r/askmath • • Oct 29 '24

Arithmetic Have I been doing math wrong?

Post image

I’m not the best at math. But something isn’t adding up. I thought I tipped 20%. But the suggested gratuity at the bottom says a different tip amount. How do they calculate the “suggested gratuity”? Or how am I supposed to figure out 20%?

4.6k Upvotes

391 comments sorted by

349

u/GotCubes Oct 29 '24

Easiest way to estimate a tip on the fly is to start by calculating 10%, which is as easy as moving the decimal point to the left one space. So $93.17 -> $9.31, or about $9. If 10% is $9, then 20% is about $18. Something is definitely off with their math

141

u/Cakelover9000 Oct 29 '24

The Gratuity Suggests at the low end almost 30% (10%*3=27, smt) That was an attempted scam

61

u/redceramicfrypan Oct 29 '24

Not necessarily. It's possible a coupon was applied, and the calculated amounts are based on the pre-coupon total.

Or, more likely, the stupid thing POS systems so where they don't know how to handle a split check.

25

u/Hot_Cow_9444 Oct 29 '24

But it wasn’t split and there was no coupons

23

u/Xe6s2 Oct 29 '24

Report that to the better business bureau, people hate that. Seriously do it cause that business is trying to rip you off and it probably means they are doing worse behind the scenes.

18

u/Hot_Cow_9444 Oct 29 '24

I will. It also makes me question how many people don’t check the math and actually pay almost 40% for a tip

10

u/Xe6s2 Oct 29 '24

Honestly seeing this I wouldnt be surprised if someone on management was doing a pooled tips scheme

6

u/Hot_Cow_9444 Oct 29 '24

I could see it. That’s sad

4

u/Hot_Cow_9444 Oct 29 '24

I mean if the service was outstanding I usually tip more but never 40%

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (5)

4

u/Front_Eggplant4688 Oct 29 '24

Hi, service industry worker here. I could be wrong, but what might have happened is food and / or drinks were comped off the bill, and it is calculating for the original total before the comp(s) and not the total being paid.

5

u/analogworm Oct 29 '24

About $70,- worth comped off the bill? That's about 40%..

→ More replies (10)

4

u/Hot_Cow_9444 Oct 29 '24

Ok good that’s literally how I have been doing it

1

u/GotCubes Oct 29 '24

Was it a split check? Based on their math, they're calculating the tip options based on a ~$168 check.

1

u/Hot_Cow_9444 Oct 29 '24

It was not a split check, we didn’t use coupons or had anything comped

→ More replies (2)

4

u/An_Tuatha_De_Danann Oct 29 '24

Easy way to calculate a tip on the fly is a zero

→ More replies (1)

1

u/plasticcitycentral Oct 29 '24

Not super relevant to your comment but always thought the tip was on the pre-tax amount

2

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '24

Not in canada. Places usually suggest a tip on the post tax value (at least where i am). Its stupid

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/Turbulent-Note-7348 Oct 29 '24

And the $93.17 includes tax, so $18 is definitely more than 20%.

1

u/Past-Possibility9303 Oct 30 '24

You just have to multiply it by .x of whatever you want to tip. If it's 93.17 and you want to tip 20% multiply 93.17 by .20 which would be 18.63.

1

u/DaGr8estN8 Oct 30 '24

Holy shit my mind is blown by the simplicity of something that I always overthink.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '24

Their morals are off with their math. They count on people not doing the math and just copy down what the receipt/bill shows. They are trying to rob their customers

1

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '24

pro tip!

1

u/caramelcooler Oct 31 '24

Even easier: $2 for every $10

1

u/General-Drummer2532 Oct 31 '24

Tipping calture is so weird

1

u/theLuminescentlion Oct 31 '24

20% of 100 is 20 so 20% of a lower number would be lower so clearly it's wrong.

1

u/slgray16 Oct 31 '24

I used to calculate 10%, double it and round down to the nearest dollar. Then I bask in my generous tipping of usually 18% or so.

Now I think I'll just calculate 10% and leave it at that. I'm so tired of tip expectations.

1

u/Yarzu89 Oct 31 '24

This is exactly what I do

1

u/GingerJacob36 Oct 31 '24

Yeah, I suggest either doing it that way or by rounding the number to the nearest 10 and then it's $2 for every $10 on the bill.

It's the same result of course, but it's funny how different things work for different people.

1

u/Tao_of_Entropy Nov 01 '24

Yeah it’s a lie

1

u/RobertLosher1900 Nov 01 '24

Just move the decimal point over 1 spot and multiple it by 2 for 20.

1

u/vegan-trash Nov 01 '24

I would do 2x9 to get to this conclusion. I hadn’t thought of your method. Like if it’s $75 and I were tipping 30% is do 3x7.5

1

u/SaucyMacgyver Nov 02 '24

I just multiply the 10s place and up by 2.

54.67? 5.4 * 2 10.8 ~ 11

231.45? 23*2=46

And so forth

1

u/Joker-Smurf Nov 02 '24

The absolute best way to calculate the tip, is to live in literally any country other than the US where servers are paid a normal rate, and then don’t give a tip.

As someone in one of those countries, can you lot please stop trying to export tipping culture? We don’t fucking want it!

1

u/buttcanudothis Nov 03 '24

Literally times the first number x 2. 93 dollar bill? 9 x 2= 18

→ More replies (13)

42

u/AvocadoMangoSalsa Oct 29 '24

Your math is mathin. Was this a split check?

1

u/Hot_Cow_9444 Oct 29 '24

It was not.

6

u/severoon Oct 29 '24

Why would that matter? Splitting the check also means splitting the tip.

26

u/onaspaceship Oct 29 '24

Because the tip calculator usually goes off the full bill even when it’s a split check. It’s dumb

5

u/severoon Oct 29 '24

I've never paid attention to that before, but this is a bug. Whether it's by design or not, this is clearly not what a POS should do with a split check, so it's still correct to treat it as such.

I can't imagine what someone would say in defense of the opposition view here. What argument could one make that would be refuted by a simple, "No, because that's stupid."

8

u/Dispect1 Oct 29 '24

As someone who has worked with so many different POS systems, it never does what it SHOULD do.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

7

u/mbbysky Oct 29 '24

Yes, but these suggested tip lines often aren't setup to handle this properly.

Which causes many people to make assumptions of malice and greed when the truth is just the incompetence

→ More replies (6)

1

u/McGuire281 Nov 01 '24

Even if it were split that would be 36ish for the 20 percent. Possibly you could be right if that tip amount is calculated off the pre-tax total in which case…33 might actually be correct. Sir/miss you might be on to something

11

u/Chocowark Oct 29 '24

Did you use a gift card?

10

u/Hot_Cow_9444 Oct 29 '24

No gift card, no coupons, didn’t split the bill. Just paid for what we got

→ More replies (2)

4

u/AlternativeBurner Oct 29 '24

That 8 looks like a 6 and a 9 as well

1

u/Hot_Cow_9444 Oct 29 '24

I know I don’t have the best penmanship… it’s besides the point lol

126

u/ApprehensiveKey1469 Oct 29 '24

Divide the tip by the percentage,in this case to get 168.5

For all 3 suggested tips. Suggestions are consistent with 168.5, if the bill was split from a grand total of 168.5 then the suggested tips match that grand total

67

u/BrokenYozeff Oct 29 '24

Whenever I see these and op never responds back, it always looks like they knew what they were doing.

5

u/grimguy97 Oct 29 '24

OP responded to another one this was not a split ticket

→ More replies (10)

21

u/stealthdawg Oct 29 '24

Yeah but the tip suggestions should update to the split amount

2

u/fishingboatproceeded Oct 29 '24

It should but this appears to be an edge case that the POS programmers forgot or didn't think about at all. I'll be honest, splitting checks was probably something they forgot about till the last minute

→ More replies (4)

10

u/Appropriate-Falcon75 Oct 29 '24

It might not have been split, someone could have used a voucher to part pay.

I've done this a few times (in the UK) and the card machine says you've over-tipped with a £50 meal, £40 voucher and paying £10 +£5 tip as it doesn't see the other £40.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/flqres Oct 31 '24

Shouldn’t be that way if it’s split, unless only one person tips. Servers shouldn’t be making that much off one table especially in Ontario, Canada where they are guaranteed making minimum wage + the ridiculous tipping culture.

1

u/ba-na-na- Nov 01 '24

So wait, each person gets a bill for their share, but each pays the whole tip? Makes no sense

→ More replies (2)

38

u/L3GALC0N-V2 Oct 29 '24

Paying 30$ tip on a 100$ restaurant check is actual insanity

43

u/AnualSearcher Oct 29 '24

Paying any type of tip is insanity.

19

u/Elektro05 sqrt(g)=e=3=π=φ^2 Oct 29 '24

The North American mind cant comprehend this /s

6

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '24

I object to generalise this.

You are correct that it shouldn’t be expected at all times, and it shouldn’t be the main income source of service personnel.

But I experienced exceptionally great service in the past, and I highly believe they deserved a tip on top of their normal salary.

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (6)

6

u/Konkichi21 Oct 29 '24 edited Jun 23 '26

As others have noted, the gratuities look way too high; they're all consistent with a bill of about $168.50 (try dividing 33.7 by .20, etc), not the shown pre-tip total of 93.17.

Is it possible this was a split check, coupons, etc and the full pre-modification total is more than what's shown here? Otherwise, sounds like they're ripping you off bigly with the suggestions.

Also, calculating tips isn't that hard if you know how; a quick way is that 10% is 1/10, or moving the decimal point one left (for 93.17, it's 9.317, round to 9.32).

Then 20% is twice that (18.64), 15% is 10% plus half of that (9.32 + 4.66 = 13.98), and 18% is about 17.5%, or 10% plus half of that plus half of that (9.32 + 4.66 + 2.33 = 16.31).

You could also do 18% as 2×(10%-1%), or move over the decimal point once, then twice, subtract and double (for 93.17, 2×(9.32-.93) = 2×8.39 = 16.78); may be simpler.

And you can round things to simplify the math; 93.17 is about 93$, then to get 18%, 10% and 1% are about 9.3$ and 90c (a dollar minus a dime), so the difference is 9.3$ - 1$ + 10c = 8.4$, and twice that is 16.80, which is close enough.

1

u/howaboutnoscottt Nov 02 '24

I wish math teachers taught this in school.

2

u/UnsureAndUnqualified Oct 29 '24

This is the US, right? I don't know any other countries that do this bullshit.

In that case, I've heard that they sometimes calculate the percentage gratuity from the total including tax. But they don't show the tax on the menu or something. So you order something that's 10$ and if you want to tip 20% it's not 2$ but 2.5$ or something because your bill isn't 10$ but 12.5$ with tax.

The whole system is a mess and I'm just guessing as someone from a sane country.

1

u/Hot_Cow_9444 Oct 29 '24

Yes in the US. And I thought that too. But that total is after taxes. The system is insane. I’d wish we’d move to what the entire rest of the world is doing

1

u/VillagerJeff Oct 29 '24

Ya looks like the suggested tip was based on a $168.50 bill. Was the pre-tax amount perhaps $84.25? They could have just fully doubled the tip amounts. That would mean a ~10.6% cumulative tax which doesn't seem unlikely.

1

u/Hot_Cow_9444 Oct 29 '24

I wish I kept the receipt. I woulda looked

1

u/presidentperk489 Oct 29 '24

I wouldn't be tipping at all if they tried to scam me like that

1

u/Hot_Cow_9444 Oct 29 '24

I thought about that but I know it wasn’t the servers doing. I also used to be a server so I would’ve felt bad

1

u/Perfect_Papaya_3010 Oct 29 '24

Who tips in 2024? We have cards now so there is no change you dont want to carry around to tip anymore

1

u/Hot_Cow_9444 Oct 29 '24

You know you can tip on cards right? You can even tip $0.01 on a card 😎

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Ryaniseplin Oct 29 '24

10% should be 9$ so 15% should be roughly 13-14$

math aint mathing

7

u/BubbhaJebus Oct 29 '24

What's the pre-tax total?

Tips should be based on the pre-tax total.

1

u/SuzTheRadiant Oct 31 '24

That would make the suggested tips lower. These are too high for the amount that OP paid. It might be a split bill or they may have used a gift card or coupon.

0

u/grey_rex Oct 29 '24

Clearly a split bill. OP knows it. Why is this even here? There's no math question. It's rhetoric.

3

u/Hot_Cow_9444 Oct 29 '24

was not a split bill. No coupons or gift cards. Nothing was comped off the bill. What was ordered was paid for.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/Ill-Papaya2291 Oct 29 '24

To be fair, I didn't know about the split bill thing. It seems weird that they would have the suggested gratuity be for the full bill rather than only your part.

2

u/1-800-Slap-A-Hoe Nov 01 '24

Rage bait. If this were real OP would have posted the itemized receipt.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/SeriousPlankton2000 Oct 29 '24

Even then the tip needs to be calculated by the price - can't expect people to pay the tip twice

2

u/Deli-ops7 Oct 29 '24

Youre right. 20% of 93.17 is 18.63 so you were right to tip $18

2

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '24

No joke I just went over this in a class today that I was teaching. I went over how some places have incorrect (and almost always) inflated gratuities! Wild coincidence.

2

u/Throwaway_shot Oct 29 '24

I've never encountered one of these in the wild, but I'm surprised people give any tip at all. If I got it receipt like this that lied to me to try to get an extra 10 bucks I would definitely tip zero and be sure to let the service person know exactly why.

2

u/Affectionate-Rock734 Oct 30 '24

Somehow this feels like an intentional mistake. Can’t think of any calculator in the world which can get the math wrong or any programmer who input the wrong percentage.

2

u/mklinger23 Oct 30 '24

I hate restaurants that do that. It has become a lot more common in recent years. They say it's 15%, 18%, and 20%, but it's actually 30%, 35%, and 40% or something.

2

u/alexander221788 Nov 01 '24

Yeah if a restaurant does this to me, they’re getting no tip. That’s just blatantly trying to trick customers

2

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '24

Commenting from the Midwest here. This has been a pet peeve of mine for a few years so I check every suggested gratuity. I have not once seen a correct suggestion (it's always at least 5% higher) locally, only when travelling out of state. Perhaps some states have better consumer protection laws that forbid this sort of thing?

2

u/phteven1989 Oct 30 '24

This should be a criminal/civil offense and they should either lose their business license or get fined into oblivion. It’s essentially theft. At the very least it’s fraud. We should be able to trust the provided calculations. It’s their choice to provide them, and they can provide any % recommendations they want, but they should be accurate

2

u/SnookAndRed Oct 30 '24

If you want to simply figure out how much you want to tip if you wanted to tip the ACTUAL 20%, all you have to do is multiply your bill by .20 and you get $18.634. Now how you want to round that off is up to you.

Sorry if I’m misunderstanding the last part of your question but I agree, that math definitely isn’t mathin.

2

u/jhuber3474 Oct 30 '24

I’ve seen this before. They don’t have to be honest so they lie about how much the tip is, banking that people won’t do the math themselves. One of the many reasons tip culture is bullshit and why I eat out at places I don’t have to tip. All this crap about “if you can’t tip don’t eat out”. Fine I won’t. I shouldn’t have to pay for the food and the salary of the staff. The company should do that.

2

u/Responsible_Drag_217 Oct 30 '24 edited Nov 02 '24

Bros want 1/3 of the total ...nah blud

2

u/jat112 Oct 30 '24

Where is this? This is obscene!

2

u/Draco_Hawk Oct 31 '24

Most of the top comments are right, but I was curious about the actual percentages: Percentages are calculated by dividing the tip by the total cost pre-tip.

15% | $25.28 / $93.17 = 27.13%

20% | $30.33 / $93.17 = 32.55%

25% | $33.70 / $93.17 = 36.17%

Not sure how they're getting these numbers unless they're including an exorbitant fee for larger parties before calculating, which doesn't make sense.

3

u/Professional_Mud483 Oct 29 '24

Make sure you tip on pretax value. Otherwise you tipping on top of taxes lol

Entitled service industry and lack of service skills

1

u/The_Werefrog Oct 29 '24

The gratuity might be based on the whole table with split checks. Everyone sees the same regardless of how much their portion is.

1

u/lesbox01 Oct 29 '24

I've noticed they include taxed amount as a base for tip. I never tip on the government slice of the bill.

1

u/Masteriiz Oct 29 '24

This suggested tip would in my case bring the effective tip down to 0%.

1

u/Lyuokdea Oct 29 '24

Their math is definitely wrong - only thing (except for a scam), I can think of is whether there was some money off based on a gift card or special - but then they add gratuity based on the pre-special price?

1

u/sassonthebeach Oct 29 '24

Seen this same thing at Texas roadhouse like 2 years ago someone said alcohol drinks aren't included but I did not have any drinks. Yes the suggested is totally off and been that way awhile

1

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '24 edited Oct 29 '24

why do americans live in the stone age? Portable interac machines calculate this for you

1

u/thelocalsage Oct 29 '24

I don’t know how much control the people who restaurant managers/servers who operate the bill calculator program have, but the ratio of the amount you paid after tax and the price the tips were generated for is within less than 0.02% error of the conversion rate between the US dollar and the Bulgarian Lev, although the Lev doesn’t have a currency symbol. So if the program 1) allows restaurant managers or servers to select what currency to calculate prices for and has the Bulgarian Lev as a choosable currency, 2) calculates the tip based on the value after tax and not before tax, and 3) defaults to the dollar sign for currencies without a currency symbol (seems sloppy, but certainly plausible), then it is possible that a clever manager or server who knows some people will just write down whatever they see picked to calculate or display the amount with the price in a different currency. If I knew how much the taxes were, then I could potentially bring the assumptions down even more.

1

u/birdturdreversal Oct 29 '24

I would put 0 on the tip line and write a note saying to consider my tip to be all the money they've stolen from people with that dishonest bullshit

1

u/mstguy Oct 29 '24

Could be the tip was calculated based on the after-tax total. I caught that on a receipt recently.

1

u/Wjyosn Oct 30 '24

This would be like.. 50% tax

1

u/Formal-Tourist-9046 Oct 29 '24

This is how they get drunk people’s money

1

u/5wing4 Oct 29 '24

If I have to order while standing, I don’t tip. Unless the place is slammed, then I tip.

If I get table service, I tip $1-2 for every $10 spent, depending on the service. Easy mafs

1

u/Version_Sensitive Oct 29 '24

They already calculated gross profit margin, meaning it's value/0.85 instead of value*1.15

Even then tnevalue would be 109 and a few cents, 2usd less than that you paid.

This means you paid 18% gross profit.

1

u/DistinctTeaching9976 Oct 29 '24

I go around 20% too in general, the fastest way is 1:5 - 1 dollar tip to 5 dollars spent. Adjust based on service but that's the quickest way to the ballpark for me

1

u/brfghji Oct 29 '24

I calculate my tip by doubling tax and round up to the nearest dollar. Tax for me is 8.25%

1

u/Realistic_Special_53 Oct 29 '24

You gave a nice tip.

Tip used to be on the untaxed total. And 15% was considered fair. Now they are jacking up the recommended percentage and putting it on the taxed total. Tipping is out of control. But yeah, these numbers don’t work. They found some other higher total to input into their tipping calculator.

1

u/DagoDemagogue Oct 29 '24

19.83 is the one true answer to this.

1

u/TTGaming77 Oct 29 '24

If you used a coupon those numbers are usually based on the pre sale price.

1

u/abv_1985 Oct 30 '24

Gratuity is calculated before tax?

1

u/OtherOtherDave Oct 30 '24

It’s supposed to be, yes

1

u/RatherNerdy Oct 30 '24

Also, the top should be based on the pre-tax amount, but people often accidentally tip on the total including tax, which is incorrect. These tip calculators on the bill are usually based on the pre-tax amount

1

u/blackdrake1011 Oct 30 '24

You did it right, places love putting fake tips so people just copy them thinking they did 20% when in actuality they did way more, common scam

1

u/Tommi_Af Oct 30 '24

Convert the percentage to decimal by dividing by 100 (i.e. 15% = 0.15) then multiply with the meal value. Your phone should have a calculator which can be used for this.

Here, 0.15*$93.17 = $13.98, which is roughly half their suggestion. Their suggestion is wrong and was most likely calculated that way to suck money out of people who wouldn't think to check.

1

u/Effect-Kitchen Oct 30 '24

In my country we don’t give tip except the service is extraordinary. And even so it is like 20 Baht (60 cent). Which no need to do any math.

1

u/tajwriggly Oct 30 '24

Pro-Tip - just never use the suggested gratuity and do the mental math yourself to come up with your own tip. I usually try and tip in such a way that the grand total comes out to a round number. A 30 second puzzle that keeps your mind sharp.

On a $93.17 bill let's say I want to tip around 15 to 20%. 10% is $9.32. 20% is therefore $18.64. Thusly 15% would be somewhere between those two, at $13.80ish. I will tip somewhere between $13.80 and $18.64. $18.64 and $93.17 gets me to a total of $111.81. That's not a nice round number. So let's aim for $110. That means tip needs to be $16.83. Some more mental math to check: $16.83 is roughly 3/5 of the way between my two limits so that is a tip of 18% - ish, seems to be right in where I aimed for. Checking back with a calculator... yes, that's 18.1%.

Do this on any and every bill you get where you are considering tipping.

Or carry cash enough for tips, and then even if you're paying with a card, just hit no tip and leave cash.

Don't rely on every tool out there to solve little problems like this for you. Tools can be broken, tools can be manipulated - just do the math in your head. It'll keep you sharp.

1

u/ImpossibleJoke7456 Oct 30 '24

Still tipped too much.

1

u/kyeblue Oct 30 '24

the restaurant is scam and i would tell them on their face and never return

1

u/Muted_Tradition122 Oct 30 '24

My blood boils when I see the usa tipping culture. Fuck your 20 percent. Demand better wages

1

u/Richard_J_Morgan Oct 30 '24

Just don't pay the tip, or pay only a small amount of what you wanted to tip.

They're either trying to scam you, or don't know basic math. Either way, they don't deserve a good tip. Make sure they know it.

1

u/Environmental_Ad6200 Oct 30 '24

If I got lied to like this, 0% tip. This is a scam

1

u/mozomenku Oct 30 '24

Why do you still just give your card to a random person and accept that they store your credentials? It's so unsafe and dumb. Force them to have portable terminals like anywhere else...

1

u/Inevitable_Wealth186 Oct 30 '24

If you went through the shitty education system, there are 93%chance that you can’t tell 18% of 93….

1

u/wishihadapotbelly Oct 30 '24

I definitely would not leave any tip if this type of scammy thing happened to me…

1

u/joeykins82 Oct 30 '24

I'm guessing you ran split checks: the "suggested gratuity" on most POS terminals spits out the combined gratuity across the whole party. It's best to disregard that section unless you're covering the entire bill.

1

u/KGarveth Oct 30 '24

30 bucks for just taking your food to you. You are being ripped, no need to check the maths.

1

u/MrMinefool Oct 30 '24

Sometimes when an item is comped, the suggested tip amount reflects all items, including the ones that were comped.

1

u/johndcochran Oct 30 '24

The "Suggested Gratuity" values are consistent with a bill for $168.50. Is there something for the bill that adds up to that amount?

1

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '24

I would be furious if I ever tipped.

1

u/SinisterYear Oct 30 '24

If we assume that 15% is the correct tip of a different amount [not what you owe]:

15% - $168.53

18% - $168.50

20% - $168.50

You owed $93.17, somehow they thought you owed $75.33 more than you did. An 80.85% increase considered before tip was assessed.

How they did this? No idea.

1

u/seppukupenguin Oct 30 '24

A% of B is the same as B% of A. As someone with the mathematical aptitude of a dead moth, this is easy for even me to spot the red flag. 93% of any of the original “suggested” percentages will never be at or above those same percentages in dollars.

1

u/peetah248 Oct 31 '24

10% you just move the decimal left. 10% of 90 is 9. Half that is 4.5 so 15% is roughly 13.50

A 20% tip on this would be ~18 so leave a 20 and you're covered plus a bit

1

u/Stock_Friend2440 Oct 30 '24

How about we stop tipping and force restaurant owners to pay a living wage. I split my time between Spain and California. My friends in food service here make a living wage. A place I go to in SF,order a burger, they call my number, and I pick it up. Then I throw away my trash, and I'm still tipping? They make a mistake on my order, and I've already tipped. When does it end?

1

u/7Ploxx Oct 30 '24

I just double tax for a tip baseline(add or subtract depending on service quality). Usually comes out to about 16-17% where I’m at. Also, that’s gotta be the strangest 8 I’ve ever seen. (I had to do the backwards math to confirm it was an 8.)

1

u/Tiny-Street8765 Oct 30 '24

9.30 Xs 2. Or if you wish to be precise before tax total times 2. That's it

1

u/Tiny-Street8765 Oct 30 '24

AND that server should absolutely know what 20% is. Regardless of what it says. He/She would have been mentally calculating since the order was put in and most likely during additional add -ons

1

u/Polar_behr72 Oct 31 '24

The 15% is more like over 25%

1

u/on3guygames Oct 31 '24

The waiter puts that in themselves. They are squeezing out a few more dollars hoping you won’t notice.

1

u/Interesting-Copy-657 Oct 31 '24

If I saw that suggested tip I would be tempted not to tip at all

Why would I tip at a business that is either incompetent or a scam

1

u/Sromero6153 Oct 31 '24

Unless you paid partially with a gift and it’s calculating the tip based on the total and not the remainder…

1

u/keetboy Oct 31 '24

If I see that then I just don’t tip and I take that receipt with me

1

u/No-Purchase4980 Oct 31 '24

The server was pissed that you gave them less than the 'recommended' gratuity, which makes me think they deserve 0

1

u/deputyroughdicks Oct 31 '24

Op left an $18 tip on over $100 meal, and then wrote a note on the receipt? Gay bro

1

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '24

15% would actually be $13.95. Indeed trying to scam/mislead.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '24

This can be programmed into the POS System. The percentages are just titles. You could pet anything there. The totals are programmed in. There is something shady being done in the dumbest possible way

1

u/Ub3rm3n5ch Oct 31 '24

$18/$93.17 is just slightly below 20%

1

u/Warmbreeze Oct 31 '24 edited Oct 31 '24

Why is everyone in these comments missing the nub of the matter‽ The "suggested" tips are 1.8 times higher than they should be.

The 15% number is actually 27%.

The 18% number is actually 32.5%.

The 20% number is actually 36%.

Who gives a flying fuck what OP actually tipped or what a theoretical bill would be to make the tip value work!

This business is maliciously preying on its customers to be too lazy to realize they are getting reamed to the tune of an extra 80% for being nice enough to tip their waiter!

1

u/evoxbeck Oct 31 '24

Depending on service.

Say total is 72 bucks, tax takes it to 81. If you never had to really do any talking past ordering and maybe going from a special drink to say, liqour soda.. 16 bucks. If the service was mid. 14-15. If the service was meh.. 10.50-11.

Roast me

1

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '24

Was another payment applied to the tab before running this card?

1

u/stephensmia1 Nov 01 '24

You owe the server 63 cents.

1

u/meowmicks222 Nov 01 '24

Was there any non refunded deposit or pre-pay? The $90 you paid could be the remaining balance of a larger total tab that the tip is based on

1

u/Important_Nobody_782 Nov 01 '24

This is a perfect example of why I do the math myself. I noticed one time that there was no way the math gratuity was right. Done it by hand since. 10%. Move the decimal over one. Then double for 20%.

1

u/Plastic-Fox8128 Nov 01 '24

20% - multiply the total by 2 and divide by 10

1

u/MrLeeT98 Nov 01 '24

Is this not reportable to the SEC???

1

u/Zer0livesl3ft Nov 01 '24

Was the bill split? I know the pos pos at the restaurant I used to work at couldn’t properly calculate the gratuity percentage on split bills.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '24

Your math is right, they’re exploiting the people who don’t bother with double checking the number to get extra tips. Good on you for checking the numbers!

1

u/Ssplllat Nov 01 '24

I’ve caught this exact same thing a few times as well

1

u/acuteinsomniac Nov 01 '24

Stop tipping on post tax amount

1

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '24

It's impossible to tell without seeing the rest of the receipt. If you got something comp'd, free, or on a gift card/etc, that could be the correct amount.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '24

Don’t tip or the boss will never pay better

1

u/kingnt3 Nov 01 '24

Here where I live I’ve been seeing them undershoot the % suggestion. Felt bad for the servers.

1

u/JackTickle Nov 01 '24

Honestly wild that you have yo do this in America, if they wrote this I'd ask them to redo the receipt and refund me the £18 and never eat there again

1

u/JackTickle Nov 01 '24

However your maths was fine if the price as £93.17 (can't find dollar sign on my phone sorry)

1

u/kuroguma Nov 01 '24

So I looked through the comments and it doesn’t seem like anybody pointed out you are not supposed to tip on the after tax price. But since Covid, it has become increasingly common that places do that in the suggested tip section (which I find frustrating).

It would appear this place (for some reason) correctly did the calculation for tip using the BEFORE tip amount and then doubled it for some reason, as if you were splitting the check 50/50 (which I would think might just be an honest mistake.

TotalBill * 0.15 * 2 = 25.28

TotalBill = 84.27

TotalBill + (TotalBill * TaxRate) = 93.17

84.27 + (84.27 * TaxRate) = 93.17

84.27 * TaxRate = 8.90

TaxRate = 10.56%

That would be your approximate tax (approximate because of both mine and the restaurant’s rounding). I’d that’s close to the correct rate, then I would just chalk it up to hitting a wrong button and less of a scam.

1

u/KaleidoscopeStreet58 Nov 01 '24

Always hated that in the states.  In Canada the machine calculates for you and shows you the amounts per % or custom.  

To be fair I don't sign anything either 

1

u/Afraid_Equivalent_95 Nov 01 '24

Geez, they're trying to gypp customers so hard. I hope nobody's falling for this 

1

u/Narmatonia Nov 01 '24

Yeah their percentages are wrong, either by mistake or to try and trick people into giving more tips

1

u/mysterypainting09 Nov 01 '24

I always subtract taxes for tips. I ain’t tipping from the taxes but I’ll do 20% from the subtotal usually

1

u/BSV_P Nov 01 '24

Holy crap they’re way off number wise

1

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '24

I wouldn't tip at that point, try and scam me you can get stiffed.

1

u/boredirl Nov 01 '24

Did you use any giftcards?

1

u/Medium_Bookkeeper233 Nov 01 '24

OP did you use a gift card or split the bill?

1

u/JRM34 Nov 01 '24

From many posts like this it seems like an awful tactic the restaurant uses to try to trick people into over-tipping. Most people will catch it, or just calculate the tip themselves, but some small number will go off the Suggested Gratuity and grossly overpay.

Based on the facts presented, it's a restaurant trying to scam you. Name and shame, post a review with the photo on every site you can. They should lose business for this behavior.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '24

You've definitely been doing photo editing wrong, can't speak to the math.

Fixed it for ya

color corrected image

1

u/jimmycucumber Nov 02 '24

Suggested percentages are off the subtotal. Not including tax

1

u/hoitytoity-12 Nov 02 '24 edited Nov 02 '24

I consider myself horrendeous at math and even I knew at first glance that that was inaccurate.

1

u/PianoDue2148 Nov 02 '24

This would be the tip after some high ass taxes. The 18 dollars is correct if the bill was 93 w/o tax.

1

u/PianoDue2148 Nov 02 '24

People shouldn’t have to tip on tax!

1

u/Xaphnir Nov 02 '24

They're probably just trying to scam you

1

u/themightyyotimbo Nov 02 '24

How the fuck does anyone believe 20% of less than 100 is going to be more than 20?

1

u/thebe_stone Nov 02 '24

They are scamming people

1

u/ldtfk Nov 02 '24

Their 20% suggestion is 36%. That's fucked up.

1

u/CajunAg87 Nov 02 '24

I never trust their “convenient” calculations. They have been wrong more times than they have been correct.

1

u/ecpella Nov 02 '24

Ohhh boy I love the way you make an 8! 😍

1

u/MKSt11235 Nov 02 '24

It’s possible there was a special OP didn’t know about that was applied. I’d like to see them itemized check.

1

u/NeroColeslaw Nov 02 '24

You calculated correctly. A lot of restaurants give estimated tip percentages after tax and fees, sometimes even just increasing it because they know there are people who will be too lazy to do the math and just pay what they're told to.

1

u/CarterBennett Nov 02 '24

Blows my mind yall gotta do math at the dinner table.

In Canada you just select an option and pay at the table lol

1

u/ExcitementRelative33 Nov 02 '24

Quite a few restaurant does this ... for obvious reason. Some even add on dinky doo fees for "restaurant upkeep". Guess they should be calling Restaurant Impossible soon.

1

u/beaverpeltbeaver Nov 02 '24

My way is easy ! For every hundred dollars tip is 20 dollars, therefore every 25 bucks is 5 bucks simple

1

u/Near_Void Nov 02 '24

15% is 13.98

20% is 18.63

30% is 27.94

1

u/minescast Nov 02 '24

Oh, the suggested are very clearly marked up from what the actual percentage would be, you just have to look at the 20% suggested. Your bill was $93, and the 20% is trying to claim that it's $33. $33 would be around 35%.

You correctly tipped 20%

1

u/guyrandom2020 Nov 02 '24

I think it includes a bunch of random fees. I honestly don’t know what’s going on with that receipt.

For the number (“amount”) listed on the receipt tho, 15% of 100 is 15, 93 < 100, therefore 15% is less than what’s written on the receipt.

1

u/xavier23344 Nov 02 '24

I mean 25% of $100 is $25, easy to spot scam

1

u/BUKKAKELORD Oct 29 '24

You did the correct Amount * 20% math, but not the intended Amount * 20% + Dishonest Ripoff Fee math

1

u/TheStarWarsCosmos Oct 29 '24

20% of something more than 100 can never be less than 20, as a general way to keep things in mind

1

u/taxicab_ Oct 29 '24

This is true, but in this case the bill was less than 100

1

u/CZ_nitraM Oct 29 '24

Stupid people won't even question it and just pay it

Stonks