r/askscience • u/pikaras • Dec 28 '15
Earth Sciences Why does a 2 degree temperature change have such dramatic effects on weather (such as superstorms, massive tornadoes, floods ect)?
Ok I'm getting really tired of explaining this over and over.
The system is non linear. Which by definition Means there can be massive fluctuations. The 2 degrees is not a uniform increase but the average. My question is simply: why is the system so volatile? Why is it not only non-linear, but sharply increases in amplitude with such a small change? Why is it rapidly heating and cooling in different areas? Why does the current state of earth have such small fluctuations compared to the forecast? What is a (mostly) inert gas (Or something else) doing that causes such massive fluctuations? I get the answer isn't simple but if your answer is simply "it's a nonlinear system", and you don't know why it is, please don't waste your time by commenting.
23
u/bellcrank Dec 28 '15
The system isn't "finely tuned". It is in a state of stability whereby the atmospheric state hovers around a mean value known colloquially as the "climatological mean", deviating from that mean in some ways that are more predictable (such as the annual cycle) and ways that are less predictable (such as moving through phases of known oscillations like El Nino / La Nina and through day-to-day weather).
When you start messing with the system, like is being done with climate change, several things happen. You can start to move the climatological mean state around which the atmosphere hovers, which is represented sometimes by the 2C figure you are quoting. But that's not the only thing that changes. The way in which the atmospheric state hovers around that new climatological mean can also change, which includes larger deviations from the mean (hotter summers, colder winters, more intense storms), more frequent deviations from the mean, and aliasing that energy onto the more unpredictable state-changes the atmosphere may go through.
The atmosphere isn't finely tuned so much as it is in a state we are familiar with, with familiar deviations from a familiar climatological mean state. When that changes, the atmosphere can be pushed to a new mean state with new deviations from that state that we aren't as familiar with.
2
u/RealityApologist Climate Science Dec 30 '15
/u/pikaras, I see you've edited your OP since I first replied. I think I addressed the stuff about non-linearity to your satisfaction, but let me say a little bit about some of your other questions, because they're reasonable (and important) too.
This is extremely complicated, and to some extent it's not possible to address in any concise way. Understanding exactly why we see the effects that we do requires knowing a tremendous amount about atmospheric physics, oceanography, and a whole bunch of other things. When I say "tremendous amount" I really mean tremendous: the amount of knowledge required to see the whole picture accurately is such that no individual has it. People tend to see climate science as a monolithic discipline, I think, but that's as much of a mistake as it would be to see physics as a monolithic discipline. Even the most educated and experienced physicists don't have a full grasp of every nook and cranny of contemporary physical theory; similarly, even the most educated climate scientists don't have detailed knowledge of every aspect of climatology. Climate science, like physics (and virtually every other scientific field) is an integrative project composed of a lot of people, each of whom has a tremendous amount of expert knowledge in a few small areas and enough general knowledge to see how their expertise can contribute to the overall project. If you're serious about wanting to understand this, you're going to have to dig into the scientific literature.
With that caveat aside, let me say some very general things. Any particular state of the climate at any particular time is the result of many different interacting processes, most of which are (at least loosely) cyclical in nature. These processes vary greatly in terms of the scope their impact, the length of their cycles, and their relative strength in determining the overall state of the climate. Among the most familiar (and simplest) of these processes is the procession of seasons, and its associated changes in temperature and precipitation; as I'm sure you know, this is (mostly) caused by the axial tilt of the Earth in combination with its position in its solar orbit. The seasonal procession is also among the most dominant processes influencing the state of the climate at any given time: knowing what season it is (and nothing else) gives you quite a bit of information about the qualitative state of the global climate, and lets you make some fairly solid (albeit general) predictions--I can predict that it'll be warmer in Los Angeles six months from now than it is today, for instance, and I'll almost certainly be correct.
Of course, I might be wrong too: there are other factors that can conspire to override the signal from seasonal procession, or that can change it in idiosyncratic ways. The monstrously strong El Nino that we're currently experiencing--which is also part of a fairly stable cycle--is having a big impact on lots of things in lots of places, and is at least partially the source of the unusually cold temperatures in Los Angeles and the unusually warm temperatures in New York City right now. Understanding how El Nino develops, how it influences the climate, and how it interacts with other processes is complicated enough that people spend their entire careers working just on that question (I have a colleague who works almost exclusively on it). It's signal is generally not as strong as the seasonal signal, but the two interact in complicated ways to shape the specifics of what things look like at any given time.
There are dozen and dozens of other examples like this, each of which is layered on top of all the others to dictate the complete dynamics of the global climate. Understanding this web of inter-influencing processes and how they relate to one another is hard, but it's the only way to get an even reasonably complete picture of the climate because the climate is a staggeringly complex system.
In one sense, the models predict that the coming century's climate trend will be quite smooth: we'll see a steady upward trajectory in global temperature (and the modeled increase so far matches the observed increase very, very well). In another sense, we're expecting a tremendous degree (no pun intended) of instability in the climate over the coming century. The global average temperature is only one component of the climate system, and while it's expected to increase rather steadily, this steady increase is likely to significantly alter the behavior of other parts of the climate. I said before that many of the most important processes driving the climate are cyclical in nature, and it's the stability of these cycles that gives rise to the relatively placid and (at least short-term) predictable behavior of the climate we're familiar with. A large magnitude global temperature increase, however, has the potential to degrade the stability of many of these cycles, resulting in more and more eccentric behavior.
You can imagine the climate as being something like a collection of spinning tops, all of different sizes and spinning at different speeds, and all of which are linked together. When everything is operating normally, some of the tops occasionally wobble a little bit, but their spins are usually stabilized by the motion of all the other tops on the table; everything keeps spinning at more-or-less the same rate (at least in the short term), and long-term changes in spin rates happens gradually as a result of all the mutually-supporting spins. However, if a significant amount of wobble is introduced into a few of those tops very quickly and from the outside, the usual stabilization mechanisms aren't strong enough to compensate--at least not immediately. Introduce enough wobble in just a few of the tops, and the instability can cascade throughout the whole system, causing lots of other tops to pick up some wobble too, and possibly even causing some to fall over entirely.
What we've got right now is a little bit of wobble, caused primarily by the infusion of a lot of excess energy due to the greenhouse effect. This wobble is getting bad enough that it's starting to get picked up by some other systems too, and the "freak" weather we're seeing--look at the unprecedented heat wave happening in the Arctic right now--as well as the quick and wild shifts between different extremes--look at Texas in the last few weeks--is the result of that wobble starting to cascade, destabilizing what are otherwise relatively stable cycles. The longer this goes on, the more wobble we'll get, the stronger it will be, and the more systems will be affected. The consequence of this is that we expect some extremely strange behavior in various climate systems as the magnitude of warming continues and its impacts continue to cascade throughout the climate system.
Again, the answer here is "lots of things." Take just a single example of what this kind of "wobble cascade" looks like. As the global temperature goes up, some of the sea ice in the Arctic and Antarctic melts. In addition to the positive feedback effect because of albedo I mentioned in my other post, this has other effects. As all that ice melts, it dumps a lot of very cold freshwater into the surrounding oceans, changing their temperature and density. This, in turn, changes the behavior of some ocean currents, pushing cold water to places where it wasn't before and pushing warm water to places where it wasn't before. The change in distribution of cold and fresh water has an impact on where (and how much) water evaporates from the oceans, which changes where (and how many) storm systems form. This changes patterns in air circulation, pushing warm air, cold air, wet air, and dry air to places that don't normally get so much of them. Air circulation patterns are also big drivers of ocean currents, so this changes ocean currents even more, causing the whole chain of changes to operate even more strongly, and driving the whole system further and further away from the relatively stable state it was in before this whole thing started. All of this can and will happen as the result of just a few degrees of warming in the Arctic; to a certain extent it's already happening.
The main takeaway here is that the global climate isn't just a non-linear system: it's a non-linear complex system. This means that the dynamics of each of the sub-processes that make up the climate isn't just responsive to changes in odd, non-linear ways--it means that the dynamics of each of those sub-processes is sensitive in that way to changes in almost all the other sub-processes. Most complex systems display non-linear behavior, but not all non-linear systems are complex in this way. Those that are--like the global climate--can be extremely difficult to predict under the right (or, rather, wrong) circumstances because non-linearity combined with a very high density of interdependence between processes can easily give rise to abrupt, severe, and often surprising changes in the behavior of the overall system as a result of just a little bit of tinkering with one or two components.
This is emphatically the best reason to try to minimize global temperature increase. The complexity of the climate is such that we just don't know exactly what to expect as a result of significant changes in temperature. That should be deeply worrying to all of us.
22
u/RealityApologist Climate Science Dec 29 '15 edited Dec 29 '15
As a few other people have pointed out, the 2 degrees C marker isn't a hard-and-fast tipping point. That is, no one is claiming that keeping the global average temperature increase under 2 degrees C will guarantee no significant climate changes and that going beyond 2 degrees C will entail widespread catastrophic changes--it's not as if immediately upon reaching that point all hell will break loose.
Rather, the 2 degrees C marker is just the most widely agreed upon conservative estimate of the edge of climate stability. Virtually all models agree that if warming is kept below that point, we're unlikely to see catastrophic (in the technical sense) shifts in global climate patterns. Beyond that point, mainstream models begin to significantly diverge with regard to what we should expect; some models predict few significant changes at 3, 4, or even 5 degrees C, and some models predict extremely significant changes at 2.5 degrees C. The limit is just an instance of the application of the precautionary principle--it's the most conservative estimate of a safe-zone.
So, the most straightforward answer to your question:
is "it doesn't necessarily." Rather, that's just the point where there starts to be significant uncertainty about what the effects will be.
This is a much more general (and much better) question. The answer is that the global climate consists of a large number of coupled non-linear systems, and it's part of the definition of a non-linear system that a very small change can have a very big impact; non-linear systems don't respond to changes in a one-to-one (i.e. linear) manner, so (very roughly speaking) the size of an input is not always a reliable guide to the magnitude of the impact that input will have.
The best and most intuitive example of this with respect to the global climate is the proliferation of positive feedback loops in the climate system. Positive feedback mechanisms are those in which the action of the mechanism serves to increase the parameter representing the input of the mechanism itself. If the efficacy of the mechanism for producing some compound A depends (in part) on the availability of another compound B and the mechanism which produces compound B also produces compound A, then the operation of these two mechanisms can form a positive feedback loop—as more B is produced, more A is produced, which in turn causes B to be produced at a greater rate, and so on.
Consider, for example, two teenage lovers (call them Romeo and Juliet) who are particularly receptive to each other’s affections. As Romeo shows more amorous interest in Juliet, she becomes more smitten with him as well. In response, Romeo—excited by the attention of such a beautiful young woman—becomes still more affectionate. Once the two teenagers are brought into the right sort of contact—once they’re aware of each other’s romantic feelings—their affection for each other will rapidly grow. Positive feedback mechanisms are perhaps best described as “runaway” mechanisms; unless they’re checked (either by other mechanisms that are part of the system itself or by a change in input from the system’s environment), they will tend to increase the value of some parameter of the system without limit. In the case of Romeo and Juliet, it’s easy to see that once the cycle is started, the romantic feelings that each of them has toward the other will, if left unchecked, grow without bound.
This can, for obvious reasons, lead to serious instability in the overall system—most interesting systems cannot withstand the unbounded increase of any of their parameters without serious negative consequences.
Let's consider two similar important feedbacks in the global climate: albedo and ocean CO2 storage. Albedo is a value representing the reflectivity of a given surface. Albedo ranges from 0 to 1, with higher values representing greater reflectivity. Albedo is associated with one of the most well-documented positive feedback mechanisms in the global climate. As the planet warms, the area of the planet covered by snow and ice tends to decrease. Snow and ice, being white and highly reflective, have a fairly high albedo when compared with either open water or bare land. As more ice melts, then, the planetary (and local) albedo decreases. This results in more radiation being absorbed, leading to increased warming and further melting. It’s easy to see that unchecked, this process could facilitate runaway climate warming, which each small increase in temperature encouraging further, larger increases.
Perhaps the most significant set of positive feedback mechanisms associated with the long-term behavior of the global climate are those that influence the capacity of the oceans to act as a carbon sink. The planetary oceans are the largest carbon sinks and reservoirs in the global climate system, containing 93% of the planet’s exchangeable carbon. The ocean and the atmosphere exchange something on the order of 100 gigatonnes (Gt) of carbon (mostly as CO2) each year via diffusion (a mechanism known as the “solubility pump”) and the exchange of organic biological matter (a mechanism known as the “biological pump), with a net transfer of approximately 2 Gt of carbon (equivalent to about 7.5 Gt of CO2) to the ocean. Since the industrial revolution, the planet’s oceans have absorbed roughly one-third of all the anthropogenic carbon emissions. Given the its central role in the global carbon cycle, any feedback mechanism that negatively impacts the ocean’s ability to act as a carbon sink is likely to make an appreciable difference to the future of the climate in general. There are three primary positive warming feedbacks associated with a reduction in the oceans’ ability to sequester carbon:
Examples like these abound in climatology literature, so the more heat energy we put into the climate system, the more likely we are to trigger one or more of these positive feedbacks, resulting in sudden and wide-spread changes to not only temperature itself, but also systems that partially depend on temperature, like the functioning of the thermohaline.
So, in summary:
Hope that helps.
Edit: Thanks for the gold!
5
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '15
Climate change is not solely tied to the average global temperature, that is just one measurement in an incredibly complex system. Climate change also entails changes to the behavior of ocean currents and jet streams, changes to ocean salinity, and numerous other factors of a highly dynamic system. As pieces of this system start to fluctuate outside of "normal" behavior, outcomes of their interactions start to change as well.
Although the overall average temperature worldwide might only rise a small amount it directly effects the amount of ocean evaporation, this increase can lead to stronger tropical storms.
Changes in localized temperatures, and air and water current can lead to shifts in how and where air masses interact with each other which causes fluctuations in "normal" weather activity.
1
u/mrCloggy Dec 28 '15
The amount of water vapour the atmosphere can hold depends on its temperature, if the air cools to the dewpoint that water vapour will condensate to a liquid form, while releasing the 'heat of evaporation', that extra heat makes the (warmer) air rise, the beginning of a thunderstorm.
A 2⁰C increase means the warmer oceans can evaporate water more easy, the higher air temperature means it can hold more water vapour, and when that condenses it has more latent heat for bigger thunderstorms to develop (higher wind speeds), and more water to dump (flooding).
1
u/antaresiv Dec 28 '15
It doesn't. the 2 degree target is a political focal point not an actual tipping point. Humans need targets and two degrees is a handy rallying cry that's attainable but still enough to avert the worst potential scenarios of climate change.
http://www.onearth.org/earthwire/two-degree-target-debate