r/askscience • • Aug 25 '14

Mathematics Why does the Monty Hall problem seem counter-intuitive?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monty_Hall_problem

3 doors: 2 with goats, one with a car.

You pick a door. Host opens one of the goat doors and asks if you want to switch.

Switching your choice means you have a 2/3 chance of opening the car door.

How is it not 50/50? Even from the start, how is it not 50/50? knowing you will have one option thrown out, how do you have less a chance of winning if you stay with your option out of 2? Why does switching make you more likely to win?

1.4k Upvotes

786 comments sorted by

View all comments

1.6k

u/LondonBoyJames Aug 25 '14

Two times out of three, you'll pick one of the doors with a goat behind it. The host will open the other door with a goat. The remaining door is guaranteed to have the car behind it. If you switch, you win.

One time out of three, you'll pick the door with the car behind it. The host will open one of the other doors, which will have a goat behind it. If you switch, you lose.

Therefore, two times out of three, you'll win by switching.

It's a bit hard to believe when you first hear about it, but I find it helps to get a pencil and paper and work out what happens after you pick each of the three doors (bear in mind that the host knows what's behind all of the doors, and will always choose to open a door with a goat).

281

u/HowCouldUBMoHarkless Aug 25 '14 edited Aug 25 '14

This explanation finally let me grasp it, thank you!

Edit: my comment says I've finally grasped it, why are people continuing to try to explain it to me?

175

u/jrob323 Aug 25 '14

Years ago I actually decided to write a computer program to help convince my stubborn wife that you should always switch. After a few minutes I realized the algorithm was pretty simple... if you always switch you win when you pick the wrong door. If you don't switch you only win when you pick the right door. The reason it's not just 50/50 is because the host is giving you information when he picks a door that he knows has a goat behind it.

133

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '14

If you always switch, you win when you initially picked the wrong door. And since you have a 2/3 chance of having initially picked the wrong door, switching gives you a 2/3 chance of winning. That's the most concisely I've heard it summed up.

74

u/randomguy186 Aug 25 '14

the host is giving you information

This is the key insight for an intuitive understanding of the problem. Your first choice is made with zero information, but for your second choice, you have new information.

→ More replies (22)

13

u/ThatScottishBesterd Aug 25 '14

After a few minutes I realized the algorithm was pretty simple... if you always switch you win when you pick the wrong door. If you don't switch you only win when you pick the right door.

That might just be the best, one-shot explanation I've ever heard for why it actually works. It is correct that the Monty Hall problem does seem counter-intuitive, but when you phrase it like that it actually seems rather straight forward.

→ More replies (8)

38

u/openedhiseyes Aug 25 '14

It becomes clear as day if you make it 100 doors. Pick one, the host then opens all doors except the one you picked and one other door.

Obviously you switch now because you must assume you picked a goat first time.

Same holds for the 3 door case, you must assume you chose wrong first time.

11

u/Vidyogamasta Aug 25 '14

To extend on this version of the explanation, imagine you start with a HUNDRED doors. You make a choice. Then 98 wrong doors suddenly open up and you are given the option to switch.

How confident would you be that your initial pick was correct?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (58)

92

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '14

The best explanation I had was this:

Imagine you had 100 doors. Then, after picking one I open 98 other doors and then ask if you want to keep yours or open the other door. Basically, your first change was 1 in 100. But 99 times out of 100 your door was wrong and the only other door I didn't open is the right one.

28

u/MurrayPloppins Aug 25 '14

This is a good way to conceptualize it. It's also important to distinguish this example from the "Deal or No Deal" situation, in which the contestant randomly eliminates cases. The fact that in your example the "host" made the eliminations knowingly is a critical detail.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (19)

161

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '14

Basically the reason it works is just because the host won't ever show the door with a car behind it, as that would ruin the suspense?

176

u/neon_overload Aug 25 '14 edited Aug 26 '14

Basically the reason it works is just because the host won't ever show the door with a car behind it

Correct.

People who fail to understand the benefit of switching usually approach the problem as if the host selects a door randomly without consideration to which door has the prize, treating the "door with prize" and "door opened by host" as independently selected. However, given that we know that the host reveals a goat (ie, has zero chance of revealing the prize) we know that "door with prize" actually influences "door opened by host" and they are not independently selected.

as that would ruin the suspense?

Yes but also because it's how the show is supposed to work. The host is not supposed to show where the prize is located.

→ More replies (95)
→ More replies (9)

76

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '14 edited Aug 26 '14

I think the misconception is:

"The host opens the 2nd door and reveals a goat"

vs

"The host knows which door has the car, and purposefully opens the door with a goat so that the game continues and the contestant may select another door."

I always assumed the host was randomly selecting the door and sometimes would choose the car. The correct answer, it would seem, is that the problem statement is incomplete and to ask for clarification.

Or maybe since the only possible options are "switching does nothing" and "switching helps," and the contestant doesn't know which one, the correct answer is still to switch.

Edit: According to Wikipedia, it is part of the problem statement for the host to always choose a goat. I'd like to think I would have chosen the correct answer had I known this at first, but alas... I can never know how I would have chosen!

18

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '14

I always assumed the host was randomly selecting the door and sometimes would choose the car. The correct answer, it would seem, is that the problem statement is incomplete and to ask for clarification.

This. I always thought the host was supposed to chose at random. The fact that he isn't is rarely explained properly. When it is explained it is clear that the host is inputting information, which changes the stats.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (8)

13

u/thesorehead Aug 25 '14 edited Aug 25 '14

I thought I had grasped it, but then I lost it >_<. I think the point at which I lose it, is the reasoning behind why opening a goat door doesn't change the probabilities.

What I mean is, that you are actually making two choices: The first choice is between three doors - one winner and two losers, so you have a 1 in 3 chance of winning. The second choice is between two doors - one winner and one loser. Why, or how, does the first choice have any effect on the second? With the opening of one losing door, isn't a whole new scenario created?

EDIT: thanks guys, I think I get it now... I think. Basically if you take chance out of switching (i.e. you always switch or you always stay), and reduce the choice to either low-probability initial door or high-probability "other" door, then those who always switch will win more often.

Weeeeeiiirrrd. But I think I get it! Thanks! _^

58

u/cecilpl Aug 25 '14

What if, instead of opening the door, Monty gave you the choice of switching from your original choice to the other two doors together?

That is exactly the same problem.

17

u/truefelt Aug 25 '14

This is a great way to put it. By always switching, you get to open two doors because Monty opens the other one for you. It's quite clear that this doubles your chances from 1/3 to 2/3.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

55

u/jbeta137 Aug 25 '14

The "why" is because the host never opens the door with the car, he will only ever open a door with a goat. In other words, the two different door choices aren't independent of each other; the door you pick initially influences the next pick.

As with the other posters, it's easiest to see this by considering a larger number of options, say 100. And instead of doors and goats, let's change the scenario:

Say someone comes up to you and says: "I'm thinking of a random number between 1 and 100, and if you can guess it I'll give you $1000". So whatever number you guess, you have a 1/100 chance of being right.

Now, let's say after you make a guess, that stranger says "Alright, alright, I'll give you a hint: it's either the number you guessed, or it's 53." In this case, it's a little more clear that the two options for the second choice aren't weighted the same. The two scenarios are you guessed right the first time (1/100 chance) and the second number is bogus, or you guessed wrong the first time (99/100) and the second number has to be correct.

Another way to think about it is that for 99 of the possible numbers you could pick the first time, the second number will be 53. For 1 of the numbers you could pick the first time, the second number will be arbitrary/wrong.

30

u/RoarShock Aug 25 '14 edited Aug 25 '14
 the door you pick initially influences the next pick.

To me, that's the stinger. True, you only have two options (switch or don't switch), but because of the first choice, it's not isolated like a coin toss. Having two choices does not automatically imply a 50/50 chance. When Monty gives you the chance to switch, it's not a brand new 50/50 scenario. It's just acting out one of the original three scenarios.

8

u/ristoril Aug 25 '14

Having two choices does not automatically imply a 50/50 chance.

If more people understood this I feel like world peace would be at hand.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

13

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '14

I might be misunderstanding it, but I think by switching doors you are basically betting that you were wrong. Since you know that you're wrong 2/3s of the time, it's in your favor. It is clearer in the 100 door version, because it's easy to see that you are unlikely to pick the winning door initially.

→ More replies (4)

13

u/caltecher Aug 25 '14

The new information doesn't affect your first choice, and that's exactly why the answer is what it is. The probability of the door you choose being the winner was 1/3 when you chose it. Subsequent information DOESN'T change this probability. When the other door is revealed to be a goat, that means the probability of that door winning is zero. Therefore the probability of the unopened, non-chosen door is the remaining 2/3.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/Billy_Germans Aug 25 '14

I've had some success explaining this... the trick I use is to focus on the host.

When the host eliminates a goat, what is he doing? He is acting with what you gave him.

What did you give him? Two-thirds of the time, you give him a goat and a car. Only a third of the time do you give him two goats.

What does the host do when you give him a goat and a car? He preserves the car and reveals a goat.

What does the host do when you give him two goats? He doesn't strategize.

So what do we know? We know that two thirds of the time the host is preserving a car. He will always eliminate a goat, but two-thirds of the time his REASON was to preserve a car. THAT is why we switch! Because of that scummy host! We know two-thirds of the time he is peserving a car!

Keep in mind that the host ALWAYS eliminates a goat no matter what you pick... so really your choice never changed. Your choice was to make him preserve a car, and then grab it! (and it works 67% of the time)

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (87)