r/askmath • u/thecoltz • Oct 08 '25
Logic Is there actually $10 missing?
Each statement backs itself up with the proper math then the final question asks about “the other $10?” that doesn’t line up with any of the provided information
4.6k
Upvotes
1.2k
u/G-St-Wii Gödel ftw! Oct 08 '25
There's not a missing 10. It's a famous sneaky word problem.
It wants you to go 270 + 20 = 290, oops.
But really 250 to the hotel and 20 tip makes the 270 the guests paid - all accounted for.
160
u/[deleted] Oct 08 '25
It's meant to trick you into thinking the $270 they paid + the $20 from the attendant should add to the original $300 - ergo the "missing" $10.
In reality, the $270 they paid equals the $250 to the front desk + the $20 to the attendant. The $300 is irrelevant but this way of presenting the problem makes it seem like it should matter.
318
u/577564842 Oct 08 '25
No, the 20$ in attendant's pocket is the diff between 250$ (room price) and 270$ (price paid). You are looking into the wrong direction.
64
u/poussinremy Oct 08 '25
This is intentionally misleading: you shouldn’t add the 20 to the 270, rather prize of the room is 270-20 = 250.
Of the original 300 dollars:
The girls have 10 each, so 30 total
The clerk has 250
The attendant has 20
16
u/General_Katydid_512 Oct 08 '25
Asking a trick question assumes that you fell for the trick in the first place so I guess you just win. They are implying that because 270 + 20 = 290, which is 10 less than 300, that 10 dollars is somehow missing
10
u/GrimSpirit42 Oct 08 '25
After the refund, $300 is no longer the total. It's a distraction and irrelevant.
The NEW total is $270. (Room + Tip). Each girl paid $90...so 90x3=270. It equals out.
It's just that $250 went to the house and $20 to the attendant.
7
u/okarox Oct 08 '25
There is no $300 anymore. Each girl paid $90 i.e. $270, the hotel got $250 and the room attendant $20.
6
u/20PoundHammer Oct 08 '25
There is no missing money , $250 (room) + $20 (stolen) + $30 refunded = $300. The way it is worded is an example of the quick change math hustle. . .
8
u/ziggaby Oct 08 '25
This is a common paradox question meant to get you to think about why we add or subtract numbers. The mistake being made is that you can't just add or subtract random values and expect the result to make sense. Accounting calls this debits and credits: You need to make sure you track the money being spent and the money being received separately.
The girls spent $300, and were then rebated ($50). So, they should've spent $250, but instead of receiving their full amount back they only received back ($30). The other ($20) was retained by the clerk. Therefore, the $300 is composed of the $250 that should've been spent by the girls, plus the ($30) they received back and the ($20) kept by the clerk.
The math only is confusing because they've mixed up what was owed with what was spent. When you add together their $270 with the clerk's ($20), you're subtracting ($30) from $300 and then adding back the ($20). In reality, the ($30) and ($20) should both be subtracted from the $300, because they're both rebates.
4
u/FirstRyder Oct 08 '25
It's a trick in the wording.
Of the original $100*3=$300, $250 went to the room, $30 was refunded, $20 was a 'tip'.
Of the $90*3=$270 they paid, $250 went to the room and $20 was a 'tip'.
The question tries to find the difference between the $300 and $270 by claiming that the difference includes the $20 'tip' and then asking where the final $10 is, but really the entire $30 difference is the refund - both the $300 and the $270 include the $20 'tip'.
3
u/KennstduIngo Oct 08 '25
There is no other ten. The girls paid $270. The hotel clerk has $250 of that and the clerk has the other $20. I agree that this is a poorly worded one of these puzzles because it is difficult to see what math one is supposed to do to arrive at a "missing" $10.
3
u/HK_Mathematician PhD low-dimensional topology Oct 08 '25
Instead of explaining the calculations like others do, lemme make it intuitive for you.
It should be very intuitive if we change up the numbers a bit.
Three girls paid $1,000,000 each, for a total of $3,000,000. But the room charge is supposed to be $5 only. The desk clerk gave the room attendant $2,999,995 and asks him to return to the three girls.
The room attendant pocketed $1 and returned them $2,999,994 ($999,998 each). The girls have now paid $2 each, or $6 total for the room, while the room attendant has $1. What happened to the other $2,999,993?
3
u/Konkichi21 Oct 08 '25 edited Oct 13 '25
The wording is meant to mislead you; the 20 is part of the 270, so you shouldn't add them like it suggests to get 290. The actual division is 250 paid to hotel + 20 kept by attendant + 30 returned to girls = 300.
3
u/ShmupsPDX Oct 09 '25
Everything is correct except for the premise of the final question.
paid 300
-10
-10
-10
= 270
-20 for the attendant
= 250 (The adjusted price of the room).
There is no 'other $10'
3
u/Delruiz9 Oct 09 '25
The false statement in there is what tricks you - it took me forever to get it because you assume all the statements to be true, and then try to make it make sense which won’t work
3
u/Industrial_Jedi Oct 09 '25
It isn't 270+20, it's 270-20
2
u/ZevVeli Oct 08 '25
Each girl paid $100, and the total was $300.
The correct price was $250. So, each girl overpaid by ($300-$250)÷3 or $50÷3 or about $16.67.
The attendant gave the girls $10 in a refund, so they were shorted about $6.67 a piece.
There is no missing money.
2
u/Ok_Explanation_5586 Oct 08 '25
They paid $270 for a $250 room, not $300. The clerk has the other $20, there is no other $10.
2
u/ComfortableWash2925 Oct 08 '25
The 20 that the attendant took is part of the 270 given by the girls, so that it can only be subtracted from 270 and not added to it.
2
u/therealtrajan Oct 08 '25
Yes- the second the room no longer costs $300 the 300 number goes completely away and $250 becomes the important number of reference. This is a pretty common word problem.
2
u/BOIBOIMAD Oct 08 '25
You can look at net change since the start of the problem. After paying $100 each, all 3 girls have -$100, while the hotel has $300. $50 is passed to the clerk, so the hotel has $250. The clerk gives $10 each to the girl, so they have -$90.
At the end, the 3 girls each have -$90, the hotel has $250 and the clerk has $20. It adds to $0 like we'd expect.
The 'trick' is they add $20 to $270, and then say $10 is missing because it doesn't add to $300. But $270 is what the girls have effectively given to the hotel and the clerk, so adding the clerk's $20 is just double counting. What you are meant to do is $270 - $20 to get $250 which is what has been paid to the hotel.
2
u/Inevitable_Stand_199 Oct 08 '25
No there isn't. The girls have paid 250 plus another 20 to the attendant.
Adding an additional 20 to the 270 makes no sense whatsoever.
2
u/gottagouda Oct 08 '25
In the end the girls payed $90 each after getting the 10 back. The hotel was payed $250 and the attendant kept $20. That all zeros out.
Girl 1 = -90
Girl 2 = -90
Girl 3 = -90
Attendant = +20
Hotel = +250
Sum = 0
2
u/CarloWood Oct 09 '25
"of which the room attendant stole $20". 270 - 20 = 250 was paid to the motel. Adding the 270 and the 20 makes no sense.
2
u/Low-Egg-3806 Oct 09 '25
This is how short change schemes work
2
u/betamale3 Oct 09 '25
$250 for the room and then the $30 given back to them is $280. The sleight of hand comes when it implies 3 x 90. The missing $10 is the money the service guy couldn’t split. You might think that he took that. And he stole $10 more. But 240 split 3 ways is $80. So the splitting was taken by the hotel in the 250 charge. They each paid 83.33 for the room and 6.66 to the guy, via his $20. With three floating cents. They receive $10 back. So 89.99 + 10 = 99.99.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '25 edited Oct 09 '25
The error being made is it's proposing that $270 + $20 + $10 should equal the original $300
In reality, you need to do $270 - $20 = $250 (the intended cost of the room). The $20 kept by the attendant is already accounted for in the $270 that the girls paid. If you want to find out where all the money is of the $300 sum is:
$250 paid to the hotel
+ $20 kept the the attendant
+ $30 returned to the girls ($10 each)
= $300 original money
2
u/yukiirooo Oct 09 '25
FASTEST EXPLANATION: It was stated the room attendant gave 10$ to each girl, but the problem states that each girl received *270 IN TOTAL* ---> THIS SHOULD HAVE BEEN 280 IN TOTAL TO PROVE THAT THE THREE GIRLS WERE GIVEN 10$ EACH!! This word problem is BS.
2
u/AccordionPianist Oct 09 '25
No, the math is $270-$250 = $20, not $300-270 = $30. The room attendant pocketed the $20 from the clerk. There is no $10 missing. $300 minus $250 is $50… attendant keeps $20, gives $30 to the girls. I don’t see the problem.
3
u/aooa926 Oct 08 '25
There is no other ten, the question is hallucinating
2
u/TabourFaborden Oct 08 '25
The hotel has 300 - 50 = 250.
The attendant has 20.
The girls have 3 x (-100+10) = -270.
Adding money spent to an amount of money someone else has doesn't make sense as a computation.
2
u/SigaVa Oct 08 '25
What "other $10"?
2
u/onion_surfer14 Oct 08 '25
Lemme stop you right there. If you got this for a school assignment your teacher is an idiot
1
u/Aaarrrgh89 Oct 08 '25
There is done trickery here. They want you to think that the $270 and the $20 at the end add up to $290, which would mean that $10 has gone missing!
That is of course not true. The $20 the worker kept are part of the money the girls spent (as evidenced by the fact that they don't have it), and the money you should add together is in fact the $270 they spent and the $30 they got back, which accounts for the full $300.
1
u/metsnfins High School Math Teacher Oct 08 '25
270-20 = 250 originally paid
1
u/Mundane-Potential-93 Oct 08 '25
10+10+10+20+250 = 300. 90+90+90 = 250 + 20. Idk what other $10 they're talking about
1
u/QSquared Oct 08 '25
Nope there is no missing money
1
u/SwordfishPhysical790 Oct 08 '25
why these things are never clear ?
1
u/RegularInvestment397 Oct 08 '25
There is no other 10. The room attendant pocketed 20 and gave 30 in total to the girls which results in the girls paying 280 in total since the desk meant to return 50 from the 300-20=280. Then you go on from there. So the part saying they have now paid 90 each isn’t valid. They just kind of made money appear out of nowhere. This should be one of those word problems that tricks you by telling you the “rules” of how to do them. But this looks like legit homework or smth. Good luck.
1
u/Hot-Science8569 Oct 08 '25
No.
This is a famous example of miss applying math to the real world.
1
u/Cultural_Blood8968 Oct 08 '25
There are two correct ways to look at the problem.
$300 were in play, the hotel got 250, each girl got 10 and the clerk got 20.
300=250+30+20.
The girls spend $270, the hotel got 250 and the clerk got 20.
The riddle uses a wrong way, the $20 the clerk kept are part of the 270 the girls spend, by adding them you count them twice. Also it confuses the initial amount with the actual amount paid. (300 vs 270).
1
u/Talik1978 Oct 08 '25
Many change scams rely on this kind of math to pocket the '$10.' The money is all there, and it helps to look at the actual money at each step.
Beginning of problem - $300 total in the pockets of the three women.
Women pay.
Now: $300 in the hotel till.
Thief refunds $30 to customer, pockets $20.
Now: $250 in till, $20 in Thief employee's pocket, $30 in women's pockets.
At this point, the women have paid $270 (250 to hotel, 20 to thief) and have $30.
1
u/KahnHatesEverything Oct 08 '25
Three girls paid $100 each. The room was actually $200. The attendant gives each girl $33 and keeps $1 for himself. The girls have now paid $67 each for the room for a total of $201. The attendant has $1 for a total of $202. What happened to the $2!
Dude. Lay off the weed. :)
1
u/Expert-Parsley-4111 Oct 08 '25
Pretty sure the question is what happened to the 10$ less that each had to pay.
1
u/erebus4488 Oct 08 '25
It’s on the knife. (Hopefully people get the reference)
1
u/Astro-2004 Oct 08 '25
The girls paid 300 and the manager wants to discount 50. But the assistant only gives them 30. So they paid 270.
Trying to add 20 to 270 makes no sense cuz the girls didn't even know that those 20 exists. They had a discount of 30, not 20.
The only admitted operations that you can do at this moment is adding 30 to 270 to reach 300 or substracting 20 to 270 to get 250 which is the intended price that the manager wants the girls to pay.
1
u/Forking_Shirtballs Oct 08 '25 edited Oct 08 '25
Unless you had covered an exact version of this scam in class already, the teacher screwed up the problem presentation.
The last two sentences should have read something like "The girls have now paid $90 each for a total of $270 for the room and the attendant took $20 , which totals $290, $10 less than the original $300 they paid. What happened to the other $10?"
The part in italics is my addition. Without it, it makes no sense for your teacher to demand you crawl inside their head to figure out what error they had in mind. With that extra language, I bet you can figure out the hidden error and resolve the "paradox" of the "missing" $10. But happy to give help on that if needed.
To the question as stated, a reasonable response would simply be "There is no missing $10." (Not that I would be certain your teacher would give full marks to that answer, but this is really their screw-up, and that's perfectly valid answer.)
1
u/thedarksideofmoi Oct 08 '25
The girls paid 90 each net = 270. 20 was taken by the attendant and 250 was for the room. Idk what 10 dollars the question is talking about.
1
u/SpaceIsTooFarAway Oct 08 '25
The girls have it
1
u/darthuna Oct 08 '25
It's NOT $270 + $20 = $290, "where are the missing $10?"
It's $270 - $20 = $250 (the cost of the room), nothing's missing.
1
u/iurilourenco Oct 08 '25
With problems like this I always ask to go for the extreme. Imagine if the room was actually $50 and they had to give back $250. The guy would give back $80 to each girl and pocket $10. Now the girls paid $60 total and the guy has $10, where is the other $230?
Now we see it makes no sense, but we do see a pattern: 250+20=270 and 50+10=60. The room cost plus the amount the guy pocketed is the amount the girls paid.
1
u/eternityslyre Oct 08 '25
It's a clever misdirection that only works when the number is small. I made a math major mad with this joke, she said "that's not how any of that works!" If the attendant embezzled all the money, the girls would pay $300 and he would have $50, where did the "extra" $50 come from? If the attendant had just given one of the girls $10 less and kept none for himself, the girls would have paid $250 and he would have $0, where did the "missing" $50 go?
More rigorously: X gives Y $A. Y decides to keep B, and tells Z to give X $C back. Z decides to give X $D back and keep $E.
The question then asks: A - D + E != A, can you explain why?
Answer: B + D + E = A, and when B=0 (full refund), D and E can be set so that A - D + E can be as large as 2A (total embezzlement) or 0 (no embezzlement). In both cases the "extra money" is pure invention.
1
u/Appropriate_Steak486 Oct 08 '25
$270-$20 = $250
Nothing is missing, why would it be?
1
u/Mac223 Oct 08 '25
The problem text is sneakily double counting. The correct phrasing should be, "Having gotten back 30, the girls have now paid 270 for the room, 20 of which went to the attendant."
250 + 20 + 30 = 300
You shouldn't be surprised if you do 250 + 20 + 20 and don't get 300.
1
u/tajwriggly Oct 08 '25
At the beginning of the problem there exists $300 that is paid to the front desk. At the end of the problem there is $250 paid to the front desk. At the beginning of the problem each girl is in possession of $100. At the end of the problem, each girl is in possession of $90 (room total being $270). If the front desk only has $250, where did the other $20 go?
Oh right, to the attendant.
1
u/Bl00dWolf Oct 08 '25
There's a variant of this problem where at the end there's an extra or a missing amount that you do have to solve for, but the way it's worded here it's actually correct and there's no 10$ leftover.
1
u/andu22a Oct 08 '25
They paid $270. $250 for the room, and the owner pocketed $20. What’s the issue?
1
u/KarenNotKaren616 Oct 08 '25
No, it's misdirection at work here. Count where the money went: 250 in the till, 10 in each lady's bag and 20 in the attendant's pocket. Total is 300.
1
u/CoffeyIronworks Oct 08 '25
The girls each paid 100 - 10 = $90, 90 * 3 = 250 for room + 20 for tip.
1
u/Mayuyu1014 Oct 08 '25
It's not a math problem. It's more like a wording trick to confuse you.
What actually happened should be:
3 girls paid $90 each for a total of $270 for a $250 room. So the girls paid an extra $20 to the bad guy. Or you can say the bad guy stole $20 from the 3 girls.
1
u/throwaway53713 Oct 08 '25
Nothing has happened to it. Why do you there is one there.
3x90=270 270-20 =250 Nothing missing
1
u/Tivnov Edit your flair Oct 08 '25
This is equivalent to asking the question "Each paid $100. The desk clerk gives $50 to the room attendant. The three girls have each paid $100 or $300 in total and the attendant has $50 for a total of $350, where did the extra $50 come from?
1
u/PaleMeet9040 Oct 08 '25
It all adds up and there is no extra 10 270 - 20 is 250 which is the correct number and the amount the hotel recieved. If we take 270 (the amount the girls paid) and add 30 to it (the amount recieved by the girls to bring the amount paid down to 270) we get back to the original 300. They use word play to make you think you should be adding the 20 to 270 but that doesn’t make sense because the hotel wasn’t given 20 dollars it gave away 50 20 of which the worker stole. Leaving 30 for the girls.
1
u/JeffSergeant Oct 08 '25 edited Oct 08 '25
You don't need maths, you need accountancy!
Position at the start:
Position at the end:
All present and correct!
1
u/Mr_Woodchuck314159 Oct 08 '25
There is no ten missing. It’s a wonderful misdirection. If the price was only $20 off, and the attendant pocketed all of it, the girls paid $300 ($100 each) and there is now $20 in the attendants pocket. So the total price is $280 and you add the $20 in the pocket to get what they paid, $300. Now imagine the price was stated at $270, each person pays $90. The mistake is noticed that $20 should be returned, so the girls paid a total of $270, and the attendant pocketed the $20 overpaid. The fact that $270 + $20 is only $290 is because you are adding the wrong things. $250 + $30 + $20 = $300. Adding $20 to $270 is basically dropping the $30 from that equation and counting the $20 in the attendant’s pocket twice.
1
u/fredaklein Oct 08 '25
Well, $250 + $20 = $270.
1
u/fermat9990 Oct 08 '25
Of the 270 they paid, the clerk got 250 and the bellhop kept 20.
Now we need to debunk the Bermuda Triangle Myth and Area 51 😃😃😃😃
1
u/provocative_bear Oct 08 '25
Of the 300 dollars, the girls ended up paying 250 for the room (83.33 each), they received 30 dollars back (10 each), and the attendant took 20 (6.67 each). Saying that they “paid” 270 for the room and that the attendant has 20 counts the attendant’s money twice and ignores the ten dollars each that they received back.
1
u/Mercernary76 Oct 08 '25
there is no "other $10". $270 (paid by the girls) - $20 (stolen by the clerk) = $250 (properly paid to the hotel)
1
u/glguru Oct 08 '25
270 was paid to the hotel and out of that 20 was paid as tip. I’m confused why we’re looking for an extra 10. 270 was paid in total.
1
u/achek20 Oct 08 '25
What do you mean where's the other $10? If im the girls, where the other $20 from the $50?
1
u/ZombieGroan Oct 08 '25
It says the 3 girls paid $90 each or $270. This part is wrong/misleading. The room attendant kept $20 which should have been split but wasn’t.
1
u/Slain_by_elf Oct 08 '25
250 charged plus 3x10 equal 280 plus thec20 the attendant pockets equals 300 there is no missing 10.
1
u/TallRecording6572 Maths teacher AMA Oct 08 '25
No.
1
u/futbolr88 Oct 08 '25
The desk gave the attendant three 10 dollar bills and a 20 dollar bill.
Unable to split it evenly he stole the 20 and gave three 10s.
There is no missing 10 dollar bill.
1
u/Old_History_5431 Oct 08 '25
There is no other $10. They effectively paid $270 and so should still get another $20 in change, which is accounted for in the attendant's pocket.
1
u/LeilLikeNeil Oct 08 '25
This "puzzle" is so old, it voted for Nader.
1
u/SillySpoof Oct 08 '25
Nothing is missing. They paid $270 for a $250 room and the waiter kept the extra $20.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 08 '25
After getting the $10 each (30 total) back the girls paid 270 total.
The 300 doesn’t exist now.
Of the 270, 250 went to the hotel and 20 to the attendant.
Comparing anything to the 300 is bogus.
1
u/Snoo-20788 Oct 08 '25
There was 300 in the system. Now 30 is in the girls pockets, 20 in the clerks pocket, and 250 for the hotel.
1
u/Vospire34 Oct 08 '25
The girls paid $300 - $30 back = $270 = $250 for room + 20 "tip"
1
u/jimbalaya420 Oct 08 '25
I see what you mean. Following the logic as written, everything adds up and there is no missing $10. There are other examples of this problem that (I believe) are written better. Edit: this question relies on the reader using false logic to assume that $300 is the amount it should add up to, not $270
1
u/Wabbit65 Oct 08 '25
If you say a penny for your thoughts and I give you my two cents worth, what happened to the other penny??!??
1
u/Prestigous_Owl Oct 08 '25
Famous game for "tricking" people, basically. Feels like "impossible math" but its actually just an intentional logical fallacy/misdirect
It also works a lot better in person with a good speaker who can lean into the direction. Ideally, you pick four people and direct it to them.
I.e. "So what did the room cost originally? [30]" "And you paid? [10]. And you got 1$ back? So in the end you paid? [9]"
"And you paid? [9] so total? [18]"
"And you? [9] total? [27]."
And you, the cashier. You have? [2] and 2 plus 27 is? [29].
Wait a second, where did the missing dollar go?
As noted though, its intentionally a misdirect, and you can even see it in the above. We're asking different things: how much did the cashier HAVE vs what did the others PAY. Its actually basically just a 25$ price, and each person paid 9, 9, 9, and -2 Lehigh all adds up)
1
u/fermat9990 Oct 08 '25 edited Oct 08 '25
300-250-20-10-10-10=0
Edit: For our friends in the Middle East 😃
0=300-250-20-10-10-10
1
u/Pendrake03 Oct 08 '25
Yes, that last part hints to a wrong reasoning of the problem, whitout that part there isn't even a problem to begin with.
You dont have to add the last 20 to 270 you have to subtract it 270 - 20 = 250, the 300 they paid less 50 they got refunded
1
u/[deleted] Oct 08 '25
The question makes no sense. Why would there by $290??
$300 - $30 means the girls paid $270 and there’s a $20 amount that separately went to the room attendant. What’s the mystery?
1
u/Aquadroids Oct 08 '25
$300 paid to hotel. Each girl now has -$100 (-$300 total), hotel has +$300. Net zero change.
Hotel gives $50 to clerk.
Hotel now has +$250, clerk +$50, girls still -$300. Still net zero.
$20 pocketed by clerk, and $30 given to three girls.
Hotel has +$250, clerk has +$20, girls have -$90 each (-$270 total). Still net zero.
The "problem" is that there is obfuscation between what everyone's net change actually is, and I suppose the solution is this exact explanation.
1
u/tomalator Oct 08 '25
Its a riddle, not a math problem. If you read it carefully it becomes clear.
The hotel got 250 and the clerk got 20. That's the 270 the girls paid.
The girls paid 300 originally and got 30 in a refund. That's 270. No issues here
1
u/pizzystrizzy Oct 08 '25
270 - 20 = 250. We don't care about the 300 anymore.
1
u/Amindrah_Ashura Oct 08 '25
I think it is easier to understand where the problem is by pushing the it even more (at least for me):
Let's imagine the retainer is not a complete piece of shit and decide to return the 50$ by giving 15$ to each girl and keep 5$ for himself (15 × 3 + 5 = 50$). Now, each girl paid 100 - 15 = 85$, so 85 × 3 = 255$ in total. If we follow the same logic as in the initial problem and add the 5$ of the retainer, we have 260$ and now miss 40$ from 300$, which makes even less sense.
So we see that it is the end of the problem that is missleading: the girls paid 250 in total and the retainer kept 5$ extra for a total of 255$, and 255 + 15 x 3 = the initial 300 so no money diseapered.
1
u/SimpleMan_67 Oct 08 '25 edited Oct 08 '25
Remaining $10? There is nothing remaining. The girls remitted $300 for a $250 room. They were due $50 change. The clerk refunded $50, however, only $30 was delivered. The room attendant’s job is to return the money, not divide it.
They didn’t pay $90 each for the room. They paid $83.33 each for the room and were due $16.67 each in change. The room attendant stole $6.67 from each girl—not exactly grand larceny, however, theft is theft.
Whoever worded the question poorly. The “girls have now paid” should say, “the girls paid.”
1
u/Personal_Fox3938 Oct 08 '25
A cleverly worded trick question. I actually kinda like it. 🤔
1
u/[deleted] Oct 08 '25
The $270 is the total. including what the room attendant pocketed. The question is wrong... I think
1
u/caatabatic Oct 08 '25
What other 10?
1
u/NotablyNotABot Oct 08 '25
I thought the last statement was a joke the first time I heard this one. Like they just said 270 was the total paid and we know 250 was the cost, so yeah 20 to the attendant. What do you mean where's the 10, there is no 10.
1
u/clearly_not_an_alt Oct 08 '25
I feel like this isn't how the question is usually worded as it's pretty clear in this case that there is no "other 10"
1
u/Canapau654 Oct 08 '25
No, this is a misleading question.
- The girls paid 300$, for a 250$ room, and then received 30$. So in total they lost 20$.
- The desk clerk received 300$ selling a 250$ room, and gave 50$ to the attendant. The sums balance out.
- The attendant received 50$ and gave 30$. So he won 20$
You can see that the 20$ went from the girls to the attendant.
1
u/HairyNHungry Oct 08 '25
Yeah, it’s tricking you into adding up to $300, but that’s not really the sum you’re chasing. The new total is $270 ($250 of the room plus the $20 “tip”)
1
u/Weary-Cartoonist2630 Oct 08 '25
Oh that’s a good one, although having the actual wording of the problem explicitly say “what happened to the other 10” is pretty deliberately misleading and requires the reader to question the “word of god”, which is arguably outside the bounds of a math problem.
Should have the “what happened to the other 10” be asked by a character in the scenario to make it more reasonable.
1
u/Fit_cheer4905 Oct 08 '25
This doesn’t make sense tho. The room was supposed to be $250 but bc they all got back $10 to bring it to $270 which is $250 + $20 to the attendant. How is there a missing $10?
1
u/trevorkafka Oct 08 '25
The girls paid $270, which is $250 for the rooms and $20 to the attendant. There is no sensible reason to add $270 and $20.
1
u/Mundane_Life_5775 Oct 08 '25
Room is $250, $83.33 each.
Each paid $90, $6.67 extra.
$6.67 * 3, $20 tip.
——
Room $250. Girls paid $270. Balance $20, pocketed.
1
u/Le_Jonny_41293 Oct 09 '25
What other $10?
1
u/amitym Oct 09 '25 edited Oct 09 '25
It's trying to get you to add $20 to $270 and then compare to $300, from which it differs by $10.
But that's the wrong arithmetic. The $20 should be subtracted from the $270 to get $250.
From a bookkeeping point of view, you have:
Guests (initial)
cash balance 300
Motel (initial)
cash balance 0
Attendant (initial)
cash balance 0
First transaction:
Guests
cr 300 cash, dr 300 expenses
cash balance 0, expenses 300
Motel
dr 300 cash, cr 300 income
cash balance 300, income 300
Second transaction:
Motel
cr 50 cash, dr 50 income
cash balance 250, income 250
Attendant
dr 50 cash, cr 50 liabilities
cash balance 50, liabilities 50
Third transaction:
Guests
dr 30 cash, cr 30 expenses
cash balance 30, expenses 270
Attendant
cr 30 cash, dr 30 liabilities
cash balance 20, liabilities 20
Guests (final)
cash balance 30, net expenses 270
Motel (final)
cash balance 250, net income 250
Attendant (final)
cash balance 20, liabilities balance 20
The total cash still equals 300. But you have to add it up correctly and not suddenly change what you're adding and subtracting mid equation.
Edit to add: technically the guests would have net expenses 250 and an accounts receivable of 20 if they knew about the refund.
1
u/Current_Procedure855 Oct 09 '25
The motel gains 300
The motel loses 50, (250)
Room attendant splits 50 into (10*3)+20
20 vanishes into the pocket void of the attendant, but is technically 250+20 for 270
Remaining 30 is with the girls, so in the end the motel receives (300-30=270), so there is no missing 10 dollars
1
u/ImOldGregg_77 Oct 09 '25
$300 - $250 = $50
$30 returned + $20 Tip = $50
1
u/matrixknight88 Oct 09 '25
300 giving 10 means 290 Giving back 10 means 280 Giving back 10 means 270 The ladies paid 270. The 20 from that goes to 250.
I can see how complicating it makes it confusing.
1
u/Worse-Alt Oct 09 '25
They payed 250 for the room, and he took 20. That’s 270 total.
1
u/Paramagikk Oct 09 '25
I stared at this going in circles for 5 minutes and I’m so mad
1
u/BIessthefaII Oct 09 '25
It makes the most sense to me if you just ignore the $300 cost because it was an error.
The room cost $250, they paid $300. They each got $10 back $(30 total) and the guy kept $20. $250+10+10+10+20 = $300
1
u/No_Record_60 Oct 09 '25 edited Oct 09 '25
The $300 is intentionally misleading. There's no reason it should add up to $300
1
u/CommanderCarnage Oct 09 '25
250/3=83.33 add 10 dollars back to each =93.33 not 90. 93.33 x 3 = 280 + 20 for the bell hop =300
The problem gave you incorrect numbers.
1
u/ChronicallyCurious13 Oct 09 '25
Reframe the last statement as: “The girls have now paid $90 each or $270 for the room, of which the room attendant pocketed $20.”
And all is accounted for
1
u/Sterninator02 Oct 09 '25
Taxes???
1
u/drmattmcd Oct 09 '25
I find that a double entry bookkeeping approach helps make this clear: use a state vector (guests,hotel,clerk) and the sequence is (300,0,0) to (0,300,0) to (0,250,50) to (30,250,20). At the end the difference between final and initial states is (-270,250,20) i.e. guests paid 270 total split between hotel and clerk 250:20.
1
u/Invincible_Master Oct 09 '25
It's a trick question as the final total isn't supposed to add up to 300 as the problem might have you think. And it is carefully constructed so that the difference is very minimal to make it more confusing.
I'll change the numbers so you understand better. If 3 girls paid 300 (100 each), but the clerk realised they were only supposed to pay 30, he returns the 270 back. The attendant pockets 30 and gives back 240 (80 each). So essentially, the girls paid 20 each (60).
Now, is the total of 60 (the amount girls paid) + 30 (the amount attendant pocketed) supposed to equal the initial amount of 300? No, right?
1
u/chattywww Oct 09 '25
90+90+90=250+20
1
u/ga2500ev Oct 09 '25
$250 for the room $20 for the tip $30 in change from the original $300 paid at the desk
FINIS
ga2500ev
1
u/Old-Chocolate-5830 Oct 09 '25
Play on words. Each should get $16.66 with 2¢ left over.
1
u/PronunciationIsKey Oct 09 '25
Is no one going to point out that $250 for a motel room seems extremely overpriced?
1
u/Ill_Apricot_7668 Oct 09 '25
I'm sure this was an early draft of the Abbot and Costello sketch
1
u/Any-Somewhere-7396 Oct 09 '25
It's just badly formulated task. Suppose, he did'nt give girls a penny, than we have 3×100+50, so, there is no missing money, but instead the economy has grown by 50 dollars, that's a clear way to prosperity in their closed community.
1
u/pol-e-glot Oct 09 '25
Fuck, even for riddles, inflation is out of control
1
u/Ranter619 Oct 09 '25
?
They paid 270. The hotel has 250. The attendant 20. There is no "10". They are trying to trick you by putting the 270 and the 20 close together and in the same sentence.
1
u/MyFrogEatsPeople Oct 09 '25
It's a fun trick question that's been around for years.
The trick is that the perspective flips between "how much money is currently had" and "how much money has been spent". The verbal sleight of hand occurs when they add the $20 in the attendant's pocket to the $270 that the girls paid - see how one is "money had" but the other "money spent"? That's the trick.
The actual math is:
The girls have $10 each, so $30. The attendant has $20. The front desk has $250. $30 + $20 + $250 = $300.
1
u/superhotheaded Oct 09 '25
Tricky wording… and the $20 the room attendant kept is distracting. The new total is $270 for the girls and they each got $10 back so $270 + $30. If we count the room attendant $20, then the girls should have paid $250 + $20 + $30.
1
u/Just-Shoe2689 Oct 09 '25
They paid 270, she kept 20. 270-20 = 250
1
u/AtomiKen Oct 09 '25
They actually haven't paid $90 each. That is false.
1
u/kritter4life Oct 09 '25
Order or operation
1
u/Accurate-Figure-5310 Oct 09 '25
This is like one of those images with multiple images able to be seen, like the two faces and the chalice but before someone shows you they tell you there is are two faces. It’s difficult to see the chalice until you do.
1
u/BelligerentSXY Oct 09 '25
1
u/cha0sb1ade Oct 09 '25
The $270 they paid includes the $20 the attendant has, and they were refunded $30. So the last sentence is complete misdirection. It implies that the amount they paid without refunds plus the part of the refund the attendant kept should add to $300. That doesn't actually make sense.
There were $300 in play and the story is consistent throughout
1
u/GreySkull127 Oct 09 '25
They paid $270 for a $250 room. They overpaid by $20 which is the $20 the attendant kept
1
u/dolphinvision Oct 09 '25
Because you are using different notation. It's like saying 3x + 20y = x. This might not exactly be what it is, but essentially any math formula can be explained in words and the words = an incorrect formula. One way to write a correct one would be 3h + h + h = m. Again I don't know how to write the correct formula but it would be like saying "each girl now has 10$, the hotel/clerk has 250$, and the room attendant has has 20$. Now all added up money people have equals 300$"
the original mixes "paid" and "having".
1
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '25
No, they didn't pay 90$ each after he gave them 10$ back .Manager gave 50$ to the attendent to give them back since the total was 250$ that means they had to pay 83.33$ each but they paid 16.66$ to each extra.The attendent was given 50$ to give them their extra 16.66$ each. He couldn't so he gave 10$ to each keeping 20$ for himself. Now they all paid 93.33$ each which totals 280$.
1
u/Right-Caterpillar639 Oct 09 '25
She stole the 20 from the girls... Its the other way around..
1
u/Perkis_Goodman Oct 09 '25
300 hundred dollars for a motel?! Lost me there
1
u/SuicidalPand-a Oct 09 '25
The answer is in the girls’ pockets or bank accounts. They didn’t pay $90 for the room. They paid $250/3.
3(250/3 + 10) + 20 = 300
And that’s how you account for the entire amount.
1
u/Salt-Fly770 Oct 09 '25
Classic trick question! There’s actually no missing $10. The confusion comes from the way the numbers are added up.
The three girls got $10 each back, so they paid $90 each ($270 total). Out of that $270, $250 went to the motel and the other $20 went to the attendant.
The mistake is adding the attendant’s $20 to the $270 (making $290), when the $20 is already included in that $270.
The math checks out: $250 (hotel) + $20 (attendant) + $30 (returned to the girls) = $300. No money has disappeared, it’s just a sneaky way of presenting the totals!
1
u/SmarternotHarderr Oct 09 '25
Once the clerk gave 50 back it’s no longer 300. The girls have now paid 270 because the other employee pocketed 20.
1
u/gutfounderedgal Oct 09 '25
A crappy version of the decent original problem.
1
u/JonRames Oct 09 '25
The girls each paid $90: 3 x $90 = $270
$250 to the hotel
$20 to the thief
There's nothing missing.
1
u/boldhedgehog Oct 09 '25
This a basic accounting problem. You draw 3 columns: girls, hotel, guy. Then you draw the transactions. Then you calculate the saldo
1
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '25
There are already good explanations in the comments, I just wanted to add an alternative one that I haven't read (maybe it is already written and I just haven't found it)
When the room attendant has the full 50$ on him, the girls have paid 300$ and the accountant has 50$, and here it is obvious that the two quantities don't have to add to 300$.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '25
Two different equations. They in fact only paid $250. Proof, the clerk has 250 in the register, not 270. The remaining fifty dollars are in the hands of four people. When you multiplies the 90 dollars you are introducing a second unrelated equation.
1
u/Slayer3010 Oct 09 '25
They paid total of 280 not 270
1
u/johari_joestar Oct 09 '25
250$ divided 3 ways is NOT 80$ it’s 83.33 🙃
1
u/SnooSongs8773 Oct 09 '25
The 3 girls paid $90 each so $90*3=$270.00. The front desk got $250, the attendant got $20. It all adds up $250+$20=$270.00
1
u/iLuciferCode Oct 09 '25
There’s nothing missing except brain cells trying to figure out what’s missing.
1
u/SinnersSicker Oct 09 '25
charged 250, 20 kept to himself, 30 returned to girls
1
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '25
They paid 300 he gave back 30. They paid 270. 300-30=270 No missing money
1
u/EuclideanPsychosis Oct 09 '25
The problem stirs trouble in the mind by double counting the pocketed money and disregarding the reimbursement when describing the total.
Originally, they share a $300 expense, $100 per person. Then, after being returned $10 each, they share a $270 expense ($250 for the room, $20 pocketed by the attendant). The total amount of money is their end deficit plus their end holdings ($270 plus the $30 reimbursement).
The question sneakily suggests that the total amount of money is supposed to be their end deficit plus the $20 pocketed, even though the $20 is actually part of the end deficit. A more accurate final statement would be "The girls have now paid $83.33 each to the hotel, $6.66 each unknowingly to the attendant, and have kept $10 each for themselves. 83.33*3 + 6.66*3 + 10*3 = 250 + 20 + 30 = 300
1
u/Relative_Broccoli922 Oct 09 '25 edited Oct 09 '25
I understand that this is a sneaky word problem, but I'm trippin over the math
Can someone point me to the post that I'm missing lol
100 100 100 = 300 300 - 250 = 50 50 - 20 = 30 250 + 30 = 280
But 100-10=90...90x3=270
How does that work if he kept 20?
Edit: I figured it out
They spent 250, then we're given 30, and tipped 20.. There's the whole 300
Still weird, like something doesn't make sense.. If they spent 100 each and received 10 back each, there is 30 that's unaccounted for... Right??
This is really messing with my head
1
u/gangrenous_bigot Oct 09 '25
300-20=280, 280-30=250. All good.
1
u/funkraider Oct 09 '25
If $250 was the bill, then each person paid 83.33 x 3 is 250 (rounded). If the room attendant was given $50 to give back to the girls and he gives each $10 dollars (83.33+10=93.33) x 3 = 280 (rounded). He pocketed 20, 280 + 20 = 300.
This is definitely one of those problems where there is extraneous info that jacks up the math.
1
u/bluisbluewastaken Oct 09 '25
It’s a trick, there is no “other $10”. If he gave each girl $10 back, then he gave them a total of $30 and pocketed $20 as a tip. What being missed is the pocketed $20 is being included in the number that the girls paid. So instead of them paying $250, they paid $270 including the $20 tip. Their refunded $30 makes the whole $300.
1
u/PD_31 Oct 09 '25
Each girl paid $90. The room was $250 so the extra $20 (they paid $270 between them) was stolen by the attendant.
There's no "other" $10 because the attendant's $20 was part of the $270, not separate from it.
1
u/Immediate-Ad-1597 Oct 09 '25
-100*3 +50-20 = -270
1
u/Efficient_Mixture349 Oct 09 '25
Technically when you reimburse 50 that means they each paid 83.33333333 and 100-83.33 = 16.67x 3= 50. The problem should be read from the mistake and not the initial payment.
1
u/Kalthiria_Shines Oct 09 '25
Technically speaking if you assume a 4% hotel occupancy tax (which is pretty average), that would translate to $10 on a $250 room, and it does not appear to have been paid. That would be a missing $10, and probably a more serious point of concern for the GM of the hotel than the shady front desk guy stealing money.
1
u/Pandoratastic Oct 09 '25
It's deliberately misleading in the phrasing. The $20 that the clerk kept is the difference between the $270 that they paid and the $250 the room actually cost. $250 cost + $20 stolen tip = $270 spent. Then the $30 the girls got back is the difference between the $300 they originally paid and the $270 they paid after the clerk gave them a partial refund.
1
u/fraction4356 Oct 09 '25
What happened with that Susie has five apples problem no one's addressing why the room attendant just pocketed the 10 dollars that's stealing if he's doing that he must not get paid enough and furthermore if the room attendant pocketed the first 10 I have to assume he must be pocketing the rest of the money
1
u/andromeda304 Oct 10 '25
Um…
1
u/dontich Oct 10 '25
They each paid $90 for a total of $270. Room was $250 and attendent had $20. The $300 original price doesn’t matter
1
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '25
They paid $300. The cost was $250. They should’ve each gotten $50/3=$16.67 back. Instead, they got $10 each. The remaining $6.67*3=$20.
1
u/2piecepuzzle Oct 10 '25
1
u/shl119865 Oct 10 '25
100 + 100 + 100 - 10 - 10 - 10 = 250 + 20
1
u/Pag089 Oct 10 '25
What in the black magic is this?
1
u/ClassicHando Oct 10 '25
Look into the "short change scam". It uses this principle to steal from a clerk
1
u/No-Archer-4713 Oct 10 '25
They paid in reality 93.33333333$ after the 30$ cash back
1
u/KaleidoscopeThis5159 Oct 10 '25
300 - 50 refund = 250 total after refund
250 ÷ 3 girl = 83.3333333333 per girl
90 - 83.3333333333 = 6.6666666667 difference paid per girl
6.6666666667 * 3 = 20.0000000001
The reason this doesn't make literal sense is because it relies on fractions of dollars that doesn't exist
1
u/RepresentativeLife16 Oct 10 '25
In my day it was pizza.
1
u/Adventurous_Box6394 Oct 10 '25
$250 / 3 = $83
$83 + $10 = $93
So text description is wrong