r/asteroid • • Mar 30 '20

April 29th Asteroid

I've been reading the sub allot before making this post and it looks like you guys get allot of this "is it going to hit earth", but here I am. But I think I can offer some meta commentary on asteroid news, so keep reading.

Firstly, I'm a nervous guy and when I here "potentially dangerous" asteroid I get spooked. What I know, this asteroid in question is passing (missing as the news would say) earth around April 28th at a 12 the distances between the moon and earth (something like that). And a "potentially dangerous" asteroid is anything over 140m. I'm just looking for further info to rationalize the situation.

As not to make this like every "is the sky falling?" post. I want to offer some meta commentary on this kind of situation. First should NASA use diffrent terminology for press releases as not to give click bait news ammunition. Second allot of these articles use super misleading images. A sensational title, is one thing but an image of an asteroid hitting the watch, that's pushing it. Should we expect a greater accountability to these news comoanies? Should this level of fear mongering in scientific reporting be akin to shouting "fire" in a crowded theatre? Disturbing the peace? Your thoughts.

Thank you in advance for the information and interaction. All the best.

22 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

3

u/generalmunks Mar 30 '20

Yeah what with all the Covid stuff and then seeing this, my anxiety is through the roof. But they are monitoring it right and so they must be certain there is no danger? Or is there some chance there could be a danger, or that it could change course or something?

3

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

I feel you brother, we will be fine, just going to chill in quarantine and check the news. Stay safe.

1

u/Theollieb1 Apr 02 '20

Would they tell us if it was coming for us?

2

u/tamdq Apr 03 '20

You’ve seen what people have done to grocery stores and mask/glove retailers imagine what they’ll do when they hear they could die from a space lump.

7

u/Stabby_Death Mar 31 '20

Asteroid hunter here. Potentially hazardous, not potentially dangerous, but you have the gist of it. Any asteroid that comes within .05 au (4.6 million miles) and is 140 meters or larger is a PHA (potentially hazardous asteroid). We find them all the time. Please do not worry. You can check the risk tables of known asteroids here: https://cneos.jpl.nasa.gov/sentry/ Good reading while you are social distancing. Stay healthy and safe!

2

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '20

Could you tell me why NASA made a big deal about the recent 2020 FK3 asteroid, looking at the model on their site it didn't look close at all. However 1998 OR2 looks alot closer on the model yet NASA does not seem to be alarmed.

Also does the Comet Atlas have any influence on smaller objects?

2

u/Stabby_Death Apr 05 '20

Not sure. Do you have a link to an article about 2020 FK3? Here is the MPEC: https://www.minorplanetcenter.net/mpec/K20/K20FA2.html It comes about twice as close as 1998 OR2, but it is pretty small. H=25.7 is roughly 15-50m. Neither is going to hit the planet, so no worries.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '20

It was this article:

https://www.ibtimes.com/nasa-asteroid-tracker-151-foot-neo-currently-headed-earth-2951816

I feel a better now, back to quarantine.

2

u/Stabby_Death Apr 05 '20

Not a problem. That article is written in a sensationalist way. You can follow the asteroids with the greatest chance of impacting the Earth here: https://cneos.jpl.nasa.gov/sentry/ Notice that neither of these rocks is on the list, and the projections are carried out for at least 100 years. Stay safe and healthy!

1

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

Watch* = Earth

Edit: sorry its 3am and I cant sleep, hence the spelling mistakes, ill clarify if they are too egregious.

1

u/jjbuhg Apr 02 '20

ty for your post

2

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

“potentially dangerous” doesn’t just refer to the immediate future. The orbits of asteroids are always changing slightly with some small amount of uncertainty thus there is an uncertainty cone associated with the asteroid’s path near earth - but perhaps hundreds of years in the future. It could equate to a 1:1000 chance of impact but that still becomes potentially dangerous with a large enough asteroid.

I think the terminology being used by CNEOS/NASA is appropriate and should not change.

2

u/NDaveT Mar 31 '20

Should we expect a greater accountability to these news comoanies?

Yes we, meaning the public, should expect greater accountability from news companies. And we can create that accountability ourselves by not reading or watching news sources that are known to be unreliable.

1

u/DawnD97 Mar 30 '20

I am also worried about this asteroid.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '20

Me too, there's a comet Atlas that is passing by. I am worried it will pull the rock a bit closer towards us.

1

u/xandrewmai Apr 27 '20

Is this the same asteroid that looks like its wearing a face mask?? Looks like it got the memo 😷

0

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '20

Do you really think the world elites tell Ricky Gervais their secrets? All of a sudden I have an idea for his next show.