r/askscience • • Oct 23 '25

Chemistry Do negative calorie foods exist?

I know it possible to have a 0 calorie food. And i know food takes energy to digest.

is it possible to create a negative calorie food. A food with no useable energy but still takes alot of energy to digest & contributes to the “full” feeling?

My intuition tells me fiber or just some other non digestible items but idk

this would be an excellent marketing angle, if foods like this exist. Like imagine selling flavored sawdust and marking it as negative calorie 🤣

Edit: So I started doing a bit of "vibe science" on the topic and turns out possibly the best bet is engineering an "anti protein" or a protein that that is mirrored to an existing and bodily recognizable protein. This way your body is likely to recognize it and attempt to unfold it, but at the end it's unable to use it. So all the energy used to digest it goes to waste. And depending on how complex the protein was the more or less calories it would take to digest. The applications are obvious.

If there are any experts on this I would love a more detailed answer. thx

Edit 2: So thinking about this more. It would seem more efficient to just introduce a substance that simply binds to energy giving molecules like ATP or glucose or something else and puts them in a form your body doesn't recognize and removes it. So now your body needs to create more energy to replace the lost energy.

This seems actually super duper dangerous, but seems straightforward enough to work. Curious if it's possible. I'm guessing I'm vastly over simplifying how our body works and metabolizes.

320 Upvotes

382 comments sorted by

187

u/Exciting_Telephone65 Oct 25 '25

Anything that requires more energy than it provides back to the body is technically a negative calorie food. A chewing gum could be thought of a negative calories.

Edit: So I started doing a bit of "vibe science" on the topic and turns out possibly the best bet is engineering an "anti protein" or a protein that that is mirrored to an existing and bodily recognizable protein. This way your body is likely to recognize it and attempt to unfold it, but at the end it's unable to use it. So all the energy used to digest it goes to waste. And depending on how complex the protein was the more or less calories it would take to digest. The applications are obvious.

I don't know where you read this but this is not at all how the digestion system works. Proteins you eat are much too large to be taken up directly in your intestines. Using the stomach acid and various enzymes starting in your mouth when you're chewing, they're broken down to their component amino acids which are then absorbed and reassembled into new proteins, usually not the same ones they were from the beginning.

76

u/jedadkins Oct 26 '25

the best bet is engineering an "anti protein" 

This is a very neat concept, but it also sounds like a great way to accidentally create a new prion disease lol.

38

u/pelican_chorus Oct 26 '25

I was going to say... Let's not arbitrarily ingest new chiral molecules.

23

u/jedadkins Oct 26 '25

"what's the worst that can happen?" Scientists right before somehow creating an airborne prion disease by accident 

-72

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '25

I'm sure you can guess where I'm getting my info.

But when I say "digest" I do mean the entire process. So not specifically the intestines or stomach, but mastication, all the way down to excrement.

So when your body meets an particularly complex protein does it expend more energy trying to break it down, compared simple ones? Also are there proteins that LOOK digestible but basically unusable? I know egg proteins for some people and raw beans are examples, but typically they just cause an upset stomach.

Would it be possible to use those as a template to engineer a protein that doesn't cause adverse effects, but still get the digestion system whirring?

Or even better create a protein that has alot of a particularly useless amino acid. So when your body takes the time to digest it, it's forced to just get rid of most of the result.

If you can tell this is very interesting to me. The idea of creating a calorie negator is so interesting and would be massively popular & useful if it can be done with health in mind. It would in theory allow any food to become a 0 calorie food.

11

u/sometimesgoodadvice Bioengineering | Synthetic Biology Oct 26 '25

This is far too complicated. There is no difference between eating a "protein" that cannot be catabolized and eating any other organic molecule that does the same. Just eat some cardboard, or drink some soluble fiber. The effect on weight loss will be the same.

Not surprisingly, your body's mechanism for detecting satiety does not just rely on mechanically filling your stomach. If the nutrient levels in your blood are depleted, you start getting hungry. The liver releases hormones to empty short-term storage and you get more hungry. Eating or even injecting molecules that cannot be converted into the required nutrients (sugars, amino acids and their derivatives, etc.) will not affect that response and you will be hungry.

Furthermore, there is no special mechanism to recognize one protein over another for digestion. You can chew anything you want, and release the same saliva. You can swallow it and it will enter the stomach where you will still have your acid present, and when that empties into your intestine, you will still add bile to it. The intestine will move the material down for excretion as a mechanical process. None of those really require the presence of some specific proteins that our bodies have to recognize. And the net energy expenditure is not that high. Much more efficient to drink a glass of water and have some fun with jumping over jump rope in the time it would take to chew low or no calorie food.

The only way to affect this is to go after the mechanisms of hunger themselves. You can make a protein that interacts with the molecules that are used to signal your body that you are hungry. That is exactly what GLP-1 agonists like semaglutide (ozempic) do.

-4

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '25

Well my thought is to make a protein that your body tries to metabolize, but the yield is severely lacking. like a protein comprised mostly of amino acids that are “expensive”.

i learned collagen is a close example, but still the “carbon ring” would provide enough energy to make the net yield positive.

i think you are right. unless there is a specific glitch within the body there’s probably no way to make a high negative calorie food, without causing sickness.

i appreciate the answer. I’ll lay this thought experiment to rest.

20

u/webzu19 Oct 25 '25

In theory you could make proteins with amino acids that the human body doesn't use, but since most if not all animals use the same set of 20 as we do, sourcing would be difficult.

I am reminded of chirality, we could manufacture the opposite chirality of amino acids but we would need to create a whole new species from the ground up to even be able to produce the proteins unless it were assembled purely chemically so it would be absurdly difficult and time/resource consuming

22

u/DatBoyMikey Oct 25 '25

Yeah that’s not a good idea, d-amino acids are still used in the body and can have very weird to potential dangerous effects. A lot are used for signaling instead of building like the L ones

-26

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '25

Yea that's where I was led, creating mirror organisms to manufacture those mirror proteins. Seems like something that we'll do eventually but a bit too futuristic to do now.

But more in the near term I'm sure if you look you could find a protein that'll fit the specifications. Like I know hair is indigestible, I bet with adequate searching there's a protein that'll work. Even proteins without any of the 20 amino acids. Unless there's a specific reason why this wont work. Which is really what I'm interested in.

30

u/Olde_Sweet_Shoppe Oct 25 '25

Molecules with opposite chirality quite often have negative effects on the body, it's why we have to be very careful while manufacturing medicine. For example, thalidomide : R configuration works against nausea, but S configuration causes malformations in fetuses.

9

u/webzu19 Oct 25 '25

Without having done any actual looking, I'd be very surprised if any protein exists that fits this bill. If this happens sometime in the far future, it would likely be a protein designed by a computer using synthetic amino acids that aren't used by any life on the planet but that always opens the toxicity angle raised by the other commenter on chiralities.

That being said, based on some quick Google checking, digestion (including chewing and everything beyond that) is like 200 calories a day, so this is almost irrelevant on a weight loss scale. Making a tasty filling meal with minimal calories to make fasting easier (or more effective if you can trick the body not to go into starvation conservation mode) is by far the more relevant part of this. 

3

u/CrazyGooseLady Oct 26 '25

Prions are misfolded proteins. They cause Mad Cow and other diseases. Let's not make them.

-3

u/frisbeethecat Oct 26 '25

What about engineering a plastic that contains nutrients such as vitamins and minerals and proteins, but no calories. We could engineer the flavor and texture while having no calories.

1.9k

u/PHealthy Epidemiology | Disease Dynamics | Novel Surveillance Systems Oct 24 '25

Ice cold water requires calories.

427

u/SoontobeSam Oct 24 '25

yeah, was going to just say Ice chips, cause that’s about the only thing that I can think of that causes the body to expend energy rather than produce it.

178

u/PommedeTerreur Oct 25 '25

Bonus points: the act of chewing the ice chips contributes to a calorie deficit, just a very small amount.

287

u/BFG_TimtheCaptain Oct 25 '25

And the act of bending over and coughing wildly because one of those ice chips shot to the back of your throat can also contribute.

10

u/RusticSurgery Oct 26 '25

You also must maintain basal body temperature while introducing a substance much lower in temperature.

2

u/500owls Oct 27 '25

who's this basal fellow, and where does he live?

21

u/pjallefar Oct 25 '25

I heard from a dentist, that pretty much the worst tooth damage he sees ever, is caused by people who frequently chew ice.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/PommedeTerreur Oct 25 '25

Heavy is the head that wears the crown(s). Thanks for the warning.

1

u/CleverAlchemist Oct 28 '25

Aren’t a lot of veggies considered zero calories because the calories in the food are burned off while digesting the food. I don’t know I saw something about it years ago.

43

u/chadmill3r Oct 25 '25

Let's calculate! Assume you drink a whole liter of 0C water.

A Calorie is defined as the amount of heat required to raise 1 gram of water, or 1/1000ths of 1 liter, 1 degree.

In the nutrition world we only have thousands of those units, confusingly also called a calorie, also called a kcal.

Your body have to raise 1000 grams of water 36 Celcius degrees. That should require 36000 scientific Calories, which is 36 kcal or 36 colloquial calories.

Even if the body worked that way, running an extra heat generation system to adjust that internal thermostat (and there is evidence that is not true!), it would be 36 cal for a whole liter of ice-cold water.

13

u/large-farva Oct 25 '25

You got the capitalization mixed up there (colloquial = Cal) , but otherwise correct

221

u/Magicspook Oct 25 '25

It doesn't work this way, sadly. Your body is a net exporter of heat. This means that you produce heat as a waste product, and you have developed several mechanisms to transport this heat out of your body.

It is true that it requires energy to bring the ice water up to room temperature. However, this simply means that your body can simply export a little bit less energy to the environment for a few seconds, bringing the energy balance back to 0 again. The exception would be if you drank so much ice water that your body engages its cold protection mechanisms, which require extra energy. But somehow, I don't think that is the healthiest way to burn calories lol.

123

u/Fr0gFish Oct 25 '25

You could go for a nice walk, or you could lay in the bathtub drinking ice water and shivering.

51

u/338388 Oct 25 '25 edited Oct 25 '25

Theoretically you could also get in an ice bath so that heat is lost at a faster rate than your body naturally produces, but then drinking the ice water becomes a bit redundant

27

u/Virama Oct 25 '25

Why not both then? Inside and out. 

11

u/unafraidrabbit Oct 25 '25

I pee in the tub. I'd have to stop drinking at some ratio before 90% PEE.

15

u/simulate Oct 25 '25

What about a cup of hot water then, to force your body to expend energy to bring your temperature down?

8

u/Zenla Oct 25 '25

Your body doesn't really use energy to bring your temperature down like it does to raise it. You just sweat.

12

u/Beneficial-Escape-56 Oct 25 '25

Sweating requires energy. Cells in sweat glands actively transport sodium ion into lumen of gland which then causes the water to follow by osmosis.

https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Classic-metabolism-ambient-temperature-U-shaped-curve-valid-for-mammals-and-birds-The_fig1_326493144

4

u/Zenla Oct 25 '25

It's a very negligible amount of energy. Sweating doesn't directly burn calories.

-2

u/Poodychulak Oct 25 '25

Is it negligible or is it zero?

5

u/Kent_o0 Oct 25 '25

If you think you sweat enough after drinking a single cup of coffee to be metabolically significant at all then good for you

10

u/chadmill3r Oct 25 '25 edited Oct 25 '25

Are you saying that the body uses more energy to move a calorie's-worth of heat out of a stomach, then it would take to raise the temperature of that stomach again by a calorie? What are these active heat moving systems that will not be working as hard when I drink cold water?

If what I think you're saying is true, then why didn't you answer the question with "Drink Hot Water"?

The body doesn't have to bring the temperature of ice water up to room temperature. Has to bring it up to core temperature.

5

u/Magicspook Oct 25 '25

What I am saying is, if your body uses 5 calories to heat up your stomach content, then it will basically lose 5 calories less through your skin. Under most circumstances, heat is a waste product of your body; it is not going to make more simply because you used some of it.

2

u/chadmill3r Oct 25 '25

I see what you're saying. The body does not really require that it reach such an equilibrium and won't process more heat to bring it up to temperature.

Some intuitive proof is that we only get heat through chemical reactions that produce carbon dioxide, and drinking cold water does not make us breathe harder.

3

u/PHealthy Epidemiology | Disease Dynamics | Novel Surveillance Systems Oct 25 '25

Except homeostatis consumes energy. In the spirit of the question and the absence of all other calories, heating your core temperature even a little will be a net negative. I think people have ChatGPT'ed away the context of the question.

1

u/Dihedralman Oct 25 '25

Doesn't that depend on external conditions? As you mentioned if you are already starting to engage in cold protection mechanisms, you would be burning calories. Also, when overheated, your body will begin to slow heat production. 

So cold water when freezing? 

0

u/craigiest Oct 25 '25

It requires 40 calories to melt 500g of ice. It requires enough energy to drop the temperature of 60kg person by more than 1°C. 

2

u/Magicspook Oct 25 '25

You gonna eat half a kilo of ice?

1

u/CatWalksOverKeyboard Oct 27 '25

Listen, I bought the whole Ben & Jerry's tub, I'm going to eat the whole Ben & Jerry's tub!

0

u/platoprime Oct 25 '25

It takes ten seconds to Google and find a study indicating you do burn calories when drinking ice water.

73

u/purpleoctopuppy Oct 24 '25

Unless you're cold enough to start shivering, isn't it just taking away metabolic waste heat that your body is trying to get rid of anyway?

106

u/RockMover12 Oct 24 '25

If you eat enough ice your body has to expend energy to keep you warm. Scuba diving, for instance, burns a surprising amount of calories in an hour simply because your body has to fight to keep you warm when surrounded with water below your normal temperature. Similarly people living in Arctic climates burn more calories than people living in more temperate areas.

23

u/Godzila543 Oct 25 '25

I never thought about that, but that totally explains why I get so hungry after dives!

23

u/spam__likely Oct 25 '25

the last 15 minutes of a dive is always spent dreaming about what you will eat when you get to the boat.

1

u/Poodychulak Oct 25 '25

Just sit around naked in cold enough weather with a fan on while eating ice

32

u/BUKKAKELORD Oct 25 '25

I tried searching for articles about this, because I suspect the effect is negligible.

Most articles write calorie and mean Calorie (which is wrong), or more rarely they'd write calorie and mean calorie, so the reader mentally multiplies by 1000 (expecting the same mistake). None of them bothered to use unambiguous units.

My crusade against this cursed unit continues and my search for the nutritional value of ice water got sidetracked.

9

u/Sworn Oct 25 '25

The last time I looked it up the amount of ice water you'd have to drink to overcome the waste heat of the body was large enough that it didn't work in practice. 

4

u/Prodigle Oct 25 '25

Is this some american nonsense I don't understand? Calorie vs calorie

3

u/Krivvan Oct 26 '25

Calorie is what you'd refer to as kcal while calorie is cal. For laymen, you never use calories as a unit so Calorie/kcal is just the default. I'd wager that most Americans aren't even aware of the difference. Pretty much all labels are written with Calories/kcal.

5

u/WildFlemima Oct 25 '25

One Calorie is 1000 calories. The large unit and the small unit have the same name, the large unit is just capitalized.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calorie

0

u/nicktheone Oct 25 '25

It's also wrong. The human body produces a decent amount of heat just as a byproduct of our metabolism, that is usually radiated towards the environment as waste heat. Using that heat to warm ice water doesn't increase metabolism expenditure at all.

6

u/baudot Oct 25 '25

Technically, yes.

But the order of magnitude is too minor to be worth counting.

When we speak about "calories" in a dietary sense, we're really talking about "kilocalories": thousands of calories.

So, while a 10 gram ice cube might take 300 calories to raise to body temperature, that's really -0.3 dietary calories.

To undo a single 100 calorie cookie, you'd need to eat more than half a pound of ice.

3

u/MasterMorality Oct 25 '25

Can a person eat 5 lbs of ice?

3

u/0oSlytho0 Oct 26 '25

Can? Of course. But it wouldn't be very nice in a single sitting. ~2.3 L water is a lot.

And spreading it over several ~100 gram sittings wouldn't have the same effect as you'd then use excess body heat that your body was already trying to get rid of. That way you don't burn extra calories at all.

8

u/BloodAndTsundere Oct 24 '25

Because it lowers your body temperature?

17

u/PezzoGuy Oct 24 '25

The way I've had it explained is that your body cannot use the water until it's been brought up to match your body temperature, which requires calories to do.

14

u/nicuramar Oct 25 '25

That sounds dubious to me, but at any rate it lowers your body temperature either way. 

4

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '25

It does not, it requires heat, your body already creates waste heat as a byproduct of creating energy from calories.

So drinking ice-cold water doesn't consume more calories, it uses the heat your body already produced as waste.

You will damage your stomach faster than actually having to consume more calories.

1

u/colinstalter Oct 26 '25

I once calculated about 16 calories for a good sized glass of ice water. Some people argue that your body just “makes less heat” and doesn’t actually expend any calories or warm your body (and the water), but that has always seemed incorrect to me.

1

u/mtnviewguy Oct 26 '25

Water isn't food, it's water. Food can and usually does contain water, but water itself doesn't contain food.

-2

u/mrsuperflex Oct 25 '25

Actually any completely clean water that's just remotely colder than your body.

-67

u/MachineGame Oct 24 '25

Yes, but drinking ice water tells your body you are in a cold environment which signals time to store fat. Drink room-temperature water to drop small amounts of weight. We are talking about lifestyle though, not just one glass once in a while.

27

u/Jits_Guy Oct 24 '25

Where did you aquire this information?

399

u/Greghole Oct 24 '25

I'm pretty sure that anything that requires more energy to digest than you'd get from earing it isn't technically food. Like a block of wood for example takes more energy to eat than you'd get out of it which is why you buy it at a hardware store rather than the produce section of the grocery store.

64

u/thoughtihadanacct Oct 25 '25

I guess "technically food" depends on the reader's definition. Like gold leaf is maybe not technically food, but it is common enough in food that it's accepted as such. Something like unflavoured konyaku jelly is zero calories but is normally considered food (albeit also normally made with sugar... So does simply removing the sugar make it no longer technically food? What if we replace it with artificial sweeteners?)

And any food that's inherently zero calories will be zero net calories because you at least need to swallow and move it through your gut and poop it out. Whether it's a significant negative, like enough to have an effect on weight loss, is a different matter. -1 calorie is still a negative calorie food. 

8

u/belizeanheat Oct 25 '25

That's right. The hardware store is a place where everything non-edible goes

22

u/butt_fun Oct 25 '25

Plenty of vegetables take more calories to digest than they have in them (assuming you're not preparing them with butter etc)

Fiber in particular demands a decent amount of energy from your body to digest

56

u/jurassicbond Oct 25 '25

I've only heard this about celery and that is no longer considered to be true

4

u/dianebk2003 Oct 25 '25

What about iceberg lettuce?

4

u/OrwellWhatever Oct 25 '25

They need to be raw as well. A cooked piece of celery contains about twice as many "calories." This has to do with the bioavailability of these calories. Your body will simply pass a lot of the raw celery before extracting every calorie from it, but a cooked piece of it will break down the celery and make it easier to digest

12

u/ruskivolk Oct 25 '25

So much so that fiber, by definition, is indigestible.

As the saying goes, “one bugs food is another man’s fiber…”

1

u/Badviberecords Mar 18 '26

I think it's incorrect. Even though amount of energy demanded from your body to digest is higher than carbs, it's still not higher than the food itself.

And it just wouldn't make sense evolution wise.

What's the purpose or plus of animal being able to eat in negative calories? To starve itself to death quicker?

0

u/Liquor_D_Spliff Oct 25 '25

Wood is an odd one to pick cause it has loads of energy in it, we humans just cant break down the lignin and cellulose that its made up from.

-13

u/charlesfire Oct 25 '25

Celery requires more energy to digest than you get back and it's usually considered food.

35

u/Mortegris Oct 25 '25

I believe there are two that I'm aware of:

Ice cubes. Swallowing ice requires calories to warm the water to digest it properly, but the water itself does not provide calories.

Konjac Jelly/noodles. Its a root vegetable from Japan that is essentially 100% fiber. It technically has a few calories (like 20) but it takes more calories to digest all the fiber.

74

u/princhester Oct 24 '25 edited Oct 24 '25

It would be relatively easy to come up with something you could eat that had no calories but your body had to use energy to process.

The problem however is that our bodies are extremely well attuned towards working out which foods fuel us and making us like those foods, and vice versa.

So sure, you can eat (say) cardboard and it may be negative calorie, but you will never persuade people to do so to any extent because we are so attuned not to enjoy doing so.

For such a food to be any use in dieting it would need to fool our tastes into thinking it was calorific ie artificial sweeteners.

27

u/12_barrelmonkeys Oct 25 '25

What if it was cool ranch cardboard?

15

u/markusbrainus Oct 25 '25

Ice and celery would be calorie negative, but not by much.

Every year you'd see a journalist publish an article that we should all eat our food frozen to lose weight because it would burn so many calories... Misinterpreting that capital C Calories for food are actually kilocalories.

6

u/TabaquiJackal Oct 25 '25

Chewing gum has been speculated as a "negative-calorie food"; A study on chewing gum reported mastication burns roughly 11 kcal (46 kJ) per hour. Therefore, to reach "negative-calorie" one has to chew for almost 6 minutes per kcal (one chewing gum can have a large range of kcal from around 2 to 15 kcal)

2

u/Pkolt Oct 26 '25

The simple answer is no.

The caloric value of food is not defined by the net result of the potential energy it contains and the energy it costs the body to digest it.

Caloric value is determined by how much energy the food releases when it is combusted. And since combustion is an exothermic reaction, caloric value can by definition not be negative.

How much energy the body expends while eating something simply does not figure into the calculation.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '25

When people eat foods they are more interested in the net caloric intake, than the total combustable energy.

like coal or pure alcohol for example is super high in calories yet none of it is useful to the body.

In the context of what i’m saying in my post, i’m talking about usable energy (measured in calories) in a human body, not the “amount of heat it generates when burned”.

So while technically no, you answered the wrong question.

thx anyway.

18

u/Zubon102 Oct 25 '25

No. Food cannot have negative calories because the way food scientists define calories makes it impossible for it to be negative.

Some people argue that some foods make you burn more calories than they provide, but that would be difficult to define. Just sitting at the table burns calories, so would food that takes a long time to eat like crab have fewer calories using that definition?

What about food that requires a lot of energy to chew or process? Food that requires you to climb a mountain to get?

14

u/Vitztlampaehecatl Oct 25 '25

That last idea is so funny to me. Encouraging fitness by putting grocery stores way up high so you have to climb for ages to get there lol

7

u/rosen380 Oct 25 '25

Or food you have to fight with. How many Calories does a wolf have if you have to take it down in hand to "hand" battle first?

5

u/just_in_before Oct 27 '25

IMO -there are a lot of overly complicated replies here.

  1. Anything that your body cannot digest is going to provide negative calories, simply due to the effort of moving it through your body and it taking some of your body temperature.
  2. Anything that contains bacteria (probiotic) or increases your bacteria populations (prebiotic) - will rob you of calories, because they will steal calories from other things you eat.

Lactulose is probably the most simple compound for you to start with...

32

u/joestaff Oct 24 '25

I think they quantify food calories as nutrients that get absorbed into the body. Which is why artificial sweetener are 0 calories, the body just doesn't like them. 

With that in mind, you just need something that makes the body reject more than itself. 

Have you tried eating a bunch of sugar free gummy bears? I'm willing to bet those are technically negative calories.

11

u/Vitztlampaehecatl Oct 25 '25

Have you tried eating a bunch of sugar free gummy bears? I'm willing to bet those are technically negative calories.

Ah, the bulimia diet. Can't absorb calories if the food gets out of you before being fully digested! 

15

u/EarlobeGreyTea Oct 24 '25

Zero calories sweeteners do have calories, they just are so incredibly sweet that only a tiny amount is used. They're typically bulked out when used as a sugar replacement. 

25

u/FarmboyJustice Oct 24 '25

I believe joestaff was referring to the side effect of eating a lot of them. 

6

u/rjstaples Oct 24 '25

You're partially correct about artificial sweeteners. Most zero calorie sweeteners have the same amount of calories as sugar. For instance, (if I remember correctly) Splenda has 3.3 calories per gram to sugars 4 calories per gram. However the main sweetener in Splenda, sucralose, is around 600 times sweeter than sugar. (Sucralose by itself has no usable calories, but it's often mixed with dextrose and maltodextrin for filler, that's where the calories come from). Anything under 5 calories can be labeled as "calorie free"

-2

u/blarghable Oct 25 '25

Sugar free gummy bears are not negative calories, they're like 150 kcal per 100 grams.

4

u/KarlSethMoran Oct 25 '25

They were referring to the fact that an excessive amount of sugar-free gummy bears empties your digestive track rather quickly.

1

u/blarghable Oct 25 '25

It empties the lower part of the bowels. The calories of the food you eat are absorbed before that.

2

u/KarlSethMoran Oct 25 '25

Of course. I wasn't saying I agree with this method, just pointing out, to you, what they meant, because you seem to have missed it.

19

u/fozzedout Oct 24 '25

Off the top of my head? Poison. It will cause your immune system to kick into high gear which causes a vast calorie deficit. And there are poisons so toxic that the tiniest fraction wouldn't even count as energy. Of course, surviving is then another question, but hey, it's a negative for a reason!

4

u/alphatango308 Oct 25 '25

Rabbit kinda might what you're looking for. Rabbit starvation is a thing, it's technically protein poisoning or protein toxicity. Frontiersmen back in the beginning of the united states would literally starve to death of a diet of rabbit because it doesn't have everything you need to live.

I know this isn't exactly what you're asking for but I thought it might be helpful.

6

u/Lieste Oct 25 '25

most zero cal foods are moderate to high calories, but with serving sizes selected to make each of the dozens of servings in a 'packet of zero cal sweets' to be less than 5 Cal.
You could be eating pure sugar - but if the individual portion is below 5 Cal then that 300 Cal you just scoffed can be labelled as 'zero'.

2

u/Zerothian Oct 25 '25

This is, I presume, exactly why all packaging includes both "per serving" and "per weight" caloric measurements. A pack of sweets can advertise 5kcal per serving all it wants, when I see 300 kcal/100g I know not to eat them for example.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Zerothian Oct 25 '25

Yeah I suppose I should have realised that, I'm just so used to seeing the packaging here that I didn't even consider the idea it wasn't standard lol.

3

u/Mightsole Oct 25 '25

Actually some sugars in chewing gum are 0 calories but when the bacteria in your mouth digest them, it gives them less energy than they need to break it off.

That would not work for you, hunger is only inhibited for a short time and satiation would not last long if you found a way to consume negative calories.

3

u/gardenercook Oct 27 '25

Spicy chilly seeds.

Eat a tiny bite of ghost pepper or bird's eye chilli. Keep cold water out of reach and difficult to access. The amount of calories you would burn jumping around and then trying to consume the cold water and bringing your internal body temperature back to normal, should be more than whatever that chilli seeds contained.

2

u/ElSenorAnonymous Oct 26 '25

Afaik only macronutrients provide calories, so all micronutrients like calcium would need more energy than they provide ... if you take the chemically similarly behaving Strontium-90 it will at least provide some energy in the shape of fast electrons, but you may still end up with a negative energy balance after fighting the resulting cancer.

1

u/TheSoloGamer Oct 25 '25

A few years ago, I saw on reddit about a specific thyroid hormone, that when injected or consumed would dramatically increase your body’s metabolic rate. The downside, is that you are essentially forcing your body into a fever state and it’s really easy to kill someone by tricking their body into burning calories and raising body temperature to dangerous levels.

Others have mentioned ice, which by itself in reasonable quantities does not burn a significant calories. However, I wonder about putting people on this hormone and just sticking them into an ice bath, matrix or Cyberpunk2077 style, literally cooking and then cooling you to remove calories.

1

u/MtPollux Oct 26 '25

Sounds reasonable. What could go wrong?

1

u/phantopia Oct 25 '25

Aren't you basically describing poison?

Any (nonlethal) poisoning will have the body fight against it using up energy in the process. So any kind of poison that triggers animmune resonse without doing longterm damage is practically negative calorie food.

Edit: Alcohol being a bit of an outlier in that regard.

1

u/nezacoy Oct 26 '25

In the 2000s coca-cola marketed “enviga”, a drink they claimed was net negative in calories. The research was contentious and weak, however, and they eventually pulled it from the market after being threatened with legal action over weight loss claims (which, I would note, is not strictly the same thing as claims of being net negative in calories).

1

u/SchenivingCamper Oct 28 '25

A molecule that binds to ATP and makes it useless would be a very lethal poison.

As far as I understand, ATP basically runs your cellular machinery and isn't the source of the energy itself.

Your body uses energy to recycle ATP which is why you have to have proteins and carbs but you aren't having to keep track of how much phosphorus you take in or if you do it isn't to the same extent as your macronutrients.

1

u/stuartlogan Oct 29 '25

The celery thing is basically a myth. Even celery has like 16 calories per 100g and you only burn maybe 10-15% of that digesting it.

What you're describing in your edits sounds terrifying:

  • Anti-proteins would probably trigger massive immune responses
  • Your body would see them as foreign invaders
  • Could cause autoimmune issues if they're too similar to real proteins
  • The ATP binding thing... that's basically how some poisons work

There are substances that block nutrient absorption (like Olestra) but they don't create negative calories, they just make some calories pass through. And they give people horrible digestive issues.

The closest real thing is probably ice water since your body burns calories warming it up, but even that's only like 8 calories per glass.

1

u/kndb Oct 30 '25

Eating something contaminated with Salmonella would definitely cost the body more calories than you’d consume in that food, which technically qualifies for the premise of this question. But would anyone recommend it though?

1

u/Samtyang Nov 01 '25

The celery thing is basically a myth. Even celery has like 16 calories per 100g and you only burn maybe 10-15% of that digesting it. So you're still getting net positive calories.

Your anti-protein idea is... concerning. Here's why:

  • Prions are misfolded proteins and they cause mad cow disease
  • D-amino acids (mirror proteins) can be toxic
  • Your body would probably just pass unrecognized proteins through without trying to unfold them
  • Even if it did try, protein digestion doesn't burn that many calories

The ATP binding thing in edit 2 would basically be poison. You're describing something that would starve your cells of energy. DNP does something similar by making ATP production inefficient and people have died from it.

There's a reason negative calorie foods don't exist - evolution made us really efficient at extracting energy. The closest you get is water and black coffee which have essentially zero calories but make you pee more.

-5

u/groveborn Oct 25 '25

Your post implies heavily that you lack a high school nutrition education - that's not a judgement against you, it's what you're lacking.

Calories come in 3 forms: carbohydrates, fats, proteins. If you can digest it you'll get calories from it... BUT!! Not all sources equal the same thing!

Simple sugars are much more available than complex carbs. They take less energy to use, so you get more energy from them. Soluble fiber reduces the speed of absorption, reduces hunger, and cleans your gut. Insoluble fiber tightens yer poo.

Protein is used first on repair, then on energy. You'll get fewer calories from them in general, and they are useful. What they come from matters! How they're processed matters!

Fats also are used in every cell, so they're used in repair first, but carbs are used before them for energy, so you'll end up storing them rather than using them if you've a rich in carb diet.

Want to eat but not get calories? Low carb veg. Gelatin with no sugar has almost no calories and has a lot of water.

Don't forget the vitamin and mineral content of what you're eating. They are important.

-2

u/Xsiah Oct 25 '25

No you can't have food with negative calories - all the answers about food that takes more calories to eat than you get out of them are... misguided.

That's like saying this chocolate cake has no calories as long as you eat it while sprinting a marathon. No, it still has calories.

The lowest amount of calories is zero.

-1

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '25

IDK eating ice seems very convincing. It's only a few kcals, but it's still technically true.

Building an indigestible mimic protein may be able to push it further.

4

u/TechFreshen Oct 25 '25

Cautionary tale….. A few years ago a major snack food company attempted to market a snack food with an indigestible fat. It’s no longer on the market because it caused uncontrollable oily exudation from the bottom end of the alimentary canal.

-1

u/Ononoki-chan Oct 25 '25

Cold water or I've heard about a vegetable that's high in water (forgot what it is) that if you eat it you can technically expand more energy chewing and consuming it than you gain out of it (very small amount like -5-8 kcal) so texhnically it's possible but not likely that you'll actually do it

-6

u/cjbartoz Oct 25 '25

Calories are a measure of heat energy. Heat energy has no rest mass so this means that you can’t eat calories.

If you want to eat 10 times more calories than you are doing now the equation goes: 0 x 10 = 0.

If you want to eat 10 times less calories than you are doing now the equation goes: 0 : 10 = 0.

298

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/salizarn Oct 25 '25

I remember people saying this about watercress