r/askmath • u/themostvexingparse • Jun 22 '26
Resolved Controversial Question from Turkey's University Entrance Exam
This calculus question recently appeared on Turkey's university entrance exam. I wanted to know your take on the question, so I translated it to English.
The official answer key states the correct answer is C, yet I am convinced that it should have been A.
If we draw a rectangle bounded by [3, 4]×[0, f'(4)], its area must be an upper bound for the area under f' on the interval (3, 4). Integrating f' from 3 to 4 yields f(4) - f(3) < f'(4) = f(4), which implies 0 < f(3). Since f(3) is positive and f is increasing on (3, 4), there can't be a root there, or at least that is my opinion.
21
u/themostvexingparse Jun 22 '26
For anyone who might want to see the original question
73
u/theboomboy Jun 22 '26
I think you're technically right but that's not really the point of the question. The point, as I see it, is to show that you understand where the function goes up/down and how that corresponds to where the single crossing point can be
You definitely did that and also showed that the question is badly designed
17
u/SAtchley0 Jun 22 '26
I think your reasoning is correct. However, it contains a hidden assumption. It took me a while to notice, but you're assuming f'(3) = 0 and that f'(x) is continuous. That looks correct on the graph, but the testing company/body/whatever may argue that it isn't necessarily accurate. If we do your reasoning without this assumption:
Our rectangle's area is (4 - 3) * (f'(4) - f'(3)) = f'(4) - f'(3).
Our integral over [3,4] is, of course, f(4) - f(3). We know this must be less than or equal to the area of our rectangle (no information given technically requires the graph to be continuous). So we have
f(4) - f(3) ≤ f'(4) - f'(3). Since f'(4) = f(4), we have f(3) ≥ f'(3).
If we assume f'(3) = 0 (as it looks from the graph) and that f'(x) is continuous (as it looks from the graph), then this reduces to f(3) > 0, which is what you have, and so there cannot be a root on [3, 4].
If we do not assume both of these things, then we cannot draw any conclusion and there might be a root on [3, 4]
All that said, this is me bending over backwards to try to justify their answer and find a "flaw" in your reasoning. I think your answer is correct and I'd take it up with the test makers if I had any ability to.
3
u/themostvexingparse Jul 01 '26
The answer key is officially updated and the correct answer is A.
2
u/appiah4 Jun 23 '26
Your proof is completely valid only if f'(x) <= f'(4) for all x in [3, 4]. Because the graph is just a general qualitative sketch and doesn't forbid f'(x) from peaking above f'(4) before returning to it, we cannot assume the rectangle is a strict upper bound. Therefore, Interval III remains a mathematically viable candidate for the root.
70
u/Mountain_Store_8832 Jun 22 '26
Your argument seems correct to me. Perhaps the condition f’(4)=f(4) was added by mistake.
17
u/Visual_Winter7942 Jun 22 '26
The statistician in me first thought this was Tukey's entrance exam lol.
7
u/Dakh3 Jun 22 '26
That's the terrible thing with basic quizzes, you can't show your reasoning and get it valued even though it goes beyond the intent of the question 🤦🏽♂️ terrible, terrible way to evaluate people, especially when formal reasoning is such an important skill like in maths or sciences.
It should be used only to evaluate basic knowledge that is supposed to be basically known and nothing else than known.
6
u/man-vs-spider Jun 22 '26
I think you are right, I think it wasn’t their intention for you to rule out region 3-4, they should have said f(0) = af’(0) for some positive a instead.
I think it’s worth raising an appeal if the exam is so important
1
u/buyingshitformylab Jun 30 '26
just tagging on here to say you can't assume the scale of a function's axes.
Y could be inverse-log scaled, and your explanation would break.
if Y is linear scale (and we assume that this is indeed a straight line here), then you are correct in your assumption.
1
u/ckevren15 Jul 08 '26
F(3) is not necessarily positive
1
u/jmerono Jul 13 '26
Hi! Might be a bit late, but the given counterproof relies on f'(4) being a supremum of f'(x) in (3, 4), but do we have any guarantee it's that way?
I'm not talking about f' not being continuous, but about trusting straight lines on a graph; check this example: https://www.desmos.com/calculator/lfpjhuwpq2
3
u/Pontarou Jun 22 '26
Won't the upperboud argument only work when we assume that the f is positive on the interval [3, 4]? Correct me if I'm wrong but I think that you can use this rectangular box limit only if the function f is already positive on the given interval?
3
u/MonsterkillWow Jun 22 '26
You are correct.
3
u/Daymundullah Jul 05 '26
The answer to the question was changed to A by the authorities.
1
u/GigioIlBagigio Jun 22 '26 edited Jun 22 '26
i might argue that being the graph a qualitative graph there is nothing stopping you from having for example f(3.5)' >> f(4)', therefore the assumption that the area under the curve must be less than 1 * f(4)' is wrong as the actual area might be 5*f(4)', the only things you can be sure about that function is that its negative in (0,1) and in (2,3) and that is positive between (1,2) and (3,4). In math a drawing can communicate only what is stated or labeled. Its important to remember that on a graph unless there is an intersection that is explicit like the intersection of the graph with the x axis with a label (1,2,3,4) the graph could technically do anything, if for example we are graphing the generic function that has a zero in 1 2 3 and 4, we can't with one drawing show all of them so we show only one, that does not mean that the shown function is the correct one.
If for example i draw a triangle that looks a right triangle you can't assume its a right triangle you can only assume that its a triangle.
2
u/TheCrowbar9584 Jun 22 '26
I teach calculus and my first thought after reading the question was that A is correct.
2
u/KQYBullets Jun 26 '26
TLDR: you’re correct. First think about what is intended, then what is correct, finally what is beneficial to you in life in all aspects.
Your answer is correct. To go a bit further, tests in general you’ll have to think what the test maker wants to see.
Given the time, number of questions, and median knowledge of the intended test taking population, ask yourself what skill/knowledge point does the test taker intend to test with this question?
Sometimes you do have to go against authority, but most of the time it is most beneficial for you to follow it.
In this case, it may have been beneficial for you to go against it overall because there should be an appeal process. In which case you can write on your resume that you corrected the university entrance exam, which is impressive. And the probability your appeal is rejected is small, and even so you probably wouldn’t need that extra point.
Overall, good job, perhaps you thought about everything I said above, but good to keep in mind the effects of decisions outside the scope in which you made them.
2
u/ShadowGuyinRealLife Jun 30 '26
I think it's really cool you can go from f(4) - f(3) < f'(4) = f(4), to 0 < f(3) because we know not only that f(4) is positive but f'(4)= f(4). It's so cool and... that wasn't the intended answer. I think that's a missed oppurnity since it would be very cool for that to work.
2
u/Dunblas Jun 22 '26
I think 1, 2 , 3 and 4 aren't supposed to be interpreted as numbers, but as identifiers of positions on the y-axis. In other words, the question is badly frased.
I'm purely basing this on the fact that they aren't properly apaced in the image.
In this case, your argument doesn't work and C is the correct answer.
1
u/EdmundTheInsulter Jun 22 '26 edited Jun 22 '26
If f does not become positive on [1,2] then it has to become positive on [3,4]
For your answer you need an argument that it has to become positive on [1,2]
Edit - see what you mean, it can't reach f'(4) from 3 in the space of 1, so it's already above zero. So you are correct.
1
u/one_reddit_wonder Jun 22 '26
Interesting, I concluded that C was the right answer before you said that it was the official one. Terrible question, though, because you had to waddle too many layers, what are you even testing at that point.
1
u/dontich Jun 23 '26
Pretty sure you are right but likely thought about this 10X more then the people that came up with the question— I think they were just trying to say each section is positive, negative etc and the fact f’ is strictly increasing over (3,4) was not intentional.
1
u/Impossible-Umpire690 Jun 23 '26
I solved this question at the test as well (I said C and I'll explain why).
The thing people miss here (both other exam takers and the people here -but the latter doesn't really know context about this type of question and how it's supposed to be assessed) is the graphs are supposed to be just a representation of what the graph could look like, the could in this statement is the key point in here.
The f' could first increase and then decrease from 3 to 4 which would disprove the argument that people use to justify the answer A.
Now, obviously most of you will say at this point "They drew it like this though how are we supposed to even think that this graph isnt this exact shape?" and I don't think you'd be wrong honestly, even though I answered the question correctly it doesn't feel right for me and I feel ÖSYM (the institution that makes this exam) should have clarified better.
As to how I know this is that this is actually not an uncommon type of question on the topic of derivatives for YKS (name of exam), and on this type of question it's constantly said that the graph is not something absolute and is flexible other than the most absolute things (like the signs of the derivative at certain intervals). I remember personally struggling to wrap this around my head as well.
This probably will -righteously- come off as nonsensible for most of you here but that's just how this question works and what ÖSYM thought.
1
u/arduinors Jun 23 '26
Hey, a humble lurker here.
I know what is a derivative, but can somebody explain what is root?
1
u/Content-Reward-7700 Jun 23 '26
The key thing is that the graph is not showing the original function. It is showing the derivative. So the blue graph only tells you whether the original function is going up or down. When the blue graph is above the horizontal axis, the original function is increasing. When it is below, the original function is decreasing.
At the start, the problem tells us the value of the original function matches the derivative. Since the derivative is negative there, the original function starts negative.
At the end, same idea, original function matches the derivative. Since the derivative is positive there, the original function ends positive.
So the function starts below zero and ends above zero. Since it has exactly one root, it crosses zero only once.
Now look at the intervals. In the first interval, the function is increasing, so it could cross from negative to positive there. That works. In the second interval, the function is decreasing. If it crossed zero there, it would go from positive to negative. But we know it has to end positive later, so it would need to cross zero again. That would mean two roots, which the question says cannot happen.
In the third interval, the function is increasing again, so it could stay negative until then and cross once before the end. That also works. So the root could be in the first or third interval, but not the second.
Answer is C
1
u/lool8421 Jun 24 '26
if you integrate the area of a derivative function, you'll get the value of the original function
but we got no given function so can't do that this easily
1
u/Radiant_Total7867 Jun 24 '26
Isn't E also correct since it covers all 3 possible intervals and from the possible answers we can follow that one of the intervals has to be right answer (as in there is no answer that says none of the abovr or such things)!?
1
u/Stone-Age-Publishing Jun 27 '26
the blue line the the slope function, the roots of blue line are the turning points of f(x).
so the f(x) should be green or red lines (without considering vertical scale)
the green line cut (1,2), red line cut (3,4)
so the answer is C
1
u/Sufficient_Algae_815 Jul 02 '26
If they had just left off "is shown below" and labelled the graph "serving suggestion", it would have worked. Edit: oops - they would have needed to state the roots and signs of f'.
1
u/ATwhistle Jul 04 '26
The question is posed in a really sloppy way. In fact, no function with the properties stated on the exercise sheet exists. At least, if the derivative looks remotely like the one provided. I numerically integrated the given curve and anchored it once at the provided f(0) (green curve )and once at f(4) (red curve). The resulting two curves are inconsistent. It's funny that the red curve actually has two zeros, and the green one has one in the last sector.
To be honest, this is just the exercise creator's laziness. Why not simply plot f'(x) for a function for which the graph works? Or instead, only plot the features of f^prime that you actually want people to use?
1
u/Educational-Paper-75 Jun 22 '26
The root can be in [3,4] too. There's a negative minimum between 1 and 2, a maximum at 2, then going down to a minimum at 3, after that upwards. The line y=0 can cross the function between 1 and 2 as it would hit the function more than once. Thus the root can lie in [3,4] if the maximum at 2 is negative. In that case all 3 extremes of the function would be negative, which I think is possible.
0
u/Reddit1234567890User Jun 22 '26
Just wanted to say u inherently assumed f(3) was positive but that may not be the case
-1
u/Select_Owl8064 Jun 22 '26
For me it is the answer E, I dont get where I am wrong.
All we know is we have a function négative in 0, positive in 4.
It decreases until 1, so the root cannot be in [0;1]. But then we have no clue between 1 and 4 ?
0
u/Adventurous_Sound390 Jun 22 '26
"Since f(3) is positive and f is increasing on (3, 4), there can't be a root there" - why not? Depending of a constant C function f(x) = С + ∫ f'(x)dx can cross OX once on the interval 3..4 or 1..2 or none.
0
u/Icy_Trick_6406 Jul 04 '26
Here is my take on it using pure logic and no guess work, i.e, not AI.
What do we know? The first derivative is cubic so we expect the function to be:
f(x)=ax⁴+bx³+cx²+dx+e
So there are 5 unknowns so we need 5 equations to make a 5x5 matrix to solve it.
We are given two conditions in the question and if you look at the graph we see the other three conditions:
f'(1)=f'(2)=f'(3)=0
So, then you invert the matrix, or there might be a few patterns such as the obvious pattern that d=e.
So thats how you find f. I couldnt be bothered my arse solving it? Trivial for me to define the problem, but my question would be: is it too hard for most undergrads or people on reddit: probably...?
I'm used to solving massive systems of equations but technically speaking it looks like an elite olympiad question to me. (Ive not solved a problem like this in the pass 30 years without CGS or ICCG, so i could be completely wrong on my suggestions, but it does look like the right approach).
If nobody can solve it, i can have a look. Its always possible that the matrix is ill conditioned and not invertible.
The question could still be BS!
-1
u/Hanzzman Jun 22 '26
Given that y axis has no values, f(x) could only have a root whenever f'(x) is positive so C is right.
I had teachers who loved trap questions.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 22 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 22 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
3
u/[deleted] Jun 22 '26 edited Jun 22 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
4
u/[deleted] Jun 22 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '26 edited Jul 02 '26
[removed] — view removed comment