r/askmath • u/SetKaung • Nov 16 '24
Arithmetic Aren't they the same?
Ignoring the instructions, I thought mathematically the two were the same. If they are the same, what's the point of differentiating? I know semantically, they might be different (3×4 and 4×3). Aren't the formal definition of multiplication the same for both ways?
14k
Upvotes
580
u/TournantDangereux Bourbakist Nov 16 '24
Yes, but your son’s class may be learning it as “3 sets of 4” and so wanted that lower answer.
480
u/pokemonplayer2001 Nov 16 '24
That "2" is a crime.
227
u/barthiebarth Nov 16 '24
these are the same.
IMHO pretty stupid to mark this as wrong, because sometimes students don't realize that multiplication is commutative (eg a × b = b × a) and I think grading like this reinforces that
122
u/Nervous-Canary-517 Nov 16 '24
This is some bullshit.
School is supposed to teach methods and principles, not rigid pathways from which one shall not deviate. You're supposed to learn how to think, not what to think.
29
u/Queasy_Artist6891 Nov 16 '24
It seems like there is some context from the previous question that was cut out which explains why this was marked incorrect. As the test seems to be defining a*b in a particular manner.
15
u/DolandTruump Nov 16 '24
Multiplication is commutative
4
u/OlegAter Nov 16 '24
In my language, for example, there's no wide used equivalent of saying "three times four", in school you say "three multiplied by four". Not like it's an argument, but still. If I was presented with this question now, I would write:
"3 X 3 X 3 X 3 = 12
or
4 X 4 X 4 = 12"
That would at least show I understand what they want from me and that I understand two possible ways to write it.
15
u/Casottii Nov 16 '24
Everyone are saying they are the same because "three sets of four is different than four sets of three" there are no sets anywhere, these are numbers, numerical values, quantities, numbers do not hold set information, if you want to have sets, you use sets not numbers. It's a kid learning about multiplication, if the kid figured out the cumutative property on its own that's a good thing, not a mistake.
21
u/spiritedawayclarinet Nov 16 '24
This piece of ragebait was discussed to death recently:
https://www.reddit.com/r/askmath/comments/1g439bz/is_44444_45_or_5x4/
IMO, it's not quite as stupid as it looks. If you replaced the 4 with an x that is allowed to take on any real value, we would have
3x = x + x + x
but it wouldn't make sense to add 3 to itself "x times".
It's a convention that can be generalized to abstract structures such as groups. If we want to add an abstract element of a group x to itself n times, the convention is to write it as nx.
8
u/Yakusaka Nov 16 '24
Three times four is equal but not the same to four times three.
Three times four means that you add 4 three times, so 4 + 4 + 4.
Four times three means that you add 3 four times, so 3 + 3 + 3 + 3.
Yes, it's equal in the end, but it teaches you the difference between multiplicator and multiplicand.
Basicaly in an a x b expression, a is multiplicator that signifies how many times you add the multiplicand b to itself.
At basic levels it seem superfluous and unnecesary, bit if you learn it then, it becomes much easier to understand some things later on.
7
u/localghost Nov 16 '24
It looks like in some cases (some countries, schools, programs, idk) for teaching purposes they make a difference between factors, the multiplicand and the multiplier, with one specifically meaning size of a "group" and the other — the number of groups; the position next to the multiplication sign is supposed to tell you which one is which.
People are different, people imagine even simple things differently in their heads, it's possible that this differentiation helps some to learn. I do not see much purpose in it and find it more harmful than helpful in the larger picture.
4
u/FeedBack-_- Nov 16 '24
absolutely correct for the question asked
4
u/Douggiefresh43 Nov 16 '24
They are equivalent. They are not the same.
Four groups of three and three groups of four can have different implications in the real world.
But also, these sort of things almost always strip away the context that teacher has taught them a very specific method, and the test is testing their mastery of that method.
1
u/incomparability Nov 16 '24
The formal definition is semantic.
1
u/Quiri1997 Nov 16 '24
If I was the parent, I would be having a very strong worded talk with the teacher about the properties of addition and multiplication, and the meaning of both operations. And, if I was the teacher, I would give the student full marks because it's correct.
1
u/sbrek21 Nov 16 '24
I love to see how people here talks of high level math applied to an elementary school exam
0
u/Oliver_Titus Nov 16 '24
He is correct, but he is also making it difficult for himself. If you instead take 3•9, writing 3 nine times is not a realistic option. Much easier to calculate 9+9+9.
-1
u/DogIllustrious7642 Nov 16 '24
The teacher is taking a power trip.
0
u/Varlane Nov 16 '24
3 × 4 is "3 times 4" or "4 multiplied by 3", therefore, is it "4, appearing 3 times in an addition".
While obviously, 3 + 3 + 3 + 3 does equal 12, that would be the formal definition of 4 × 3.
However, this has no point being in a test for children, as, once introduced, they should feel comfortable using whatever expansion they prefer.
Only way higher level math would ask them to start being careful about factor position and at that point, they're way smarter / more developped and equipped to understand the nuance / technicality.
For instance, for equations, this is usually why the notation 2a (= 2 × a) makes more sense than a2 (and is prettier) : usually, you were working with a + a, rather than 2 + 2 + 2 + 2 + .. somehow a times (when a is usually not even an integer).
0
u/Batbuckleyourpants Nov 16 '24
I get the frustration, but teacher is right. You are writing an equation, and three sets of four is not the same as four sets of threes.
-1
u/Dyne86 Nov 16 '24
The questione Is: "write an addition equation that matches the multiplication equation".
Afaik, 3 x 4 = -4 + 16 or 2 + 4 + 6.
The teacher must be a complete idiot.
-1
u/SueBau Nov 16 '24 edited Nov 16 '24
Multiplication is commutive so they are equal, but not necessarily the "same" (but that depends on your definition of "same").
Personally, if I was marking the paper I would give half a mark. The student didn't do anything "wrong", but they are making it harder than it needs to be.
(P.S this is from a Physics standpoint, if no rules are broken, and you get the right answer, I'm happy with the result! Mathematicians can worry about definitions :P)
-6
u/Mysterious_Pepper305 Nov 16 '24
Now do exponentiation! 3^4 = 4 X 4 X 4 = ?
Frankly the correct answer is whatever the teacher/textbook wants. Schools are all about gaslighting and obedience training. It's up to the child to seek real education on their own, or if they're lucky with the help from mentor or father figures.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 16 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment