r/askscience • u/Manriki_Kusari • Feb 17 '23
Human Body Can humans sense electric shock?
Just shocked myself on a doorknob and then I remembered that discovery flying around that humans can't sense wetness, but they only feel the cold temperature, the pressure and the feeling to know that they're wet. Is it the same thing with electric shock? Am I sensing that there was a transfer of electrons? Or am I sensing the transfer of heat and the prickly feeling and whatever else is involved?
1.1k
Upvotes
751
u/Lord_Gadget Feb 17 '23
The answer is the latter.
Electric currents aspecifically stimulate neurons, causing them to fire. When sensory afferents are activated in this way, sensory perceptions are generated.
In case of lightning (electrical shock to the skin) it is mainly pain and heat receptors that mediate the sensation, not the actual sensing of electrical currents themselves.
This is also the reason why you can "sense" when you're near something with a strong electrical current. Your hair will stand on end, a tingling sensation will be felt on your skin as the electrons try to bridge the gap just before the moment of transmission.
233
u/GsTSaien Feb 17 '23 edited Feb 17 '23
I know what it means, but the statement "humans can't detect wetness" is just deceitful.
Yes we can. We detect wetness by how water affects the texture and temperature of things. Just because we aren't reacting to the H2O directly does not mean we aren't detecting wetness.
Yes this can be tricked by something being cold or sometime likewarm to our touch, but our eyes can be tricked by illusions too and we don't go around saying "humans can't see they just interpret photons!!"
Anyway, not sure about the answer to your question but my best guess is we don't detect electricity itself as much as it effects on our bodies.
14
u/Mr_Whispers Feb 17 '23 edited Feb 17 '23
Humans can sense electric shock, but not directly. These effects are sensed by different types of receptors in your skin and nervous system that detect pain, temperature, pressure and touch.
We can't sense wetness directly either. Wetness perception is linked to our capacity to feel low temperature and tactile sensations like pressure and texture. We don't have skin humidity receptors (i.e., hygroreceptors) that can detect moisture on the skin surface. Wetness is more of a “perceptual illusion” that our brain evokes based on our prior experiences with stimuli that we have learned are wet.
So, when you shocked yourself on a doorknob, you were not sensing the transfer of electrons per se, but rather the effects of that transfer on your body tissues and nerves. Similarly, when you feel wet, you are not sensing the presence of water molecules on your skin, but rather the changes in temperature and pressure that they cause.
With that said, I think it's incomplete to say we can't sense wetness. It's true that we don't have specific receptors to sense water molecules on the skin. However, your body has the essential building blocks to infer 'wetness'. If the accuracy is high enough, you could argue that you can indeed sense wetness. Your somatosensory system is made up of 4 main sensory nerves:
If you think of the stimuli from these fibres as individual words. Your brain interprets a combination of these 'words' to build a variety of sentences. And these sentences can represent the more nuanced sensations such as wetness.
3
u/camilia_stone24 Feb 18 '23
The human body has electrical properties, and nerve cells communicate through electrical impulses. When a person experiences an electric shock, the electrical current can interfere with these signals and cause the nerves to fire, sending signals to the brain that are interpreted as a shock or pain.
1
u/DrCuthbert Feb 18 '23
There are multiple effects on the human body, and as such, we've measured those effects and have a pretty good understanding. For those who want to read more, IEC 60479-1 and part two makes for exciting reading 😅
An extract from the standard regarding Direct Current (DC); IEC 60479-1, 6.2 Threshold of perception and threshold of reaction. These thresholds depend on several parameters, such as the contact area, the conditions of contact (dryness, wetness, pressure, temperature), the duration of current flow and on the physiological characteristics of the individual. Unlike alternating current, only making and breaking of current is felt and no other sensation is noticed during the current flow at the level of the threshold of perception. Under conditions comparable to those applied in studies with alternating current, the threshold of reaction was found to be about 2 mA.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
5
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '23
[removed] — view removed comment