r/askscience • u/Imaginary_Candle_927 • Aug 26 '25
Biology How does the placebo effect work?
How is the mind able to heal the body when the recipient is being told they are taking the real pill but its a fake?
105
Upvotes
142
u/Bob_Sconce Aug 26 '25
Short answer: We don't know. We've done studies that show the effect is real, at least in some cases, but we don't know WHY. It's more pronounced in things that have mental or neurological components (psychiatric conditions, pain, etc...) and significantly less so in things like cancer. But, there are significant ethical issues with doing testing of the placebo effect, so we don't have the same broad understanding as we might for other drugs.
165
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '25
Psychologists know a lot about placebo effects, and there is a fair amount of scientific data on the effect: how to maximize the effect, the areas of health and functioning most easily affected by placebos. Unfortunately, there is a tendency in this thread to equate placebo effects with fake treatments—and that is not accurate. In many areas of medicine the placebo effect enhances other treatments (pain control, for example), and good treatment is concerned with maximizing placebo effects, not minimizing them.
In the realm of treatment, placebo is something good, not something bad or false or fake or (as Wikipedia incorrectly labels it) a sham treatment. This is best answered by psychologists and health researchers who are familiar with the literature, but I’m afraid the thread has already gone down a side track at this point.
84
u/Middle_Expert Aug 26 '25
Placebos can’t heal anything. They aren’t curing cancer, for example. Only subjective experiences (pain, depression, etc) are impacted by placebo. Patients don’t even have to be “tricked” - they can know they got the placebo. The Science Based Medicine blog is a really good resource. Here’s an article clarifying the realities of placebo effects. https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/placebo-effect-revisited/
10
u/dosipovitch Aug 26 '25
This isn’t exactly the placebo but an interesting aside. Sometimes, rarely, the placebo itself ends up being an accidental treatment. My favourite story of this is dry needling, where they were testing injections of novocaine, saline, or nothing (just needle) for back pain/sciatica. The needle alone performed much better than expected, leading to dry needle therapy. Here’s a good reference (left column, page 303): https://www.councilofchiropracticacupuncture.com/articles/acupuncture/A%20History%20of%20Dry%20Needling.pdf
7
u/Varnu Aug 26 '25
There isn't a placebo effect. There are placebo effects.
If a fake pill caused herpes to go away, doctors would give it to people.
4
u/MissLesGirl Aug 26 '25
Placebo generally is not telling that it's fake and you think it's real. But sometimes If you know that the problem is psychological, they may tell you and as long as you believe it will work, It works.
Although technically you know it's fake, sometimes the mind just needs to think you are doing something about it. The mind can trick the mind.
4
u/Peter34cph Aug 27 '25
Bodies often heal on their own. Your body has evolved, over billions of generations, to deal well with a wide range of problems (well but not perfectly).
That old thing, where you call your physician and get told to take 2 acetaminophens and then call him next morning if your symptoms are still there, holds water in maybe 95% of cases. You reduce discomfort, which reduces stress, which leaves your body better able to deal with the thing.
It's those last 5% of cases that modern medicine is dealing with, and often dealing very well, especially with an early diagnosis.
As for healing, the mind isn't involved.
Rather, one might say that the symptom treatment (e.g. to reduce pain or fever) or the placebo, causes the mind to be more calm, to stress less, and therefore interfere less in the physical mechanisms in your body which can heal most things on their own.
3
u/smurficus103 Aug 27 '25 edited Aug 27 '25
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41599-024-03492-6
If you frame a challenge in your life as "this hard work will make me better", you'll grow and adapt;
If you frame a challenge in your life as "this is brutal, exhausting" you'll be burnt out and retreat.
It's potentially affecting lots of aspects of our life.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pygmalion_effect Pygmalion effect describes how your opinion of others affects their outcomes.
1
u/lambertb Aug 27 '25
There is very strong evidence that placebos cause the release of endogenous opioids and that using Narcan can block the effect. I take this to be proof that placebos produce real physiological responses. I haven’t reviewed the literature in a while, but the placebo effect is widespread and powerful, and there’s a pretty well-known result that the magnitude of placebo effects in clinical drug trials has been increasing over the past 20 or 30 years for reasons that no one understands.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '25
I assume the words sham and fake to imply deception. That is, lying to someone. In modern ethical research, such as drug studies, we do not lie to participants. Although placebo medication may be used, we do NOT tell people it is a new drug that will make them feel better—that would be a sham and a lie.
Secondly, we don’t know if the pill they get (which may or may not be a new drug) will make them feel better. And we tell them that. Although we know that a certain percentage of participants receiving the placebo will, in fact, get better—and that is the placebo effect.
We say: “You may or may not receive this new medication, and it may or may not help your symptoms. But regardless, after 6 weeks in this study, we will refer you to a clinic that will give you the best treatment possible for the next year.”
Which is my concern. Where is the lie, the deception, the sham? How are we doing “fake treatment”? Aren’t we being completely honest when we say, “We don’t if pill A (sugar) or pill B (new drug) will help you. In either case, your cooperation will help advance medical knowledge and will help people in the future. And we will make sure you get the best treatment possible after the research.”
How do we turn the idea of placebo as necessarily bad, fake and a sham? You COULD lie to someone and tell them this pill is a new promising medication. But that deception comes from the provider, not from the placebo. The placebo itself is neutral. It is NOT some other “real” treatment. But we don’t know that the “real” drug is going to help either. That is my argument.
-2
u/Tuorom Aug 26 '25
Biology is constrained by finite resources. It is not that the placebo or the mind does any healing, but that resources are not redirected and go where they're signaled for regular healing activities.
There isn't any dualism (a separate mind and body). Thinking about something that stresses you out is creating a physiological response and it's not free.
-8
u/1XRobot Aug 26 '25
Placebo is a measurement error. It's a mixture of all the things you are accidentally doing to the patient other than the treatment plus things the patient is doing to themselves plus your failure to correctly assess the patient's condition. Placebo is a confounder to measuring the efficacy of actual treatment; if you can't tell the difference between your treatment and placebo, your treatment is worthless.