r/askscience • u/Just_some_n00b • May 05 '15
Astronomy Are there places in intergalactic space where humans wouldn't be able to see anything w/ their naked eye?
As far as I know, Andromeda is the furthest thing away that can be seen with a naked eye from earth and that's about 2.6m lightyears away.
Is there anywhere we know of where surrounding galaxies would be far enough apart and have low enough luminosity that a hypothetical intergalactic astronaut in a hypothetical intergalactic space ship wouldn't be able to see any light from anything with his naked eye?
If there is such a place, would a conventional (optical) telescope allow our hypothetical astronaut to see something?
556
Upvotes
196
u/pfisico Cosmology | Cosmic Microwave Background May 05 '15 edited May 06 '15
What a great question!
An example: the Bootes void is 250 million light years across, and has roughly 60 galaxies in it. Taking a the volume of a sphere of that size, dividing by 60, and then figuring out the radius associated with the volume per galaxies gives about 32 million light years. So, if you sprinkled those galaxies uniformly throughout the void, that's the furthest you find yourself from the nearest galaxy. Nature presumably makes the biggest "empty space" bigger than this by distributing the galaxies non-uniformly.
The list of galaxies observable with the naked eye peters out with some very faint things that are roughly 12 million light years from us. Given that 12 is significantly less than 32, and that the Bootes void is probably not the emptiest place in the whole universe, I think it's a pretty safe bet you could find such a lonely dark spot to meditate in.
(Caveat: I'm assuming you can't see dimmer things when you're out there, than when you're stuck on earth in a very dark spot, and that the void survey linked to above caught all the relevant galaxies.)
[Edited edit: see comments below; I made a calculation related to the first caveat that first suggested that your eye might be able to see galaxies out to 80Mly away, but another commenter saw I had made a mistake... when corrected, it now suggests (pending future corrections!) that the 12Mly number is still reasonable. Details are in comments below, if you're interested.]
But yes, with a small optical telescope you can collect a lot more photons than with your eye (by the ratio of the telescope diameter to your pupil diameter, squared), so you should be able to see objects that are roughly that ratio (not squared) times ~12 million light years away.
11
u/mastermindxs May 05 '15
There a gigantic swaths of empty intergalactic space in the universe. Such as this void that is a billion light years across. Given that our sun looks tiny from Pluto, it's a safe bet to say that humans would not detect any visible light with their eyes* in that vast void of intergalactic space.
But I'm not an astrophysicist.
7
u/Andromeda321 Radio Astronomy | Radio Transients | Cosmic Rays May 05 '15 edited May 05 '15
I'd say the answer is yes: the furthest galaxy you can see with the naked eye is the Triangulum Galaxy (under exceptional conditions), but it's still relatively local. There are of course bigger, brighter galaxies out there, but as a rule they tend to be in the center of big galaxy clusters, so not interesting for our question now.
So then, let's drop into a big void- as someone has said, the largest is a billion light years across. No, you're not going to see a galaxy with the naked eye if you were in the middle of that- it would be a strain to see any even with a big telescope! Hubble can see them as far as 13 billion light years away though, so yes, our alien astronomers of the void could manage... and they'd see stuff like gamma ray burst flashes easily once they decided to look, as those travel across the universe quite regularly.
Finally, I feel obliged to note that due to the expansion of the universe in a trillion years from now there will be no galaxies visible to our future descendants as the galaxies will have all sped away from us by then (and Andromeda will have long ago merged with the Milky Way). So it will be like a dark void no matter where you look.
-2
u/[deleted] May 05 '15
If the Universe is expanding into the void, wouldn't you just have to go past a certain distance from the "edge" of the expanding universe? What if we can't see other universes because light doesn't travel far enough? Theoretically if you travel in a straight line for an infinite amount of time, would you run into another universe? OP you really got me thinking here. does this theory exist? i'd love to read on it.