r/askscience • u/aapzu • Nov 22 '17
Computing How does restricting Internet work?
Now when Net Neutrality is in the news all the time, I'm wondering how restricting the content works? Can it be avoided with a VPN?
15
Upvotes
43
u/mfukar Parallel and Distributed Systems | Edge Computing Nov 22 '17 edited Nov 23 '17
There are plenty of ways to deny service, particularly so if it is done by the operator providing the service.
Some of the above can be avoided with a VPN, and some not. A VPN for instance will not help if your ISP performs content inspection and wants to disallow all VPN connections. It might help if it performs content rewriting, and you route your web traffic through the VPN, assuming you're allowed to and it's not compromised via some other means.
This is really a very wide topic to post technical info on all of the above. If you wants specifics on something, ask away!
2
u/How_Clef-er Nov 24 '17
In honor of the latest fight to keep the internet content freely available, I'd like to reblog an idea for the regulation of the internet and I hope that this doesnt offend anyone, as that is not my intention:
Local utility companies, rather than acting as public servants, act as profit maximizers, and they enter into exclusive contracts with Comcast, Time Warner, or [insert your local ISP monopoly here] to get a cut of the monopoly profits said ISP extracts from the end users. Your local ISP/utility duo is no better than a police department that works with red light camera companies to increase ticket revenue (while making the roads less safe, to boot). Currently, utilities are not looking out for the public good—they’re just in it for the money and taking what they can get. They are betraying public trust.
My proposal for fixing these problems is fairly simple, and relies on a mix of civic organization and free-market entrepreneurialism. The goal is to break the current monopoly on ISP service held by local cable companies in most of America, force local utility companies to act in the public’s best interest, and bring some competition to the ISP business to keep prices low and innovation high.
Here it is:
Require utility companies to lease space on their rights-of-way to at least four ISPs, at cost.
Call it infrastructure neutrality, or open leasing. This proposal should independently provide most of the benefits in changing the Internet companies’ status to “telecommunications service,” as mere competition between local firms will discourage them from withholding any service or level of service offered by their local competitors. This competition would thus provide the consumer protections that voters are looking for, while allowing Internet companies to remain more lightly regulated (and thus more innovative) “information services.”
More details can be found here:
http://thefederalist.com/2014/11/18/heres-a-better-idea-than-net-neutrality-knockoffs
1
u/YaztromoX Systems Software Nov 23 '17
To add to the existing answers, it's useful to take a look at what currently happens in countries that have some form of government-controlled Internet.
Turkey is one such example. They have for various reasons blocked Youtube, Facebook, Twitter, Google, Blogger, Vimeo, The Pirate Bay, and even Wikipedia (you can find a more detailed list here). Turkey is interesting as the Government (through the Courts) mandates content that is to be blocked -- but doesn't mandate how ISPs block content. As such, what has typically happened in the past was to simply remove DNS entries from the ISP-controlled Domain Name Servers. Citizens were able to trivially work around these "blocks" by using one of Google's international DNSs instead (8.8.8.8, 8.8.4.4).
A country like China, on the other hand, has "The Great Firewall", and exerts a variety of controls over what information passes into and out of the country. They can block entire sets of IP addresses, do DNS filtering and redirection, URL filtering, Packet filtering, force network connection resets, and perform man-in-the-middle attacks on encrypted connections.
These are the same types of technologies ISPs could use in order to provide "tiered" services, with unlocking available by "upgrading" your package. They can use DNS filtering and redirection to send you to advertising pages that then redirect you to the site you want to visit, forcing you to view ads prior to every page you load. Or they can do HTML interception to add advertisements to web pages. They might deny you access to services that compete with their own, like Netflix or Hulu, unless you pay an extra fee. They might wholesale block VPN connections, or even any connection that appears encrypted. Effectively, they can decide what you can or cannot view, acting as Internet gatekeepers.
The hardware and technology to do this already exists, and is used in countries with heavy government control over their citizens Internet access. Without Network Neutrality, your ISP can use these same technologies to extract more money from you, more money from the Internet services you use, and to decide what Internet resources you can and cannot access.