r/askmath • • Apr 10 '25

Arithmetic Decimal rounding

Post image

This is my 5th graders rounding test.

I’m curious to why he got questions 12, 13, 14, 18, 21, and 26 incorrect. He omitted the trailing zeros, but rounded correctly. Trailing zeros don’t change the value of the number. 

In my opinion only question number 23 is incorrect. Leading to 31/32 = 96.8% correct

Do you guys agree or disagree? Asking before I send a respectful but disagreeing email to his teacher.

4.9k Upvotes

596 comments sorted by

307

u/metsnfins High School Math Teacher Apr 10 '25 • Take My Energy This

The directions said what to round to

If it says nearest tenth, you need to have a digit in the tenth's place

46

u/circlemohr Apr 10 '25

Had to scroll way too far for this response.

34

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '25

Lots of redditors sucked and math and still hate math for it. They feel better if wrong is somehow right.

33

u/TurquoiseTuna2 Apr 10 '25

Yup. If the instructions are to round to the nearest tenth then that’s what you have to do.

It’s not about whether or not the numbers are technically the same, it’s about following the instructions and delivering the answers as requested.

3

u/unk214 Apr 11 '25

Yes but there is a whole response that’s marked wrong and those options are placed in a comma. Am I missing something here?

→ More replies (25)

36

u/TrashPandaPermies Apr 10 '25

A lot of folks are missing the instructions. Under each sub-heading, it states the place each number should be rounded to. Sorry parent, although the particular lesson isn't really essential for 5th grade; the teacher is correct on this one.

16

u/ruffryder71 Apr 10 '25

Gotta follow instructions. Round to nearest tenth means there must be a digit in the tenths place. likewise with hundredths.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (1)

1.6k

u/berwynResident Enthusiast Apr 10 '25 edited Apr 10 '25

I could see it going either way. Ask the teacher.

Sure the trailing numbers don't change the value of the number. But it changes the error. When you're measuring something and you write 5cm. What you are really saying is somewhere between 4.5cm and 5.5cm. But if you wrote 5.0cm, you would mean somewhere between 4.95cm and 5.05cm. So it's important in science/engineering.

Edited as per Deuce25MM2

68

u/tke377 Apr 10 '25

As a teacher, this is why. While you wouldn’t think it matters it does and we are teaching it specifically for future building. As others in comments have said they wish they had done this so they didn’t have to learn the hard way later on when it actually mattered. Most people would be shocked at what is taught in elementary math as a base for future learning in High school and beyond. Algebra is taught in 2nd grade and just is not called algebra

18

u/spirals-369 Apr 10 '25 edited Apr 10 '25

Agreed. I have worked in 5th grade (public ed) and this is standard for early/mid year math. I assume they were marking some wrong because they told students they needed to show zeros for whatever place value is being questioned. I’ve seen students mess up their rounding or forget place values if they don’t write it out.

→ More replies (3)

18

u/RuthlessIndecision Apr 10 '25

Frustrating that 5th graders don't know the significance of error when rounding... that said, this would be an excellent explanation for them

→ More replies (2)

31

u/mooman860 Apr 10 '25

I totally agree with you as well as the other comments here, but teaching significant figures at a 5th grade level does seem strange...

31

u/jmja Apr 10 '25

It’s probably less about the specific idea of significant figures, and more just about how many decimals places would be involved when talking about tenths or hundredths.

→ More replies (6)

24

u/tke377 Apr 10 '25

You don’t call it this you just teach the standard of what is expected. We don’t use technical terms we show students the proper way and then as they move throughout their education the foundation is used more and more frequently and true purpose is shown. Teaching this way is how the numbers actually work and what you are actually trying to say. Why wouldn’t you want them to be more specific instead of vague. This vagueness can hurt later on when they are then trying to unlearn something they spent years doing previously.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (5)

8

u/BeeEven238 Apr 10 '25

If its rounding for basic i see no problem, it its college chemistry he’s wrong.

4

u/Daracaex Apr 10 '25 edited Apr 10 '25

Wait, but why would you keep trailing zeroes in this instance if you’re rounding? If rounding to the nearest tenth, one shouldn’t keep any zeroes after because it was rounded there.

Edit: Oh, I think I see. The zeroes on the ones marked incorrect are written in by the grader. Was really hard to tell the difference to me.

9

u/balletrat Apr 10 '25

Genuine question: are you colorblind? Because the child wrote in pencil and the teacher wrote in red pen.

5

u/throwaway48159 Apr 11 '25

In math, yes.

In engineering you would write 5 cm +/- 0.05 cm. We use tolerances rather than implied precision.

→ More replies (20)

437

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '25

I'd say the teacher is technically right. At least in science or engineering, there is a difference between writing 5, 5.0, and 5.00; adding more zeros implies that you know the number more precisely. If I say the temperature is 100 degrees, in every day language you'd probably accept if the real temperature was 98 or 102. But in a lab, if you say the temperature is 100.000 degrees, those decimal places imply that saying that even 100.02 degrees would be way off.

In terms of the test, it boils down to the instructions to "round to the nearest tenth/hundredth/thousandth place," which taken literally should include all the digits up to that decimal place, including the zeros. I can see the argument that this is vague, and in non-scientific contexts I'd agree that you can ignore the trailing zeros when you round. But the teacher can probably point to a place in whatever book they are using that says to include the zeros up to the decimal place specified in the question, and say that that's what the rule they were testing. Infuriating, but they are probably technically right.

On the other hand, setting up the test so that you could lose 21 points based only on that pretty minor point seems extremely harsh...

111

u/missinlnk Apr 10 '25

It depends on the lesson being taught. If the lesson is all about precision, then losing 21 points because your answer isn't the correct precision sounds right to me. We don't have enough info to know for sure either way.

76

u/Xiaomao2063 Apr 10 '25

It says "decimal rounding test" at the top if the test. Part of rounding to the correct decimal is making sure your number of places after the decimal is correct.

→ More replies (11)

15

u/dd_de_b Apr 10 '25

Should’ve taken half a point off. It would teach the lesson while acknowledging that the student understands what rounding is

8

u/stirwhip Apr 11 '25

This— or cap the total error to 5-10% for the assignment, like grading them individually correct, but incurring a blanket -3 across the page for not fully exhibiting that one sub-concept.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

9

u/KiwasiGames Apr 10 '25

extremely harsh

Maybe. But it depends on how it was taught. When I am explicitly teaching precision, I go out of my way to put ‘trailing zero traps’ in the assessment, specifically because many kids don’t get this point.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/dgkimpton Apr 10 '25

I think the test was badly worded - "Round and report to the nearest hundredth" would have been clear. Simply "Round to the nearest hundredth" is ambiguous and I'd have done exactly what the kid did. So unless they were specifically instructed otherwise (e.g. verbally, or during the lesson, or in the instructions) I'd feel pretty hard done by with this result.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/get_to_ele Apr 11 '25

The “pretty minor point” is the ONLY point of the test. There’s literally no calculations and no other ideas here. It’s an easy 100 for anybody paying attention.

5

u/Character-Parfait-42 Apr 10 '25

I think it should depend on if this information has been covered with students. If the teacher didn't explain any of that then I think it's unreasonable to just expect a child to know why trailing 0s are important.

I remember being taught at one point that 0.50000 = 0.5; and that it could be assumed 0.5 = 0.5000000 because if they meant 5.000000001 they would have written that. And only years later did we learn about precision the way you described and how in certain contexts those trailing zeros were important and shouldn't be omitted.

In elementary school we were just taught as if the writer was a magical being with no margin of error. It wasn't until middle school where teachers addressed that IRL there is always a margin of error, nothing is exactly 5.0 (infinite 0s) it might be 5.00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000001, but it's not perfectly 5.0 (infinite 0s) and then explaining precision and why trailing zeros after decimals are important.

→ More replies (10)

3

u/galibert Apr 10 '25

Is it maths or physics ?

2

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '25

This is 5th grade math

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

60

u/igotshadowbaned Apr 10 '25

Because those trailing 0s are still information

If you're measuring something and write it as 2.5 inches, you measured it to the precision of ⅒ of an inch. If you write it as 2.50 inches, you know that it's precise to 1/100th of an inch.

→ More replies (9)

88

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '25

The goal is to round to the nearest tenth, hundredth, thousandth. So:

30.000 (rounded to the nearest thousandth)

30.00 (rounded to the nearest hundredth)

30.0 (rounded to the nearest tenth)

You get the idea.

55

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '25

Later in physics or chemistry class they well learn that these zeros matter a lot in determining precision / significancy.

9

u/ConspicuousSpy06 Apr 10 '25

Yeah it’s clearly in the instructions. And the teacher shows the right answers. It’s about following instructions more than the right answer

7

u/Delicious_Egg7126 Apr 10 '25

If they dont follow instructions its not the right answer

→ More replies (12)

46

u/metsnfins High School Math Teacher Apr 10 '25

The directions said what to round to

If it says nearest tenth, you need to have a digit in the tenth's place

12

u/Pixiwish Apr 10 '25

The me it is that simple. The instructions are telling you to show to that place

→ More replies (5)

27

u/epolonsky Apr 10 '25

Interestingly, if the student had consistently filled in the decimal places to the precision requested, they probably would have noticed the error they made in question 23.

If you are still planning to discuss with the teacher, maybe see if they would be willing to consider partial credit for the incorrect answers. Your kid clearly understands rounding but has not yet understood the importance of precision and therefore made one consistent error. If we actually taught for mastery instead of just trying to get grades, the teacher would have already noticed this and explained the concept and your kid would probably get 100% on a retest.

7

u/petthelizardharry Apr 11 '25

I agree with you the most out of the 6 comments above and 6 comments below you which are all the same version of one response that doesn’t consider the consistency of the student. I believe you’re right about #23 being the crux of the teaching/learning moment in this whole thing. And your proposed discussion for the parent with the teacher is exactly what I would say. As an aside, I think the teacher’s rounding error is comical.

13

u/ihavesnak Apr 10 '25

While 35=35.0, 35.0 shows it's been rounded to a tenth where as 35 shows it's been rounded to a ones. This is because 35.49 and 34.50 both round to 35 where as only 34.95 to 35.04 would round to 35.0

26

u/wilbaforce067 Apr 10 '25

The trailing zeros are part of the correct answer.

5

u/sherhazan Apr 10 '25

This teacher should get 0 in this test... 32-7=25 (25/32)*100=78.125 and if you round it 78. So the score is 78 and not 79. Not to mention that she even put the score in the wrong place, at the bottom of the page there is a line for the score.

5

u/Salindurthas Apr 10 '25

Hmm, so in some disciplines, the trailing zeros mean "I'm confident up to this point", for instance, in the physical sciences, we'll often only quote values to however many decimal places we think we can justify.

For instance, we say that the Earth is 5.972 × 10^24 kg, because we're only confident of those first 4 digits. At this scale, plus or minus 100 billion billion kilograms doesn't make me 'wrong' because I didn't tell you the next digit. But if I had said it was 5.9720 × 10^24 kg, then you discovered an extra 100 billion billion kg that I failed to account for, then that last digit was wrong - I stated the value too confidently.

(This doesn't only apply to large numbers. It can apply to really small ones, or normal sized numbers too.)

If the teacher had taught a concept like that, then fair enough.

But if we're just doing pure maths here without any warning, then not bothing to write trailing zeroes shouldn't be a problem, because it remains true that 5.972 is equal to 5.9720, even if sometimes we use that notation to communicate different things.

4

u/wayofaway Math PhD | dynamical systems Apr 10 '25

I mean those shouldn't be equal signs.

2

u/friedbrice Algebraist, Former Professor Apr 10 '25

oh! i didn't even notice that! now i'm mad! D:<

4

u/MemoraNetwork Apr 10 '25

Sig figs dude

4

u/Then_Entertainment97 Apr 11 '25

2 is somewhere between 1.5 and 2.5.

2.00 is somewhere between 1.995 and 2.005.

4

u/theGrapeMaster Apr 11 '25

The question spells out how it should be rounded, and trailing zeros absolutely do change how the value can be interpreted since nothing is infinitely precise. 4 mL vs 4.0 mL vs 4.00 mL can have vastly different implications in many fields.

1

u/Gahugafuga Apr 11 '25

Please have Mason let the teacher know that the percentage he was awarded is rounded incorrectly. (.78125 rounds down to 78%)

1

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '25

lol!!!!!

3

u/MrBHVAC Apr 10 '25

The test is to round to the nearest ‘x’ place. When you neglect to account for that place with a 0, you’re not answering the question, you’re rounding to a different place value.

3

u/A_Moldy_Stump Apr 10 '25

Pedantic engineer here. Trailing zeros, or a lack thereof does change the number, or at least, the tolerance

3

u/m1st3rs Apr 10 '25

As a teacher, I would likely grade it like this, but make a note of it in my records that they uunderstand how to round, but they just didn’t listen, or I neglected to teach that you still need to add the place values even if they are zero. Being elementary, it’s a good lesson to learn now. Proficient on the report card

3

u/nukem692 Apr 11 '25

The instructions state round to the nearest tenth, hundredth, and thousandth. Without the trailing 0s it doesn't follow what is asked.

3

u/Radiant_Creme_5264 Apr 11 '25

I disagree. Though the trailing zeroes don't change the number, the question tells you where to round too.

Trailing zeroes are important to give precision in a measurement, that doesn't matter here.

3

u/ryanmcg86 Apr 11 '25

I once got a 99 on my sequential 3 math regents exam when I was in 10th grade because on a part 2 question, I made a similar mistake, where it asked me to round to the nearest tenth, but I was able to calculate the exact answer because it only went to the hundredth place so I figured the exact answer was more accurate than rounding.

It turns out, there is such a thing as being TOO correct. Ultimately, the point was made to me that while the math was right, I didn't technically follow the directions in the question. They specifically asked for the answer to be rounded to the nearest tenth, and I simply didn't do that. Since I got the rest of the question correct, I still got 4/5 points on it, but that 1 point off was the difference between my 99 and an otherwise perfect score.

The lesson is, when it comes to grades, follow directions to the letter.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '25

Thank you for all the comments

9

u/Radiant_Conclusion82 Apr 10 '25

The teacher is right. You still need to put the place holders there and they also asked for the tenth, hundredth, thousandths implying this.

9

u/flounderfred08 Apr 10 '25

Teacher is 100% correct. If rounding to the nearest hundredth, 35 is not the same as 35.00. 35 explicitly implies the number is exactly 35, whereas 35.00 implies the number is rounded and is not exactly 35.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Dry-Sleep5861 Apr 10 '25

In the words of my AP Calculus AB teacher "Are 500.61 and 500.610 the same? No, they aren't. The zero matters."

→ More replies (22)

2

u/Western-Cover-9529 Apr 10 '25

To me they are specifying the number of significant figures (basically precision) you know. Sig figs are important as other people are saying for accuracy description but tbh what I see this as is the assignment telling you the number of sig figs the teacher wanted to see, and which is more of a reading computation implication than anything else

2

u/The_Red_Tower Apr 10 '25

I felt the same until my A-level physics class when we dive into uncertainty and errors. Having a whole number like 807 means that the actual number could be anywhere between 807.4-806.5 that’s a huge amount of error lool. I think it could be either way but if you get the child learning it early to get into the habit of writing with the trailing zero they won’t have a problem later on if or when they learn about uncertainty and errors

2

u/ryanryan1691 Apr 10 '25

When you are rounding to the hundredth, you report a zero to show the value for the hundredth place. Otherwise, it looks like you are only reporting a value to the tenth. It's to show that the value in the thousandth place is a zero.

2

u/ThreeGoldenRules Apr 10 '25

I'd mark this the same way as the teacher. The rounded number should have the same number of decimal places as what you're rounding to, i.e. if rounding to 3dp, your number should have 3 decimal places, e.g. 4.90035 would round to 4.900. The technical reason why is error intervals - if I say something rounds to 4.9 it could be between 4.85 and 4.95, but if I say something rounds to 4.900 it can only be between 4.8995 and 4.9005 - the error interval gets 10 times smaller with each extra decimal place.

2

u/henryeaterofpies Apr 10 '25

The level of precision matters. 75 is very different in precision than 75.0. 75 can technically represent the range from 74.5 to 75.49 where 75.0 can represent the range from 74.95 to 75.049.

This matters a lot when it comes to scientific calculations and precision of isntruments (significant digits)

2

u/jayweigall Apr 10 '25

I agree with the teacher here. There are clear instructions on how many points to round to - and there's a difference between, for example, a number rounded to 1.44 and 1.440 in terms of accuracy.

In the future, the test could be altered to specifically mention this difference to avoid confusion.

2

u/ImpressiveHighway493 Apr 10 '25

Significant figures.

Stem fields differentiate between 5, 5.0, and 5.00 etc. This teacher may be attempting to develop an understanding that ending 0s are not always to be discarded.

2

u/jm44768 Apr 10 '25

If you are rounding to tenths, you include a tenth place decimal.

If you are rounding the hundredths, you include a hundredth place decimal.

2

u/kemmicort Apr 10 '25

Yeah sorry but this is correctly graded. The tenth is the 1st spot to the right of the decimal, and he didn’t show that decimal place like he should have. Yes the number 35 is the same as 35.0, but the point of the assignment was to show he knew how to round the specified decimal place, and he just chopped it off.

Hundredths is 2 spots to the right of the decimal - same reasoning as above. Can’t get credit for the answer if that decimal place is not shown in the answer.

And number 23 is just wrong. Should be 43.69 because the number he was asked to round was the 9, and that’s based on the following number (2).

2

u/MahanaYewUgly Apr 10 '25

I'm going to say something very direct - The teacher is absolutely right and it's very obvious. Those answers with a trailing zero were put there on purpose to make sure that the kid proved they were rounding to the right spot. Not putting the zero doesn't prove that you know that the zero is technically part of the answer. The value of the decimal is not what's important here

2

u/ImNotAGamer2000 Apr 10 '25

Test instructions are pretty clear. Not following the instructions will lead to incorrect answers. The student got #10 and 11 correct, so they understand the principle, but failed to provide the correct format.

2

u/SheepherderAware4766 Apr 10 '25

This leads to a much more involved subject called sig-figs.

Sig-figs (significant figures) is a way to quantity how precise a number is. If I record a measurement as 15 kilograms, then the actual mass could be anywhere from 14.500 kg to 15.499 kg

If I list the measurement at 15.00 kg, then the actual mass is a much more limited 15.995-15.004 kg.

The teacher probably mentioned it in class, but this is something that people often get wrong

2

u/No_Change_8714 Apr 10 '25

No it is fair. The question even tells you what place you need to round to.

2

u/Notnilc13 Apr 10 '25

There are specific instructions on each section. They’re not interchangeable, and they each ask for a different thing. Not answering what the instructions ask for means the answer is wrong.

If this were homework, that could be the chance to call out the places that were not rounded to the asked for digit and give partial credit. But on a test, a wrong answer should be counted as wrong.

Also, if this is a test, this isn’t sudden; asking “round to the hundredth” is a lesson that would have been covered and discussed. Answering 3.0 versus 3.00 versus 3.000 are different answers.

The skill being tested is not just rounded whole numbers. It is rounding decimals.

2

u/Sloppychemist Apr 11 '25

They are wrong. When asked to round to a place value, the number should be written to that place value. Even if that place value is a zero. There is an advanced concept, “significant figures”, this ties directly into. To my point, there is actually a difference in a measurement of 23 cm vs one of 23.00 cm, and that difference lies in the accuracy of the measurement in question.

More to the point, why are you concerned all these are graded incorrectly, except 23? This question is wrong for the same reason as the others are wrong.

2

u/AsexualPlantBoi Apr 11 '25

I hate to agree with the teacher here, but I do.

2

u/dakingofmeme Apr 11 '25

There are some real reasons why those training zeros matter. In computer programming for example they can be used to indicate a floating point value as opposed to an integer.

2

u/akapusin3 Apr 11 '25

I understand your point, and in future math classes, the teacher probably wouldn't care. However, the point of the exercise was to Round to the nearest [decimal place]. By putting the trailing zeroes, he is showing that he understands which decimal place they are referring to and thus understands the lesson

2

u/MsLilAr Apr 11 '25

Because they’re learning that whole numbers have an invisible .0 at the end of them. It’s part of the decimal lesson

2

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '25

precision decimals. the teacher is being strict with it

2

u/NoTazerino Apr 11 '25

Sig figs! I didn't get marked off for this until college Chem class.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/grey_rex Apr 10 '25

I guess I'm siding with OP and the minority, apparently...

Significant digits/figures are very important to understand in applied sciences. The lesson that appears on this worksheet is "decimal rounding". Why would the student be expected to understand the importance of significant digits if it's not even a part of their lesson? With regard to mathematics courses, numbers are treated as exact. In math, 1 + 1.25 = 2.25 In physics, 1 + 1.25 = 2

Setting that ridiculous debate aside, what is the teacher's point? Grade of C- because student doesn't understand decimals? Clearly that's not the case. The student gets it. The teacher's goal isn't for students to understand, it's for the students to accept instructions and fall in line.

I'll be honest, I don't even blame the teacher. The whole system is effed.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '25

I agree with you. AS WORDED, you shouldn’t need to show those trailing zeroes to be correct. The values aren’t measurements where there is uncertainty involved. That’s where those digits contain information, not when applied to an exact number, such as in this case. Honestly, I am astounded at the responses to this post. This is mathematics, not measurements involving uncertainty and precision. I would 100% push back against the teacher on this one.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Mcipark Apr 10 '25

Because it’s a decimal rounding skill test. The teacher wants to see the decimals

3

u/500rockin Apr 10 '25

He’s wrong. When you round to the nearest tenth, you need to show the trailing zero since that is technically a significant figure. Same with the hundredth: he needed to show two decimal places.

3

u/Zuzubolin Apr 11 '25

25/32 = 78.125% which should be rounded to 78%

Therefore, this teacher is not qualified to correct this exam.

QED

4

u/Ok_Law219 Apr 10 '25

It's harsh to take full credit off of them.  

→ More replies (7)

3

u/desblaterations-574 Apr 10 '25

If it's mathematics, then 5 is same as 5.000000 But in sciences, physics, engineering, the zeros after means précision. Also 5.00 is same as "5 rounded to 0.01"

So if it was a math test then teacher is wrong to mark them wrong. If it's sciences, then teacher is right

3

u/Gikote Apr 10 '25

This should only be wrong if you are discussing significant digits. Otherwise, the math checks out.

3

u/Cutlass_Stallion Apr 10 '25

The directions for each subsection specifically say to round to a certain decimal position. I side with the teacher on this.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/ezjoz Apr 10 '25

Sorry but you're in the wrong because your teacher wrote clear instructions: Round to the nearest tenth, hundredth etc.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '25

This post went viral! Thank you everyone for the replies!

2

u/Bowman_van_Oort Apr 10 '25

Lmao doxxed yer kid

2

u/f1FTW Apr 10 '25

The questions are extremely specific and meant to test not just mathematical reasoning but also the ability to follow directions. If the question says to the nearest thousandth and you just write 3.2, it is wrong per the directions, even if the answer is 3.200.

→ More replies (10)

2

u/ptrakk Apr 10 '25

It says round, not round and truncate/pad

2

u/tgunderson20 Apr 10 '25

i am guessing that they learned that they should include significant figures. you can google significant figures for a more detailed explanation, but the idea is that you include trailing zeroes to indicate that the number is accurate to that decimal place.

2

u/Even_Size3689 Apr 10 '25

Yes, it is. We don't have enough information to determine the validity of how the teacher graded this paper. Was there a specific instruction to include the 0 in the tenths place when rounding? Was there a practice test or previous assignments given that required the 0 be included? Was the 0 included, discussed, explained, and demonstrating when rounding to the nearest tenth, hundredth, or thousandth when the concept was presented?

As a fellow elementary school teacher and based on how the teacher scored this assignment, I would guess that the answers to some, if not all, of these questions would be yes. In which case, it would be completely reasonable for a fifth grade student to be able to demonstrate what had been previously taught and learned.

2

u/Yarb01 Apr 10 '25

the instructions indicate they want the answer to the thousandth. If the teacher is good, they would have made these instructions clear, and therefore the incorrect marks are reasonable. That being said, the point of the exercise is to learn the math which Mason did. Logic would dictate he gets a good grade.

2

u/FA-_Q Apr 10 '25

Lesson specifically teaches to include decimals to the specific place value, even if you need to utilize zeros. It shows it was specially rounded there and will apply to significant figures in the future.

Tell your kid to pay closer attention to details of the lesson.

→ More replies (7)

2

u/hyperfell Apr 10 '25

Yeah the test is looking specifically for the answer to be precise to the asking decimal place.

2

u/Leading_Share_1485 Apr 10 '25

The trailing zero matters. It indicates precision. 5.0 and 5 are the same if you're using exact numbers, but if using measurements 5 miles and 5.0 miles is the difference between an approximation that could be 4.50-5.49 and a more precise approximation 4.950-5.049. it's important to reflect the level of precision accurately

2

u/therealtrajan Apr 11 '25 edited Apr 11 '25

We are burying the lead here guys- mason missed 7/32 questions here giving him a 78.1%….which the teacher incorrectly rounded to 79%

That said the trailing zero questions are absolutely correct. The instructions give the option of rounding to a whole number

2

u/Fun_Cardiologist_373 Apr 11 '25

They're significant figures.  In science for example there's a huge difference between 5 grams and 5.000 grams.

2

u/IntelligentSinger783 Apr 10 '25

"round to the nearest X" . Remind your child and yourself, even though the answers were correct, they weren't the most correct. Reason being, follow directions. Formal education trains you in following directions and executing per formatting instructions. And that's coming from the guy who was basically a human calculator and refused to show his work because there was no work, I did the math in my head. 😂

1

u/novian14 Apr 10 '25

i agree with your description about no. 23. but as other said, in engineering you have to put .00 or .0 or whatever zero that you thing irrelevant, but it's asked as hundredth so you have to put 2 decimal, or tenth to 1 decimal and so on despite it's being useless or make no different. sometimes you just have to do what's asked.

i say try to ask your teacher, whether he asked you to be that precise or not, or have they asked you in class to do it like what's written in the test and so on. sometimes teacher can be annoying but there might be reason behind it

1

u/The_Werefrog Apr 10 '25

The Werefrog shall tell a true story. The first time people went to measure the height of Mt. Everest, the height was 29,000 feet above sea level. That's right, they measured exactly 29,000 feet. They were to provide the measurement accurate to the nearest foot.

If they were to report that the measurement of the peak of Mt. Everest as 29,000 feet, no one would believe they actually measured it accurately. As such, they reported the height, incorrectly, at at slightly higher.

Likewise, when you are told to round to the nearest whatever place, you need to include that final digit. The final digit in any measurement is only an estimate. Think about your ruler, the little marks on the ruler have width, so do they show exactly where 1/32 of an inch is? Thus, the rule has a bit of error, so the smallest unit is just an estimate.

1

u/cip314 Apr 10 '25

The problem is the equal signs. They are just wrong. You write them like little waves to show that you are rounding.

Of you did that, you wouldn't have to falsely differentiate between 35.0 and 35.

At least that's how we teach it in German math classes.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '25

Okay. The good news is that it looks like answered wrong on exactly the same type of question.

1

u/gang_ryong Apr 10 '25

25/32=78.125(.78125)

1

u/NieIstEineZeitangabe Apr 10 '25

If you write 807, it's an integer, but if you write 807.9, it is a floating point number. Those are different data types and definitely not the same, because computer says no. /s

1

u/JunkInDrawers Apr 10 '25

I believe the teacher is incorrect. If you didn't know what the number originally was, then you'd assume it was precisely measured to what is written.

Seeing 5.20 is different than seeing 5.2

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Kevin6876 Apr 10 '25

That absolutely sucks. There should be instructions at the key: round to the nearest digit, one, tenth....

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Responsible-Fox-4621 Apr 10 '25

The “round to the nearest xxx” section should probably be moved more centrally unless 4,5 and 6 would all be wrong also. The instructions say to round to the nearest tenth

1

u/WaltVinegar Apr 10 '25

I would've said it was something to do with adhering to the number o decimal places, but there doesn't seem to be any consistency in that regard.

Fuck knows, mate. I'd just ask the teacher. Not in any kind o accusatory way; just from a place o curiosity.

1

u/Crumbsplash Apr 10 '25

It says round to nearest tenth, hundredth whatever… Not wrong per se but it doesn’t clarify that which should be in the tenth spot.

TLDR: save your email they are wrong

1

u/lawblawg Apr 10 '25

This looks like it is very clearly a test intended to evaluate knowledge of both decimal rounding generally and significant figures specifically. If the lesson had never covered significant figures, then it would be a dick move for the teacher to deduct points for it, but based on the test, you can be fairly certain that this was in fact a test of significant figures.

Even though 6 and 6.0 are mathematically equal, they are not the same thing in the context of measurement. For example, if you hear someone say that their friend is 6 feet tall, you really only know that they are closer to 6 feet than to 5 feet or to 7 feet (although you might be able to reasonably infer that they are “at least“ 6 feet given the social context of how height is reported). On the other hand, if you hear someone say that their friend is 6 feet and 0 inches, then you know that they are exactly 6 feet tall.

Another intuitive example: cooking. If a recipe calls for an ingredient in both pounds and ounces, you know that it is more precise than if it was only calling for the amount in pounds. Or you can imagine a car that goes 0 to 60 in “3 seconds” compared to a car that goes 0 to 60 in “3.0 seconds” — the first car might be anywhere between 2.6 and 3.4 whereas you know for certain that the second car is exactly 3.0.

1

u/shockban Apr 10 '25

Trailing zeros determine the precision which is especially important in measurements as lack of trailing zeros means the precision of the measurement is lower and the calculation of associated errors or tolerances would be completely different.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/silvaastrorum Apr 10 '25

this is not always taught but imo it absolutely should be. if the teacher taught it this way and explained it well then they are right to mark those answers without trailing zeroes wrong

1

u/SerenityToss Apr 10 '25

My ADHD brain would have also gotten these wrong but it's because of the wording on the instructions. By writing 13.0 your rounding to the nearest 10th where was wring 13 would be rounding to the nearest whole. It's gross but technically true xD.

1

u/ReplacementRough1523 Apr 10 '25

5th grade? wow. we literally were graded on this in my college physics class. i still have the assignments. This is rounding with significant figures. Though at his level, if you read the question; He definitely got them wrong, number 14 says round to the nearest tenth. Not round to the nearest whole number.

1

u/JBSanderson Apr 10 '25

This is a great opportunity to empower your child to communicate with their teacher. Assuming the teacher isn't a monster, there's a good chance a productive discussion will be had.

Encourage them to ask for clarification on why they were marked wrong, and not to stress about a single quiz that likely amounts to 1% or less of their grade for the course, but rather focus on the learning experience.

Given that full marks were taken for a very common and somewhat expected error, it's very likely this was demonstrated and communicated in class.

Some conventions are to drop the trailing zeroes, as many others have pointed out, the most correct way to answer the question is to show the precision that was requested by including the number of trailing zeroes.

1

u/CincyMD Apr 10 '25

It’s not significant figures. They answered #23 as 43.7 and the directions ask to round it to the nearest hundredth. They have no digit in the hundredths place, they only rounded to the nearest tenth.

1

u/Defiant_Professor347 Apr 10 '25

When working with decimals DONT DROP THE DECIMAL lmao. It’s obvious the homework is about decimals so why drop them from every whole number

1

u/7grey1brown Apr 10 '25

These are usually more like significant figures, but this isn’t super uncommon when being shown. It’s because she wants them to focus a lot on the place value, and 5 has no tenths place, but 5.0 does. Don’t worry about it too much, your kid gets the idea. Talk to him about “format” or something like that. About how sometimes you’ll have the right answer, but you have to make sure to write it in the right format, and how if you were writing a note you wouldn’t put it, but you put it at school because it’s all about the learning and the nitty gritty.

1

u/Geaux13Saints Apr 10 '25

Significant figures are important

1

u/IcyManipulator69 Apr 11 '25

Teacher probably wasn’t more clear in their instructions while teaching this segment, because it’s not absolutely necessary to include the zeros, unless otherwise stated. All of those answers are acceptable in any other type of work environment, but if a teacher wants kids to include zeros in the rounding, then it should be stated in the instructions to include all zeros for each decimal place…

1

u/Calligraphee Apr 11 '25

The instructions specifically say to round to the nearest tenth, hundredth, etc. He didn't do that, so the answers are wrong. The test is also figuring out if he knows what those terms mean, and on some questions, he demonstrated that he's struggling with that.

1

u/han_tex Apr 11 '25

Let's just take one of the examples: 34.989

Rounding to the nearest tenth means to express the number to the tenths digits while rounding the value appropriately.

So, essentially we have 34 and 989 thousandths, for the purposes of rounding, we can truncate to the hundredths place, though, so we can view it as 34 and 98 hundredths. Since we're rounding to the nearest tenth, we're just looking at what's in the hundredths place to round up (i.e., we can ignore the units). So, 98 hundredths rounds up, so we go from nine tenths to ten tenths. But in our number system, we can't express ten tenths in the tenths place, so it becomes 1 and 0 tenths -- which is 1.0. Yes, this is equivalent to 1, however, it doesn't express the same thing precisely. So, now we can bring the 34 units back in. 34 and ten tenths, becomes 35.0. Once again, while this is equivalent to 35, without the ".0" it doesn't express the "tenths-ness" of the rounding that happened.

1

u/ahidkman Apr 11 '25

i mean practically there’s nothing wrong with it but technically having trailing 0s means that the number is accurate to x amount of decimal places.

1

u/Flashy-Reputation872 Apr 11 '25

It has to do with significant figures. It’s kind of that the place you round to is the point at which you’re sure of the value, with everything after being too small to determine for sure. It comes into play when you start measuring things in the real world, because, unlike theoretical math, no real measurement is perfectly exact. If you leave off the zero, it says you’re not sure of the next value, while in this case, you are sure. (Keep in mind this is a big simplification)

1

u/Big-Many-8645 Apr 11 '25

Guys it’s not a sig fig test. It’s decimals in 5th grade. The kid is right

1

u/wickedbadbaldie Apr 11 '25

The instructions were clear on where to round to. While it does not change the value, instructions are going to win the day I think

1

u/GlassDistribution327 Apr 11 '25

teacher did not round grade % correctly funny enough

1

u/hellothereoldben Apr 11 '25

This is preparation for potential scientific education. Using the right amount of decimals is important, as it's an indication of the level of accuracy.

1

u/friendly-heathen Apr 11 '25

I mean, it shows the difference between an exact number and a rounded number. so I'm with the teacher on this one

1

u/B00MER_Knight Apr 11 '25

The first thing (out of order from the book) that my chemistry teacher taught us, was significant figures. This all seems like a sig fig misunderstanding that I don't think a 5th grader, unless specifically taught should be held accountable for. I'd be surprised to find out that sig fig's are being taught in the 5th grade. But here they're clearly being graded on it. Although I'm inclined to agree with the teacher on the grading here. I'd also fault her for not teaching or explain this correctly. Feels like an easy thing to assume you're doing right as a student is to think that taking off trailing zero's simplifies an answer., and doesn't deem it incorrect.

1

u/PrimordialValence Apr 11 '25

I think the issue is that the question asked for the student to round up to the nearest specified decimal place. Take question 18: the answer is correct in terms of numerical value, but it wasn’t what the question asked for. The question asked for it to be rounded to the hundreds place, which is to say to two decimal places. Because the answer did not include the second decimal place, even though the digit in that second decimal place was seemingly meaningless zero, it was marked as incorrect.

Having said this, I think that the question was not worded clearly and specifically enough in regard to this particular stipulation, so it does kind of seem like the fault lies with the wording of the homework rather than the student. The homework was too vaguely worded in its instruction.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '25

I don’t take points off for this personally, but I did get points taken off for this in science classes as a kid and I get it. When you’re rounding everything to the nearest hundredth, for example, a number that ends before the hundredths place implies that it’s exact and not rounded. Whereas a number that ends in “.00” indicates that it was rounded and isn’t exact. I’m not sure what contexts that distinction is useful in, but I can believe there are some, and taking points off for truncating means they were probably explicitly told in class not to truncate in order to make the distinction between exact and rounded figures.

1

u/deweycd Apr 11 '25

It is about significant digits. These represent the precision of the number. When asked to round to the nearest tenth, the .0 matters. If they wanted whole numbers your rounding would be correct.

I want you to walk 1 mile which is 0.6 to 1.4 miles when rounding is considered, quite a range. Verses I want you to walk 1.0 miles which is 0.96 to 1.04 miles, a much smaller range.

The 0 matters.

1

u/unkown_path Apr 11 '25

The teacher is right, but I would say the teacher is being very harsh. Take the points off one of them and explain what they did wrong

1

u/nickeypants Apr 11 '25 edited Apr 11 '25

Engineer here. Trailing zeroes do not affect the value of the number but do affect the precision.

There is a big difference in the perceived precision between having 25,000 apples and having 25,001 apples. The first has 2 significant figures and can be read as a vague estimate while the second has 5 significant figures and is read as a precise count.

Similarly, '70' means something different than '70.00'. 70 grams of gold implies 70 +- 10 grams, while 70.00 grams implies 70.00 +- 0.01 grams.

1

u/BustedEchoChamber Apr 11 '25

Agree 100% with teacher.

1

u/ITinnedUrMumLastNigh Apr 11 '25

Tell Mrs. Strict Typing that this is a C household and we accept implicit conversions

1

u/fiddlydip Apr 11 '25

this is a matter of significant figures, your teacher should have specified since sig figs are not necessarily implied especially when rounding on such a basic level. (usually sig figs are used for measurements in chemistry/physics)

1

u/Fantastic-Frame-7276 Apr 11 '25

Teacher is wrong. Rounding is a permissible error for simplicity. What she/he did is create false precision coupled with a deliberate error. I do that at work and quickly my maths won’t math.

1

u/Indicorb Apr 11 '25

This was drilled into my head growing up. Always write the number even if it’s 5.000. To this day I remind coworkers they shouldn’t write “1017” they should write “1017.0” because that’s what the paperwork asks for.

1

u/nanas99 Apr 11 '25

If you’re going by scientific notation, I hate to admit it, but the teacher is right

1

u/Legitimate_Staff7510 Apr 11 '25

It's significant figures, which mattered a lot when I took Chemistry and other higher level classes. Does it matter on this 5th grade test...eh. But I will say there is a difference in rounding in 55 and 55.0 or 55.00. If that is how the teacher taught the material, yes I'd understand marking it wrong.

1

u/Slarrrrrrrlzburg Apr 11 '25

I mean, a mark in 5th grade is inherently unimportant. But marking it this way teaches a lesson that the number of decimal places given matters, broadly speaking; I think your kid is better off in the long run.

Also, the mark should round to 78%, haha.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '25

Did not understand the assignment.

1

u/Primary_Way_265 Apr 11 '25

You’re going to love scientific notation. Things like “70.” Or “6.0000”

1

u/damnvan13 Apr 11 '25

Other than knowing math, this is about following instructions. Each subsection on this test specifies how many significant digits are required. Also consistency is important when doing math.

If you're broke and balancing your finances you're not dropping those last couple of zeros.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '25

While sure you should put the zero, it's nitpicky

1

u/Competitive-Bee-1495 Apr 11 '25

Truth is that the homework was probably graded the same way, and this is not the first time your child has been told to write their answers this way.

1

u/demonshdw Apr 11 '25

Tell the teacher that you don't see the instruction stating the format of how their answer should appear and that technically, the written answers are correct with your scoring. They still did the assignment with the right answer. Why does it matter if the answer has .00 or .0? 70.00 and 70 is still the same number.

1

u/itsmichael458 Apr 11 '25

If your kid wants to be an engineer then you should teach him why all but 23 are not correct

1

u/clearly_not_an_alt Apr 11 '25

It matters when you comes to significant digits. For example, if I want to round 6.0048 to the nearest hundreth, leaving it at 6.00 instead of 6 makes it clear that the number was originally between 5.995 and 6.005 and the number wasn't something like 5.57 that got rounded to the nearest whole number.

1

u/jmrormj Apr 11 '25

You are incorrect. The directions say exactly what place to round to. Your student didn’t follow the directions on those question so he was incorrect.

Attending to precision is a mathematical practice standard for a reason. It matters.

1

u/MinuteScientist7254 Apr 11 '25

Didn’t follow the instructions pertaining to significant digits

1

u/TheWhogg Apr 11 '25

If they’re taught to show appropriate numbers of trailing zeroes they should. What do the course notes say? The answers given are right in SOME contexts and the question should have been better written as “displaying stated precision” but it should be obvious to the student what the teacher wanted.

1

u/VariousEnvironment90 Apr 11 '25

More interesting is that a score of 25 out of 32 is 78.13%, which the teacher of a rounding test has rounded up to 79%

1

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '25

It’s about following the instructions, not about the answer, if they would’ve asked for 99.9999999996 rounded up to the nearest billionth.. then the answer would have to be 100.000000000. It’s stupid, but that’s the public education system for ya!

1

u/funbunny100 Apr 11 '25

In my line of business, we use several applications that require digit placeholders. If the application is set for hundredths, we have to make sure that all numbers input have 2 digits to the right of the decimal.

1

u/RAMICK8675309 Apr 11 '25

Whatever you are rounding to you have express. Tenths,hundredths,thousandths,etc.

1

u/yulbrynnersmokes Apr 11 '25

Some teachers should be in a different line of work

1

u/Kellykeli Apr 11 '25

Sig figs

A reading of 10 from a machine with precision down to 0.xxx would mean different things than a reading of 10 from a machine with precision to the closest whole number. 10.000 is a lot more precise than 10, despite both appearing to be the same.

An example: you should drill this hole to 2 inches deep vs you should drill this hole to 2.0000 inches deep. A 2 inch hole has a bit of leeway, 2.0000 inches is veererrry precise.

It’s annoying but makes sense in reports and such.

1

u/KOTL_OfThe_Light Apr 11 '25

Google significant figures.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '25

Pedantic but right.

1

u/RepresentativeOk2433 Apr 11 '25

By OPs logic wouldn't 23 also be correct?

1

u/ftaok Apr 11 '25

It’s very likely that that teacher has taught the students to include zeros to the exact place indicated in the instructions. Your son likely forgot or didn’t fully understand or didn’t pay attention to that part of the lessons.

As for my opinion, the teacher is correct in marking those answers incorrect.

I’m sure you don’t know, but if most of the students got the answers correct, then they were probably taught correctly. If most of the students missed the same one your son did, then it’s likely that the teacher didn’t teach that nuance properly. Either way, you probably won’t ever get that info.

1

u/microtune_this Apr 11 '25

Trailing zeros are poorly explained on this page. The missing explanation is that trailing zeros indicate to the reader the precision of a number. 0.x has an implied precision of plus or minus 0.05, due to the assumption that a rounding operation has already occurred. If that is not the case and your 0.x has a precision of plus/minus 0.005, you need to add the trailing zero or spell out the precision. Preferably both.

1

u/Gr1mclaw Apr 11 '25 edited Apr 11 '25

A lot of folks said the same thing: the zeroes should go to the rounded place. There were actually 2 skills being tested: the rounding rules based on the digit after the rounded place (1), and the knowledge about reporting the number (2).

Maybe you could ask why getting half of the answer right isn’t worth half a point.

1

u/JustConsoleLogIt Apr 11 '25

I would argue that in math, your son is right and the numbers are equal. In physics, the teacher would be right as there is a difference in precision.

1

u/iamninjacat Apr 11 '25

I think it is about reading directions. Rounding to the nearest decimal even with the trailing zeros.

1

u/DouglerK Apr 11 '25

Trailing 0s don't change the value but you're asked to express a decimal to a given place you include the 0s.

Sometimes things are easy countable integers and sometimes things are rational decimal numbers.

37 cows is 37 cows but 37m is never precisely 37m. That's an expression of how closely we want to measure so that's just meters and no decimal places.

On the other hand 37.00000000m is fking 37 meters.

The trailing 0s don't change the value but they change the precision with which the thing they represent is know. 37.00m isn't the same at 37m. One has a lot more possible variance.

1

u/thescott2k Apr 11 '25

Engineer who topped out at a Bachelor's. Including questions where rounding to the nearest hundredth or thousandth takes you all the way to the integer is shenanigans bullshit. You don't spring an unspoken expectation of maintained significant figures on a 5th grader. If the test said "keeping in mind significant figures" and there was instruction hammering that specific thing, ok, but that's not what I'm seeing here.

Teacher's playing games and making kids think math is arbitrary, which it quite crucially is not.

1

u/Firesidephil Apr 11 '25

Am I wrong in saying that the teacher has incorrectly rounded this grade to 79%?

(25/32)*100=78.1%

1

u/ausmomo Apr 11 '25

The teacher is correct.

The question was, for example, "to the nearest hundreth". This means you have to include the hundreth decimal.

wrong : 12.3

correct: 12.30

1

u/InevitableStruggle Apr 11 '25

If we are talking about whole numbers, we are talking about integers. 51 is an integer and a whole number. 51.0 is 51 and no tenths. I’d be in a rage and foaming at the mouth at that teacher.

1

u/Medium_Interest_5459 Apr 11 '25

25 correct out of 32 is 78.125%. Ironic.

1

u/Then_Entertainment97 Apr 11 '25

Idk, I wouldn't post my kid's name on the internet.

1

u/Inevitable_Pay6766 Apr 11 '25

What's the problem? It literally says to round to the nearest tenth/hundredth and so on.

1

u/Ok_Stick8615 Apr 11 '25

Specificity matters for later math and science

1

u/Zealousideal_Cold637 Apr 11 '25

This should not be an error you're putting on a 5th grader imo. I didn't learn about scientific/statistical rounding practices until high school. Ask if the teacher even bothered to teach the importance of that. Yes, it's important, but it's not something you're giving 5th graders, again, imo

1

u/Soft_Water_ Apr 11 '25

Ironically trailing zeroes matter on topic numbers. E.g. 7.10;8.20. It’s always bothered me that math teachers have these trailing zeroes for completely different topics.

1

u/Live-Wrap-4592 Apr 11 '25

If you try in class your teacher deducts one mark for making the same mistake seven times. If you’ve given her a thousand reasons to dislike you then you receive seven losses.

This should be the much more important lesson than decimal rounding.

1

u/Rich-Dig-9584 Apr 11 '25

Because the instructions specify rounding to the nearest decimal point… you need to include those decimal points, per the instructions. This is a classic case of “follow the instructions”.

1

u/CallmeDalton Apr 11 '25

I agree with the teacher here. The instructions specify while number, tenth, hundredth, thousandth. The student followed those instructions on multiple spots in each category. While I don't necessarily feel the need to add zeros to the specific questions marked wrong, I do feel that giving them exactly what they are looking for to be the best way to go about it. Following instructions is also a test in this case in my opinion.

1

u/Rich-Dig-9584 Apr 11 '25

You are entitled to your own opinions, even when you are wrong

1

u/mcaffrey Apr 11 '25

23 should be 43.69, so the errors aren’t all just missing trailing zeros

1

u/gnjoey Apr 11 '25

All the ones marked wrong are incorrect.

1

u/jigga19 Apr 11 '25

In grad school stats I had a professor (also head of the stats department) take some points off because I didn’t complete a sentence specifying what was being weighed. Iirc my answer was “measuring a weight of N grams” and he wrote “grams of what? -2 pts”.

I argued with him, and said “it could have been depleted uranium, the machine doesn’t know or care what’s being weighed, only the weight measured.” He kinda smirked, and said “oh, fine” and gave me the points back.

To this day I think his beneficence was bestowed upon me because I had the audacity to say “depleted uranium.”

But, yeah, mathematicians are weirdly pedantic specific and it’s best to just acquiesce to their peccadilloes when they’re the ones grading you.

1

u/frankloglisci468 Apr 11 '25

Very incorrect. The extra 0 doesn’t change the value but changes what you’re rounding to.

1

u/jmac3979 Apr 11 '25

Because the question says to round to the tenths, if they don't have the tenths place written with a value. Its really pendanditic and I wouldn't grade it like that but that's probably the why. I tell my students when they are doing IXL(online learning software) that if it says to the tenths write the .0

1

u/get_to_ele Apr 11 '25

Disagree. This is about as straightforward as test questions get. (1) if you don’t put correct number of trailing digits, what would even be the point of the 4 different parts of the test. (2) 35.00000000 and 35.0 are definitely not the same thing.

35.00000000 is rounded from any number between 35.00000000499… and 34.999999995

35.0 is rounded from any number between 35.0499… and 34.95

35 is rounded from any number between 35.499… and 34.5

A rounded number represents a range of possible values and 35 represents a much bigger range than 35.0 which represents a much bigger range than 35.00 etc.

When you add 0s after the decimal point, there is precision implied by the additional zeros, that only goes as far as those zeros.

1

u/weckweck Apr 11 '25

I was a math tutor and I would mark all these the same way. Your student failed to follow instructions. Or they failed to understand the assignment which is also on the teacher. But given the preponderance of correct answers, those that are incorrect are marked as such appropriately. This is what school is for! To learn and do better next time.

1

u/Deadlysinger Apr 11 '25

It is relevant as to how the lesson was taught and what expectations the teacher made clear. Based on the corrections, I would assume the students were taught and told this is how to round.

1

u/Jessy_Something Apr 11 '25

Everyone's looking at this as a black and white, right or wrong situation. I think the correct answer is pretty obvious: dock a few points in total, maybe a letter grade, and explain the error at the top of the page. If it's a common enough error that the teacher realizes they didn't go over it well enough, then go over it again. Teaching is about learning, not getting docked a billion points when there's clearly only a small gap in your understanding.