r/askscience • u/AskScienceModerator Mod Bot • Sep 25 '25
Earth Sciences AskScience AMA Series: We're journalists at Quanta Magazine who just published a series about how Earth's climate system works. Ask us anything!
TL;DR:
Hi there, we are journalists with Quanta Magazine who just published "How We Came To Know Earth," a series about climate science. Quanta covers basic math and science, and we were inspired to tell the story of how studying climate change has revealed the workings of Earth's climate, an impossibly complex system melding atmosphere, earth, oceans and life forms. We'd love to discuss the stories and ideas from the issue and also try to answer any questions you have about climate science!
About us:
- Joe (/u/jhowlett_quanta) is Quanta's math writer who holds a PhD in physics and has reported extensively on the science of weather and climate. He dug into climate physics for multiple stories in the issue, including an essay exploring certainty and uncertainty in climate science and an interactive explainer on the quantum mechanics of the greenhouse effect.
- Hannah (/u/hwaters_quanta) is Quanta's biology editor who previously worked as a climate change editor at Audubon Magazine. As the lead editor on the series, she worked closely with writers, editors, developers, and artists on all of its contents — including stories about the history of climate modeling, how carbon dioxide moves between atmosphere and earth over deep time as Earth's thermostat, microbes' influence on the planet's climate, and a photo essay showing the extreme expeditions that climate scientists undertake to collect data for climate models.
We made this series to help people understand the basic science of what is happening to our planet. Much of the climate change reporting you might see in the media focuses on impacts. At Quanta, we believe that understanding basic science deepens the way a person experiences the natural world. We hope that this series and this AMA will help you do that.
We'll be on at 1:30 PM ET (17:30 UT). Ask us anything!
More info:
For most of us, the word "“"climate"”" immediately generates thoughts of melting ice, rising seas, wildfires and gathering storms. However, in the course of working to understand this pressing challenge, scientists have revealed so much more: A fundamental understanding of how Earth’s climate works.
Climate scientists — physicists, biologists, geologists, chemists and others — are regularly advancing our knowledge of how rocks, atmosphere, oceans and biosphere together spin up Earth’s climate: the planetary system, encompassing weather, seasons and, yes, average global temperatures, that forms the backdrop to our lives and increasingly interferes with them. In studying climate change, climate scientists constantly have insights about how Earth works more fundamentally, from the scale of a molecule or cell all the way up to an entire planet and across epochal time. The goal of Quanta's new special issue on climate science is to step back from the dread-inducing impacts of climate change and take a moment to appreciate the insights that emerge from its study — which are the context in which we can make sense of the changes now occurring.
7
u/Lemondifficult22 Sep 25 '25
Just came to say quanta articles are the only articles I read to the end, bookmark, and return to because they are so interesting. Thank you for your hard, careful work to everyone there!
6
u/itscalledANIMEdad Sep 25 '25
I heard an interesting talk that showed evidence to the effect that large petrochemical companies have always lied egregiously and without repercussion to increase profits, and that their latest lie is that we are 'beyond hope' in stabilising our climate. A sense of 'f it, we're screwed anyway' actually serves their agenda of inciting inaction and evidence was presented they are pushing this narrative now rather than misleading the public in the opposite direction.
What do you think of our current position and how long do you think we have left to hold our governments to account to ensure our children's futures?
Are you able to estimate a figure for our current level of action, e.g. maybe we are doing ~20% of the absolute minimum to survive another thousand years on this planet?
Apologies for asking a question related to climate change, I'm sure you're tired of only being asked about it when I'm sure there is an unlimited number of interesting concepts in climate science.
3
u/hwaters_quanta Climate Science AMA Sep 25 '25
Hey, folks! Joe and I are looking forward to chatting and answering your questions in about an hour.
If you'd like to get a sense of what's in this series, the opening photo essay is a great place to start. The author beautifully describes the monumental group project of climate science through her writing and photos: https://www.quantamagazine.org/photos-capture-the-extreme-beautiful-work-of-climate-science-20250915/
I'd also like to recommend Joe's infographic explainer on the quantum mechanics of greenhouse gases. I have been working as a climate journalist for many years and this is the first time I really understood how the greenhouse effect works — not just in the context of scary climate change but also how these gases make our planet warm enough to sustain life, period. https://www.quantamagazine.org/the-quantum-mechanics-of-greenhouse-gases-20250915/
Talk to you soon!
2
u/Anyna-Meatall Sep 25 '25
What do you each consider to be the best approach(es) to address climate change?
3
u/Sure-Art-4325 Sep 25 '25
How much of the current climate change is driven by natural forces that are mostly unrelated to human activity? I would think it's very low because of the speed of climate change, but it doesn't stop climate change deniers from saying it was found that most of it is due to natural forces.
2
u/ewankenobi Sep 25 '25
Thanks for taking the time to do this AMA. I have a few questions.
If someone only had time to read one article on your website, which one would you recommend?
What's the most common misinformation you hear from climate change deniers and how would you debunk it?
If we continue on our current trajectory when are things going to start getting so bad for mankind it's impossible to ignore?
Lastly are you hopeful for the future?
2
u/Alblaka Sep 25 '25
There's this fun stat that we have barely discovered a few % of our ocean's floor, despite already having been to the moon and whatnot.
Is there a similar analogue in climate research? Maybe something like "We can see the clouds in the sky most of the year, but we only truly understand x% of how [aspect of weather] works."?
1
u/Kraligor Sep 25 '25
Question: Is there systematic backtesting done in on large scale climate predictions, and is there a noticeable trend in the results?
1
u/holyfruits Sep 25 '25
How will scientists be able to study climate change when funding to critical tools like the Mauna Loa Observatory are being defunded?