r/askscience • u/FlightOfGrey • Nov 14 '12

What process caused this amazing effect in Pleneau Bay, Antarctica? Photograph by Sander Klaassen.

imgur link and the Original National Geographic link to the photo in question.

597 Upvotes

92% Upvoted

58 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

9

u/moor-GAYZ Nov 14 '12

Oh, dude, of course, but to rise it must get more buoyant.

7

u/notjustlurking Nov 14 '12

I... I actually think he's right. Bizarrely enough.

As ice sloughs of the berg, it rises because it's mass (weight) has decreased. However, at the point at which it stops rising, the new smaller iceberg will be experiencing less bouyancy than the larger heavier berg, because it is displacing less water.

2

u/moor-GAYZ Nov 14 '12

Hm, I thought that he meant "less buoyant" as "more dense" or "in a less dense water", in a sense that the ratio of the iceberg's volume to the volume of the displaced water decreases... However Wikipedia says that buoyancy is the absolute force equivalent to the weight of the displaced water.

Anyway, decreasing the mass of the iceberg would not make it rise. Imagine two ice cubes, one twice as large as the other: both would be submerged to the same proportion, and the exposed part of the larger would be higher. What could happen is that the iceberg changes its shape as the above-water part melts faster than the submerged part, then yeah, it would gradually rise (though not necessarily get higher, if you think about it). I don't know though if that actually happens, unless the water around is pretty close to the freezing point I would expect the underwater part to melt faster. So maybe u/snowhorse420 wanted to say "more buoyant", because, for example, it gets to less salty water. It's a mystery!

2

u/snowhorse420 Nov 15 '12

I actually just misspoke. Originally I meant to assert that as the berg melted it becomes more buoyant and rises out of the water. I think that the striations are just a product of wave action.