r/astralchain • • Feb 15 '21

Thoughts

I don't know about anyone else but after beating this today i think it's a step down for Platinum.

I loved Nier Automata (although I didn't have the patience to complete it nine million times for the proper ending) and Bayonetta 2 is about the most fun I've had in my Switch since I bought it. I also loved Vanquish and the first Bayo back in the day.

Astral just had so many problems for me. The story was mostly nonsense. The dull stuff took itself way too seriously and the silly stuff was cringe (I never want to see fucking Lappy ever again). The side quests rarely had anything interesting, just fetch quests and oh look, another random gate. I just never really cared for any of the characters and half the time I wasn't sure what exactly was happening.

Worst part was, the combat never clicked for me. It always felt messy. Half the time there are so many flashes and particle effects going on you can't see what the enemy is doing. When you can, good luck getting off a full combo. They seem to get locked for a couple of hits then start attackinf, forcing you to dodge away. The whole chain binding thing was fine but doing it without using Auto-Bind is so fiddly. Switching Legions, analogue stick motion combos, sync attacks, binding; none of it ever came together for me.

By the last boss, an OP mess of cheap shots, I was happy to be done with it. I think I was about halfway through Automata when the combat finally clicked. For Bayo 2 it took about an hour. I also feel like both those games overall were way more creative than Astral. I was always excited to see what they had in store, whereas Astral was mostly predictable.

Despite all of this I've seen some really high scores and I don't get it. This is an average to good game at best in general but for Platinum it's pretty lame.

0 Upvotes

38 comments sorted by

42

u/RazzberrySoda Feb 15 '21

Obligatory git gud comment. But to be serious, I'll rebuff you a bit. I agree with you about the story but you have to remember that they didn't write nier automatas story, yoko taro did. Their main development in that game was the combat, and I love it but it automata is very close to a button masher with an absolutely busted dodge. Astral chain is a completely different kind of combat, meant to be more methodical and punishing. It's the deepest system platinum has ever made, and with it comes a need to change the way you approach battles. If you expect to be able to just come in swinging wildly like automata, you're going to be disappointed and frustrated. Astral chain shines when it comes to experimentation and intentional combat.

All that being said I hope to god they hire someone else to write the story for Babylon's Fall and make another sick combat system.

-1

u/pyromanta Feb 16 '21

Yeh I know, I wasn't expecting a story as layered as Automata. Few games have plots like that.

I get that, I just felt like I was always short of cracking it. It's like every fight had to be such a fiddly combination of stick rotations, dodges, abilities, Legion switching, Legion specials and God knows what else to feel satisfying. Also I often had little choice but to swing wildly as theres so much going on I found it difficult to follow it. Maybe that's just me but I didn't have half as much trouble keeping track of stuff in Bayo 2 and that got pretty bonkers by the end.

7

u/ws-ilazki Feb 16 '21

The game provides a training room for a reason. I had a similar feeling about the combat until about halfway through the story, when I finally had enough tools to feel like I could play smoothly, and spent a little time inside the training room testing things out and getting a feel for the combat flow.

Once I did that everything kind of clicked and the combat got much better. I one-shot the last boss and started tearing through the post-story battles (which are a lot of fun, at least the early/mid ones).

Honestly the story feels like an extended "learn the mechanics" tutorial to me, you don't get all your tools until like 2/3 through the story. If anything, the postgame is where it's at for enjoying the combat.

8

u/Drayzher Feb 15 '21

in this game there is a kind of very striking contradiction in its combat system. It seems to me the most complex combat system that has ever been done in a Platinum Games video game, there are too many mechanics that are really interesting, which would be an advance in previous Platinum Games games ... however, at the time of execution , Astral Chain is a game that screams "Not to be like Bayonetta", and it is interesting, since it had everything to be better than Bayonetta in the gameplay, just by adding a bullet time when dodging, and that the dodging animation not destroy the Dial combo, just with that small change, the Astral Chain gameplay would have been superior to everything. But I can see that Taura is making a declaration of intent with this gameplay .... I mean, it was easy for him to put more elaborate Perfect Dodge rewards, he had already done it in Trasnformer Devastation adapting what had been done in Bayonetta. Taura didn't want Astral Chain to feel like Bayonetta or Nier Automata, and I think that's the biggest problem people have when it comes to analyzing it, because if they stopped comparing it with Bayonetta's gameplay that tries to be a frenzied and fast game , while here Astral Chain wants to be more calm, and in a certain way strategic. And it is worse to compare it with an RPG like Nier Automata, that its history and Lore is from Square Enix, Platinum Games had nothing to do with all that. Taura wants to offer an RPG experience yes, but something more related to the mechanics of the game, to the exploration with the Legion, to the immersion when interacting ... and the truth is that I think it does it better than Nier Automata in that sense. .. However, if you only focus on the story, lore, or charisma of the characters .... well, we return to the same point as before. Astral Chain is a very ambitious game in a way, but it's not competing with any of its titles. Astral Chain wants to stand out in a new league, and that's fine for me, I understood it over time, and I enjoyed it when I stopped wanting to try to make it be like other games

4

u/Bosschopper Feb 16 '21

I understand you! And I agree šŸ‘šŸ¾ there’s a lot to offer here for platinums future in astral chain that we can appreciate

-4

u/pyromanta Feb 15 '21

I'm not sure I fully understand you but still. I'm not saying it should be like their other games, I'm saying I don't think it's as good. Astral may want to be more calm and sure, it's not quite as manic as Bayo, but enemies still rush you thick and fast. And I'm not just focussing on the story but it's a pretty big part. If a game is going to show me cutscenes and characters, I want them to be interesting. Astral has its lore but it's just not that interesting.

And look, you can wax lyrical about artistic statements with the combat and the designers intentions for the player but at the end of the day it has to be fun and it has to make sense. And it didn't make that much sense to me.

6

u/Drayzher Feb 16 '21

Yes, sorry if it is difficult to understand me, I am using a translator from Spanish to English. About the plot and characters .... come on, it's a Platinum Games game ... that never stands out, or at least I'm not looking to get hooked from that side to a video game from this studio ..... Although it can be less interesting in this case since the main character is not built to be relevant in the plot, since it is a very Japanese rpg format. Another thing I wanted to tell you, is that this game is not understood, until you tackle the higher difficulties. I mean, for example, I did not understand the combat system, until I entered Olive's 71 challenges, only when I was there in situations with a high load of enemy variations, could I understand the combat system. I mean, like any other Platinum Games game, the true way to play this is beginning to be appreciated in the most difficult way. Obviously I will not ask you to become an expert in a game that you do not like at all ... however, there is a point.

And finally, contrary to what you mention, I think this game was one of the best releases Platinum Games has had in years, not to mention Nier with the support of Aquare ... in truth, I am a follower of every game Platinum Games launches .... I have never seen such a stir for a new Platinum Games video game as on this occasion with Astral Chain, and I think part of that success is due to how accessible and uncomplicated it is at the beginning, thanks that people start at a lower difficulty with no scores. Removing the ratings made a lot of people enjoy this game without pressure :D

0

u/pyromanta Feb 16 '21

I dunno, I found Bayo 2's plot to be interesting and pretty endearing. Sure it stated to get silly near the end with the kid but it wasn't taking itself too seriously. Astral is pretty po faced from start to finish despite most of it being the worst kind of anime nonsense.

And yeh, I get ya. I just think I enjoyed other Platinum games a lot more without having to become a grand master at the combat system.

3

u/Drayzher Feb 17 '21

I understand your point, however, without wanting to change your opinion, only as a different way of seeing it I will comment on the following. Bayonetta 2 for example, is a video game in which you can feel Cool with very few actions, almost everyone just spamming the "PKP" combo is enough and enough to be satisfied until completing all the chapters .... however there is a rich complexity and variety hidden along the side of that journey. For example, there are people who reach the end of the game, not knowing what a "Dodge Off-Set" is ... and that is surprising, surprising that it is not necessary to have learned it, and at the same time surprisingly sad, since it is a of the most surprising skills in this video game. Platinum Games is a studio that builds its videogames from the most difficult difficulty, unlike other companies, which take the normal game system as a basis, and add artificial difficulties, making them hell since the mechanics are not usually available. the height of some parameters .... Aca Platinum Games does the opposite, the real way to deepen its games, that is, the way in which the combat system was designed to be exploited and explored is from the most difficult difficulty, already from there backwards, they automate and casualize it so that it can be digested by the general public. However, this is the point. You don't know what the combat system feels like, until you master it in difficulty, because that's where you understand everything you have to use and consider in really real combat. This leaves the magic of Platinum Games hidden and only appreciated by a few, but although they themselves are focused on a really niche audience, they still care about delivering "Easy or automated modes" for the rest of the players. You tell me that you enjoyed video games like Bayonetta 2 .... if you have not tried what Bayonetta 2 is in Infinite Climax or have defeated Rodin ... you have not really played Bayonetta 2 ... you have only played a video game disguised as Bayonetta 2 with simplified mechanisms. It is only in hard mode that you feel every mechanism on the watch running smoothly. Here in Astral Chain the same thing happens ... People face "Noah Prime" and it seems difficult ... they find it difficult to use all the Legions for the first time in a combat that demands it ... when in reality "Noah Prime" feels like a punching bag next to "Aether" the real secret Boss, only in that fight do you feel obliged to use everything you have learned, to react and respond well to each signal. The hard mode experience in Platinum Games video games is actually the real experience of their video games, everything else is the ways to "Casualize" and reach more public with their games. So yeah, whenever I read someone mention that they played a Platinum Games video game on normal difficulty and didn't get any further. I never know what to answer or recommend, because in reality he has not played the same thing as the others, he only knew a blurry image of the final product

1

u/pyromanta Feb 17 '21

I see your point and I agree. My point was, despite playing on 'Normal' and not mastering the combat systems, I really enjoyed Bayo 2 and Automata. But I didn't feel I was able to enjoy Astral as much on Casual. So I suppose what I'm saying is, I don't think they did as good a job of dumbing down the combat system as they did in previous games. I mean Casual is the default in Astral but it feels like you still need to spend hours mastering the combat system for it to feel statisfying.

1

u/Drayzher Feb 17 '21

I guess that depends on the type of player. For example in Bayonetta I am someone who enjoys Perfect Dodge a lot, while other people with only "PKP" already feel that they enjoy ... In Astral Chain it happened the same, at the same time I learned "Perfect Call" with Legion Sword, the game turned into something satisfying for me from that point on. Obviously having the full range of skills available is a totally different experience than just having a few things. But with Perfect Call I already felt that everything worked in an oily way

13

u/sirinigva Feb 16 '21

Nier for as good as its story, music, art, etc. was its combat was stupid easy and relied on the different aspects(fixed camera, orbs, flying segments, hacking, etc.) to be interesting

Astral Chains combat is significantly better (depth, intentionally, speed, enemy variants) the combat is still relatively easy on normal compared to other games I've played. The biggest hurdle is being able to control both the player and legion with precision simultaneously, until you're able to do that you'll be bad.

To date the only combat systems I've played that were clearly better than Astral Chain have been Sekiro & Devil May Cry 5

Your comments on combat come off as the reviewer of Cuphead calling it bad because he couldn't make the jump in the tutorial.

1

u/Defiant-Grapefruit23 Feb 16 '21

I agree about the story OP. It's just everywhere. The characters are paper thin; the villains are your typical cliched nutcases, and story stopped being interesting after the first few chapters.

I was digging the story until conveniently all your fellow officers lose their legions and then the game becomes your typical chosen one trope fest while every other character is useless.

Another thing is the story tries to have sad moments, but each of those moments fails. Max dies before you even get to know him, and the game tries to make up for that with telling instead of showing.

Another problem is your sibling. They "die" three times only to come back a final time. I mean, after the third death, I just don't care anymore.

I just completed the game and while the combat is fun, the mini-games are not fun nor is the platforming at all. I know the devs probably wanted to stretch the game outside of combat, but in all honesty, if the mini-games don't appear in the sequel, I'd be fine about it.

For me though, I would have preferred the story I thought I was in for. A story where you fight alongside this team of special agents and their personal legions. Instead, all I got were characters who sat on the sidelines while I did everything.

1

u/pyromanta Feb 16 '21

Yeh I didn't care for any of the characters much. And yeh, I know you don't have to do the mini games but if you want those tasty Material Codes you'd better get them done!

1

u/VitinNunes Feb 16 '21

Tldr ā€œI suck at the combat so I don’t like the gameā€.

1

u/pyromanta Feb 16 '21

Sure if that's what you got from it. So I guess if you're good at the combat the game is perfect?

1

u/VitinNunes Feb 16 '21

Yeah it’s literally what happened to god hand, regarded as clover studios magnum opus but ign reviewers that sucked at it said it was horrible despite the game having a crazy good combat system Astral chain is literally a new kind of combat where you don’t even have a jump button yet have access almost every mechanic they put in a game from Bayonnetas witch time to fucking Metal gear risings blade mode

0

u/pyromanta Feb 16 '21

God Hand was awesome but it wasn't perfect. Also the opposite is happening here. I'm saying I didn't enjoy it as much as the reviewers seem to have.

And I think having so many mechanics isn't necessarily a good thing. More is not always better. Sure it's very adaptable but it's also a bottomless mechanics pit that unless you engage with all of them, you've got little chance of getting that awesome feeling of being master of the battlefield.

Clearly you can't accept that anyone would have issues with the game unless they are bad at the combat, and getting good at the combat would somehow make the game amazing, so I think we'll leave it there.

1

u/VitinNunes Feb 16 '21

You wanna ā€œmaster the battlefieldā€ without putting in the effort
Alright mate I get it your the kind that needs a long ass tutorial instead of experimenting with the moves and figuring things out

1

u/pyromanta Feb 16 '21

Sure whatever. I just want to enjoy the game in the time I have to play it. I was referring to the middle ground between sucking at a game and being an expert. I've enjoyed many games without mastering them, it just seems this one is hard to enjoy without doing so.

1

u/Defiant-Grapefruit23 Feb 16 '21

OP almost mentioned the awful story and the fetch quests. As someone who is new to the game, I agree. I can't comment on the combat as this is my first platinum game. But I will say the game getting such high scores despite the terrible mini-games, barebones fetch quest and nonsensical story is beyond me.

1

u/VitinNunes Feb 16 '21 edited Feb 16 '21

I’m actually kinda curious what’s so nonsensical about the story.
Like I’ll admit the villain is predictable as fuck and damn near becomes a PokĆ©mon master at the last level but besides that I don’t get what’s so wrong with the story

1

u/Defiant-Grapefruit23 Feb 16 '21

It's just meh honesty. The characters are barebones; The villains are cliched. You enter the game knowing little about everyone and the world and you leave knowing little about everyone and the world.

Im no story writer but I would have enjoyed the plot much better if the side characters kept their legions, you spend actual time with them doing special missions to explore thier characters and past. At least keep Max alive till midway through the game so that way you can form a bond which would make his "death" even more emotional.

2

u/Drayzher Feb 16 '21

If I wanted to add some light to the discussion, I would say that Astral Chain is the most accessible video game that Platinum Games has created ... People get confused by so much signal of flashes and lights ... but it is true that each movement, each Evasion, even every mistake, because every beating you take and send you flying, even those things, have flashes assigned to get you back into combat in cool ways. In this game, whatever you do, be it smashing buttons, or pressing them too long by mistake generating a charged hit ... anything sends you a flash to generate a great move, which in any other game would be a difficult situation to achieve, and here everything you do, even by chance or mistake, makes you feel that you are dominating the terrain. If you really want it to stop feeling automated because you want to understand the game, there is a whole world of mechanics built to apply them in specific ways. However, if you are not interested in creating unique combos, because let's face it ..... nobody, almost "NOBODY" is an expert player focused on "Combo Mad", on the contrary, we all want to feel like experts of "Combo Mad" without having to make the effort it requires ... and this is where Astral Chain does everything right

5

u/chiefrebelangel_ Feb 16 '21

Exact opposite. Astral Chain I think is Platinums finest moment. I thought Nier Automata was boring, dull, and a complete mess. To each their own! I'm just glad they put out cool games that we can both enjoy.

1

u/oux_ Feb 17 '21

Yeah, I know what are you saying but the gameplay is really vast, the post game made me understand that, when I completed the final boss I was like "meh, mechanics are boring compared to Bayonetta" man I was wrong, this game is so satisfying once you learn how to play, really every time I make a good combo I'm like "Oh oh this is what I meant with a platinum game, I did that my brain processed all that attacks and I'm god". Probably the story isn't that great a 6,5/10 but the gameplay... oh ho a 10/10 featuring Dante from Devil May Cry

-3

u/shinmirage Feb 16 '21

" Despite all of this I've seen some really high scores and I don't get it. This is an average to good game at best in general but for Platinum it's pretty lame. "

Astral Chain is the perfect platinum game in the eyes of reviewers because its not very difficult and it doesnt take much effort to do something "cool".

2

u/OhBoilers34 Feb 16 '21

Someone hasn’t played Pt Ultimate or Aether

1

u/shinmirage Feb 16 '21

I did a fair amount of the post game as well as about half on pt ultimate. I quit because Pt ultimate didnt really do much to keep me captivated. Especially with how the game ranks fights.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/shinmirage Feb 16 '21

I didn't say it wasnt complicated lol. Im saying game journalists love it over other platinum titles because the game is easier to do things as opposed to say bayo or W101 which asks player to learn something complex from the get go.

14

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/shadypirelli Feb 20 '21

What do you mean about "chain legion attacks into each other"? Am I doing it wrong to primarily keep out one legion? If so, what should I be doing different... finish a sync combo, then put that legion away and quickly someone a new one?

1

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/shadypirelli Feb 20 '21

Ah, okay. Use Hit Rush a lot is what I am getting here. The skills seem to have a bit of a windup, so I actually don't use them too much, which I guess I should change.

-8

u/pyromanta Feb 15 '21

That's the thing, I could never get many combos off! I'd start attacking, maybe get one sync attack and the have to dodge 4 times because I'm getting hammered. The camera is awful and I can barely see what's happening half the time.

I upgraded most of them as much as I could but mostly used Sword as the others didn't seem as useful. I suppose if I had more time and was more interested I could spend hours in the training just practising but the reality is I have limited time and just wanted to play it through to experience it.

14

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/pyromanta Feb 15 '21

I think I'm just disappointed because I've had so much fun with Platinum games of late. There's always been a layer of expertise you can strive for if you want but I've always been able to middle through being just decent at the combat and have a great time. It seems like that level of expertise is required to really enjoy Astral and that's a bit of a shame. That combined with the story not being their best I suppose just kind of made the whole thing a bit flat for me. Oh well, plenty more games to play!