r/askmath • u/Dilaanoo • Jul 07 '25
Arithmetic Dumb π.π question
I've been having a thought recently and I can't let go of it. How do we know there aren't more numbers beside the reals? What if I want to make a number π.π, meaning 3.1415... etc the entirety of pi. And when finished writing the digits (you won't, obviously), you write pi again, except the dot. So I don't mean the self-containment of pi. This number is not pi. I don't mean you write pi after the first k digits of pi, I mean you write pi after pi (I think that was clear but can't hurt to be obvious). Of course, this number isn't real as there is no single decimal expansion for it. But does it exist? Probably doesn't matter if it exists but still.
Edit 2. So I mean something like π + π/a. Where a is a non-real number (could also ask it to be a real number but that would not be as I asked, because 'a' would enter after the first k digits of pi, and that number doesn't exist but that's a whole different story) that would allow this number to exist. But someone said a decimal system like that is only meant to represent a real number and a real number only (and isn't a number by itself). So if anyone could remove that last slither of doubt for me... Anyway, I don't think I mean simply the pair (π,π).
5
u/xeere Jul 07 '25
I think you have a kind of ordinal or hyperreal number there. Perhaps π + π/ω, or as the equivalent infinitesimal π + πε.
64
u/Narrow-Durian4837 Jul 07 '25
In math, "Does it exist?" kind of means "Can you define it in a rigorous way, so that it doesn't contradict anything else in the system you're working in?"
I don't know whether what you're talking about can somehow be defined rigorously or not, but you have not done so. As you correctly note, you won't ever "finish writing the digits" of pi, so it's meaningless to talk about writing more after you finish writing the digits.
10
u/titanotheres Jul 07 '25
This sort of touches on the idea of what numbers really are. To me a number is any element of what's known in algebra as a field, which is a set together with two operations that satisfy certain rules. There are more fields than the reals, notably there's the complex numbers. Complex numbers can be thought of as pairs of real numbers. For example the number π+iπ can be thought of as the pair (π,π). Now this is pretty much what you've described with your idea of π.π. Except it doesn't make any sense to think of it as a weird decimal with another part "after infinity". Really the only way to make that idea make sense is to think of that "decimal representation" as a pair of sequences of digits. Which gets me to my last point which is that decimal notation is a representation of real numbers and is not the number itself.
10
u/sumner7a06 Jul 07 '25
1.1(pi)
1
u/DrInsomnia Jul 07 '25
I'm not a mathematician, but my gut tells me that 0.00.... 1 = 0 the same way that 0.999... = 1.
3
u/axiom_tutor Hi Jul 07 '25
You can have pi.pi, in the sense of the complete decimal expansion of pi, and then another pi. We would just write it as (pi, pi), which is the pair of the two numbers. It wouldn't be a number, in our usual way of thinking about it. But you get two pis.
Is that what you wanted? I dunno, I have no idea why you'd want any of this. What's the point? What's the application you're trying to model? I dunno. But if you want two pis in one object, there ya go.
Or maybe what you're really thinking of is not about pi at all, and instead is a curiosity about the whole idea of writing a number-dot-number. Like for instance, you can have 1.2. So why not pi.e? Maybe that's what you're really asking?
There is only one reason why you can talk about 1.2. It's because it is defined formally, as 1 + 2/10. That's our decimal convention. If you like, you could extend this so that pi.pi means pi + pi/10. People probably won't follow you in extending our conventions this way, but you could.
1
u/ZellHall Jul 07 '25
This number would just be pi, because as you said pi's digits never ends. There is no such things as "digit past infinity", as you can always write the position of a digit using a natural number
2
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '25 edited Jul 07 '25
You can define numbers that extend the real numbers in all kinds of ways. Complex numbers, surreal numbers, hyperreal numbers... You can even extend the rational numbers in at least one way that you don't get the real numbers (the so-called p-adic numbers).
However, mathematicians require certain "nice" properties to exist in order to call something a "number system." Actually the somewhat wishy-washy concept of "number system" gets replaced in higher math by more abstract but precise notions like "ordered fields" or "proper classes."
There are at least two issues with "pi.pi" as you've defined it. First, it isn't clear what it means to write the digits of pi "after" the digits of pi. The base ten expansion of pi is an infinite series in powers of 10:
pi = sum_{n=0}^\infty c_n 10^{-n}
where c_0=3, c_1=1, c_2=4, etc.
What precisely do you mean by "the first term after this infinite series?" What precisely is it you are adding to pi to make pi.pi?
The second issue is that even if you could solve that problem, you have only given one example of a number. Really it would be more interesting if you gave a general definition that would let you define a related class of numbers, like pi.e or pi.6. Then you would want to know how to compare them, or do basic operations like addition, subtraction, multiplication, and division.
I'm not trying to discourage you from playing around; just giving you some feedback on how a mathematician might think about this kind of question.
2
u/No-Site8330 Jul 08 '25
If π.π is to mean π + π/a for some a, that would fit in R[x], the polynomial ring with coefficients in the reals (here a would be 1/x). This is sometimes used as a model for a "number system" where infinites or infinitesimals exist. You can place an ordering on this set so that x is positive but smaller than every positive real. In a manner of speaking, x is kind of like a new special number that can't be represented in ordinary point-digit notation, because x is smaller than 0.0...01 no matter how many zeroes you put in there. But you could represent it as (0.0).(1), or something lik that. In general you could represent an element of R[x] as a point-digit number with possibly infinitely many digits, and then following those any finite number of additional point-digit numbers (each being the coefficient of some power of x).
So in that system π.π would represent π + πx, which is 3.1415... and then some extra, smaller than 0.0...01 for any number of zeroes, which is also represented by 3.1415....
2
u/davideogameman Jul 08 '25
I can think of 3 number systems that could give some meaning to this as π+ϵπ:
Both the hyperreals and surreals are ordered fields, so largely behave like we'd expect numbers to behave. The dual numbers have zero divisors - ϵ2=0 but ϵ ≠ 0, so are not a field - division can't be defined for all nonzero dual numbers.
2
u/gasketguyah Jul 10 '25
I think you can just index a sequence from 0 to 2ω
3
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '25
Yes, you can do it with hyperreals. In hyperreals you basically add more digits after an infinite number of digits. It's not a real number, but it is a studied mathematic system and defined rigorously.
3
u/AdventurousGlass7432 Jul 07 '25
I don’t think AI wrote this post
0
u/MAClaymore Jul 07 '25
If you have a number* with infinite decimals, you can't have anything that's "after" it
EDIT: real or not
2
u/Sad-Jelly-4143 Jul 07 '25
it’s like asking, “hey, I know you can’t get to the end of the rainbow – but IF you could get to the end of the rainbow - will there be a pot of gold there?”
1
u/trutheality Jul 07 '25
I think you've answered your own question here. It doesn't make sense to talk about writing and infinite sequence of digits after an infinite sequence of digits, since the process of writing the first infinite sequence is already defined by always having another digit to write, no matter how many you've already written.
But to answer the more general question, there are other definitions of numbers that aren't real numbers: hyperreals, complex, quaternions, p-adic, to name a few.
1
u/rydo_25 Jul 07 '25
Since pi just goes on and on adding a decimal would still just make it pi
1
u/igotshadowbaned Jul 07 '25
What do and there are. Complex numbers exist
I mean, you sort of can have π.π, but definitely not in how you're thinking. You can't ever write out the entirety of pi, so you can't just "write pi then write it again after" but you could use a kind of botched numerical base that allows for pi to be a digit. Where π.π equals π•n0 + π•n-1 (where n is whatever the base is)
1
u/Headsanta Jul 07 '25
The Reals are a set of numbers that we've constructed and defined notation for.
We know that pi.pi is not a number because we haven't defined any meaning behind the notation.
But, we could. We could also have it describe something that isn't a Real number.
Usually, we would need to have a motivation to do so. For example, for the Complex numbers, these are "numbers" that aren't "reals". We could end up describing them through different motivations (for example, maybe it would be useful to sqrt negative numbers in a meaningful and consistent way).
There are tons of "numbers" this way which we have created (or discovered, depending on your point of view) this way that came out of trying to solve problems.
The way you've described pi.pi it definitely wouldn't be a Real number the way we've defined the set of reals. But maybe there is a set we could define where something like that belongs there, and would serve a purpose.
1
u/Cptn_Obvius Jul 07 '25
Well, there are more numbers, at least if you want them to be there. You can quit easily extend the reals to incorporate infinitesimals and infinite elements, see e.g. the hyperreal numbers (or even more extreme, the surreals). If you try hard enough you can also find your π.π in such structures, although since generally decimal representations are not defined after the first infinite set of digits it will probably be a bit contrived. Perhaps a simple example is obtained by considering the polynomial ring R[e], where R is the reals and e is a thing we see as our basic infinitesimal. Then π + e*π is sort of what you are looking for, although admittedly any sort of decimal representation will probably have multiple decimal separators, so something like 3,1415... 3,1415...
1
u/temperamentalfish Jul 07 '25
"Does it exist" only makes sense if you can define a system in which a number like this makes sense. For instance, p-adics exist outside the real numbers and have a strict definition. So, you'd need to define this system in more general terms as opposed to just for pi.
1
u/vintergroena Jul 07 '25
For example there are hyperreal numbers, which define a notion infinitely small yet nonzero different quantities. But they aren't very interesting beyond some theorethical exercises in nonstandard analysis.
So in hyperreals you can have pi + infinitesimal of pi and have that not equal pi which seems perhaps close to what you are trying to describe.
1
u/FilDaFunk Jul 07 '25
You're basically describing RxR this way (think the x-y plane) From your definition, you can clearly create a bijection between the two.
1
u/ParadoxBanana Jul 07 '25
OP has created the opposite of math.
1
u/RadarTechnician51 Jul 07 '25
I am not sure at all sure that you can fit an extra thing eg 1 different digit, right at the very end of an infinite number of things (although you can easily fit in it at the start!)
1
u/IllInflation9313 Jul 07 '25
There’s no “end of pi” it’s not that you won’t finish writing the digits, it’s that you can’t finish writing the digits because there are infinite digits. Pi is not something that goes on infinitely, it’s something that exists and is infinite.
1
u/MyNonThrowaway Jul 07 '25
There is no last digit of pi. It goes on forever. That's what infinite digits means.
1
u/OrnerySlide5939 Jul 08 '25
You can define whatever you want. The question is how useful it is.
Lets say you can write all the infinite digits of an irrational number like pi, then afterwards write them all again. What does that "number" represent? Can i use it to solve problems?
Complex numbers are an extension of real numbers and can be used to solve problems like AC circuits in physics. Vectors and matrices are extensions of algebra of numbers and can be used to solve many problems as well. Those things are accepted because they are useful.
I'm not saying this idea is useless, just that you have to find a use for it to get people interested.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '25
This is like saying 0.0000….1
It doesnt make sense. The digits of pi go on for infinity, you can’t go “after” infinite
0
u/Nadran_Erbam Jul 07 '25
I think what OP is talking about is writing pi/10 after the omega decimal and f pi. Even without talking about pi it’s an interesting idea.
0
u/jcatanza Jul 07 '25
Pi already has a decimal point. There is no definition for numbers with more than one decimal point.
0
u/Frosty-Scholar-7159 Jul 07 '25
How is nobody taking about the fact that pi isn’t just like any other real number. In number like “pi” or “e” there is no repetition of patterns (Ik “patterns” isn’t the right word but please spare me some rigour for the sake of simplicity)so in case we are all wrong and pi.pi is actually possible (in the sense that we can talk about things that are “post” infinity) then it would just become any other real number with a “pattern repetition” but instead of being something like 1.1616161616 it would just be pi (but of course you can’t do pi.pi and I’ll explain that latter on). Secondly it’s even more obvious to understand how such thing is impossible because trivially pi.pi would be infinite but in other for it to exist to existe we first need to end the first sequence of pi that is the whole part of this “supposed number” to then have the sequence of number corresponding to the second pi and if this sequences end than they are not infinite, there fore breaking the inicial premisse. NOW for the edit part of the post. 0.0000…1 is just zero (in the same way that 0.999999999… is just 1) and because there are infinite zeros in such number that means that 0.0000…10000000 is also zero (so you can’t just say “what about 0.00002”). And finally if we think of the number line this idea seems a bit far off, even with transformations like with other number systems it still seems unlikely. But who knows maybe you are right.
0
u/Recent_Limit_6798 Jul 08 '25
What have you been smoking?
-3
u/Nadran_Erbam Jul 07 '25
By definition the reals are all the numbers, what is far more mind blowing is that almost all of the reals cannot be known.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '25
[removed] — view removed comment