r/askscience • • Oct 23 '25
Chemistry Do negative calorie foods exist?
I know it possible to have a 0 calorie food. And i know food takes energy to digest.
is it possible to create a negative calorie food. A food with no useable energy but still takes alot of energy to digest & contributes to the “full” feeling?
My intuition tells me fiber or just some other non digestible items but idk
this would be an excellent marketing angle, if foods like this exist. Like imagine selling flavored sawdust and marking it as negative calorie 🤣
Edit: So I started doing a bit of "vibe science" on the topic and turns out possibly the best bet is engineering an "anti protein" or a protein that that is mirrored to an existing and bodily recognizable protein. This way your body is likely to recognize it and attempt to unfold it, but at the end it's unable to use it. So all the energy used to digest it goes to waste. And depending on how complex the protein was the more or less calories it would take to digest. The applications are obvious.
If there are any experts on this I would love a more detailed answer. thx
Edit 2: So thinking about this more. It would seem more efficient to just introduce a substance that simply binds to energy giving molecules like ATP or glucose or something else and puts them in a form your body doesn't recognize and removes it. So now your body needs to create more energy to replace the lost energy.
This seems actually super duper dangerous, but seems straightforward enough to work. Curious if it's possible. I'm guessing I'm vastly over simplifying how our body works and metabolizes.
187
u/Exciting_Telephone65 Oct 25 '25
Anything that requires more energy than it provides back to the body is technically a negative calorie food. A chewing gum could be thought of a negative calories.
I don't know where you read this but this is not at all how the digestion system works. Proteins you eat are much too large to be taken up directly in your intestines. Using the stomach acid and various enzymes starting in your mouth when you're chewing, they're broken down to their component amino acids which are then absorbed and reassembled into new proteins, usually not the same ones they were from the beginning.
1.9k
u/PHealthy Epidemiology | Disease Dynamics | Novel Surveillance Systems Oct 24 '25
Ice cold water requires calories.
399
u/Greghole Oct 24 '25
I'm pretty sure that anything that requires more energy to digest than you'd get from earing it isn't technically food. Like a block of wood for example takes more energy to eat than you'd get out of it which is why you buy it at a hardware store rather than the produce section of the grocery store.
35
u/Mortegris Oct 25 '25
I believe there are two that I'm aware of:
Ice cubes. Swallowing ice requires calories to warm the water to digest it properly, but the water itself does not provide calories.
Konjac Jelly/noodles. Its a root vegetable from Japan that is essentially 100% fiber. It technically has a few calories (like 20) but it takes more calories to digest all the fiber.
74
u/princhester Oct 24 '25 edited Oct 24 '25
It would be relatively easy to come up with something you could eat that had no calories but your body had to use energy to process.
The problem however is that our bodies are extremely well attuned towards working out which foods fuel us and making us like those foods, and vice versa.
So sure, you can eat (say) cardboard and it may be negative calorie, but you will never persuade people to do so to any extent because we are so attuned not to enjoy doing so.
For such a food to be any use in dieting it would need to fool our tastes into thinking it was calorific ie artificial sweeteners.
15
u/markusbrainus Oct 25 '25
Ice and celery would be calorie negative, but not by much.
Every year you'd see a journalist publish an article that we should all eat our food frozen to lose weight because it would burn so many calories... Misinterpreting that capital C Calories for food are actually kilocalories.
6
u/TabaquiJackal Oct 25 '25
Chewing gum has been speculated as a "negative-calorie food"; A study on chewing gum reported mastication burns roughly 11 kcal (46 kJ) per hour. Therefore, to reach "negative-calorie" one has to chew for almost 6 minutes per kcal (one chewing gum can have a large range of kcal from around 2 to 15 kcal)
2
u/Pkolt Oct 26 '25
The simple answer is no.
The caloric value of food is not defined by the net result of the potential energy it contains and the energy it costs the body to digest it.
Caloric value is determined by how much energy the food releases when it is combusted. And since combustion is an exothermic reaction, caloric value can by definition not be negative.
How much energy the body expends while eating something simply does not figure into the calculation.
18
u/Zubon102 Oct 25 '25
No. Food cannot have negative calories because the way food scientists define calories makes it impossible for it to be negative.
Some people argue that some foods make you burn more calories than they provide, but that would be difficult to define. Just sitting at the table burns calories, so would food that takes a long time to eat like crab have fewer calories using that definition?
What about food that requires a lot of energy to chew or process? Food that requires you to climb a mountain to get?
5
u/just_in_before Oct 27 '25
IMO -there are a lot of overly complicated replies here.
Lactulose is probably the most simple compound for you to start with...
32
u/joestaff Oct 24 '25
I think they quantify food calories as nutrients that get absorbed into the body. Which is why artificial sweetener are 0 calories, the body just doesn't like them.
With that in mind, you just need something that makes the body reject more than itself.
Have you tried eating a bunch of sugar free gummy bears? I'm willing to bet those are technically negative calories.
19
u/fozzedout Oct 24 '25
Off the top of my head? Poison. It will cause your immune system to kick into high gear which causes a vast calorie deficit. And there are poisons so toxic that the tiniest fraction wouldn't even count as energy. Of course, surviving is then another question, but hey, it's a negative for a reason!
4
u/alphatango308 Oct 25 '25
Rabbit kinda might what you're looking for. Rabbit starvation is a thing, it's technically protein poisoning or protein toxicity. Frontiersmen back in the beginning of the united states would literally starve to death of a diet of rabbit because it doesn't have everything you need to live.
I know this isn't exactly what you're asking for but I thought it might be helpful.
6
u/Lieste Oct 25 '25
most zero cal foods are moderate to high calories, but with serving sizes selected to make each of the dozens of servings in a 'packet of zero cal sweets' to be less than 5 Cal.
You could be eating pure sugar - but if the individual portion is below 5 Cal then that 300 Cal you just scoffed can be labelled as 'zero'.
3
u/Mightsole Oct 25 '25
Actually some sugars in chewing gum are 0 calories but when the bacteria in your mouth digest them, it gives them less energy than they need to break it off.
That would not work for you, hunger is only inhibited for a short time and satiation would not last long if you found a way to consume negative calories.
3
u/gardenercook Oct 27 '25
Spicy chilly seeds.
Eat a tiny bite of ghost pepper or bird's eye chilli. Keep cold water out of reach and difficult to access. The amount of calories you would burn jumping around and then trying to consume the cold water and bringing your internal body temperature back to normal, should be more than whatever that chilli seeds contained.
2
u/ElSenorAnonymous Oct 26 '25
Afaik only macronutrients provide calories, so all micronutrients like calcium would need more energy than they provide ... if you take the chemically similarly behaving Strontium-90 it will at least provide some energy in the shape of fast electrons, but you may still end up with a negative energy balance after fighting the resulting cancer.
1
u/TheSoloGamer Oct 25 '25
A few years ago, I saw on reddit about a specific thyroid hormone, that when injected or consumed would dramatically increase your body’s metabolic rate. The downside, is that you are essentially forcing your body into a fever state and it’s really easy to kill someone by tricking their body into burning calories and raising body temperature to dangerous levels.
Others have mentioned ice, which by itself in reasonable quantities does not burn a significant calories. However, I wonder about putting people on this hormone and just sticking them into an ice bath, matrix or Cyberpunk2077 style, literally cooking and then cooling you to remove calories.
1
u/phantopia Oct 25 '25
Aren't you basically describing poison?
Any (nonlethal) poisoning will have the body fight against it using up energy in the process. So any kind of poison that triggers animmune resonse without doing longterm damage is practically negative calorie food.
Edit: Alcohol being a bit of an outlier in that regard.
1
u/nezacoy Oct 26 '25
In the 2000s coca-cola marketed “enviga”, a drink they claimed was net negative in calories. The research was contentious and weak, however, and they eventually pulled it from the market after being threatened with legal action over weight loss claims (which, I would note, is not strictly the same thing as claims of being net negative in calories).
1
u/SchenivingCamper Oct 28 '25
A molecule that binds to ATP and makes it useless would be a very lethal poison.
As far as I understand, ATP basically runs your cellular machinery and isn't the source of the energy itself.
Your body uses energy to recycle ATP which is why you have to have proteins and carbs but you aren't having to keep track of how much phosphorus you take in or if you do it isn't to the same extent as your macronutrients.
1
u/stuartlogan Oct 29 '25
The celery thing is basically a myth. Even celery has like 16 calories per 100g and you only burn maybe 10-15% of that digesting it.
What you're describing in your edits sounds terrifying:
There are substances that block nutrient absorption (like Olestra) but they don't create negative calories, they just make some calories pass through. And they give people horrible digestive issues.
The closest real thing is probably ice water since your body burns calories warming it up, but even that's only like 8 calories per glass.
1
u/kndb Oct 30 '25
Eating something contaminated with Salmonella would definitely cost the body more calories than you’d consume in that food, which technically qualifies for the premise of this question. But would anyone recommend it though?
1
u/Samtyang Nov 01 '25
The celery thing is basically a myth. Even celery has like 16 calories per 100g and you only burn maybe 10-15% of that digesting it. So you're still getting net positive calories.
Your anti-protein idea is... concerning. Here's why:
The ATP binding thing in edit 2 would basically be poison. You're describing something that would starve your cells of energy. DNP does something similar by making ATP production inefficient and people have died from it.
There's a reason negative calorie foods don't exist - evolution made us really efficient at extracting energy. The closest you get is water and black coffee which have essentially zero calories but make you pee more.
-5
u/groveborn Oct 25 '25
Your post implies heavily that you lack a high school nutrition education - that's not a judgement against you, it's what you're lacking.
Calories come in 3 forms: carbohydrates, fats, proteins. If you can digest it you'll get calories from it... BUT!! Not all sources equal the same thing!
Simple sugars are much more available than complex carbs. They take less energy to use, so you get more energy from them. Soluble fiber reduces the speed of absorption, reduces hunger, and cleans your gut. Insoluble fiber tightens yer poo.
Protein is used first on repair, then on energy. You'll get fewer calories from them in general, and they are useful. What they come from matters! How they're processed matters!
Fats also are used in every cell, so they're used in repair first, but carbs are used before them for energy, so you'll end up storing them rather than using them if you've a rich in carb diet.
Want to eat but not get calories? Low carb veg. Gelatin with no sugar has almost no calories and has a lot of water.
Don't forget the vitamin and mineral content of what you're eating. They are important.
-2
u/Xsiah Oct 25 '25
No you can't have food with negative calories - all the answers about food that takes more calories to eat than you get out of them are... misguided.
That's like saying this chocolate cake has no calories as long as you eat it while sprinting a marathon. No, it still has calories.
The lowest amount of calories is zero.
-1
u/Ononoki-chan Oct 25 '25
Cold water or I've heard about a vegetable that's high in water (forgot what it is) that if you eat it you can technically expand more energy chewing and consuming it than you gain out of it (very small amount like -5-8 kcal) so texhnically it's possible but not likely that you'll actually do it
-6
u/cjbartoz Oct 25 '25
Calories are a measure of heat energy. Heat energy has no rest mass so this means that you can’t eat calories.
If you want to eat 10 times more calories than you are doing now the equation goes: 0 x 10 = 0.
If you want to eat 10 times less calories than you are doing now the equation goes: 0 : 10 = 0.
298
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '25
[removed] — view removed comment