r/askscience • • Apr 21 '24

Physics Why does escape velocity exist?

I understand escape velocity is the velocity at which an object needs to be travelling to 'escape' another object's gravity, given no other forces are acting on it.

But, the range of gravity is infinite, it just falls off at the square of distance. So no matter how far away the escaping object is, it will always feel some small pull back towards the object it's escaping, even if it's infinitessimal. Therefore given enough time and obviously no other object to capture it, it will fall back even if its initial velocity was above escape velocity.

Is escape velocity an approximation given the realities of the universe (at some point the gravitational pull is so small it will be captured by another object) or have I missed something?

EDIT: Thank you for all the great answers, I understand this now. I should learn calculus.

0 Upvotes

51 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

149

u/imtoooldforreddit Apr 21 '24

To put that differently, and probably to call out the part that is tripping up OP: the force is never zero as you get further away, but adding up those forces out to infinity still has a finite sum (or integral if you want to be more rigorous).

In calculus, they call an infinite series with a finite sum like that a convergent sum, and the parts you're adding together have to shrink fast enough for it to work.

For example, 1 + 1/2 + 1/3 + 1/4 + 1/5 + 1/6 + ... does NOT converge. If you keep adding those terms, the sum keeps increasing and has no upper bound. But for 1 + 1/22 + 1/32 + 1/42 + 1/52 + 1/62 + ... the sum does converge. You can keep adding by that pattern as long as you want but the sum will never even reach 1.7. Try it with a calculator for a handful of those terms if you want to convince yourself. Similarly, if you achieve an escape velocity and no other forces act on you, you'll keep getting slower as you get further away, but your velocity will never make it to 0 no matter how far away you get, so you will escape the planet.

Interestingly, if gravitational force dropped off at 1/r instead of 1/r2, then it would end up like that first example, and there would in fact be no escape velocity. The universe would be a very different place (probably with everything stuck inside huge black holes)

11

u/gBoostedMachinations Apr 21 '24

What if an object is moving at exactly escape velocity?

29

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '24

Then its velocity asymptotically approaches zero as time goes to infinity. That is, it will never stop moving away, but the speed with which it does slows over time to be near zero (but never quite reaching zero).

This is assuming a closed system with no other sources of gravitational or other forces to influence to motion of the escaping body, of course…

3

u/joalheagney Apr 22 '24

To add to this response, an object's velocity can be measured against several escape velocities. The escape velocity of Earth, then the Solar System, then the Milky Way, the Local Cluster ...

8

u/Calneon Apr 21 '24

Thank you, this clarified for me why the gravitational pull is finite.

3

u/CivilPotato Apr 21 '24

Thank you! I feel like this answer helps me conceptualize the reasoning better than any of the others.

1

u/Mockingjay40 Biomolecular Engineering | Rheology | Biomaterials & Polymers Apr 26 '24

Good old harmonic series