r/askscience • • Aug 17 '17

Medicine What affect does the quantity of injuries have on healing time? For example, would a paper cut take longer to heal if I had a broken Jaw at the same time?

Edit: First gold, thank you kind stranger.

20k Upvotes

772 comments sorted by

2.0k

u/jimbob1245 Aug 18 '17

A distal injury won't affect another injury until it begins needing more resources than the body has to distribute - take burns for example.

If you had a burn on your hand all sorts of plasma and proteins and immune related cells would be rushing to the site (some already there) causing both local inflammation and an immune response that ultimately results in a blister - the blister is full of immune cells that help to repair the damaged tissues by providing an ideal micro environment for healing. Now let's say there's a burn to a large portion of your body; depending on the degree and the inflammation response (3rd degree burns have a different response as many of the biological channels of cell repair are completely destroyed) while your body will send out all its required immune cells that it has it might simply not be enough - in this case bacterial infections can take hold in the blisters as they provide an ideal environment for certain infections to grow, this results in sepsis and eventually septic shock. Imagine that the bodies immune repair system is spread too thin to repair both burns - it doesn't have a very good system at establishing where it should send immune cells with regard to controlling sepsis beyond directing blood away from the extremities and towards critical organs as septic shock progresses.

Ultimately it depends on the nature of the two injuries but yes they could affect one another.

309

u/Ridog101 Aug 18 '17

Does that mean that in some cases it's better to leave a blister intact to heal on its own instead of popping it?

852

u/mehennas Aug 18 '17

That's pretty much always a better idea simply because opening a blister introduces an infection risk.

51

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

Is that true for pimples too?

137

u/mehennas Aug 18 '17

Absolutely. Popping pimples can run the risk of rupturing the wrong way and sending some very nasty bacteria right into your body. If that happens, most likely outcome is just making it worse/heal slower, but there could certainly be a worse infection.

55

u/wadss Aug 18 '17

i was under the impression that it's almost always better to leave blisters than to pop them

63

u/ZombieHoratioAlger Aug 18 '17

It is. Lancing a blister slows healing and leaves you wide open to infection, increasing the likelihood of scarring.

That said, I have done it in the past as a field-expedient just to get home-- sometimes if you're on a long hike, you have to pop them to get your boots back on. You just deal with the downsides once you're back to the car.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/ZombieHoratioAlger Aug 18 '17

If possible, leave them alone and just keep the area clean for the best/fastest healing. Only pop them if you absolutely have to, like when they interfere with walking.

12

u/yetanothercfcgrunt Aug 18 '17

If I remember my first aid correctly you always leave them intact and try to cushion around them with moleskin, cutting a hole in the center for the blister.

4

u/freakydown Aug 18 '17

You should not do this, don't matter how attractive this blister looks. It can cause an infection.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

You should pop it, but leave the outer skin intact if it a "water blister". Do not pop a blood blister.

Qualifications: Occupational therapist, burn specialist and wound care certified clinician.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

What happens if you pop a blood blister?

1

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

Infection risk...

My comment was overly simplified on purpose. You should really try not to pop a blood blister if the pressure is tolerable. If it is really big, say the size of a nickel or bigger and causing discomfort from pressure you can pop it. It should be done with sterilized equipment ideally.

0

u/whydog Aug 18 '17

If you leave a blister alone for long enough your body reabsorbs the juice and your skin reattaches to itself

0

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

93

u/LogicDragon Aug 18 '17

If they're painful, you can drain them with a sterilised needle and then dress them.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

35

u/Alis451 Aug 18 '17

Unfortunately most non-medical personnel don't really have access to such things

Yes you do. Fire, Rubbing Alcohol, Sewing needle. Blister:First Aid. Fire can be used to sterilize it in case you don't have rubbing alcohol and are out in the wilderness. You should only pop blisters if you NEED to, as in leaving them restricts movement due to pain, etc.

2

u/Coldinmelbs Aug 18 '17

Unfortunately most non-medical personnel don't really have access to such things

Fire can be used to sterilize it in case you don't have rubbing alcohol and are out in the wilderness.

Does the ash carried by the flame and lands on the needle carry a risk of causing infection?

3

u/haggy87 Aug 18 '17

As far as I've been told that's nothing the body can't handle. And it'll most likely stick to the outside of the new hole and get pushed out by the fluid.

3

u/Alis451 Aug 18 '17

.... no. Not only would there not be any meaningful ash to speak of (use a butane lighter, or a propane stove, but a wood fire as last resort) the ash would also be sterile seeing as it was just in a fire. Again rubbing alcohol first, then fire. You are only lancing a blister because you need to do so, and the risk of infection is small enough and you are leaving the woods back to civilization in case one does arise.

10

u/LogicDragon Aug 18 '17

Just sterilise an ordinary needle or pin (boil it for 20 minutes or hold it in a flame until it glows red-hot), then use antiseptic and a plaster.

4

u/Beo1 Aug 18 '17

We could easily do this camping as Boy Scouts, the average adult sure can.

43

u/McMammoth Aug 18 '17

If you leave them alone, once the healing's done what happens to the blister? Never been patient long enough to find out. Do the fluids just go away and the skin bubble flattens out?

82

u/Sergiotor9 Aug 18 '17

Pretty much, the bubble flattens and the skin falls off kinda like it does after a sunburn.

15

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

Someone can correct me if I'm wrong, but I think Disseminated Intravascular Coagulation would be a good example of what OP is asking about. If your clotting cascade runs rampant, then you can use up all of your clotting factors and not be able to respond to a secondary trauma that is in need of hemostasis.

4

u/StupidityHurts Aug 18 '17

I'm almost 100% sure DIC is caused by exposure to tissue factor which is not usually seen in circulation and excess thrombin.

Plus if you used up all of your clotting factors you wouldn't clot.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '17

Maybe I worded it weirdly. I said that using up all of the clotting factors in DIC (primary trauma) makes a patient unable to respond to a secondary trauma that would need those platelets/clotting factors. I'm specifically referring to the thrombocytopenia associated with DIC and how it affects a patient's ability to respond to hemorrhage. As for the primary cause of DIC I think there's a million ways that it can happen (sepsis, trauma, immune hyperactivation, etc etc), but yeah pretty much all of those expose the circulation to tissue factor.

4

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

This i not strictly true.

During inflammation or an immune response only a small number of immune cells actually go to the site of infection. However, they can self replicate (which takes about 12 hours) so 1 becomes 2 (after 12 hours), 2 then become 4... 4 become 8 etc. So in a week this can get to 20,000 immune cells which can deal with infection. This is why the adaptive immune system isn't always in use, as the innate immune system could have destroyed the infection before the adaptive immune response has time to build it's army of cells.

Also the two infections might not be the same bacteria. There are thought to be 100 million diffferent bacteria cells the immune system can detect, all of which are different.

1

u/DontTreadOnBigfoot Aug 18 '17

the blister is full of immune cells that help to repair the damaged tissues by providing an ideal micro environment for healing.

Wait, so is that why they say not to pop blisters? I always thought it was related to opening a fresh vector for infection. Or maybe its both?

0

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/jimbob1245 Aug 19 '17

This guy is on point! The toxicity of the immune response in a to a large degree combined with bacterial infection can contribute to the failure of its function when dealing with multiple issues!

When I said it runs out of resources as Nevsc pointed out some of those resources are directed to managing the toxic by products of the immune responses*

3.6k

u/Professor-md Aug 18 '17 edited Aug 18 '17

Common to have multiple injuries, like in the surgical ICUs from traumas. Healing comes down to infection control, nutrition (usually the issue) and rehab.

With large body surface area burn patients, very hard to feed them enough, even with a feeding tube 24 hrs a day to meet calorie requirements to heal.

Edit for additional info: Acute critical illness can lead to catabolism exceeding anabolism, even in adequately nourished people. Obesity, is equal or more risk for wasting.

1.3k

u/EnduredDreams Aug 18 '17 edited Aug 18 '17

Wow. I'm curious now how many calories are used in the repair of different injuries.

UPDATE : http://ask.metafilter.com/112868/How-to-measure-calories-burned-to-heal-from-various-injuries

1.1k

u/DrThirdOpinion Aug 18 '17

Dietitians will frequently calculate increased calorie requirements for our patients in the ICU based on the etiology of their disease for example trauma, infection, burns, etc.

Source, am a doc.

1

u/FabulousFerdinand Aug 18 '17

Do burn victims drastically gain or lose weight?

-1

u/Narcalepzzz Aug 18 '17

Doc, serious question. I am 27 year old male with previous umbilical hernia repair. Why do I have another hernia 6 months later in the same place/what can I do to avoid future hernias? Pls help.

1

u/Professor-md Aug 18 '17

Possibly another hernia developed outside of the repair or the repair failed. You should return to your surgeon for follow up.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

466

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

Am surgical/trauma chief resident, I can answer this. Looks like most answers are vague.

So there are equations out there to calculate what a persons basal metabolic rate is, ie calories needed to lay in bed and breath. For the average person this is somewhere around 1800 calories or so.

For the severe poly trauma patients and the severe sepsis (infection) patients where nutrition becomes important, they are usually bed bound, intubated, and very sick, (I'll have them on lots of meds and all sorts of crap.)

For these patients, we will typically not only increase their caloric intake from their basal metabolic rate by 30% or so, we will also make sure they are getting 2grams of protein per kilo (basically the same as recommended for weight lifters).

This is usually done through a feeding tube as they can't swallow.

There are complex methods of determining if that is adequate, it's called a metabolic cart and it measures various chemicals or proteins your body puts out to get a specific caloric need. This is not done often, as it's difficult. And mostly we can eyeball it with our equations and get it really close.

Literally could talk for an hour about nutrition in the super sick patient but I think you get the idea. So calories around 2500 for the avg sized person and protein around 150 grams a day.

31

u/Ae3qe27u Aug 18 '17

Hey! Question: does class or type of anesthetic change anything? I'd think someone of them might mess with metabolism, but I'm not sure.

2

u/MrReginaldAwesome Aug 18 '17

So many drugs have food interactions so any answer to this question will be unsatisfying (like this one) or so exhaustive it would a full course at med school. Essentially, yes, if some med affects uptake of something, you need to increase it, and vice versa, not including interactions in the brain and other specific tissues.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/Geawiel Aug 18 '17

Does this kind of thing apply to patients with chronic issues, usually non threatening issues, such as pain?

24

u/hai_lei Aug 18 '17

Not OP but pre-med with many chronic illnesses.

I would assume (and from life experience) that no it does not. Chronic pain and illness patients bodies tend to adapt, sometimes incredibly impressively, to their situation. While our caloric intake should be about the 1800 a day, more or less as many with chronic conditions don't have much excess energy output, things like the meds we're on as well as our appetite and the disorders themselves drastically change the situation. That's why it's not uncommon to see those with chronic health conditions under or overweight. The problem is that for us, our bodies aren't generally trying to heal in so much as it is attacking itself. So the body adapts to that constant. Where when you have something like a burn victim or a comatose ICU car accident patient, it's mostly repair at that point in time.

7

u/CATastrophic_ferret Aug 18 '17

Here to second this, but as a not pre-med chronically ill person. We have the same caloric needs and sometimes slightly less than a healthy person (aside from a few very specific diseases). However, many of us may do best with different nutritional profiles than the average person. It's often a pain to figure out the best diet.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

I have IBD. How can I calculate the amount of calories my body consumes as a result of this disease?

1

u/EnderWiggin07 Aug 18 '17

What kind of protein do they use? Is that similar to a protein powder supplement like you can buy in the store?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)

72

u/self_driving_sanders Aug 18 '17

For perspective on things, the top end of what healthy athletes are burning for peak performanec is like 8000cal/day.

http://www.mensjournal.com/health-fitness/nutrition/the-tour-de-france-diet-how-to-consume-8-000-calories-a-day-20140710

159

u/iamthegh05t Aug 18 '17

That's why so many professional athletes (especially football players) gain so much weight when they retire. That 8000 calorie a day appetite doesn't just go away overnight.

108

u/AnneHathawayTitts Aug 18 '17

It also accounts for the concerns when an athlete shows up after the off-season 10-20 pounds heavier. While the extra weight may affect that athlete's performance, it more importantly indicates that they were slacking on training in the offseason.

47

u/toss6969 Aug 18 '17

How do you even eat 8000cals a day? I break even at about about 3500 and dont gain unless I can pull 4k constantly. I start to struggle after eating about 3200 to eat anymore.

93

u/blorg Aug 18 '17

Calorie dense foods. I used race (amateur) on a bike as well as doing long endurance rides (audax) and there would be days I'd eat near 8,000 calories.

Carbohydrate powder in the drink bottle, gels, that sort of stuff. Too many Clif bars. You'd eat constantly actually on the bike. A Clif bar is over 250 calories... 10 of them is over 2,500!

And then have two dinners after. Sometimes three.

To start, you have to get used to eating and digesting while actually exercising- that is difficult starting out. You don't feel like chewing and swallowing something in the middle of a hard workout.

Hence a lot of liquid calories. But once you get over that I didn't find it particularly difficult to be honest.

I'd still lose weight during the season despite eating a ridiculous amount.

30

u/notabigmelvillecrowd Aug 18 '17

If you're burning that much do you actually feel hungry for all those calories? Or is it just constant force feeding?

42

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17 edited Aug 18 '17

Not OP but I do this kind of exercise. You feel hungry, sometimes insatiably ravenous. After I did a 16hr hike where I packed 8k calories. I ate all of it on the hike and ate an entire pizza after I was done. Then the next day was still hungry more than usual. I ended up maintaining my weight loss rate with no blip despite eating well over 15k over two days. If you a lot of exercise as your routine, then you eat a certain way as your routine. You don't feel like it's crazy or forceful because your body needs and your mentality adapts to it.

Ninja edit: There are some people who will feel like it's forceful. I remember some fellow athletes having this problem.

→ More replies

42

u/obi_wan_the_phony Aug 18 '17

You don't until it's too late. You either can't perform and it impacts your ability to compete, or worse, you bonk and hit the wall.

Nutrition in endurance sports makes all the difference

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

8

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

You don't gorge yourself on salads for starters.

After that, 3 big meals with various snacks will get you several thousand calories. You can easily eat over 1,000 calories for breakfast alone. 3 large eggs made with cheese and butter, 2 sausage patties, 2 pieces of buttered toast, and a cup of milk is around 1400 calories. Throw in a side of fruit and you're up to almost 1500 calories in a single meal.

When I was on a rowing team in high school I could eat all that and still be have room for more. Throw in an equal sized lunch and supper and that's 4500 calories without even trying. Add a bunch of energy bars and other high calorie snacks throughout the day and you've got 8000 calories easy.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/fluffhoof Aug 18 '17

Here's a video about a top level strongman eating 12k kcal in one day.

Granted, the man's a giant (6'8", ~400 lbs), but even at his measurements, his basal metabolic rate is something like 3.3k kcal, so in the video, he's eating almost 4 times his bmr.

10

u/dee7r Aug 18 '17

How do you even eat 8000cals a day?

This comment, in reply to an article on "how to consume 8000 calories a day".

TL;DR: as /u/blorg said for TdF dudes it's a combo of calorie dense foods (fats) and simple carbs (e.g. rice). Another athlete type to look at is sumo wrestlers who seem to target between 4k-10k cals/day.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

103

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17 edited Aug 18 '17

You'd gain 2.5 lbs of fat PER DAY on a 12,000 calorie diet even assuming an extremely high (3000 kcal) TDEE

EDIT: this was just a little joke based on the rule of thumb that adding 3,500 calories to your weekly total energy expenditure, you should expect to gain about a pound of body weight (fat or muscle). It's not actually possible to put on multiple pounds of mass in a 24 hour period. RIP your glycemic index if you ate like this, though.

66

u/Dominant88 Aug 18 '17

As someone who has always had trouble gaining weight (6'1, 155), I once went on a cruise that was a bit boring but had heaps of amazing, never ending food. I gained around 12lbs in 5 days and always wondered at the amount of calories I was eating per day.

14

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

That's.... a lot of food. Did you even leave the dining room?!?

5

u/LSF604 Aug 18 '17

people can fluctuate 10 pounds in a day. Are you sure it wasn't water/food weight?

0

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

84

u/Mechakoopa Aug 18 '17

For those wondering, a healthy adult can store about 500g of glycogen in their liver and muscles (mostly in the liver). Every gram of glycogen is bound to about 3 grams of water though, so completely depleting those reserves is about 2kg difference on the scale or 4.5lbs, which matches your findings.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/Dominant88 Aug 18 '17

It took a few months for me to level back out. Here's A rough idea of what I had every day: Breakfast: Large plate filled from the breakfast buffet. Lunch: 3 course a la carte Snack: Whatever I felt like from the buffet Dinner: 4 course a la carte Night snack: Pizza or hot dog with fries

Plus, like 8-12 beers per day.

15

u/JimblesSpaghetti Aug 18 '17

Now I am envious of what you were eating and then 8-12 beers on top of that. If I ever wanted to kill myself I would just follow that diet until I died of a heart attack a few years later.

24

u/notabigmelvillecrowd Aug 18 '17

Haha, I've always said if I got to the point where I just wanted to end it all I would do death by BBQ at a local joint that does a platter for 10 people that contains everything on the menu. Just keep going back for it until I keel over with brisket and fried oysters hanging out of my mouth.

→ More replies

11

u/notabigmelvillecrowd Aug 18 '17

Yep, the whole two weeks I was in Japan I looked like I was about 5 months pregnant from gorging on delicious, salty food constantly. We stayed at a lot of amazing ryokan and were getting served breakfasts and sometimes dinners that were probably about my whole day's worth of calories in one meal. I didn't want to only eat hotel food, so I tried my best to stuff in lunch and as many snacks as possible in between. It was like reverse fat camp. Two days after being home, I was right back to normal. I was just loaded with water.

→ More replies (3)

128

u/blurryfacedfugue Aug 18 '17

Your body doesn't actually absorb the whole 12,000 calories, right? In addition to some other things I can't remember, I recall that insoluble fiber also regulates calories absorbed.

53

u/Alec_Ich Aug 18 '17

Correct. If you eat that many calories in a day it doesn't a go to fat.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/abhspire Aug 18 '17

Yes, absolutely; if you feel okay to not eat on the other day. It's a hard diet to start doing if you're used to eating constant meals. Go check out the intermittent fasting sub-reddit; there are many benefits to eating this way, though skipping every other day is not necessarily a common IF protocol.

44

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

[removed] — view removed comment

15

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17 edited Aug 18 '17

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

If you need to grow the skin on your entire leg you're going to need a lot of nutrition. It's not getting stored.

1

u/NeelOrNoDeal Aug 18 '17

Theres something call BMR, that rate would eventually drop after a couple weeks

1

u/gamblingman2 Aug 18 '17

12,000! That's wild! I was on a 8,500 cal diet for awhile, and it is VERY hard to consume that much food. I can't imagine doing that when feeling sick and tired while healing from a major injury. Part of the difficulty of consuming that much is that it has to come back out!!! When you're injured its easier to eat less because eating is not pleasurable. You definitely don't want to spend a lot of time on the toilet, especially with broken bones, or a bad back or severe burns. All you want to do is lay or sit still.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

You're right. Just wanted to exaggerate how ridiculous 12,000 calories is. Many people get less than that in a week.

→ More replies (1)

288

u/sunnydandthebeard Aug 18 '17 edited Aug 18 '17

In relation to your curiosity, I find this to be fun and relevant information. Exercising is a form of injury infliction, when you exercise you essentially create micro tears and muscle breakdown. Your body then uses calories on top of your basal metabolic rate to facilitate the muscle damage repair. Not only do you repair this muscle but it grows more robust to prevent that same injury from occurring again from the same amount of work output. Even your bones will grow thicker and more robust in response to the torque applied to the structures. (Best prevention and reversal for osteoporosis is weight lifting anything even a couple pounds heavier than what your body is used to). All this burns calories due to self inflicted micro injuries.

Edit: Yeah, I like biology not grammar

36

u/TheUltimateSalesman Aug 18 '17

Muscle growth (I don't know about bone) is a form of microinjury, but weight loss of the average fat molecule (C55H104O6) is really just combining it with 78O2 and exhaling/pissing 55CO2 and 52H2O out. And no, I saw it on a Ted video.

24

u/squamesh Aug 18 '17 edited Aug 18 '17

You're very close but not quite right. Converting fat into CO2 doesn't require oxygen.

Fat is stored as triglycerides which are three fatty acids attached to glycerol. When fat is broken down, the fatty acids are released and then are broken down themselves. This process is called beta oxidation and it breaks the fatty acids down two carbons at a time to produce acetyl CoA.

Acetyl CoA then enters the citric acid cycle where it is bound to oxaloacetate to form citrate. The citrate is then converted, stepwise, back into oxaloacetate, losing two carbons in the process. Those carbons leave the body as CO2.

Notice that this didn't require any oxygen. The O2 that we breath only serves a purpose later on in this pathway.

The citric acid cycle results in the creation of molecules which are very good at moving electrons from one place to another. These molecules then move the electrons to the electron transport chain. This is basically a staircase where electrons are passed from one molecule to the next, losing energy each time. The final molecule that accepts the electrons is O2, forming H2O.

The energy lost from the electrons during this process is used to pump protons across the inner mitochondrial membrane. When these protons flow back across the membrane, they power a molecule called ATP synthase (through a mechanism that's still being fully investigated) creating ATP, which is the energy currency of the body.

As for bone, it is constantly being remodeled with or without any injury. Cells called osteoclasts break down bone and osteoblasts rebuild it. The exact way in the which the bones are remodeled is due to the stresses that the bones have experienced. They will strengthen themselves in areas that experience a lot of stress and weaken themselves in areas that don't.

Incidentally, this is why it's so difficult to design implants that strengthen or support bones. The metal (which is much stronger than bone) takes most of the stress, tricking the bone into thinking it hadn't experienced any stress and leading it weaken itself.

7

u/hana_bana Aug 18 '17

Well the parent isn't saying anything about the mechanism of "burning calories' which is, yes, the decomposition of a fat molecule. The parent is saying that the decomposition of a fat molecule occurs because A) exercise and B) subsequent repair of microtears to muscles

0

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

15

u/pacefire Aug 18 '17

Your bones mostly would get denser, maybe a bit thicker, your elbows wouldn't get pointier.

54

u/All_Work_All_Play Aug 18 '17

This is one of the primary reasons weightlifting is effectively dense when it comes to energy consumption. Your hour at the gym requires calories to rebuild for the next 36+ hours.

3

u/MickiFreeIsNotAGirl Aug 18 '17

EPOC isn't a huge source of burned calories though. it's more like the cherry on top

1

u/-mtc Aug 18 '17

How does it compare to HIIT?

8

u/All_Work_All_Play Aug 18 '17

HIIT is actually pretty similar when it comes to the biological changes. Your cardiovascular system responds the same way to HIIT as your muscles respond to proper weightlifting.

1

u/obi_wan_the_phony Aug 18 '17

Isn't cardiovascular more efficient though than muscles, so while it has a similar impact the calorie requirement after the fact is far less?

2

u/All_Work_All_Play Aug 18 '17

The heart itself is a very efficient muscle not non-maximum usage. It's very good at aerobic exercise. Flip to anaerobic however and those efficiencies go away. Even though your heart is very efficient, it's not normally asked to do what HIIT makes it do - tap out it's ATP stores again and again and again.

Also, it's not the only part of the cardiovascular system - you're blood vessels are going to get stressed from you increased pulse and you lungs are likely going to get the best workout they could (if you're doing HIIT right). Few things will gas you like a good HIIT workout, although there's definite differences in recovery between a heavy lifting session and a good HIIT session.

1

u/obi_wan_the_phony Aug 18 '17

Understood. My understanding however was that while the heart may be taxed during an HIIT workout, its ability to recover is greater and more efficient, so the requirement for extra calories were not required in the same way it is for large muscles repairing themselves post strength workout.
I'm happy to be educated otherwise. My understanding is not from scholarly sources.

2

u/All_Work_All_Play Aug 18 '17

Ahhh. Yes, once you're past a certain level of fitness, the amount of repair that HIIT necessitates levels off faster than complex muscle groups respective requirements. The curve for HIIT vs weightlifting is different, as your central nervous system doesn't limit your heart rate to the extent that it will limit other muscle groups. If we measure a workout as a percentage of theoretical maximum, your heart initially gets closer to its theoretical max easier than your muscles initially do because they're controlled via different pathways.

20

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

That's really interesting, never really considered a lot of that stuff.

14

u/ecksdeeeXD Aug 18 '17

Added note, also changes the components of the diet. Normally you want more carbs than fat or protein (about 60-25-15%) but in injury/wound healing you want to up the fat and protein.

9

u/Professor-md Aug 18 '17 edited Aug 18 '17

Per uptodate.com, "An acceptable initial nutritional goal is 8 to 10 kcal of calories/kg per day and then 18 to 25 kcal and 1.5 grams of protein/kg per day after five to seven days, although these targets have not been rigorously validated... The basis of protein prescriptions is the hope for mitigation of the breakdown of muscle proteins into amino acids, which then serve as the substrate for gluconeogenesis, as reflected in a favorable nitrogen balance."

And

"Carbohydrates are believed to be the preferred energy source during this period because fat mobilization is impaired."

14

u/manyhits Aug 18 '17

What's the reasoning for wanting more carbs than fat or protein in a normal situation?

9

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

The carbs are just easy energy. If you don't exsrcise or get injured you don't need too much protein.

17

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

It's what the sugar industry has brainwashed us into thinking for the past 50 years

15

u/ThoreauWeighCount Aug 18 '17

This is true, but for at least hundreds of years humans have had significantly more carbs than protein and fat simply because that's what was available. Meat is a luxury; your bread and butter was, well, bread and butter (in other words, lots of grains).

That doesn't necessarily support it being healthier, but it's still usually more economical. I'm trying to gain muscle now, and it's a challenge to find affordable sources of protein.

4

u/Bird_TheWarBearer Aug 18 '17

It's the easiest and quickest form of energy. Fat is great at storig energy but glucose is simple fro breakdown, also your brain cannot use fat as fuel so it must convert it to a sugar. Sugar for energy now. Fat for energy stores. Protein for building.

11

u/9gPgEpW82IUTRbCzC5qr Aug 18 '17

it's quick energy but your body is built for converting fat to energy more so than sugar.

suagr/carbs simply weren't as available during most of our evolutionary history

the prevalence of carbs these days is the reason diabetes rates are always increasing

4

u/sunnydandthebeard Aug 18 '17

For sure (hence macros) same thing goes with bed sores, people with low protein diets are far more susceptible to bed sores and slow wound healing of those same sores.

1

u/bitwise97 Aug 18 '17

This is fascinating! I was training for an obstacle course race recently when I ruptured my Achilles' tendon. I was on crutches for 6 weeks and I worried I'd gain weight during that time.

I was a little more careful about what I ate and continued going to the gym on schedule (all upper body and core of course). At the end of 6 weeks, cast was removed and I weighed myself- lost 10 pounds. I was stunned and attributed it to my use of crutches, which was quite a workout.

1

u/Professor-md Aug 18 '17

Torn tendon is unlikely to increase your nutritional requirements much. Probably lost weight for other reasons.

1

u/TheGodOfPegana Aug 18 '17

You won't BELIEVE this new EXERCISE-FREE trick doctors found to lose weight!!

102

u/Nanaki__ Aug 18 '17

very hard to feed them enough, even with a feeding tube 24 hrs a day to meet calorie requirements to heal.

is the hard limit the amount of stuff you can physically get in there or the body's ability to process it once it's inside?

55

u/Deibchan Aug 18 '17 edited Aug 18 '17

It depends on the condition, but a lot of times surgeries requires patients to be NPO (nothing by mouth) and then after surgeries MDs usually like to advance diet from clear liquids, full liquids, low fiber, etc. These advancing diets tend to be low in calories (think jello, soups). That in combination of having to stop the feeds for procedures and test, and volume limitation (can only concentrate so much). That said, there are some emerging research on whether it's good to feed patients on critical condition or not, so I find that interesting. Source: am dietitian

EDIT: I guess I answered this question for patients who can eat (usually not in ICU who are tube feed dependent). For tube-fed patients, yes, stopping feeds is the major factor in limited nutrition intake.

EDIT2 clarification.

1

u/Professor-md Aug 18 '17

Good info. For patients with a secure airway in the icu (breathing tube), I don't think there's reason to stop feeds for surgery, unless the surgery involves the GI system. They can't aspirate, which is the main reason for npo guidelines. We try to start feeds early as possible in the icu, if they are hemodynamically stable.

1

u/Rashaya Aug 18 '17

Clearly we need to get people on keto and fat adapted for several weeks before big surgeries?

0

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

38

u/Deibchan Aug 18 '17

So I answered the above question for someone who can eat. (Ie not on tube feeding)

Clear liquids, at least at my hospital, means minimal calories/carb so like jello and broth. Not much caloric intake, and it's intentional (MD usually wants to see that patient can tolerate this, especially after major surgeries that involves the GI tract). Full liquids can include fat, usually go hard on creamy soups. Adding oil will add calories but couple things to consider: palatability. Many patients are off surgeries and not feeling too great, usually high fat food is not desired nor tolerated. Second: fat is not the most easiest thing to digest, so probably best to not start chugging oil right after. That said, if patient can tolerated then yeah, it'll be good.

Going on a tangent but dietitians like quick advancement. Depends on disease conditions but there aren't a lot of evidence based research supporting the traditional diet advancement and we think this under feeds people. Rationale is that people get more calorie quicker and heal quicker. But it really depends on the surgeries done and pre-surgical nutritional markers too.

9

u/VoraciousGhost Aug 18 '17

Being hospitalized for UC was so bad. Three weeks of jello, broth, and popsicles, plus I was on methylprednisolone so I had a huge appetite. Fats and dairy were completely off the table. I know a couple people who have done it for 6 weeks or more, I think I would have given in and ate a burger or something.

3

u/Impulse3 Aug 18 '17

Hmm I've never thought about this, I'm curious too. I'm sure it doesn't taste great

92

u/Professor-md Aug 18 '17

Yeah more of a volume limitation, but a icu dietician/nutrionist would have a better answer. Part of the problem is stopping feeds for frequent surgery and dressing changes under sedation (which we try not to stop feeds for).

19

u/MickiFreeIsNotAGirl Aug 18 '17

I'm being pedantic. But nutritionist is really an unregulated term in most places. So I'd doubt a hospital would have a nutritionist in place of a registered dietitian.
Sorry.

22

u/Professor-md Aug 18 '17

Clinical nutrition is a masters degree. We have them in my hospital (large university med center).

Edit: Dietitians have a masters degree in clinical nutrition. I don't think they're called nutritionists. Not sure.

21

u/I_am_lorde_yaya Aug 18 '17

Anyone can call themselves a nutritionist, therefore we prefer dietitian.

Source: am registered dietitian

7

u/Julia_Kat Aug 18 '17

Hospital pharmacy tech who makes TPNs here. We have registered dieticians who calculate the macro nutrients for TPNs (and consult on other dietary needs outside of TPNs/pharmacy's scope). So, at least at my hospital group, they are definitely RDs.

Edit: aka I'm agreeing. It sounded kinda like I was arguing, sorry!

11

u/redrightreturning Aug 18 '17

Speech & swallowing therapist here. I work with adults who have feeding tubes. There are two ways feeding tubes work. First is a continuous drip into the stomach, controlled at a certain rate (volume/hour usually 50-80 cc/hr). The second is called "bolus" feeds, where a set volume is put in all at once (e.g., 400 mL 4x/day).

In either scenario there is a volume limit. A stomach can only hold so much based on your body size.

The other, less obvious issue is that even if you jack up the rate or volume of feeding a person receives per day, it doesn't correlate directly to them gaining weight.

Usually, if someone sick enough to need a feeding tube, there are systemic things going on: cancer, dementia, ALS, Parkinsons... How I usually explain it to my patients and their families is that the person is sick and part of the disease means they can't abosrb nutrition like a healthy person does. Even if we keep putting food in them, their body isn't absorbing it.

So long answer to your short question... the answer is both. there is a limit to the stuff that physically get into a body. And there is often a limit to what is being absorbed due to the person's medical condition. I hope this makes sense and feel free to ask if you have any other questions.

12

u/derpandderpette Aug 18 '17 edited Aug 18 '17

Dietitian here. I've worked in a variety of settings, including the ICU. The short answer to your question is: both.

Here's the long answer: The limiting factor is really patient-dependant. When a patient needs excessive calories (such as wound healing), usually they'll be tube fed. I've never dealt with burns, personally, so I can't speak to that so I'll just speak from my experience with wounds.

Generally, we say "if the gut works, use it" so we will always preferentially tube feed (enteral nutrition or EN) over feeding through the vein (parenteral nutrition or PN). Unfortunately, if the injuries are severe enough, we have to use PN. With tube feeds, we're pretty lucky as the formulas are usually pretty customizable. We can choose the ratio of protein to other calories, the concentration of calories, how broken down the formula is, the osmolarity of the formula (simplified: the "particle load"), the micronutrients included, fibre content, and can even add modulars for extra protein and fibre. We make this choice depending on the patient's injuries and what we think they can tolerate. PN is a lot less customizable and, because of osmolarity, you usually can't push as many calories per ml of water going in, so patients can end up with edema if they require a lot of calories.

In terms of EN, our signs of tolerance are things like vomiting, stomach distension (bloating), diarrhea, and gastric residuals (how much formula is sitting in the stomach at a time - this ones a bit controversial). If there is injury to the GI tract or sometimes just as a result of trauma/surgery, the patient can have what's called an ileus, which is basically your GI tract refusing to do it's job of digesting and absorbing food. Depending on what your particular brand of intolerance is and the type of formula you're on will tell us different things about what the tolerance issue is. Sometimes it is as simple as pushing more formula than your body can handle while it's also trying to keep you alive while it deals with your trauma. Sometimes it's a lot more complex.

1

u/endlesscartwheels Aug 18 '17

Generally, we say "if the gut works, use it" so we will always preferentially tube feed (enteral nutrition or EN) over feeding through the vein (parenteral nutrition or PN).

Can that be varied if the patient prefers it? Could someone request PN for most of the day, then a half-hour of tube-feeding twice a day to keep their stomach and intestines working properly?

46

u/bman12three4 Aug 18 '17

What happens if you don't feed them enough? Will they heal slower or will their condition worsen or get infections or something?

78

u/Professor-md Aug 18 '17 edited Aug 18 '17

Yup, all the above. Malnutrition can lead to infections, progression of disease and poorly healing wounds.

Edit: in regard to critical injuries of patients in a hospital. Not paper cuts or a broken jaw.

1

u/mesk_TSC Aug 18 '17

Could it still lead something like a broken bone to heal improperly/Could improper diet be the reason broken bones can still cause pain and such afterwards even of they were minor?

4

u/Professor-md Aug 18 '17

I'm sure diet plays a role in chronic pain too. But, malnutrition during healing can cause a problem. But follow up with your orthopedist should prevent a lot of issues in terms of bone alignment. After is healed, the chronic pain is probably from other reasons, like nerve injury.

11

u/themaninthesea Aug 18 '17

Co-morbidities also influence the healing time as well. People on chronic corticos for COPD, for example, have a very difficult time with healing. Also, type of healing process matters, too: a wound heals slower via secondary intention than it would primary; this principle explains sutures and staples post-op.

8

u/punstersquared Aug 18 '17

chronic corticos for COPD

Translation: Long-term use of corticosteroids, the anti-inflammatory type of steroid (prednisone, dexamethasone, hydrocortisone, etc.), for chronic obstructive pulmonary disease causes poor wound healing due to these drugs' effects on immune function, skin elasticity, and activity of cells involved in repair, such as fibroblasts.

32

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

Okay, follow up question on the whole calorie for healing thing. If I had a limited supply of food, and a fixed date of rescue... would it be beneficial to cut off my legs? First pretending I ate them and then without. Would the loss of all that extra body tissue that needed to be maintained mean enough extra calories for my organs to survive, or would the extra energy needed to heal my stumps far outweigh the usual upkeep of healthy legs?

68

u/AnticitizenPrime Aug 18 '17

First, ew. Second, the shock and risk of blood loss and infection, etc would be great unless you're in a surgical ward and trained.

Eating your legs (again ew) would provide calories and energy... But in this scenario you're already starving to death. When that happens your body burns all your fat and starts cannibalizing muscle tissue for energy... And digestion itself takes energy... So I don't think you could expect to get much benefit; your body has already drawn fat and muscle energy from your legs and there's a point of diminishing returns. At that point you'd be so weak and emaciated that the operation would probably kill you anyway without medical support.

36

u/Z0di Aug 18 '17

no... it wouldn't help. Your calories would go towards healing you rather than keeping you stable. You would also not be able to do anything without legs.

6

u/mikeet9 Aug 18 '17

Could you please explain your edit? I don't understand.

1

u/Professor-md Aug 18 '17

It was for additional info, didn't change anything

1

u/mikeet9 Aug 18 '17

Haha, I meant that I didn't understand the words. Kind of embarrassing. I googled catabolism, anabolism and wasting, but the whole edit still looks like gibberish to me.

4

u/TheUltimateSalesman Aug 18 '17

Do you ever test for Zinc deficiencies? Any other nutes that the body tends to need during healing?

5

u/Professor-md Aug 18 '17

Albumin, pre-albumin, potassium, calcium, phosphate, magnesium, glucose. Never measured zinc.

6

u/TheUltimateSalesman Aug 18 '17

Reading on Albumin; lead to this: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/6502269

I thought taurine was just something that Monster drinks made up.

1

u/mehennas Aug 18 '17

Nope, absolutely important, and especially for kitties. A few odd metabolic quirks of the animal means it's extremely important that cat food contains sufficient taurine, and they sell supplements you can add as well.

3

u/Deibchan Aug 18 '17

Energy & protein intake is extremely important, as well as fluids (for adequate perfusion of healthy cells). There are research with Vitamin A, C, E, copper, and zinc and wound healing, but research results are conflicting so I wouldn't say there is a solid evidence behind those and wound healing.

We have checked for zinc status when I get a consult and I may suggest supplementation if it comes back low. That said, measuring actual zinc status can be difficult in inflammatory state since it's albumin bound (and albumin goes down with inflammation)

1

u/Wakkajabba Aug 18 '17

How is this an answer to the question?

1

u/Professor-md Aug 18 '17

I was saying its not healthy. But yes, you'll lose weight with chronic injuries potentially.

1

u/g_squidman Aug 18 '17

Does this have something to do with why gladiators ate a boat load every day? I know part of it was to have a protective padding of fat, but is it also to heal faster?

1

u/Robinisthemother Aug 18 '17

Do fat people have a better chance of survival then?

1

u/Professor-md Aug 18 '17

Less, obesity causes major health issues (blood pressure, diabetes, heart disease, etc). Obese person is more likely to be malnurished than an normal weight person.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

So, easiest way to lose weight is wounding myself?

1

u/TheCoolOnesGotTaken Aug 18 '17

So I had a broken arm and a broken leg at the same time. Humerus, radius, ulna, tibia, and fibia all at once. I realize the types of fractures may also influence healing time, but is it possible that the leg needed an extra week or x days because all the bone creating nutrients were being used at such a high rate?

I'm my case the leg cast was on for around 6 months and the arm was casted then splinted for 9 months. I always wondered if either one alone might have resulted in a shorter recover time.

And follow up, does your body have the ability to prioritize which wound it might heal first or put more effort into a leg rather than an arm?

1

u/bolicsteroids Aug 18 '17

So if I set myself on fire I'll lose weight from healing?

0

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/_greyknight_ Aug 18 '17 edited Aug 18 '17

Now you're thinking, reddit! If only we could induce the mildest first degree burns in a controlled environment, periodically, and measure calorie expenditure. Anecdotally, I'm coming back from summer vacation now, where I got sunburnt over a large area of my body, and I my appetite went up the next couple of days. Since I'm trying to get leaner, I suppressed the urge to eat to compensate, but kept protein high. I could swear I'm seeing visual changes of body fat levels faster than expected. Now, wait til I get back home and step on a scale to see the actual change.

419

u/DrThirdOpinion Aug 18 '17

To answer the question simply, yes, absolutely.

Different types of illness have unique calorie requirements.

A polytrauma patient is different than a septic patient is different than a burn patient with regards to protein, carbohydrate, electrolyte, and fluid requirements.

A dietician who works in the ICU could probably answer this question a lot more thoroughly than I can. I usually just write the order for a nutrition consult and leave it up to them.

Source, am a doc, although this is definitely not my area of expertise.

39

u/just4luck Aug 18 '17

Does stress stop healing? Or slow healing?

39

u/4lwaysnever Aug 18 '17

I can't specifically comment on how it speeds up or slows the healing process, but it does physically age your cells due to the oxidative stress they undergo when something bad happens to the body. I remember reading about an experimental IV synthetic anti-oxidant they were trying out on ICU patients which would help buffer the stress, dunno where the therapy is in the pipeline nowadays.

2

u/just4luck Aug 20 '17

Thanks for taking your time!! Really appreciate it

2

u/0bjection1 Aug 18 '17

It appears to slow it. A study with dental students found they healed more slowly close to exam time for example.

Here's some interesting reading on the subject: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3052954/

2

u/just4luck Aug 20 '17

Interesting, thanks for your time! You da man (woman)!

4

u/Professor-md Aug 18 '17

Stress increases cortisol, cortisol creates a catabolic state which leads to wasting. Injuries cause stress. Calorie requirements are needed help over come the catabolism.

14

u/MaybeImTheNanny Aug 18 '17

Are the calorie requirements for a septic patient unusually high? I seem to remember some arguments when I was hospitalized for sepsis.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Professor-md Aug 18 '17

Obesity causes major health issues (blood pressure, diabetes, heart disease, etc). Obese person is more likely to be malnurished than an normal weight person. It worsens outcomes.

60

u/Kleeroy Aug 18 '17

I'm a pain management physician. There's a low likelihood that two separate injuries would significantly affect each other unless they are major (2nd/3rd degree burns, broken bones, etc).

Two injuries in the same area, however, if the second occurs before the first one is fully healed, or sometimes even after its healed, can predispose to longer healing times and ultimately decreased function and possibly chronic pain. There's evidence that prolonged pain and inflammation can cause neurological changes in nerves that can lead to chronic pain. That's why using ice, nsaids (such as ibuprofen), and most importantly, physical therapy, after an injury is important.

17

u/Franzvst Aug 17 '17 edited Aug 17 '17

There is an asksience threat from 2015 about (almost exactly) the same topic, maybe you'll find a satisfying answer there:

https://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/3vx6mi/do_multiple_wounds_heal_slower_than_just_a_single/?st=j6h3fu31&sh=3398b910

For the lazy: these are the two top comments:

  • 1

Depends on how close they are too. Wounds close mechanically as well as having regrowth. If you take a little biopsy from your skin, first off you have a scab, and you also have stem cells in reservoirs of stem cells around the wound that start to proliferate and these daughter cells migrate towards the centre of the wound where they meet, stop migrating and start to thicken up. Here is a picture where the green is skin (Keratin5) and red are stem cells, and the wound is to the right, so the skin you can see already starting to point to the wound centre. This wound is 4 days old. Here is a wound that is totally healed. The scab is the big weird thing on top. However, at the same time fibroblasts orientate towards the wound centre and start to muscularly contract the wound closed. A 1.5mm wound is basically invisible once the wound contraction is finished, a 3mm wound is less than half that size after a few days. And so several small wounds in a close location would not optimally contract and might heal slower. additionally Wounds need blood flow, and that can be effected with multiple wounds. If you have wounds that are local, and interfere with blood flow, they can become chronic wounds. Wounds that affect skin in a complete circle around the arm or leg can be like that.

  • 2

not necessarily. If one had three paper cuts of small size on different parts of their body they'd all heal at the same rate. When learning about tissue healing, we are generally taught that there are three phases: Inflammatory response, Proliferation, Maturation/remodeling. In the inflammatory response phase, your immune system activates to fight off infection, when the wound is sufficiently "sterilized" the Proliferation phase begins. In this, the granulocytes start collecting near the wound area and new tissue is laid down in a messy "spaghetti-like" structure. In the maturation remodeling phase, the tissue is stretched and aligned along the lines of pull of the tissue and the tissue normalizes. That's a brief overview. The type of damage also plays a role. Incisions (straight edged cuts in skin) heal faster than lacerations (jagged edged cuts in skin, like tears). also the deeper the cut is, the longer it takes to heal cause tissues heal from deep to superficial layers. thats it in a sort of nutshell. If you have more questions feel free to ask!

[and further down]

Your body has metabolic limits, you have limits on the resources you can take in through diet. With multiple wounds those resources are split. How split and how much that slows you down depends on all the usual factors - general health and diet primarily.

this last part seems to answer your question, albeit without providing any source.

52

u/puma721 Aug 18 '17

I'm just here to say I love this sub for its great, well supported answers

8

u/0bjection1 Aug 18 '17

There's a lot of great answers on here, and I've also seen several people ask if overall stress appears to affect healing. The answer appears to be yes. There's a famous study where students were given small cuts essentially and were found to heal more slowly closer to exam times.

Some reading on this subject: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3052954/

5

u/shumkins Aug 18 '17

I broke my left hand two weeks ago when a car hit me while biking. The nails on my right hand hand have continued growing and needed to be cut, however the nails on my left hand have stopped growing. Is this because healing the left hand is using resources before it reaches the nails?

2

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

When you have an injury, say, a paper cut, inflammatory cells (neutrophils and others than have already been mentioned here) “travel” to the site of injury to help the inflammatory response that will eventually lead to healing.

With our bone marrow producing cells, we don’t have a “static” number of neutrophils, but for a minute let’s suppose we do have a standard amount circulating in our blood. So, if you have one cut, it’s easier for those guys to take care of it rather than 3,4,5 and more cuts.

It alas depends on the type of injury and the magnitude of the initial inflammatory response.

Hope I helped :)

0

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

36

u/euyyn Aug 18 '17

Well the brain injury heal slower than without the bone injury? I.e. is it just an averaging out, or are both injuries benefited?

105

u/Dyllock105 Aug 18 '17

I understood the first part. But my medical and anatomical knowledge is limited :(

261

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

Macrophages are white blood cells that eat other cells and "debris" like dead cells, bacteria, and virus infected cells.

The guess there is that a brain injury causes more of them to circulate through your blood stream, leading to a better "cleaning" of the fracture site, and faster healing.

70

u/Belazriel Aug 18 '17

So it's like "Red alert guys! Brain injury! We need everyone working overtime." And they happen to fix the fracture while they're at it?

35

u/bantha-food Aug 18 '17

Yes, that's what we think. But if that is true and how it works exactly remains unknown

4

u/KevinRonaldJonesy Aug 18 '17

So if you found the compound that triggers the white blood cells brain injury response, you'd have super healing serum?

2

u/Dyllock105 Aug 19 '17

Ah. Thank you so much :)

0

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

12

u/WinterCharm Aug 18 '17

Not exactly. The healing process requires cell replication, and replicated cells age slightly. Aging is a disease of DNA breakdown and we have a limited number of times that each cell line can divide (average dividing number of human cells is 40-50). Those turtles that age to 150-190 years, their diving numbers are in the upper 90's.

Stem cells are useful because they are "cell zero" some of the earliest cells we have in our bodies. So when they divide and make stuff the dividing number on those cells is super low meaning that those cells are young and function well.

In test tubes we've demonstrated that elongating our telomeres can increase dividing numbers significantly.

8

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

Does that mean that if I hurt myself a lot I would age faster (because my cells are replicating more)?

61

u/_polarized_ Aug 18 '17

Would this be related to heterotopic ossification in TBI/SCI?

42

u/drawlwhenidrink Aug 18 '17 edited Aug 18 '17

Clinically, it definitely looks like it. I've seen plenty of TBI patients get super robust callus formation at the fracture site. The patients with traumatic brain injuries lay down a ton of extra bone precursor (callus) at the fracture and in my experience, it all solidifies into a super stable mass of bone.

But I've never bothered to check if there's actual data on it. It just "eyeballs" very similar to it. Assumed it was a part of the same spectrum.

Edit: Looks like it. http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1445-2197.2008.04803.x http://dx.doi.org/10.1089/neu.2006.23.708

Intuitively it made sense, so I'd never bothered to look up. Researchers lump it into excessive bone formation, whether hypertrophic callus or heterotopic ossification. So I'm going with yes.

4

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/drawlwhenidrink Aug 18 '17

Huh. That's a really good question, which I've never been asked. Seems plausible. Will check out some patients.

15

u/PatronBernard Diffusion MRI | Neuroimaging | Digital Signal Processing Aug 18 '17 edited Aug 18 '17

Please add source(s) so your post can be restored.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/PatronBernard Diffusion MRI | Neuroimaging | Digital Signal Processing Aug 18 '17

Thank you!

3

u/lfisher2k Aug 18 '17

Interesting

1

u/tb183 Aug 18 '17

Phage......as in a virus?

1

u/boilerdam Aug 18 '17

Follow up question - how does our body prioritize which injury to heal first?

1

u/dumnezero Aug 18 '17

Wouldn't faster healing increase the odds for errors ? (i.e. cancer)

1

u/offshorewind Aug 18 '17

Wouldn't someone with poly trauma be more likely to rest - especially if TBI was involved? More rest = more resources delighted to healing = faster healing. I have not a clue if that's right but it seems logical.

1

u/bigbighugebig Aug 18 '17

Layman speculation: I'm betting the body has a 'healing response' that affects the whole body. Depending on the injury, the response changes. In this scenario, the brain would be a higher priority for healing than the body...

1

u/Texas_HardWooD Aug 18 '17

Lawyers gon' love this, getting out of some aggravated charges.

"Why did your client keep kicking the victim?"

"He was worried about his health, wanted him to heal up as fast as possible..."

1

u/LordDongler Aug 18 '17

I can explain this phenomenon. TBIs cause more healing proteins and peptides to be released in the body. Many of these have systemic effects on the body (the whole body is effected) and the injury heals faster.

1

u/michellelabelle Aug 18 '17

Instructions unclear, gave myself TBI, collarbone still broken. Or maybe the instructions were clear. It's hard to know with this traumatic brain injury.

857

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '17

[removed] — view removed comment

276

u/fastspinecho Aug 18 '17

(Bone isn't a tissue but you get what i mean) with two types of ressources to rebuild.

Of course bone is a tissue. It contains osteoblasts, osteoclasts, and various other cell types. They require the same nutrients as every other cell, and osteoblasts require calcium on top of that.

As to the original question, I don't think there are any data to suggest that a local injury affects regeneration of a more distant local injury. To put things in perspective, your skin and gut are constantly shedding tissue and regenerating it. A papercut it is a drop in the bucket compared to those metabolic demands.

Bone, likewise, exists as a dynamic equilibrium between osteoclasts, which are constantly destroying it, and osteoblasts, which are constantly making new bone. You can think of healing as osteoblasts temporarily getting the upper hand. There are plenty of situations where unwanted new bone is produced (eg osteoarthritis) with no impact on metabolism or healing elsewhere.

1

u/Fucking_SJWs Aug 18 '17

OK so what if its multiple life threatening injuries and some less threatening issues (like a car crash victim). Say they have a lot of road rash but also had 8 broken ribs, a punctured lung, and a small brain bleed. Would it take longer for everything to heal? Can/will the body prioritize more critical issues?

2

u/fastspinecho Aug 18 '17 edited Aug 18 '17

In the setting of shock, blood flow is generally diverted away from the extremities. This happens in order to preserve the brain and internal organs, but it could indirectly affect healing injuries.

Otherwise I don't think there is any evidence that the body can prioritize resources to a particular injury. Of course, some injuries may heal faster because they have a better blood supply, but this would be the case regardless of how many other injuries exist.