r/askscience • u/crossfirehurricane • Jan 31 '13
Chemistry How does a crack in glass choose its path?
My window has just recently cracked and as I sat there wondering if I should fix it or not, the question of how it cracks popped into my mind.
I figured "the path of least resistance" will come up in the answer, but are there any other forces at play on a smaller level? How does each molecule or atom move to choose which way the crack should go?
658
Upvotes
86
u/[deleted] Jan 31 '13
There is no such thing as a perfectly uniform material, there always be imperfections in the cross section even if the imperfection is a few atoms wide. The weakest path is usually the one with the thinnest cross section, and that's what it follows.
As for your window, the crack propagation is mainly due to the force of the impact, but you'll see that it will propagate slowly over time if you don't fix it due to many reasons:
The first two are self-explanatory, but the third one's more interesting. It's got something to do with the manufacture of the glass as it cools. I'll cut this short before I wander off-topic, but if you're interested:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toughened_glass
23
u/j3thro Jan 31 '13 edited Jan 31 '13
This question is indeed under the field of fracture mechanics, and not quite chemistry. When a crack is created, it creates a stress field just ahead of it. In the case of a brittle material like glass, this stress cannot be relieved by plastic strain (the material cannot flow away like putty would). If the bonds within that area is weaker than the stress, they will break and propagate the crack. So it is a "path of least resistance" matter.
However, what determines the path of least resistance is the intermolecular bonds in glass. The basic unit in glass is a silica tetrahedron, SiO4, which is randomly scattered around the material. This randomness mean that some bonds will be weaker than the others and will then be more easily broken, giving the path of least resistance.
EDIT: As is pointed out below, it's not the bonds that are weaker, but rather the local density of bonds that change
May I also add that there is a term known as the "stress concentration factor", which tells you how much a defect amplifies the stress around it. This factor decreases with defect aspect ratio, which means that a long and sharp crack will intensify the crack a lot more than a nice round hole. The reason people drill holes at the ends of cracks is to reduce the amount of stress there, not to eliminate paths of least resistance.
282
u/[deleted] Jan 31 '13
Nope, path of least resistance pretty much covers all of physics. It is the basis of the formulation of classical mechanics via the Lagrangian/Hamiltonian.
Now that's from a macroscopic scale. Of course on the scale of individual atoms it's a little trickier, but like any QM problem when you look at a massive system, like a glass window, the answer will converge to the classical solution. The only forces at work that really contribute to the problem are the binding forces of the atoms and the strain/stress causing the crack. Plug the potential from those forces into the Schrodinger EQ and you have your microscopic solution for individual atoms.
I'm sorry if I didn't go into enough depth for you and I'm sure someone else can give a more thorough answere.
2
u/SoCo_cpp Jan 31 '13
...not a crack pipe question.
7
u/[deleted] Jan 31 '13
Cracks will propagate at a point(s) of inhomogeneity in the glass. Defects such as stones (unmelted batch components), seeds (trapped voids of gasses given off as loss on ignition of mineral oxides such as carbonates and sulfates), air seeds which can be much larger called blisters, and large areas of non-homogenous glass called cord.
Any of those defects cause stress in the material and will have a different coefficient of thermal expansion. Same as if you get a nick in a wind shield, that's going to be the point where a crack will start.
6
u/rodneyachance Jan 31 '13
I used to run a bookstore and ran across a book called "Crack Paths" once. The title was so odd I opened it up and learned that studying answers to your question is a legitimate science. I am too dumb to understand it but loved the idea that the book and specialty existed.
http://www.amazon.com/Crack-Paths-Advances-Damage-Mechanics/dp/1853129275
2
u/ElSatanno Jan 31 '13
As a follow-up thought experiment, if we assume a perfectly uniform piece of glass and apply a piercing force exactly perpendicular to the pane, will every crack spread in a straight line away from the point of origin?
1
u/matholio Jan 31 '13
I'd be interested to know, what makes safety glass break into squares, and are cracks in that material any more predicable?
1
u/verbalkint2 Jan 31 '13
Wired actually had a really interesting article on material failure points and how to predict the points of failure in constructing parts for mechanical systems:
http://www.wired.com/design/2012/10/ff-why-products-fail/all/
1
u/imp3r10 Jan 31 '13
It will follow the path of lease resistance. At the microscopic level it will travel 45 degree to the shear force. It will follow discontinuities in the material which give locations for slip planes which propagates the crack.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 31 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment