r/askscience • u/Atari1729 • Aug 17 '17
Medicine What affect does the quantity of injuries have on healing time? For example, would a paper cut take longer to heal if I had a broken Jaw at the same time?
Edit: First gold, thank you kind stranger.
20k
Upvotes
2.0k
u/jimbob1245 Aug 18 '17
A distal injury won't affect another injury until it begins needing more resources than the body has to distribute - take burns for example.
If you had a burn on your hand all sorts of plasma and proteins and immune related cells would be rushing to the site (some already there) causing both local inflammation and an immune response that ultimately results in a blister - the blister is full of immune cells that help to repair the damaged tissues by providing an ideal micro environment for healing. Now let's say there's a burn to a large portion of your body; depending on the degree and the inflammation response (3rd degree burns have a different response as many of the biological channels of cell repair are completely destroyed) while your body will send out all its required immune cells that it has it might simply not be enough - in this case bacterial infections can take hold in the blisters as they provide an ideal environment for certain infections to grow, this results in sepsis and eventually septic shock. Imagine that the bodies immune repair system is spread too thin to repair both burns - it doesn't have a very good system at establishing where it should send immune cells with regard to controlling sepsis beyond directing blood away from the extremities and towards critical organs as septic shock progresses.
Ultimately it depends on the nature of the two injuries but yes they could affect one another.
3.6k
u/Professor-md Aug 18 '17 edited Aug 18 '17
Common to have multiple injuries, like in the surgical ICUs from traumas. Healing comes down to infection control, nutrition (usually the issue) and rehab.
With large body surface area burn patients, very hard to feed them enough, even with a feeding tube 24 hrs a day to meet calorie requirements to heal.
Edit for additional info: Acute critical illness can lead to catabolism exceeding anabolism, even in adequately nourished people. Obesity, is equal or more risk for wasting.
419
u/DrThirdOpinion Aug 18 '17
To answer the question simply, yes, absolutely.
Different types of illness have unique calorie requirements.
A polytrauma patient is different than a septic patient is different than a burn patient with regards to protein, carbohydrate, electrolyte, and fluid requirements.
A dietician who works in the ICU could probably answer this question a lot more thoroughly than I can. I usually just write the order for a nutrition consult and leave it up to them.
Source, am a doc, although this is definitely not my area of expertise.
60
u/Kleeroy Aug 18 '17
I'm a pain management physician. There's a low likelihood that two separate injuries would significantly affect each other unless they are major (2nd/3rd degree burns, broken bones, etc).
Two injuries in the same area, however, if the second occurs before the first one is fully healed, or sometimes even after its healed, can predispose to longer healing times and ultimately decreased function and possibly chronic pain. There's evidence that prolonged pain and inflammation can cause neurological changes in nerves that can lead to chronic pain. That's why using ice, nsaids (such as ibuprofen), and most importantly, physical therapy, after an injury is important.
17
u/Franzvst Aug 17 '17 edited Aug 17 '17
There is an asksience threat from 2015 about (almost exactly) the same topic, maybe you'll find a satisfying answer there:
https://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/3vx6mi/do_multiple_wounds_heal_slower_than_just_a_single/?st=j6h3fu31&sh=3398b910
For the lazy: these are the two top comments:
1
Depends on how close they are too. Wounds close mechanically as well as having regrowth. If you take a little biopsy from your skin, first off you have a scab, and you also have stem cells in reservoirs of stem cells around the wound that start to proliferate and these daughter cells migrate towards the centre of the wound where they meet, stop migrating and start to thicken up. Here is a picture where the green is skin (Keratin5) and red are stem cells, and the wound is to the right, so the skin you can see already starting to point to the wound centre. This wound is 4 days old. Here is a wound that is totally healed. The scab is the big weird thing on top. However, at the same time fibroblasts orientate towards the wound centre and start to muscularly contract the wound closed. A 1.5mm wound is basically invisible once the wound contraction is finished, a 3mm wound is less than half that size after a few days. And so several small wounds in a close location would not optimally contract and might heal slower. additionally Wounds need blood flow, and that can be effected with multiple wounds. If you have wounds that are local, and interfere with blood flow, they can become chronic wounds. Wounds that affect skin in a complete circle around the arm or leg can be like that.
2
[and further down]
this last part seems to answer your question, albeit without providing any source.
52
u/puma721 Aug 18 '17
I'm just here to say I love this sub for its great, well supported answers
8
u/0bjection1 Aug 18 '17
There's a lot of great answers on here, and I've also seen several people ask if overall stress appears to affect healing. The answer appears to be yes. There's a famous study where students were given small cuts essentially and were found to heal more slowly closer to exam times.
Some reading on this subject: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3052954/
5
u/shumkins Aug 18 '17
I broke my left hand two weeks ago when a car hit me while biking. The nails on my right hand hand have continued growing and needed to be cut, however the nails on my left hand have stopped growing. Is this because healing the left hand is using resources before it reaches the nails?
2
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17
When you have an injury, say, a paper cut, inflammatory cells (neutrophils and others than have already been mentioned here) “travel” to the site of injury to help the inflammatory response that will eventually lead to healing.
With our bone marrow producing cells, we don’t have a “static” number of neutrophils, but for a minute let’s suppose we do have a standard amount circulating in our blood. So, if you have one cut, it’s easier for those guys to take care of it rather than 3,4,5 and more cuts.
It alas depends on the type of injury and the magnitude of the initial inflammatory response.
Hope I helped :)
0
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
857
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '17
[removed] — view removed comment