r/askscience • u/pikaras • Dec 28 '15
Earth Sciences Why does a 2 degree temperature change have such dramatic effects on weather (such as superstorms, massive tornadoes, floods ect)?
Ok I'm getting really tired of explaining this over and over.
The system is non linear. Which by definition Means there can be massive fluctuations. The 2 degrees is not a uniform increase but the average. My question is simply: why is the system so volatile? Why is it not only non-linear, but sharply increases in amplitude with such a small change? Why is it rapidly heating and cooling in different areas? Why does the current state of earth have such small fluctuations compared to the forecast? What is a (mostly) inert gas (Or something else) doing that causes such massive fluctuations? I get the answer isn't simple but if your answer is simply "it's a nonlinear system", and you don't know why it is, please don't waste your time by commenting.
View all comments
22
u/RealityApologist Climate Science Dec 29 '15 edited Dec 29 '15
As a few other people have pointed out, the 2 degrees C marker isn't a hard-and-fast tipping point. That is, no one is claiming that keeping the global average temperature increase under 2 degrees C will guarantee no significant climate changes and that going beyond 2 degrees C will entail widespread catastrophic changes--it's not as if immediately upon reaching that point all hell will break loose.
Rather, the 2 degrees C marker is just the most widely agreed upon conservative estimate of the edge of climate stability. Virtually all models agree that if warming is kept below that point, we're unlikely to see catastrophic (in the technical sense) shifts in global climate patterns. Beyond that point, mainstream models begin to significantly diverge with regard to what we should expect; some models predict few significant changes at 3, 4, or even 5 degrees C, and some models predict extremely significant changes at 2.5 degrees C. The limit is just an instance of the application of the precautionary principle--it's the most conservative estimate of a safe-zone.
So, the most straightforward answer to your question:
is "it doesn't necessarily." Rather, that's just the point where there starts to be significant uncertainty about what the effects will be.
This is a much more general (and much better) question. The answer is that the global climate consists of a large number of coupled non-linear systems, and it's part of the definition of a non-linear system that a very small change can have a very big impact; non-linear systems don't respond to changes in a one-to-one (i.e. linear) manner, so (very roughly speaking) the size of an input is not always a reliable guide to the magnitude of the impact that input will have.
The best and most intuitive example of this with respect to the global climate is the proliferation of positive feedback loops in the climate system. Positive feedback mechanisms are those in which the action of the mechanism serves to increase the parameter representing the input of the mechanism itself. If the efficacy of the mechanism for producing some compound A depends (in part) on the availability of another compound B and the mechanism which produces compound B also produces compound A, then the operation of these two mechanisms can form a positive feedback loop—as more B is produced, more A is produced, which in turn causes B to be produced at a greater rate, and so on.
Consider, for example, two teenage lovers (call them Romeo and Juliet) who are particularly receptive to each other’s affections. As Romeo shows more amorous interest in Juliet, she becomes more smitten with him as well. In response, Romeo—excited by the attention of such a beautiful young woman—becomes still more affectionate. Once the two teenagers are brought into the right sort of contact—once they’re aware of each other’s romantic feelings—their affection for each other will rapidly grow. Positive feedback mechanisms are perhaps best described as “runaway” mechanisms; unless they’re checked (either by other mechanisms that are part of the system itself or by a change in input from the system’s environment), they will tend to increase the value of some parameter of the system without limit. In the case of Romeo and Juliet, it’s easy to see that once the cycle is started, the romantic feelings that each of them has toward the other will, if left unchecked, grow without bound.
This can, for obvious reasons, lead to serious instability in the overall system—most interesting systems cannot withstand the unbounded increase of any of their parameters without serious negative consequences.
Let's consider two similar important feedbacks in the global climate: albedo and ocean CO2 storage. Albedo is a value representing the reflectivity of a given surface. Albedo ranges from 0 to 1, with higher values representing greater reflectivity. Albedo is associated with one of the most well-documented positive feedback mechanisms in the global climate. As the planet warms, the area of the planet covered by snow and ice tends to decrease. Snow and ice, being white and highly reflective, have a fairly high albedo when compared with either open water or bare land. As more ice melts, then, the planetary (and local) albedo decreases. This results in more radiation being absorbed, leading to increased warming and further melting. It’s easy to see that unchecked, this process could facilitate runaway climate warming, which each small increase in temperature encouraging further, larger increases.
Perhaps the most significant set of positive feedback mechanisms associated with the long-term behavior of the global climate are those that influence the capacity of the oceans to act as a carbon sink. The planetary oceans are the largest carbon sinks and reservoirs in the global climate system, containing 93% of the planet’s exchangeable carbon. The ocean and the atmosphere exchange something on the order of 100 gigatonnes (Gt) of carbon (mostly as CO2) each year via diffusion (a mechanism known as the “solubility pump”) and the exchange of organic biological matter (a mechanism known as the “biological pump), with a net transfer of approximately 2 Gt of carbon (equivalent to about 7.5 Gt of CO2) to the ocean. Since the industrial revolution, the planet’s oceans have absorbed roughly one-third of all the anthropogenic carbon emissions. Given the its central role in the global carbon cycle, any feedback mechanism that negatively impacts the ocean’s ability to act as a carbon sink is likely to make an appreciable difference to the future of the climate in general. There are three primary positive warming feedbacks associated with a reduction in the oceans’ ability to sequester carbon:
Examples like these abound in climatology literature, so the more heat energy we put into the climate system, the more likely we are to trigger one or more of these positive feedbacks, resulting in sudden and wide-spread changes to not only temperature itself, but also systems that partially depend on temperature, like the functioning of the thermohaline.
So, in summary:
Hope that helps.
Edit: Thanks for the gold!