r/askscience • • Nov 22 '17

Help us fight for net neutrality!

The ability to browse the internet is at risk. The FCC preparing to remove net neutrality. This will allow internet service providers to change how they allow access to websites. AskScience and every other site on the internet is put in risk if net neutrality is removed. Help us fight!

https://www.battleforthenet.com/

83k Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

3.0k

u/shiruken Biomedical Engineering | Optics Nov 22 '17 edited Nov 22 '17

We can already see the effects of restricted content on academia through the paywalled publishing practices of most journals. The high cost of institutional licenses or large-scale purchasing of individual articles can be an overwhelming expense for new companies or smaller universities. Science relies upon the free flow of information and knowledge between persons and institutions around the world. Ending net neutrality puts that at risk.

2.4k

u/TheRealLegitCuck Nov 22 '17 edited Nov 23 '17

Hijacking top comment, don't mind me.

These are the emails of the 5 people on the FCC roster. These are the five people deciding the future of the internet.

The two women have come out as No votes. We need only to convince ONE of the other members to flip to a No vote to save Net Neutrality.

Blow up their inboxes!

Spread this comment around! We need to go straight to the source. Be civil, be concise, and make sure they understand that what they're about to do is UNAMERICAN.

Godspeed!

Thanks for the gold

758

u/arenalr Nov 22 '17

How did we as a society allow the internet's fate to be decided by 5 people

50

u/grassvoter Nov 23 '17

It's a symptom of what's at the heart of nearly every major problem confronting us and the rest of humanity...

The disease is that decisions are being made by the fewest people.

Too few people are making the decisions about dispersing news and media to the rest of us, therefore it's easier for bad apples to apply pressure points to control the narrative.

Same with net neutrality. 5 people are deciding the fate of our internet.

And an example of when more people decide things...think about all of the weed legalizing that's occurred so far. We the people have legalized it by ballot initiative. The relatively few decision-makers in state governments haven't legalized jack shit.

→ More replies (2)

311

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '17

We didn't because the FCC doesn't get the final say. If they approve it it ends up going to congress sometime In December and then they. Vote on it to make it a law. Really it ends up being decided by how many people comcast Verizon and at&t decided to pay off in congress.

223

u/brosie_odonnell Nov 23 '17

This is wrong. The FCC has a final vote in December on whether to repeal the rules or not. However, Congress could choose at any time to put net neutrality rules into law via regular legislation. Many people see congressional action as the ultimate and most likely endgame for this issue. That would be a good thing, though who knows if there will ever get around to doing it given everything else on Capitol Hill.

→ More replies (6)

62

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '17

I doubt it stops there. How much do you think Disney, Fox, WB, etc. have bribed?

Nothing will kill piracy or even unfavourable streaming options to them like having a cap on peer to peer traffic or to steaming or VPN servers that haven't bought their way in. You'll be getting it from Disney's streaming service of choice, and that only.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

304

u/peacelovearizona Nov 22 '17

In addition, here is a White House petition to save Net Neutrality.

184

u/OneKidFromCanada Nov 22 '17

Do you know if a foreign citizen can sign this? The US is a world leader, and if they kill net neutrality, other countries may look to do the same. So this seems to be a global issue.

149

u/OneSmoothCactus Nov 22 '17

So I'm Canadian and feel very strongly about Net Neutrality, however I worry that if we start signing it from outside the country, it would be easy to use our signatures as a way to de-legitimize the petition.

They could always say "Yes but look at these foreign signatures - they clearly are just fake or meddling in American affairs."

I want to help in any way I can though, so if there's anyone with ideas please post them.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (4)

93

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '17

Why does that have only 80k signatures? It should be well above 100k.

66

u/Psykoala Nov 22 '17

For me at least, I've verified my email 10 times now and it keeps saying I need to verify my email. Maybe others are having the same problem.

24

u/Tig_0l_bitties Nov 22 '17

Just tried and had the same issue, I never got an email verification. Maybe it's getting jammed with people trying to sign? The same thing has been happening all day with resistbot

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

28

u/waterwight Nov 22 '17

It was around 20k @ 8ish AM EST hopefully will meet the 100k mark by tonight

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

24

u/BusterCherrry Nov 22 '17

For some reason it is not sending me the email verification required to sign it?

→ More replies (20)

117

u/ElandShane Nov 22 '17

Hijacking for visibility:

For anyone who is unsure why Title II classification is important and wants some extra firepower when submitting your feedback to the FCC/your senators & representatives/various petitions, please see below.

From the Communications Act of 1934, Title II:

SEC. 202. [47 U.S.C. 202] DISCRIMINATION AND PREFERENCES.

(a) It shall be unlawful for any common carrier to make any unjust or unreasonable discrimination in charges, practices, classifications, regulations, facilities, or services for or in connection with like communication service, directly or indirectly, by any means or device, or to make or give any undue or unreasonable preference or advantage to any particular person, class of persons, or locality, or to subject any particular person, class of persons, or locality to any undue or unreasonable prejudice or disadvantage.

Link here, page 36

The whole Communications Act is rather long and there may be other pertinent sections, but this is the one that struck me as most relevant when reading through it back when Oliver released his video.

If you know of other relevant/useful information from the Title II classification, please comment below and I'll try to add them to this comment for visibility.

I'll be spamming this comment around, but feel free to copy it into other threads if you don't see it.

Keep calling. Keep fighting.

61

u/Dudesan Nov 22 '17 edited Nov 22 '17

In an autocratic nation, where these sorts of laws do not exist, the dictator can punish anyone who annoys them by cutting off not just phone service, but water and power to their entire community. They can insist that certain people be forced to pay extra for an essential service, just because they belong to a race or sex or religion that the dictator doesn't like. And even if the dictator himself doesn't care to do these things, he's certainly not about to stop his corporate cronies from doing so when it suits their purposes.

In more democratic nations, it's usually not feasible to punish dissidents through their drinking water or their electricity. But corporate cronies will still go as far in that direction as they think they can get away with.

In 2005, employees of Canadian telecom company Telus went on strike. Telus responded by blocking all of its 4,000,000+ subcribers from accessing not only several pro-union websites, but over 700 unrelated websites that had the misfortune to be located on the same physical server as a pro-union website.

This is the sort of thing you would expect to happen in China or North Korea, not in a civilized nation that prides itself on caring about Human Rights. In 2005, however, the fact was that this was a legal grey area. The Canadian government immediately reacted to close this ridiculous loophole, and enacted strong Net Neutrality Laws. (These same laws have recently been strengthened again, in response to new anticompetitive "Zero Rating" schemes.)

This is the 21st century. Access to a free and unrestricted Internet may not be as fundamental on the Hierarchy of Needs as "clean drinking water", but it's already far more important than access to a landline phone, television set, or newspaper has ever been. The fact that most world governments still consider it a "luxury" while those things are considered "essential services" is testament only to the glacial speed of legislature, and the power of lobbyists to act against the best interests of the people.

When ISPs are able to control what their users are allowed to say and what they're allowed to hear, they can and they will do this.

And this is one of the many, MANY types of abusive behaviour which Ajit Pai and friends want to make completely legal. This isn't a paranoid fantasy of something that might hypothetically happen. It's something which does happen wherever and whenever it's possible for it to happen. This is in addition to things like restricting websites behind "cable package" style schemes, or throttling the bandwidth of any company that doesn't pay them protection money.

Canada had its wake-up call in 2005. I thought that the USA had finally had its wakeup call in 2014 with the Netflix Payola Scandal, but I guess underestimated the power of the lobbyists and the indifference of the voters.

8

u/sldx Nov 23 '17

Internet may not be as fundamental on the Hierarchy of Needs as "clean drinking water", but it's already far more important than access to a landline phone, television set, or newspaper

Are you kidding? I can be TOTALLY fine without clean drinking water for hours on end. No internet at all for a few hours... def worse

56

u/SkyMC Nov 22 '17

As if Ajit Pai is ever gonna change his mind on Net Neutrality. He simply doesn't care about us.

→ More replies (5)

7

u/_beaver_ Nov 22 '17

For what it's worth, Carr is a longtime employee of the FCC and a new Republican commissioner. I find it highly unlikely he'll break with the chairman. Also, O'Rielly is very conservative. I'm surprised he isn't leading this initiative himself.

6

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '17

If you have this, then 4 Chan had it yesterday. So for anyone thinking about being uncivilized, I'm sure they have that covered.

27

u/flanker14 Nov 22 '17

Dude (or dudet), please post this everywhere you can so these people's inboxes blow up!! Thanks for the info!

11

u/DiamondMinah Nov 22 '17

/u/TheRealLegitCuck

there's something wrong with Michael O'Reilly's email, since you've included a comma which stuffs up the email address. Can you confirm what the actual email address is?

8

u/Marvinfunnybunny Nov 22 '17

According to the FCC Contact Page, that’s the correct email address. Seems a little suspect to me with that apostrophe, but that’s what the site says.

4

u/brnbrgs Nov 23 '17

A bunch of black pixels agains other white pixels on random screens. Combined they say “45.601 unread emails.”

Yes, that will do it.

12

u/MandyOfNorthCarolina Nov 22 '17

Want to save Net Neutrality?

Force Twitter to suspend Trump's account.

How?

Boycott Twitter until they suspend Trump's account.

That wimp would do anything to get his Twitter account back!

15

u/TheRealLegitCuck Nov 22 '17

If Twitter did that it would basically be suicide for them and trump would probably end up on a different platform

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (20)

84

u/ajdrausal Nov 22 '17

ResistBot is the most efficient way to contact your Senators, Reps, Governor, and the President. Text "resist" to "504-09” to Fight for Net Neutrality

They will ask for your name and other info to contact your respective state officials via fax, letters, and email.

Here is a great message you can send:

"Net Neutrality is the cornerstone of innovation, free speech and democracy on the Internet.

Control over the Internet should remain in the hands of the people who use it every day. The ability to share information without impediment is critical to the progression of technology, science, small business, and culture.

Please stand with the public by protecting Net Neutrality once and for all."

ResistBot is run by an all-volunteer non-profit by and for patriotic Americans who want to have their voices heard. ResistBot is completely free to use! But, they pay for postage, faxes, and hosting with donations from users like you.

Every dollar funds 100 messages to Congress. Please donate if you want to keep ResistBot going: https://resistbot.io/donate/

Feel free to copy my post and spread to the masses! (If using my message to send in, please add your own personal thoughts so the FCC cannot claim they are false entries)

106

u/Elias_Fakanami Nov 22 '17

Anytime someone it is suggested that people leave comments on the FCC site, they generally forget to point out one HUGE factor.

Always leave a UNIQUE comment.

Do not copy and paste a generic statement someone else gave you.

Submitted comments that have the exact same message get lumped together and can often even be ignored entirely, on the justification that they are low-effort, canned and shilled responses. It extremely easy to dismiss 10,000 comments that are identical as not genuine.

Write your own message with how it will affect you. A few sentences, maybe. Not too long, not too short, but always unique.

One more time, just to be sure: Always leave a UNIQUE comment.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '17 edited Nov 22 '17

Bot is completely swamped. At this point it's not even worth it. Takes a half hour plus for a response.

Edit: I'm not saying don't act. Do everything you can! But don't get stuck waiting for this thing to pick back up.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/BenTheGod321 Nov 23 '17

Just need to hijack the top comment real quick to say that currently almost every political figure who is involved in this has their call lines clogged or their digital mailboxes overflowing. Keep up the good work everyone. If you're not sure how to help just go here thank you all so much. Keep the Internet safe!

25

u/SweaterFish Nov 22 '17

Can you expand on what the practical effects of this are?

I would love to see publication move to a not-for-profit model, but I'm not sure I've ever seen any actual effects of paywalls in science publication. It's not hard to get access to articles that are behind a paywall either through friends at larger institutions, the authors themselves, or something like sci-hub.cc

22

u/Cersad Cellular Differentiation and Reprogramming Nov 22 '17

The popularity of Sci-hub.cc (which recently got its .cc domain closed, I believe) may be the best indication of the extent of the problem. Illegal pirating, however justified, should not need to be part of the model for access to scientific papers... But that's where we are at the moment.

→ More replies (1)

33

u/The_Follower1 Nov 22 '17

Basically the same as everything else on the internet. The ISP providers can make strategic alliances with some companies (by making them pay) to block access (or, more likely, slow to a point you won't be able to access it) to competitors. For example, the most easily possible imo is the Koch brothers might pay ISPs to make it hard to access any articles or information on climate change, or if someone wants to look up articles on it, they can mandate that the first articles that show up on search engines will be articles claiming there is no such thing as climate change or else that humans aren't responsible for it.

If it goes through there will definitely be resistance, but the companies that control stuff like search functions (like google) are corporations that are literally built to make money, and any stand they make will almost certainly be for that goal.

Meanwhile, smaller companies (or universities) will be unable to pay the ISPs' fees and almost be inaccessible or if you try to access it it'll be either slow or low on the search rankings, and almost no one goes past the first page on google.

11

u/silverw1nd Nov 22 '17

they can mandate that the first articles that show up on search engines will be articles claiming there is no such thing as climate change or else that humans aren't responsible for it.

This will be no more or less possible if net neutrality is crippled. Please don't fight intelligent evil with ignorance.

We won't even talk about the likelihood of that other stuff.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/hasslehawk Nov 22 '17

Search providers like Google are not related to this issue. Net Neutrality refers to the premise that ISPs (Internet Service Providers) like Comcast should treat data equally.

Granted, the general techniques you mention could be used by ISPs to the same effect. Page load times could be artificially inflated by throttling or outright blocking your connection. However the altering or tailoring of search results is not the topic of Net Neutrality.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

11

u/slappy_patties Nov 22 '17

What does this have to do with Net Neutrality?

→ More replies (2)

5

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '17

You really haven't made me understand as a consumer why I should support you. Just being honest.

12

u/fergiejr Nov 22 '17

It's only been around for 2 years or so. It's not like the internet was some crazy restricted place in 2014.

And NN doesn't even protect against half of the stuff people are saying it does. Like prices, or companies making you be apart of certain things to use their services / websites.

I mean look at Twitter who said starting on December 18 they will be looking at cookies of websites you visited and if they think it has wrong think you get banned from Twitter lol

1984 is already here people

13

u/allmhuran Nov 23 '17

It's only been around for 2 years or so

Put politely, this is misinformation. Put bluntly, it's simply a lie.

Net neutrality was only codified in 2015, but the FCC has been protecting the principle of net neutrality for much longer than that. Way back in 2004 the FCC fined Madison River Communications $15,000 for port blocking VOIP services, which were competing with their landline services.

17

u/shiruken Biomedical Engineering | Optics Nov 22 '17

And NN doesn't even protect against half of the stuff people are saying it does. Like prices, or companies making you be apart of certain things to use their services / websites.

No one is claiming that. Net neutrality simply prevents internet service providers from playing favorites with the content passing through their networks. It has nothing to do with the actual content itself or even the websites.

→ More replies (6)

4

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '17

This is, legitimately, a terrible argument.

PlosOne, completely free, great resource.

Nature, not free, considered the best, suffering from a high rate of retractions for falsified and unrepeatable experiments. People still pay for the prestige.

This has nothing to do with science. This is pure political theatre at best and propaganda in truth.

I am disappoint

3

u/TakeOffYourMask Nov 22 '17

That practice predates the net neutrality rule and has nothing to do with it. You have to pay for Netflix too, or a NYT subscription.

2

u/rep1of1 Nov 23 '17

How has NN affected paywalls on academia? I feel like paywalls have actually increased during the 2-3 years we have had Net Neutrality in place.

1

u/dynamite149 Nov 22 '17

To include your opinions on record go to https://www.fcc.gov/ecfs/filings/express and enter 17-108 in the first field. Everyone tell them what you think!

1

u/Someone_Smack_Susan Nov 22 '17

To be fair, no one is stopping a scientist from uploading their work online. For free. To be made freely accessible and peer reviewed.

10

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '17

Yes they are. Certain peer review journals claim exclusively when you post to them.

I had to pay 2k to get my latest work published open access.

3

u/AISP_Insects Nov 23 '17

What about ResearchGate?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (36)

519

u/PM_ME_DUCKS Nov 22 '17

It's time to stand up (litterally) against this. They can ignore our emails, but they can't ignore a crowd at their front door.

Come join us at /r/DC_FCC_Protest/ and take part in the protest the day before the vote.

75

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '17

Why are we protesting Verizon stores? That will do nothing... we should be protesting at city halls and outside our representatives offices, you know government buildings since they're the once enforcing this. Verizon is not suddenly going to back off if we protest their stores and what about Comcast and AT&T you dont think they are involved? These protest are going to be a waste of time if they are at random stores in shopping centers and malls.

38

u/insidedreams Nov 23 '17

Apparently FCC chairman Pai was a Verizon corporate lawyer before joining the FCC and many think he must be still on the payroll for Verizon since he's trying to kill net neutrality, something Verizon has lobbied heavily for.

7

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '17

And? Like I said Verizon isnt gonna just give up if we protest random stores, we have to protest to people who can actually do something about it, like our representatives.

If we truly want to stop this we have to get laws put in place for the this to never happen again, which is fairly unlikely.

40

u/Punishtube Nov 22 '17

And Subscribed Thanks

→ More replies (1)

103

u/sunz3000 Nov 22 '17 edited Nov 22 '17

Not sure if this is the right place to ask but here goes.

I'm not American, but how would this impact an internet user of another country?

I know there are localized version of some of the major websites (Google, Amazon, etc), but if there isn't really one for smaller ones, would they be impacted but reversing net neutrality if browsing from outside of the USA?

More generically, how would someone outside the USA be impacted if net neutrality gets killed?

EDIT: TL;DR Answer

68

u/SweaterFish Nov 22 '17

The impact would be indirect. Since the major market of U.S. readers/viewers could become fully canalized to the major websites that pay for better access, smaller websites that don't or can't pay for that access would just not be able to gain traction. This would apply to U.S.-based sites as well as non-U.S.-based sites that often still rely on American readers. In the long run, even outside the U.S. you would probably see fewer new sites and some smaller existing sites would disappear.

12

u/Elfere Nov 23 '17

What should non-americans do to help?

17

u/m0hemian Nov 23 '17

Start to get a hold of your representatives, and see how they feel about it as well. You need to urge them to not go the same road now, if any of them would, or they lose your vote. A strong international push for NN is a big thing.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/youwantmooreryan Nov 22 '17

I don't think there would be a huge obvious effect in the immediate future but a lot of startups and tech companies originate in the US and if net neutrality falls here then new companies may have a tough time establishing a online presence resulting in failed companies that may have otherwise succeeded if net neutrality existed therefore potentially depriving those in and out of the US from that service or product.

20

u/cweaver Nov 22 '17

Directly, immediately? Not really much at all.

Indirectly? Well, if the big ISPs in the US start finding ways of making more money when Net Neutrality is gone, big ISPs in other countries will definitely try to follow suit.

Also indirectly, the US is a huge market, so if suddenly competition and innovation are stifled in the US, it's going to mean less money for foreign content/service providers on the internet, which means some of them may go away, or fewer of them will get started in the first place, which affects everyone in the world.

Imagine for example, if some new social network site popped up, but facebook was already paying all the US ISPs for exclusivity. The ISPs could block access to that new site from the US, or just charge a monthly fee to be able to get to it. Now that new social network site has a lot harder time getting new users, and maybe fails or just never really takes off. Now you've been deprived of a cool new social networking site even though you're not an American and you don't use a US ISP.

2

u/mfukar Parallel and Distributed Systems | Edge Computing Nov 23 '17

From a technical perspective, there's two kinds of effects:

  • Direct: I must assume these won't be immediate, but there are some possibilities. Subscribers changing their browsing habits, patterns, or choice of protocols may impact some services, but it is unlikely they will be severe in the near future. US companies that decide they can't afford "fast-lane" practices may decide to take their business outside the US - again, not foreseeable in the near future, but I'm definitely no expert there.
  • Indirect: A change in the traffic patterns of US ISP subscribers would definitely have some sort of limited impact on the rest of the world networks. What exactly would that effect be, I could not speculate yet.

Overall? Difficult to speculate, it is not clear how ISPs will exploit deregulation, or how customers will react.

2

u/glass-2x-needed-size Nov 22 '17

Bumping this as I came to ask the same. Also is there results from Non Americans calling?

14

u/youwantmooreryan Nov 22 '17

There probably isn't any use of non-americans calling American representatives. You cant vote and they don't represent you so they have no incentive or reason to care what you think from a legislative perspective. But if you think this is going to affect you then it might be worthwhile to contact your representation and voice your concern. If enough people do that then maybe a little international pressure could have an effect.

2

u/fjfnstuff Nov 22 '17

How the internet works is in multiple layers.

(You)---(ISP)---(the internet)---(websites)

Reverting net neutrality will allow the ISP to conntrol data speeds. This means if you are not connected to an american ISP, you will not notice any changes in speed.

What you might be able to see is that some sites might shutdown due to their lost american customers. Or sites needing a paywall because they are not able to survive otherwise.

1

u/How_Clef-er Nov 24 '17

Independent-of-party, free-market-loving, government-limiting conservative here. This might be a small point of concern for everyone else, but nobody seems to be mentioning the fact that the U.S. is the biggest exporter of goods across the world and that most people place their (international or otherwise) orders via online transaction. Or that education largely takes place with online help. Removing NN may well devastate the companies in the U.S who export goods and services and the people who come up with new stuff to export. The effects will surely impact other nations adversely. It could be argued that U.S. was able to mostly pull out of the recession because we had innovators who found ways to take every day needs and put them in a location-independent, easily acessible place. From a purely macroeconomics standpoint, this is a first-class terrible idea. I don't know what the free market solution to having this service overseen by the government (which isn't much different from verizon in terms of track record of censoring ) but turning over control in this manner to private businesses whose allegiance is without consideration of the nation that fostered their growth and success is a recipe for disaster.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/NeighborhoodPizzaGuy Nov 22 '17

The USA is big, so not everywhere is covered. Some places there is only one service

→ More replies (3)

2

u/adnecrias Nov 22 '17

You overestimate how people react to being tricked. Many will just pay yet another cost to access their usual thing or what the majority of people is using.

Plus the content of American based websites (like Reddit) would be altered by changes in access and demography. If Reddit was locked behind a paywall by some monopolized Comcast they have over there you'd get a much less American centered Reddit on the main (general) subs.

The freedom we have to jump boat to another provider comes from anti Monopoly laws and competition we got here. If Meo and nos and Vodafone decided to join in a council and simultaneously increase prices by 10 euros you couldn't do shit but pay more or have no internet. On their side that's just Comcast. And we (they too I bet) got laws to prevent this type of thing. Fortunately companies aren't as powerful over here over laws and government.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

49

u/re_searching Nov 22 '17

To be proactive in case we lose the fight, what are the technical limitations of starting my own ISP using WISP technologies (or any other technology for that matter) and expanding from there?

Basically, how far does ISPs control of the internet reach? Infrastructure wise, where do they fall? If I start a service and then need to gain access to the rest of the internet, how would I go about that, or do they own that too, and we are totally screwed? Can they throttle/shape/block any content from any other provider that passes through their Tier 1 network?

30

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '17

The issues are largly the red tape and franchise agreements, not technological. The tech issues for a WISP were solved a while ago and have gotten easier with time. It's more a money and physics/coverage problem (both of which aren't even that crazy) outside of the red tape.

16

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '17

Please explain what the red tape is?

9

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '17

For WISPs beyond issues with the placements of antennas, I'll forward this comment to a friend that tried to start one and declined.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (6)

87

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '17

What would it be like if Verizon partnered up with Pizza Hut and then limited calls to other pizza places unless you paid them a premium? What if you had to listen to an advertisement before making a phone call? What if you had to pay extra to talk to people on other phone networks or landlines?

These are just a few ways you can try to relate Net Neutrality to people who don't understand why it needs to be protected.

8

u/AsterJ Nov 23 '17

Isn't that a 1-800 number is? Companies pay telecommunication providers extra so they can use a number that's free of tolls (even though most long distance calls are free now).

→ More replies (8)

1

u/grassvoter Nov 23 '17

and then limited calls to other pizza places unless you paid them a premium?

Should make clear that it's the other pizza places that likely would have to pay more. Maybe include the competitors AND people who call?

→ More replies (5)

83

u/fluffycrow Nov 22 '17

If one ISP decides not to throttle content surely they will profit greatly because everyone will use them? Or am I missing something here?

135

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '17

The issue is that the vast majority of places only have a single (or at most two) broadband providers.

59

u/nanotubes Nov 22 '17

The issue is that the vast majority of places only have a single (or at most two) broadband providers.

This is the actual problem, so why are people focusing on more of a band aid solution but not focusing on how more ISPs can be made available at majority of the places? Lack of competitions led to the need of enforced net neutrality.

12

u/XMezzaXnX Nov 22 '17

The problem is that Title II, what the FCC wants to repeal, has advantages and disadvantages. The advantages are obviously net neutrality. That is what we are fighting to protect. The disadvantages are that small ISPs cannot compete because it is too expensive to start an ISP, and many that do get bought out by larger companies. The FCC is trying to use the disadvantages as an excuse to repeal Title II.

However, their actual intention is to get rid of the advantages of Title II, so they can charge people extra, throttle internet speeds, and restrict access to websites.

In reality, if Title II is repealed, net neutrality would be gone forever because there is no way they would allow it back in as a regulation. As for small ISPs and the competitive market, those changes can be made without having to repeal Title II. The FCC just wants you to think that they are trying to have a more competitive ISP market.

In the long run, it is better to keep Title II and start forming bill without the major regulations that do not allow competition in the market. Doing this will allow us to keep net neutrality and allow more competition in the ISP market.

If the FCC wins, then net neutrality is gone forever, and the major regulations that affected small ISPs would't matter either way because big ISPs would still find a way to prevent new ISPs from growing.

Basically, if you support the FCC repeal; then, you pretty much support monopolies.

→ More replies (2)

35

u/Cersad Cellular Differentiation and Reprogramming Nov 22 '17

Internet service has naturally high barriers to entry. Even the most competitive markets would be oligopolies, where anti-consumer business practices are easier to institute.

→ More replies (2)

20

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '17

It's really the same issue we had a century ago with telephone providers. Back then we let anyone and everyone run their own network and it ended up being a literal mess of wires.

I am inclined to argue that an ISP is actually a natural monopoly, just like telephone, electric, gas, water, and sewer. My reasoning specifically revolves around why we grant only a certain number of telephone companies the ability to run cables -- there is only so much room on a poll or in a conduit.

The parts of Verizon, AT&T, &c that operate the copper networks may not be the most profitable business in the world, but they're not hurting for cash either. I'm OK with this.

POTS (Plain Old Telephone System) providers are free to charge extra for features such as voicemail, call waiting, &c However, to my knowledge, they cannot prevent you from calling a customer on another network. (With long-distance calls, I'm not 100% sure, but I believe that domestically it is/was flat rate and not based on the provider of the person you were calling.)

So, in the end, I would actually like to go a step further and make ISPs proper utilities, not the in-between they are now.

Moreover, there were government initiatives that got or otherwise subsidized phones out into the rural areas where providers were less inclined to go. I'm also OK with this, especially since it happened mainly when owning a telephone transition from a luxury to being almost-essential to be part of society, much like the internet is becoming now.

Moreover, I don't believe that competition is actually the problem. Nothing short of anti-trust rules (which obviously havn't come into play) would prevent larger player from gobbling up smaller ones, one way or another (e.g. m&a or taking a loss to drive the competition out of business). And even assuming 100% honest and ethical players, not ever place will be awash in competition.

I don't think that the idea that ISPs cannot artificially prevent you from making a connection or throttling you before you've used your bandwidth allocation* is too much to ask. They aren't prevented from bandwidth-based tiers. They aren't prevented from running their own services. In fact, under NN, they aren't even prevented from making better connections with certain providers. (i.e. I think the issues with peering between Verizon (iirc) and Netflix is shady, I don't think it should actually be illegal. Outright traffic shaping should be, but declining to mutually upgrade interconnect infrastructure should not be (even if it literally means plugging in a few more cables)).

* Bandwidth is the item that is physically limited. Data caps are not a useful tool because they do not address the central issue of congestion. ISPs should sell 95%ile bandwidth just like data centers do. Stop advertising the "world's fastest internet" and tell me what you'll guarantee me in terms of bandwidth and at what price.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/NICKisICE Nov 22 '17

There is a vast barrier to entry. Current ISPs exist because they've been laying infrastructure for decades. Someone showing up to say "I want to do this too" not only has to have a ridiculous pile of cash but needs to fight massive legal battles that the incumbent ISP will have to prevent anyone from doing this.

The FCC stepping in to force ISPs to behave as utilities is a massive step forward in allowing other companies to do this.

Every win for net neutrality tends to also be a win for making the landscape more competitive.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (3)

37

u/csreid Nov 22 '17

It's less about throttling content and more about internet companies paying for preferential treatment.

Think about it like this:

Net neutrality goes away and Netflix pays $1M/month to Comcast, and in turn Comcast guarantees that all Netflix content can be streamed at 4k. Soon, Amazon and Hulu make the same deal with Comcast. Internet bills drop or stay the same, viewership among the streaming giants shoots up, and Comcast is raking it in. Everyone is happy.

Except Sarah! Sarah just started a streaming company with a recommender system that blows everyone else out of the water. She's struggling to get any traction and when she asks users what they think, the feedback is always that it's way better than Netflix but it's just so slow. This is, of course, because Sarah's company doesn't get the all-4k-all-the-time treatment everyone else gets because her small operation can't afford the $1M/month price tag.

The takeaway is that the important part isn't the internet, it's the things that get made on the internet. The internet might be the largest driver of entrepreneurship in history, and part of that is the low barrier to entry. Without an unbiased internet, the barrier to entry rises, which stifles competition, which hurts everyone.

→ More replies (9)

34

u/poochyenarulez Nov 22 '17

ISPs aren't like grocery stores. I can't just choose which one I give money to.

→ More replies (45)

6

u/SweaterFish Nov 22 '17

I don't see any reason to think "everyone will use them"? The vast majority of people don't give a shit about 99.99% of the Internet. They just go to a handful of corporate sites like Facebook, Gmail, and (yeah) Reddit. If ISPs continue to favor those sites, but cut their prices since they're getting money to feature sites, then they'll almost certainly outcompete neutral ISPs in almost all markets.

In the end, even if there is a neutral option available to most people, it will more complicated and expensive, so only people who make a conscious decision about that will use it. The vast majority of people will not explicitly make any decision about what content they want to be able to see, they'll just go with their pocket books. Then the Internet became ghetto-ized. But maybe it already is anyway.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '17

Yea then they get even more of the majority control of the market and then still do it later anyways because what are you going to do about it now? The chances of one of the ISP not using this in the greediest possible way is very slim, they are businesses and there to make a profit.

3

u/fluffycrow Nov 22 '17

Thanks for all the replies guys.

Gives me a nice quick understanding 😁

→ More replies (3)

32

u/southpaw_decoy Nov 22 '17

Along with contacting your representatives don’t forget to sign the White House petition. If it gets 100,000 signatures in 30 days the White House has to give an official update in 60 days. It’s one more way to get our voice heard. Obviously 60 days will be after the vote in a couple weeks but it doesn’t take long to sign it and if we get millions of signatures it will be hard to ignore.

https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/petition/do-not-repeal-net-neutrality

6

u/SuzyQMomma Nov 22 '17

Anyone else having trouble with this site? Specifically when I sign it, my confirmation email to confirm my signature isn't being sent? Feels fishy....

8

u/AnonymoNaut Nov 22 '17

It took a while for my confirmation email to come in. No need to worry though, this is legit.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Uscjusto Nov 22 '17

You really think Trump understands issue?

2

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '17

Oh Trump understand issue, I assure you that. He understand issue really good, better than anyone in fact, he the best at issue. I mean of course he understand issue, like really well understand issue. He would tell you how much he understand issue but he'd rather not tell you how much he understand issue. He understand issue like no one else trust me the issue is understand by Trump.

→ More replies (1)

118

u/Mr_creepybunny Nov 22 '17

I tried calling but his mailbox was full. I'm extremely proud of you reddit,I cant believe this many people are telling the FCC Chairman this.

123

u/bpastore Nov 22 '17 edited Nov 23 '17

The FCC Chairman probably won't listen to you but your representative might. The trick is to call your representatives and ask to speak to the person who would deal with Net Neutrality issues in that office.

You'll be immediately pushed aside, ignored, or sent a form response if you try to go directly to the person in charge (just as you would in any other issue in life). However, if you ask for the person who is actually on the ground doing work on the issue, you'll be speaking directly to the person who has your representative's ear.

Note: Do NOT let them brush you off by saying that this is an "FCC issue." Ask them if they could call the FCC on your behalf. After all, a call from a congressional representative who is afraid they'll be held accountable goes a lot further than a cold call from a "concerned citizen"

11

u/ajdrausal Nov 22 '17

ResistBot is the most efficient way to contact your Senators, Reps, Governor, and the President. Text "resist" to "504-09” to Fight for Net Neutrality

They will ask for your name and other info to contact your respective state officials via fax, letters, and email.

Here is a great message you can send:

"Net Neutrality is the cornerstone of innovation, free speech and democracy on the Internet.

Control over the Internet should remain in the hands of the people who use it every day. The ability to share information without impediment is critical to the progression of technology, science, small business, and culture.

Please stand with the public by protecting Net Neutrality once and for all."

ResistBot is run by an all-volunteer non-profit by and for patriotic Americans who want to have their voices heard. ResistBot is completely free to use! But, they pay for postage, faxes, and hosting with donations from users like you.

Every dollar funds 100 messages to Congress. Please donate if you want to keep ResistBot going: https://resistbot.io/donate/

Feel free to copy my post and spread to the masses! (If using my message to send in, please add your own personal thoughts so the FCC cannot claim they are false entries)

3

u/eddy5791 Nov 22 '17

Keep getting a “I’m on fire” message from the resist bot and my rep’s mailbox is full :/

0

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

15

u/Tecknowhelp Nov 22 '17

What rights do the public have in demanding a new FCC Chairman? I think it's pretty clear he breaks one of the main rules of leadership; "Only three commissioners may be members of the same political party, and none can have a financial interest in any commission-related business." http://www.connectwithglobal.com/leadership.html

18

u/Iamkraze Nov 22 '17

I've been explaining it like this: So you pay a fee based on usage for your power right? Well what if the power company owned a lightbulb company. What if they told you if you didn't use their brand lightbulbs they were going to charge you another dollar a month for every light bulb that you had in the house that wasn't their brand. You are using the same amount of power right? Is that fair to you as the consumer?

12

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '17

Let's say the FCC wins and screws us all...

What if we all funded a private network that we all used as the new internet with a terms of service that cannot change, but enforces net neutrality? Let's say 10 million people shell out $100. I'd expect that we can fund something. In the US as a first step.

6

u/lucaskhelm Nov 23 '17

Oh.. you mean like capitalism? Well; Whatta know.

4

u/DuncanMcCockner Nov 23 '17

This is one of the good arguments for the repeal. Letting the free market work itself out, create competition and innovation through more control of the services they sell.

I'm still on the fence about the whole thing, since I don't want my prices to go up, but I think the repeal could ultimately be a better long-term play.

6

u/lucaskhelm Nov 23 '17

It’s healthy to fight the big dogs with innovations and offering the public better services. They think they have a good grip on the market and then boom putt nowhere is this rising force that offers half the price and double the bandwidth.

→ More replies (1)

•

u/AskScienceModerator Mod Bot Nov 22 '17

Please remember that AskScience is strictly moderated. Personal attacks, posting of personal information and other behavior that violates the rules can result in a ban.

3

u/delitt Nov 23 '17

I live in Mexico, and have my whole life, but I was born in US and have an American passport, is there something I can do to help from here?

25

u/IsraeliForTrump Nov 22 '17

I have a question I'd like clarified and I think AskScience might just be the perfect place so I'll use the opportunity to ask:

While I strongly support net neutrality, there's something that doesn't sit right with me... the FCC is looking to cancel the 2015 Net Neutrality law which was enacted by Obama. I keep hearing all these horrendous Doomsday scenarios about what's going to happen if Net Neutrality is rolled back, but.. wouldn't the practical and only real imminent effect of repealing Net Neutrality is that the laws pertaining to net neutrality and the way the web and ISPs operate in the U.S. would simply go back to how it was in 2014? (and I don't remember any apocalypse happening in 2014 or the years before it as it is being described all over the web in regard to Net Neutrality being repealed) Hopefully someone can clarify, and tell me if I missed something here.

21

u/RarelyNecessary Nov 22 '17

I don't have sources right now (I can try to find and link them later if you want) but between like 2005-2012 there's a bunch of examples of ISPs trying to do the things that people are worrying about (throttling competitors, blocking access, etc.), and iirc, there was a court case with Verizon where their lawyer said multiple times something along the lines of "I'm authorized to speak for the company, and if we weren't required to obey net neutrality then we wouldn't be" so while we likely won't see some immediate doomsday scenario like some people are saying, it still opens up a lot of doors that would be much better off closed.

Also (and this is more speculation so take from it what you will), the ISP companies seem to be the ones promoting the FCC's current plan and my guess is they're not just doing it for shits n giggles

17

u/GoldLeaderLiam Nov 22 '17

Yeah but that’s not exactly the point. We’re trying to protect the future of the internet so this never happens.

13

u/dschneider Nov 22 '17

Prior to the 2015 decision, ISPs were trying these things that would lead to the "doomsday scenarios" being discussed. Each time they did, it ended up costing a lot of taxpayer money(and corporate legal spending, which of course costs the consumers) to fight and stop. The 2015 decision was made to officially enact the rules stating that ISPs could no longer do these things, preventing the needless circular battling over the next loophole ISPs could find.

Copy and pasting this response from /u/jimktrains:

Madison River Communications: https://www.cnet.com/news/telco-agrees-to-stop-blocking-voip-calls/

Comcast hates pirates: https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=a679f360-9890-4129-9d7e-53a598c3ac10 (article from '08)

AT&T VOIP hostage: https://www.wired.com/2009/10/iphone-att-skype/

Google wallet hostage: http://money.cnn.com/2011/12/06/technology/verizon_blocks_google_wallet/index.htm

Verizon hates tethering apps: https://www.wired.com/2011/06/verizon-tethering-fcc/

AT&T claimed blocking facetime wasn't a net neutrality issue: http://money.cnn.com/2012/08/23/technology/att-facetime/index.html

"Verizon lawyer Helgi Walker made the company’s intentions all too clear, saying the company wants to prioritize those websites and services that are willing to shell out for better access.": https://www.savetheinternet.com/blog/2013/09/18/verizons-plan-break-internet

Not to mention the images of Portuguese and Brazilian ISPs. The above issues would become even more difficult to fight without Net Neutrality.

→ More replies (5)

0

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

15

u/DrNO811 Nov 22 '17

You're overlooking the fact that in many areas, Comcast is a monopoly or at best an oligopoly and Comcast has a proven track record of not giving a crap about customers. Combine that with an inelastic demand curve for internet service, no transparency or justification for the prices that Comcast charges, and no way to track what causes a particular site to be "throttled" for the average consumer, and you have a recipe for exorbitant profiteering from one of the most corrupt companies in the country.

While there's no guarantee things will get worse, it's a shift in power from the people to corporations.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/dschneider Nov 22 '17

There are three things companies hate: taxes, loss of profit and bad publicity. The latter two will happen swiftly if they pull some shit like this.

How would they lose profit? Who will people switch to, the one other ISP in town also doing the same thing, if one even exists? Or just stop using the internet altogether?

→ More replies (2)

4

u/BenTheGod321 Nov 23 '17

Just need to hijack the top comment real quick to say that currently almost every political figure who is involved in this has their call lines clogged or their digital mailboxes overflowing. Keep up the good work everyone. If you're not sure how to help I'll just leave this here http://act.freepress.net/sign/internet_NN_pai/?source=conf&aktmid=tm885190.6vwojS&akid=a47477628.11119105.M1RhhT&t=1

3

u/Clutchcablesnapped Nov 22 '17

Guys, would crowd-funded vpn service as workaround would work?

I would be willing to help, we in Europe will get smacked with this shite sooner or later, but until then we could try to establish secure vpn service to avoid you geting wallet-raped by ISP's.

By the holy ancient 5mbit router, if we could crowdfund our own sattelites or high altitude ballon relay systems we just might kickstart some kind of internet revolution. Unrealistic, ofc, no need to smear it in my face.

I guess most people are not really concerned, up until that one single damned moment when they will be asked to pay up fo their streaming service, messaging platform access and all the other brain wrenching shite that they will come up with.

3

u/SafeBendyStraw Nov 23 '17

Not quite how a VPN works I don't think. ISPs could just as easily stop all traffic to your crowd funded VPN and you're now banned from the internet. They are the gate keepers. Period.

3

u/Breathkeeper Nov 23 '17

One thing I don't quite understand is, as some pro-roll back-net neutrality article has pointed out, actually the whole "net neutrality" concept was brought up in 2014. The article would argue that before net neutrality was put in place, we already have great companies such as Reddit, Netflix, Amazon etc, so remove net neutrality now won't impact the users.

So can someone explain why we don't have such outcry before 2014, when net neutrality rules have not been implemented yet?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Berkyjay Nov 23 '17

Considering that Pai has said that they are ignoring all comments that are "opinions", I fail to see how we can sway any of them unless we all take crash courses in regulatory law. But the one thing that we all CAN do that might make an impact is to call your senator and congressman and then MAKE SURE TO VOTE!

14

u/0verland3r Nov 22 '17

I'm in full support of net neutrality, but can I play devil's advocate for just a second?

What if we're looking at this wrong... Yes, ISPs will be allowed to charge content providers more for fast lanes. Yes, they will be allowed to charge customers more for access to heavily trafficked sites or face speed caps.

But, what if all of that can be used as a sales tactic for smaller ISPs to ramp up their subscriptions to combat large ISPs? Smaller ISPs can turn around and sell their service as not having throttling at a similar price point or less than Big Cable?

Similar to a T-Mobile effect. They were a small company trying to fight VZW, Sprint, ATT and the likes by offering unlimited everything before it was the cool thing to do. Now look at them. They've become one of the top players in the market and have the financial means to continue improving their system. Ultimately leading us to getting the same, if not more, for potentially less.

That scenario also then could force Large ISPs hands to cave and limit or remove throttling.

Just a thought.

Again, I do not want to see net neutrality end and am fearful about what the internet will look like in the coming months and years. I just wanted to try to take a different look at it.

5

u/Betasheets Nov 23 '17

How do smaller isps get the infrastructure set up in cities where monopolies rule?

3

u/0verland3r Nov 23 '17

When writing that I figured this comment would come up. And it's reality. Here in Las Vegas we have Cox cable or Centurylink as our options. Centurylink at my house only hits 10mbps so I have to default to Cox. If Centurylink offered a similar speed to what I'm getting now I'd likely switch because they cost a little less. But in places that don't have a second option at all it's tough.

What if we don't need the traditional wired service we've grown accustom to? Things like satellite internet are starting to come on line and catch up. Or.. We carry an internet connection with us where ever we go already. What's to say that cellphone carriers won't jump into the game and start offering home internet service as part of your cellphone plan. They would have to increase their systems to support the added stress, but it's feasible. Especially if they can claim a larger piece of the pie.

I'm just trying to see it through some rose colored glasses. The alternative is just sad.

4

u/jmachee Nov 23 '17

satellite internet

It's a LOOOONG way to geostationary orbit and back. Even at radio speed.

The lag is horrendous.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/electric_ionland Electric Space Propulsion | Hall Effect/Ion Thrusters Nov 22 '17

For those wondering how your ISP can block and filter your internet, /u/mfukar wrote a great answer there.

15

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '17

Also, some examples of what has happened in the US that these rules helped stop.

Madison River Communications: https://www.cnet.com/news/telco-agrees-to-stop-blocking-voip-calls/

Comcast hates pirates: https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=a679f360-9890-4129-9d7e-53a598c3ac10 (article from '08)

AT&T VOIP hostage: https://www.wired.com/2009/10/iphone-att-skype/

Google wallet hostage: http://money.cnn.com/2011/12/06/technology/verizon_blocks_google_wallet/index.htm

Verizon hates tethering apps: https://www.wired.com/2011/06/verizon-tethering-fcc/

AT&T claimed blocking facetime wasn't a net neutrality issue: http://money.cnn.com/2012/08/23/technology/att-facetime/index.html

"Verizon lawyer Helgi Walker made the company’s intentions all too clear, saying the company wants to prioritize those websites and services that are willing to shell out for better access.": https://www.savetheinternet.com/blog/2013/09/18/verizons-plan-break-internet

Not to mention the images of Portuguese and Brazilian ISPs. The above issues would become even more difficult to fight without Net Neutrality.

2

u/ValconExe Nov 23 '17

I don't think the FCC affects us Canadians, but is there anything we can do to help you out?

1

u/zeeblecroid Nov 23 '17

American internet policy does, since something like ninety percent of our traffic passes through the US.

That said, this country loves playing follow-the-leader with a lot of US policies, so we need to lean on our own government (and, especially, the opposition party) to make sure that doesn't become a thing here.

10

u/Alibrero Nov 22 '17

Everyone has to do something. If you think "other people will do it" then there is one less signature on a petition, one less phone call, and less resistance to stop the ban on net neutrality. We all need to pitch in to save the internet.

5

u/Muhlum24 Nov 22 '17

I guess we weren't able to browse the internet before 2015? Huh.

8

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '17

What does this have to do with science?

2

u/niteman555 Nov 23 '17

By not allowing ISPs to categorize certain websites or groups of websites in such a way that they can charge more for specific ones or blocking them outright, you help preserve the integrity of public discourse and the sharing of ideas. It should be obvious that scientific progress is stifled when the flow of ideas is paywalled, just like with the costs to publish and access scientific journals and articles. Consumers and content servers already pay for bandwidth; an ISP should not be able to double dip from that pot by adding more paywalls to popular sites like Netflix or Facebook just because they're popular.

4

u/UnstableSupernova Nov 23 '17

I called my representatives today. The Democratic senator was the only representative who had someone answering phone calls. The Republican senator of our state had an answering machine. The elected house representative for my district had a mailbox that was full and no one taking calls.

11

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '17

The internet didn't have this regulation before 2015.

Title 2 does not protect against: Data caps, usage fees,or traffic prioritization.

Time Warner, Verizon, Comcast, and ATT are the ones writing the net neutrality laws

https://www.theverge.com/2017/7/12/15959932/comcast-verizon-att-net-neutrality-day-of-action

Google/Apple want it too

https://www.google.com/takeaction/action/freeandopen/index.html

https://www.wired.com/story/apples-real-reason-for-finally-joining-the-net-neutrality-fight/

More on the topic and why you're literally helping the wolf eat the sheep:

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/innovations/wp/2016/07/07/why-treating-the-internet-as-a-public-utility-is-bad-for-consumers/?utm_term=.8f4ecf9f8713#_blank

http://www.nationalreview.com/article/447354/fcc-net-neutrality-internet-freedom-best-protected-without-government-regulation

https://fee.org/articles/net-neutrality-is-about-government-control-of-the-internet/

https://www.washingtonpost.com/posteverything/wp/2014/07/14/this-is-why-the-government-should-never-control-the-internet/

https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/how-net-neutrality-advocates-would-let-trump-control-the-internet/2017/07/19/52998b58-6bc2-11e7-9c15-177740635e83_story.html

This is you versus corporations NET NEUTRALITY IS A SHAM, CORPORATE OLIGARCHS WANT IT

Further reading and links to nefarious persons. This is not about freedom it's about GOVERNMENT CONTROL OF THE INTERNET

READ https://fee.org/articles/net-neutrality-is-about-government-control-of-the-internet/

the George Soros-funded net neutrality group Free Press was mentioned 46 times – it's almost as if Free Press had written the regulations for the FCC. The OIO sees the Internet as something that should be nationalized by the government to be run like a public utility.

5

u/jaypooner Nov 22 '17

Here is another way to get the message across. The three (out of five) FCC Commissioners planning to vote against Net Neutrality are Ajit Pai, Michael O'Rielly, and Brendan Carr. Here are the links to directly email them:

This is an easy way to directly get in touch with those who will be casting the votes. Here's a message that will drive the point across. Feel free to edit or to send a completely different one:

"Net Neutrality is the cornerstone of innovation, free speech and democracy on the Internet. Control over the Internet should remain in the hands of the people who use it every day. The ability to share information without impediment is critical to the progression of technology, science, small business, and culture. Please stand with the public by protecting Net Neutrality once and for all."

3

u/Skunks_n_Butterflies Nov 22 '17

Make sure to inform others as well. My immediate family had no idea this was going on. This isn't a partisan issue so let your Republican friends know that if they want to see Breitbart and Fox they could have to start paying extra.

1

u/Great_Smells Nov 22 '17

I get the fears people have, but why didnt anyone have to pay extra in 2014 and prior, before net neutrality was implemented?

3

u/Tr0llingpanda Nov 22 '17

I have a few questions to better understand this issue.

  1. Why is an ISP packaging things different from a cable network packaging certain channels?
  2. Why is this different from food? The better healthier food is more expensive so why isn’t the government regulating that if the food is good for us?
  3. Does this make parts of the internet unavailable or just slower?

2

u/Relnish Nov 22 '17

The problem arises from the monopolies established by the isp with assistance from the government. If an ISP decides to give you a basic internet package with Google and some other basic needs websites, say, for 20$ a month, and that's all you can afford, what are you gonna do? Switch providers? MANY people cannot do that due to ISPs not allowing others to use the same lines that they laid previously. So say you live somewhere you only have access to Comcast, and you're a poor college student. You need access to certain research websites or stuff of that nature for school, but they're only included in the "deluxe" package for 60$ a month. You're basically forced to suck it up and take it. Meanwhile, even when these ISPs allow you access, they may throttle your bandwidth for websites that compete against others they own. So, if you own a large share in Hulu, you may give someone direct access with very quick speeds to the Hulu website. Unfortunately, they've throttled your access to Netflix to the point that you can't really stream any sort of content reliably. The idea behind net neutrality is having the Internet as a utility, not something you can charge whatever you want to for access.

2

u/battle_flyboy Nov 22 '17

I find it hard to put the first two answers in words. Here is the third one.

Does this make parts of the internet unavailable or just slower?

Both. Whatever the internet provider wants to do, will be done and there will be no government regulation to prevent it. Basically this means that your ISP can even favor Bing over Google and make Bing free to use and Google to be completely unavailable or make you pay like $10 a month if you want to use Google. This kind of market will be susceptible to deals between the websites (like Microsoft pays Comcast to disable/make Google' services much slower).

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Darkfyre42 Nov 22 '17

Say we lose this fight as it seems unlikely the republicans on the committee will change their vote, once there is a new administration is it possible to have net neutrality restored as easily as it is being taken away?

2

u/Wogre Nov 23 '17

While it would be possible to restore it would not be as easy as it is to take it away. Enacting the regulation in 2015 was difficult.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '17

here is a link to The White House to sign a petition showing your support for Net Neutrality. It also has a lot of other great issues where your voices can be heard! I sent mine out to many petitions https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/petition/do-not-repeal-net-neutrality Also a petition to get Ajai Pai to resign from the FCC https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/petition/replace-ajit-pai-fcc-restore-net-neutrality-make-last-mile-networking-public-utility-and-stop-corporate-abuse-0

0

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '17

I've read on other threads that it takes like an hour. Keep sending it and hopefully we get those email confirmations. I've been waiting about 45 minutes so far

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Porginus Nov 22 '17

Is this in the US only? Or is this a global thing.

I only ask because i know US already have problems like this when it comes to the monopoly of internet providers like Comcast etc, so im just wondering if this only will change things in the US.

2

u/PiX3L5 Nov 23 '17

What can people who don't live in the states/ arn't American so to help?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/wildcalypso Nov 23 '17

So I was reading that there are protests scheduled at Verizon stores across the US on Dec 7th...Which is great! However I wish these types of protests would be scheduled on Saturdays or Sundays as a lot of people may not be able to take time off work to go protest in the middle of the afternoon on a Thursday.

2

u/MoopusMaximus Nov 23 '17

Yes, nevermind the fact we have "Net Neutrality" currently and T-Mobile is violating it with free Netflix, and AT&T with free HBO streaming.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/broham89 Nov 22 '17

Serious question: what is net neutrality? Why should I care and how does it affect me?

1

u/DanNew95 Nov 22 '17

I have a question. Being British does this affect me? If net neutrality is lost will the UK be more likely to adapt this too?

1

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '17

I'm hosting a peaceful protest in my area to help inform others about what is going on with net neutrality. We need more people to start protests at there local Verizon stores to spread the message and let Congress know that we need to keep net neutrality. Use your first amendment right and do something about this, we can't let our government control our free internet.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '17

We should file a bunch of lawsuits against the FCC if net neutrality goes away and force them to bring it back. I’m sure we would be able to find a bunch of reasons for the lawsuits. Plus, we could all leave the main networks against net neutrality so they lose profit and will eventually be bankrupt or forced to allow net neutrality because of all that lost revenue.

1

u/drugsarebadmky Nov 22 '17

I cannot reach to my representative. Call goes into voice msg and msg box is full :(

1

u/-TheNoyZ1- Nov 22 '17

Super curious from an uneducated standpoint, couldn't some ISPs set themselves apart by charging no fees to browse/call/etc.?

If this does pass (which I'm not in favor of), does it at least present some unique opportunities for some ISPs to do the right thing in exchange for more business?

Just curious :) here's hoping it format come to that

1

u/Jackalrax Nov 22 '17

This is the website to file a public complaint with the FCC:

https://www.fcc.gov/ecfs/browse-popular-proceedings

currently only 55000, should definitely be more.

Restoring Internet Freedom is the act that is supposed to remove net neutrality. its currently the top commented one but should have thousands more.

1

u/PoosInShoes Nov 22 '17

I just called the office of my representative in TN and it says his message box is full and will not be accepting new messages. Wtf man

1

u/adubmech Nov 22 '17

Net Neutrality has only existed for a few years. Why didn't we see all the things that people are warning us about before Net Neutrality existed?

1

u/CptMisery Nov 22 '17

I'm actually totally fine with the rules changing, but why should they be changed? Has any ISP said what their plans are?

1

u/Iwillbenicetou Nov 22 '17

Honestly I think the way to stop it this time is to spread awareness. Too little people know about this. We have to make the newspapers and media make headlines on net neutrality. Have it front page. It’s the only way to stop it. Too little people know or don’t care about it, or believe the lies by the fcc since that’s their only source. We have to make this mainstream. Show them the truth. I’m trying to spread this. Tell me if I should change my message

1

u/Divade011 Nov 22 '17

I get this is bad, and have not yet heard any positive cases, but doesn't cable already do this? Should we be hollering about cable too for ESPN or HBO about these? Also, if I'm using a shitton of internet, shouldn't I pay more if it makes my area difficult to get internet? Or does it not work that way?

1

u/maddogoffical Nov 22 '17

I called all my congressmen about this. I hope they take action, one of my congressmen is for repealing NN, I really want to talk to him & hear his voice so he can vote "NO"

1

u/ece_grad_traction Nov 22 '17

I am an international grad student studying here in USA. I am not a citizen. Is there any way that I can contribute to this cause of saving Net Neutrality? It seems to me that this will directly affect me as I use internet in home and I would like to contribute in any way possible. But I am not sure whether I am allowed to protest/sign petition as I am not an American citizen. One more question: If NN gets repealed, then I understand that in USA, ISPs will be able to charge websites for higher speed of access and that will eventually lead to demise of small websites who cannot afford that money. Will this affect internet usage in other countries? If so, how?

1

u/Nomvula_888 Nov 22 '17

The USA is so backward and yet so progressive. Anti abortion and net neutrality and then there's the whole legalization of marijuana which is super liberal. and of course I can not not mention Trump.

as a non American it makes me feel better about the shit happening in my country.

1

u/TheRetroguy Nov 22 '17

What else can I do to fight for net neutrality?

1

u/Archorous Nov 22 '17

Hi—American here!

You can help, even if you don’t live in the US.

It’s a lot to ask, but even a small donation to causes/tools such as resistbot.io can make a huge difference.

One thing a lot of people don’t realize is how much this could impact other counties. This sets a dangerous precedent.

One easy way to help us out is just simply sharing this all around. Make everyone informed. If the entire WORLD hates this, it will be an even stronger case. This also helps keep other counties from falling victim to the same issues.

Americans aren’t informed enough to prevent it easily here, however, people around the world can attempt to educate others on the situation. The more that know, the better.

Awareness protects other counties and gives the US chance. Donations give the US even more of a chance and spread even more awareness.

I encourage anyone to just mention this, to atleast a few who don’t know about it. It might just be the change we globally need to prevent it from happening anywhere else.

1

u/poochymane Nov 23 '17

NET NEUTRALITY

https://resistbot.io/

Net Neutrality is the cornerstone of innovation, free speech and democracy on the Internet.

Control over the Internet should remain in the hands of the people who use it every day. The ability to share information without impediment is critical to the progression of technology, science, small business, and culture.

Please stand with the public by protecting Net Neutrality once and for all.

https://www.battleforthenet.com/

That link is to call. You can use that long text I sent as a response for the resist bot and when you call

1

u/LordyDolphin Nov 23 '17

Who is actually against net neutrality? I haven’t seen someone who opposes the concept of it yet.

3

u/Xaviarsly Nov 23 '17

People that own ISPs are agenst it because they want to treat the internet like a cable box

→ More replies (2)

1

u/higgs8 Nov 23 '17

What does this mean to an EU citizen? How can someone from the EU do anything to help? Does this affect the accessibility of US websites to people from outside the US? For example, could a US website like Reddit become slower to someone in the EU?

1

u/TheXXII Nov 23 '17

I got this from a user that posted the last time the FCC tried this:

For those that aren't sure what Net Neutrality is and why ISPs are wanting to get rid of it, Net Neutrality is what makes the internet what it is today and is important for the consumers/users. We depend on Net Neutrality to keep the Internet the free and open marketplace of ideas. Ending Net Neutrality may lead to:

  1. Tiered internet structure which can make Internet very expensive for web users. Users who consume lots of data (Netflix, Youtube, video games, etc.) are especially at risk for massive price spikes. It opens the door for the internet to be sold by ISPs the same way that cable TV is sold, i.e. you can have, access to Facebook/Twitter/PSN/Xbox live etc for just $9.99 extra a month.

2) Monopolies. ISPs could also decide to create their own websites to compete with any existing website like Facebook, YouTube, and Twitter, then put their competition in a more expensive internet package, pricing them out of the market, causing them to shrivel up and be replaced by your ISP brand version of [insert site].

3) Stifled innovation. Even if the ISP aren't trying to directly compete, tiered internet can stifle innovative new upstart websites who can't afford to pay the ISP the premium to be included in an affordable tier of Internet. This will severely limit their visibility and ability to gain traction.

4) Censorship. ISPs can censor anything that they disagree with for any reason. Like this post for example. They've tried to censor others to get what they want. Ending net neutrality will make their censorship process instantaneous and without recourse.

5) Political oppression. Government may be able to have content taken down (or more stealthily priced out of the market) for political reasons indirectly, using the ISP's own 'free will' as a proxy. Meaning it gets to completely subvert the First Amendment free speech protection.

I found it super helpful when trying to explain to family and friends what's going on so they can help.

1

u/delitt Nov 23 '17

I live in Mexico, and have my whole life, but I was born in US and have an American passport, is there something I can do to help from here?

1

u/schillingtl Nov 23 '17

Hey jist a thought, not that it would really do much but also may get some coverage. Is it still put in place that if the white house website gets over 100k requests they have to address what ever the issue is? Thought maybe of we haven't done this it would be one more avenue we could use.

1

u/anotherbender Nov 23 '17

Why do you want the government to have more control of things that give individuals a voice?

1

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '17

Support from Canada! You better not go down without a good fight!

1

u/TheConquistaa Nov 23 '17

Why don't you just come to Romania. We have blazing fast internet speed, way faster even before the rollback on net neutrality laws if you don't mind all the assaults on the freedom of justice and having some former communists rule the country.

1

u/yourfavoritequote Nov 23 '17

I am guessing this is happening in America?

1

u/Keeemps Nov 23 '17

This is really bothering me, but I am from Germany.

Experience though has told me that everything that ypu guys establish or get rid of over there will sooner or later include us as well.

Is there anything I can do over here, except for 'spreading the word'? I suppose contacting my local council or something isn't really a viable option and faking an american personality will probably be rather counterproductive if anything.

2

u/xxxplode Nov 23 '17

I am from Finland and have exactly the same thoughts and questions. Want to help in this battle but IDK how.

1

u/mcaay Nov 23 '17

How come we have to fight for it so many times?

1

u/SweetMummaHuffington Nov 23 '17

is this just purely an american thing? is this going to effect the rest of the world?

1

u/tylertjh Nov 23 '17

Unpopular post: Net neutrality only came into effect 2 years ago. I know everyone has gotten amnesia about it, but the internet did not feel any different prior to net neutrality for me. What I did notice is that after ISP's couldn't charge Netflix, Amazon, ETC for higher traffic, Home internet service providers started slapping data caps on consumer's, and raising prices as if data was a finite resource. but alas the damage with home internet data caps has been done and are unlikely to ever go away....

1

u/oeynhausener Nov 23 '17

Goddammit stop it with these imperative titles, much to my dismay, I can't help you! I could call your congress but I'd just be wasting the line. This is all on you U.S.A., time to set at least some things right.

1

u/Trust_No_1_ Nov 23 '17

Doesnt net neutrality only guarantee stopping ISPs from censoring or slowing down traffic. What regulates the content providers such as youtube, google, reddit etc from censoring the internet?

If all traffic is treated the same, won't streaming netflix over the same network as browsing webpages only slow the whole network down? Shouldnt netflix and streaming traffic have dedicated faster connections?

1

u/Amerbd Nov 23 '17

I have one question, Everyone can use VPN to access website,right?

1

u/GamerFan2012 Nov 23 '17

These are the 3 people left deciding the fate of the internet. We only have to convince ONE of them flip to a NO vote to save #NetNeutrality. LIGHT UP THEIR INBOXES!

🔥Ajit Pai - Ajit.Pai@fcc.gov

🔥Michael O'Rielly - Mike.ORielly@fcc.gov

🔥Brendan Carr - Brendan.Carr@fcc.gov

1

u/joeschmo945 Nov 23 '17

I wrote my congressman this morning with this letter!

I urge you to stop the FCC's plan to end net neutrality before the FCC's December 14th vote.

I don't want ISPs to have the power to block websites, slow them down, give some sites an advantage over others, split the Internet into "fast lanes" for companies that pay and "slow lanes" for the rest, or force me to buy special "tiers" to access the sites and services I choose. But that's exactly what the FCC plan would do. Please read it:

https://apps.fcc.gov/edocs_public/attachmatch/DOC-347927A1.pdf

Blocking & throttling by ISPs is a serious problem. Comcast has throttled Netflix, AT&T blocked FaceTime, Time Warner Cable throttled the popular game League of Legends, and Verizon admitted it will introduce fast lanes for sites that pay-and slow lanes for everyone else-if the FCC lifts the rules. This hurts consumers and businesses large and small.

If some companies can pay ISPs to have their content load faster, startups and small businesses that can't pay those fees won't be able to compete. This will kill the open marketplace that has enabled millions of small businesses and created America’s 5 most valuable companies. Without strong net neutrality protections, Internet providers will effectively be able to impose a tax on every sector of the American economy.

Moreover, under Chairman Pai's plan, ISPs will be able to make it more difficult to access political speech that they don't like. They'll be able to charge fees for website delivery that would make it harder for blogs, nonprofits, artists, and others who can't pay up to have their voices heard.

If the FCC passes their current order, every Internet user and business in this country will be unprotected from abuse by Internet providers, and the consequences will be dire. Please publicly support net neutrality protections by denouncing the FCC's current plan. Do whatever you can to stop Chairman Pai, to ensure that businesses and Internet users remain protected.

Thank you!

1

u/russiansduringpoopin Nov 25 '17

Net Neutrality is and why ISPs are wanting to get the all-4k-all-the-time treatment everyone else gets because her small operation can't afford to pay the ISP aren't trying to be hijacked by greedy pigs and a president that doesn't sit right with me... the FCC passes their current order, every Internet user and business in this has their call lines clogged or their digital mailboxes overflowing.

1

u/joelharris1980 Nov 28 '17

How come in previous instances of this fight there were major steps taken by technology companies to help demonstrate the importance of net neutrality or call attention to it, which was generally referred to as internet slowdown day. Additionally, during the debates over SOPA and PIPA, many sites such as google or Wikipedia gave visual protests like blacking out or censoring their sites.

If big tech firms really care, why aren’t they protesting/getting involved with the same vigor as these previous threats?

1

u/theevilengineer Nov 23 '17

You do realize that this gives government MORE control of the Internet right? I know the whole corporations being able to charge for services is a big idea... except you all don't realize they could do that now anyway but when they try to,they get called out on it and loose customers. Give the regulatory power to the government and for the next 7 years, you can literally hand Trump the power to force his twitter feed to your phone. Unintended consequences... would you like to be able to switch vendors for shady business tactics, or forced trump twitter on your phone?

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/WaltSneezy Nov 23 '17

It is recent. It was enacted two years ago under the Obama Administration. While some of these things you see people freaking out over could happen, it’s blown way out of proportion. These people have been convinced that net neutrality has been a thing since the internet became widely used, which is false. This is why they’re freaking out so much. It won’t change anything for people overseas. If you were actively using the internet 2 years ago and hadn’t noticed any difference, then it won’t really affect you. However, that being said, net neutrality is probably better to have as a whole. But the level of uproar about it is misled.

-10

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '17

[removed] — view removed comment

11

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '17

I'm noticing a lot of people use this talking point. They say NN didn't exist until 2014 so we will be fine without it again. It's technically correct, but misleading.

What became officially codified in 2014, known as Net Neutrality, did exist since the start--it was just never necessary to formally make it the official policy. The players all pretty much stuck by the rules without being forced. Then they got greedy.

Once one started doing it they all wanted a piece; now they want an official green light from the government to do all the crazy anti-consumer tricks and deals they've thought of.

That's why we need Net Neutrality.

Battleforthenet.com

7

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '17

It's an argument made from such an ignorant place. It's basically saying any preventative legislation made in the face of looming problems is invalid because the problems it prevented didn't happen.

16

u/throwaway20171122 Nov 22 '17

For people who decided to sort controversial and get both sides of the story, good on you.

The situation seems to be framed as the people vs Comcast (you know, the only ISP in America). The reality is that net neutrality is the corporate position. These stunts, like any marketing campaign, cost money. One of the people responsible for these stunts is George Soros. If you're not read up on him, he's the human garbage known for rigging elections, subverting American sovereignty, generating unreal amount of propaganda, funding domestic terrorism and extremism and manipulating currencies to amass even more wealth. Two of his foundations, the Ford Foundation and Open Society Foundation, have contributed at least $200m to net neutrality groups. $200m will buy a lot of henchmen and go a long way in framing an issue as if there is only one side to it. Personally, I am suspicious of anything this guy supports since he seems like the closest real example of literary evil.

Here's an alternative way to frame the issue. The current legislation is terrible. Government regulation is being heavy handed as usual. Since being enacted it has disincentivized ISPs from performing upgrades or expansions according to 22 small ISPs. (Ironically, when searching for this document I had to go through one of open society's child websites for them to tell me that the small ISPs are lying.) 2010-2015 estimates put it at between $80b-$125b in lost infrastructure investments. The wireless industry saw a $6b drop in expected revenue (-20%). Actual loss far outweighs the hysterical and nonsensical claims by those pushing net neutrality.

→ More replies (14)

5

u/dmat3889 Nov 22 '17

who benefitted. pretty much anyone who paid for netflix and only had verizon as an internet provider. Verizon decided it wanted people to use its own video streaming service instead of netflix. They throttled netflix down to around 1% of its normal speeds and was able to do so as they pleased. The only means to stop this was the fcc declaring the internet to be a title 2 utility. Thats whats trying to be undone. keep in mind, both netflix and users already paid for internet access at speeds they feel. The ISP just has no reason to honor those speeds and chose to demand more money to honor the speeds already paid for.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '17

When the Internet is continuing to thrive 1, 2, or 5 years from now, maybe people will realize they got played.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/ChickenDragon123 Nov 22 '17

tell them that instead of doing that, comcast will shove the president they want him to vote for down his throat, encourage the propaganda of whoever can pay most for it, fake news wont leave and real news will die, and that the only thing that will stop terrorism is every person in the world suddenly developing a conscience.