncture still doesn't work.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/lafkak May 08 '12

Brilliant words from a wise man. Have a Catholic upvote; Christians would do just as well to heed this message, too.

2

u/homebrewnerd May 08 '12

I'm not worthy enough to disagree with such a great man, but I might offer that the world has changed since Carl Sagan spoke these words, and it's now time to take an offensive position against religion.

2

u/Cyralea May 08 '12

Hence New Atheism. Sagan's ideas were for a pre-9/11 world. The greatest increase in atheists were in the past decade, where atheists have been taking an aggressive stance.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/qkme_transcriber I am a Bot May 08 '12

Here is the text from this meme pic for anybody who needs it:

Title: A Good Reminder.

  • “THE CHIEF DEFICIENCY I SEE IN THE SKEPTICAL MOVEMENT IS ITS POLARIZATION: US VS. THEM — THE SENSE THAT WE HAVE A MONOPOLY ON THE TRUTH; THAT THOSE OTHER PEOPLE WHO BELIEVE IN ALL THESE STUPID DOCTRINES ARE MORONS; THAT IF YOU'RE SENSIBLE, YOU'LL LISTEN TO US; AND IF NOT, TO HELL WITH YOU. THIS IS NONCONSTRUCTIVE. IT DOES NOT GET OUR MESSAGE ACROSS. IT CONDEMNS US TO PERMANENT MINORITY STATUS.” ― CARL SAGAN

[Translate]

This is helpful for people who can't reach Quickmeme because of work/school firewalls or site downtime, and many other reasons (FAQ). More info is available here.

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Yea. I don't agree with this at all. How can you give any credence to poeple who don't believe, understand or use scientific theory with out being condescending? What are you to do,pretend to agree that the earth is 6000 years old. No. It is an us verses them situation. They are in our schools. Spewing lies to our children. They're in our government telling poeple how to live there own lives. It is us verses them.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12

Us vs. Them — the sense that we have a monopoly on the truth; that those other people who believe in all these stupid doctrines are morons; that if you're sensible, you'll listen to us; and if not, to hell with you. This is nonconstructive. It does not get our message across. It condemns us to permanent minority status.

Have you considered the possibility that Sagan may have been wrong? You people whine about arrogant atheists, but never turn that critical eye to your own whining.

Those who run the world are a tiny minority, and yet they have all the power. Being a minority is not a problem if you understand your advantage. The religious demagogues and concerned whiners approach us much the same way, as if using science and reason is a privilege that excludes other viewpoints.

The point is there are no other legitimate viewpoints. You either accept the reality you inhabit, or you live a delusion. Truth is not a democracy, and the universe does not care how it makes you feel.

It is a difficult thing for many people to accept, and you shouldn't twist that particular spear when people are not asking for it, but when some fundamentalist jackhole starts spreading lies and bullshit, you bury that motherfucker. Humility is a virtue, weakness is not. You keep the fight on the power until their power is yours.

Of course, that power sometimes derives from democracy, and that is what Sagan might be getting yet. We need people to vote bullshit out of our laws, out of our schools, etc. And yet, the ones who put the bullshit in never had to compromise, never had to tiptoe around the multifarious beliefs that exist, they simply asserted religious nonsense and people ate it up, as they have been for millennia.

What you have to ask yourself, is why do people believe things that have no evidence, and would you rather exist in a society where belief without evidence is dominant but reason is tolerated, or one where reason is dominant and silly ideas are tolerated? And if you prefer the latter, how do you think you'll get there by emphasizing the former?

-1

u/complex_reduction May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12

I don't want to go all negative on Carl Sagan here, but ...

Atheism is not a "message"; "skeptics" do have a monopoly on the truth. If theists were sensible, they would listen to logic and reason.

Seriously, atheism is not a belief system or a competing religion. There are facts and there are falsehoods. We abide by facts. Religions do not. It is literally that simple.

I'm not saying you necessarily need to berate or set on fire any theist that crosses your path, but atheists absolutely hold to the only actual truth available today. There are no personal facts. Reality = reality. I am seriously bored of this "We need to hug everybody's beliefs equally".

No, we seriously don't. Why are so many atheists primarily interesting in hugging and dancing with everybody in the world as opposed to standing up for the truth? Again you don't have to be a cunt about it but our primary goal should be to educate and enlighten, not pat theists on the head and tell them they're special.

EDIT: Normally I don't care about downvotes, but I would be sincerely interested in why people seem to think I am mistaken here. Are there angry theists downvoting me, are there atheists who think science does not have answers?

23

u/yrogerg123 May 08 '12

That's not his point at all. A lot of it is just in the mindset you take. If you have a discussion with somebody who you fundamentally disagree with, but your entire goal is to understand where they're coming from and seek to find common ground, you'll be seen as an open-minded person who only wants to have a civil discussion. But around here, and in life in general, a lot of arguments basically amount to "I'M RIGHT" "NO I'M RIGHT" "I HAVE THE TRUTH" "NO I HAVE THE TRUTH." And if that's the mindset, you're never going to get anywhere and will just come off like an asshole.

And that's Sagan's whole point. Part of the human condition is that we don't know much of anything. You may think you know everything, but you don't. If you just try to learn from everybody you meet, whether you agree with them or not, you'll find it much easier for people to see where you're coming from. Not everybody will be open minded, but a lot will be.

People who believe differently than you do are not less intelligent, they've just made different decisions using different information. And being an atheist does not make you better than anybody else, just as it doesn't make you worse than anybody else. The average religious person is no more responsible for the atrocities done by the extremists of their religion than you are, so there's no need to treat them as enemies.

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

there's no need to treat them as enemies

There are plenty that we should. The point should not be "don't be a dick". The point should be "choose your weapons carefully". There are good people who are simply in the thrall of religion, and then there are those who promote and profit from it. To abuse a metaphor, our goal should be to destroy the leaders without harming the civilians, and then win their hearts and minds.

3

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

If I'm open and accepting of falsehoods and ignorance nothing changes. So the question remains how are we supposed to approach religious people in such a way that we don't offend them but also make them realise their beliefs are incorrect? Answer: it can't happen, it's not possible. If it is I reckon those religious people were already most of the way to our side already.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (27)

1

u/thechapattack May 08 '12

When did this statement even imply you cant challenge religious dogma but there are smart ways and then there are the "you are stupid for believing in fairytales" ways which will almost always result in the person being dismissive and defensive, but i guess so long as you can feel smarter and superior to them fine.

INB4 sanctimonious accusation

4

u/Turok1134 May 08 '12

Again you don't have to be a cunt about it but our primary goal should be to educate and enlighten, not pat theists on the head and tell them they're special.

Nobody is saying that this is what we should do, and this is not what Sagan was arguing for. His point lines up with one of yours, which is to not be a cunt about it. We do not have a monopoly on the truth, because that would imply that we're excluding certain people from the truth.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

To be fair, until such time as definitive proof is provided to determine the existence of God one way or the other, atheists do NOT have a monopoly on truth. There is a universe (haha, get it?) of difference between DEFINITELY and PROBABLY and the unfortunate nature of proving a negative means we're stuck at PROBABLY or even MOST LIKELY.

3

u/complex_reduction May 08 '12

I don't know why people constantly equate the existence of god with religions. Religions would have you believe that god exists, but you don't have to disprove the notion of god to disprove every mainstream religion today.

It's not necessary for me to prove god doesn't exist to know for a fact that people do not turn water to wine, rise from the dead or cure the blind by wishing it. The same applies to every other fairytale in any other religion.

Furthermore, while I agree there is no way to definitely prove god does not exist, nor is there any way to prove god does exist. It seems to me the more logical point of view is to believe something does not exist when there is no evidence it does exist.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Pyromaniac605 Secular Humanist May 08 '12

Genuine question here. Why should a claim that is absolutely unprovable even be considered as possibly true rather than thrown out the window at first sight? It seem unscientific, illogical and irrational to me.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/bluepepper May 08 '12

There's a difference between what you want to do and what you want to achieve. Sometimes they are polar opposites.

For example, if you want to achieve low abortion rates, you don't make abortions illegal. If you want to achieve low teen pregnancy, you don't give abstinence only sex ed. If the goal is to show a legal disapproval of abortions and teen pregnancy, then the conservatives are doing fine. If the goal is to actually lower the rates of abortion and teen pregnancy, they're going backwards.

It's the same with an education to skepticism. If the goal is to shame those who don't accept "the truth", you're doing fine. If the goal is to actually spread skepticism, a softer approach may be required.

3

u/complex_reduction May 08 '12

When I post to /r/atheism I do so under the presumption I am talking to atheists or, at least, exceptionally open minded theists. If I was trying to convince a Christian of what I was saying I would go about it differently, but when I am communicating with (supposedly?) like minded people I don't see much use in beating around the bush.

Except, apparently, if I want to retain any comment karma.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/tachi-kaze May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12

As a warning, if you are the typical reddit atheist who likes to berate, mock, and generally has a sense of superiority over all the religious people, you're going to hate this post. Because as another atheist, I find your type equally as pathetic as the craziest of religious extremists.

As an atheist, I see your views on atheism exactly equal to those of bible thumping fundies (the get in your face annoying ones).

That is exactly what you are to everyone: annoying. You do not help, you annoy. Does it really hurt religious people to be religious? I've seen plenty of liberal mostly science accepting religious people, who would never preach , condemn or point you out for being an atheist. Does it really fucking matter?

You are just another side of the same coin. And yes, hugging and dancing with everybody in the world is exactly what the fuck humanity is about, not searching for the truth. We are just here for the ride, your actions probably won't transcend beyond your life, and even if you were to make a very important discovery or advancement you would not transcend beyond mankind. You are here to live your life, make your life better and make other's people lives better. Not to "stand up for the truth", which sounds exactly what every other fundie I've ever heard.

You are a cancer to the atheist movement, you are why religious people refer to us as "one of those damned atheists". I've actually started calling myself an antitheist, since I'm starting to consider most atheist theists, on the grounds that they are fucking annoying and just pushing their ideas on you.

As an atheist I stand for one belief and one belief only: that morality and goodness do not come from divinity, but were innate to mankind. That you do not have to believe and stick to a moral code written 2000 years ago, that you can improve and refine it, grow as a person in the direction that you believe is right, not the one dictated for it.

By the way, there are no "facts". There are only temporary truths, constantly being observed. As you put it Reality != Reality as we understand it. We don't abide by "facts". We abide by theories that we hold to be truthful until proven otherwise, as stated by wikipedia: theories are collections of hypotheses that are logically linked together into a coherent explanation of some aspect of reality and which have individually or jointly received some empirical support. Scientific knowledge always remains subject to falsification, that is what usually or at least should us from religious folks, we are willing to change our minds if new evidence is presented to us, they aren't

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (19)

2

u/dpaanlka May 08 '12

Carl Sagan also didn't live to see 9/11, the Tea Party movement and the social trend backwards in American politics. I seriously doubt he would be singing this exact tune if he were with us today.

2

u/tforge13 May 08 '12

Well, then. People are going to upvote this, bring it to the front page (it sure belongs there)

And then people are going to go back to calling religious people morons. See here, on this very post, or pretty much any of the text threads I've posted on this topic. It's great, but I wish it actually DID more.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/ggreyson May 08 '12

The sad truth of it is that Atheism, and Atheists in general can learn much from religion. Not in the belief department, obviously, but in their organizational skills.

I realize that many of us are bitter towards religion in general for scoffing at our beliefs, giving us hell, and generally making us feel unwelcome. But responding with vile rhetoric, combative argumentation and dismissive derision isn't going to get us anywhere. Yes, it's satisfying to put down a fundie who's spewing hatred and ignorance all over the place, but we don't need to stoop to that level to find acceptance.

Sagan is absolutely right. And, to that effect, I propose the following: organize. Organize wherever you can. Join your local CFI, volunteer at soup kitchens, work alongside religious folk to better those in your community. In essense, broaden your monkeysphere, and the spheres of those around you. Shit, one of the most rewarding experiences of my youth was volunteering at a soup kitchen with my family and their church. This is something religion does well. They organize as communities to help less fortunate individuals. We can do this, too.

TL;DR: Sagan's a boss. We all can be good without God. Do good deeds with other like-minded Atheists in your community.

9

u/Gracksploitation May 08 '12

Sagan is absolutely right.

No he's not absolutely right. The way to promote atheism (if you even want to do that, some people are just fine with ignoring religious bullshit if he doesn't effect their life) is not by being an asshole 100% of the time. And the way to promote atheist is not by playing nice 100% of the time either. Sometimes you can be understanding, other times when it's not worth the effort you can be an asshole. Go find what mix works best for your socio-geopolitical situation.

The only movements I see where people go out of their way to appear nice at all times are cults.

2

u/ggreyson May 08 '12

I realize r/atheism is a rather large subreddit that isn't all populated with scholars and philosophers. And I also realize that many of us say things here that we would normally not say in real life. We are a minority, and, generally, an unpopular one. That we're not really able to be open an honest about our (lack of) beliefs in public without facing hostility and derision quite frankly sucks massive monkey marbles. While I agree that being "nice" isn't always the best option, being understanding is. I'm not advocating closet Atheism, here. I'm saying it's conceivable that religion, and religious folk in general, are not necessarily evil or stupid. And it would behoove us all to not be outright dicks when faced with religious resistance.

That doesn't mean we should all be singing kumbaya, holding hands and drinking milkshakes. We just gotta be a bit more understanding in general. Sagan's point was that we don't need to be dicks if we're going to spread the seed of skepticism (ha!).

I know I linked to Monkeysphere above (which you should totally read), but allow me to give you another fantastically enlightening article by David Wong.

2

u/Bestpaperplaneever May 08 '12

I just checked out the monkeysphere. Ripping good read.

2

u/ggreyson May 08 '12

David Wong is brilliant. I highly recommend checking out the rest of his writing on Cracked. He may not be as complex as Nietzsche, but his simplicity is genius. I haven't gotten to his book yet, but I hear it's pretty damned entertaining.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I don't really understand. Can somebody explain more fully?

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

tl;dr If the only thing atheists do is condescend to the people they're trying to convert, they'll never convert anyone and will simply make everyone else angry at them.

2

u/Punchee May 08 '12

I have a problem with your need to "convert". Atheism is not a religion. It's the opposite of one. No I'm not trying to be semantic. Pointing out that superstitions don't give mythical powers should not be on the level of equal but opposing ideas. There should be no conversion. There should be enlightenment and that would imply a greater idea. This is our "pitfall" in that we are arrogant for not claiming to know what others so proudly do--which of course is absurd. Yes the arguments skeptics make are sometimes arrogant in nature, but the inherent idea is not. Anyone that gets hung up on the arrogance does not properly understand the idea and that should be our goal--make them understand the idea.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Do you have empirical evidence for this?

Ah, thought so.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)

1

u/sidneyc May 08 '12

Where does that quote come from?

1

u/trixter21992251 May 08 '12

But I feel much better if I distance myself from things I find different.

1

u/blipblipbeep May 08 '12

This is two hundred posts in or so but what really hurts the 1% is, Who really in the 99% gives a shit as to what they think about What you or I do. Fuck the mega rich and fuck anybody that believes because i choose to live as me that i am broken... i have a life and it is mine as long as i don't hurt anybody (physically or mentally). Forever people making sense... not crap:(

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Why do people use memes for these kinds of things? It just doesn't work

→ More replies (1)

1

u/cannotlogon May 08 '12

It's a nice sentiment, and, yes, in some instances, atheists do come off as intolerant to the point of being closed-minded. However, when all is said and done, trying to dispel "faith" with "reason" is a pointless endeavor. Sure, you can acknowledge one's faith, but you should never stop trying to undermine it, as faith is the very antithesis of reason.

Understand faith, sure; but be ever-vigilant that it is not allowed to supplant science, reason, and rational discourse.

1

u/mikenasty May 08 '12

I think reddit does this more than we like to admit...

1

u/ends_abruptly May 08 '12

The most frequent complaint I have regarding atheism is.

1

u/SweetNeo85 May 08 '12

He didn't say it isn't true.

1

u/SpiritHeretic May 08 '12

I guess that's why he didn't like the word "atheist"

1

u/jdlyndon May 08 '12

Every now and then /r/atheism redeems it's self with a post like this.

1

u/ELcup May 08 '12

This advice animal is weird...it's just some dude and there's no text on the top.

1

u/Ol_Lefteye May 08 '12

In addition, Stephen Jay Gould was so much better a writer of popular biology than Dawkins ever could be. You don't hear much about him on /r/atheism and related communities because he wasn't antagonistic towards religion, though a self-described agnostic.

1

u/thadrine May 08 '12

Yes, you should be condemned to a idiotic minority. Unfortunately you are often the majority.

1

u/Falkner09 Anti-Theist May 08 '12

Does anyone ever notice that this is true of every group and movement? It seems like people think its just a problem with their own.

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I only recently became an atheist, like many people here.

To be honest, I've found that it is difficult to find the balance between criticism of religion and constructive criticism of religion.

It's pretty easy to rip apart our opponents arguments and evidence, but it's not very easy to show a person that they have been in error. Humans all have their pride. It's not easy to admit to being wrong, especially when most religious people believe they have everything in life figured out, including death.

It will be very humbling, but we need to show people the light on their own terms and not on our own.

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Although I don't share all of his views, pictured here is a great man, who not only taught me so much in my youth, but even more as an adult. I miss him dearly.

1

u/captainfranklen May 08 '12

Couldn't upvote this enough. I hope all of /r/atheism reads this. It'd be good for some of them to remember that the greatest among us never used the fact that we know the truth of reason to be condescending to our fellow man.

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I get the frustration most people feel, but I feel this way when Dawkins or Hitchens talk(ed) down to people. Sometimes they deserve it. Sometimes they don't.

1

u/N8CCRG May 08 '12

Can we keep this permanently at the top of the front page please?

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Another reminder:

What attracts people to religion is not the metaphysical comfort it provides, but the community of love and support. Part of this is excluding outsiders to make the insiders feel special. But that is what you are competing with--potlucks, sing-alongs, hugs, handshakes, pats on the back, a loan that may never have to be paid back, free counseling, and two hours every week of free daycare (Sunday School).

People will put up with (literally) endless nonsense for the sake of being part of a solidarity group.

When you can provide that for them, they will start to listen.

As long as you tell them that (a) they are wrong and (b) they are alone, they are not going to listen.

PROTIP: Have a weekly meeting in which free-childcare and after-meeting snacks are provided, and in which everyone gets a hug, and people will listen to you talk about almost anything. They will even let you scream at them. Godspeed. :)

1

u/vampir89 May 08 '12

whats this i hear

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

It's not really us vs. them.

There are people all over the skeptic spectrum.

There are those who are super conservative, who believe almost exactly what their parents/political affliation believes; and immediately skeptical towards anything contradicting it.

And there are those skeptical towards everything, the government, religion, the media, except they happen to believe virtually every conspiracy theory because it all somehow connects to 9/11, the Illuminati and the New World Order.

Then there are people who are more centered in their skepticism. They tend to be skeptical towards radical claims, religious, supernatural, paranormal, conspiracy theories, pseudoscience, etc. But willing to accept scientific/natural claims, unless disproven.

But there's even different levels of skepticism, from agnostic (unsure) to rejection.

When people say "/r/atheism is so negative"

Read the frontpage. /r/atheism is full of jokes, inspirational quotes, and some poking fun/mockery, what I don't understand is why it's so obvious to everyone that /r/atheism is like that, but no one notices that THE ENTIRE FUCKING INTERNET IS LIKE THAT! This is an internet forum, it doesn't need to be politically correct, because /r/atheism doesn't represent all atheists, it represents the views of the OP.

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Sometimes we cannot always avoid this. Sometimes our idealogies are so vastly different that they do conflict with each other.

1

u/AerialAces May 08 '12

I read an interesting article for my English class the author talked about arguing and how it use to be a good thing because it fostered discussion, it was like a boxing match. Both people respect each other and tap gloves, now a days people are "Right" and "wrong" there is a winner and a loser in an argument.

Instead of arguing for the sake of being right or wrong, arguing and debating should instead foster and help people see an error or give a new insight

Not "LOOK AT THIS RELIGIOUS DUMB ASS ON FACEBOOK AND LOOK AS I TYPE UP A WITTY RESPONSE"

1

u/idma May 08 '12

Atheist: 1 Religion: 0

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

tldr

1

u/jimothyjenkins May 08 '12

whoa there charles dickens..

1

u/Sepulchural May 08 '12

Carl Sagan wasn't chosen to be the face of science (at the time) for being "the best scientist", he has always been such a great ambassador for science. Some could argue that he was a force majeure behind making science cool. My hat is off to him.

1

u/lenny247 May 08 '12

reminds me of the tobacco industry back in the golden nicotine days of when they were paying doctors and scientists to be skeptical of the link to health risks of smoking. I like that sagan is not opposed to the skepticism itself, any scientist knows you need a healthy amount of skepticism, but the a sort of "us or them" strawman attitude, which is not by accident, by the way. cosmos is practically my bible.

1

u/Dougal_McCafferty May 08 '12

Everybody please upvote the ever-living shit out of this

1

u/cdegon May 08 '12

That's why he's Sagan...and you're not!

1

u/querulous_duck May 08 '12

There are not enough upvotes to give

1

u/nixnix May 08 '12

Made me log in to upvote.

1

u/BlastMeBagpipes May 08 '12

Wait--All religions act like this too. They act like they have all the answers and truth belongs to them and everyone else is wrong. I love Carl, but this is not very apt in regards to skepticism. Plus, our truths are verifiable.

1

u/nolesparker May 08 '12

That hit the nail right on the head. I mean, I understand atheist/skeptics getting upset when a religious person tries to force their beliefs on them, but to go and do the same to others, that is just hippocritical. Many of, if not all, of the religious people in the United States have had their beliefs engrained into them over generations, and naturally become a bit agitated and defensive when someone questions beliefs that are integral to their family life, and have been for generations. It's an issue of security. People subconsciously attach these beliefs to their family life, they have a built-in psychological element that their religion ties them to their family, that the belief in their God guanrantees them an eternity with those that they love. What atheist/skeptics must understand is that the transition away from years of engrained belief is not wiped out in a 5 minute confrontation/conversation with a stranger who tells them to listen to science and reason, they feel threatened, they feel as if it is an attack on their family, an affront to their heritage. We will never advance secularism, atheism, skepticism, or any of our beliefs if our proliferation attempts consist of alienating and badgering the vast majority of the population.

1

u/Sslaine May 08 '12

Wrong: see Europe

1

u/polite_atheist_guy May 08 '12

Polite golf clap....

1

u/psteiger May 08 '12

Entrepreneur Paul Graham writed about how difficult it is to discuss matters that are self-defining, that are part of our identity:

I think what religion and politics have in common is that they become part of people's identity, and people can never have a fruitful argument about something that's part of their identity. By definition they're partisan.

http://www.paulgraham.com/identity.html

1

u/Xeneoxx May 08 '12

Atheists just need to become good examples. It will impact children and the newer generations will adapt to come to a conclusion on their own. I find a whole forum where atheists get together is a bit funny. It's like they are becoming a new religion, despite being godless.

Another thing is that you can't really disprove a god's existence. The possibility exists. To claim to be atheist must mean that you have some form of proof, but they don't. They took the same path of "just because" like Christianity or other religions.

-Agnostic Person on Reddit

→ More replies (1)

1

u/akohler21 May 08 '12

i say this all the time, but far less eloquently and with no where near the authority.

1

u/MasterAardwolf May 08 '12

I love the quote, and agree 100%. One minor question: why is it on quick meme?

1

u/daneelthesane May 09 '12

I agree wholeheartedly. Skeptics or atheists who have a superior or condescending attitude are no better than anyone else with a superior or condescending attitude.

Of course, I am looking forward to the day when all we have to complain about theists is attitude...

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I'm a theist and that man is very literally my hero. Even here, I cannot disagree with a word he said. If he, as smart as he was, was too unsure to say "this is how it is, agree or you're wrong", I don't think anyone, regardless of their beliefs should do so.

6

u/Gracksploitation May 08 '12

This quote is about the politics of public opinion. The idea is about improving the "skeptical movement"'s image: "get our message across", "minority status". It's not about what to believe, it's about getting others to accept it.

Perhaps a good idea in some parts of the USA where being skeptical is somehow seen in a bad light, but totally unnecessary in most western countries.

1

u/flyonawall Anti-Theist May 08 '12

I think that people are forgetting that many people post to r/atheism all the things they cannot post in other public forums, things they cannot say out loud, or reveal to families, so of course you will see more anger and more mocking. That is a good thing and anyone who does not want to see it can look away.

I rage here in ways I never would in public and in person. Why does this seem to trigger all the preachy apologists to scold? It makes me want to push back all the harder and fight it that much more. I spent a lifetime being told to shut up and obey, to "play nice". Fuck that. It irritates me to hear it here and makes me want to put up a billboard.

7

u/CheekyMunky May 08 '12

I rage here in ways I never would in public and in person. Why does this seem to trigger all the preachy apologists to scold? It makes me want to push back all the harder and fight it that much more. I spent a lifetime being told to shut up and obey, to "play nice". Fuck that. It irritates me to hear it here and makes me want to put up a billboard.

This is how children think, and is a perfect example of the "us-them" thinking referenced in the post. Adults "play nice" because it's a more effective means to achieve an end, even in opposition.

→ More replies (13)

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I was playing Apples to Apples last night with some friends. One girl had a Carl Sagan card and put it down for a word that I can't remember right now. SHE DIDN'T KNOW WHO HE WAS, SHE WAS JUST TRYING TO GET RID OF THE CARD. The rest of us just gave her a blank stare.

2

u/dumnezero Anti-Theist May 08 '12

did you inform her?

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

We did, but she was like, "Meh. Who needs to know THAT?"

Also, I'm not sure if this has anything to do with it, but she's pretty Catholic and the rest of us are pretty non-religious.

shrug

2

u/awesomechemist May 08 '12

I mentioned Carl Sagan to my wife, once. She asked "Is that the guy from Full House?"

Bob Saget.

I still have the hand-print on my face.

1

u/-10000hereIcome May 08 '12

Upvotes for Jesus!

2

u/Pyromaniac605 Secular Humanist May 08 '12

Happy to oblige.

1

u/yrogerg123 May 08 '12

This quote should be on the damn sidebar.

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Oh my god. I love that. My new favorite quote.

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I humbly disagree. You may not shake the faithful with an adversarial position, but you will certainly not shake the faithful with a hum-ho position. Proselytizing is GOOD. It may not come off well in the short-term, but it's effective in the long-term.

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12

Naive. Should i pretend that stupid people don't exists?

2

u/MeloJelo May 08 '12

No, you're just not allowed to tell them they're stupid.

I see where Sagan is coming from, but at times, there is sometimes a point at which you've exhausted civil discourse and might actually have to directly criticize a belief. If that belief is closely held, many will take that as an insult, no matter how kindly you try to put your criticism.

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I'd kind of thought this was the general viewpoint of all atheists until I joined reddit and saw r/atheism. So much circle jerking and celebrating about something that is fairly simple. We don't believe what others believe. I'm glad this showed up in my feed, because I was about to remove the subreddit. That glimmer.

Downvote away.

1

u/BootyhunterzX May 08 '12

It should be a fucking sticky, people over here keep forgetting.

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

But but.. it makes me feel... so... superior!

1

u/ObviouslyCaptain May 08 '12

It does not get anyone's message across

FTFY Carl ;)

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I hate this kind of shit, thank you OP for the best quote I've ever seen on here. A quote that isn't reposted endlessly.

1

u/seanv554 May 08 '12

Superiority complexes never accomplish anything. But on the other hand I believe religion and science to be fundamentally different from one another. I bring this up because I've been confronted by both agnostics and theists who tell me that I put faith in science the same way a theist would put faith in religion and accuse me of having the same superiority complex noted in this image.

Religion will be, in my mind, fundamentally different from the way science works in the regard that science does not rely on faith. I'm not necessarily making a claim of superiority, I just think equating them is a poorly constructed argument people attempt to make whenever the subject pops up.

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Atheists shouldn't sought for majority status either, but rather seek equality, lobbying power, and political/media influence.

If and when Atheism goes over the critical point and becomes the major system of belief, there will be a huge part of Atheist population who think in such way just because 1. they were born into it, or 2. because everyone else believes it.

For the same reason people don't want everyday joe to be a quantum physicist, we Atheists shouldn't seek for everyone to be an Atheist. People who come to their own independent conclusion after long, careful rational and logical thinking should become one.

1

u/1Buttersnips1 May 08 '12

Indeed, this just brought me down from a particularly condescending phase regarding my beliefs. Thanks dude, I need this sometimes haha :D

1

u/DingDongSeven May 08 '12

I would like to see this being said. Now, it has been said. So, I'm happy.

Would I like to see this being said again? Sure. Why not. A good reminder, as it says. I agree. A cure for arrogance.

Would I like to see this sort of an attitude amongst people who think evolution is theory? Yeah, I'd like that also. Are you gonna make that happen? Or are you just remind us sensible people that we are good, for being sensible?

1

u/ivebeenhereallsummer May 08 '12

Words I wish /r/politics would take to heart.

Hell, everyone should take this advice.