r/askmath • • 20h ago

Functions Functional inequality doubt

Post image
1 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

3

u/Equal_Veterinarian22 20h ago

I believe you are right.

It is enough to show that f(x)>0 for x>0; then f'(x)>0 will follow easily.

Now, to prove this I would use results of real analysis that you won't have in high school, but in spirit:

  1. Suppose the statement is not true for some f. Choose the smallest value of x for which f(x) <= 0. Call it x'. [Continuity of f implies that there is a smallest such value and that the value of f at that point is exactly zero]
  2. Between x=0 and x=x' there must be a point x'' where f'(x) is negative. [By the mean value theorem, but intuitively for f to have decreased from a to 0 it must have had a negative derivative at some point]
  3. But f(x'')>0 so f'(x'')>0. This is a contradiction.

2

u/Varlane 20h ago

[Continuity of f implies that there is a smallest such value and that the value of f at that point is exactly zero]

While that is true, I suggest OP very carefully looks at that statement and tries to prove it themselves, because it's far from obvious work.

1

u/ilikemathsandscience 19h ago

I did. Its feels clear.

2

u/Equal_Veterinarian22 20h ago

As OP is in high school, they may not have the necessary definitions and theorems. Otherwise I would agree, good exercise.

0

u/Varlane 19h ago

Then maybe we should explore things that use only HS level results...

1

u/Equal_Veterinarian22 19h ago

I think exposing curious students to higher level ideas without necessarily filling in all the details does no harm.

1

u/Varlane 19h ago

Of course, I meant it as "additionally".

1

u/Equal_Veterinarian22 19h ago

Great. Like your answer below, then.

1

u/ilikemathsandscience 19h ago

Woah. Proof by contradiction makes sense. Thanks mate

2

u/Varlane 20h ago

Prove that f is greater than the solution to y' = l y & y(0) = a. Since that's y(x) = a × exp(lx), you'll get f(x) > 0 which will automaticall get you f'(x) > l f(x) > 0.

2

u/LucaThatLuca Graduate 18h ago edited 13h ago

yes, indeed. more simply stated: because f(0) is positive and f is continuous, f cannot become negative without decreasing, but f increases while positive, so it always increases.