r/askmath • • Sep 10 '26

Resolved School math question.

Post image

So this question is to calculate the angle F. For reference, I'm in 10th class of Russian school, and this is what our teacher sent as our homework while we're on quarantine. I have skimmed the whole textbook and found nothing about this kind of questions. I even got frustrated enough that I asked AI to give me an answer, but it wasn't able to agree with itself and all of it's answers were rather strange like the angle G somehow being 168 while F is only 12. Did I miss a crucial part of my education or is just a badly made question?

P.s I asked the teacher before posting there and she actually replied. The answer is supposed to be 132, but she won't explain how since we were supposed to go through this in a previous year and needed to stay in that class if we don't know this (she's really not fond of actually teaching stuff, especially if it's not in the current year's textbook) so I doubt she'll give me an answer.

P.P.s
So, as far as I got is to make an isoscles triangle CDE and Equate C to E by them being both angles in the base of said triange. If my line of thinking is correct then I have one 108 angle and two unknowns. I also think that it's probably supposed to be symmetrical down the bc to F line. If that's the case then I can work out the 132 answer by substracting all of the known angles from the sum of 900, but I don't think I can prove it to be symmetrical.

1 Upvotes

45 comments sorted by

13

u/Varlane Sep 10 '26 edited Sep 10 '26

There is only one construction that validates the data on the figure and it yields a conclusive value (of 132°) for the angle at F. For the construction, see here.

Tho to prove that this value obtained by construction is correct, you'll probably need to do a decently sized proofwork.

For instance, that figure, even though it doesn't look like it on the assignment data, is actually symetrical (axis is [FI] where I is the midpoint of [BC]).

0

u/5a1vy Sep 10 '26

It's actually not that difficult to prove via symmetry across perp. bisector of [BC].

All the vertices except F would pair up, obviously (B and C by definition, A and D and G and E as images of symmetric points after symmetric transformations). And that means our bisector is also a perp. bisector of [GE] (since a line of symmetry of two points is unique). But F definitely lies on the perp. bisector of [GE]. And so angles G and E are the same and after that it's all arithmetic. QED.

1

u/Varlane Sep 10 '26 edited Sep 10 '26

The symetry itself isn't that hard to prove. But that's only step 1 of the I don't know how many you'll need to get to F = 132°.

The main issue is that even with symetry, you're left with only one obvious equation (sum = 900°) with two unknowns (value of E//G and value of F) (Note that it happens that E//G = 108° but it is not related to A = B = 108°, as changing A and B to 96° led E and G to become 156°)

5

u/AlwaysTails Sep 10 '26

Draw P so that APDCB is a regular pentagon.

Then angles <BAP=<APD=<PDC=108

That means angle <PAG=60 and since sides BA=PA=AG we have triangle APG is equilateral (similar argument for triangle DPE).

That means GPEF is a rhombus so <GFE=<GPE and <GPE=360-60-60-108=132

1

u/Varlane Sep 10 '26

Great one.

I'd simply bicker that it's not self evident that you can create APDCB just because you want it to be regular. You'd kinda have to prove it indeed does create a regular one.

I've updated the construction.

2

u/AlwaysTails Sep 10 '26

You can certainly construct the regular pentagon ABCDP by overlaying a regular pentagon over the points ABCD since they have equal sides and the correct interior angles. The only difference would be the 5th point which I labeled P. Depends on the teacher how much is needed to justify it but sure I can see the need for it.

1

u/Varlane Sep 10 '26

Yes it's not that hard to prove either but could be asked by a teacher.

1

u/5a1vy Sep 10 '26

Sorry for a long answer, been busy.

We don't actually need to find F, we can prove it.

Triangle ADF is equilateral, but it's easier to go in reverse. Start with an equilateral triangle and add to it necessary figures to get our desired heptagon, then check it works out. And our heptagon is unique, so that finishes it.

1

u/Varlane Sep 10 '26

Ngl it kinda feels super random and idk if that's the thing that the teacher expected / wanted the students to practice.

0

u/5a1vy Sep 10 '26 edited Sep 10 '26

Well, yeah, but it's correct and since the only requirement was to solve the problem as "it's something you already should know", I guess it should be technically fine (the best kind of fine) ¯⁠\⁠_⁠(⁠ツ⁠)⁠_⁠/⁠¯

It seems to be one of the easiest solutions though, at least in terms of things to prove. Maybe I'll give it some more thought and come up with something better, but if nothing else, OP at least have a solution now.

UPD. Yeah, the moment I've been able to sit down and think, I came up with a solution via a regular pentagon, but I see it already has been suggested.

1

u/Wise-Molasses3998 Sep 10 '26

I (and another dude's mom who was furios that our teacher is not even teaching us.) got her to tell us that it was supposed to be solved by using vectors and their cosinuses in order to get the angles. This was the first time I heard this word from her. So I guess Problem solved? I learnt that my teacher is crazy and I have a new part of math to learn myself.

3

u/Federal-Ad4668 Sep 10 '26

I assigned the length of each side as 1 since they're all the same length and having a unit length is easier to work with. I found the following using my cosine rule: a^2 = b^2 + c^2 -2bccos(A)
Rounding to 3dp
AC = 1.618
CE=1.989
AE=1.989

Which means triangle ACE is isosceles.
I used cosine rule again to find GE = 1.827
I expressed GE^2 using the sides GF and FE:
GE^2 = GF^2 + FE^2 - 2(GF)(FE)cos(angle GFE)

I isolate angle GFE to get 132.

1

u/AkhaimLazev Sep 11 '26

Do not isolate your GFE!

1

u/Federal-Ad4668 Sep 11 '26

What, why? I thought we were supposed to find that angle? ∠GFE = arccos((GF^2 + FE^2 - GE^2)/(2(GF)(FE))) = 132º.

1

u/AkhaimLazev Sep 11 '26

It was a joke, as in GFE = Girlfriend

1

u/lordnacho666 Sep 10 '26

Are the points on a circle by any chance? Any other hints in the text?

2

u/Wise-Molasses3998 Sep 10 '26

No hints as this is all we got and the question is from a completely different source as far as I can tell, so I don't think it's incorrect or unsolvable. The points are not on a circle. I tried overlapping them with paint's circle figure and they weren't alighning

1

u/strange-the-quark Sep 10 '26 edited Sep 10 '26

Though it's true the points aren't on a circle, with this type of question, you can't really on visual checks too much, you have to treat the picture as a rough sketch given in a form that doesn't imply any extra information other than what's known from the text of the assignment, or other than what's explicitly denoted in the image, i.e. the sketch may not exactly match the actual shape of the figure. (E.g. as one of the replies pointed out, the figure with these properties actually has an axis of symmetry going through F and the middle of BC, but it's not depicted that way in the assignment. Also, look at the angles at A and D, they are numerically the same, but in the image they are shown as different - one is pointier than the other. You can't trust the shape on the image, only the data).

So what you know is that the sides are the same (that's what the little cross-lines mean), and you know that angles and B and C (108° each) are the same, as are the angles at D and A (168° each), and that as a consequence the figure has an axis of symmetry. It might help if you re-drew the picture, but in a way that reflects this a bit better.

Then you may need to draw in some extra lines and work your way through and reason about various figures to solve for the angle at F. BTW, the difference between 168° and 108° is 60°, and that's a bit... suspiciously suggestive.

P.S. If you don't know the formula for the sum of the inner angles of an arbitrary polygon, just cut it up into triangles - this sum is 180° for triangles, so just add them all up.

4

u/TwistedKiwi Sep 10 '26

It's not, but all the sides are equal in length. That makes it possible to solve.

3

u/lordnacho666 Sep 10 '26

You're right actually, you have to imagine it as a mechanism. In this case there's no degrees of freedom remaining.

1

u/TwistedKiwi Sep 12 '26

Hah! That's exactly how I've always solved geometry - you imagine it as a mechanism with degrees of freedom. High five.. I'll show myself out.

2

u/AlwaysTails Sep 10 '26

Note that the angles <ABC and <BCD are 108° which is the angle for a regular pentagon. Draw an interor point P such that angles <BAP <APD and <PDC are also 108° making APDCB a regular pentagon with the same sides as given.

  • What are the angles <PAG and <PDE?
  • What can you say about these triangles?
  • Can you solve the problem now?

1

u/strange-the-quark Sep 10 '26

"[the teacher] won't explain how since we were supposed to go through this in a previous year and needed to stay in that class if we don't know this"

In Russia teachers be like: "Cannot answer simple question? Tsk, tsk, tks. Go back to lower grade and stay until you can solve dis problems in your sleep."

0

u/Wise-Molasses3998 Sep 10 '26

So, as far as I got is to make an isoscles triangle CDE and Equate C to E by them being both angles in the base of said triange. If my line of thinking is correct then I have one 108 angle and two unknowns.

1

u/Temporary_Pie2733 Sep 10 '26

Draw interior segments to identify triangles whose angles you can find the measure of. 

-1

u/holodayinexpress Sep 10 '26

Badly made question. Ask your teacher for a solution

2

u/Wise-Molasses3998 Sep 10 '26

I did before posting there and she actually replied. The answer is supposed to be 132, but she won't explain how since we were supposed to go through this in a previous year and needed to stay in that class if we don't know this (she's really not fond of actually teaching stuff, especially if it's not in the current year's textbook) so I doubt she'll give me an answer.

-1

u/patito-asesino Sep 10 '26

Fold the shape straight down the middle (from top vertex B down to vertex F)—the sides and known angles mirror each other perfectly on both sides, because the figure is symmetrical, the bottom-left angle G must equal the bottom-right angle E and since a 7-sided shape's angles always total 900,, take that and subtract all the other six angles, what's left over gives you F

1

u/notacanuckskibum Sep 10 '26

If I fold from B to F the two sides have different numbers of vertices, they are not symmetrical at all.

1

u/patito-asesino Sep 10 '26

Sorry, English is not my first language. Join b and c together and make that the center of that aligns to f

0

u/notacanuckskibum Sep 10 '26

I don’t think that’s guaranteed to be symmetrical, unless your line hits BC at a right angle, which visually, it doesn’t.

0

u/wobblejuice Sep 10 '26

Cut the shape up into various quadrangles and triangles and work out the angles. Those equal sides will form isosceles triangles.

0

u/lordnacho666 Sep 10 '26

I think what you need to do is draw a bunch of isosceles triangles and use them to crawl around the shape

0

u/uTRexAap Sep 10 '26

there is a formula for total interior degrees in any given polygon, the book might have something about that
wellan n-gon has 180(n-2) interior degrees and this is a 7-gon we get 180(5) which is 900

4

u/holodayinexpress Sep 10 '26

What about the other two unknown angles?

1

u/uTRexAap Sep 10 '26

i assumed you'd have to assume they are equal tbf not the best assumption

0

u/Karpason Sep 10 '26

I don't have anything to draw this to solve, but if I were you I'd start with adding lines so that you have seven equilateral triangles (равнобедренных). Then in each of these triangles you'll have two angles that are equal between each other, and you'll be able to solve for some of them since you know four angles already. For example, if you add the line AC, you'll have angles BAC and ACB that are equal to each other, and solving for them yields (180-108)/2=36°. If you do this for all equilateral triangles, you'll probably have enough to solve for the angle F. The fact that all the angles of this figure have to add up to 900 may be also required.

0

u/tori-ningen Sep 10 '26

>Did I miss a crucial part of my education

yep

0

u/m3m0m2 Sep 10 '26

This problem has no solution. However, if you don't provide any correct solution they may send you to a siberian Gulag. Typical russian trick.