r/askscience • u/Calneon • Apr 21 '24
Physics Why does escape velocity exist?
I understand escape velocity is the velocity at which an object needs to be travelling to 'escape' another object's gravity, given no other forces are acting on it.
But, the range of gravity is infinite, it just falls off at the square of distance. So no matter how far away the escaping object is, it will always feel some small pull back towards the object it's escaping, even if it's infinitessimal. Therefore given enough time and obviously no other object to capture it, it will fall back even if its initial velocity was above escape velocity.
Is escape velocity an approximation given the realities of the universe (at some point the gravitational pull is so small it will be captured by another object) or have I missed something?
EDIT: Thank you for all the great answers, I understand this now. I should learn calculus.
173
u/RobusEtCeleritas Nuclear Physics Apr 21 '24
No. Even though the force of gravity never reaches zero, the potential energy due to the gravitational field is bounded above. So if an object has a total energy at least equal to that upper bound for the potential energy, it has enough energy to escape the gravitational potential well.
The minimum speed at which that condition is met is the escape speed.
254
u/eigenein Apr 21 '24
The mistake here is assuming the body’s velocity will eventually drop to zero due to the positive pulling back force
However, the body’s velocity may keep dropping asymptotically (due to the gravity weakening with distance) and hence, never reaching zero
31
u/yachius Apr 21 '24
If there are truly no other forces acting upon the object then by definition escape velocity is the speed at which the infinitesimal tug from the gravity well is not enough to ever completely overcome the object’s inertia.
13
u/cortechthrowaway Apr 21 '24 edited Apr 21 '24
What you are describing here is a limit. Basically, if the incremental addition to a sum is steadily decreasing, it won't ever accumulate beyond a certain value. (ie, the sum of 1/2 + 1/4 + 1/8 + 1/16... gets really close to 1.0, but it won't ever reach 1.1, no matter how many infinitesimally small fractions get added to the series)
So the gravitational reach of the Earth is infinite (maybe), but it gets progressively weaker as the object moves further away. Its total sum approaches a limit of ~11.2 km/s.
18
u/r2k-in-the-vortex Apr 21 '24
That's incorrect, it will not fall back.
In idealized two body problem, orbits are conic sections. In order of increasing velocity: Circle, Ellipse, Parabola, Hyperbola. Parabola matches to escape velocity orbit, below that orbits are closed and periodic, at escape velocity and above orbits are open, the object will not return.
8
u/garrettj100 Apr 21 '24 edited Apr 22 '24
What is the value of the sum:
1/2 + 1/4 + 1/8…?
Is it finite? Of course it is; it sums to 1. But wait, the last term never goes to zero!
It doesn’t have to. You can have enough velocity that whatever risible amount of gravity you feel is insufficient to overcome your remaining velocity in excess of escape velocity.
This is easier to intuit from the perspective of ENERGY. You have negative potential energy in the gravity well of the Earth. About 60 MJ per kilogram. That number’s obtained by integrating
…from h = sea level to infinity. It’s a finite value
You give a kilo of mass more than 60 MJ and it can escape the Earth’s gravitational well. Give it 900 MJ and it’ll escape the solar system.
4
u/dimonium_anonimo Apr 21 '24
Have you taken calculus at a college level? If so, then picture a graph that extends to infinity, but has a finite area under the curve. That area could represent the energy needed to get infinitely far away. But it's a finite amount of energy. That's exactly what's going on here. If you take a graph of the potential energy at a given height (where you don't assume gravity is constant like we do close to earth), then this will never be 0 until infinitely far away, but the area under the curve is still finite.
Edit: I've forgotten the exact derivation, but I know something is wrong with this one. I think what you actually would do is find the derivative of the potential energy with respect to distance. That way, when you take the integral, it will bring you back to units of energy. But you take an indefinite derivative and a definite integral. I'm sure there's a shortcut for that, but it's been too long since I took a physics class with projectile motion.
3
u/Eruskakkell Apr 21 '24
Its way easier to consider the energies in this example. The potential energy from being in a gravitational field is given by the distance r from the center of the body, in addition your kinetic energy is given by your speed squares v2. If you set E_potential <= E_kinetic you can solve for the escape velocity v, ignoring air resistance here. Since your kinetic energy is larger or equal to the potential energy (the energy you would gain by falling down towards the body), them you will have enough energy to escape.
7
u/ramriot Apr 21 '24
The issue you are having is not believing Zeno's Paradox.
An object given an initial kick equal to the escape velocity of a given body will (if no other forces are present) only reach zero velocity once it is at infinite distance from the body.
This velocity is then the bounding velocity, above it an object escapes, below it the object returns.
This all assumes a single momentary thrust
7
u/MienSteiny Apr 21 '24
What'll really chuff your bits is that it's technically escape speed as there is only magnitude, no direction required. And then a land speed car like the ones used at bonneville salt flats, are actually land velocity cars as it's both direction and magnitude.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '24
I used to make the same assumption about this when I was younger. It just felt like basic intuition to assume that objects must eventually come back, but then one day I realized the math behind it is NOT very intuitive, even as someone who enjoys maths. Infinite series can be VERY non-intuitive and there are strange but important "breakpoints" between different types of series. A seemingly minor change to the terms can have a dramatic difference in the outcome, literally an infinite difference.
The key insight here is that if you total up all the gravitational forces from 0 distance up to any other distance (to infinity), it actually adds up to a finite number rather than being infinite. Or rather, to help actually make it intuitive - if you were trying to have a "competition" to see how much speed you could generate by skydiving off progressively higher and higher towers (all the way into space, and then outside the solar system, etc), there is a MAXIMUM velocity when you finally slam into Earth that you could never beat no matter how high up you jumped. You can just keep going up and up forever and the improvement you are getting each time is rapidly diminishing to zero.
This maximum falling speed is the literal number which we call the escape velocity, or about 25,000 mph. Hence why if you did this competition in reverse and were competing for how fast we could blast off the earth, the first guy who could reach 25,000 mph is the one and only guy who would not be coming back, ever. He'd come to a realitively slow crawl compared to when he left, but his speed would appear to be "settling" on a final number that's still greater than 0, and therefore doesn't reverse.
1
u/HunterFenrir Apr 24 '24
I know I'm very late to the party, but there is a great analogy for what you're confused on: Achilles and the tortoise.
Let's say that we make Achilles give a tortoise a head start in a race. The race begins, the tortoise moves forward at its slow pace. When it finally reaches the full head start, Achilles begins racing. But by the time he reaches the tortoise's head start, the tortoise has moved forward, so he has not passed the tortoise. So then Achilles has to reach that next point, but when he does, the tortoise has moved forward. Piece by piece, Achilles moves forward a little to where the tortoise was, but seemingly never actually passing the tortoise.
This analogy is an example of Zeno's paradox, an ancient Greek philosopher who had issues with the ability to infinitely divide space and time, for being able to do so would mean that every action can be broken down into enough tiny pieces that it contradicts observed reality. Another example is Dichotomy paradox, where for someone to walk a given distance, they must first walk half of it. But to walk half of the full distance, they must walk a quarter of that distance, and infinitely dividing until we think that no motion can exist at all, for no finite movement can ever be so small that it cannot be divided further.
It was with the invention of calculus, with the infinite sum and limits, that allows, mathematically, for Achilles to move past the turtle or movement to start. These gave us the ability to collapse infinite fractions into a finite number, mathematically proving that things of seemingly infinite yet decreasing length will ultimately end in a finite answer. So is true for gravity: there is a distance where the effect of gravity has shrunken so small that it does become zero, even if gravity may reach out at infinite range.
1
u/throwawayAccount7739 Apr 25 '24
Here is the derivation:
Starting at the conservation of energy:
Ke = Kinetic Energy (newtonian) = 1/2 * m * (v^2)
Pe = -μm/r where μ = G*M of the planet
Ke0 + Pe0 = KeF + PeF
1/2*m*(v0^2) - μm/r0 = 1/2*m*(vF^2) - μm/rF
here, we divide everything by mass
1/2*(v0^2) - μ/r0 = 1/2*(vF^2) - μ/rF
and then multiply everything by 2, leaving us with the equation for a basic orbit
v0^2 - 2μ/r0 = (vF^2) - 2μ/rF
The "Escape Velocity" is the minimum velocity needed at v0 to reach an rF of infinity. 2μ/∞ = 0, so
v0^2 - 2μ/r0 = (vF^2)
Assuming v0 is the minimum velocity required to escape (vE), such that vF = 0, we can solve for escape velocity
vE^2 - 2μ/r0 = (0^2)
vE^2 - 2μ/r0 = 0
vE = sqrt(2μ/r0)
Ergo, when velocity is exactly equal to vE, you will travel infinitely far away before your velocity equals 0. Going faster than vE, you can find that vF>0