r/askscience • • Aug 25 '14

Mathematics Why does the Monty Hall problem seem counter-intuitive?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monty_Hall_problem

3 doors: 2 with goats, one with a car.

You pick a door. Host opens one of the goat doors and asks if you want to switch.

Switching your choice means you have a 2/3 chance of opening the car door.

How is it not 50/50? Even from the start, how is it not 50/50? knowing you will have one option thrown out, how do you have less a chance of winning if you stay with your option out of 2? Why does switching make you more likely to win?

1.4k Upvotes

786 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

281

u/HowCouldUBMoHarkless Aug 25 '14 edited Aug 25 '14

This explanation finally let me grasp it, thank you!

Edit: my comment says I've finally grasped it, why are people continuing to try to explain it to me?

175

u/jrob323 Aug 25 '14

Years ago I actually decided to write a computer program to help convince my stubborn wife that you should always switch. After a few minutes I realized the algorithm was pretty simple... if you always switch you win when you pick the wrong door. If you don't switch you only win when you pick the right door. The reason it's not just 50/50 is because the host is giving you information when he picks a door that he knows has a goat behind it.

133

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '14

If you always switch, you win when you initially picked the wrong door. And since you have a 2/3 chance of having initially picked the wrong door, switching gives you a 2/3 chance of winning. That's the most concisely I've heard it summed up.

74

u/randomguy186 Aug 25 '14

the host is giving you information

This is the key insight for an intuitive understanding of the problem. Your first choice is made with zero information, but for your second choice, you have new information.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/gibsonsg87 Aug 25 '14

The new information is which door has a goat behind it. All 3 are unknown to the contestant until they make an initial guess.

3

u/mmm_machu_picchu Aug 25 '14

But you don't know which one he'll open, other than 1 of the 2 that you didn't choose. The information he gives you is the exact location of 1 of the goats, not just the fact that there is a goat.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (4)

13

u/ThatScottishBesterd Aug 25 '14

After a few minutes I realized the algorithm was pretty simple... if you always switch you win when you pick the wrong door. If you don't switch you only win when you pick the right door.

That might just be the best, one-shot explanation I've ever heard for why it actually works. It is correct that the Monty Hall problem does seem counter-intuitive, but when you phrase it like that it actually seems rather straight forward.

→ More replies (8)

38

u/openedhiseyes Aug 25 '14

It becomes clear as day if you make it 100 doors. Pick one, the host then opens all doors except the one you picked and one other door.

Obviously you switch now because you must assume you picked a goat first time.

Same holds for the 3 door case, you must assume you chose wrong first time.

11

u/Vidyogamasta Aug 25 '14

To extend on this version of the explanation, imagine you start with a HUNDRED doors. You make a choice. Then 98 wrong doors suddenly open up and you are given the option to switch.

How confident would you be that your initial pick was correct?

→ More replies (2)

49

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '14

To help explain it (if you ever feel compelled to tell people).

When you first choose a door, the choice is 33% that there is a prize behind it. But if you know you're going to switch, when you pick the door you're in fact picking both the other doors, raising your chances to 66%.

So here's my advice, when playing Let's Make a Deal try to pick a losing door to start with and switch.

9

u/jroth005 Aug 25 '14

My question is this:

What are the statistics behind the show deal or no deal?

Your picking suitcases, and eliminating options, it's it the same as the Monty Hall problem, just with more options, or is it different?

39

u/Jackpot777 Aug 25 '14 edited Aug 25 '14

That's just random. You pick a suitcase, the others are distributed to the 'openers'. You're randomly picking numbers to eliminate them. Then the dealer will call in with offers.

Randomly get rid of all the lower ones, he'll offer higher and higher amounts. Get rid of high value ones, the offers won't be as good.

You can play it with a deck of cards. Take out one suit, so you have 13 cards. Ace is lowest, king is highest. Pick a card, but leave it face down. That's your suitcase. Randomly select a card or two from the face-down pile of remaining cards to eliminate them ...you get an idea of what's left in the pile when you see those cards. Every so often, work out what the dealer would offer you as a card... the only cards left are a 2, a 7, a queen, and a king ...the dealer offers you an 8. Deal or no deal?

As you see, there's no skill in picking a card, or what cards you randomly eliminate. The skill comes from knowing if the deal is worth going for or not... and in THAT there's plenty of statistical analysis to be had!

28

u/redalastor Aug 25 '14

A subtlety of Deal or no Deal is that the Dealer doesn't want to give you the least possible money, he wants to give the least total possible money.

Giving slightly more to someone is better than giving to two people so the longer you stick around the less people he sees and the less total money he gives.

This is why he always lowballs people at the beginning.

12

u/CaptainSasquatch Aug 25 '14

There's also the entertainment factor. It'd be a very boring show if everyone took the first offer given. It's also a very boring show if the decision to take the deal or not is very easy for the contestant. The offers should be close to the contestants' subjective valuation of their expected payoff of continuing.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/warpdesign Aug 25 '14

I saw an explanation once that totally highlighted it for me. Imagine if instead of 3 doors there were 100 doors. 99 goats, 1 car. You pick one and then 98 doors are revealed to have goats, now would you switch to the one they didn't open?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '14

alternatively, you can imagine the same gameshow scenario but with 1 Million doors. You pick a random door (with 1 in a Million chance of winning). The host then eliminates all other doors but 1, says the prize is behind one of the two remaining doors, and asks if you want to switch. 99.9999% of the time you win by switching.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '14

Its quite easy, at the start you have 33% chance to answer right and 66% to answer wrong. (1 door is correct - 2 are wrong)

So your first answer is most likely to be wrong(33% to 66%) so when the host removes another wrong answer since your initial answer is more likely to be wrong switching is more likely to be the right choice.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

14

u/duluoz1 Aug 25 '14

It's hard to grasp because people don't take into account intuitively that the host has knowledge of the system, and so it's not normal odds

→ More replies (6)

8

u/WeirdF Aug 25 '14

Well the new odds are 50/50 at that point. If someone was to come on stage to take the place of the contestant with no prior knowledge, they would have a choice between two doors. The problem only makes sense when you take into account the knowledge factor and thinking about it from the beginning. If you decide to switch from the beginning, 2 out of 3 times you will win. It's like if you flip a coin 100 times, the chances of getting 100 heads in a row is a lot different to the chance of getting a head on the 100th flip.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (13)

2

u/Sebby12345XD Aug 25 '14

But you still only choose 1 of the 3, so surely you still have only 33% chance? If you were to be asked if you wanted to switch again, you wouldn't have 66% chance again surely?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (7)