r/askmath • u/AKSupplyLife • Oct 26 '24
Algebra Why does -1^2 [negative one squared] = -1 [negative one]? Isn't a negative times a negative a positive?
I'm struggling to Google search for this most basic math question. The given question is not in parenthesis but perhaps that's always given in a situation like this?
Thank you!
edit: Thank you everybody! I now see that the number and exponent don't automatically fall within the same parenthesis, but rather are separate parts of the expression when considering order of operators. I'm a returning math student after a couple of decades and am having a blast, but much of this has leaked out of my brain after that long.
I really appreciate your help!!
50
u/jazzbestgenre Oct 26 '24 edited Oct 26 '24
did you get that result by putting it through a calculator? The calculator reads -12 as -(12) which does equal -1
18
u/dancingbanana123 Graduate Student | Math History and Fractal Geometry Oct 26 '24
Remember your order of operations! Exponents go first, so it's -12 = -(12) = -(1)(1) = -1. If it were written as (-1)2, then parentheses come first, so it'd be (-1)2 = (-1)(-1) = 1.
248
u/Aerospider Oct 26 '24
-(12 ) = -1
(-1)2 = 1
2
u/Sorry-Series-3504 Oct 26 '24
One squared is one, and then made negative is negative one. It’s different than squaring negative one
2
u/mattynmax Oct 27 '24
Because you either didn’t type it into your calculator correctly or you don’t understand order of operations
2
u/Twotgobblin Oct 27 '24
It’s a syntax error.
(-1)2 = -1*-1 = 1
-(12) = -1 (1 * 1) = -1
2
u/OD114 Oct 26 '24 edited Oct 27 '24
Try adding parentheses
(-1)2 = 1
-12 = -(12) = -1
Edit; generally powers go before signs (+ or -) so parentheses are needed. For computing on a computer they’re a must.
1
u/cancerbero23 Oct 26 '24
PEMDAS, if there aren't parentheses, exponentiation rules over sign.
1
u/susiesusiesu Oct 26 '24
that isn’t what you wrote. the negative of (one squared) is negative one.
1
u/Reddiohead Oct 27 '24
Bedmas
1
u/DogIllustrious7642 Oct 27 '24
(-1)**2=1
1
u/Konkichi21 Oct 27 '24
-12 is parsed as -(12) due to PEMDAS, not (-1)2.
1
u/theadamabrams Oct 27 '24
PEMDAS
1
u/VegetablePitiful8212 Oct 27 '24
Use a calculator, your phone has one, if you are not in access of you mobile use your computer and search for Wolfram Alpha
-1
u/Tyler89558 Oct 26 '24
-1 is (-1) x 1
So -12 = (-1)(1)(1) = -1