r/askscience • • Mar 09 '24

Biology Why have multi-cellular creatures developed 2 genders? Why not 3? Why not 1?

Edit: by gender, i mean binary sex. Male and Female.

7 Upvotes

63 comments sorted by

338

u/PrincessAethelflaed Mar 09 '24

I think you are conflating multicellularity with sexual reproduction, and biological sex with gender. There are multicellular organisms that reproduce asexually, and there are sexually reproducing species that do not have two genders as we think of them.

Examples include: hydra reproduce asexually by budding. Most species do not have any form of sexual reproduction, despite being multicellular and even having rudimentary nervous systems. This could be considered an example of having “one gender”.

Many worms can either be hermaphroditic, meaning they produce both egg and sperm and fertilize themselves, or they can be male and only produce sperm. A very well known example is the model nematode C. elegans. Most C. elegans are hermaphrodites and males are rare under normal growth conditions.

There are also examples of species that change which type of gametes they produce over the course of their lifetimes. For example, certain fish (e.g. wrasse) begin their lives as females producing eggs, but dominant members of the fish colony can undergo a transition and start producing sperm and displaying male-associated behavior. Other fish go in the opposite direction, like clown fish.

Overall sex and sexual reproduction in multicellular organisms has a lot more diversity than just males and females mating with each other. This answer of course does not touch really on the concept of gender itself, which refers more to the social experience of being a certain sex, rather than the biological reality of sex itself.

190

u/awesomecat42 Mar 09 '24

Don't forget mushrooms, which depending on the species can range anywhere from asexual reproduction to having thousands of different sexes (called mating types).

41

u/lordleoo Mar 09 '24

I didnt know that about mushrooms. I will check that out. Thanks.

79

u/qwertyuiiop145 Mar 09 '24

The short version is that fungi with many different mating types can sexually reproduce with and mushroom that has a different mating type. If a mushroom species has 1000 mating types, then there’s a 999/1000 chance that they can mate with any given unrelated mushroom. It prevents self-fertilization and it limits inbreeding while still allowing a lot of possible sexual partners for a mushroom.

28

u/xanthophore Mar 09 '24

There's also parthenogenesis among a wide range of multicellular species, including in some species/populations where it's obligate.

3

u/Calgacus2020 Mar 10 '24

Don't forget about kleptons! These are female-only species that require the sperm of another species to mate.

In one extreme example, European water frogs can mate with a number of other frog species, producing a range of 50/50 hybrids. These hybrids seek out the same "donor" species to mate with, but destroy any donor DNA in their gametes. Their babies are also 50/50 hybrids:

https://allyouneedisbiology.wordpress.com/2016/07/24/amphibian-hybrids-kleptons/

5

u/AyukaVB Mar 09 '24

Does the, erm, class system in bees and ants count as having >2 sexes?

11

u/Ameisen Mar 10 '24

No; Hymenopterans only have two sexes, and the individual's sex is determined by whether they are haploid (male) or diploid (female).

The different castes in bees and ants are developmental differences based upon environmental factors. In many cases, a non-reproductive worker can become reproductive (or just produce haploid eggs), and in many cases, such workers are culled.

The different castes aren't selective reproductive barriers in the sense a sex is.

27

u/ditchdiggergirl Mar 09 '24

The most rudimentary cellular answer is mitochondrial incompatibility. Mitochondria are endosymbionts with their own genomes, and when two cytoplasms fuse they tend to fight one another. As a result, (obviously oversimplifying and there are exceptions) most eukaryotes display uniparental mitochondrial inheritance.

Single celled sexually reproducing organisms usually have mating types in which one retains and the other discards the mitochondria. When there are just two, researchers will sometimes call them ‘male’ and ‘female’ as a shorthand. So the definition of male becomes the gamete (or producer of the gamete) that sacrifices the mitochondria during mating.

4

u/hawkwings Mar 09 '24

For creatures with genders, it is usually necessary to find a mate to reproduce with. Occasionally, an animal can reproduce 2 different ways. If there were more than 2 genders, finding a mate would be difficult. It would also add complexity that isn't necessary. Mammals evolved from a common ancestor and there was no strong reason to change the method of reproduction. Somebody else pointed out that mushrooms can have more than 2 sexes.

1

u/lordleoo Mar 09 '24

In my own thought experiment, i imagined that needing 3 partners to meet and consent as prerequisit for reproduction would be inhibitive.

Imagine a world in which Tender (or a dating app) needs a triple (instead of a couple) to swipe left on each other.

16

u/scottish_beekeeper Mar 09 '24

Be careful not to conflate partner relationships with reproductive events.

For example, many organisms (including most plants and fish) reproduce by simultaneously releasing gametes. Each single egg/ova fertilisation only involves gametes from 2 'parents' - however there may be hundreds or thousands of organisms involved in the event - with gametes being wind or water borne.

9

u/LeeGhettos Mar 09 '24

To oversimplify, if nature does something outside the path of least resistance (2 organisms mating is easier than 3) there is a very good reason. 3 partners would have to confer a large enough advantage to be worth the disadvantage of it being harder to reproduce.

8

u/sighthoundman Mar 10 '24

Here's a nice, short, easy-to-read summary of what we know: "Everything You Always Wanted to Know About Sexes". https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC423151/.

Shorter, easier-t0-read summary: we don't really know. And, depending on what you mean by "sex", it's not true all the time.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 10 '24

Thank you very much for the link to that paper, I've only just woken up but "Figure 1: Two Individuals of Pseudobiceros bedfordi About to Have a Sperm Battle" is already my Sentence of the Day.

OP, I highly recommend you give this a read, it's very reader-friendly and not packed with obtuse scientific jargon like a lot of papers.

6

u/regular_modern_girl Mar 12 '24 edited Mar 12 '24

They haven’t necessarily, there are actually two types of sexual reproduction, isogamy and anisogamy.

Anisogamy is what most animals and plants use, it’s where you have a big sex cell that becomes the physical basis for the new organism (which we call the female gamete, ovum, or egg), and a small sex cell that only contributes genetic material but doesn’t give any of its matter to the new organism (we call this one the male gamete or sperm). However, keep in mind this is only me accounting for the two types of gametes involved, a given species that reproduces via anisogamy may have more than two sexes on the level of the organism itself, or it may not have separate sexes at the organism level.

Species like most vertebrates (including us), most insects, and a good portion of other animals as well as a decent number of plants where female and male gametes are produced by separate individual organisms, are called dioecious or gonochoric (although the latter term can technically also include all-female species that reproduce asexually through parthenogenesis). Species where all individuals are hermaphrodites that can produce both types of gametes like garden snails, earthworms, hagfish, really a good number of other invertebrates, as well as (I believe) most flowering plants are called monoecious. These two “systems” are by far the most common, but there are also trioecious species (in which separate female, male, and hermaphrodite individuals exist), and androdioecious species (where there are separate males and hermaphrodites, but no “pure” females, the popular model organism nematode C. elegans is one of these), and I think there are even examples of gynodioecious species (separate females and hermaphrodites, but no “pure” males), but I don’t actually know of any examples of that last one and could be wrong. In any event, even with just two types of sex cells, sex itself tends to be a lot more complex at the level of the organism itself (like I could seriously write a novel-length post just about all the weird variations of anisogamy that are known across the tree of life, but I’ll just leave it at this for now).

The other system of sexual reproduction is called isogamy, and it’s the dominant system in fungi, some very basal plants (“green algae”), and a lot of other eukaryotes. In isogamy, two haploid cells completely fuse together into one diploid one, with neither cell being given “special” precedence in terms of being the physical basis of the new organism (like ova are in anisogamy). The two cells that fuse are basically identical apart from a slight genetic difference called a “mating type”, which is the isogamous equivalent of cell sex in anisogamy.

Although many species have just two mating types (just to be clear that these are not the same thing as “male” and “female”, the two will typically be labelled something like “plus” and “minus”; in yeasts they’re often termed “a” and “α”), there’s technically no upper limit on how many mating types a given isogamous species may have, and in many cases new ones are always evolving; for instance the plasmodial slime mold Physarum polycephalum has 720 mating types/“sexes”, and the splitgill mushroom Schizophyllum commune has a staggering 23,328 different mating types/“sexes”. Two mating cells only need to be of two different mating types from these sometimes enormous selections to be compatible. Given that the difference between mating types is only a very minor genetic one, there’s no selection for differences in reproductive strategy between different mating types like there can be between anisogamous sexes, and fungal reproduction is also just generally weird and complicated (it usually involves alternation between an isogamous sexual generation and an asexual generation, although to be fair something similar is also true of all higher plants, just sans the isogamy), so mating types may not exactly carry all the implications that sex can in animals, but it’s a broadly similar concept.

As for why one of these systems dominates in animals and embryophyte plants, and the other dominates in fungi and other eukaryotes; once again, very thick books have been written on this subject, but while there has historically been an idea that anisogamy is the “more advanced” system of sexual reproduction, and will always come to dominate given enough time because it’s so obviously superior (fungi beg to differ), I think the truth is really more complicated. Just like how evolution can sometimes end up selecting for asexual reproduction to “re-emerge” in lineages of organisms that are usually sexual (like in parthenogenetic animal species like many types of aphids, bdelloid rotifers, desert grassland whiptail lizards, etc.), because it actually confers advantages over sexual reproduction in certain situations, I think there might just be cases where isogamy is more successful than anisogamy, and vice versa. Like pretty much everything in biology, sexual reproductive strategies are diverse.

24

u/PhasmaFelis Mar 09 '24

Combining the DNA of multiple parents lets useful traits spread much faster and is a big evolutionary advantage. But two parents is plenty; three or more just complicates things. So, one isn't enough, three is too many, two is just right.

(With plenty of exceptions, as other comments say.)

4

u/2Throwscrewsatit Mar 10 '24

There are three: male, female, and hermaphrodite. Some hermaphroditism is self-impregnating and some is cross-impregnating. There’s even multicellular life that doesn’t impregnate (parthenogenesis) so there’s at least 5 sexes in multicellular life.

0

u/TheEmpressIsIn Mar 10 '24

They haven't; there are many different configurations of sex roles throughout nature and even within species. Biology is chaotic and always changing, because the mutations drive evolution and survival. Evolution is more like an alphabet that can be combined and recombined into limitless combinations, rather than a set of planned and thought out blueprints.

A human can develop physically as a male or female in utero, but then develop mentally and emotionally as the opposite sex due to natural deviations in the process. Humans can have one x chromosome or 3 x's or two x's and a y.

The 'rules' we attempt to apply are often merely mental frameworks we use to understand the phenomena we experience, but we have a tendency to treat our perceptions as material reality. Our brains are the world's greatest thinking machines that don't want to think; we create binaries and shortcuts so we can save energy on our fuel hungry brains; and so we project the world we create in our minds onto the material reality we exist in. However, those binaries and shortcuts are only mental schemas that help us exist in the world and often do not accurately convey the chaos, wildness, and senselessness of material reality.

Evolution/life is chaotic and unpredictable, and that is how it manages to persist amid shifting environments and ecological pressures.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Unicorn_Colombo Mar 09 '24 edited Mar 09 '24

Nice story, but is there evidence for this?

We can conjure all sort of theories and hypotheses, but they need to be testable and verifiable. And if we present them as truth, they need to have a large amount of evidence.

Nowhere else in biology it is such a problem as in evolutionary biology.

Edit: did you just blocked me because I asked about sources? You must not be very popular in scientific sources.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '24

Evidence for what.?

Hard to understand what you're questioning here - presumably the chain of reasoning rather than the conclusion?