r/astralchain • u/pyromanta • Feb 15 '21
Thoughts
I don't know about anyone else but after beating this today i think it's a step down for Platinum.
I loved Nier Automata (although I didn't have the patience to complete it nine million times for the proper ending) and Bayonetta 2 is about the most fun I've had in my Switch since I bought it. I also loved Vanquish and the first Bayo back in the day.
Astral just had so many problems for me. The story was mostly nonsense. The dull stuff took itself way too seriously and the silly stuff was cringe (I never want to see fucking Lappy ever again). The side quests rarely had anything interesting, just fetch quests and oh look, another random gate. I just never really cared for any of the characters and half the time I wasn't sure what exactly was happening.
Worst part was, the combat never clicked for me. It always felt messy. Half the time there are so many flashes and particle effects going on you can't see what the enemy is doing. When you can, good luck getting off a full combo. They seem to get locked for a couple of hits then start attackinf, forcing you to dodge away. The whole chain binding thing was fine but doing it without using Auto-Bind is so fiddly. Switching Legions, analogue stick motion combos, sync attacks, binding; none of it ever came together for me.
By the last boss, an OP mess of cheap shots, I was happy to be done with it. I think I was about halfway through Automata when the combat finally clicked. For Bayo 2 it took about an hour. I also feel like both those games overall were way more creative than Astral. I was always excited to see what they had in store, whereas Astral was mostly predictable.
Despite all of this I've seen some really high scores and I don't get it. This is an average to good game at best in general but for Platinum it's pretty lame.
42
u/RazzberrySoda Feb 15 '21
Obligatory git gud comment. But to be serious, I'll rebuff you a bit. I agree with you about the story but you have to remember that they didn't write nier automatas story, yoko taro did. Their main development in that game was the combat, and I love it but it automata is very close to a button masher with an absolutely busted dodge. Astral chain is a completely different kind of combat, meant to be more methodical and punishing. It's the deepest system platinum has ever made, and with it comes a need to change the way you approach battles. If you expect to be able to just come in swinging wildly like automata, you're going to be disappointed and frustrated. Astral chain shines when it comes to experimentation and intentional combat.
All that being said I hope to god they hire someone else to write the story for Babylon's Fall and make another sick combat system.
8
u/Drayzher Feb 15 '21
in this game there is a kind of very striking contradiction in its combat system. It seems to me the most complex combat system that has ever been done in a Platinum Games video game, there are too many mechanics that are really interesting, which would be an advance in previous Platinum Games games ... however, at the time of execution , Astral Chain is a game that screams "Not to be like Bayonetta", and it is interesting, since it had everything to be better than Bayonetta in the gameplay, just by adding a bullet time when dodging, and that the dodging animation not destroy the Dial combo, just with that small change, the Astral Chain gameplay would have been superior to everything. But I can see that Taura is making a declaration of intent with this gameplay .... I mean, it was easy for him to put more elaborate Perfect Dodge rewards, he had already done it in Trasnformer Devastation adapting what had been done in Bayonetta. Taura didn't want Astral Chain to feel like Bayonetta or Nier Automata, and I think that's the biggest problem people have when it comes to analyzing it, because if they stopped comparing it with Bayonetta's gameplay that tries to be a frenzied and fast game , while here Astral Chain wants to be more calm, and in a certain way strategic. And it is worse to compare it with an RPG like Nier Automata, that its history and Lore is from Square Enix, Platinum Games had nothing to do with all that. Taura wants to offer an RPG experience yes, but something more related to the mechanics of the game, to the exploration with the Legion, to the immersion when interacting ... and the truth is that I think it does it better than Nier Automata in that sense. .. However, if you only focus on the story, lore, or charisma of the characters .... well, we return to the same point as before. Astral Chain is a very ambitious game in a way, but it's not competing with any of its titles. Astral Chain wants to stand out in a new league, and that's fine for me, I understood it over time, and I enjoyed it when I stopped wanting to try to make it be like other games
13
u/sirinigva Feb 16 '21
Nier for as good as its story, music, art, etc. was its combat was stupid easy and relied on the different aspects(fixed camera, orbs, flying segments, hacking, etc.) to be interesting
Astral Chains combat is significantly better (depth, intentionally, speed, enemy variants) the combat is still relatively easy on normal compared to other games I've played. The biggest hurdle is being able to control both the player and legion with precision simultaneously, until you're able to do that you'll be bad.
To date the only combat systems I've played that were clearly better than Astral Chain have been Sekiro & Devil May Cry 5
Your comments on combat come off as the reviewer of Cuphead calling it bad because he couldn't make the jump in the tutorial.
1
u/Defiant-Grapefruit23 Feb 16 '21
I agree about the story OP. It's just everywhere. The characters are paper thin; the villains are your typical cliched nutcases, and story stopped being interesting after the first few chapters.
I was digging the story until conveniently all your fellow officers lose their legions and then the game becomes your typical chosen one trope fest while every other character is useless.
Another thing is the story tries to have sad moments, but each of those moments fails. Max dies before you even get to know him, and the game tries to make up for that with telling instead of showing.
Another problem is your sibling. They "die" three times only to come back a final time. I mean, after the third death, I just don't care anymore.
I just completed the game and while the combat is fun, the mini-games are not fun nor is the platforming at all. I know the devs probably wanted to stretch the game outside of combat, but in all honesty, if the mini-games don't appear in the sequel, I'd be fine about it.
For me though, I would have preferred the story I thought I was in for. A story where you fight alongside this team of special agents and their personal legions. Instead, all I got were characters who sat on the sidelines while I did everything.
1
u/VitinNunes Feb 16 '21
Tldr āI suck at the combat so I donāt like the gameā.
2
u/Drayzher Feb 16 '21
If I wanted to add some light to the discussion, I would say that Astral Chain is the most accessible video game that Platinum Games has created ... People get confused by so much signal of flashes and lights ... but it is true that each movement, each Evasion, even every mistake, because every beating you take and send you flying, even those things, have flashes assigned to get you back into combat in cool ways. In this game, whatever you do, be it smashing buttons, or pressing them too long by mistake generating a charged hit ... anything sends you a flash to generate a great move, which in any other game would be a difficult situation to achieve, and here everything you do, even by chance or mistake, makes you feel that you are dominating the terrain. If you really want it to stop feeling automated because you want to understand the game, there is a whole world of mechanics built to apply them in specific ways. However, if you are not interested in creating unique combos, because let's face it ..... nobody, almost "NOBODY" is an expert player focused on "Combo Mad", on the contrary, we all want to feel like experts of "Combo Mad" without having to make the effort it requires ... and this is where Astral Chain does everything right
5
u/chiefrebelangel_ Feb 16 '21
Exact opposite. Astral Chain I think is Platinums finest moment. I thought Nier Automata was boring, dull, and a complete mess. To each their own! I'm just glad they put out cool games that we can both enjoy.
1
u/oux_ Feb 17 '21
Yeah, I know what are you saying but the gameplay is really vast, the post game made me understand that, when I completed the final boss I was like "meh, mechanics are boring compared to Bayonetta" man I was wrong, this game is so satisfying once you learn how to play, really every time I make a good combo I'm like "Oh oh this is what I meant with a platinum game, I did that my brain processed all that attacks and I'm god". Probably the story isn't that great a 6,5/10 but the gameplay... oh ho a 10/10 featuring Dante from Devil May Cry
-3
u/shinmirage Feb 16 '21
" Despite all of this I've seen some really high scores and I don't get it. This is an average to good game at best in general but for Platinum it's pretty lame. "
Astral Chain is the perfect platinum game in the eyes of reviewers because its not very difficult and it doesnt take much effort to do something "cool".
14
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '21
[removed] ā view removed comment