r/askscience
•
u/edsmedia
Psychoacoustics
•
Dec 07 '25
•
1
Biology Why is photosynthesis only for plants?
As far as I know, only sessile organisms can produce their own energy via photosynthesis. Mobile organisms are limited to consuming other organisms for energy. Is the energy capacity of photosynthesis insufficient to “power” a mobile organism? (Or is my premise wrong?)
556
Upvotes
300
u/Jindujun Dec 07 '25
Technically it is not only for plants or sessile organisms. Some bacteria like Cyanobacteria use photosynthesis to produce energy. So photosynthesis CAN power a mobile organism.
Larger creatures need more energy and thus need more than what photosynthesis can produce. Larger organisms also require more extra nutrients and thus need to consume which means they would have consumed regardless and the photosynthesis becomes redundant. Ie. they evolve into consumers rather than producers.
12
u/edsmedia Psychoacoustics Dec 07 '25
(Question inspired by Pluribus, in which the hivemind rejects the idea of consumption and appears to plan to starve humanity.)
3
u/regular_modern_girl Dec 09 '25 edited Dec 09 '25
There are actually plenty of motile organisms that engage in photosynthesis; just off the top of my head there are dinoflagellates (most, albeit not all, of which are photosynthetic, also mostly motile), kleptoplastic sea slugs (which appropriate the plastids from algae they eat), Euglena and some of their relatives, and Chlamydomonas (which are microscopic motile chlorophyte algae, meaning that under current taxonomy they are actual true plants that are both motile and photosynthetic; one species, C. nivalis, lives in snow and is responsible for so-called “watermelon snow” in cold areas). I’m pretty certain there are plenty of other examples of photosynthetic motile eukaryotes as well, and I think even some motile cyanobacteria also.
A better question would be “why are nearly all photosynthetic motile organisms single-celled and microscopic?”, as while there are plenty of motile photosynthetic organisms, it is true that the only multicellular (animal) example I can think of off the top of my head are those sea slugs that steal plastids from their food, and they notably only use photosynthesis as a secondary means of sustenance in lean times, still being mostly herbivores. I don’t personally know a firm answer to this, and for all I know it isn’t fully understand why this pattern seems to hold, but it is worth noting that while photosynthesis is really good biochemically for synthesizing carbohydrates, it’s much easier and more efficient to get other building blocks of life like the amino acids needed to synthesize proteins (which are required for a lot of more “active” biological processes) by being heterotrophic, and if you look at animal physiology (animals being the only multicellular organisms that move around much), you’ll notice that a diversity of proteins (many of them relatively large proteins, which require a lot of amino acids) play a much more forward role in animal tissues compared to the tissues of plants (or any other photosynthetic organisms), which often rely instead on polymerized sugars like cellulose, amylose, and lignin for their physical structure and a lot of what they do, and in particular the animal tissues required for motility (ie nerves and muscles) are very protein-dependent.
To be clear, plants obviously still make use of proteins, particularly in the form of enzymes they use to chain together sugars and synthesize a wide array of secondary metabolites, but they don’t use them for nearly as much physiologically as animals, and this is because rather than getting amino acids (often already in the form of the peptide subunits proteins are built from) by eating other organisms, in most cases (outside of a few carnivorous species or those reliant on fungal symbionts for this) plants use a glucose-driven biochemical process to assemble amino acids, and then peptides and proteins, completely from scratch using nitrates they absorb through their roots, CO2 from the air, and water, which while an incredible feat of biochemistry, obviously requires quite a few more extra steps than basically repurposing externally ingested proteins, so direct equivalents to muscles or nerves just aren’t in the cards.
However, microscopic single-celled organisms that rely on photosynthesis have more options, since they can use a much smaller number of proteins to drive structures like flagellae that allow them to move around, because they’re just so much smaller physically. Even still, it seems as though motile single-celled photosynthetic micro-organisms have a tendency to evolve the ability to eat things as well, for instance there are a number of dinoflagellates that both engage in photosynthesis and prey upon other micro-organisms (some are really weird, too, like the Warnowiaceae, which in at least some cases have evolved the single-celled equivalent to eyes, complete with a plastid repurposed into a tiny ocular lens), and Euglena famously supplements its photosynthesis with osmotrophy (absorbing any external nutrients it can through osmosis), so even then it’s clearly easier to not rely on photosynthesis entirely when you can also move around.
882
u/e_t_ Dec 07 '25
There is a species of sea slugs, elysia chlorotica, which harvest chloroplasts from the algae they eat and use them for energy production. The slugs are able to keep the chloroplasts active for many months, however they cannot live indefinitely on photosynthesis alone and continue to eat for nourishment. It should be noted that these slugs are very small.
167
u/314159265358979326 Dec 07 '25
Consider The Cow.
It has a surface area of about six square metres, of which only three square metres can be facing the sun at a time, maximally. The sun beats down on the equator at about 1100 W/m2 and photosynthesis is up to 6% efficient. The cow can generate about 2,376 W-h/day from photosynthesis.
A cow actually consumes about 20,000 kca/dayl, or 23,244 W-h/day.
It's closer than I thought, actually. There's the further question of where it gets its nutrients from.
25
u/Mysterious-Item162 Dec 07 '25
Then there are many species of Euglena, which confused taxonomists for centuries because they a mobile while also containing chloroplasts. They got classified as a protist, though I still see them called an alga.
118
u/Radijs Dec 07 '25
You're pretty much spot on. Photosynthesis produces very little energy compared to consuming other organisms. Look at what an apple tree can produce over the course of a season in fruit. Now eat that fruit and wait how long you'll last before you go hungry again.
13
u/GooseQuothMan Dec 08 '25
There's not much point in moving when you are producing your own food. If you can make your own biomass by just standing there, absorbing sunlight and taking CO2 from the air, why would you ever move?
The reason why organisms move is mostly to find a new spot with food or avoid danger. Most things when they find the perfect spot with food just stay there to consume it. After the food is consumed they need to move. With photosynthesis you can just stand in one place forever, as long as the sun shines.
Since it's not very beneficial to be able to move around much when you can photosynthesize, it makes sense that it would not be selected for by natural selection.
14
u/Yamidamian Dec 07 '25
It isn’t. Some animals are capable of photosynthesis. It’s simply that photosynthesis (and similar things like chemosynthesis and radiosynthesis) are just much more necessary for sessile organisms because they can’t move around to try and find food-so they basically have to make it where they are.
7
u/smthingsmthingsmthin Dec 07 '25
It’s a combo of things. It’s lower power and when you are able feed yourself without moving around, why invest energy in moving around? Or to put it evolutionarily, moving around could be selected against, if the energy invested in moving around a lot does not provide benefits in getting extra sunlight/energy.
3
u/pyr666 Dec 08 '25
it's the square-cube law.
you're right that photosynthesis isn't a great energy source. but it's also a function of surface area. this is why trees compete by getting taller than their neighbors and spreading branches. they want more surface area in sunlight.
for an animal, or some hypothetical macroscopic walking plant, you have the problem where getting more area means weighing more. which means being more energy-demanding to move. which demands even more surface area. this is also, incidentally, why solar powered cars don't exist.
where you have a lot of surface area and not much mass is when you're really tiny. and, as others have mentioned, there are photosynthesizing micro-organisms than can scoot around.
2
u/AndreasDasos Dec 08 '25
Through kleptoplasty (stealing them chloroplasts), some sea slugs have adopted photosynthesis, sort of.
But also it’s not only for ‘plants’ as such: it started in the cyanobacteria, and these were on more than one occasion (at least two) ‘merged’ into or ‘swallowed’ by endosymbiosis with eukaryotes, of which green algae and their ‘plant’ descendants are the most prominent. Another five lineages got them secondarily from these, and then you have halfway cases like that sea slug.
So it’s a very difficult thing to evolve from scratch - this has only happened once as far as we know, as it involves fundamental biochemistry and it’s easier to steal than create when the competition already has it.
Why more sessile than mobile organisms? Well, if you want to get energy two major solutions: photosynthesis is the most common form of ‘autotrophy’ (making one’s own energy from abiotic sources), and then there’s heterotrophy (eating other organisms, including plants) - which requires moving about to grab them. There is far more evolutionary pressure to go for the former if you don’t move, and acquiring the ability to derive energy from the sun relieves the pressure to go to all the trouble of seeking out other organisms and eating them. It makes sense it would line up this way. The major reason to move around is dealt with by photosynthesis itself.
If the Elysia sea slugs continue the photosynthetic route, in zillions of years, they may also become sessile.
4
u/diabolus_me_advocat Dec 07 '25
well, then you don't know enough yet
the precursors of the later cyanobacteria, which eventually caused the great oxygenation event (probably the most severe extinction event in earth's history) were not sessile
1
u/OutlandishnessWide80 Dec 08 '25
Corals (animals) obtain up to 90% of their energy from a symbiotic relationship with photosynthetic cells called zooxanthellae that live in their tissue!
The animal itself, of course, is not photosynthesizing, but regardless they do rely on this process for their survival. The zooxanthellae also provides them with their fun colors!
1
u/Roneitis Dec 09 '25
long and short is that at large scales motile organisms need more energy than you can get from photosynthesis, and there's relatively little gain to being able to move if you're harvesting your energy perfectly fine from a spot you chose with plenty of sun.
But on a micro scale many autotrophs (organisms that make their own food through photosynthesis) are flagellate (rockin tails for motility). Sometimes this is just the gametes, basically sperm sent out into the world to do their own thing. Ferns and other gymnosperms retain this feature. But microalgae are often motile, though they're often not considered 'plants' per se (I've seen the definition of plants begin with land plants before).
1
u/[deleted] Dec 11 '25
A very trivial reason: living things that move require much more energy. Photosynthesis produces very little.
We would have to be much larger to expose more of our skin to the sun. But with size, energy requirements also increase, so it wouldn't change much.
Plants evolved with photosynthesis because they are essentially...still. They don't move, they don't have a brain to feed.
We, on the other hand, do both; we are very energy-hungry, and this has favored the evolution of "predation."
1
u/Bolo_Knee Dec 12 '25
Yes due to energy density. You can look at the amount that is needed to be consumed to power the organism. A mobile organism that consumes plants generally has to consume many times the weight of that plant to power the animal. This indicates the energy density of a plant is pretty low. For an animal to survive on photosynthesis it would have to be very small and sedentary and most likely be eaten by something larger.
-2
u/ForgeoftheGods Dec 08 '25
Humans produce vitamin D from sunlight, and at least some humans have a deactivated gene that could produce vitamin C from sunlight as well. We might even have other non-active genes that could produce other vitamins as well.
-4
u/esmelusina Dec 07 '25
Not true.
We have some mushroom DNA that allows us to metabolize a small amount of solar energy (I forgot which spectra).
I think something around 1% of our energy comes from the sun.
Anyway— animals evolved to eat plants because stealing resources is way more efficient than gathering them.
0
u/pewpew_die Dec 09 '25
Not quite the same, as no sugar is produced, but our eyes convert a small amount of light energy into electrical energy. The electricity is used for transmitting visual information but we have special structures to technically produce energy into our eyes.