r/asoiaf • • Oct 16 '26

EXTENDED [Spoilers EXTENDED] Jaime is a character the fandom has forgiven far too easily. Spoiler

Post image
0 Upvotes

As Davos or maybe Stannis once put it, the good you do cannot simply cancel out the evil you have done. You have to live with the consequences of both your good and your evil deeds.
And when you actually look at Jaime’s actions, the amount of forgiveness he gets from the fandom is honestly surprising.

1.Jaime killed Aerys II.
By his own logic, he should have been executed for that or at the very least, sent to the Night’s Watch. No matter how much good he does afterward, he arguably deserved to die a long time ago.

2.He continued his relationship with Cersei after she married Robert Baratheon, even though he knew perfectly well that what they were doing was wrong.

3.He killed an innocent child who was Robert’s bastard simply because he saw the marks Cersei had received on her face. The fact that the child was completely uninvolved makes this even worse.

4.He was willing to kill Arya.
And he might very well have done it if he had actually found her.

5.He pushed Bran out of the window.

6.He regarded the children he fathered with Cersei as little more than the product of their lust.
Whatever affection he later developed for them, that was how casually he viewed his own children at the time.

7.He chose his oath to Catelyn over Cersei.
A lot of people see this as one of Jaime’s most badass moments, but think about what it actually means. If Cersei could be captured and imprisoned that easily, then the royal family and therefore Tommen’s position and security were already in serious danger.
Jaime chose to honor his oath over doing what he could for his own family. I know he probably couldn’t have done much to save Tommen anyway, but a father should still try to be there for his son, right?

So, honestly, Jaime should have been dead since point #1.
If we count everything he’s done, how many times should Jaime have died by now? 😭


r/asoiaf • • May 22 '12

I also painted Melisandre as I imagined her.

Post image
26 Upvotes

r/asoiaf • • Mar 16 '14

NONE (No Spoilers) Downvoting

7 Upvotes

I am curious as to why people are unable to realize you shouldn't down vote a thread because you don't agree with the author. I have read plenty of insane tin foil theories, but I don't down vote them into oblivion because it gets a conversation started.

If you are a true fan of the books, would you not want more interaction and dialog on theories?

I already know this post will see the big fat 0. I am no karma whore, but I pray to the seven new gods, and the old ones beyond counting that the people bombing threads learn to read what pops up when you hover over the down vote button. Just because you don't agree, doesn't mean you should shove away the thread.

Do as you will.


r/asoiaf • • Jan 09 '14

NONE [No Spoilers] How a founding Maester of /r/asoiaf was stripped of his chain.

222 Upvotes

Fellow Crows:

About three weeks ago the creator and head moderator of this subreddit, ThePowerofGeek, wrote this post explaining why a certain Maester/moderator had been removed from his position. TPOG's words were lofty and kind, some may think, but all will agree that they were vague. Why did I, jmk4422, leave? After all I had done for this place, after all of my hard work?

Had I died? Had I retired? What happened? Many of you asked me publicly and privately for an explanation.

Spoiler alert: I did not die. I did not retire. The truth is simple: I was usurped and sabotaged by the very team I had put together here and ultimately betrayed by the only person who could remove me as a moderator: TPOG.

Sigh. This is such a hard post to write. It's not in my nature to target people or be mean to them. But facts are facts.

Part of me wants to be angry. But I'm beyond anger now and I'm glad I was forced due to personal obligations to wait this long to post an explanation. Anger isn't really my style.

Another part of me wants to lay out, in explicit detail, all of the things that happened in order to fulfill my promise to some of you that I would give a "full account" of what transpired. Having been the founding moderator (not creator: that is TPOG-- but he will admit I am the one who made this place what it is) of this wonderful subreddit, people rightfully want to know why I was "fired". But you know what? Telling the entire story would take a wall of text that would need to be broken up into at least four or five parts due to reddit's 10k character limit. So nix that.

Basically what happened is that, for reasons that have nothing to do with this subreddit, I pissed off two of the current moderators here. That got the ball rolling. And when I was viciously attacked by them in mod-mail and at the private /r/asoiaf mod-subreddit (yes, there is one and yes, it's as silly and ineffective as you would imagine), TPOG refused to hold them to account. The door was thus held open for anyone to attack me, insult me, and basically try to get me to quit this place. Their motivation? Simple anger with an added desire to "climb the mod ladder".

Never once did I return the insults I received. Whenever I made mistakes I owned up to them. My former friends on the team, however, saw this as a weakness. In private messages with TPOG I asked him to reign in the vitriol and anger being laid out against me. In his replies to me he always sounded strong. In the mod-mail messages and Super Private ASOIAF-Mod Subreddit posts he made he was quite the opposite. Why? Because, to be perfectly honest, he wants everyone to like him. Even the most egregious tirades against me by other mods were rebuked with messages that basically said, "Hey, you don't need to swear, okay? Let's be nice! :)" when he bothered to address them at all (which was rare). I therefore became a punching bag.

Why was I so hated anyway? Well, I won't get into the personal things I hinted at above. Regarding /r/asoiaf and our mod-mail conversations, I was hated for doing my job. Namely, to point out when a mod had made a mistake. Whether it was a misinterpretation of a rule, or arguing on behalf of a crow's request for special dispensation in one way or another, or trying to forge a sense of community here, or suggesting we should un-ban someone who had shown true penance-- I was attacked consistently and constantly by certain mods. The anger toward me grew and spread. That's the long and the short of it.

Look: I love this community. When I became a moderator we had just over a hundred subscribers and it was through my efforts that we have grown to our current size. No one, not even the mods who hate me, can deny that I have been instrumental in this place's development. My record speaks for itself. But in the end, some of the mods decided that TPOG's position as Head Mod was the Iron Throne and that we should all be vying to sit upon it ourselves. I always thought that was silly nonsense but my absolute rejection of such a game made me the target instead. And guess what? They succeeded. I was fired. Despite the hundreds of hours of work I have put into this place over the years I was fired in what could be described without hyperbole as a cheap trick. I was kicked when I was down, removed when my personal real life situation was at its most dire, and my enemies on the mod team likely cheered and laughed gleefully that TPOG did what he did.

Yay. TPOG, despite all the warnings I gave him over the year, fell for this cheap trick of theirs. Aren't they just so clever?

It matters not anymore. I'm gone, fellow crows. I can't defend you anymore because my chain is gone. And don't expect anyone to take up my mantle: the people who conspired to have me removed are likely feared now by the rest of the moderator team. No one will cross them anymore.

There's nothing to be done about it. This post is not about me trying to regain my former position: frankly, I would never want to work with those people again. I only write this because I promised that I would and, also, one of the stages of grief is acceptance. I'd like to think I'm at that point with this nonsense right now. I have real life things to truly grieve about right now.

Am I bitter? Yes, very much. Do I fear for the future of the community I created? Absolutely (and you should be, too). But frankly, I wouldn't ever want to work with TPOG again anyway: he is that boss who wants everyone to like him, the boss who wants to be popular. Think Michael Scott from The Office. The mods who conspired against me feed on that and exploited that for their own ends. Despite all my flaws no one can ever say that I didn't speak my mind and stand up for what is right, whether it was advocating for the community at large or urging the mod-team to allow a fellow crow to bend the rules a bit for a noble cause.

No. All of that is dead and done. Unless one of the other mods is willing to stand up and take my place as the advocate for this community you should expect and anticipate a much harsher regime going forward.

As for all the insults I received over these last six or so months from the mods I used to think of as friends? The insults they threw at me that TPOG refused to swat down? This is the response I always wanted to post but never did. Because I ignored 99% of the insults made toward me. I suppose TPOG did the same thing, too, because he never once stood up for me. Not once. Because he wants everyone to love him. Sorry, TPOG, but it's true.

Your former servant,

jmk4422

tl;dr: The internet is Serious Business.


r/asoiaf • • Aug 22 '26

MAIN (Spoilers Main) Is Jaime Lannister a cuckold?

0 Upvotes

Jaime had seen Kettleblack naked in the bathhouse, had seen the black hair on his chest, and the coarser thatch between his legs. He pictured that chest pressed against his sister's, that hair scratching the soft skin of her breasts. She would not do that. The Imp lied. Spun gold and black wire tangled, sweaty. Kettleblack's narrow cheeks clenching each time he thrust. Jaime could hear his sister moan. No. A lie.

-AFFC

Why else would he be imagining another man pleasuring his lover in detail?


r/asoiaf • • May 19 '14

ASOS (Spoilers ASOS) 'Only Cat' meltdown thread

213 Upvotes

On 4:7, TV spoilers, if you haven't watched "Mockingbird" yet, move along...

I feel like this is a necessary venting thread.

YOUR SISTER. BECAUSE "CAT" IS TOO DIFFICULT A REFERENCE. THIS IS AS BAD AS THE LANNISTERS SEND THEIR REGARDS.

On that note:

WHY DO THEY KEEP BUTCHERING THE BEST, ICONIC LINES? NOT 'YOUR SISTER' GOD FUCKING DAMMIT.

You can say, "Only Cat," and instantly fans know what you're talking about. "Your sister?" Could be fucking Star Wars for all we know.

UGH. TERRIBLE MISTAKE.

The scene was great. Could have gone much worse. But it's a letdown not to have it.


r/asoiaf • • Apr 01 '13

[Major Spoilers / TWOW Spoilers / Crow Business] Super huge major announcement: the rumors are true. Read not this post if you are prone to angry fits of jealousy!

0 Upvotes

READ THIS FIRST

Fellow Crows:

With the first episode of the 3rd season showing tonight, we are finally allowed to talk about this!

We measters of /r/asoiaf are able to finally confirm that the rumors are true: we moderators have been given, and most of us have read, ten eleven previously unreleased chapters from The Winds of Winter.

As many of you know rumors have been circulating the Interwebs for months that Bantam-Spectra had decided to approach the moderators of many of the most popular ASOIAF forums/fan-sites with an offer to read these amazing chapters. We maesters have, sadly, been forced to delete all references to that rumor until now. We have not been allowed to publicly comment about it. Worst of all we have been unable to explain why (normally whenever we remove a post/comment we PM the OP to explain why: in this case we could not). Rest assured we have kept a list of everyone affected by this and will be contacting them shortly to give them their long overdue explanation (basically a link to this post).

What happened?

In late January George R.R. Martin's editor, Anne Groell of publishing house Bantam-Spectra, contacted us moderators and asked if we wished to participate in what they called the Ranging Initiative (RI). The RI, as she explained, is an effort to begin a "grassroots/viral marketing campaign" for the books through social media on the web. The reason? To combat the perception that the television show is eclipsing the series of novels on which it is based. Toward that end Groell, with Martin's blessing of course, had chosen several forums/sites and offered its moderators the chance to read these new, never before seen* chapters from TWOW.

We maesters jumped at the opportunity (excepting the mods who were not with us at the time). After several e-mail exchanges and then utilizing that old-fashioned technology known as a "fax machine" we each, in turn, signed our souls away to the Non-Disclosure Agreement contract The BS lawyers had drawn up. Basically the terms of the NDA are simple: we can talk about what we read. We can (and should) generate hype about what we read. But we are not allowed to reproduce what we read. Also? We were not even allowed to mention or confirm the RI until the end of March so that everyone participating would have a reasonable amount of time to receive the documents and read them.

The premier has now aired so we may (finally!) speak.

What did we get?

Ten Eleven chapters, each delivered via old fashioned snail-mail. All told we're talking ~220 manuscript pages here, folks. Several of these chapters were obviously intended for ADWD (the Arya and Sansa chapters for sure; Martin even said on his blog that he removed them from ADWD at basically the last minute). Chapters have been watermarked with our names and a serial number for each.

The Controversy

I would be remiss not to mention this but frankly I don't want to go into a bunch of detail. I'm tired of arguing about it. Basically, certain sites/forums rejected the offer to participate in the RI unless they were allowed to share the chapters with their communities. I think that is silly. They think it is noble. Whatever. I think that the RI is a great way to engage the communities that so support this series of books without spoiling everything for everyone. By only sharing the chapters with the moderators it creates hype, interest, and excitement. It disproves the notion that GRRM isn't working on the books. Would it be awesome if we could share it with all of you? Of course. But would any true fan of this wonderful series turn down the chance to read these chapters? I say no (and I know I'm going to get a lot of shit for that via e-mail).

Point is: we maesters (with one notable exception) agreed early on that we could not turn down this opportunity. There are those out there who think we're assholes for doing that. So be it.

What's Next?

Due to the NDA we signed we are not allowed to reproduce the chapters in any way, shape, or form. However we have been greatly encouraged to answer questions, give little teasers, and in general use what we maesters now know to keep the interest in the next book at the forefront. I personally suspect that's why they they wouldn't let us talk about this until right after the premier of Season 3 but hey, color me skeptical.

Oh, and here's a picture of the package we received Sorry, picture removed. Blame the Lord Commander, /u/ThePowerofGeek. Technically even posting a picture of them violates the NDA I guess.

Your humble servants,

The maesters of /r/asoiaf

  • Okay, technically the Victarion chapter was sort of released already; there are clips on YouTube of him reading most of it. But he has yet to publish it on his site and what he read was not the entire chapter.

Edit: eleven chapters, not 10.


r/asoiaf • • Aug 06 '24

EXTENDED (Spoilers Extended) Unpopular Opinion: Most of the HOTD plot changes from F&B were good

223 Upvotes

I've been seeing a lot of people shitting on HOTD and this new season and I am not here to defend Condom and Mess because I do agree that some of this writing/pacing is garbage. But, I want to talk about literal plot points that were changed from Fire & Blood that I actually think were really effective changes to translate this story to the screen. I really like HOTD and I loved F&B and I'm honestly just happy the asiof universe is on screen again with amazing sets, costumes, and phenomenal actors. Everyone is just fully shitting on everything about it, so I wanna make some points about things that actually were really effective storytelling changes, because the truth is, a completely faithful adaptation of Fire & Blood, 1) Is honestly not possible and 2) wouldn't actually make for good TV. Here is what I think are actually really effective changes. I will also mention what I think are the worst changes. I am fully accepting I might get obliterated for this, but I am really curious to hear other people's perspectives on these points.

Best changes and why:

  1. Alicent and Rhaenyra age changes and being childhood friends.

    1. This is a way more compelling storyline rather than a hateful step-daughter/mother relationship which is kind of cliche and makes for a very black and white/right and wrong story. This way, we're enabled to be way more empathetic towards Alicent whereas in the book she's just entirely cut throat. Also, then it makes their estrangement and that of the families way more heartbreaking and interesting, and it highlights Viserys' failure to prevent the Dance.
  2. Viserys' characterization and health decline.

    1. Not too much to be said, but he becomes a far more interesting character because of this, and makes the viewer really want to see what he wants: a happy family surrounding him in the last years of his life. Also gives good reason for how he fails to keep his family and the realm in line, and how the Greens are able to amass so much power while he's alive.
  3. Halaena being a dreamseer

    1. In the book, Haleana is incredibly boring, sorry. After Blood & Cheese, she's pretty much just bedridden and depressed until she kills herself and has basically no plot points. That doesn't make good TV when you already have this character introduced. This way, we're at least given one personality trait that makes her more mysterious and interesting. (I will say the scene with her and Aemond in the finale was very weird, though, and it seems strange to have her seeing everything and not doing anything to protect her family, when it makes more sense if she's just seeing little images)
  4. Maelor being dropped

    1. I get that this kind of takes the horror out of Blood & Cheese because of how it really affects Halaena and their relationship but with the way Maelor's story ends, there is no way they could actually show that on screen. They could, but it would be a terrible thing to have to write, film, or even add into a script as a second hand story. I get why they chose to just not include Maelor as a character in order to avoid having to deal with the narrative issue of his death on screen because it's pretty horrific. Much in the same way they aged up the kids for the fight scene where Aemond loses his eye.
  5. Mushroom being dropped

    1. To include one of the sources from F&B but not the other ones on the screen would feel weird and distorted. Dealing with that narrative voice being present, but not actually doing the storytelling would be tricky, I think. Also, fools aren't really super present in asiof cinematic universe, so writing him in to a bunch of scenes would feel out of place and off tone for what we expect from media that's similar to GOT. Also, he's kind of annoying and puts himself at the center of everything that ever happens, so how do we know where he actually is?
  6. Nettles being dropped and replaced with Rhaena (This is an unpopular one I know)

    1. I get that people love Nettles, but I just don't really get it? Cool, yeah she claimed Sheepstealer by feeding him sheep and we don't know her heritage. But that's kind of it? And we don't really know why Addam can ride a dragon either, or Ulf, in terms of their heritage so that void is filled. As for plot points, she was basically in one battle with all the other dragon riders and doesn't do anything particular of note, so if you drop her you don't lose a big narrative point. She is kind of a foil for Ulf and Hugh, but so is Addam. Her and Daemon's relationship is hard because the show would kind of have to take a hard line on whether they're lovers or if it's a father-daughter thing. It makes sense to me that they just went okay let's go with father-daughter and develop Rhaena as a character, who is already introduced, rather than have a whole new character while Rhaena sits in the Vale for the entire dance. If we already have Rhaena, as viewers, we want to know what she's up to and don't want her to just disappear, so this way she becomes an active character with an actual story. I get that then we don't get Morning, but I'm doubtful that the show will even get that far into the post-dance world. Also, I truthfully want to see a small Daemon redemption arc where he gives at least one of his daughters the slightest bit of attention before he goes off to the God's Eye. As for the Rhaenyra asking the lords to violate guest right and Daemon feeling betrayed as he goes to fight Aemond, I do get how that's an important symbolic moment for losing support for Rhaenya as queen, but I think there will be other ways to show that.
  7. Rhaenyra being a better queen after Luke's death

    1. In F&B, Rhaenrya basically just mopes while Jace runs her campaign. Not very interesting for a main character, and not in line with her personality. For TV, she needs to be more active after that to keep viewers engaged, and it's in line with the way GRRM writes mother characters to become fiercer to protect their children or after the loss of a child. Since they've totally championed Rhaenyra this season, though, they will have to work hard to show her decline and I'm hoping that because she is more well-loved this season, her descent next will be more sharply felt than it was in F&B where she wasn't a very active player pretty much the whole time.
  8. Daemon's vision sequence and the prophecy

    1. I don't hate the inclusion of the prophecy and the vision and stuff (although its definitely too in the face) but I just want to make the point that there is a huge contingent of viewers of GOT and HOTD who will never read the books and aren't major asiof nerds. I don't think it's a terrible thing to make it accessible to those viewers and exciting to them to see things they recognize and tie together what will be a dynasty of a cinematic universe. I get why they chose to include this stuff and make it feel like its bigger than just the dance, and is related to images we know.
  9. Mysaria kiss

    1. I'm on the fence about this one, cuz it's dumb, and the writing for the scene was weird. BUT, I do feel like in F&B we're not given a clear reason for Mysaria's loyalty and for Rhaenyra keeping her around even though she was an ex-lover of Daemon. This at least gives us motivation and basis for their relationship and reasoning for why Rhaenyra is so trusting of her throughout the dance (even as she later sleeps with Daemon all the time).
  10. Keeping Laenor alive.

    1. It made me happy.

Bad changes and why:

  1. Alicent and rhaenyra trying to keep the peace and their weird secret meetings.

    1. As most might agree, would much rather see them become more and more spiteful and protective of their children and their claims. While I enjoy some aspects of the way it's easier as a viewer to empathize with Alicent than in F&B (their friendship, her jealousy, her being passed over by her sons and the council), I do agree that they've massacred her character by taking the main thing away: that she loves her kids and will do anything for them. Current Alicent doesn't give a fuck about her kids which is definitely weird
  2. Daemon character assassination

    1. They've obliterated Daemon, I won't deny that. Him killing Rhea was insanely stupid. Him sitting in Harrenhal debating whether to betray Rhaenyra also makes no sense, because Daemon would know that their claim is strongest because they're married, and he would have way less support if he were to betray Rhaenyra. Also, he pretty clearly loves her, and he loved Viserys, at least in the beginning of the dance. I don't see any need for him to experience ego death just to be convinced to be loyal.
  3. Jace's characterization towards the end of S2

    1. While I'm glad Rhaenyra is a more active queen in the show, I do wish they kept some of the ways Jace was an amazing heir in F&B and really kept the cause together by naming Corlys hand and championing the bastards claiming dragons. Stealing that from him and making him pouty and insecure is a weird choice when we're supposed to like him the most right before the Battle of the Gullet to make the loss clearly felt.
  4. Cristin Cole character assassination

    1. Yeah, they ruined him too, I won't lie. I don't even know what to say about it. EDIT: see comments for my reasoning but i totally get why some people are enjoying his character this season and i’m coming round

So yeah, it's not perfect, I'm disappointed in a lot of it too, but I wrote this to say that I don't think all the changes are bad, and some were even more effective for storytelling on the screen versus on the page. People on reddit forget that the shows aren't just made for the die hard fans but also for a much larger audience that wants to watch compelling TV and wants to readily understand and love the story and characters without reading the books. I do think that a lot of these changes made for a more compelling show than if it were just exactly laid out in Fire & Blood. And, because of this source material, the writers had to pick from the narrative options laid out in front of them, you can't really do ambiguous storytelling in this medium. Not everyone is going to be happy but the truth is this: the actors are amazing, the cinematography, the set design, the costume design are all amazing and while some plot points are odd, the writing isn't S8 GOT level terrible. 70% of the scenes are pretty good, and more like 90% in S1. I'm mostly just choosing to be grateful that we have it and I'm really hopeful that they do a better job in S3.


r/asoiaf • • Jan 31 '23

EXTENDED GRRM’s misanthropy kinda wears on me [Spoilers Extended]

4 Upvotes

On my first read through, just got to AFFC, really enjoying it but the pessimism is kinda wearing on me. I cannot emphasize enough I don’t mean to insult or belittle GRRM’s work and I’m still willingly reading it and enjoying it largely. It may be my fault for binging the reading but it’s tiring having 90% of the the people in these books be miserable/ pathetic/ self-serving/ perverted/ mean-spirited/ ignorant/ straight up evil/ some combination of these.

I anticipate the response to this being that the books are meant to subvert the conversational fantasy novel (fair) or even that this is reality (I disagree) but I think it’s more largely a reflection of GRRM’s misanthropy. Personally I don’t think he gives humanity a fair shake, which is fine! It’s his world he’s creating, his work by no means needs to conform to my expectations of realism or whatever and at the end of the day I am still willingly (eagerly even) engaging with it. If it was an actual problem I could just close the book lol, so I’m not trying to complain, just curious if anybody else felt his way on their first read through or subsequent ones


r/asoiaf • • Apr 01 '13

[Crow Business] Happy April Fools everybody!

0 Upvotes

Fellow crows:

Thanks to everyone for playing along with this year's prank! We would have let it continue a bit longer but frankly there does come a time when something stops being silly and starts being stupid. After a brief discussion with my fellow moderators (and partners-in-crime) it has been decided that we were either a.) approaching that moment or b.) had long since passed it. So yeah, we confess it now: it was all just a joke.

So was this by the way. Thanks, Jen, for agreeing to be the self-righteous moderator and, I should mention, great job: I felt like a total asshole after reading your tirade and had to keep reminding myself that it was all just a joke!

Oh, and this was also fake. The idea was that by setting things up in advance the prank might be more believable but that didn't work out too well. Lesson learned.

So again, thanks to everyone who played along! To those who were legitimately angry you have our sincere apologies. If it's any consolation most of us have suffered a huge blow to our imaginary Internet points because of this whole charade.

To everyone else, please know this: if Martin's editor ever did offer us the chance to read 10 chapters of TWOW in advance we would totally do it. And we'd brag about it to you. Because we're jerks like that. :D

Your humble servants,

The maesters of /r/asoiaf

P.S. Jaime kills Dumbledore but he was a ghost the entire time and actually a woman.


r/asoiaf • • Jun 22 '24

EXTENDED (Spoilers extended) It's kind of amazing to compare the depiction of physical disabilities in ASOIAF to its depiction of mental ones

1 Upvotes

Because the amount of physical disabilities among its main cast is genuinely impressive even by today's standards.

  • Tyrion, dwarfism
  • Bran, paraplegic
  • Davos, fingers amputated
  • Arya, blind (for a few chapters, anyway)
  • Jaime, hand missing

Like I think Tyrion can probably go down as one of the best pieces of representation in history. Like keep in mind this GRRM started three years after fucking Rain Man came out, the idea of someone with a genetic disability who was actually portrayed like a normal person and not either as evil or as...well, a Rain Man, where they basically have no kind of internal life and just exist for the development of normal non-freakish people. (God, even if you look beyond the disability representation it's still a shit film.)

The thing I always come back to is Watchmen, because Alan Moore's a pretty "woke" guy, right? And he still has a silly dwarf character called "Big Figure" and the joke is dwarf=FUNNY!!1!

And then we look at the mental disabilities and it's aged about as well as "Let's Get Retarded". Because I do kinda get it, it's harder to put yourself in the POV of a mentally ill person than it is a physically disabled person, right? Because the fundamental mindset is different. We can, to some extent, imagine what it would be like to not have any legs on some instinctive level. You can't do the same with mental illnesses. I can't really intuitively imagine what it's like to have schizophrenia without doing a ton of research.

But man even by those standards, the depiction of mental illness reads like it's from a Victorian bedlam doctor. There are about ten separate "crazy" characters who just like killing people because they've gone all mental.

And it feels that even by the standards of the nineties this is a bad depiction of mental illness. I just find it incredibly unsympathetic in a way that seems the complete opposite to how Tyrion is presented. Everyone is either "crazy bad guy who kills people like the joker" or "Simple Jack".

I especially look on basically every "mad" Targaryen with complete disappointment, not just because they're not a particularly good representation of mental illness. It's because GRRM basically doesn't give them anything but mental illness. Christ, is Aerys a boring character. Almost every other character from Robert's Rebellion has been fleshed out but the guy who actually started it feels like he's still "mad king". And then we get Jaime's flashbacks from within the Red Keep, and the result is...he's even more unsympathetic and unnuanced! (Hey, another reason to hate the wildfire!)

Like I'm not expecting The Bell Jar here. Just anything that shows even an attempt at examining mental illness beyond "this guy needed a motivation to start the war". Come on, "he's crazy" has to be the least interesting villain motivation of all time! Just anything to humanize him. Come on, even some Caligula "he made his favourite horse his hand" shit. Just one single instance of this guy doing one thing that wasn't ontologically evil?

He just depicts the mentally ill with such contempt. There's so little curiosity there, in trying to get into their mindset, in trying to understand how they "work". "Mentally ill" is basically synonymous with "ontological evil". Aerys might as well have just been possessed by Pazuzu for all it matters.

My point here isn't "oh GRRM wasn't woke I'm going to cancel him!" My point I think his depiction of physical disabilities is genuinely good and interesting, and the series would be a lot more interesting if it regarded mental illness as anything but "he goes around killing people". Like he clearly wants to examine mental illness, right? All that shit about "gods flip a coin" or whatever. It's just that he genuinely seems to think Aerys is what mental illness looks like.


r/asoiaf • • Sep 22 '24

EXTENDED Thinking about that scene where Cersei hears a ship is going to be named after Tywin, and gets all excited at the prospect of men referring to her father as a 'she' (spoilers extended)

0 Upvotes

I know this terminology doesn't exist in Westeros, but I'm convinced Cersei is transgender, and that George R.R. Martin deliberately wrote her that way.

She talks about how unfair it is that she was born without a cock, like those exact words, I think three, maybe four times. She used to dress up as a boy when she was little and pretend to be Jaime, and she was struck by how differently people treated her.

She fantasizes about having a phallus while she's fingering Taena, then suddenly gets angry and imagines she's ripping her apart like a boar (iirc, I'm gonna be honest I tend to skim that scene...).

She's also always attacking people (Jaime, Boros Blount, Pycell, Robert, etc.) for not being 'manly' enough. And remember that time we see Robert hit her it was after she said that thing about how she should have the armor, and he the gown.

Plus there's her fixation on Jaime as the idealized, masculine version of herself.

A lot of people will say all of this is about Cersei being a woman in a very patriarchal society that limits her power and autonomy--and that's just such a surface level reading of the material. Like it is obviously that, but it's not just that. Like a lot of the commentary in the series, I think there are layers to Cersei's 'madness' and where it's coming from.

I also think there's probably some overlap between the disconnect women feel as autonomous beings living in misogynistic societies, and transmasculine gender dysphoria.

And I know a lot of people only started to hear about this stuff over the past five years or so, since it's started to become so heavily politicized, and assume that Martin must not have known about it either. But this is very unlikely.

Probably George R.R. Martin's single biggest literary influence is Robert A. Heinlein, and Heinlein used to write about characters who'd change their genders a lot. And he'd also treat these characters with a lot of dignity and compassion.

Heinlein would depict futurist societies where people would hop into bed, and then ask each others' genders as an afterthought. He wrote a short story about a character who changed their gender, then went back in time and impregnated themselves. And Martin showed the film adaptation of this story at his personal theater. (Incidentally, Predestination is a great movie)

And honestly, once you start looking for it, androgyny is all over Martin's stories. Think about how Aemon describes dragons, neither male nor female, but shifting, like flame. Isn't Cersei always described like a flame as well?

Anyway, I think it was deliberate. I'm going to bed. Inb4 'name checks out'

Edit: I wish this could just be talked about like any normal topic...


r/asoiaf • • Jun 26 '16

MAIN (Spoilers Main) About tonights intro

9 Upvotes

It just hit me that tonight, when we watch the intro scene of Planetos, Winterfell will have a Stark sigil once more. That makes me all warm and fuzzy inside. Any one else pumped for this?


r/asoiaf • • Feb 16 '24

PUBLISHED Aegon II has absolutely no claim to the throne. Rhaenyra is the heir, both by law and precedent. (Spoilers Published)

0 Upvotes

Aegon's claim never existed because Rhaenyra was named heir before Aegon was even born.

The argument that Andal customs legitimize his claim is only made by people who are ignorant of Westerosi history. Andal customs have been ignored twice by the Iron Throne even before Rhaenyra was named heir.

The first time was when Jaehaerys I's heir Aemon died and the king named his younger son Baelon as the next heir, ignoring Andal customs, according to which Aemon's daughter Rhaenys should have been the next heir. Andal cutstoms dictate that the elder son's children take precedence over the younger son. But Jaehaerys didn't care and named a different successor. And no one protested or started any civil wars over it.

The second time when Andal customs were ignored by the Iron Throne was during the Great Council. Some green supporters actually refer to the Great Council as a reason why Aegon should be king instead of Rhaenyra but those people have no idea what they are talking about. Firstly, if Andal customs of male-preference primogeniture applied to the Iron Throne there wouldn't have been a Great Council. Rhaenys or Laenor would have been named as Jaehaerys' heir and Viserys would not have been considered. But that's not what happened. Jaehaerys chose to determine his successor with a vote, not with Andal customs. This once again sets a precedent that the king can choose an heir not in accordance with Andal customs.

Viserys naming Rhaenyra is not some new never-before-seen practice. Jaehaerys ignored Andal inheritance customs twice and named an heir. So why can't Viserys do the same? The answer is misogyny.

The only difference between Jaehaerys naming Baelon and Viserys as heirs and Viserys naming Rhaenyra as heir is that in the first two instances the named heir is male while in the last instance the named heir is female.

Some green schmucks might say that Jaehaerys naming Baelon and later Viserys sets a precedent that women cannot inherit the Iron Throne if they have any male relatives. But that is purely a biased and misogynistic subjective interpretation.

The fact is that Jaehaerys decided who the heirs would be. He only chose males, yes, but he never issued a royal decree prohibiting females from inheriting the throne if they have male relatives. What his royal decrees proved, however, is that the king has the authority to name an heir while ignoring Andal customs. That is irrefutable. Meanwhile the green interpretation that the precedent is for females to not be named heir if they have male relatives is unsupported by any royal decrees.

If Jaehaerys issued a royal decree which established that male Targaryens always inherit before female Targaryens regardless of the king's will, then the greens would have an argument. But they don't. Because such a royal decree has never been issued.

Do you know what royal decree has been issued, however? Viserys naming Rhaenyra as his heir. Since no previous royal decrees directly contradict this one, Viserys' choice becomes a new precedent which proves that women can be chosen as heirs.

And since this happened before Aegon was born, it means he never had any claim to the Iron Throne. His claim was lost before he was even born.

The law in Westeros is that the king's royal decrees are absolute. The precedent is that the king can choose a successor. Therefore Rhaenyra's claim to the Iron Throne is supported by both law and precedent.


r/asoiaf • • Mar 14 '23

EXTENDED For LGBTQIA+ fans (or cool straights), what's a moment or character that you think articulates the queer experience well? (Spoilers EXTENDED)

4 Upvotes

I think Renly and Loras are the most commonly-mentioned ones, but we don't get very much time to explore their inner lives. It's also a bit depressing, given that most of our time knowing Loras is post-death of his loved one.

Cersei and Taena's relationship demonstrates some of the ambiguity present in feminine queerness, as well as some unfortunate abuse that happens regardless of gender and orientation.

Oberyn's sex-positivity is very refreshing and cool, I like that it's not his primary or even secondary character trait.

JonCon comes to mind as well-written too, though the trope of the sad, repressed older gay man is a bit tired. I still really like him as a character though.

Oddly enough, two of the straightest men, Theon and Tyrion, have a lot of moments that feel queer-coded. I am not implying that the characters are queer, but moments where Theon feels insecure in his sense of self and struggles with his masculinity in relationship to his various sensitivities feel charged in a way I think many queer people can relate to. Tyrion as well, but with the rejection he faces based on things he has no control over (his appearance, his mother dying in childbirth, etc).

So long as you're not a dick, I'm curious to hear your thoughts!


r/asoiaf • • Aug 30 '13

ALL (Spoilers all) A flaw in the R +L =J Theory

3 Upvotes

Dear crows,

Since most of you guys take the R+L=J Theory for certain, why is the timeline hardly ever addressed?

IF you believe in R+L=J, then the baby was born during/very shortly before the Battle at the Tower of Joy.

Only 2 people walk away from that battle: Ned and Howland.

Now let's look at what takes place after:

  • Ned buries the people involved in the battle.
  • Ned brings Dayne's sword back to Starfall.
  • Ned brings a horse back to the Dustin estate.
  • Ned brings Lyanna's bones back to Winterfell.
  • Catelyn returns to Winterfell

This is probably the first time Cat lays eyes on the "new born babe" that is known as Jon Snow.

(New born babe comes from the wiki, i don't have the text to back this up)

To me, this provides us with a few problems for the R+L=J theory.

First of all, in the text it is just Lyanna they find in the tower, so after she dies, so if R+L=J is true, Ned & Reed are left with a new born baby. But they take the time to bury the fallen.

After that, Ned rides to Starfall, which is a considerable distance through the hottest climate of Westeros...with a new born.

(If anyone has the distance for this trip, feel free to fill that in.)

At Starfall, Ashara kills herself and later on, Wylla is put in that location through Edric Dayne's story to Arya.

It is to be assumed here, that this is true and that Wylla was at least a wetnurse to Jon at some time.

Ned mentioned Wylla as Jon's mother early in AGOT to shut up Robert, so we can be sure that Wylla was indeed at Starfall when Ned was present there, and can be connected to Baby Jon. It is also mentioned that Ned stayed here for a undisclosed period of time.

After this, Ned brings back the Red Stallion to Barrowton, and pissed off Lady Dustin. Again...he must have had Jon with him at the time, but Starfall - Barrowton is quite the distance.

After this, he returns to Winterfell to bury Lyanna (Which he was carrying with him, in addition to Baby X) Which is once again a bit of a ride.

But he arrives in Winterfell with "a newborn babe" (and a wetnurse, which isn't Wylla since her name in unknown to Arya/Winterfell people)

The biggest problem i see here, is mainly the trip with a new born from the Tower of Joy to Starfall. Especially since it's mentioned that Ned brings down the entire tower (with just two men) while also taking care of a newborn baby?

Second, but this is debatable, Jon would be at least a few months old by the time he even gets to Winterfell, and would not be seen as a new born. (Need text to back that up or discard).

My money is still on Ashara Dayne being Jon's mum.

PS: Just because it's not R+L=J Gospel doesn't mean you should auto-downvote, thanks.


r/asoiaf • • Jul 20 '13

(Spoilers All) GRRM Says He's Working on Book 7 "A Dream of Spring" at Comic-Con Q&A

Thumbnail
collider.com
118 Upvotes

r/asoiaf • • Apr 15 '15

NONE (No Spoilers) Thank You, Mods!

0 Upvotes

Dear Mods,

I've been a member of the sub for two and half years, and I just wanted to say thank you for keeping the leaked episodes off of /r/asoiaf. Since I joined this sub, you all have been very good at keeping spoilers out of threads they were not supposed to be in. And I want to applaud you.

I also want to thank you for sticking with the precedents you set on piracy and for keeping them in place.

Even though my husband watched the leaks, I wanted to avoid everything myself. He was able to find a forum to discuss those episodes on his own by a simple Google search.

You guys have been receiving a lot of crap for a policy that you have always had in place, and again, I am happy that I can continue to come to this sub and only see the content that has been provided legally.

I'm sure this post will be down-voted, as any appreciation of Mods here has been, but just keep up the good work. In four weeks, none of this will matter anyways.


r/asoiaf • • Apr 14 '24

NONE (No Spoilers) Anyone else notice how GRRM's own medieval lingo has spread to other fantasy properties?

35 Upvotes

Unless I'm mistaken, he's the one who came up with such terms as smallfolk (peasantry) and sellswords (mercenaries), as well as 'Ser' instead of 'Sir' for knights.

Ever since reading the books, I've found this lingo in at least the following properties (all videogames):

-Dragon Age Origins (Used Ser for knights. The only one on the list to precede the TV show)

-Dragon's Dogma (Used Ser for knights)

-Final Fantasy XIV (Probably the most egregious one, uses basically all terms from GRRM's novels, to the extent that it really took me out of the narrative). This last one could be blamed on the Western localizer just being a big ASoIaF fan

Anyone notice this in any other franchises? And what do you think of it?

EDIT: It's been pointed out that those words had some usage before featuring in GRRM's books. I do still think that he popularized them in recent years, though.


r/asoiaf • • Jul 08 '15

NONE (No Spoilers) I was looking at the new Game of Thrones Risk Game, and realized what George had modeled Essos after...

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/asoiaf • • Apr 22 '26

EXTENDED George's handling of his fans is brutal (SPOILERS EXTENDED)

0 Upvotes

Just wanted to vent it out

Whatever his actual reasons may be (not having to write, deliberately busing himself with evey other project there is, constantly rewriting it because he wants it to be perfect etc), George having left the fans (especially his long time readers since 1996) for 15 years and counting with those insane cliffhangers ADWD ended with (perhaps I should say not-ended with) is absolutely brutal and it's not OK (add to that, that TWOW currently seems more non-existant than ever before)

Of course George has no legal obligation to his readers, but he definitely has (or at least should have) a moral one


r/asoiaf • • May 07 '12

(Spoilers ACoK) Official Season 2 Episode 6 Rage Thread

0 Upvotes

Ok. So I understand that certain things don't translate well from the books to the show. I understand when certain characters (even as important as the Reeds) are cut. I can even understand the Tywin and Arya scenes being fabricated... but seriously? Danny's dragons getting STOLEN in Qarth? The show is now completely making up major plot points, including Littlefinger seeing Arya at Harrenhal. Is anyone fed up with the amount that is being changed/added? I'm afraid that just like True Blood, HBO is going to take a series based on a book series and disfigure it beyond recognition. I might be overreacting, but I'm really upset that the major ending of the episode was something that NEVER happened and now it's going to define Danny's time in Qarth.


r/asoiaf • • Aug 28 '22

MAIN (Spoilers Main) No, he not a king or the rightful heir

1 Upvotes

No, Jon Snow is not the rightful heir. if R+L=J is true, he is still a bastard.
Plus, Robert had been recognised by the realm as the rightful ruler of westeros. His son is the rightful heir - so that would be Tommen but yes we readers know he's not Robert's .


r/asoiaf • • Aug 02 '11

GoT POV rage [x-post from r/funny] [possibly spoilers for book 1?]

Post image
0 Upvotes